Educational Interventionand Negotiation
Educational Interventionand Negotiation
Educational Interventionand Negotiation
net/publication/264964350
CITATIONS READS
0 815
1 author:
Amrita Mondal
University of North Bengal
11 PUBLICATIONS 0 CITATIONS
SEE PROFILE
All content following this page was uploaded by Amrita Mondal on 30 January 2015.
ABSTRACT
The Christian missionaries became interested in spreading education in
Bengal from the mid-eighteenth century. While doing so, the missionaries'
main aim was to make the local people realise that their salvation lay in
acceptance of Christianity, while they criticised vicious practices of Bengal.
The Charter Act of 1813 had empowered missionaries to preach Christianity
in India. Besides preaching, the Act also encouraged the missionaries in other
philanthropic works. In the educational field, this philanthropy was marked
by the introduction of western science along with Biblical studies, which
ultimately marginalisation of the indigenous knowledge system. However,
interaction between indigenous education and missionary's education system
had reframed the missionaries' educational aims over time. This indicated that
these Christian missionaries did not fully reject the indigenous knowledge
system. In this context, the paper evaluates the educational activities of the
Serampore mission. It consults several missionary documents of Serampore
mission. Besides, this paper also tries to explore the Serampore Missionaries'
perception of indigenous knowledge systems. The Mission established in
1800 by William Carey, Joshua Marshman and William Ward in Serampore.
With this Act, the East India Government had become interested in
educating indigenous people and the process started with the establishment
of 'Calcutta School Book Society' (1817), 'School Book Society' (1818), and
'Hindu College' (1817). Meanwhile, controversy started on the issue of
spending of one lakh rupees while educating the 'natives'. To solve the
problem, the Company Government had decided to prepare a secular and
78 Exploring History
II
Soon after it foundation, Serampore Mission started its journey in
educational field while opening two boarding schools on 1st May 1800 and
one native school in the month of June with forty pupils.9 Mr. and Mrs.
Marshman was the pioneer in that work. Considering the Charter Act of 1813,
Educational approaches of Serampore Mission can be divided into two
phases.
During, pre 1813 period, educational curriculum of Serampore Mission
was almost same like the other missionaries in India. Their aim behind the
establishment of schools was to bring changes in the hearts of the heathens
by providing them education, converting them to Christianity and train them
as future missionaries. Keeping these aims in mind Serampore Missionaries
tried to introduce such curriculum in their schools where students were given
lessons of arithmetic, 'Scripture'10 along with English language. However,
missionaries had also given emphasis on learning of vernacular languages,
like Sanskrit and Bengali. At the beginning these Missionaries did not give
importance to the science subjects. First and foremost, they introduced
subjects like orthography, grammar and vocabulary in vernacular language,
mathematics along with the lessons of ethics and morality.11 Even when they
established 'Benevolent Institution' during 1809-10, for the Eurasian poor of
Kolkata, there also they limited their curriculum within "reading, writing, and
Arithmetic, in different degrees and capable of preaching the scriptures in
the Bengalee or the English languages".12
After 1813, changes occurred in the educational curriculum of Serampore
Mission's schools. Marshman planned to extend the curriculum as well as
the schooling network in different parts of Bengal and outside of it. These
plans were properly drafted in 'Hints Relative to Native School', published
in 1816. Several reports of the Institution for the Encouragement of Native
Schools in India have depicted the implementation of these plans and
expansion of schooling network in different parts of Bengal. In Hints Relative
to Native School, Marshman discussed about the introduction of new
subjects, like Geography and use of compendiums in the Native Schools.
Compendiums were used to describe matters like grammar, arithmetic,
including a view of the solar system, ethics and morals etc.13
At the school level they did not introduce any science subject except
Geography and 'Jotish'. Only after the establishment of Serampore College;
the Mission authority introduced different science subjects like Chemistry,
Botany and Zoology in the College syllabus. They also introduced the
80 Exploring History
Scientific Copy Book to help students to make their concepts clear.14 While
preparing that copy book they followed a method. At first they chose a topic
and then explained that in one, two or three sentences of convenient length.15
The 'Scientific Copy Book' contained the ideas of solar system or 'Jotish',
Geography, Chronology, General History, True nature of virtue, Morality and
Religion.16 This copy book was a hand book for students, which provided
essential knowledge for their future. After intensive study of sample questions
of this book, it can be said, though these Serampore Missionaries tried to
introduce science education, but while doing so, they were propagating
Christianity, as they incorporated questions related to Christian theology and
ethics within this copy book.
