Block 5
Block 5
Block 5
SECTOR*
Structure
12.0 Objectives
12.1 Introduction
12.2 Goods Markets
12.2.1 Interest Rate and Investment
12.2.2 Aggregate Demand and the Interest Rate
12.3 Derivation of the IS Curve
12.3.1 Slope of the IS Curve
12.3.2 Position of the IS Curve
12.4 Let Us Sum Up
12.5 Answers/ Hints to Check Your Progress Exercises
12.0 OBJECTIVES
12.1 INTRODUCTION
*
Dr. Nidhi Tewathia, Assistant Professor, Gargi College, University of Delhi
IS-LM Analysis The goods and money markets are interrelated – interest rate influences
investment which influences output. Similarly, growth in output influences
demand for investment which in turn affects interest rate. Thus studying goods
market and money market separately does not give us a correct picture of the
economy. For economic stability in the economy, there should be equilibrium in
both goods market (equilibrium output) and in money market (equilibrium
interest rate). In view of this economists such as J R Hicks (1904-1989) and
Alvin Hansen (1887 – 1975) tried to combine the equilibrium in both goods and
money markets.
Goods market is the one where aggregate demand and aggregate supply interact
with each other and equilibrium level of income and output are determined. In
the Keynesian model we saw that equilibrium output is realized when saving and
investment are equal. A limitation of that model, however, was that the effect of
interest rate on saving and investment was ignored.
Goods market equilibrium can be described through the IS curve (IS stands for
Investment - Saving) which shows all the positions where investment and saving
in the economy are equal. In Unit 11, we considered investment to be
autonomous or fixed for simplicity. In reality however investment is not fully
exogenous.
As you saw in Unit 11, equilibrium level of output is given by
A
Y0
1 c ct
i = rate of interest
Interest
Rate
I
Investment
O
The position of the investment curve is dependent on the slope of the investment
function, i.e., b and the level of autonomous investment, I . The intercept of the
investment curve will depend on I , while its slope will depend on b. If
investment is highly responsive (value of ‘b’ is larger), the investment curve will
be flatter (see Fig. 12.2). In this case, a small decrease in the rate of interest will
result in a large increase in investment (see Fig. 12.3). On the other hand, if the
responsiveness of investment to a change in the rate of interest is low (value of
‘b’ is relatively small), the investment curve will be steeper.
i i
Rate of Rate of
Interest Interest
I I
I I
O O Investment
Investment
Fig. 12.2: Higher Responsive Investment Fig. 12.3: Lower Responsive Investment
Interest
rate
Iʹ
I
Iʹʹ
I
O Investment
An increase in the rate of interest rate results in a decrease in AD, while level of
income is considered to be given. As pointed out earlier, A is not affected by the
increase in the rate of interest. In Fig. 12.5 we describe the effect of change in
interest rate on AD curve. At a given rate of interest i, the term ‘bi’ becomes a
constant and hence the vertical intercept of AD curve is ( A – bi).
In Fig. 12.5, we measure AD on the y-axis and output on the x-axis. In the
diagram, we depict the impact of a shift in the AD curve on equilibrium output.
Initially let the aggregate demand curve be AD 1 A cY gi 1 when the rate of
interest is 𝑖 . Here the intercept of the AD curve is 𝐴̅ − 𝑏𝑖 . The equilibrium is at
point 𝐸 and equilibrium output is 𝑌 .
154
because we are subtracting a smaller quantity from 𝐴̅ . Thus there will be an Equilibrium In
upward shift in the AD curve from 𝐴𝐷 to 𝐴𝐷 (see Fig. 12.5). the Real Sector
AD AD= Y
E2 AD 2 A cY gi 2
A gi 2 AD 1 A cY gi 1
E1
A gi1
Y
Y1 Y2
.......................................................................................................................
3) Explain the impact of a change in the interest rate on the AD curve and
the resulting equilibrium.
155
IS-LM Analysis
.......................................................................................................................
.......................................................................................................................
.......................................................................................................................
.......................................................................................................................
We continue with Fig. 12.5 for derivation of the IS curve. The ground work is
already done in the previous section where we learnt that the AD curve shifts due
to change in the interest rate. Further, there is a change in equilibrium output in
response to change in the AD curve. Thus, in Fig. 12.5, we have various
combinations of interest rate and equilibrium output levels. If we plot such
combinations in a diagram, we get the IS curve. As we observed in Fig. 12.5,
when the rate of interest decreased from i1 to i2, the equilibrium level of output
increased from Y1 to Y2. Thus we find that interest rate and equilibrium output
are negatively related. The IS curve is shown in Fig. 12.6. You should note that
on each and every point of the IS curve the real sector of the economy is in
equilibrium.
i1 E1
Rate of
interest i E2
2
IS curve
O Y
Y1 Y2
All the points on the IS curve represent the goods market equilibrium because
this curve is made up of those combinations of rate of interest and output where
savings is equal to investment (or, its equivalent, aggregate demand is equal to
aggregate supply). Fig. 12.6 shows that the IS curve is downward sloping.
Another issue to discuss is the points which are not on the IS curve. Any such
point indicates that there is disequilibrium in the goods market. Point ‘c’ and ‘d’
in Fig. 12.7, for example, show disequilibrium in the real sector , while points ‘a’
and ‘b’ show equilibrium in the goods market.
i
156
i1 a c
Rate of
Equilibrium In
the Real Sector
At point ‘d’ in Fig. 12.7, income is at Y1 but the rate of interest is at i2. At lower
rate of interest, demand for investment will increase. Such increase in demand for
investment will push the rate of interest upward. So, at point ‘d’ there is excess
demand for goods. We can generalize that at any point below and to the left of
the IS curve, there is excess demand for goods.
At point ‘c’ in Fig. 12.7, interest rate is 𝑖 while output is 𝑌 . You should observe
that the equilibrium rate of interest corresponding to 𝑌 level of output is 𝑖
(equilibrium point on the IS curve is ‘b’) which is lower than 𝑖 . Thus there is a
tendency for interest rate to decline. An implication of the above is that there is
excess supply in the market. We can generalize that any point which is above and
to the right of the IS curve, indicates excess supply of goods.
