Pilot 04.2024
Pilot 04.2024
Pilot 04.2024
Est. 1967 Britain’s best selling General Aviation magazine April 2024
Electrifying
aviation
We discover if it really APRIL 2024 ● £5.99
Arthur J. Gallagher (UK) Limited is authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority.
Registered Office: The Walbrook Building, 25 Walbrook, London EC4N 8AW. Registered in England and Wales.
Company Number: 1193013. FP806-2022 Exp. 26.05.2023.
© 2023 Arthur J. Gallagher & Co. | ARTUK-5030
Preflight
I
Editorial
Write to: Pilot, Kelsey Media, The Granary, must thank the BBGA, the British the conference,
Down’s Court, Yalding Hill, Yalding ME18 6AL Business and General Aviation trade is only now
Editor Philip Whiteman Tel 07785 616207 association, for inviting Pilot to its catching up.
Email [email protected] excellent annual conference and AGM. Less widely
Design: Sean Phillips, atg-media.com Formed in the merger of GAMTA (the appreciated is
General Aviation Manufacturers & Traders that the go-it-
Contributing Editors Eugenio Facci, James Allan, Association) with BAUA (the Business alone action denied
Nick Bloom, Bob Grimstead & Peter R March
Aviation Users Association) the BBGA is – operators of UK-
News & Flight Test Editor Dave Unwin if you’ll allow me to mix my metaphors – registered aircraft access to
This is the last edition of Pilot to be published by Kelsey Media. For the May issue onward,
the magazine’s new home will be with Key Publishing – but rest assured there will be no change
in editorship nor Pilot’s hugely experienced and long-serving team of contributors.
THE MAY ISSUE WILL BE ON SALE FROM THURSDAY 25 APRIL
58
ON THE
Features
20 Flight Test:
TL-Ultralight Sting S4
The only ‘sting in the tail’ that it’s a
microlight – and a very fine one at
that! Fast and featuring airliner-style
instrumentation and an autopilot,
it’s hard to fault
38
38 Pilot Profile
MAF’s old, bold aviator
The old saw would have it there’s
no such thing, but RAF veteran
PHOTO: MAF
Regulars
6 Pilot Notes quizzes Chalmers University of 48 Old Timers
FAA allows Velis Electro to be used for Technology about its pioneering study Pilot’s comprehensive round-up of
pilot training in USA, Bicester’s owners on the environmental impact of an events in the vintage aviation world
ask what better location could there electric aircraft over its entire life cycle
be for a 2024 vertiport and test centre 65 QFI Logbook
than one of Britain’s best-preserved 18 New Regs The top fifteen student failings
historic grass airfields… Monthly look at what’s being registered,
reregistered and deregistered 68 Safety Matters
9 Airfields Other people’s incidents and accidents
… Llanbedr Airfield, Snowdonia 31 The Cooper Column we can all draw lessons from
Aerospace Centre would surely respond The CAA is ignoring our concerns
about Electronic Conspicuity 70 Calendar
10 Flight Training All the aviation events, listed
IFA Portugal orders Pipistrel Velis 33 Airmail by location
Electros for its training fleet (maybe Let us know what you think (and maybe
you see a theme here – Ed) Goodwood win a presentation pair of bottles of 81 ILAFFT
commemorates Rob Wildeboer with Pan Am gin and vodka) How long to hold? Consternation
2024 flying scholarships in Kazakhstan
37 PTT column
13 Rotorheads Test flying an ex-ATC Kirby Cadet
Hot on the heels of Production Mk.III converted into a single-seat
Organisation Approval, eVTOL motor glider
manufacturer Volocopter becomes
an Approved Training Organisation 47 Airways
Bars and beers: a significant part of
14 Notes Special the intercontinental pilot’s life was
@Pilot_mag Pilotmagazine
Is it really that green? Eugenio Facci traditionally spent rehydrating
Dawn to Dusk plans? Hangar Homes halted... Are electric aircraft green?