When Serampore Mission established 'Institute for the encouragement of
Native School' in 1816, several schools established in towns and villages
within thirty miles of Kolkata came under its supervision. In fact, several other
schools in different parts of Bengal also came under the Institution. For
example, at Catwa17 and its neighbourhood area few schools had established
under the supervision of William Carey Junior.18 The first school report
depicts that in these areas the demand of schools was indeed high. In Dacca,
several new schools were opened by Mr. O. Leonard at the beginning of the
year 1817 but the Serampore Mission restricted the number in five. Reports
related to 'Institute for the encouragement of Native School', like, The First
Report of the Institution for the Encouragement of Native Schools in India
(July, 1816 to October 1817), depict the number of newly established schools
as well as number of enrolled students. The report also depicts that the
Serampore Missionaries introduced different subjects like, Dig-Durshuna,
Letters, Astronomical Compendium, Spelling Lessons, Tables and Inferior
lessons with Elementary Tables and most of the students were enrolled
themselves in spelling lessons and in 'Dig-Durshuna.
In the following years these Missionaries had published subsequent
reports of this Institution. The Second Report of the Institution for the
Encouragement of Native Schools in India, published in 1818, shows that
the number of students in Native schools gradually increased. By October
1818, the number of the students had reached seven thousand one hundred
and eighty eight.19 Besides, almost twelve new schools were founded after
October 1817. The second report of the Institution also shows that after 1817,
with the help of Serampore Missionaries, the Institution introduced few new
subject in the Native Schools, like Dig-Durshuna,20 Jotish, the Shastra
Puddhuti and Letters, Nittee Bakya and Spelling lessons and made certain
subjects combinations. Further, other than oriental languages, they incorporated
EDUCATIONAL INTERVENTION AND NEGOTIATION:... 81
III
While preparing a new educational curriculum for Mission's schools,
Serampore Missionaries also became interested in higher education. In 1818,
they founded Serampore College within the premises of Serampore Mission.
Later on it became the vertex point of 'eastern literature and western science'
as a result; the teaching was backed up by a well-stocked library, laboratory,
museum, medical unit and observatory. Clearly, in that Institution science was
given due attention. In the first prospectus of Serampore Collage, named,
College for the Instruction of Asiatic Christian and Other Youth in Eastern
Literature and European Science at Serampore, Bengal describes the aims
of the Institution. In the prospectus, it was said that, eastern languages like
Sanskrit, Arabic, and Chinese as well as major western languages like Greek,
Latin, and English were taught there.
The fifth point of this instruction's prospectus depicted that along with
various eastern and western languages and literatures, pupils had also
provided the lessons of European Science to expand their knowledge.
Besides, it also argued that science education should start with elementary
ideas, based on Geography, like, solar system, the laws of motion, nature of
the mechanical powers etc., and then 'gradually advance as the mind of youth
expand'.30 In this prospectus, it had also been told that lectures would deliver
on various branches of science and any Hindu or Muslim could attend them.
EDUCATIONAL INTERVENTION AND NEGOTIATION:... 83
College, Carey used to give lectures on Zoology and Botany.35 Mr. Albrech,
another Serampore Missionary and professor of Serampore College, had
taken the responsibility of the Geographical Department. He took good care
of maps of the world.36 Another respected professor of the Serampore
College of that period, Sir John Mack joined the Serampore Mission and as
Chemistry Professor at the College in 1821. While joining Serampore
Mission, he brought many scientific books along with scientific apparatuses
with him and later it enriched the College library as well as the College
laboratory. Along with chemistry, Mack also taught Geography in a scientific
way while using maps. Moreover, he translated the English map of India into
Bengali for the benefit of students. Serampore Missionaries always encouraged
the learning of natural science like Geography. The Mission's keenness
towards that subject made it a compulsory subject in school from the
beginning.37
In 1823, John Mack first delivered a lecture on Chemistry at Serampore
Mission. As the College notified, this lecture was open to all. The Fourth
report of Serampore College for the year 1823 had depicted that,
'The most respectable natives in Serampore and its neighbourhood have
been invited to attend the course free of cost, as well as the students and
Pundits of the College and those connected with the establishment. The
course has also been favoured with (attended by) the Company's Gentlemen
from Barackpore, and Calcutta'
Moreover, this lecture had left a great impact on the audience. The Fourth
report also said that after the succeeding lecture of that day, people who
attended the lecture, discussed about all things, whatever they had seen.