Let us derive the equation for the IS curve by using the goods market equilibrium
condition. We know that equilibrium is achieved when Y = AD. Substituting the
value of AD from equation (12.2), we obtain
Y = A + 𝑐̅ Y –bi
Or, Y – c Y = A – bi
Or, (1 − 𝑐̅)𝑌 = 𝐴̅ − 𝑏𝑖
Or, 𝑌 = ( )̅
(𝐴̅ − 𝑏𝑖)
where α G ̅
= is the multiplier in the presence of the government
Equation (12.3) above is the IS equation. The slope of the IS curve is defined as
the rate of change in income due to change in interest rate. The slope of the IS
157
IS-LM Analysis ∆
curve is given by , where ∆ represents a small change in a variable. The slope
∆
of the IS curve is (–)b. αG .
Those of you who are familiar with differential calculus, can see that we take
derivative of (12.3) to find the slope of the IS curve. Thus, = − b. αG . The
slope being negative reinforces the fact that Y and i are negatively related. The
steepness of the curve depends on the two factors, viz., b and αG . Recall that b
represents the sensitivity of investment to changes in the interest rate, and αG
represents the value of the multiplier.
AD AD = Y
'
A gi 2 c y
Aggregate A gi 2 c y
Demand
A gi 1 c' y
A gi 1 c y
-b Δi E1
Y
Y1 Y1’ Y2 Y2’
Rate of
i1
Interest
i2
IS1 IS2
O Y
Y1 Y1’ Y2 Y2’
158
Looking at the role of αG in the steepness of the IS curve, let us consider two Equilibrium In
different values of the multiplier, one larger than the other. Larger multiplier will the Real Sector
produce a steeper AD curve. In our analysis, we will consider a change in the
interest rate and then we will consider the change in equilibrium income in both
the cases, i.e., flatter AD curve ( αG is higher) and comparatively steeper AD
curve ( αG is lower). We utilise Fig. 12.8 for this analysis. We will see the impact
of lower interest rate on the AD curve and finally on the IS curve.
AD AD= Y
AD1
AD2
AD2
A2
AD1
E1
A1
Y
Y1 Y2
Once we are done with understanding of the slope of IS, the next thing to learn is
the position of the IS curve. We should be in a position to explain the shifts in the
IS curve. In other words, we should be in a position to identify the factors that
determine the position of the IS curve. Let us once again look at the IS equation.
159
IS-LM Analysis 𝑌 = 𝛼 (𝐴̅ − 𝑔𝑖)
We already know that α G and b are responsible for the slope of the IS curve.
This leaves us with A which shall play a significant role in the IS curve
formation. This role is nothing but the determination of the position of the IS
curve. In case A shifts, it leads to a shift in AD curve and hence shows an impact
on the position of the IS curve. Fig. 12.9 shows how this process takes place. The
upper panel of Fig. 12.9 shows the impact of change in autonomous spending
A on the AD curve. For a given rate of interest 𝑖 , equilibrium level of income
and output shifts from Y1 to Y2 due to A .
AD AD= Y
Aggregate AD2(i1)
Demand E2
AD1(i1)
A2
E1
A1
Y
Y1 Y2
i
Interest rate
i1 E1 E2
IS2
IS1
O Y
Y1 Y2
Now, in the lower panel of Fig. 12.9, at the same interest rate (i1), we have a
higher level of equilibrium income and output (Y2). This shows that the shift in
IS1 to IS2 is as a result of A . We have a new goods market equilibrium, i.e.,
(𝑖 ,Y2) instead of the old one (𝑖 ,Y1). The next question is, what is the magnitude
of the shift in the IS curve? The shift in the equilibrium level of income and
output can be easily calculated with the help of the multiplier.
Y = αG . A
160
That is, change in income is equal to the multiplier times the change in A . The Equilibrium In
the Real Sector
components of A are equally responsible for the shifts in the IS curve. Let us
look at these components,
A c TR T G C
2) Which are the factors that determine the slope of the IS Curve?
.......................................................................................................................
.......................................................................................................................
.......................................................................................................................
.......................................................................................................................
.......................................................................................................................
In this unit, we understood the role of interest rate in determining the investment
level. We dropped the assumption that the investment is autonomous or
exogenous. As the investment gets affected due to interest rate, the aggregate
demand and the equilibrium also experience a change. This process of change in
interest rate and its impact on equilibrium level of income and output helps us to
161
IS-LM Analysis derive the IS curve. All the points on the IS curve show the goods market
equilibrium and all the points off the IS curve show disequilibrium. The slope of
the IS curve is dependent upon the sensitivity of the investment to the interest
rate (b) and the multiplier ( α G ). The position of the IS curve is determined by the
autonomous spending, A .
162
UNIT 13 EQUILIBRIUM IN THE MONETARY
SECTOR*
Structure
13.0 Objectives
13.1 Introduction
13.2 Real and Nominal Demands
13.3 Demand for and Supply of Money
13.4 Money Market Equilibrium
13.5 LM Curve
13.5.1 Slope of the LM Curve
13.5.2 Position of the LM Curve
13.6 Let Us Sum Up
13.7 Answers/Hints to Check Your Progress Exercises
13.0 OBJECTIVES
After going through this Unit, you should be in a position to
explain nominal and real demand for money;
derive the LM curve with the help of demand for and supply of money;
explain the slope of the LM curve and the factors affecting it; and
explain the position of the LM curve and the factors affecting it.
13.1 INTRODUCTION
In the previous Unit we discussed about the equilibrium in the goods market.
Knowledge of the goods market and its equilibrium alone however is not
sufficient to understand how the economy works. The money market or the assets
market is equally important.
The assets market affects the level of income and output. As you might have
observed, large volume of trading occurs every day in the assets market. For
simplicity, we group all the assets into two categories, viz., a) money (cash in
hand), and b) interest-bearing assets such as bonds. A bond is a promise to pay an
agreed amount of money to its holder at some future date. For example, suppose
a borrower (usually the government or a corporate firm) borrows Rs.100 in the
form of a bond. She promises to pay Rs.4 each year to the lender (who actually
owns the bond) and will repay Rs.100 to the lender at a future specified date, say
after 2 years. The interest rate is 4 per cent per year.
*
Dr. Nidhi Tewathia, Assistant Professor, Gargi College, University of Delhi
163
IS-LM Analysis Wealth of an individual is allocated between various types of assets. If an
individual decides to have more number of bonds, she will receive more amount
of interest income accordingly. Holding more money grants her liquidity and she
can make transactions to purchase anything she wants. In the case of bonds, her
liquidity is compromised. Such decisions are called portfolio decisions. The total
wealth of an individual would either be held in the form of money or in the form
of bonds. In other words, the wealth of an individual should add up to the money
held in different types of assets.