Pooley’s all-in-one-day ... at Lee on Solent, at least. The claims, myths and facts
flying adventure competition The developer hopes his other are explored in a ‘special’
is now in its sixtieth year.
Time you entered? p8 Aeroparks will prove the
planning inspector wrong p9 by Eugenio Facci. The
conclusions may surprise you p14
Airworthiness
Women Go Gliding Weekend Directive for
The British Gliding Association (BGA)
has announced that its ‘Women Go
Gliding Weekend’ will take place
PT-6 turbine
on 27 and 28 April 2024. The aim
of the initiative is to introduce more
engine
women and their companions to Possibly the world’s most
gliding by providing a friendly and popular turboprop engine,
informative welcome at gliding clubs Pratt & Whitney Canada’s PT-6
and offering them some flying on the was recently the subject of an
day at an attractive price. Clubs that Airworthiness Directive (AD)
have already signed up to participate issued by Transport Canada.
include Banbury, Bannerdown, The AD addresses one in-
Buckminster, Bristol & Glos, Bognor service report of Second Stage
Regis, Burn, Cambridge, Dartmoor, Power Turbine (PT2) blade
ILLUSTRATION: BGA
Airfields
following newly introduced and the vertiport, along
CAA guidelines last month, with its existing Permanent
aimed at developing the Airspace Danger Area and in-
framework for the forthcoming house Air Navigation Service
Advanced Air Mobility Provision (ANSP), will position
(AAM) market. The SLiNK- the centre as the premier
What’s happening at our TECH vertiport portal will flight test centre for eVTOLs
airfields, aerodromes & airports support automated takeoff
and landing, and terminal
in the UK.
In a related story, Aerovolt
area manoeuvring of drones recently installed a charging
and eVTOL aircraft. SLiNK- point for electric aircraft
PHOTO: AEROVOLT
and in-development aircraft system for airside charging
worldwide, in early March. facilities, using a bespoke
Aerovolt is currently engaged wireless thermal monitoring
with nearly seventy regional and alarm system.
and medium sized UK The owners of the centre Snowdonia Aerospace Centre is positioning Llanbedr Airfield to
airports on smart charging are also planning the UK’s become the premier flight test centre in the UK for eVTOL
took another turn recently, when the so rather than fight the appeal in TVR has announced it has chosen
planning appeal was dismissed by court, I have decided to concentrate Thruxton Race Circuit and Aerodrome
the planning inspector for a number on getting Enniskillen and hopefully as the location for a new European
of ‘spurious’ reasons. Hangar the Isle of Man Aeroparks ‘under my Development and Brand Centre.
Homes boss Peter Day told Pilot, belt’, so that concerns about safety Thruxton, the UK’s fastest track with a
“the planning inspector just did not and security, noise and road traffic rich heritage in motorsports, emerged
can be shown to be non-issues in a as the ideal location for TVR’s base,
future planning application. replacing its current facilities in Surrey.
“Also,” he added, “there will be The selection was not only driven
a new leader of the Council, and by the location’s proximity to the track,
probably many new Councillors in but also by its historical significance in
a few months, so they may take a motorsports. One of the pivotal factors
different view about Solent Aeropark. influencing TVR’s decision was the
After all, what is there not to like local skilled employment demographic,
about having nine new aviation- Thruxton’s surrounding community
related businesses that would help offering a pool of talent with expertise
to safeguard the airport and make relevant to TVR’s operations. How
Hangar Homes claim that nine new aviation-
related businesses would help to safeguard it more sustainable, plus the capital or whether this will affect aviation at
the airport and make it more sustainable and income derived from them?” Thruxton remains to be seen.
