革律翁的摄影日记:《红的自传》的空间诗学 刘倩倩
革律翁的摄影日记:《红的自传》的空间诗学 刘倩倩
革律翁的摄影日记:《红的自传》的空间诗学 刘倩倩
硕士学位论文
革律翁的摄影日记:《红的自传》的空间诗学
学 院 : 外 国 语 学 院
专 业 : 英 语 语 言 文 学
研 究 方 向 : 英 美 文 学
研究生姓名: 刘 倩 倩
指 导 教 师 : 陈 庆 勋 教 授
完 成 日 期 : 2023 年 3 月
The Photographic Diary of Geryon:The Space Poetics in
Autobiography of Red
Liu Qianqian
A Thesis Submitted to
March 2023
Shanghai Normal University Master of Arts Abstract
Abstract
Anne Carson is widely acclaimed as one of the most classically trained poets in
the world of literature today. As a contemporary exponent of the classical spirit, she
excels in reinterpreting the classics in a contemporary and innovative form.
Autobiography of Red is a novel in verse and one of the most important masterpieces
of Anne Carson. In a fragmented but coherent narrative, Anne Carson reconstructs the
story of Hercules, the Greek god, who hunts the monster Geryon. Focused on the
novel in verse, this paper is to interpret its spatial nature through the theory of space
poetics. The main framework of the thesis consists of three parts, including the spatial
turn in poetry of Anne Carson, the construction of the space of visual imagination and
the construction of image space in Autobiography of Red.
The first part is the analysis of the spatial turn in poetry of Anne Carson,
primarily analyzed from two fronts, including the reason of her spatial turn and the
specific performance in her poetry. Firstly, the spatial turn in poetry of Anne Carson is
the consequence of her struggle with the reality. Anne Carson is immersed in the
classics on account of the lack of passion of modern people, whereas she is doomed to
confront the psychological infertility of modern people. Hence, Carson becomes a
contemporary interpreter of the classics, and her poetic creation has the characteristics
both of the classical civilization and modern experience. Carson is excellent in
reinterpreting the classics in a innovative way, through which the spatial art of poetry
is capable of manifesting itself. This paper finds that Carson’s innovation of poetry,
namely the spatial turn of poetry, stems from her innovation of the poetic form, that is,
the photographic narrative. The innovation of Anne Carson manifests itself within her
reflection on poetic language. From the perspective of Anne Carson, sometimes
language can be bewildering and it is incapable of presenting the facts. According to
this consideration, Carson portrayed Geryon as a photographer and the character
narrates his life in a photographic way.
III
Shanghai Normal University Master of Arts Abstract
The second part of this paper is the interpretation of the space of visual
imagination. The construction of this space is based on the photographic world and
Geryon’s contemplation of the world as a rover. This paper argues that within the
photographic world of Geryon, he observes the reality through the lens and the
photography taken by him is not only the grasp of some moments, but also the
incarnation of his self-consciousness. At the moment Geryon clicks the shutter, he is
surrounded by the present emotion, and the scene containing the past memories and
emotion besieges him as well. At that moment, time in different space converges and
the constant overlapping of images forms the spatialization of time. Moreover, the
spatialization of time is reflected in some certain moment as well. Carson prefers to
concentrate on some moment of enlightenment. Geryon always has the impulse to fall
into sleep and dreams so as to escape from the reality, thus, he is usually in the rift
between dreams and the reality. The boundary between dreams and the reality is
active as it has leaks and the leak is actually what Carson shows preference to. This
kind of moment, recorded by Geryon’ s photograph, occurs when Geryon is awake
from his dreams. The adult Geryon is always characterized as a rover. Geryon enables
his self-consciousness wandering the photographic world and the process is
accompanied with the flow of time. The past memories and the contemporary
experience is combined with each other at present. The original order of time is
broken and rearranged, thus the displacement of space and the erratic identity appears.
The third part of the paper is to interpret the construction of image space in
Autobiography of Red. According to the illustration, the paper finds that the
application of the image in Autobiography of Red is also spatial. First of all, the image
is metaphorical and this kind of characteristic enable the existence of image space.
Additionally, the spatiality of image primarily manifests itself in three fronts,
including the organization of image space, the malleability of image space, and the
constructivity of image space. And in Autobiography of Red, these features are rooted
in the self-consciousness and visual imagination of Geryon connoted in the
photograph and the spatialization of time. The consciousness of Geryon permeates
each other, thus, time and space is in constant changes. The extension of Geryon’s
IV
Shanghai Normal University Master of Arts Abstract
Key words: Spatial turn; photographic narrative; visual imagination; image space
V
上海师范大学硕士学位论文 摘要
摘要
安妮·卡森作为当今世界文坛古典学养最为深厚的诗人而广受赞誉,她是古
典精神的当代阐释者,擅长用当代的方式、创新的形式来重新阐释古典。《红的
自传》是一部诗体小说,也是安妮·卡森最重要的代表作之一。作品取材于希腊
神话,讲述了主人公如何坦然面对自己异于常人的身份。安妮•卡森在碎片化但
又连贯的叙事中重构了希腊神话中大力神赫拉克勒斯猎杀怪物革律翁的故事。本
文聚焦于这部诗体小说,从空间的角度切入,运用空间诗学相关理论对该诗歌进
行深入的挖掘、探讨。本文的主要框架包含三部分,即安妮·卡森诗歌中的空间
转向,以及诗人在《红的自传》中对于视觉想象空间及意象空间的建构。
第一部分着重分析安妮·卡森诗歌中的空间转向,主要包括诗人这一空间转
向背后的缘由及其空间转向的具体表现。安妮·卡森诗歌的空间转向是其困顿于
现实、逃避现实又调和于现实的结果。现代人的激情匮乏让卡森回归古典,但古
典文明的狂欢过后她所要面对的还是现实世界的贫瘠。因此,安妮·卡森的诗歌
兼具古典资源和当代感受,她是古典精神的当代阐释者。安妮·卡森擅长用当代
的方式、创新的形式来重新阐释古典,与此同时,诗歌的空间艺术也通过这种创
意形式得以展现。本文认为安妮·卡森的诗歌创新,即其空间转向的具体表现在
诗歌形态的革新,即摄影叙事。安妮·卡森的创新包含了她对诗歌语言的思考。
她认为,语言具有欺骗性,它不能描绘全部的事实。基于这样的考虑,安妮·卡
森笔下的革律翁成为了一名摄影师,并用摄影的方式叙述他的生活。
第二部分是对视觉想象空间建构的阐释,这一建构基于革律翁的影像世界及
其作为漫游者对于世界的凝视。本文认为,在革律翁的摄影世界中,他通过镜头
看世界,而他所留下的照片不仅是他对某个瞬间的捕捉,实则也暗含了自我意识
的涌动。在他按下快门的那一瞬间,当下的情绪感受包围着他,而裹挟着过往回
忆的某种情绪、某个画面也都呈现在他眼前,时间在那一刻实现了联结,画面的
不断重叠也使时间发生了空间化。此外,时间的空间化也体现在某个瞬间。本文
分析得出安妮·卡森热衷于刻画缝隙、撕裂这样的发现性时刻,她笔下的革律翁
VI
上海师范大学硕士学位论文 摘要
出于对现实刺激的逃避,总是处于梦与醒的模糊界限之中。梦与醒的边界是活动
的,有裂缝,而正是卡森所偏爱的,从梦中醒来的那一刻对于革律翁来说就是某
种发现性的时刻,这一时刻同时也被革律翁的摄影所记录。成年后的革律翁总是
以漫游者的形象被刻画,同时他也任由其自我意识漫游于他的摄影世界之中,而
这一过程也伴随着时间的流动,过往的记忆与当下的感受融于此刻,在视觉想象
的空间中,时间被打乱重组,空间继而发生了位移,不稳定的自我书写也由此而
生。本文在第三部分分析了《红的自传》中意象空间的建构。本文认为安妮·卡
森在这首诗体小说中对于意象的运用也呈现出了一定的空间性。首先,意象的隐
喻性质本身就使意象具有一定的空间性,其次,这种意象空间还体现在三个方面,
即组织性、延展性、构筑性。在《红的自传》中,革律翁的摄影世界以及内含于
其中的自我意识和视觉想象构成了这三种意象空间的特质。在诗中,人物的意识
可以保持其独立性,同时也可以互相渗透,从而实现时间和空间的联动。革律翁
自我意识的延申及其视觉想象赋予了意象更多的空间场景,也实现了该意象在不
同空间的任意移动。
安妮·卡森的这部诗体小说,以摄影代替语言完成了一部红的自传,使这首
叙事诗充满了电影般的情节,赋予读者以快门式的阅读体验。诗歌中的影像世界
即革律翁的内心世界,其主体意识具备某种类似于放映机的功效,在革律翁的意
识驱动和视觉想象下,原本静止的空间画面不断呈现在高速运转的意识屏幕上,
并以时而有序时而无序的方式向前推进,最终实现了时间的空间化。
关键词:空间转向;摄影叙事;视觉想象;意象空间
VII
Contents
Ⅰ Introduction .............................................................................................. 1
1.1 A Brief Introduction to Anne Carson and Autobiography of Red ..... 1
1.2 Literature Review on Anne Carson and Autobiography of Red ........ 3
1.3 Literature Review on Space Poetics .................................................. 8
Ⅱ The Spatial Turn in Carson's Poetry ...................................................... 11
2.1 The Contemporary Interpreter of the Classical Spirit...................... 11
2.2 The Innovation of Poetic Form ........................................................ 15
Ⅲ The Space of Visual Imagination ......................................................... 21
3.1 The Photographic World of Geryon ................................................. 21
3.1.1 The Surge of Self-consciousness Beneath the Photograph ........ 22
3.1.2 The Autobiography of a Sleeper ................................................ 25
3.2 The Contemplation of a Rover ......................................................... 31
3.2.1 The Displacement of Space........................................................ 31
3.2.2 The Erratic Identity .................................................................... 36
Ⅳ The Construction of Image Space ....................................................... 41
4.1 The Metaphorical Nature of Imagery .............................................. 41
4.2 The Organization of Image Space.................................................... 45
4.3 The Malleability of Image Space ..................................................... 46
4.4 The Constructivity of Image Space.................................................. 48
Ⅴ Conclusion ............................................................................................ 51
Bibliography ............................................................................................. 54
Shanghai Normal University Master of Arts Chapter Ⅰ
Ⅰ Introduction
Anne Carson, born in Canada, is one of the foremost poets in the English
language and a translator of the Ancient Greek classics. Anne Carson is widely
acclaimed as one of the most classically trained poets in the world of literature today.
