561-Original Article-3872-1-10-20220220
561-Original Article-3872-1-10-20220220
561-Original Article-3872-1-10-20220220
IJNHS
Importance of Nurse Workload
Management as the Main Factor Affecting
a Patient Safety Culture
Selamat1, Ratna Indrawati2, Anastina Tahjoo3
Department of Hospital Administration, Universitas Esa Unggul
Article information Abstract
Introduction: The implementation of patient safety goals is
Article history: the compliance behavior of health workers in implementing
Received; December 24th, 2021 the standards and targets set by the hospital concerning
Revised: January 22th, 2022 international patient safety goals to ensure safe services for
Accepted: February 15th, 2022 every patient. The international patient safety goals adopted
by the hospital accreditation committee (KARS) have 6 (six)
goals. Objective: The purpose of the study was to obtain
Corresponding author: empirical evidence of the effect of knowledge and workload
Ratna Indrawati on the implementation of patient safety goals mediated by
Address: Universitas Esa Unggul, Jl. patient safety culture. Method: This type of research is a
Arjuna Utara, Kebon Jeruk. Jakarta causative quantitative analytic study with a cross-sectional
Barat research design. The sample population of this study is 140
E-mail: [email protected] nurses with a saturated sampling technique. In this study,
measurements are done on primary data in a questionnaire
distributed by Google Form to 140 respondents, and all
respondents filled out the Google Form. In this study, the
International Journal of Nursing and
analysis was carried out using path analysis. Results: The
Health Services (IJNHS)
results showed that knowledge, workload, and patient
Volume 5, Issue 1, February 20th, 2022
safety culture simultaneously had a positive and significant
http://doi.org/10.35654/ijnhs.v5i1.561
effect on implementing patient safety goals. The research
E-ISSN: 2654-6310
findings show that patient safety culture can mediate patient
safety goals. The workload does not directly influence the
performance of patient safety goals. Recommendations: for
hospital management to be more attentive to nursing
workload management, the main factor affected patient
safety culture. For further research, data from other hospital
stakeholders can be added.
International Journal of Nursing and Health Services (IJNHS), Volume 5, Issue 1, February 20th, 2022 96
Introduction Those facts are confirmed by the Focus
The hospital is the place where people Group Discussion (FGD) result as the
go when they need health services. Those initial data collection at Hospital X in
who come to the hospital have the right Kota Tangerang. 58% of participants
to get quality and safe services. Events assumed that the patient safety culture
experienced by patients that can impact among nurses at Hospital X was still low,
patient safety are called Patient Safety 42% thought patient safety knowledge
Events. Patient Safety Events vary from among nurses was insufficient, and 50%
Hazardous Conditions, Near-miss of participants considered that nurses'
Events, No-harm Events to Adverse workload at Hospital X was well
Events. An adverse event that has a managed. More than 70% of reported
severe impact that causes disability and incidents, including Hazardous
even death is called a sentinel event (1). Conditions, Near-miss Events, No-harm
The success of preventing patient Events, and Adverse Events that
safety events is highly dependent on the occurred at Hospital X Kota Tangerang,
human factor. Therefore knowledge, involved nurses who directly served
workload, and patient safety culture are patients. This is not surprising
factors that need to be considered to considering the number of nurses as the
implement patient safety goals (2) (3). majority of human resources in hospitals.
At Hospital X Tangerang City, Reports from January to March 2020,
there were still patient safety incidents which are 1 Hazardous Conditions, 3
that should not have happened. Near-miss Events, 2 No-harm Events,
Therefore, it is necessary to examine the and 2 Adverse Events, all involve nurses.
factors that influence the implementation From simple investigations to Root
of patient safety goals. The primary Cause Analysis (RCA), the most
purpose of this study is to provide input common reasons are excessive workload
for the management of Hospital X and lack of knowledge about patient
Tangerang City to make improvements safety. This happens because of the high
that can reduce the incidence of patient turnover of nurses at Hospital X Kota
safety incidents. At Hospital X Kota Tangerang. For new nurses, who do not
Tangerang, there were still events where have the knowledge and experience of
superiors were angry with nurses who working in hospitals, incident reporting
reported patient safety events. This is an is a unique experience that requires
indication of a low patient safety culture. repetition to become a habit.