Flight training
News from the clubs, schools & ATOs
PHOTO: CAE
these scholarships have five hours training in the
been made possible by school’s Piper Super
generous donations from Cub. In addition to the CAE hosts the assessment using its B7373 sim based in Brussels
the community. Melanie scholarships, Pooleys
Wright, Flying School Flight Equipment has TUI fly Belgium has opened Other stages in the process
Operations Manager, says donated several PPL/ its 2024 multi pilot licence include a TUI Group online
“thank you to everyone LAPL course training (MPL) cadet pilot programme, HR call, so the carrier can get
who has kindly donated books to support the The training programme, to know applicants better
towards our scholarships. successful candidates. which is designed to turn and best assess their level of
Since we launched, To apply for a Rob new recruits into 737 first motivation and suitability for
we have raised an Wildeboer Scholarship, officers within nineteen the MPL training course.
incredible £25,000 and please email scholarship months, is also open to Candidates who progress
helped fifteen students. @goodwood.com applicants with little or no beyond this first stage
We’re delighted that explaining in no more previous aviation experience. can then expect a face-to-
we can offer four more than 500 words which Candidates must be face interview plus group
scholarship you would a citizen of the EU and assessment with one of
like to apply for and why, available to start training in the airline’s crew resource
and include brief details September 2024. However, management (CRM)
of any previous flying unlike TUI Airways’ existing instructors at its Zaventem
experience. All applicants fully-funded UK cadet pilot base, then a 737 simulator
must be at least sixteen training programme, cadets assessment hosted by CAE
years old and hold or must pay €54,000 towards in Brussels. Candidates
PHOTO: GOODWOOD
be capable of obtaining their training. A significant who clear this hurdle will
the appropriate aviation sum, but one that the carrier then have to pass a board
medical. Scholarships claims is ‘30-40% lower than interview, followed by
are only applicable for alternatives’. an online psychological
training at Goodwood Applicants must first pass assessment. This consists of
To remember and honour Flying School, all training TUI’s cadet pilot online a personality questionnaire,
its late manager Rob
Wildeboer, Goodwood
must be completed assessment process. This cognitive reasoning test, and
Flying School offers several during 2024. The features tests of English, a video interview. A hiring
scholarships every year deadline is 14 April 2024. verbal reasoning, logical decision is made at this point.
reasoning, and numeracy. Applications close on 1 May.
L I G H T A I RCR A F T P I LOT L I CE N CE
F L I G H T S I M U L ATO R G1000 L A RG E F L E E T
01865 370814
HOUR BUILDING F O R M AT I O N F LY I N G
reception@pilotflight.training
PILOTS LOUNGE
pilotflighttraining.com
pilot.flight.training PilotFlightTraining
Pilot Flight Training Ltd. Registered in England and Wales. Company number 12371676. VAT 345 9122 95. London Oxford Airport OX5 1RA
Rotorheads
The latest news from the world of rotary-wing and eVTOL aviation
PHOTO: VOLOCOPTER
Volocopter to train pilots for VoloCity aircraft receives
its future products and makes type certification, which is
the company the first electric expected later this year.
vertical takeoff and landing The company also
(eVTOL) aircraft developer announced another
to become an ATO. significant milestone last Hot on the heels of Production Organisation Approval, Volocopter
has now become an Approved Training Organisation
As part of the approval, the month, when it confirmed
company will now work to it has received Production eVTOL company to hold to design and produce
finalise the training program Organisation Approval (POA) both Design Organisation the VoloCity in-house
for its electric VoloCity aircraft from the LBA, allowing it to Approval (DOA) and POA. and has entered the pre-
in close cooperation with the commence serial production Volocopter received EASA’s serial production stage
LBA. This is in preparation of the VoloCity eVTOL at DOA in 2019, followed of manufacturing. The
for the commercial launch its two new production and by the initial POA in 2021 aircraft will operate under
of electric air taxis later this hangar facilities in Bruchsal, with the acquisition of DG EASA’s SC-VTOL (Special
year, implementing newly Germany. Volocopter is Flugzeugbau. Volocopter Condition VTOL) enhanced
published EASA regulations the world’s first and only now has full authority certification category.
You have probably heard the than a piston engine’. What did lifetime, the greater the benefit of the
argument: electric aircraft actually you actually find in your study? electric aircraft. So, even considering
pollute a lot, because it takes a lot A: We found that the environmental production and disposal of the
of energy to build the batteries and impact of an electric aircraft, batteries, the electric aircraft is much
it is a problem to dispose of them considering all the different phases better in terms of both climate change
when exhausted. But is that true? in its whole life cycle, is still lower and particulate matter emissions.