Though, some problems occurred as that lecture was delivered in English.
Mack also faced the same problem when he delivered lecture at Asiatic
society. To overcome the problem, he tried to learn the native language. He
tried to deliver lectures in Bengali and translated many scientific terms with
the help of scientific Sanskrit terms.
Parallel to all these scientific lectures, the Serampore Missionaries also
published several scientific books in vernacular language. In this process of
publishing scientific book, Carey's son Felix Carey took an important role.
A number of valuable scientific works in Bengali were written and translated
by Felix Carey.38 For example, he wrote an encyclopaedia and translated
an anatomy book, named Vidya-Harabali. It was the first anatomy book in
Bengali, published in two volumes. First volume described different internal
parts and anatomy of human body as well as the anatomy of some animals
EDUCATIONAL INTERVENTION AND NEGOTIATION:... 85
like cow and dog. Second part discussed on Chemistry, medicine and
surgery.39 These two books had a big demand for a long time, even many
years after Felix's death.40 In that book Felix Carey translated the medical
terms into Bengali and while doing so he took help from Sanskrit words.
Some of these terms are,
Hand: Hastha, Helicis major, m.: Karnagra baloyastha brihathasma,
Helix: karnagra baloy, Intestinal canal: Khudra-Pranaly, Inspissated coagulable
lymph: Medh, Integument: Charma (skin), Internal Jugular: Kanthnanthastha
raktabhak nari, Internuntii: Raganta dibash, Intestinum Rectum: Saralyantra
etc.41
Besides translating different medical terminology in Bengali with the help
of Sanskrit words, Felix Carey also translated John Mack's book Principles
of Chemistry in Bengali.
After discussing Serampore Mission's schools' and College's curriculums
of science and other subjects, it can be said that when they were preparing
the curriculum for schools and College, they gave equal importance towards
the secular curriculum of East India Company Government, moral educational
system of Christian missionaries' and indigenous educational system. This
kind of approaches of the Serampore Missionaries towards education was
mostly influenced by orientalist approach. However, later the attitudes of
different Christian missionaries while educating Indians changed. For example,
when Alexander Duff founded his school as well as college in 1830 onwards,
he was strongly critical of the secular educational curriculum of Company
Government.42 While preparing school's as well as college's curriculum, Duff
covered a large number of 'literary instructions, beginning with the alphabet
and extending to the most advanced course of literature'.43 He mainly
emphasised to make pupils rational with close questioning on various
issues.44 Moreover, through this process, he marginalised the indigenous
knowledge system.
On the contrary, Serampore Mission, while promoting science education
and rational knowledge, had not only raised questions on various superstitious
and vicious practices of indigenous society, but also gave legitimacy to
indigenous scientific knowledge by incorporating them within their schools
and college curricula. Besides, they appointed native pundits for delivering
lectures on 'Jotish'.
Conclusion:
It can be said that Serampore Mission's schools' and college's curricula
86 Exploring History
had gone through several changes. Initially their aims were to bring changes
in the hearts of the heathens by providing them education, converting them
into Christianity and train them as future missionaries. Keeping these aims
in mind Serampore Missionaries tried to introduce such subjects, which
would help to achieve their aims. When in 1813, Charter Act of 1813 was
passed and all political obligations had been withdrawn from missionaries'
activities, some changes occurred in Serampore Mission's educational activities.
Missionaries brought changes in their schools' curriculum by incorporating
new subjects, especially different indigenous subjects along with 'modern
western' subjects. Besides, they choose vernacular languages as medium of
instructions in schools. It might be possible that the reason behind choosing
of vernacular language as medium of instruction and introducing indigenous
subjects along with western subjects was, to attract large number of people
in their school. Even when the parents of the pupils opposed to their plan
of introducing the Bible in their school, the Serampore Missionaries postponed
their plan. However, they did not give up their missionary zeal while making
such negotiation with the indigenous people. For Example, while preparing
'Scientific Copy Book' they incorporated questions related to Christian
theology and ethics.