As a professor of classics, an accomplished poet and a contemporary exponent of the
classical spirit, Carson is highly regarded for her breadth of talent, unique originality
and perceptiveness, and has been admired by leading critics and writers in Europe and
America, including Harold Bloom and Susan Sontag. With classical and philosophical
genes in her blood, Anne Carson has an unconventional and transcendent poetic
vision, and she excels in reinterpreting the classics in a contemporary and innovative
form. She draws reason, ingenuity and emotion from the greats and puts them into her
own unique voice and rhythm. According to Anne Carson, suppose prose is a house,
poetry is the person who gallops through the house on fire. Carson is an author who
breaks traditional thinking mode. She has the tendency to refer allusions, and integrate
poetry, diaries, historical documents and fiction in the form of poetry which works
like collapse, thus creating experimental, artistic and highly mysterious works with
subtle emotion, careful observation and minimalist brushstrokes. In her works,
hardness and softness, classical and cutting-edge form, metaphor and allusion,
minimalist style and textual collage are interwoven, all of which are perfectly
reconciled by Carson in harmony, thus generating both a simple and composed
literary style with concise words and delicate descriptions. The famous scholar Harold
Bloom once appraised that the poetry of Carson is full of originality and ingenuity.
Her works are filled with classical characteristics and contemporary emotions.
decorates life with unusual images. In addition, due to the profound foundation in
classical literature of Carson, she is adept in citing allusions to poetry and combines
the textual collage with various creative forms, including poem, diary, history,
documentary, fiction and so forth. Based on the compounded approach, Carson
creates experimental, artistic, and mysterious works with exquisite feeling, meticulous
observation and plain writing. Moreover, it is also a conspicuous form that Carson
applies in her poetry, namely the photographic novel in verse. As a prominent medium
utilized in her works, photography enables the narrative poetry to be filled with plots
which appears in a movie and endows readers with episodic-like reading experience.
The combination of poetry and the medium of photography, being pleasantly different
from the common literary creation, is not only a refreshing experience for the research
of poetry, but also renders inspiration and enlightenment to poets.
2
Shanghai Normal University Master of Arts Chapter Ⅰ
Generally speaking, the scope of research in China is not yet focused on the poet
Anne Carson and her work, and the scale of research has not yet been established. In
contrast, overseas research on Anne Carson and her work is more abundant and more
mature, and is generally on the rise. Between 1994 and 2011, the number of articles
published was on a slow upward trend, increasing from 2011 onwards, peaking at 165
journal publications in 2015. From 2015 to 2020, there is a downward trend in
research, but since 2020, the trend in academic journals has been on the rise again.
The review has attempted to classify these results according to different research
perspectives and the number of articles, based on the literature review on Anne
Carson and Autobiography of Red from abroad over the last three decades.
3
Shanghai Normal University Master of Arts Chapter Ⅰ
With regard to Autobiography of Red, the text is a hybrid work of poetry and
pose with curious organization. Carson modifies serial strategies to create narratives
out of seemingly discrete units and these units are primarily connected through
patterns of iteration of diction, symbolism, and myth (Weaver 2008: 185). Hoffert
(1999: 95) proposes that Anne Carson’s Autobiography of Red should be included in
4
Shanghai Normal University Master of Arts Chapter Ⅰ
the list of best poetry of 1998. The work is a peculiar bridge between classical texts
and contemporary autobiographical poetry. In this work, Carson seamlessly blends
Greek myth, homosexuality, and Canadian life, into a new, unique Geryoneis
(Finglass and Kelly 2015: 179). Unlike the original Greek myth, Carson’s story writes
against history’s familiar mighty figures. This sort of resistance implied in her
narrative poetry has been a necessary psychic strategy (Georgis 2006). Autobiography
of Red is an exquisite poem of a sleeper since the protagonist Geryon in the narrative
poetry experiences the self-growth within the dream-like self-narration and Geryon
has the impulse to fall in sleep as the reaction to the realistic stimulation. In 2021, the
two significant representatives of the works of Anne Carson--Autobiography of Red
and The Beauty of the Husband--was included in the second collection of Orpheus’
translated poems and officially published by Yilin Press. This is the first time that the
work of Anne Carson has been introduced to the Chinese world.
Domestic and foreign scholars have studied Autobiography of Red from the
following four perspectives: language, writing techniques, the medium of
photography in the poetry, and self-writing of the protagonist. As regards the
application of language in Autobiography of Red, the sensory and perspective shifts
contained within poetic and vivid language draws the reader into an alternate sensory
world (Ryskamp 2014: 26). For Carson, language is a kind of mechanism of
concealment. According to O’Rourke-Suchoff (2018: 83), Carson is deemed to have a
good command of metaphor in her poetic language as a wordsmith. It can be
perceived that Carson contrives to awaken contemporary people indulged in
depression through personal passion concealed within her poetic language. The
individual lines in her poetry have Carson’s recognizable poetic force
(Signorelli-Pappas 2020: 82).
5
Shanghai Normal University Master of Arts Chapter Ⅰ
form since the work is a novel in verse with the rather odd generic tag,
“autobiography.” Autobiography of Red can be read as a Picaresque novel, in which
the hero goes through a succession of trials before he reaches maturity in the end, a
fairy tale full of dreams and monsters, or a philosophical essay raising metaphysical
questions. Carson seems to propose different layers leading to various levels of
reading and comprehension (Sébastien 2007). From another perspective, the work is
classified into fictional autobiography combined with the form of a coming-of-age
novel (Xu 2020: 63). Additionally, Xu (2020: 63) proposes that the writing of Anne
Carson is a sort of epic negation, being different from C. D. Blanton. According to her,
the thing that Carson negates is not history, but the historical writing relative to the
actuality and reality (Xu 2020: 63). Moreover, another prominent characteristic of
Autobiography of Red is the application of literary allusion. Particularly, the
utilization of the myth in poetry by Carson is a kind of method for her to manifest the
mixture of actuality and poetic feature in daily life. Carson incorporates characters
with mythic qualities into the contemporary world, propelling readers through a world
of literary allusion and sensory involvement within the internal poetic narrative (Van
Buren 1998: 88).
consideration of the form of photographic essay of the work. According to him, the
peculiarity of Carson’s photography unfixes vision as the privileged and singular
medium of the photograph, suggesting that people rethink photography as a
synaesthesia of touch and sight, or sound and sight, much as written language is.
Furthermore, Carson conveys her musing on time and photography during the process
of providing an answer to Geryon’s perennial question regarding the nature of time
through the medium of photography (Tschofen 2004: 44).
identity of Geryon, like his space is erratic, malleable and performative so that finding
the authentic Geryon is impossible (Battis 2003: 198). For Carson, she prefers to
conceal the truth beneath strata of ivory because this is the look of truth.
product, and the diversity of spatial theories provides an open field for literary
criticism (Gao 2017: 165). According to Mitchell (1980: 539), the concept of spatial
form has questionably been central to modern criticism not only of the fine arts but of
language and of culture and literature in general. Particularly, both in the West and in
the East, poetry is always the outpost of literary territory, the most sensitive to the
impact of new information and ideas, and the most capable of responding in a flexible
manner.
