Autonomy

Autonomy
Roll no. 36 to 40
Definition
Autonomy is a fundamental principle in medical ethics that recognizes the

rights of patients to make decisions about their own healthcare.
So it is the right of individual to make decisions about their own lives,
including healthcare choices.
Why is Autonomy important?
Autonomy provides the following benefits to patients.
1. Active participation
We need to make sure that the patient is actively involved in their diagnosis and treatment – and is not
just referring to their Doctor.
2. Empowerment
Promotes informed decision-making and empowers the patient.
3. Right information
It ensures that patients have access to accurate and comprehensive information about their health
conditions, treatment options, and potential risks and benefits. (It gives the patient the right information
about their health, treatments, and what might happen, so one can decide what is best for him or her.)
Why is Autonomy important?
4.It 4. Honours Patient's rights and dignity
It recognizes that individuals have the right to make decisions about their own
bodies, health, and well-being.
5. Helps in End-of-Life Decision Making

- Decisions about end-of-life care involve complex ethical dilemmas(tough
choices), such as determining the level of patient autonomy in life-sustaining
treatments.
- Healthcare professionals must navigate these dilemmas while honoring
patient autonomy and providing compassionate care.
Key principles of Autonomy
1- Informed Consent: The healthcare providers should explain all available

treatments, their course, duration, cost and outcome to the patient. Followed by
taking the patient's permission for starting with the particular chosen treatment.
2- Respect for Preferences: Healthcare providers should respect patients'

preferences and choices. Religious beliefs, family issues and economic reasons should
be understood.
3- Shared Decision-Making: There should be a collaborative approach between

patients and healthcare providers to make decisions about treatment.
Benefits of Autonomy
1. Improved Patient Satisfaction: Patient will be

satisfied on the treatment.
2. Patient Choice: A patient decides whether to
undergo surgery or try alternative treatments for their
condition.
3. Happiness: A patient feels happier and more

satisfied with their healthcare experience because
they were involved in decisions about their treatment
plan.
Challenges to Autonomy
1. Compulsion
● If a patient is being unduly influenced into making a decision, it cannot be considered truly autonomous.
● Eg: patient feels pressured by family members or societal expectations.
In such cases, healthcare professionals should exercise caution and take steps to ensure that the decision is genuinely the patient’s own.
2. Lack of decision-making capacity
● When patients lack the capacity to make decisions due to cognitive impairment, mental illness, or other factors, decisions must be
made on their behalf.
● In these situations, healthcare professionals have a responsibility to act in the best interests of the patient.
3. Cultural and Socioeconomic Factors
● Cultural beliefs and socioeconomic status can influence patients' ability to exercise autonomy.(Cultural beliefs can influence how
patients make decisions about their healthcare.
● For instance, in some cultures, there is a strong emphasis on family involvement in medical decisions. So, a patient might rely heavily on
the input of their family members when making choices about their treatment plan.)
4. Communication Barriers:
1. Language barriers: Different languages or limited proficiency can make it hard for patients to understand, affecting their
decisions.
2. Health literacy: Difficulty with medical terms or complex info can hinder patients' understanding of their condition and
treatment options.
3. Time constraints: Busy healthcare settings limit discussion time, leading to rushed decisions or incomplete understanding.
4. Cultural differences: Varied beliefs and communication styles can impact how patients and providers understand each other.
5. Solutions: Improving communication skills, promoting health literacy, offering language interpretation, and prioritizing
patient-centered care can help address these challenges.
5. Age
● In some cases, legal regulations and guardianship frameworks come into play to protect the
well-being of patients who are unable to make decisions for themselves.
● For example, very young children rely on parents or caregivers to make decisions on their
behalf.
6. Relation to other ethics
● Balancing autonomy with beneficence and nonmaleficence is important especially in cases

of mental incapacity or emergencies.
● Example: Making decisions for patients who lack decision-making capacity while honoring
their prior wishes or best interests.
Additional information
. 1. Article 21 of IPC: Right to Life and Personal Liberty
● Article 21 of the Indian Constitution guarantees the right to life and personal liberty(freedom)
● This includes the right to make decisions about one's own body and healthcare.
2. Paternalism and Beneficence
● Sometimes, healthcare professionals may believe a treatment is best for the patient, even if
the patient disagrees
● Balancing patient autonomy and beneficence (acting in the patient's best interest) is ethically
challenging and requires considering potential benefits and harms.
3. Autonomy in healthcare ensures active patient participation, leading to improved outcomes and
greater satisfaction.
Paternalism
The concept of paternalism is that the person with authority in a relationship can make
decisions for the people who are subordinate to them and that the person makes decisions in
the people's best interest.(In simpler terms someone in charge can make decisions for
others, believing it's for their own good)
This concept is based on the idea that not all people are capable of making rational
decisions.
Examples:
1. The relationship between a parent and a child.
2. Psychiatric holds: medical professionals decide to hold individuals who can cause
danger to themselves or others, even if the individual disagrees.
Paternalism vs Autonomy
Paternalism: Autonomy:
1) Doctors decide what's best for 1) Patients have the Right to make
patients, assuming their expertise healthcare decisions based on their
makes them the authority. interests and rights.
2) The "doctor knows best" rule is 2) Patient autonomy focus on avoiding
based on the concept of beneficence harm caused by overly controlling
(act in ways that benefit others and caregivers.
contribute positively to their lives). 3) Autonomy focus on deciding if
3) Doctors justify their authority by someone is capable and respecting the
claiming superior medical knowledge choices of those who are capable.
4) In paternalism doctor evaluates 4) Autonomy highlights that doctors must
decisions to make sure they're good respect patients' rights.
for patients.

Autonomy

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

Autonomy

Uploaded by

Document Information

Copyright

Available Formats

Share this document

Share or Embed Document

Sharing Options

Did you find this document useful?

Is this content inappropriate?

Copyright:

Available Formats

Autonomy

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

Autonomy

Autonomy is a fundamental principle in medical ethics that recognizes the

Promotes informed decision-making and empowers the patient.

5. Helps in End-of-Life Decision Making

1- Informed Consent: The healthcare providers should explain all available

2- Respect for Preferences: Healthcare providers should respect patients'

3- Shared Decision-Making: There should be a collaborative approach between

1. Improved Patient Satisfaction: Patient will be

3. Happiness: A patient feels happier and more

2. Lack of decision-making capacity

3. Cultural and Socioeconomic Factors

6. Relation to other ethics

● Balancing autonomy with beneficence and nonmaleficence is important especially in cases

You might also like