From the results of simple investigations The novelty of this study is placing
and RCA (Root Cause Analysis), from patient safety culture as a mediating
several incident reports, "forget" or "do variable and using path analysis as the
not know" are the most common reasons. data analysis method.
This shows a lack of patient safety
knowledge among the nurses. Another Literature Reviews
reason was "busy," which indicated the Patient safety is an essential
need to analyze the nurse's workload. component in the quality of hospital
International Journal of Nursing and Health Services (IJNHS), Volume 5, Issue 1, February 20th, 2022 97
services. The first dimension of the The design of this study used a
quality of hospital services is patient cross-sectional approach with
safety. Safety as the first domain of quantitative causality research, which
hospital service quality refers to aims to see the effect of knowledge and
"freedom from accidental injury"(3). workload on the implementation of
International Patient Safety Goals patient safety goals mediated by patient
(IPSGs) consist of 6 goals, namely: Goal safety culture.
1: Identify patients correctly; Goal 2:
Improve effective communication; Goal Sample, sample size & Sampling technique
3: Improve safety High Alert The sample in this study were
Medications; Goal 4: Ensure correct site, nurses with a total sample of 140
correct procedure, and correct patient respondents by total sampling, which are
surgery; Goal 5: Reduce the risk of the entire population. The inclusion
healthcare-associated infection; Goal 6: criteria were all nurses who directly
Reduce the risk of patient harm resulting served patients. The exclusion criteria
from falls (4). were nurses who had filed resignations
In this study, following the conditions and nurses who held managerial
of Hospital X Kota Tangerang, only positions.
target one, and target five will be
studied. Implementing patient safety Instrument for data collection
goals will serve as a layer of defense to The data collection instrument
prevent patient safety incidents from used a closed questionnaire. Each
occurring. Therefore, we can conclude statement item was provided with a
that patient safety is essential choice of answers in a rating scale using
continuously and consistently. a Likert scale, with the lowest score being
Safety culture is built by all one and the highest score being five. The
employees' attitudes, beliefs, knowledge variable consists of 3
perceptions, and values about safety (2). components with 3 question items each.
Patient safety culture defines our belief The workload variable consists of 4
system that will govern how we behave components with 3 question items each.
(1). The patient safety culture variable
consists of 7 components with 3 question
Study Model items each. The variable implementation
of patient safety goals consists of 2
components with 3 question items each.
The questionnaire that would be
distributed was in electronic form using
a google form to 140 respondents. The
collection was done directly without
intermediaries.
Data analysis was the validity test
using Pearson Product Moment
METHOD Correlation. It was said to be valid if the
Design
International Journal of Nursing and Health Services (IJNHS), Volume 5, Issue 1, February 20th, 2022 98
value of r count > r table. Data from 30 Characteristics Respondents Percentage
all data, and it was found that all Sick baby ward 4 2.9%
Polyclinic 25 17.9%
variables had data that were normally
Isolation Inpatient 29 20.7%
distributed. An outlier test was also Room
carried out, and no outliers were found. Regular
Room
Inpatient 39 27.9%
International Journal of Nursing and Health Services (IJNHS), Volume 5, Issue 1, February 20th, 2022 99
Safety culture to
Patient safety goals 0.367 0.102 3.588 0.000
implementation
International Journal of Nursing and Health Services (IJNHS), Volume 5, Issue 1, February 20th, 2022 100
the implementation of the behavior. safety incident reporting to improve the
Safety culture is one of the factors that implementation of patient safety goals.