According to Holtz (1977: 272), the spatial form of poetry is not necessarily
descriptive writing aimed at the mind’s eye but rather a form that grows out of the
writer’s attempt to negate the temporal principle inherent in language and to force
apprehension of his work as a total thing in a moment of time rather than as a
sequence of things. In a poetry with spatial turn, the poetic language, at any one
moment of time, offers the knowledge and civilization of the past and present as a
whole, and a unified spatial apprehension of the work is ultimately possible. T. S.
Eliot’s The Waste Land provides similar illustrations. Modernist authors abandons
realism in favour of the fragmented, open, and shifting forms as a means to represent
the fragmented, traumatized subjects of capitalist culture (Tao 2008: 57). In
accordance with Frank’s basic argument, modernist literary works, particularly by
Eliot, Pound and Joyce, are spatial as they replace history and narrative sequence with
a sense of mythic simultaneity and disrupt the normal continuities of English prose
with disjunctive syntactic arrangements (Mitchell 1980: 541). Guo (2008: 67)
elucidates that modernist poetry, represented by the The Waste Land partially pursues
fragmentation but retains some unifying characteristics as a whole with the
combination of the classics and the creative application of poetic language.
Furthermore, the concept of space also has a great influence on the poetic creation of
Emily Dickinson. The poet, as a ideologist, spends her whole life considering the
significance of space, which is not merely embodied in numerous images of space
utilized in her poems, but also is reflected her creation of the spatialized form of
poetry (Wang 2016: 103). Actually, Carson, as a classical enthusiast, is influenced by
9
Shanghai Normal University Master of Arts Chapter Ⅰ
the space poetics to some extent. In Autobiography of Red, Carson reinterprets the
Greek myth with the photographic narrative. Living experience can be viewed as the
unfolding of poetic space. This is neither just matter nor experience, but the collective
exploration of felt embodied meanings by individuals, which co-create as
transformations of a fecund whole (Weber 2021: 192). The stream of consciousness of
Geryon beneath his photographic world is erratic, dynamic, and unpredictable, thus
leading to the displacement of space. This is how the spatialization of poetry in
Autobiography of Red operates.
10
Shanghai Normal University Master of Arts Chapter Ⅱ
subjective and sober consciousness sometimes become the sacrifice within the fight
against the times. However, more classical works get the chance to be exposed to the
public, thus awaken those callous people or provides the orientation for people who
have already realized some sort of crisis of the civilization but are incapable of
exploring a way out of the predicament. In comparison with other language, the poetic
one has more influence. A common poem of Shakespeare plays a more significant role
in enlightening the poor and the evildoer in contrast to the education from the
churchman or the philanthropist (Woolf 2020: 170). Although some literary works fail
to make some practical innovation, at least they expose the current situation and
dilemma which has aroused concern from some people. Insomuch, it can be
considered that literature, especially poetry, is definitely not only the individual
creation of the author but also a kind of creation with social foundation.
For instance, in the poetry of T. S. Eliot, language acts not only as a medium of
experience but also as the experience itself, and therefore the innovation of the poetic
language becomes an approach to saving the modern culture (Chen 2008: 79). After
the realization of the crisis of the poetic language, Eliot along with numerous
contemporary authors attempts to create fresh forms of poetic works, especially the
transformation of language. Eliot dates back to the metaphysical poets, to Dante, to
ancient myths for the purposes of searching the traditions and order that no longer
exist in a fractured modern society (Chen 2008: 79). The waste land of the society is
inundated with varieties of degraded and depraved civilization. Under such
circumstances, the literary creation is not merely the pure representation of the reality,
but necessitates the thorough transition to save the decayed civilization. The
resurgence of the classics is incapable of assisting the poets with the salvation of the
fragmented society, so it is found that saving the poetic language becomes the primary
mission of the poets to resuscitate this waste land.
12
Shanghai Normal University Master of Arts Chapter Ⅱ
thinking mode of Carson. Therefore, being similar to Eliot, Carson traces back to the
classics to pursue the passion which is absent in the modern society as well. As a
matter of fact, the decision of Carson to embrace the classical culture is not the
thought by accident. Carson starts classics in high school with the beginning of the
study of Greek. In her own words, she has the opportunity to search her own roots
within the study of classics since she regards Greek is the best language in the world,
even better than Latin which Carson has been studied at the same time. Carson
assumes that Latin is sort of a mathematics of thought whereas Greek is an art
(D’Agata 2014: 4). Anne Carson herself is person with multiple identities, including
an essayist, translator, a classicist, a professor and a Canadian poet. Carson’s
immersion in the classics directly makes impact on her poetic creation. Autobiography
of Red is a representative work which contains the classic civilization. The novel in
verse is a coming-of-age story about Geryon. Geryon is the name of a character in
ancient Greek myth. He is a strange red winged monster who lived on an island called
Erytheia quietly tending a herd of magical red cattle, until one day the hero Herakles
came across the sea and killed him to get the cattle (Carson 1998: 5). Nevertheless,
the ancient Greek poet Stesichorus transforms the traditional story into a story of a
tragic hero from the perspective of Geryon in the narrative poem Geryoneis.
Moreover, Autobiography of Red of Anne Carson is a kind of parody of the version of
Stesichorus. Being compared to Eliot, the difference is that the throwback to the
classics of Eliot is implicit in his poetic creation while Carson’s retrospection about
those classic works is obvious and manifest within her poetry.
Nevertheless, like Eliot, Carson also discovers the pure immersion in the classics
is unable to resolve the current situation. Therefore, the characteristics of the poetry of
Carson is both classic and contemporary. For Eliot, the resurrection of the gods cannot
make the realistic world recover from the collapsed modern world. The ancient
structure and civilization can only lurk in the depth as a metaphorical counterpart, and
the fragmentation of reality that the poet is doomed to confront remains (Chen 2008:
79). Therefore, Eliot is dedicated to making innovation in modern poetic language to
14
Shanghai Normal University Master of Arts Chapter Ⅱ
revive the modern waste land of civilization. With respects to Anne Carson, she
derives psychological strength and inspiration from the classics, then return to the
modern world. The feature both of the classics and philosophy occurs in her literary
creation and her ability of the reinterpretation of the classics is excellent with a
contemporary and innovative method. Carson makes an acquisition of reason,
wittiness, and emotion from the ancient giants so as to construct her own poetic world
with peculiarity.
15
Shanghai Normal University Master of Arts Chapter Ⅱ
also has her own contemplation of the poetic language with the acute insight and
unique thinking mode. The spatiality of poetry in Autobiography of Red is precisely a
typical presentation of the reflection on poetic language of Carson. In other words,
Carson’ s reexamination of the poetic language is the fundamental cause of the spatial
characteristics in Autobiography of Red. Additionally, the consequence of this kind of
reexamination is the creative poetic form in Autobiography of Red. Carson has the
tendency to make the poetic creation with the collage of text, and in this novel in
verse, the form is accomplished by the photographic narrative.
Life is not about some meaningful detail, illuminated by a flash of light and
frozen forever, whereas photographs are. Photography is an elegiac art, a twilight art,
which records the stagnant, fading time and the death of time. To take a photograph is
to participate in the certain death, the fragility, the mutability of another person or
object. All photographs are a record of a moment of death. Photography bears witness
to the relentless passage of time, and it preserves moments and realities that are
decayed or ceased to exist as well. The camera captures reality, rather than merely
interpreting it. Like the painting, the photograph is an interpretation of the world, and
Carson’s Geryon uses the camera to record reality, in a sense, to capture it.
Photographs may be more memorable than vivid visual records because they are a
neat cut of time rather than a flow. A photographic record may give a more realistic
sense of what has happened in the past. But at the same time, when viewing a moving
image, one may miss an important moment. Each still photograph is an important
moment, and the moment that has passed becomes a tangible object that survives and
can be viewed again and again. The camera is particularly good at documenting the
trauma of time. Through photographs, humans are able to trace the chronicle of how
people age in the most visual way. As a medium of preserving the past, photographs
convey a message of the past, allowing humans to gaze at old photographs of
themselves, or of anyone they know, or of a public figure they once loved, with their
irrefutable infectiousness. Photography is an inventory of a life that has been swiftly
lived as a stage, a moment, a landscape seen, a group of people met is able to be
16
Shanghai Normal University Master of Arts Chapter Ⅱ
brought together through photographs, then the flow of time is permanently sealed,
thus becoming a time that can be extracted at will in five-dimensional space. The
output of photography is at the same time a melancholy object. The fascination
created by the photograph is reminiscent of death and can also be sentimental. The
photograph turns the past into a still object that is tenderly watched, the death of time
is only the surface, what is sorrowful and discomforting is the memory beneath time
that is about to be forgotten or has been banished from the mind. The infectious power
of the visual image instantly turns the past into the present, and the silent past gives
voice to itself through the photograph.
Photography is not only about preserving the past, but also about uncovering and
preserving an overlooked reality with a new vision. Apart from some specific
functions and occasions of photography, what touches people to take photographs is
the discovery of beauty, which people often regret for not having recorded in time.
Photographic viewing implies a tendency to find beauty in stuff that is too
commonplace to be seen by everyone, and the documentarian makes a new visual
choice to preserve reality. By cropping reality more narrowly and enlarging a corner
of it, the photographer has taken on a more ambitious form.
