Summary For Quantum

Summary for Quantum
Mak Pik Hong (HCCS No. 2 of 2008)
(1) Laceration 7cm on left knee – B$13,552 (B$1,936 for 1cm)

(2) V shaped laceration on dorsum of tongue – B$19,360 (B$1,936 for 1cm)
(3) 6cm lacerated wound of the right ankle – B$11,616 (B$1,936 for 1cm)
(4) Large hyper pigmented and hypertrophic scar on the left knee measuring 7cm and
1cm thick – B$8,470 (B$1,210 for 1cm)
(5) Large horizontal hyper pigmented scar on the medical aspect of the right ankle
measuring 11cm with tenderness – B$15,310 (B$1,210 for 1cm scar & B$2,000.00 for
tenderness)
(6) Open compound subtalar or peritalar dislocation – B$50,585
(7) Torn ligaments – B$40,800 (B$6,800 for 1 ligament)
(8) Osteoarthritis of both the ankle and talar joints – B$14,520 (B$7,260 for 1 ankle)
(9) Tibial nerve injury – B$15,260
(10) Cost of future medical treatments and medical appliances
(11)Cost of shoe orthoses
(12)Cost of hiring a maid
(13)Loss of earning capacity
Mohamad Arif & Others v Too Shu Vun (Civil Suit No. 80 of 2012)
1st Plaintiff
(1) Deep lacerated wound on forehead about 8cm x 2cm – B$12,000 for 10cm
(2) Fracture of frontal bone with several brain injury – B$185,000
(3) Clinical depression – B$55,000
(4) Right ankle injury – B$28,000
(5) Subtrochanteric fracture of the right femur – B$35,000
(6) Moderate degenerative arthritis on right ankle joint – B$8,500
(7) Multiple right orbital bone fracture with displacement of the supraorbital margin
and roof of the right orbit – B$15,000
(8) Comminuted fracture of the posterior wall of right frontal sinus – B$12,000
(9) Fracture of the right superior ethmoid bone – B$4,000
(10)Damage to right optic nerve – B$15,000
(11)Permanent partial loss of right vision (6/20) eye acuity and sever constriction of the
visual field with temporal hemianapis – B$15,000
(12)Bilateral periorbital haematoma – B$7,000
(13)Conjuntival chemosis and exposure keratopathy in his right eye – B$3,000
(14)Lacerated wound and scar on the right knee 9cm – B$11,000
(15)Lacerated wound and scar 8cm on the left knee – B$10,000
(16)12cm longitudinal incisional scar on his right forehead and scalp with slight
depression at the upper end of forehead – B$15,000
(17)5cm tracheostomy scar over the lower anterior neck – B$5,500
(18)Right hip lateral aspect 20cm incisional scar – B$18,000
(19)Right knee lateral aspect 11cm incisional scar – B$8,000
(20)Left ankle medial malleolus 2cm laceration scar – B$2,500
(21)Loss of amenities – inability to participate in any sports
(22)Loss of future earnings
(23)Loss of TAP and SCP contribution
(24)Loss of declared dividends from TAP and SCP
(25)Education allowances
(26)Passage allowances
(27)Air passage for Haj
(28)Housing entitlement
(29)Cost of lifelong care/driver/domestic assistance
(30)Loss of use of BAB6075
2nd Plaintiff
(1) Degloving injury on the scalp with multiple stellate lacerated wounds on forehead
which was extending to right front parietal scalp with degloving about 15cm -
B$20,000
(2) 15cm scar from forehead to the scalp – B$12,000
(3) Lacerated wound and 4.5cm scar over the left forearm – B$7,500
(4) Multiple abrasion/lacerations over left hand, below left eye, right forearm, right
wrist, below right knee with scarring – B$12,000
3rd Plaintiff
(1) Small wound in the right parietal region – B$1,500
(2) 2cm laceration and scar of the left upper eyelid – B$5,000
(3) Brain injury – pontine and prepontine cisternal bleed – B$30,000
(4) Small upper lip frenulum tear – contusion of upper lip – B$3,000
(5) Multiple abrasions on his face, bruising over right eye and abrasion on left hand –
B$3,000
Sayed Late Momin Sheikh v Sykt Haji Abd Hamid Haji Bakar (Civil Suit No. 310 of 2004)
(1) 6cm traverse open wound with fracture of the lower 1/3 left tibia and fibula with 8%
permanent disability and permanent limitation of 5◦ plantar flexion and 5◦”
dorsiflexion of left ankle and possibility of early degenerative changes in ankle joint –
B$25,000
(2) 12cm long scar of which 6cm scar has a breath of 3cm and loss of skin over left thigh
– B$10,000
(3) Loss of future earnings
Norfahrizen Bte Hj Sulaiman v Law Tsuey Jen & Voon Jiunn Shiong (Civil Suit No. 5 of 2004)
(1) Dislocation of the left big toe – B$5,000