have a strong influence on a person's Based on the discussion above, the
behavior (5), (6), study results support several studies
(7). According to Tylor (5), culture is a conducted in Indonesia, which also show
complex consisting of knowledge, belief, the relationship between nurses'
art, law, morals, habits, and abilities knowledge and the implementation of
acquired by a person as part of a patient safety goals. Sithi & Widyastuti
community, which is a hospital. (8) conducted a study on the factors that
Therefore, knowledge is also a factor that contribute to patient safety incidents in
influences a person's behavior. implementing patient safety goals for
inpatients at a hospital in the city of
Effect of knowledge on the Depok. In this study, it was found that
implementation of patient safety goals staff and knowledge factors are some of
There is a positive influence of the factors that contribute to patient
knowledge on implementing patient safety incidents. Research conducted by
safety goals (p-value <0.05) with an Soeryo Koesoemo et al. (9) shows the
estimated value of 0.456. This proves relationship between nurses' knowledge
that knowledge affects the and attitudes towards the application of
implementation of patient safety goals patient safety goals in the inpatient room
by 45.6%, and other variables outside this of Aulia Hospital, South Jakarta.
study influence the remaining 54.4%. The Syarianingsih Syam & Kurnia Widi
direct influence of knowledge on the Hastuti (10) researched the relationship
implementation of patient safety goals is between nurses' knowledge and
0.456, while if a patient safety culture attitudes towards implementing patient
mediates it, the estimated value is 0.119. safety goals in Yogyakarta Hospital.
It can be concluded that patient safety
culture has a role in improving the Effect of workload on the
implementation of patient safety goals. implementation of patient safety goals
Based on descriptive analysis using The result found no effect of
the three-box method on the knowledge workload on the implementation of
variable, the highest index value is found patient safety goals with a p-value of
in P7, an indicator of reducing the risk of 0.207 (>0.05) with an estimated value of -
infection related to health services, 0.121. This shows that the workload does
namely "I can explain five moments of not affect the implementation of patient
hand hygiene" with a score of 93.43. The safety goals. Based on these results, it can
lowest index value is found in P1 of the be concluded that the nurse's workload
incident reporting indicator, "I does not affect patient safety goals.
understand how to report patient safety Based on the analysis of the
incidents," 82.86. distribution of respondents using the
These results indicate that the three-box method, the average
hospital needs to pay attention to patient distribution of respondents with an
average index value of 73.77 lies in the
International Journal of Nursing and Health Services (IJNHS), Volume 5, Issue 1, February 20th, 2022 101
high category. The highest index value of patient safety, is still very weak. Nurse
80.71 is in BK4, the task level indicator, workload is the volume of work of
namely "I feel I can complete every task nurses in a hospital unit. At the same
given ."The lowest index value is found time, the work of nurses is the time
in the BK1 unit level indicator, namely "I needed to treat patients 24 hours per day.
feel that my unit's workload is balanced It is essential to know the workload as
between the number of patients and the the basis for knowing the work capacity
number of nurses," with an index value of nurses so that there is a balance
of 65.57. Employees feel that the between the nursing staff and the
workload of their unit is balanced workload.
between the number of patients and the
number of nurses. As much as 40% of Effect of knowledge on patient safety
employees think that there is a balance culture
between the number of patients and Through statistical calculations using
nurses. Amos V21, it is known that there is a
One of the factors that influence the positive and significant influence
risk of decreasing performance is between knowledge to patient safety
workload. An increase in workload can culture. Based on the coefficient of
occur if the number of nurses does not determination test (R2), the estimated
match the level of care needs of the value of the knowledge variable on
patient (11). For this reason, the hospital patient safety culture is 0.257. This means
can use various methods of calculating that the knowledge variable affects
the needs of nurses according to the patient safety culture by 25.7%, while
conditions and needs of the hospital. other variables outside this study
Hospital management can use the influence the remaining 74.3%.