Now answers are beginning to than that of a fossil fuel-powered
emerge: Rickard Arvidsson, Anders one. The electric aircraft has a higher So, this is good news. However, your
Nordelöf, and Selma Brynolf of environmental impact at the beginning study is based on an aircraft using
Chalmers University of Technology of its life due to specific factors electricity from renewable sources.
in Sweden have conducted the first during production. However, as the At the moment only about one third
ever study on the environmental aircraft begins to fly, the benefits of of the UK’s electricity comes from
impact of an electric aircraft over its electric propulsion start to kick in, renewables. Is it still better here, in
entire life cycle. Contributing editor and as it reaches a quarter of its life terms of sustainability, to fly electric?
Eugenio Facci sat down with the the electric aircraft becomes more Yes, even in this case, it is still better to
study’s lead author, Rickard Arvidsson, environmentally friendly. By the end of fly electric. We can say that because
to discuss their conclusions. its life the electric aircraft will have had we also evaluated the aircraft against
a much smaller carbon footprint than the average 2019 EU electricity mix,
Q: Typical criticism of electric the piston-engined one (reduced by which had roughly twice the carbon
aircraft includes claims that ‘it takes roughly 60% - Ed). This is true despite intensity of the current (2023) UK
a lot of energy to build a battery’, the need to produce of replacement electricity mix. In that case, the electric
‘disposing of a used battery has batteries, which happens a couple aircraft become environmentally
a large environmental impact’ of times during the useful life of preferable after about half of its
and ‘you end up polluting more the electric aircraft. The longer the expected lifetime. An electric aircraft
running on UK electricity would We based our study on the Pipistrel electrification of the car fleet (which
thus become more beneficial than a Alpha Electro two-seater, one of will be by far the main driver). In
corresponding fossil fuel-based aircraft the earliest available all-electric particular, it is already estimated that
after somewhere between a quarter aircraft. Much of the data on the demand for lithium will reach current
and a half of its expected lifetime. composition and use of the aircraft production capacity by 2030, and
was kindly provided by Pipistrel. some estimations suggest the same
Was building/disposing of a battery Regarding the production of important for cobalt. Some studies regarding
perhaps a lot less sustainable components, we relied largely on lithium indicate that we actually
in the past? Have there been previous studies done at Chalmers have enough of the raw material,
serious improvements recently University of Technology regarding, but that the real problem lies in our
that have tilted the balance? for example, lithium-ion batteries, ability to extract it and process it in
Yes, early studies of environmental electric motors and inverters. For large quantities. The infrastructure
impacts of battery production, production of everyday items such as to do that does not exist yet.
specifically of the lithium-ion aluminium, we relied on the world’s In addition, there is a high
batteries used in electric uncertainty related
aircraft and elsewhere,
typically reported
We based our study on the to such projections.
For example, there
higher [production] Pipistrel Alpha Electro two-seater are other battery
energy intensity and technologies under
environmental impacts. These largest LCA (Life Cycle Assessment) development that do not require the
studies considered smaller industrial database, called Ecoinvent. same set of metals, including lithium-
production of lithium-ion batteries, While an electric aircraft is more iron-phosphate (LFP) batteries that
which was less energy efficient per unit sustainable than a piston-engined contain lithium but no cobalt or nickel,
of output. Currently, lithium-ion batteries one, you also found that it is worse in and sodium-ion batteries without any
are produced in larger, so-called terms of ‘mineral resource scarcity’, of these metals. While the lithium-
gigafactories, with annual outputs at meaning that it uses rare materials nickel-manganese-cobalt batteries
more than one gigawatt hour. This that are fairly difficult to source considered in our LCA seem to be the
has led to notably lower impact per and produce on an industrial scale. currently preferred choice for electric
kilowatt hour of energy storage in So, do we have enough minerals to aircraft, it is difficult to foresee if that
batteries. [Technology for] the disposal convert all cars and small aeroplanes will also be the case in the future.