State of the economy depends on both goods market and assets market, and there
is an important link between the two. The complete picture emerges only after we
study both goods and assets markets. In the present Unit we will be largely
discussing about money, bonds, stocks, houses, etc., as forms of wealth. In Unit
14 we will combine both the goods and the assets markets to find out equilibrium
rate of interest and equilibrium level of output.
Let us begin with the distinction between ‘the nominal demand for money’ and
‘the real demand for money’. Nominal demand for money is the amount of
money (in India, for example, the number of rupees) demanded by an individual.
The real demand for money is also the demand for money but in terms of the
number of units of goods that money will buy. This real demand is equal to the
nominal demand for money divided by the price level. For example, nominal
demand for money (also called Nominal Wealth, WN) is Rs.500, and the price
level is Rs.5. Then the real demand for money will be equal to 100 units of goods
(= 500/5). It is important to note that if the nominal demand for money and the
price level doubles, then the real demand for money remains unchanged. Real
demand for money is also known as ‘demand for real money balances' or real
balances. Real bond holdings will be equal to the sum of money and the bond
holding divided by the price level. Real financial wealth of an individual should
be equal to the sum of demand for real balances (L), and real bond holdings
(BH). Also, another way to look at the real financial wealth is the nominal wealth
(WN) divided by the price level (P):
So,
WN
L + BH = …(13.1)
P
Decision of holding more real balances would mean a decision to hold less real
wealth in the form of bonds. It means, if we consider the money market only, we
can have understanding on the assets market. If the money market is in
equilibrium, the bond market will also be in equilibrium because real wealth is
distributed in these two markets only.
164
The real financial wealth available at a given time, in an economy, will be the Equilibrium in the
Monetary Sector
sum of the real money balances and the available real bonds. So, the total
financial wealth will be equal to:
WN M
SB
P P …(13.2)
where M is the stock of nominal money balances, SB is the real value of the
supply of bonds and P is the price level.
The amount of real wealth an individual wish to hold should be equal to the
amount of real wealth available in the economy. We equate (13.1) and (13.2) to
obtain
M
L + BH = SB
P
M
Or, L (BH SB) 0
P …(13.3)
If the demand for real balances (L) is equal to the existing stock of the real
M
balances, we find that L 0 . This leads to the interesting observation,
P
i.e., BH should be equal to SB. If the real money demand is equal to the real
money supply, then the demand for real bonds should be equal to the supply of
real bonds. Now, let us consider a situation where the money market is not in
equilibrium, and see its implications for the asset market. Suppose real money
demand is more than real money supply. Given the wealth budget constraint
M
given at equation (13.3), the excess demand in the money market (i.e., L )
P
there needs to be neutralized by excess supply in the bond market (i.e., BH <
SB). With this behaviour, we reinforce the fact that studying only the money
market would help us in comprehending the bond market also.
The decision of how much money to be held as nominal balance or in the form of
cash is dependent on the income or real income of an individual and the interest
rate on various assets available for investment. The cost of holding money is
165
IS-LM Analysis
nothing but the foregone interest rate on the assets in which the investor could
have invested. Higher interest rate increases the cost of holding money.
Individuals make transfers from money to bonds whenever their money holdings
become large. But if an individual holds her majority of wealth in the form of
bonds, then she needs to be ready for the inconvenience which low level of
liquidity brings. We can say that at high levels of income, an individual demands
more of money (means more liquidity) and at high rate of interest, the individual
demands more bonds (means less money or less liquidity).
Keeping the above in view, we can write the money demand function as
L = kY – h i k, h > 0 …(13.4)
where k is the sensitivity of money demand to the level of income (Y) and h is
the sensitivity of money demand to the interest rate (i). An increase in the income
by Re.1 increases the real money demand (L) by Rs. k. An increase in the interest
rate by 1 per cent decreases the real money demand by Rs. h. The quantity
demanded is a decreasing function of the rate of interest and increasing function
of the income. In Fig. 13.1 we depict such a demand curve for money.
Interest
Rate
L
L
O
Quantity of Money
The supply of money is generally taken as fixed. The nominal quantity of money
supply is controlled by the Central Bank of the country. So, we take it as given at
M . We also assume that the price level is constant ( P ). Thus, the real money
supply would be ( ).
In Fig. 13.2 we show that money supply in the economy is constant; represented
by a vertical line. An implication of the vertical money supply curve is that it is
independent of interest rate. Thus any change in interest rate does not lead to a
change in money supply.
166
Equilibrium in the
Monetary Sector
i M
P
Interest Rate
L
O
Quantity of Money
i
Interest rate
E1
i1
L1
L
O M
P Quantity of Money
Now suppose that the level of income increases from (𝑌 ) to (𝑌 ). From equation
(13.4) we find that money demand (L) will increase. Accordingly, the money
demand curve will observe a rightward shift from 𝐿 (𝑌 ) to 𝐿 (𝑌 ) and the
equilibrium point will shift from 𝐸 to 𝐸 . In Fig. 13.4, the new equilibrium is at
E2 which corresponds to the equilibrium level of income, Y2, and the interest rate,
i 2.
167
IS-LM Analysis
E2
i2
Interest
Rate E1
i1
i3 E3
L2 (Y2)
L1 (Y1)
L3 (Y3)
With the new equilibrium, we have received another combination of income and
rate of interest where money market is in equilibrium. At the rate of interest i1,
there exists excess demand for money due to increase in income level (Y). This
excess demand pushes up the rate of interest to i2 to achieve the new equilibrium
where demand for money equals supply of money.
If the income level decreases to Y3, the money demand curve will shift leftwards
(see Fig. 13.4) and this will lead to excess supply of money. This excess supply
of money pushes the interest rate down and the equilibrium rate of interest is
realized at i3 so that the supply of and the demand for money are equal. We
observe that a lower level of income (𝑌 ) is associated with a lower rate of
interest (𝑖 ).
Check Your Progress 1
1) Distinguish between real and nominal demands for money.
....................................................................................................................
....................................................................................................................
....................................................................................................................
....................................................................................................................
2) Write down the equation of the demand for money and interpret it.
....................................................................................................................
....................................................................................................................
....................................................................................................................
168
Equilibrium in the
13.5 LM CURVE Monetary Sector
The combinations of income (Y) and interest rate (i) which we discussed in the
previous sections are important for understanding the LM curve. A series of such
combinations eventually generates the LM curve. The LM curve shows the
combinations of interest rates and levels of income such that the demand for real
balances is equal to the supply of real balances. All the points on the LM curve
indicate the money market equilibrium and all the points outside the LM curve
indicate the disequilibrium in the money market. The LM curve is positively
sloped, i.e., as Y increases, the rate of interest increases.