(2) Facial scar – B$7,000
(3) Fracture of the right femur + 3 surgical scars i.e. 9cm on the outer aspect of the
upper right thigh, 1cm scar below the largest scar and 1cm scar above the right knee
– B$25,000
(4) Award for the hire of a maid
Ansyaruddin v Amarco Sdn Bhd (Civil Suit No. 8 of 2006)
(1) An abrasion on the corneo in front of the iris of his right eye – B$16,320
(2) Loss of amenities – no award
(3) Loss of future earnings/loss of earning capacity – no award
Hajah Sadiaih Binti Mat v Tham Tong Seng (Civil Suit No. 150 of 2000)
(1) Fracture of lateral third of right clavicle + loss of amenity – B$16,000

(2) Osteoarthritis – B$6,000
(3) Multiple small abrasions on the right cheek, right wrist and right knee cap – B$2,000
for each of the abrasions
(4) Cost of future domestic help – no award
Bijun Bin Kalur v Pahaytc Sdn Bhd (Civil Suit No. 59 of 2006)
(1) Half-inch wastage of left leg – B$2,000

(2) Bruise over right anterior upper chest – B$2,000
(3) Multiple abrasions over the left thigh, right elbow, right knee, right hand and face –
B$8,000
(4) Small laceration wound on right leg – B$1,300
(5) Small cut on right hand, superficial cuts on face – B$2,000
(6) Scarring i.e. 2-inch scar over the tibial tuberosity, multiple scars over the left leg and
3-inch scar inn the middle of the tibia – B$8,500
(7) Loss of future earnings
(8) Loss of amenities
Linda Rosana v Chen Kim Siong (Civil Suit No. 23 of 2005)
(1) 4-inch (10cm) laceration, left parietal region – B$14,000

(2) Two scars on inside left thigh, measuring 3cm and 6cm respectively – B$9,000 (6cm =
B$6,000 & 3cm = B$3,000)
(3) 3cm laceration on right elbow – B$3,300
(4) 4cm laceration on chin – B$4,400
(5) Long laceration over the right hip (12cm) – B$10,000
(6) Multiple abrasions over the right thigh, right inguinal region, both feet, both hands,
right eyelid, right elbow and chest – B$12,000
(7) Bruising over both feet, upper right breast, left leg and right upper arm – B$10,500
(8) Haematoma injuries to left ankle, back of thigh and all over the right leg – B$13,000
(9) Fractures of the 3rd, 4th, 5th, 6th and 7th ribs – B$20,000
(10)Fracture of the left scapula and dislocation of the left acromio – clavicular joint –
B$30,000
(11)Parasymphyseal fracture of the mandible causing devitalisation of the lower anterior
teeth especially number 41 – B$25,000
(12)Teeth 11 & 12 – B$6,000
(13)Tooth 13 – B$3,000
(14)Tooth 22 fractured and lost – B$3,000
(15)Tooth 41 dead – B$3,000
(16)Dentoalvolear fracture from tooth 13 to tooth 21 at the pre maxilla – B$6,600
(17)Arthritic changes to jaw – no award
(18)Post-traumatic stress syndrome, atypical odontalgia and depression – B$55,000
(19)Loss of future earnings and/or loss of earning capacity
(20)Future medical expenses
(21)The cost of psychiatric treatment in Indonesia
Hajah Suayah Binti Haji Kamis v Maimunah Binti Abdul Gani (Civil Suit No. 73 of 2004)
(1) C2 fracture – B$48,000