Besides, while preparing Serampore Mission College's curriculum, the
missionaries incorporated western science along with eastern literature. This
curriculum made Serampore College the vertex point of 'eastern literature and
western science'. They incorporated indigenous knowledge, like 'Jotish' in the
college's curriculum and also legitimised the Indian's notion of eclipse which
was depicted in Surya Siddhanta. When Serampore Missionary like Felix
Carey translated several scientific books into Bengali, they took help from
different Sanskrit words. Appointing native pundits for delivering lectures in
schools and college also indicated the orientalist nature of Serampore
Mission.
Moreover, all these approaches of the Serampore Mission indicated that
unlike the other Christian Mission and missionaries, the Serampore Mission
and its Missionaries maintained a negotiable attitude towards indigenous
knowledge by legitimising indigenous rational knowledge as well as indigenous
scientific knowledge by incorporating them within their schools' and college's
new curricula, especially while promoting science education.
Notes:
1. Laird, M. A., Missionary and Education in Bengal, 1793-1837, Oxford, 1972,
p. xi.
EDUCATIONAL INTERVENTION AND NEGOTIATION:... 87
23. Hints Relative to Native Schools, Together with the Outline of an Institution
for Their Extension and Management, p. 26.
24. Ibid., p. 27.
25. Ibid., p. 37.
26. Ibid.
27. Downs, Federick S., Christianity in North East India, Delhi, 1983 p. 54.
28. Ibid.
29. Sangma, Milton, A History of American Baptist Mission in East-India, Vol.
II, New Delhi, 1992, p. 2.
30. College for the Instruction of Asiatic Christian and Other Youth in Eastern
Literature and European Science at Serampore, 1819, p. 7.
31. Adam, William, On the State of Education in Bengal, Calcutta, 1835, pp. 70-71.
32. Suryasidhanta was an old Sanskrit book on astronomy.
33. Lilabati was an old Sanskrit book on Astronomy and mathematical calculation.
34. Samachar-Darpan, 20th March, 1819.
35. 'Brief Memoir Relative to the Operation of Serampore Missionaries, p. 27.
36. Ibid.
37. Calcutta Gazette, Thursday, 27th May, 1824.
38. Palit, Chittabrata, Scientific Bengal, New Delhi, 2006, p.49.
39. Carey, Felix, Vidya - Harravalee, Bengalee Encyclopedia, Vol.1, Serampore, 1820,
p. 3, (Actually the proposal of that second volume discussed in the end of first
volume and it was also said that after completing so respected mission press
notified that on Samachar-Darpan and on Friend of India.)
40. Friend of India, 1835-1839, during those years Felix Carey's book on anatomy
appeared in the advertizing page which display the mane of those books which
were on sale.
41. Carey, Felix, Vidya - Harravalee, op.cit., p. 5.
42. Viswanathan, Gauri, Masks of Conquests, op.cit., p. 48.
43. Ibid., p. 53.
44. Ibid., p. 54.
Reference:
Primary Documents:
Newspapers:
Carey Library and Research Centre, Serampore College, Serampore, Hooghly
1. Friend of India, (Quarterly Series), 1818.
2. Friend of India, 1835-1840(weekly).
EDUCATIONAL INTERVENTION AND NEGOTIATION:... 89
3. Samachar-Durpan, 1819.
4. Calcutta Gazette, 1824.
Institutional Papers:
Carey Library and Research Centre, Serampore College, Serampore, Hooghly
1. College for the Instruction of Asiatic Christian and Other Youth in Eastern
Literature and European Science, Serampore, Bengal. London, 1819.
2. Hints relative to native schools together with the outline of an instruction for
the extension and argument, Serampore, Mission Press, 1816.
3. The First report on the institution for the encouragement of native schools
in India with list of subscribers and benefactors, Serampore, Mission Press,
1817.
4. The second report of the institution for the support and encouragement of
native schools begun at Serampore, Nov.1816, with a list of subscribes and
benefactors, Serampore, Mission Press, 1818.
5. The Third report of the institution for the support and encouragement of native
schools begun at Serampore, Nov.1816, with a list of subscribes and benefactors,
Serampore, Mission Press, 1820.
6. Manual of direction of Superintendents attached to the Institution for the
Encouragement of Native Schools, Mission House, Serampore, 1818.
7. Brief memoir relative to the operation of Serampore Missionaries in Bengal,
London, 1827.