In Fig. 13.4 we obtained three equilibrium points, as the level of income changed,
viz., 𝐸 , 𝐸 and 𝐸 corresponding to (𝑌 𝑖 ), (𝑌 𝑖 ), and (𝑌 𝑖 ) respectively. We
plot these points in Fig. 13.5. In Fig.13.5 we take output on the x-axis and
interest rate (i) on the y-axis. When we plot the three combinations (𝑌 𝑖 ), (𝑌 𝑖 ),
and (𝑌 𝑖 ) we obtain an upward sloping curve. It is called the LM curve; ‘L’
representing liquidity and ‘M’ representing money supply.
i
Rate of Interest
i2 LM
E2
i1
E1
P
i3 Q
E3
0 Y
Y3 Y1 Y2 Income and Output
You should note that on each and every point of the LM curve, the demand for
real balances is equal to the supply of real balances. Thus the money market is in
equilibrium if the economy is operating at any combination of output and interest
rate, which are on the LM curve. An implication of the above is that the money
market is not in equilibrium condition if the economy is operating at any point
outside the LM curve. Let us consider two such points, P and Q in Fig. 13.5. At
point P, which is to the left and above the LM curve, there is excess supply of
money for given level of income. This will push the interest rate down and the
money market will be in equilibrium. At point Q, which is to the right and below
the LM curve, there is excess demand for money. This will push the interest rate
up so that there is equilibrium in the money market.
Now let us derive the equation for the LM curve. In equation (13.4) we have the
demand for real balances. The supply of real balances is given by . By
169
IS-LM Analysis equating the demand for real balances with the supply of real balances we obtain
the equation for the LM curve. Algebraically it can be shown as follows:
M
= kY – ℎ𝑖
P
M
Or, ℎ𝑖 = kY –
P
1 M
Or, 𝑖 = kY …(13.5)
h P
The slope of LM curve can be derived from the LM equation, given by (13.5).
You should note that the slope of the LM curve denotes the change in rate of
Δi
interest due to change in income, i.e., , where ‘∆’ represents a small change
Δy
in a variable. Thus,
Δi k
…(13.6)
Δy h
Those of you, who are familiar with the concept of differentiation, will find that
slope of a curve is given by the first derivative of a function. We obtain the slope
of the LM curve by taking partial derivative of equation (13.5) such that = .
From (13.6) we find that the slope of the LM curve is given by the ratio of k and
h. An implication of the above is that greater the responsiveness of the demand
for money to income (k) and lower the responsiveness of the demand for money
to the interest rate (h), the steeper will be the LM curve.
LM1
Interest Rate
LM2
0
Quantity of Money
170
In Fig. 13.6 we present two LM curves with different slopes. If the demand for Equilibrium in the
Monetary Sector
money is relatively insensitive to the interest rate (i.e., h is close to zero), then the
LM curve will be nearly vertical (LM1). On the other hand, if the demand for
money is very sensitive to the interest rate (i.e., h is large), then the LM curve
will be nearly horizontal (LM2).
M M'
Let us describe a situation where real money supply increases from to .
P P
This will shift the money supply curve (the vertical line in Fig. 13.3). Such a shift
in the money supply curve will result in a decrease in the rate of interest for each
level of income. Thus there will be a rightward shift in the LM curve.
In Fig. 13.7 the rate of interest changes from 𝑖 to 𝑖 for each level of income. We
have kept the income level unchanged at Y1 to highlight the fact that at each level
of income, the equilibrium interest rate has to be lower to induce people to hold
larger real balances. Similarly, at each level of the interest rate, the level of
income has to be higher so as to raise the transactions demand for money (kY)
and thereby absorbing the higher real money supply.
If there is a decrease in real money supply, the LM curve will shift to the left.
i LM1 LM2
Rate of interest
i1 E1
i2 E2
Y
O0 Y1
Fig 13.7: Shift in the LM Curve
171
IS-LM Analysis
...................................................................................................................
....................................................................................................................
...................................................................................................................
........................................................................................................................
.......................................................................................................................
.......................................................................................................................
........................................................................................................................
We began the unit with a discussion on the options for individuals to hold money.
We assumed that an individual holds money either in the form of cash or in terms
of interest-bearing assets i.e., bonds. Further, we showed that if we study the
money market, the bond market is also understood side by side. So the focus was
laid on the money market. The demand for and supply of real balances was
explained with the help of diagrams. The LM curve was derived in terms of
equation and diagram. The movements in the rate of interest due to change in the
money demand and money supply were explained. The impact of such
172
movements on the LM curve was discussed. Further, the slope and position of the Equilibrium in the
Monetary Sector
LM curve was discussed. It was observed that the change in nominal money
supply is the major factor that affects the position of the LM curve.
173
UNIT 14 NEOCLASSICAL SYNTHESES*
Structure
14.0 Objectives
14.1 Introduction
14.2 Simultaneous Equilibrium
14.3 Equilibrium and Adjustment Process
14.4 Classical and Keynesian Zones
14.5 Let Us Sum Up
14.6 Answers/Hints to Check Your Progress Exercises
14.0 OBJECTIVES
After going through this Unit, you should be in a position to
describe the simultaneous equilibrium in goods market and money market;
explain the adjustment process in the equilibrium output and interest rate;
and
distinguish between the classical and the Keynesian zones in the IS-LM
model.
14.1 INTRODUCTION
In Unit 12 we derived the IS curve which indicates the points on which there is
equilibrium in the goods market. In Unit 13 we derived the LM curve, which
indicates the equilibrium in the money market. Now, the problem at hand is to
bring about equilibrium, simultaneously in both the markets. In this unit, we will
discuss the interaction of the IS and the LM curves, shifts in these curves, and the
adjustment process in case disequilibrium exists.
For simultaneous equilibrium in the goods market and the money market, there
needs to be a single combination of interest rate and income level which satisfies
the equilibrium in both goods and money markets simultaneously. In Fig. 14.1
we super-impose the IS and the LM curves. In the figure, we represent income/
output level (Y) on the x-axis and the interest rate (i) on the y-axis.
*
Dr. Nidhi Tewathia, Assistant Professor, Gargi College, University of Delhi
In Fig. 14.1 we find that the goods market and the money market clear at point Neoclassical
E1. The equilibrium rate of interest is i1 and the equilibrium level of income and Synthesis
output is Y1. You should remember that we assume the price level to be constant
(𝑃). An implication of the above is that firms are willing to supply any amount of
goods and services at that price. At E1, the economy is in equilibrium as both
goods and money markets are in equilibrium. Thus, the firms are willing to
supply Y1 level of output and equilibrium interest rate is i1. Firms are producing
their planned amount of output and individuals have their portfolio composition
according to their plan. There is no unplanned inventory accumulation or
rundown of inventories.
i
LM
interest
rate
E1
i1
IS
i1 output
O Y1
If any of the two curves (viz., IS and LM) changes, there will be a change in the
equilibrium levels of income and interest rate. The impact of the shifts in the IS
and the LM curves on equilibrium output and interest rate, however, will be
different.