formula from the Indonesian National Levett-Jones et al. (13) conducted a
Nurses Association (PPNI) workshop to study exploring nurses' knowledge
calculate the need for nurses if it takes about patient safety. According to him,
into account the number of visits and nurses' perception or confidence about
length of treatment per patient. It can their level of knowledge is more
also be used if the ability and resources influential than the actual level of
for personnel planning are limited, the knowledge. Perceptions of knowledge
type, type, and volume of health services and self-confidence affect the formation
are relatively stable and quite effective in of a patient safety culture.
overcoming the occurrence of spikes in According to the book Patient Safety
cases because it takes into account the Culture: Theory, Methods, and
full capacity of inpatient care (total used) Application – 1st edition, Waterson (14)
which can occur at any time. shows that patient safety culture is
The results of this study support the formed from the learning process so that
result of other research Sitanggang (12), there is a relationship between
which finds that the strength of the knowledge and culture. Thus, the higher
relations between the two variables, or deeper one's understanding of
namely the workload of nurses and something, the more likely that
International Journal of Nursing and Health Services (IJNHS), Volume 5, Issue 1, February 20th, 2022 102
knowledge becomes a culture within a of a patient safety culture can be
person. Previous research has linked hindered by things that are not liked or
knowledge and learning processes with become a negative factor for someone to
patient safety culture (13), (15), (16), (8), adopt a new culture. The excessive
(17), (18), (19), (20), (21), (14), (22), (23). workload can be a barrier to forming a
patient safety culture in a nurse. Other
Effect of workload on patient safety studies have also shown that for nurses
culture with undue burdens or organizations
Based on the results of statistical tests that place too much emphasis on labor
on the estimated value, it is known that efficiency, the formation of a patient
the workload has a positive and safety culture is also hampered (25), (26).
significant effect on patient safety
culture. Based on the estimated value of Effect of patient safety culture on the
the workload, it impacts 63.5% on patient implementation of patient safety goals
safety culture. Other variables outside The results of statistical testing
the study influence the remaining 36.5%. showed that patient safety culture had a
This variable appears to be the dominant positive and significant effect on the
or most significant variable influencing implementation of patient safety goals.
work safety culture. The average index value of 78.33 lies
Based on descriptive analysis using in the high category based on descriptive
the three-box method, the average index analysis using the three-box method. The
value of 73.77 lies in the high category. highest index value is found in the BPK4
The highest index value of 80.71 is in safety system indicator, namely "I feel
BK4, the task level indicator, namely "I the hospital has a good SOP in the
feel I can complete every task given ."The implementation of patient safety," with
second-lowest index value is found in an index value of 82.86. The lowest index
BK9, the patient level indicator, namely value is found in the BPK8 work pressure
"I feel that the distribution of patients is indicator with a value of 70.29, namely "I
quite evenly distributed among all health can always cope with work pressure in
workers," with an index value of 71. this hospital." there are 44% of
The results of this study are in employees who are doubtful if
accordance with Flin et al. (24) in his employees can overcome work pressure
book Measuring safety climate: problems in a hospital environment.
identifying the common features, The results of the study support
suggests that one of the factors that previous research, which has found that
influence patient safety culture is work culture is a decisive factor that influences
pressure, namely the work environment the implementation of patient safety
and workload. Previous research has goals (8,13-23).
also found a relationship between
workload and patient safety culture. In Study Limitations
the book Patient Safety Culture: Theory, This study has some limitations that
Methods, and Application – 1st edition, can be a source for future studies. The
Waterson (14) shows that the formation limitations found in this study: this study
International Journal of Nursing and Health Services (IJNHS), Volume 5, Issue 1, February 20th, 2022 103
was conducted on nurses who work in perceived imbalance between the
different areas, which means the number of nurses and patients. The
knowledge and perceived workload will competence of nurses as the ability to
be different. For example, nurses in the deal with workloads needs to be
inpatient and outpatient departments continuously improved through training
will be other in their workload and level and education so that there is no
of knowledge. excessive workload without having to
add too much human resource.