of batteries has not yet changed as to electric propulsion? And exactly
rapidly, but also does not contribute which minerals are we talking about? Does this mean that we will need to
as much to their life-cycle impact. We are mainly talking about the metals pay a lot more for those minerals,
lithium, nickel and cobalt, used in the and would this have a large
On which aircraft did you base cathode of the battery. In the short impact on the cost of operating
the study, and how did you collect term, the demand for these metals is an electric aeroplane (or car)?
the data? likely to increase, mainly due to the Metal prices do not reflect the scarcity
PHOTO: CHALMERS UNIVERSITY OF TECHNOLOGY/DANIEL KARLSSON
risk indicated by the LCA results, would happen to electric aircraft and Pipistrel reports that the
and they do not even reflect the given increased production levels, batteries in its next electric aircraft
possibility of shortages within the which would counteract potential already have three times longer life.
next few years. Rather, metal prices increases in battery metal prices. There are also battery technologies
reflect the supply-and-demand under development that focus on
balance as it stands today. How In your study, you also found achieving higher performance, such
metal prices will change in the future that, if battery capacity were as lithium-sulphur batteries, that might
is therefore difficult to foresee, and to be doubled, electric aircraft achieve much higher energy storage
so is the effect on battery prices. As would use the same amount capacity, compared to today’s
mentioned before, there are battery of rare minerals as piston- lithium-ion batteries. Considering
technologies under development engined aircraft, effectively these different developments, it does
that avoid some of the battery eliminating the problem. But will not seem unlikely that the balance
metals for which high demand we be able to double battery can in future be turned in favour of
might become a problem. These capacity and, if so, by when? the electric aircraft, even taking into
battery technologies might come Predicting battery performance account mineral resource scarcity.
to the rescue if some metal prices over time is challenging, but there
grow high. Also, prices of lithium- has been a steady increase in the Do you have a company or project
ion batteries have gone down as performance of the lithium-ion working at the leading edge of
production has increased, which is batteries studied over time, both aviation? Do you think we should
a common historical phenomenon regarding life and how much energy cover your company or project?
seen for many products. There is they can store. It seems likely that Email contributing editor Eugenio
reason to believe that the same such developments will continue, Facci at [email protected]
30
Global 25
warming
(kg CO2 eq/h)
20
15
10
0
Electric aircraft Electric aircraft Fossil fuel-based aircraft
(long lifetime + EU) (long lifetime + green)
The Hawker Demon was the fighter version of the Hawker Hart Cameron Fire-90 G-BZJA is one of several distinctive special shape
light bomber and, of 305 built, G-BTVE is the only airworthy balloons built by Cameron Balloons, in this case for fire extinguisher
example of the trio left in existence. Following an 18-year manufacturer Chubb. Unusually for a balloon of its age (24 years),
restoration, it flew again in June 2009, painted in the colours of 64 after a period when it was cancelled from the UK register, it has
Squadron RAF, and was based at Old Warden, where it is seen in recently been restored. Unlike the 3 litre Hydrospray model on
this image from May 2017. This magnificent machine was sold to which it is fashioned, this one claims to have a capacity of a mere
the USA as N1HD in February 2024. 3,110,844 litres!
Former flybe DHC-8-402 G-FLBA was transferred to Guernsey as CitationJet CJ4 G-SDRY was transferred to the Isle of Man as
2-FLBA in January 2024 and is currently stored in Malta, awaiting its M-JHCI in February 2024. More than 2600 of the Cessna 525
next operator. 93 of the type have been registered in the UK but the CitationJet have been built and the Model 525C CitationJet CJ4 is
departure of G-FLBA, seen here at Manchester in April 2013, brings the largest, capable of carrying nine passengers and a single pilot
the total left to just eleven. over a range of more than 4000 km.