Let us assume that there is an increase in the autonomous investment. This results
in an increase in the autonomous spending(𝐴̅) and hence there is a parallel shift
in the IS curve from IS1 to IS2 (see Unit 12). Correspondingly, the equilibrium
shifts from E1 to E2 which indicates higher equilibrium level of income and
output, and higher rate of interest. In Fig. 14.2 you can see that output increases
from Y1 to Y2, and interest rate increases from i1 to i2.
You should observe that the extent of change in the level of income (= G A) is
not the same as the extent of shift in the IS curve. This is because we are dealing
with the money market also. Increase in ∆𝐴̅ leads to increase in income, which
affects the demand for money. Supply of money remains fixed while the demand
for money increases. Consequently the rate of interest increases in the money
market. This has a negative impact on the investment spending. As interest rate
175
IS-LM Analysis rises, investment falls to some extent. Hence, the final change in the income is
less than 𝛼 ∆𝐴̅ .
i
LM
Interest E2
rate i2
E1
i1
IS2
IS1
Y
O Y1 Y2
Income and Output Level
Fig. 14.2: Shift in the IS Curve
i
LM1
i2 E2
IS1
0 Y1 Y2 Y
Let us assume that there is an increase in the money supply in the economy.
Consequently there is a right-ward parallel shift in the LM curve from LM1 to
LM2 (see Unit 13). Consequently, the equilibrium changes from E1 to E2. As we
can see from Fig. 14.3, interest rate decreases from 𝑖 to 𝑖 while output level
increases from Y1 to Y2.
176
Check Your Progress 1 Neoclassical
Synthesis
1) Explain the simultaneous equilibrium in the goods market and the money
market.
.......................................................................................................................
.......................................................................................................................
.......................................................................................................................
.......................................................................................................................
2) Explain the impact of a leftward shift in the IS curve through appropriate
diagram.
.......................................................................................................................
.......................................................................................................................
.......................................................................................................................
.......................................................................................................................
3) Explain the impact of a leftward shift in the LM curve through
appropriate diagram.
.......................................................................................................................
.......................................................................................................................
.......................................................................................................................
.......................................................................................................................
In the previous Section we found that equilibrium output and interest rate are
realized at the intersection of the IS and the LM curves. In this Section we will
show that there is a tendency of the market to reach back to the equilibrium. If
the economy is outside the IS and the LM curves (when there is no equilibrium in
the economy), an adjustment process in the economy takes place and the
economy moves to a new equilibrium point. Let us appreciate the following two
points:
a) If there is an excess demand for money, the interest rate will increase. The
interest rate will fall in case we observe excess supply in the money
market.
b) Excess demand for goods leads to an increase in output and excess supply
of goods leads to a decline in output. The former involves run down of
inventory with the firms while the latter leads to accumulation of
inventories.
177
IS-LM Analysis Let us consider Fig. 14.4, which shows the adjustment process that market
follows to regain equilibrium if there is some shock/ disturbance. Let us assume
that the economy is operating at a point which is not on the IS and LM curves. In
other words, Fig. 14.4 shows few points (for example F, G, H and K) which do
not reflect the equilibrium in the money market as well as the goods market.
From such points, how does the economy reach towards equilibrium?
i
LM
F
Interest
rate
H E G
i0
Any point to the left of the LM curve shows excess supply of money (see Unit
13). On the other hand, any point to the right of the LM curve shows excess
demand for money. Similarly, any point to the left of the IS curve shows excess
demand for goods (see Unit 12). On the other hand, any point to the right of the
IS curve shows excess supply of goods.
Let us take any random point G (it represents excess demand for money and
excess supply of goods). The arrows given at point G specify the direction in
which adjustment takes place. Excess demand for money will cause interest rate
to rise. This is because assets are sold off for money and price of assets decline.
Upward pointing arrow represents rising interest rate. Excess supply of goods
leads to involuntary accumulation. So the firms start reducing the output. The
leftward pointing arrow represents the declining output.
Points F, H and K inn Fig. 14.4 are similarly points of disequilibrium where
adjustment takes place and eventually the economy reaches at E, the point of
equilibrium. Even if only one of these two markets is observing disequilibrium,
the economy reaches back to equilibrium after the adjustment process.
In Fig. 14.5 we have indicated the direction of change by arrow marks. Any point
on the IS curve, apart from E, shows equilibrium in goods market but a
disequilibrium in the assets market.
178
Neoclassical
Synthesis
i
LM
Interest
rate
E
i0
IS
Y
O Y0
Income and Output
In Unit 13 we discussed about the slope of the LM curve which shows the
sensitivity of money supply on interest rate and output level. There could be two
extreme cases with respect to the LM curve, viz., i) the LM curve is horizontal,
and ii) the LM curve is vertical. We will see the implications of both the
situations.
In the first situation, when the LM curve is horizontal, the public is prepared to
hold all the money at a given interest rate. It reflects a situation known as
liquidity trap. In such a case, monetary policy has no effect on the rate of interest
and the level of output. A condition of liquidity trap exists when the rate of
interest is very low (for example, nearly zero). Public would not want to hold
bonds at such low interest rate.
Let us now learn about classical and Keynesian positions through the IS–LM
model. Fig. 14.6 shows the classical and the Keynesian ranges in the LM curve.
Let us assume that the economy is operating at Y1. The LM curve is infinitely
elastic at Y1. In case the government exercises an expansionary fiscal policy,
which means government expenditure increases, then the IS1 curve shifts to IS1.
179
IS-LM Analysis
i
IS'
IS
Rate of
Interest
'
IS 2
IS2
IS'1
IS1
' '
O Y1 Y 1 Y2 Y 2 Y3 Y
There is nearly no increase in the rate of interest but income level has risen from
Y1 to Y1. Rate of interest does not increase because sufficient idle money is
available in the economy. This is the Keynesian range as individuals are in a
situation of liquidity trap. Under such circumstance monetary policy is
ineffective and government should take up fiscal measures.