Conclusion Teamwork also needs to be formed and
Knowledge and workload mediated built through team-building activities so
by patient safety culture partially have a that nurses can work well together. In
positive and significant effect on the terms of patient safety culture, hospital
implementation of patient safety goals, leaders need to continue to pay attention
and learning has a direct impact on the to what makes up a safety culture
implementation of patient safety goals, starting from hospital management. A
but workload does not directly affect the no-blaming culture is formed, and
implementation of patient safety goals. finally, a patient safety culture.
If all these aspects can be met, it is
Managerial Implications hoped that knowledge, workload, and
This study proves the hypothesis of patient safety culture will be formed that
the influence of knowledge, workload, support the implementation of patient
and patient safety culture on safety goals.
implementing patient safety goals.
Hospitals, in this case, management Implication for further study
must be able to increase nurses' To obtain more representative
knowledge about patient safety and results, it is necessary to conduct
manage the workload of nurses well so research with a larger sample under
that the implementation of patient safety normal conditions.
goals can be carried out optimally.
It is necessary to periodically evaluate Recimmendation
the patient safety knowledge of Hospital management needs to form
employees, especially nurses. Patient systems and patterns that can improve
safety socialization and resocialization, knowledge of managing workloads well
both for incident reports and patient and form a patient safety culture by
safety goals, need to be a routine agenda. paying attention to the continuity of
This can be done effectively and patient safety socialization and
efficiently by using online meetings resocialization. It also evaluates and
regularly and continuously by adding enhances nurse schedule arrangements,
exciting elements such as competitions increasing nurse competence, and
and quizzes with prizes to avoid teamwork to establish a patient safety
boredom. Nurse workload management culture.
by managing a reasonable work schedule
needs to be considered to eliminate the Acknowledgments
International Journal of Nursing and Health Services (IJNHS), Volume 5, Issue 1, February 20th, 2022 104
The authors express their highest 2(1). https://doi.org/10.9707/2307-
appreciation and gratitude to Dr. Rokiah 0919.1014
Kusumapradja, S.KM., M.HA, as the 8. Sithi DS, Widyastuti A. Contributing
head of the ESA Unggul University factor to incident of patient safety within
implementing patient safety goal in
Hospital Administration Masters study
inpatient Depok City Hospital Indonesia.
program. Dr. Rian Adi Pamungkas, S.
Annals of Tropical Medicine and Public
Kep, M.NS, PHN, have given a lot of Health. 2019; 22(11):316-324
support, assistance, and motivation since 9. Koesoemo S. Hubungan Antara
the lecture began until the writing of this Pengetahuan dan Sikap Terhadap Lama
journal. Thank you to the respondents Bekerja Perawat dalam Penerapan
who have participated and the hospital Sasaran Keselamatan Pasien di Ruang
for allowing this research to be carried Rawat Inap Rumah Sakit Aulia Jakarta
out. Selatan 2018. Seminar Nasional Pakar ke
2 Tahun 2019 Buku 1 : Sains dan
Teknologi; 2018.
10. Syam NS, Hastuti W, Kurnia S.
References Relationship Between Knowledge and
1. Donaldson, Liam. Textbook of Patient Attitude with Implementation of Patient
Safety and Clinical Risk Management. Safety Targets in RSUD Yogyakarta.
Springer; 2021. Jurnal Medicoeticolegal dan Manajemen
2. Cox s, Thomas, JM, Cheyne A, Oliver A. Rumah Sakit. Jurnal Medicoeticolegal
Safety culture: The prediction of dan Manajemen Rumah Sakit. 2018; 7(3):
commitment to safety in the 205-211.
manufacturing industry. British Journal 11. Gillies, D. A. Nursing Managements
of Management. 2002; 9(s1): 3-11 System Approach (Third). Philadelphia:
3. Kohn, Linda T. Rapporteur's Report WB Saunders; 2009.
Session I: Origin of the problem: 12. Hasanah N, Aira DMF, Widiastuti F.