17
Shanghai Normal University Master of Arts Chapter Ⅱ
accepted by the mainstream. Carson gives Geryon a new lease of life, but puts him
through pain in a different way. Geryon documents his life through photography, his
experiences captured in a shuttered narrative in every frame. Susan Sontag (1977: 163)
elaborates that reality is understood as unmanageable and inaccessible, and the
photograph is a way of imprisoning reality, of keeping it in stasis. The collection of
photographs can be used as an alternative world, one that exists specifically for those
effects that are exciting or soothing or compelling. Geryon’s photo diary is more
about trauma and scars than it is about exciting moments. He has no way of capturing
the time that has passed, no control over his life and can only give vent to all his
emotions in his photographs:
Geryon kept the camera in his hands and spoke little. I am disappearing, he
thought
but the photographs were worth it.
A volcano is not a mountain like others. Raising a camera to one’s face has
effects no one can calculate in advance. (Carson 1998: 135)
The flowing time is perishable while the time conserved within the picture
though photography is under control. Geryon believed that people are neighbors of
fire and it is certainly true. Fire is a kind of ephemeral existence yet it has fiery and
fervent life. Likewise, a few decades of human life, no matte being impassioned or
insipid, cannot escape the destiny of death. Nonetheless, oblivion, rather than death, is
the authentic destination. Hence, the record of the reality through photography
impresses people with the death of time and a certain memory. Although the transitory
oblivion happens, the picture is able to present the recurrence of the past. Geryon’s
Greek mythology and red wings are a symbol of his heterosexuality, a situation made
all the more difficult by the fact that Carson’s poetry is full of depictions of his
homosexuality. Geryon is outside the order, unable to manage reality, he chooses to
imprison all his trauma in his photographs; each moment Geryon captures is a
standstill in time, time imprisoned in the photograph, and with it the trauma encased
18
Shanghai Normal University Master of Arts Chapter Ⅱ
Only within the darkness, Geryon has the courage to expose the real self. He prisons
time in his photographs and prisons himself as well.
too many words are used which are not the facts as the language is unconvinced with
instability and perplexity. In Autobiography of Red, the unreliability of language is
able to be proved:
Geryon watched his mother pick a fragment of tobacco off her tongue before she
said,
Does he ever write anything with a happy ending?
Geryon paused.
Then he reached up and carefully disengaged the composition paper
from the teacher’s hand.
Proceeding to the back of the classroom he sat at his usual desk and took out a
pencil.
New Ending.
All over the world the beautiful red breezed went on bloeing hand
in hand. (Carson 1998:38)
In order to satisfy his mother, Geryon makes modification of the ending of his
writing. Thus, the uncertainty of language renders the narrative of Carson innovative
and creative. In adolescence, the conflict between language and photography begins
to manifest itself in Geryon. During this period, Geryon gets acquaintance with
Herakles. The intimate relationship between him and Herakles is not understood and
accepted by Geryon’s mother. In addition, Geryon is no longer dependent on his
mother as well as his childhood and he has less conversation with his mother, even he
began to lies to her. Conversely, photography gradually becomes his autobiographical
language, which is a more authentic and credible one.
20
Shanghai Normal University Master of Arts Chapter Ⅲ
In accordance with Lu (2022: 133), the imagination of poetry is the poet’s ability
to transform both the experience and memories so as to create the new and unique
image. Both the intensification of personal imagination and the utilization of
empirical elements expand the context and vision of poetic narrative (Lu 2022: 130).
Additionally, this sort of imagination is associated with the poet’s understanding and
expression of language, personal life, the soul, history, and culture. As a classical
enthusiast, Carson enables her protagonist Geryon, who is from the Greek myth, to
finish his autobiography in the photographic way. Geryon is immersed in the
photographic world and indulges himself in the flow of self-consciousness. Within the
space of his visual imagination, those traumatic experience and memories have the
tendency to torture him from time to time and the time and space is consequently
chaotic and turbulent, which actually has a great influence on the construction of the
space of visual imagination.
21
Shanghai Normal University Master of Arts Chapter Ⅲ
22
Shanghai Normal University Master of Arts Chapter Ⅲ
The series of description is the world through Geryon’s lens as well as the inner world
of Geryon as “photography is a way of playing with perceptual relationships” (Carson
1998: 65). Driven by Geryon’s consciousness, the originally static spatial images are
constantly presented on the high-speed screen of consciousness, and move forward
in a manner which is sometimes ordered and sometimes disordered, forming a
powerful spatial fluid, thus completing the construction of modern spatial poetics.
Since the childhood of Geryon, he has been suffering from the terrible and
horrible reality, such as the sexual assault from his elder brother, the separation from
his lover Herakles, the estrangement from his mother. In addition, Geryon himself has
been in the state of self-constraint and self-imprisonment as he has a pair of unusual
red wings. Therefore, the inner world of Geryon is always a mass of chaos with
disordered, restless and confused emotion:
23
Shanghai Normal University Master of Arts Chapter Ⅲ
The description that Geryon has no idea how to photograph Lima is actually the
symbolization of his chaotic brain. In a sense, a brain with miscellaneous emotion and
thoughts can be tantamount to a blank and empty brain. The psychological world of
Geryon is dynamic with continuing spatial motion, thus his photographic world which
connotes his self-consciousness is also in a chaos.
Photography preserves memories, and it is not only objects that carry memories;
like poetry, photography takes as its starting point the action of people. Photography
functions first and foremost as an extension of the middle-class wanderer’s eye
(Sontag 1977: 55). The wanderer is a connoisseur who knows the pleasure of looking,
an empathetic connoisseur who sees the world as “picturesque.” The wanderer
discovers and feels the world, similar to the photographer who observes and records it,
and whose process of capturing reality through the lens is the process of feeling the
world.
Resting the camera on the rear window of the car Geryon is watching the road
fall away behind them
into a light so brilliant it feels cold and hot at once. (Carson 1998: 137)
24
Shanghai Normal University Master of Arts Chapter Ⅲ
endows the light with coldness. Sometimes the world recorded by Geryon is
depressive and decadent is not only because his additional subjective consciousness
connoted in those scenes but also because Geryon has the tendency to concentrate on
those decayed creatures:
Geryon wanders nowhere but in the bleak garden of the hotel. A series of images
including “ruined roses”, “dry blades” and “clod air” is what Geryon observes and
captures through his camera. The depressive scenery is essentially the consciousness
and emotion of Geryon. Insomuch, it can be perceived that as Geryon contemplates
the world, he realize the self-contemplation and self-writing as well. In this regard, the
autobiography of Geryon can also be considered as the photographic diary of Geryon.
The loss of the sense of time has become an important feature of the view of time
during the post-modern times, but the loss of the sense of time does not mean the
nonexistence of time. The fact is that in the society of post-modern period, time
comes into existence in another form: that is, traditional, linear, one-dimensional time
is disintegrated, and the totality of time becomes a fragmented, non-directional
fragment of time after its collapse. These fragments of time are influenced in some
way and are organized and brought together into the “now”, which becomes the only
sign of temporal existence that embraces the past and the future. From this perspective,
time is incorporated into a space centred on the “now”, or rather, both past and future
time are incorporated into the space of the present. Accordingly, time is spatialised. In
other words, the spatialisation of time is another mode of existence of time, in which
25
Shanghai Normal University Master of Arts Chapter Ⅲ
time is incorporated into the space of a certain moment, and the linear character of
time is destroyed, and the characteristics of space is highlighted. This is a significant
feature of the view of time within the post-modern times. And the precondition of the
occurrence of the spatialisation of time resulting from this change is rooted in three
major reasons. Firstly, due to the development of technology, time is compressed and
the elimination of the sense of spatial distance occurs. Secondly, the turnover of
capital in consumer society accelerates, thus giving rise to the dilution of the original
sense of temporality. In addition, time is dismembered on account of the necessity of
symbolic production and image-making, of which everything becomes an element.
This sense of spatio-temporality is well presented in many classical works, such as in
stream-of-consciousness works, especially Virginia Woolf’s To the Lighthouse and
Mrs. Dalloway. It can be observed that the spatialisation of time occurs on the basis of
the transformation of people’s conception of time and space, not only exists in the
space-time of post-modern times. Hence, it is only when the conditions are prepared
this concept of space-time becomes more intense, but it does not prevent it from
appearing in the age of clear and orderly chronology, especially in literary and artistic
works. Autobiography of Red also has a non-linear presentation of time, where time is
incorporated into the space of the present, where past, present and future are all
centralized in the same space. However, the spatialized form of time presented in
Carson’s poetry is not the result of the aforementioned altered sense of time and space,
and therefore this novel in verse cannot be taken as a simple testament to this notion
of time and space. The spatialization of time in Autobiography of Red is mainly
reflected in an instantaneous moment with enlightenment. Geryon shows preference
to this sort of moment as he is not interested in human comfort and for him, “much
truer is the time that strays into photographs and stops” (Carson 1998: 93).