If we see the other extreme in Fig. 14.6, where economy is operating at Y 3 level,
we realise that the LM curve is nearly vertical. Rate of interest is too high for
people to hold money. The interest bearing assets are lucrative to invest the
money. Hence, the real money balances are low. When government borrows
(with an intention of increasing the level of investment), in such a situation,
government investment becomes a competitor of private investment and there is
no increase in total investment in the economy. Due to this high competition, the
rate of interest rises but not the income level. This range of the LM curve is
known as the classical range. Under such circumstances, fiscal policy is not
much effective. We have already discussed the distinction between classical and
Keynesian views in Unit 9.
The moderate range seems to be more realistic vis-à-vis the Keynesian and the
classical ranges of the IS-LM model. Such a moderate range is depicted in Fig.
14.6 by the income level Y2. When government investment increases, the
complete ‘crowding out’ of the private investment does not take place. There is
an increase in the rate of interest but there is an increase in the level of output
also. In Fig. 14.6 we find that the output level increases from Y2 to Y2 due to the
shift in the IS curve from IS2 to IS2.
180
Neoclassical
Check Your Progress 2 Synthesis
1) Explain how the adjustment process takes place in the IS-LM model.
.......................................................................................................................
.......................................................................................................................
.......................................................................................................................
.......................................................................................................................
......................................................................................................................
2) In what respects the classical range of the LM curve is different from the
Keynesian range?
.......................................................................................................................
.......................................................................................................................
.......................................................................................................................
.......................................................................................................................
.......................................................................................................................
Further, we discussed about the Classical and Keynesian ranges with respect to
the LM curve. When the LM curve is vertical, it reflects a situation similar to the
classical model where the output level does not change as a result of government
borrowing. On the other hand, when the LM curve is nearly flat, it reflects a
situation similar to the Keynesian model because the public investment leads to
shifts the income level only and not the interest rate.
181
IS-LM Analysis Check Your Progress 2
1) Refer to Section 14.3.
2) Refer to Section 14.4.
3) Refer to Section 14.5.
4) Refer to Section 14.6.
182
GLOSSARY
: According to classical economists, the aggregate supply curve is
Aggregate Supply
Curve vertical, implying that total output is always at the full employment
level. In the short run, according to Keynes, the aggregate supply
curve will be horizontal if the economy has under-utilised
resources.
Automatic Stabilizers : Revenue and expenditure items in the budget that automatically
change with the state of the economy and tend to stabilize GDP
Autonomous spending : A part of AD that is independent of the income and output level.
Average Propensity to : C
Consume The ratio of consumption expenditure to income i.e., .
Y
Balance of Trade : It refers to the export and import of only visible items.
Balanced Budget : Equilibrium income rises by the same amount by which the
Multiplier government spending rises. It is assumed that the change in
government spending is equal to the change in taxes. Taxes are
taken as autonomous taxes.
Bank Rate : Rate at which the central bank lends funds to the commercial
banks.
183
: Periodical ups and downs in economic activity in an economy.
Business Cycle
There are four phases of a business cycle, viz., expansion,
recession, depression, and recovery. During expansion phase the
economy grows while during recession there is a deceleration in
growth rate. Depression is much severe and the economy may
witness negative economic growth. During recovery, as the name
suggests, the economy recovers from depression.
Capital Goods : These are goods which help in further production of goods.
Example could be machineries.
Cash Reserve Ratio : It is the percentage of bank deposits that the banks are required
(CRR) keep with the central bank. In India, in 2019 the CRR is 4 percent.
Thus, if Rs. 100 is deposited in a bank, the bank needs to keep Rs.
4 with the RBI. The RBI can vary the CRR between 3 per cent and
15 per cent.
Circular Flow : It is a flow of goods or services or money from one (set of)
transactor to another (set).
Classical Model : A model of the economy derived from ideas of the pre-Keynesian
economists. It is based on the assumption that prices and wages
adjust instantaneously to clear markets and that monetary policy
does not influence real variables such as output and employment.
Consumer Price Index : Consumer Price Index represents the rate of increase in the
consumer prices of a basket of goods and services.
Core Inflation : Core inflation is a measure of inflation that excludes items that
face volatile price movement, notably food and energy.
184
: Cost-push inflation is a sustained rise in the general price level due
Cost-push inflation
to a rise in the cost of production in the economy.
Depreciation : It is the loss in the value of capital asset because of normal wear
and tear and expected obsolescence.
Direct Personal Taxes : These are the taxes imposed on households in the form of
income tax or wealth tax. Those on whom they are imposed pay
them.
185
External Commercial : ECB are loans which are raised by a country’s corporate sector
Borrowings (ECB) from external financial organizations on commercial terms.
Factor Cost : It is the total cost incurred to employ factors of production to give
rise to a flow of goods and services in an economy. It is equal to
value of market price minus Net Indirect T axes.
Factor Services : These are the services rendered by factors of production such
as land, labour, capital and enterprise.
Financial Sector : This sector of the economy mops up savings of various sectors and
uses it for lending to other sectors of the economy.
Fractional Reserve Under this system, banks are required to hold a certain fraction of
Banking System their demand and time liabilities in the form of cash balances with
the central bank.
Goods Market : When AD and AS interact with each other. All points on the IS
Equilibrium curve reflects equilibrium in the goods market.
Government Sector : It is the sector, which produces goods and services that are not
sold at a price. Such goods are meant to meet collective
consumption requirements of an economy. The expenses of these
goods are met by tax and non-tax revenue of the government.
Gross Domestic : It is the sum of final goods and services produced in a country
Product (GDP) during a period of time, usually a year. We do not include
intermediate goods and income acquired through illegal activities
in the GDP. In most countries, including India, estimated value of
GDP is available on a quarterly basis as well as on a yearly basis.
186
Gross National : It is the value of goods and services produced in an economy
Product (GNP) over a year, without duplication but gross of depreciation. It is the
goods and services produced by the normal residents of an
economy.
Income from Domestic : It is the factor income enjoyed by households and private sector
Product accruing to over a year in an economy.
Private sector
: Change in income leading to a change in leisure/ labour due to
Income-Leisure trade
off change in the wage rate.
187
Inventories : The stock of goods maintained by producers to tide over
unexpected fluctuation in demand.
Keynesian Model : A model based on the ideas contained in Keynes’ General Theory.
It assumes that demand creates its own supply so long as
unemployment exists, and that prices and wages do not adjust
instantaneously to clear markets.
Liquidity Preference : People are willing to hold whatever amount of money is supplied
Region to them such that the monetary policy becomes completely
ineffective.