Cancellations
G-FWPW Piper PA-28-236 Dakota Cancelled by the CAA
G-GAID Cessna 182T Skylane Transferred to Austria
G-GBHI SOCATA TB10 Tobago Permanently withdrawn from use
G-AIYG Stampe SV4B Transferred to Belgium
G-GEOF Pereira Osprey 2 Permanently withdrawn from use
G-ANVY Proctor 4 Permanently withdrawn from use
G-JEJE RAF 2000 GTX-SE Permanently withdrawn from use
G-APCC DH82A Tiger Moth Cancelled by the CAA
G-LBRT Beech D17S Staggerwing Transferred to USA
G-AVIC Cessna F172H Skyhawk Transferred to Republic of Ireland as EI-AEX
G-LGNJ SAAB 340B Transferred to USA as N981ES
G-AWHY Falconar F-11-3 Permanently withdrawn from use
G-MMGS Solar Wings Panther XL Permanently withdrawn from use
G-AZYA Gardan GY80-160 Horizon Cancelled by the CAA
G-MNMK Solar Wings Pegasus XL-R Permanently withdrawn from use
G-BCDL Cameron O-42 (HAB) Cancelled by the CAA
G-BMMJ Siren PIK 30 Transferred to The Netherlands G-MTPB Mainair Gemini Flash IIA (Mod) Permanently withdrawn from use
G-BTPT Cameron N-77 (HAB) Permanently withdrawn from use G-MTRX MW5 Sorcerer Cancelled by the CAA
G-BTVE Hawker Demon Transferred to USA as N1HD G-MZGM Cyclone AX2000 Permanently withdrawn from use
G-BUPC Rollason Beta B2 Permanently withdrawn from use G-NHVL Airbus EC175B Transferred to Malaysia
G-BUWF Cameron N-105 (HAB) Cancelled by the CAA G-NMCF Eurocopter AS355N Re-registered G-UBET
G-BUZR Lindstrand LBL 77A (HAB) Permanently withdrawn from use G-NUNI Lindstrand LBL 77A (HAB) Cancelled by the CAA
G-BVEA Mosler Motors N3 Pup Cancelled by the CAA G-PEEE Van’s RV-7 Re-registered G-PRKY
G-BVXA Cameron N-105 (HAB) Cancelled by the CAA G-PRPB DHC-8-402 Transferred to Nigeria as 5N-CCS
G-BXUO Lindstrand LBL 105A Permanently withdrawn from use G-PTCC Piper PA-28RT-201 Arrow IV Transferred to Republic of Ireland
G-BYYM X’Air 582(2) Cancelled by the CAA G-SDRY Cessna 525C CitationJet CJ4 Transferred to Isle of Man as M-JHCI
G-BZAK X’Air 582(9) Permanently withdrawn from use G-SGSG Bombardier Global 5000 Transferred to San Marino as T7-NEX
G-CCGM Kiss 450-582(2) Transferred to France G-SNOG Kiss 400-582(1) Permanently withdrawn from use
G-CCKM Mainair Pegasus Quik Transferred to Philippines G-THRE Cessna 182S Skylane Transferred to France
G-CCOT Cameron Z-105 (HAB) Transferred to Poland G-TOTN Cessna 210M Centurion Crashed at Bradda Head, IoM, 17 July 2023
G-CDDL Cameron Z-350 (HAB) Transferred to France G-TUKM Boeing 737-8K5 Transferred to Republic of Ireland as EI-FFA
G-CFKN Lindstrand GA22 MkII (HAB) Permanently withdrawn from use G-WNSE Sikorsky S-92A Transferred to Brazil as PR-CPX
G-CGBO Rolladen-Schneider LS6 Transferred to The Netherlands G-WUKH Airbus A321-231 Transferred to United Arab Emirates as A6-WAH
G-CGFH Cessna T182T Turbo Skylane Transferred to Sweden G-XINE PA-28-161 Cherokee Warrior II Transferred to USA
G-CHGN Easy Rider Spirit Cancelled by the CAA G-XXEC Agusta A109S Grand Transferred to India
G-CHUP Eurofox 912(S) Transferred to Norway G-YPSE Airbus EC130T-2 Transferred to USA
11.3 lb/sq ft and a power-to-weight ratio in total) and while replying to Steve I seconds. There is negligible adverse
of 13.2 lb/hp. As Saltby has an elevation accidentally change frequencies! This yaw. The stick-free stability is exactly
of 480ft, in the summer I always calculate causes mild consternation, confusion, as I remember it from my previous
the density altitude, but with an OAT of and some degree of irritation for a experience of the earlier model, being
+9°C, 25kt on the nose and a concrete minute or two, but I eventually work it a little weak directionally, positive
runway, I suspect takeoff performance out – and Keith and I use a lot of hand longitudinally and neutral laterally. The