(2) Future costs of domestic help – B$93,000
(3) Future earnings & loss of earning capacity – B$66,00 for loss of future earnings &
B$10,000 for loss of earning capacity
Rahmah Bte Hj Abd Hamid v Ak Md Ali Inda Putra Bin Pg Dato Hj Hamzad (Civil Suit No. 301
of 1998)
1st Plaintiff
(1) Pain and suffering during consciousness for 7 days before dying – B$30,000
(2) Dependency
(3) Retirement funds
(4) Funeral expenses
2nd Plaintiff
(1) Minor head injuries, lacerations of the eye brow and eyelid and traumatic hydreasis -
B$6,000
3rd Plaintiff
(1) Swelling over the root of the nose – B$1,000
(2) Tenderness over 7M joint with painful occlusion – B$2,000
(3) Lacerations – B$3,000
(4) Loose tooth – B$1,000
(5) Fracture of fingers – B$4,500
4th Plaintiff
(1) Fractures of the left humerus and the left tibia – B$21,400
(2) Laceration over the upper lip – B$3,000
5th Plaintiff
(1) Injury to the right lower limb – B$13,000
(2) Severe head injuries – B$37,200
Mohamad Affi Bin Hassan (through his father and next friend Hassan Bin Haji Garip) v Alving
Chong (Civil Trial No. 72 of 2005)
(1) Left fronto temporal fracture – B$5,920

(2) Left mastoid bone fracture – B$5,920
(3) Right left fronto temporal a/c extra dural haematoma – B$4,000
(4) Right temporal a/c subdural haematoma – B$4,000
(5) Multiple scars on head, lip and right shoulder – B$1,200 for all faint scars
(6) Loss of consciousness – disallowed
Baru Agong & Salli Agong v Anting Anak Berang (Civil Suit No. 50 of 2004)
(1) Miscarriage – B$15,000

Pg Hj Abdullah Bin Pg Mohamad v Hj Mohd Zaidi Bin Hj Serudin (Civil Suit No. 67 of 2004)
3rd Plaintiff
(1) Fracture of right clavicle (collar bone) – B$5,000
(2) Trauma on right shoulder – B$600
(3) Abrasion to the left side of face and right ear – B$2,000
(4) Trauma to the frontal region of the head – B$2,000
2nd Plaintiff
(1) Tenderness of lower chest and epigastrium
Tajuddin Bin Chuchu v Alim Bin Haji Mohamad (ICCS No. 14 of 2001)
Award B$36,000 for pain and suffering and loss of amenities for the following lacerations and
scarring to her face:-
(1) Vertical 5cm x 1cm deep laceration over the right side of the forehead extending to
the right eyebrow
(2) 2cm long transversely placed laceration over the nose bone/bridge
(3) 4cm long obliquely placed and 1cm deep laceration on the left cheek with skin lost
(4) 1cm laceration on the left side of cheek
(5) 1cm laceration wound on the chin
(6) Scarring as a result of the laceration and the surgical procedure performed
Fabiola Ng Yiok Chin v Megalift Sdn Bhd (Civil Suit No. 87 of 2011)
(1) Open comminuted fracture of the right elbow – B$35,000

(2) Multiple lacerations on right elbow – B$20,000
(3) Scarring – B$25,000
(4) Osteoarthritis of the right elbow joint – B$8,000
(5) Loss of amenities
(6) Cost of future medical treatment
Law Tsuey Jen v Noorfahrizen Bte Haji Sulaiman (Civil Appeal No. 1 of 2006)
(1) Dislocation of left big toe – B$5,000

(2) Penetrating injury to chin, internal injury in the oral cavity and scarring – B$7,000
(3) Fracture of the right femur, scarring and permanent disability – B$20,000
(4) Domestic help

Summary For Quantum

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

Summary For Quantum

Uploaded by

Document Information

Original Title

Copyright

Available Formats

Share this document

Share or Embed Document

Sharing Options

Did you find this document useful?

Is this content inappropriate?

Copyright:

Available Formats

Summary For Quantum

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

Summary for Quantum

Mak Pik Hong (HCCS No. 2 of 2008)

(1) Laceration 7cm on left knee – B$13,552 (B$1,936 for 1cm)

(1) Dislocation of the left big toe – B$5,000

Ansyaruddin v Amarco Sdn Bhd (Civil Suit No. 8 of 2006)

(1) Fracture of lateral third of right clavicle + loss of amenity – B$16,000

(1) Half-inch wastage of left leg – B$2,000

Linda Rosana v Chen Kim Siong (Civil Suit No. 23 of 2005)

(1) 4-inch (10cm) laceration, left parietal region – B$14,000

(1) C2 fracture – B$48,000

(1) Left fronto temporal fracture – B$5,920

(1) Miscarriage – B$15,000

(1) Open comminuted fracture of the right elbow – B$35,000

(1) Dislocation of left big toe – B$5,000

You might also like