Liquidity Trap : At a very low rate of interest (nearly zero), people wish to hold any
amount of money and not interested in the interest-bearing assets.
LM Curve : Locus of the points which show the money market equilibrium at
various combinations of income and rate of interest.
188
: Change in the output due to an additional unit of labour employed.
Marginal Product of
Labour
Marginal Propensity : The increase in consumption due to one-rupee increase in income.
to consume (mpc) Y
It is arrived at by calculating .
C
Marginal Propensity : Increase in saving due to one-rupee increase in the income. It is
to Save written as ‘s’ or mps.
Money Flows : These are the flows, which are normally a consequence of real
flows between various sectors of an economy.
Money Multiplier : The money multiplier is the ratio of the stock of money to the
stock of high powered money.
Money Transactions : These are the transactions between one transactor and another or
between one group of transactors and another in terms of money to
money without being backed by real transactions.
National Income : It is the same aggregate as net national product at factor cost
(NNPFC).
Net Current Transfers : It is the difference between unrequited transfers from the rest of the
from the Rest of the world, over a year, and such transfers from the economy to the
World rest of the world.
Net Domestic Capital : It is that part of total production of capital goods and inventories
Formation which are meant to add to total capital stock of an economy
over a year in an economy.
189
Net Domestic : It is the value of goods and services produced in an economy,
Product (NDP) over a year, without duplication, net of depreciation.
This concept is related to the concept of domestic territory.
Net Exports (NX) : It is the difference between total value of exports and imports over
a year.
Net Factor Income : It is the difference between factor incomes earned by the normal
from Abroad residents of an economy stationed abroad temporarily and the
factor incomes earned by normal residents of the rest of the
world stationed in the economy temporarily.
Net Indirect Taxes : It is the difference between indirect taxes and subsidies.
Normal Residents : They are the households or institutions, which have their centre
of interest in the economy but some of them may temporarily be
stationed aboard.
Open Market : Sale/ purchase of government securities by the central bank to/
Operations from the public and the banks.
Per Capita GDP : The ratio of Gross domestic Product (GDP) to total population of a
country.
Personal Disposable : It is the factor income and transfer incomes left at the disposal of
Income the households after paying direct personal taxes and
miscellaneous receipts of government administrative departments
from personal income.
Personal Income : It is the factor income and transfer incomes enjoyed by the
households of an economy over a year.
190
: It shows the relationship between inflation and unemployment.
Phillips Curve
Phillips curve is downward sloping in the short-run, implying a
trade-off between the two. In the long-run the Phillips Curve is
vertical, implying that unemployment rate cannot be brought down
below natural rate of unemployment.
Price Level : It is the average of prices of all the goods and services produced in
a country.
Rate of Net Foreign : It is the difference between rate of gross domestic capital
Capital Inflow formation and rate of gross domestic savings.
191
Real Flows : These are the flows of goods or services from one set of
transactors to another.
Real Money Balances : Quantity of nominal money divided by the price level.
Real Transactions : Those transactions, which are related to exchange of goods and
services between two transactors or two groups of transactors.
Repo Rate : Rate at which the central bank lends funds to the commercial
banks against submission of collateral such as securities by the
banks.
Residential Investment : Investment incurred on construction of new houses and buildings
is called as residential investment.
Rest of the World : This sector deals with economic transactions of an economy
Sector with the rest of the world.
Reverse Repo Rate : Rate at which the commercial banks can deposit their excess
liquidity with the central bank, by purchasing securities.
Statutory Liquidity : Banks are required to hold a certain percentage of their demand
Ratio (SLR) and time deposits in the form of government securities. Currently
(in 2019) the SLR is 19.5 per cent in India.
192
institutional features of the business environment.
Transfer Payments : One-way payment of money for which no goods or services are
received in exchange.
Wealth Budget : Sum of individual’s demand for money and demand for bonds is
Constraint the individual’s total financial wealth.
Wholesale Price Index : Wholesale Price Index represents the rate of increase in the
wholesale prices of products.
193
GLOSSARY
: According to classical economists, the aggregate supply curve is
Aggregate Supply
Curve vertical, implying that total output is always at the full employment
level. In the short run, according to Keynes, the aggregate supply
curve will be horizontal if the economy has under-utilised
resources.
Automatic Stabilizers : Revenue and expenditure items in the budget that automatically
change with the state of the economy and tend to stabilize GDP
Autonomous spending : A part of AD that is independent of the income and output level.
Average Propensity to : C
Consume The ratio of consumption expenditure to income i.e., .
Y
Balance of Trade : It refers to the export and import of only visible items.
Balanced Budget : Equilibrium income rises by the same amount by which the
Multiplier government spending rises. It is assumed that the change in
government spending is equal to the change in taxes. Taxes are
taken as autonomous taxes.
Bank Rate : Rate at which the central bank lends funds to the commercial
banks.
183
: Periodical ups and downs in economic activity in an economy.
Business Cycle
There are four phases of a business cycle, viz., expansion,
recession, depression, and recovery. During expansion phase the
economy grows while during recession there is a deceleration in
growth rate. Depression is much severe and the economy may
witness negative economic growth. During recovery, as the name
suggests, the economy recovers from depression.
Capital Goods : These are goods which help in further production of goods.
Example could be machineries.
Cash Reserve Ratio : It is the percentage of bank deposits that the banks are required
(CRR) keep with the central bank. In India, in 2019 the CRR is 4 percent.
Thus, if Rs. 100 is deposited in a bank, the bank needs to keep Rs.
4 with the RBI. The RBI can vary the CRR between 3 per cent and
15 per cent.
Circular Flow : It is a flow of goods or services or money from one (set of)
transactor to another (set).
Classical Model : A model of the economy derived from ideas of the pre-Keynesian
economists. It is based on the assumption that prices and wages
adjust instantaneously to clear markets and that monetary policy
does not influence real variables such as output and employment.
Consumer Price Index : Consumer Price Index represents the rate of increase in the
consumer prices of a basket of goods and services.
Core Inflation : Core inflation is a measure of inflation that excludes items that
face volatile price movement, notably food and energy.
184
: Cost-push inflation is a sustained rise in the general price level due
Cost-push inflation
to a rise in the cost of production in the economy.
Depreciation : It is the loss in the value of capital asset because of normal wear
and tear and expected obsolescence.
Direct Personal Taxes : These are the taxes imposed on households in the form of
income tax or wealth tax. Those on whom they are imposed pay
them.
185
External Commercial : ECB are loans which are raised by a country’s corporate sector
Borrowings (ECB) from external financial organizations on commercial terms.