Furthermore, this sort of moment has the tendency to occurs in the intersection of
sleeping and waking of Geryon. Additionally, Geryon always utilizes photography to
seize and conserve the moment as his autobiography resembles a photographic diary.
The rewriting of the story of Geryon is not only confined to the plot of the
26
Shanghai Normal University Master of Arts Chapter Ⅲ
original version, but also contains the transformation of the characteristics of Geryon.
In the version of Carson, Geryon, being not as intrepid as in the Greek myth, becomes
a sensitive and solitary boy. He suffers from the sexual assault from his elder brother
and gets no shelter from his mother. Moreover, he is plagued by Herakles who turns
out to be his lover and breaks Geryon’s fragile heart. As a consequence, from the
childhood of Geryon, he began to wallow in sleep as every period of sleep is a kind of
alleviation of misery and the release of imagination for him. The real world is so
grievous and distressing that Geryon is compelled to seek comfort and from the sleep:
Every ten meters or so along the seawall Geryon could see small twined couples.
They looked like dolls.
Geryon wished he could envy them but he did not. I have to get out of this place,
he thought. Immortal or not.
He climbed into his sleeping bag and slept until dawn without moving. (Carson
1998: 130)
Within the narration which is seemingly muddled, dream-like, Geryon experiences his
personal growth and gradually expands the the spiritual landscape of the self.
Although the journey may end in a volcano, an eruptive, heavy and dangerous passion.
But that desire is perhaps what is lacking in the modern world and it is also what
Carson endeavors to portrait and pursue. Through the power of words, Carson
attempts to recall the passions within people, and of course, the hidden desire for love
in the narrative, the individual passions that exist as a vision, as well as the
motivations of the characters and the images they leave behind in the fragments, all of
which, layer by layer, the reader is left to savor.
27
Shanghai Normal University Master of Arts Chapter Ⅲ
On the way to the volcano, Geryon drifts off to the sleep on occasion, and the
boundary between dreaming and waking is blurred. The ardent gaze is transformed
into a bloody dream, which intertwines and superimposes itself in Geryon’s vision,
and is imaged as a photograph. The acute perceptions of Geryon fractures into dreams,
and the border between dreaming and waking is far more mysterious than that
between psychological reality and everyday reality, thus Geryon is apt to be immersed
in such moment. After all, the realm of dream is an empty space that the text of fate
has not yet touched, and the most magnificent landscapes people have ever seen often
come from dreams. Additionally, the space between dream and waking is active as the
space is actually a sort of seam:
Geryon suddenly wakes after midnight and he is stuck in the panic and confised
emotion, which is exactly the inducement for Geryon to finish his photographic
autobiography. Geryon is incapable of directly confronting reality, then he experience
life in his photographic world. This is how Geryon reconcile himself to reality.
Actually, during the childhood of Geryon, he relishes sleep and dreams but the
28
Shanghai Normal University Master of Arts Chapter Ⅲ
Geryon is reluctant to be awake for the reason that sleep is the primary choice for him
to escape form painful reality. Moreover, when Herakles again declines his love,
Geryon’s heart and lungs form a black crust (Carson 1998: 62) and he was suddenly
trapped. He feels bruised but pure and he falls instantly asleep (Carson 1998: 75). The
immersion in sleep of Geryon is a sort of stress response to the sorrowful and
melancholy reality. Moreover, the photograph Geryon takes at the moment he wakes
up from the dream drags him into another fantasy world. In this world, Geryon gets
the acquisition of a certain enlightenment:
He woke up from a loud wild dream that vanished at once and lay listening
to the splendid subtle ravines of Hades
where hardworking dawn monkeys were wheedling and baiting one another
up and down the mahogany trees.
The cries took little nicks out of him. This was when Geryon liked to plan
his autobiography, in that blurred state
between awake and asleep when too many intake valves are open in the soul.
Like the terrestrial crust of the earth
which is proportionately ten times thinner than an eggshell, the skin of the soul
is a miracle of mutual pressures.
29
Shanghai Normal University Master of Arts Chapter Ⅲ
Therefore, Geryon’s immersion in sleep and dream is not merely the cowardice and
self-absorption of retreating into a fantasy world. This kind of moment is also what
Carson pursues. The action of sleep announces that the unreal world beyond the
reality is magical and enigmatic, in which human beings are possible to obtain the
strength to counteract reality. The classics is a sort of fantasy world for Carson, and
the Geryon she describes gets access to the world through his dreams and
photographic diary. The wonderland of the dream not only offers the shelter and the
courage to resist and reconcile oneself with the reality, but also transcends the laws of
language. The narration of Autobiography of Red actually contains Carson’s
retrospection and reflection of the ancient civilization and language. Carson wakes up
from the classical world and interprets the Greek story in a contemporary way, namely
the photographic narrative of Autobiography of Red. According to the theory of
photography, photography is surreal art and the tradition of surreal painting is close to
a kind of dreams, mostly wet dreams, square fearful nightmares. Likewise, in
Autobiography of Red, sleep, dreams, poetic imagination, and the healing of
photography all collapse into a single force, which helps a sensitive boy to struggle
reluctantly with dignity against the order of wakefulness and the discipline of
language. Consequently, Geryon repeatedly wakes up between dream and reality, love
and loss, pain and understanding, and will eventually sleep forever in the fate laid
down for him by Greek mythology. Nevertheless, Carson does not wallow in the
ancient mystery forever as she considers that. The world of fantasy, once falls into
conflict with the reality, is confronted with the collapse. Hence, the real happiness,
wittiness and profundity are impossible to be accommodated in the realm of fantasy
and the disillusion occurs. Therefore, Carson embraces the modern world in a creative
way and the civilization and wisdom from the ancient times comes into existence at
30
Shanghai Normal University Master of Arts Chapter Ⅲ
the moment she returns to the reality. Therefore, the spatialization of time is realized
since the ancient time is incorporated into the space of the present, where past, present
and even future are all centralized in the photographic narrative, which is a
contemporary way to interpret the classics.
The word “wanderer” comes from the French word “flaneur”, which means
“wanderer” or “idler.” The image of the “wanderer” first appeared in French literature
in nineteenth century. The French poet Charles Baudelaire describes the “wanderer”
as an artist and poet wandering the streets of a modern metropolis. Furthermore,
“wanderer” is defined as a person on the edge of the city, as does Geryon. In
Autobiography of Red, Geryon is portrayed as a homosexual and sensitive boy with
eccentric red wings, who once encounters the sexual assault from his elder brother.
This multiple identity definitely puts Geryon in an awkward position in the society, in
which varieties of regulations exist. With the passage of time, the image of the
“wanderer” is no longer confined to French literature. In Autobiography of Red,
Geryon is like a “wanderer”, wandering the streets of city or the countryside, in the
midst of glitz and glamour, combining the city’s contradictions, sensitivities and
desires in an uncanny way, but always remaining aloof. It is this “wanderer”s gaze--a
hidden, conciliatory, hallucinatory gaze--that allows Carson to construct an illusory,
ambiguous visual space in his poems, through wordplay or strange line breaks.
Photography is the fragmented record of the reality with the record of some
instantaneous moment, so this kind of art can be regarded as the static record of the
dynamic space of the reality. However, the photographic narrative of Geryon in
Autobiography of Red, although working like collage, is actually the dynamic
narration of Geryon’s life and inner world with the continuous change and
displacement of space.
31
Shanghai Normal University Master of Arts Chapter Ⅲ
The reality represented by the camera is always more concealed than exposed,
because the thin space created by the photograph seals only a slice of reality.
Photography captures reality, which is an imaginative fragment of reality rather than
the real and complete reality. The photograph is a way of explaining the world, but it
is not the photograph itself that explains the world, it is the inferences, speculations
and fantasies that the viewer makes after seeing the photograph that form the
photograph’s interpretation of the world. Photography implies that if people accept the
world in the light of the reality it records, they will understand the world. But the
opposite is true: understanding the world requires us to dig into its essence, and if
humans accept the photographic record of the apparent world as the real world, their
understanding of the world will not reach the truth of the world. Thus, the
understanding of the world produced by photography is limited. By decorating the
chaotic real world with a replica of the image world, photography makes the world
seem more comprehensible to us than it actually is. People’s impression of the real
world is stuck in a thin photograph, thus creating a solidified impression. Strictly
speaking, it is difficult for people to know the world only through a photograph.
Although a photograph is able to pull us back to a scene in the past and fills in the
gaps in the many images of the past in our minds, the lens is selective. The mute past
gives its voice through a photograph, but this voice is cropped, it carries with it the
subjective emotional attitude of the photographer. The photograph is an autonomous
choice of the picture of reality in the photographer’s field of vision, so the audience is
incapable of obtaining an objective understanding of the real world through a
subjective interception of the picture of reality. The photographer was once thought of
as a keen but non-interfering observer, a scribe rather than a poet. But as it become
clear that no matter how you photograph the same thing, you are impossible to take
the same picture. The assumption that the camera provides an objective, impersonal
influence gives way to the fact that the photograph is not just a proof of what exists,
but of what one see through one’s eyes, not just a record of the world, but an
appreciation of it. For the photographer, to take a photograph is to give importance,
and there is an inherent tendency in all photographs to assign what the photographer
32
Shanghai Normal University Master of Arts Chapter Ⅲ
perceives as value to the subject, and this tendency is difficult to suppress. Therefore,
the awareness people is able to gain is in fact a kind of incomplete awareness, which
appears to be wise, just as a photograph appears to reproduce reality and possesses it.