The Sting’s tapered wings are swept mildly forward, their leading edges
being set at ninety degrees to the longitudinal axis of the fuselage
Two things distinguish the Sting S4’s wing: first, the unusually long split flaps; ... its short, broad ailerons, which are
and second... nonetheless highly effective
Dimensions
Length 6.2m
Height 2.05m
Wingspan 9.12m
Wing area 11.10sq m
Performance
Vne 144kt
Cruise 125kt
Stall, flaps down 43kt
Climb rate 1,100fpm
Takeoff over 50ft 405m
Land over 50ft 300m
Whilst the panel presents a vast ‘The stick top is liberally studded
amount of information, there’s with switches and buttons.’ There’s
room for improvement an obvious risk of confusion...
it’s actually dangerous. Take a look at fine view over the nose. The nosewheel (VNAV) on the right. Of course, there’s no
the picture above and you’ll instantly steers through the rudder pedals, and if autothrottle, so Neil recommends that I
see what I mean. At the very least it a very tight turn is required differential climb using a sensible cruise/climb IAS,
should be relocated to the side of braking can be applied via the toe- but descend using VS – vertical speed.
the throttle quadrant by the P1’s right operated hydraulic disc brakes. This is (The reason here is that if you tell it to
thigh. I’d also like ‘Master Caution’ and the best, which is why even the B787 has climb at say 750fpm, but the engine
‘Master Warn’ above the G3X. There’s toe-operated hydraulic disc brakes and subtly loses power, the AP will try and
so much information being displayed a steerable nosewheel. Many microlight maintain the vertical speed until the wing
it can get lost in the mix – and if the manufacturers install hand brakes as stalls). Of course, descending using VS
oil pressure is slowly dropping or the they’re lightweight, easy to make and also has a trap – and this is definitely one
coolant temperature of those occasions when
gradually rising I find that
subtle deviations aren’t
There’s so much information the throttle needs to be
your intention and not
so obvious as they are
with the big needles on
being displayed it can get your reaction: If you’re
zipping along straight-
steam gauges – hence my lost in the mix and-level and then
preference for attention select 600fpm down
getters. simple to fit, but I like toe brakes – without adjusting the throttle, you’ll be at
To be fair there’s plenty of stowage possibly because I have a lot of tailwheel Vne before you know it!
space in the pockets attached to the time, and taildraggers are easier if you Flying with Neil is great. He’s a very
cockpit sidewalls and you can also reach have good differential braking. patient instructor and I rapidly begin to
the baggage bay behind the seats which appreciate just how sophisticated the
can carry up to 25kg, but you can never TESTING THE AVIONICS systems are – and how they relieve
have too much! The big canopy has Neil shows me how to load a flight plan workload. Garmin’s products just keep
three latches – one on each side and a into the FMS and we’re soon launching getting better and the G3X has taken
centrally-located one that can be locked into a rather grey January sky. The the science of avionics to another level
with a key. Cockpit ventilation is good object of this flight is to test the avionics, entirely. It obviously has all the features
but there are no DV panels, which is so at 500ft I engage the autopilot. The we’ve become used to over the years,
unsatisfactory as the canopy obviously autopilot control panel is quite intuitive, but accessing them has become even
cannot be opened in flight. with the lateral (heading and track) easier due to the shallow menu structure.