Factor Cost : It is the total cost incurred to employ factors of production to give
rise to a flow of goods and services in an economy. It is equal to
value of market price minus Net Indirect T axes.
Factor Services : These are the services rendered by factors of production such
as land, labour, capital and enterprise.
Financial Sector : This sector of the economy mops up savings of various sectors and
uses it for lending to other sectors of the economy.
Fractional Reserve Under this system, banks are required to hold a certain fraction of
Banking System their demand and time liabilities in the form of cash balances with
the central bank.
Goods Market : When AD and AS interact with each other. All points on the IS
Equilibrium curve reflects equilibrium in the goods market.
Government Sector : It is the sector, which produces goods and services that are not
sold at a price. Such goods are meant to meet collective
consumption requirements of an economy. The expenses of these
goods are met by tax and non-tax revenue of the government.
Gross Domestic : It is the sum of final goods and services produced in a country
Product (GDP) during a period of time, usually a year. We do not include
intermediate goods and income acquired through illegal activities
in the GDP. In most countries, including India, estimated value of
GDP is available on a quarterly basis as well as on a yearly basis.
186
Gross National : It is the value of goods and services produced in an economy
Product (GNP) over a year, without duplication but gross of depreciation. It is the
goods and services produced by the normal residents of an
economy.
Income from Domestic : It is the factor income enjoyed by households and private sector
Product accruing to over a year in an economy.
Private sector
: Change in income leading to a change in leisure/ labour due to
Income-Leisure trade
off change in the wage rate.
187
Inventories : The stock of goods maintained by producers to tide over
unexpected fluctuation in demand.
Keynesian Model : A model based on the ideas contained in Keynes’ General Theory.
It assumes that demand creates its own supply so long as
unemployment exists, and that prices and wages do not adjust
instantaneously to clear markets.
Liquidity Preference : People are willing to hold whatever amount of money is supplied
Region to them such that the monetary policy becomes completely
ineffective.
Liquidity Trap : At a very low rate of interest (nearly zero), people wish to hold any
amount of money and not interested in the interest-bearing assets.
LM Curve : Locus of the points which show the money market equilibrium at
various combinations of income and rate of interest.
188
: Change in the output due to an additional unit of labour employed.
Marginal Product of
Labour
Marginal Propensity : The increase in consumption due to one-rupee increase in income.
to consume (mpc) Y
It is arrived at by calculating .
C
Marginal Propensity : Increase in saving due to one-rupee increase in the income. It is
to Save written as ‘s’ or mps.
Money Flows : These are the flows, which are normally a consequence of real
flows between various sectors of an economy.
Money Multiplier : The money multiplier is the ratio of the stock of money to the
stock of high powered money.
Money Transactions : These are the transactions between one transactor and another or
between one group of transactors and another in terms of money to
money without being backed by real transactions.
National Income : It is the same aggregate as net national product at factor cost
(NNPFC).
Net Current Transfers : It is the difference between unrequited transfers from the rest of the
from the Rest of the world, over a year, and such transfers from the economy to the
World rest of the world.
Net Domestic Capital : It is that part of total production of capital goods and inventories
Formation which are meant to add to total capital stock of an economy
over a year in an economy.
189
Net Domestic : It is the value of goods and services produced in an economy,
Product (NDP) over a year, without duplication, net of depreciation.
This concept is related to the concept of domestic territory.
Net Exports (NX) : It is the difference between total value of exports and imports over
a year.
Net Factor Income : It is the difference between factor incomes earned by the normal
from Abroad residents of an economy stationed abroad temporarily and the
factor incomes earned by normal residents of the rest of the
world stationed in the economy temporarily.
Net Indirect Taxes : It is the difference between indirect taxes and subsidies.
Normal Residents : They are the households or institutions, which have their centre
of interest in the economy but some of them may temporarily be
stationed aboard.
Open Market : Sale/ purchase of government securities by the central bank to/
Operations from the public and the banks.
Per Capita GDP : The ratio of Gross domestic Product (GDP) to total population of a
country.
Personal Disposable : It is the factor income and transfer incomes left at the disposal of
Income the households after paying direct personal taxes and
miscellaneous receipts of government administrative departments
from personal income.
Personal Income : It is the factor income and transfer incomes enjoyed by the
households of an economy over a year.
190
: It shows the relationship between inflation and unemployment.
Phillips Curve
Phillips curve is downward sloping in the short-run, implying a
trade-off between the two. In the long-run the Phillips Curve is
vertical, implying that unemployment rate cannot be brought down
below natural rate of unemployment.
Price Level : It is the average of prices of all the goods and services produced in
a country.
Rate of Net Foreign : It is the difference between rate of gross domestic capital
Capital Inflow formation and rate of gross domestic savings.
191
Real Flows : These are the flows of goods or services from one set of
transactors to another.
Real Money Balances : Quantity of nominal money divided by the price level.
Real Transactions : Those transactions, which are related to exchange of goods and
services between two transactors or two groups of transactors.
Repo Rate : Rate at which the central bank lends funds to the commercial
banks against submission of collateral such as securities by the
banks.
Residential Investment : Investment incurred on construction of new houses and buildings
is called as residential investment.
Rest of the World : This sector deals with economic transactions of an economy
Sector with the rest of the world.
Reverse Repo Rate : Rate at which the commercial banks can deposit their excess
liquidity with the central bank, by purchasing securities.
Statutory Liquidity : Banks are required to hold a certain percentage of their demand
Ratio (SLR) and time deposits in the form of government securities. Currently
(in 2019) the SLR is 19.5 per cent in India.
192
institutional features of the business environment.
Transfer Payments : One-way payment of money for which no goods or services are
received in exchange.
Wealth Budget : Sum of individual’s demand for money and demand for bonds is
Constraint the individual’s total financial wealth.
Wholesale Price Index : Wholesale Price Index represents the rate of increase in the
wholesale prices of products.
193
SOME USEFUL BOOKS FOR FURTHER READING
Abel Andrew B, Ben Bernanke, and Dean Croushore, 2017, Macroeconomics, Ninth Edition, Pearson
Education
Case Karl E., Ray C. Fair, and Sharon E. Oster, 2017, Principles of Economics, Twelfth Edition, Pearson
Education
Dornbusch Rudiger, Stanley Fisher, and Richard Startz, 2018, Macroeconomics, Thirteenth Edition,
McGraw Hill
Froyen Richard T., 2012, Macroeconomics: Theories and Policies, Tenth Edition, Person Education
Sikdar Shoumyen, 2011, Principles of Macroeconomics, Second Edition, Oxford University Press
194