The photograph is a slice of the world, and the relationship between the world in the
photograph and the real world is as fundamentally inaccurate as the relationship
between a still photograph and a film. The seductive and deceptive nature of
photographs is that they offer the connoisseur a relationship to the world and a hybrid
acceptance of it at the same time. Photography’s gaze beyond fluid reality makes the
viewer feel comfortable, creating a false sense of omnipresence, a deceptive insight.
For some people, the attempts to make sense of the world is boring, so the viewer is
grateful and content to see the world the photographer has gleaned for us, indulging in
the virtual reality created by photography in the mistaken belief that they are
gradually getting a glimpse of the world. The camera is a liar, and photographs are
often praised for their honesty, but this suggests that most photographs are not honest,
so it is the few that do appear that deserve praise. Photography is not just a record of
reality, it is more concerned with how reality is presented to the viewer, and with this
aim in mind, the reality recorded by photography is no longer pure, it changes the
concept of reality, and it changes the concept of realism. Photographic viewing tends
to view reality as a mass of potential photographs, thus creating a detachment from
reality, a one-sided view that creates a gap between the objectivity of the camera and
the human eye in focusing on and judging reality.
This stagnant recording of reality in photography stems not only from its
fragmentary, one-sided still images, but is also limited by photography’s pursuit of
artistic beauty. Being similar with painting, photography is a figurative art, which also
possesses the ultimate quest for beauty. For the art of figuration, the artist has to
express the highest degree of beauty in a given situation of physical pain, but it is well
known that the intense distortion of form in a situation of physical pain is
incompatible with the highest degree of beauty. Likewise, photography also tends to
create things of beauty, no one finds ugliness through photographs, but many find
33
Shanghai Normal University Master of Arts Chapter Ⅲ
Real time is fluid, while virtual reality under photography is frozen and
one-sided. The actual operation of the real world take place in time and must therefore
be explained in time, and only what is narrated can make sense to us. The poem is a
kind of sound painting, moreover an ensemble of coherent images of reality. In
Autobiography of Red, the virtual reality created by the photographic narrative is
dynamic and can be glimpsed in its entirety. Unlike the static reality documented by
photography, Geryon’s photographic autobiography allows the reader to feel the flow
of time, and his photographic diary not only documents his growth, but also gives us a
glimpse into his full state of mind after all his experiences, something that
photography cannot achieve. Moralists who love photographs always hope that words
can save them. Carson gives his protagonist, Geryon, the opportunity to document
reality through photography, while at the same time relaying Geryon’s photographs in
poetic text, at a time when photography is no longer just a one-sided representation of
the real world, but has the power of a narrative. It takes on a fluid time in the narrative
of the text with the reorganization of time resulting from the displacement of space:
34
Shanghai Normal University Master of Arts Chapter Ⅲ
In this section, the two “room” actually exist in two space. The first “room” is
the room of the mother of Herakles, in which Geryon wants to find the telephone to
contact his own mother. And the second “room”, which is seemingly the same room,
is actually another room in other space according to the emotion of Geryon at that
moment. From the very beginning, Geryon’s mother has been criticizing Geryon for
the relationship between Geryon and Herakles, which is abnormal in the modern
society. Geryon is anguished as he is incapable of getting support from the woman on
whom he has been dependent since the childhood. As a consequence, when Geryon
has to contact her mother, he cannot resist the surge of sorrow and fury, and the
second room is precisely the room of Geryon’s mother. Hence, the image of “room” in
these lines achieves the juxtaposition within the space, which is a three-dimensional
structure of image. The “unappeasable debris of woman liquors,” symbolizing the
anger of his mother, is actually what Geryon once saw or imaged in his mother’s room.
Carson’s poetry does generate depth in the unpredictable visual space. On the one
hand, it is in close association with the Geryon’s sensory and emotional feelings as a
wanderer, and on the other hand, it systematically constructs a network of
interpenetration between body and matter. The visual space built up from the
perspective of the wanderer’s gaze thus shows the interpenetration and fusion of
vision and sensation, as Geryon’s senses and feelings are evoked by the material
world, and he is exposed to the noise and chaos of life. The vagaries of visual space in
Carson’s poetry serve to enhance perception. In other words, the material world
around Geryon is affluent, and the environment in turn reflects the depth of Geryon’s
own feelings.
35
Shanghai Normal University Master of Arts Chapter Ⅲ
Moreover, the “room” Geryon imaged in his inner world is also his home and
house. The house, quite obviously, is a privileged entity for a phenomenological study
of the intimate values of inside space, provided, of course, that people take in both its
unity and its complexity, and endeavor to integrate all the special values in one
fundamental value (Bachelard 1994: 3). The house manifest itself in dispersed images
and a body of images at the same time (Bachelard 1994: 3). In the meanwhile, the
imagination arguments the values of reality (Bachelard 1994: 3), in other words, the
original house is possible to occur in different time and space due to the imagination.
In Autobiography of Red, the imagination of Geryon is not merely derived from his
photographic world, but also is from the unrestrained flow of his consciousness. For
most people, transcending their memories of the house in which they have found
shelter, they have the opportunities to comfort themselves with the illusion of
protection. Nonetheless, Geryon only trembles behind thick walls that are built by his
imagination with impalpable shadows as he mistrusts the seemingly staunchest
ramparts (Bachelard 1994: 5). Geryon experiences the “room” in its reality and in its
virtuality, by means of thought and dreams. At that moment, the mother’s “room” in
another space comes to dwell in the present space with an entire past and Geryon is in
the functional composition of imagination and memory. The “room” in which Geryon
have experienced sorrow and heartbreak reconstitute itself in a new space, and it is
because those memories of former dwelling-places are relieved within the steam of
consciousness. Memories are motionless, and the more securely they are fixed in
space, the sounder they are (Bachelard 1994: 9). With the stream of consciousness, the
past containing those memories gather to the present, thus the displacement of space
occurs.
36
Shanghai Normal University Master of Arts Chapter Ⅲ
37
Shanghai Normal University Master of Arts Chapter Ⅲ
supposed to make a relationship between the discarded queer bodies of social histories
and the discarded queer monstrosities of subjectivity.
Queerness does not define identity, the view is that it is implicated in subject
formation. In Autobiography of Red, Carson’s queer red-winged monster is a
metaphor for passions that exist outside knowable history. Red, however, is not
outside reality; rather, as Monique Tschofen argues quoting Umberto Eco, it gestures
toward “the dynamics of the real,” the force of temporality, relationality, and emotion
on existence. For Tschofen, Geryon stands for metaphor itself: the principle of seeing
what cannot be seen directly; the principle that makes a distinction between
representation and the passions in charge of or animate representation. Geryon’s
wings stand for things queer—the monster within that has no name, only adjectives.
Geryon’s red wings are not “real” but they do exist. They inflect his subjectivity
semiotically and render him, as Julia Kristeva might put it, a stranger to himself. Red
is not itself identity, not the affirmation that signifies a set of meanings; it is the
substance of confusing affects and psychic conflicts from which signification is
possible and from which subjectivities are made and unmade, named and renamed.
For Geryon, his red wings always render him confused and painful:
These days Geryon was experiencing a pain not felt since childhood.
His wings were struggling. They tore against each other on his shoulders
like the little mindless red animal they were.
With a piece of wooden plank he’ found in the basement Geryon made a back
brace
And lashed the wings tight. (Carson 1998: 53)
Geryon’s red wings are growing while he thinks the period is full of struggle and pain.
The description that his wings tears against each other is actually the symbolization of
the tearing of the ego of Geryon himself. Geryon is always in the state of being
anxious and frightened about his identity, to be specific, his weird red wings. His
inner world, being implied in his photographic world, is consistently disordered and
38
Shanghai Normal University Master of Arts Chapter Ⅲ
chaotic, which is similar to the dream of Geryon. His action of lashing the wings tight
is obviously the reflection of his suppression of his identity:
Geryon’s many actions are related to captivity and suppression, which is a kind of
insinuation and representative of his self-denial of his identity. When Geryon stopped
in the dark he involuntarily makes a interrogative noise--“Who am I?” Therefore, the
identity of Geryon portrayed in his photographic diary is erratic and is even not
acceptable to himself. It can be observed that what Geryon actually escapes is not his
miserable life but his erratic and chaotic identity.