Malcolm Ross. Regulatory Toxicology Hubungan Beban Kerja Perawat dengan
and Pharmacology; 2008. Penerapan Keselamatan Pasien (Patient
4. Joint Commission on Accreditation of Safety) di Ruang rawat inap Rumah Sakit
Healthcare Organizations. The Joint Umum daerah Raden Mattaher Jambi.
Commission announces 2014 National Jurnal Management Terapan dan
Patient Safety Goal. Jt Comm Perspect. Keuangan. 2018; 7(1): 68-78
2013;33(7):1,3-4. 13. Levett-Jones, Tracy. A cross-sectional
5. Tylor, EB. Primitive culture: Research survey of nursing students' patient safety
into the development of mythology, knowledge. Nurse Education Today.
philosophy, religion, art, and custom. 2020; 88:104372. doi:
https://books.google.co.id/; 1871. 10.1016/j.nedt.2020.104372
6. Geertz, Clifford. Thick description:
Toward an interpretive theory of culture. 14. Waterson. Patient Safety Culture:
Interpretation of Cultures; 1973. Theory, Methods, and Application - 1st
7. Hofstede, G. (2011). Dimensionalizing Edition. CRC Press; 2014.
Cultures: The Hofstede Model in 15. Abu-El-Noor NI, Abu-El-Noor MK,
Context. Online Readings in Psychology Abuowda YZ et al. Patient safety culture
and Culture, among nurses working in Palestinian
governmental hospital: a pathway to a
International Journal of Nursing and Health Services (IJNHS), Volume 5, Issue 1, February 20th, 2022 105
new policy. BMC Health Serv. 2019; 15: Journal of Nursing Education, Practice
550 and Research. 2018; 1(2): 135-143
16. Akologo A, Abuosi AA, Anaba EA. A 20. Danielsson, Marita. Patient Safety :
cross-sectional survey on patient safety Cultural Perspectives. LiU-Tryck,
culture among healthcare providers in Linköping, Sweden; 2018.
the Upper East region of Ghana. PLoS 21. Ammouri AA, Tailakh AK, Muliira JK,
ONE. 2019;14(8): e0221208 Geethakrishnan R, Al Kindi SN. Patient
17. Wu G, Mao J, Zhao L, Li Y, Li S, Wu Q. safety culture among nurses. Int Nurs
The Association of Patient Safety Culture Rev. 2015;62(1):102-10
with Hospital Safety Performance: A 22. Ulrich B, Kear T. Culture: Foundations of
Cross-sectional Survey. Health Science Excellent. Nephrology Nursing Journal.
Journal. 2019; 13(5): 1-6 2014; 41(5): 447-505
18. Cooper MD. The Safety Culture 23. Antonsen, Stian. Safety culture and the
Construct: Theory and Practice. In: issue of power. Safety Science. 2009;
Gilbert C., Journé B., Laroche H., Bieder 47(2): 183-191
C. (eds) Safety Cultures, Safety Models. 24. Flin R, Mearns K, O’Connor P, Bryden R.
SpringerBriefs in Applied Sciences and Measuring safety climate: identifying the
Technology. Springer, Cham. common features. Elsevier. 2000; 34(1-
https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-319- 3):177-192
95129-4_5 25. Cho, Mi-young. Nurses’ knowledge,
19. Buharia B, Machmud R, Dorisnita D. attitude, and fall prevention practices at
Implementation of Patient Safety in south Korean hospitals: a cross-sectional
Accredited Hospitals and Its survey. BMC Nursing. 2020; 19, 108
Determining Factors in Jambi City, 26. Aiken. Taking Action Against Clinician
Indonesia. Elevate The International Burnout. National Academy of
Medicine; 2019.
International Journal of Nursing and Health Services (IJNHS), Volume 5, Issue 1, February 20th, 2022 106