Actually, the erratic identity of Geroyn also originates from his childhood,
especially his memories in his home. Sometimes humans hold the opinion that they
know themselves in time, when all they know is a sequence of fixations in the space
of the being’s stability (Bachelard 1994: 8). Generally, the space with stability is one’s
own home, or the house, as the house is the personal corner of the world, in which
people achieves a sense of identity. However, the house is of no value to Geryon as he
has no sense of belonging at that place, where he suffers the sexual assault from his
elder brother and he obtains no protection or support from his mother whom he once
believes in and relies on. Without the spirit of house, humans would be a dispersed
being. Therefore, Geryon, is always on the journey to find a real shelter to get to
know the true self. Furthermore, the erratic identity also originates from a sort of
restriction on himself:
Freedom is what I want for you Geryon we’re true friends you know that’s why
I want you to be free.
Don’t want to be free want to be with you. Beaten but alert Geryon organized all
his inside force to suppress this remark. (Carson 1998: 74)
39
Shanghai Normal University Master of Arts Chapter Ⅲ
Herakles expects that Geryon is capable of obtaining freedom, whereas the inner
voice of Geryon yearns for the company of Herakles. According to this, it can be
observed that Geryon is incapable of tolerating the solitude and loneliness, or more
precisely, the single self. He is dependent on the one he loves to have the opportunity
to know himself, however, the reality disappoints him and his identity remains erratic.
Actually, although Herakles, as the past companion of Geryon, steals Geryon’s tender
heart, he is entirely unacquainted with the inner world of Geryon and what he pursues
is disparate in comparison with Geryon’s pursuit:
40
Shanghai Normal University Master of Arts Chapter Ⅳ
In 1945, Joseph Frank published The Spatial Form of Modern Literature, which
sparked a scholarly interest in literary space. Frank reviewed the discussion of
literature and painting in Lessing’s Laocoon and directly rejected its applicability to
modern literature (Frank 1945: 221-240). After the analysis of artistic form of modern
literature, Frank assumes that numerous works of literary figures belonging to
modernism such as Eliot, Pound, and Proust demonstrate a sort of spatialized art. The
space he mentions is definitely not the actual physical space, but the textual space of
the work. From his perspective, the space of modernist literary form primarily refers
to the technique of juxtaposition in the works of modernist writers. Modernist literary
creators have a rather self-conscious perception of the spatiality of art. For instance,
Pound considers that imagery as the unity of ideas and emotion, which is a complex
formed in a single moment. In brief, the reader of these modernist works are supposed
to understand the works in a syncretic way rather than in a chronological order, that is,
only when various and varied imagery are combined with each other can readers
perceive the purpose the author and the meaning of the works. Insomuch, the works
can be regarded spatial. As regards Autobiography of Red, various and complicated
images are utilized by Carson to adorn the melancholy life of an unusual boy Geryon
so as to form the contemporary poetic fiction of the Greek myth.
Poetic imagery is the basic building block of poetry, the soul and life of poetry.
Poetic imagery is the carrier of language. In fact, the process of creating poetry is the
poets’ search for objective things to use as imagery, constructing imagery language, so
that their subjective emotions can be expressed vividly and imaginatively. From a
literary perspective, poetic imagery is a means of shaping artistic images, while from
a linguistic perspective, it is an artistic language that conveys aesthetic information
and aesthetic feelings. Poetic imagery language is figurative, metaphorical, ethnic and
41
Shanghai Normal University Master of Arts Chapter Ⅳ
paired with the transcendental. The poet’s use of metaphor is what makes figurative
poetic imagery a vehicle for his or her subjective emotions. Poetic imagery language
is characterized by semantic multilayeredness, polysemy and indeterminacy. The
language of poetic imagery has multiple layers of semantics, i.e. it has both a surface
conceptual meaning and a deep aesthetic meaning. In the semantic system of the
language, many words have not only a physical conceptual meaning, but also a
variety of cultural meanings derived from the conceptual meaning, which are
characteristic of the nation. These words become the main imagery words of poetic
imagery language, which naturally forms the semantic polysemy of imagery language.
Poetic imagery is the material medium through which abstract emotions are
concretized, and it conveys and expresses subjective ideas in a metaphorical way,
rather than directly in unmistakable language, thus producing a hazy and ambiguous
sense of beauty, and thus a certain degree of uncertainty. When the poet constructs the
language of imagery, he uses the mechanism of metaphorical thinking. Metaphorical
thinking is based on the similarity between people and things, and between things and
objects. Therefore, metaphorical thinking follows the law of interpenetration of all
things. The poet constructs the similarity between subjective emotions and objective
things through the use of intuitive associations or extraordinary imaginative thinking
operations, and corresponds his subjective feelings to certain sensual characteristics of
objective things, thus constructing a metaphorical poetic imagery language. The poet
is stimulated by the external world to produce a creative motive, and is driven by this
motive to organize internal speech. The process of conceiving and organizing the
internal language of poetic imagery is the process through which the poet, under the
constraints of national culture, selects objective things to serve as imagery carriers
and constructs the imagery language of poetry to express his or her feelings. Once the
internal language of poetic imagery has been created, the internal language must be
externalized, expressed in sound and shaped in words, before the whole process of
constructing poetic imagery can be completed. The poet uses external linguistic
means such as phonetics, semantics and syntax to transform the internal speech into a
metaphorical external speech.
42
Shanghai Normal University Master of Arts Chapter Ⅳ
meaning of the imagery. The language of poetic imagery exists first and foremost as a
symbol of everyday language, a material medium through which the poet constructs
the imagery system and conveys the aesthetic experience, without which poetic
imagery could not form a material entity. Therefore, as far as the linguistic symbols of
imagery are concerned, they have their own conceptual meaning, that is, the
conceptual meaning of the surface of the language of poetic imagery. But when
everyday language is used as a vehicle for imagery and becomes the language of
imagery, it becomes an artistic sign to be used, which gives rise to a deep aesthetic
meaning.
Grass swan towards him and away. Joyous small companies of insects
with double-decker wings
like fighter plane were diving about in the hot white wind. The light
unbalanced him. (Carson 1998: 49)
This excerpt is not a straightforward linear structure, but a continuous loop with
a certain point as the axis, and Geryon himself is the axis. The “grass” is the
ecological image of the green plants in the courtyard, and “insects” are creatures in
45
Shanghai Normal University Master of Arts Chapter Ⅳ
the ecological system of the courtyard, and the “light” is a natural phenomenon
caused by the movement of the air. It can be observed that the three images have no
inevitable logical relations. Therefore, these images cannot be assembled in the
narrow text space but for the specific principle of organization. And the reason that
the fusion of these images is able to be perceived lies that these images become
appreciable and tangible through the behaviors they perform in Geryon. Generally
speaking, the organization of image space is not difficult to understand. The length of
the stanzas, the rhythmic counterpoint, or the placement of staccato in Western poetry,
or even the necessity of limiting the poem to “fourteen lines” are all the consequence
of strict organization of the poem. Even if some poets go beyond the rules and break
stanzas or staccato, which is seemingly the detriment of this literal organization, they
are still, in essence, implicitly following the rules and not making the poetic creation
as a true treatise. In Autobiography of Red, many fragments of sentence are utilized so
as to realize some kind of enlightening effect:
The sentence “Spokes of red rang across his eyelids in the blackness” (Carson 1998:
57) is split into two rows, which is seemingly irregular. Nevertheless, this kind of
arrangement is precisely the highlight of the blackness, which is a symbol of the
sorrowful inner world of Geryon.
The malleability of image space brings a constant fascination to the poetry, and it
manifests itself particularly in the extension space beyond the literal structure. The
concept of extension space increase the density of image, thus giving rise to the
evolution of the traditional aesthetic understanding of poetry, which is based on the
definition of the poem’s temporal duration by Lessing. The poetry is an open system,
46
Shanghai Normal University Master of Arts Chapter Ⅳ
in which each stanza is, within itself, a self-contained system of interlocking stanzas.
However, as soon as they are assigned to a chain of temporal states, each occupying a
position either before or after the other, the imagery immediately ceases to be equal.
This temporal sequence, in which the preceding causes form the final effect,
inevitably creates inertia of constant movement and it is this inertia that is effectively
exploited by extension. If the poem terminates with a puzzling ending, the readers are
capable of relying on their imagination, which is supported by the malleability of
image space, to compensate for the gap until the acquisition of one’s own
understanding of the poem.
Outside the sun had set. The little barred window was black. Geryon sat wrapped
in himself. Would this day never end?
His eye travelled to the clock at the front of the room and he fell into the pool
of his favourite question. (Carson 1998: 92)
This is the end of one chapter in Autobiography of Red and this kind of ending
possibly renders the readers puzzled and confused as Carson does not directly tell the
readers what Geryon’s favourite question is. However, the answer is not clueless since
the image of “clock” invites the readers to exert their imagination. Before Geryon is
immersed in some question, he has been contemplating the clock at the front of the
room and the clock is a tool to record time. Thus, it can be inferred that the question is
related with time. Apart from the image of “clock”, the image of “sun” is also a
distinct and noticeable evidence. The description of the sunset,which is a concept of
time dimension, actually implies what provokes Geryon’s thought and reflection. In
47
Shanghai Normal University Master of Arts Chapter Ⅳ
this sense, the image of “clock” and the image of the “sun” are associated with each
other and both of them provides the readers with the space of imagination. As a matter
of fact, Carson directly presents the favourite question of Geryon, that is “What is
time made of (Carson 1998: 80)”:
Although Carson presents the question, she does not directly reveals the answer to it,
whereas the image of “big deadweight blocks” actually gives the explanation. For
Geryon, the flow of time resembles the movement of the collection of deadweight
blocks. From this point of view, time is tangible with a entity, just like that in a five
dimensional space. The blocks from different place is exactly the incarnation of time
in different ages, including the past, now, and the future. Henceforth, Carson’s
concept of spatialization of time is exemplified anew.
Geryon’s brother was regarding her with one eye closed his mode of total
attention.
What about you Geryon
what’s your favourite weapon? Cage, said Geryon from behind his knees.
48
Shanghai Normal University Master of Arts Chapter Ⅳ
The dual structure of the image “cage” is obvious. The cage is a sort of indication of
the response of Geryon to the pathetic reality. Geryon has no courage to confront the
reality directly or fight against it and his choice is to escape from the reality and to
imprison himself in the cage, just like the tendency of him to fall asleep. Therefore,
the image of “cage” forms the constructivity of image space. However, this kind of
constructivity is still confined in the content and meaning of the verse without the
consideration of the structure of the image itself. The dual meaning of the image of
“cage” operates in a paralleled way, and the more intricate constructivity of image
space is the juxtaposition of image structures:
The two “room” actually has a more complicated constructivity. The first “room” is
the room of the mother of Herakles, in which Geryon wants to find the telephone to
contact his own mother. Nontheless, the second “room”, which is seemingly the same
room, is actually another room in other space for Geryon at that moment. Geryon is
disappointed and grieved as the relationship between Geryon and Herakles is not
accepted by Geryon’s mother. As a consequence, when Geryon has to contact her
mother, he cannot resist the surge of sorrow and anger, and the second room is
precisely the room of Geryon’s mother. Hence, the image of “room” in these lines
achieve the juxtaposition within the space, which is a three-dimensional structure of
49
Shanghai Normal University Master of Arts Chapter Ⅳ
image. This kind of characteristic also manifests itself in the traumatic memories of
Geryon:
Geryon is subjected to the sadness of the past when he stands against the wall of the
bar. The first “wall ” in this section is the one in the bar at present. And the second
“wall”, within the recollection of Geryon, is a heartrending existence. The reason is
that Geryon, standing against the wall in his high school, was once assaulted by his
elder brother. The two “wall” seemingly exists in different space. However, with the
flow of Geryon’s consciousness, the first “wall” is actually transformed into the
second “wall”, namely the one in Geryon’s memories. The displacement of time and
space resulting from the stream of consciousness of Geryon contributes to the bored
and extensive connotations of the image “wall”, thus the constructivity of image space
is achieved.
50
Shanghai Normal University Master of Arts Chapter Ⅴ
Ⅴ Conclusion
Autobiography is visual, not verbal. This explains why Carson asked Geryon to
write his autobiography through the medium of photography. Autobiography itself is a
review of the past, but also a gaze at the reality of the self. In the same way that
photography preserves the disappearing past, it also gazes at the reality of the world.
Carson, a poet with an unconventional and extraordinary poetic vision, reinterprets
the classics in a contemporary and innovative way. The use of the photographic
medium creates a photographic narrative within the poem, which is also a new form
of fusion of poetry and painting and is an innovation of poetic language more.
Photography, like mainstream surrealist taste itself, exhibits a habitual penchant for
waste, eyesores, useless objects, oddities and artifice. As the red-winged monster
Geryon is also portrayed as a homosexual who is different from the mainstream, he
would be the type of person the photographer would love to document, with a curious
yet indifferent attitude, and for the viewer Geryon is something they long to know.
And Carson does turn the camera on Geryon, leaving the mastery of the camera in his
hands.
The true insight of Autobiography of Red is that the poetry and all these sections
move like collapse, which is what Carson attempts to create. The creation of poetry is
51
Shanghai Normal University Master of Arts Chapter Ⅴ
regarded as the painting by Carson and she paints with thoughts and facts during the
process of poetic production. Carson is bored of the lack of passion of human beings
living in modern times, thus she devotes herself to the classical world, in which she
explores her roots and receives psychological comfort and alleviation. Nonetheless,
the sluggish reality is so inescapable that Carson is destined to confront it. Fortunately,
Carson succeeds in getting accordance with the reality and she becomes the
contemporary interpreter of the classics. One of the significant aspect Carson has
reflection on is the poetic language. Language is limited to time so the traditional
argument is that poetry is temporal. With the development of literary criticism concept,
the spatialization of time within poetry gradually arises, which is also what Carson
pursues among her poetic work. The spatial turn of poetry in Autobiography of Red
mainly embodies in Carson’s innovation of the poetic form. Carson is mistrustful of
the credibility of language’s description of the facts, as a consequence, she enables her
protagonist to narrate his autobiography in the way of photography. Within the
photographic world of Geryon, the photograph taken by him not only conserves some
moment he expects to seize, but also contains a deluge of the consciousness of
himself. The moment Geryon presses the shutter incorporates the present emotion of
him along with his memories of the past. Moreover, Geryon has the tendency to fall
into sleep, which is a sort of stress response to the miserable reality and escape from
the reality. Geryon is always in the boundary between dream and waking, and the
boundary between dreams and waking is active as it has leaks. Additionally, in the
space of leak, Geryon is endowed with the moment of enlightenment, which inspires
and encourages him to proceed with his photographic autobiography. Carson herself
concentrates more on some moment of enlightenment and this kind of moment,
recorded by Geryon’ s photograph, occurs when Geryon is awake from his dreams.
The photographic world is a kind of dream for Geryon to some extent. The
photograph and the self-consciousness buried in it render the time in Autobiography
of Red chaotic and disordering, thus the displacement of space occurs and the
spatialization of time is achieved. Likewise, the identity of Geryon is in constant
change as well. Geryon has been always in the process of tearing of the ego and
52
Shanghai Normal University Master of Arts Chapter Ⅴ
53
Shanghai Normal University Master of Arts Bibliography
Bibliography
Bell, Al. Medium and Mediality in Anne Carson [J]. Textual Practice, 2021, Vol. 36
(7): 1-21.
Beasley, Bruce. Who Can a Monster Blame for Being Red? Three Fragments on the
Academic and the “other” in Autobiography of Red [A]. Anne Carson: Ecstatic
Lyre. Ed. Joshua Marie Wilkinson. Michigan: University of Michigan Press,
2015. 74-81.
Bachelard, Gaston. The Poetics of Space [M]. Trans. Mariajolas. Boston: Beacon
Press, 1994.
Battis, Jes. “Dangling Inside the Word she”: Confusion and Gender Vertigo in Anne
Carson’s Autobiography of Red [J]. Canadian Literature, 2003,Vol. 176(176):
198-203.
Berta, Katherine 1. Float, by Anne Carson [J]. Women’s Studies, 2018, Vol.47(3):
377-379.
D’Agata, John and Carson Anne. A _____ with Anne Carson [J]. The lowa Review,
2014, Vol. 27(2): 1-22.
Frank, Joseph. Spatial Form of Modern Literature: An Essay in Two Parts [J]. The
Sewanee Review, 1945, Vol. 53(2): 221-240.
Georgis, Dina. Hearing the Better Story: Learning and the Aesthetics of Loss and
Expulsion [J]. Review of Education, Pedagogy and Cultural Studies, 2006,
Vol.28(2): 165-178.
McCallum, E. L.. Toward a Photography of Love: The Tain of the Photograph in Anne
Carson’s Autobiography of Red [J]. Postmodern Culture, 2007, Vol.17(3): 10.
Mitchell, W. J. T.. Spatial Form in Literature: Toward a General Theory [J]. Critical
Inquiry, Vol. 6(3): 539-567.
O’Rourke-Suchoff, Jessi. “Near and Unlost”: Reading Paul Celan with Anne Carson
[J]. Germanic Review, 2018, Vol.93(1): 76-83.
Signorelli-Pappas, Rita. Anne Carson Norma Jeane Baker of Troy (review) [J]. World
Literature Today, 2020, Vol. 94(3): 82-83.
Tschofen, Monique. First I Must Tell about Seeing: (De)monstrations of Visuality and
the Dynamics of Metaphor in Anne Carson’s Autobiography of Red [J].
Canadian Literature, 2004, Vol. 180(2): 31-50.
Van Buren, Ann K. Autobiography of Red: A Novel in Verse [J]. Library Journal,
1998, Vol.123(9): 88.
Weaver, Andy. From Cohen to Carson: The Poet’s Novel in Canada [J]. English
Studies in Canada, 2008, Vol. 34(4): 184-187.
56
Shanghai Normal University Master of Arts Bibliography
57