Taxying is delightfully simple, with a functions on the left side and vertical As with all things digital, you must sit
Lovely to fly, the Sting S4 is also capable of flying itself nicely on its autopilot – as Dave says, equally at home at Heathrow
Airport or Hedgerow Farm
, -
. ’ .
l
Hose Specialists in Fixed and Rotorwing
Applications for General Aviation,
Business and Defence
DA42-VI It's easy to fly and burns fuel like a single, but with
the added safety of a second engine. Impressive
cross-country performance is great for private
pilots and business owners, while the low operating
costs make it the ideal advanced trainer.
[email protected]
+44 1777 805 001
BEA House London Wycombe Air Park Marlow Buckinghamshire SL7 3DP
+44 (0)1494 556925 | BEAplc.com | [email protected]
Tim Cooper
ONLY
£8.99
SUBSCRIBERS don’t forget to use your
£2 OFF DISCOUNT CODE!
IF YOU ARE INTERESTED IN HISTORIC AVIATION YOU MAY ALSO WANT TO ORDER...
COLD
L
IGHTNING
CIA
SPE SUE FINITIVE GUIDE TO THE ENGLISH ELECTRIC IGH-RESOLUTION ENHANCED COLOURISATIONS
W
B HA
IS
NE
FROM THE
MAKERS OF
SUPERSONIC COLD WAR INTERCEPTOR
From the makers of
CUBAN STAND-OFF
SHOW STOPPING
CROWD-PLEASER 100s OF NEVER-S
PICTURES, EXPERTLY BRO
FIERCE FIGHTER
IN AIR DEFENCE
DOUGLAS X-PLANES
ARABIAN LIGHTNINGS
THE FOURTH V-BOMBER
£8.99 £8.99 £8.99 £8.99
FIRESTREAKER
AT MACH 2 T AI
SOVIET’S MIGHTY FOXBAT • USA’S SUPERSONIC SR
038/24
Airmail
Airmail
Your e-mails, thoughts, comments and news
STAR LETTER
silentpooldistillers.com has joined
Pilot to present our Star Letter writer
the gloriously indulgent prize of a
litre bottle each of Pan Am gin and
vodka in a Pan Am building
presentation boox
It’s EC to deceive
On Wednesday this week (27 February), I was looking in the dark, over open ground, and I concluded that it
on glideandseek.com to see if there was any activity at was most likely on a drone, had been in a car for the
my gliding club, the weather being rather dodgy and the ‘flight’ from Surrey to London, and that the glider owner
field probably too soggy from the recent heavy rain. I had used the glider’s EC device to make the drone
looked to see what else was going on in the Southeast. visible. Having the it transmitting whilst on the road was
I was surprised to see a Flarm (i.e. electronic conspicuity probably an oversight.
or EC – Ed) trace running from somewhere in Surrey, The Spring Pilot mag arrived on Thursday, and I read
right into the centre of London. It was identifying as with interest Tim Cooper’s column on how we all will
an LS3 glider, complete with its registration, the route have to get used to EC, and how EC needs to get its act
seeming to stick to roads, and crossing the Thames together. Plenty of food for thought. It struck me that we
at Southwark Bridge, and to Rosebery Avenue, where will be coming to rely on the integrity of the EC devices
it seemed to be manoeuvring at well below glider to help us get a proper picture of the environment we
airspeeds, and at very low altitude. Obviously not a fly in. If the EC on our moving map shows a glider,
glider in a trailer then! My first guess was that someone then we will be looking for a glider, and reacting
had a Flarm device activated in a car, or perhaps a bike. accordingly – similarly for any other contact. It also
However, following its progress during the afternoon struck me that EC could be used intentionally to hide
and early evening, it returned by more or less the same the true identity of an aircraft to avoid detection! The
route to its origin in Surrey (which was in the area of implications are worrying.
the address of the registered owner of the LS3 Glider
from G-INFO), it once again manoeuvred for a while, Roger Gregory, Plumstead
Air-to-air advice
appreciated Chris Fopp took part in this formation paying tribute to the late Queen, flying his
Bulldog G-BZXZ/XX629
I’ve been exceptionally fortunate to know getting the aircraft in the correct setting, went rusty in the late ’90s. I now have
Keith Wilson for a large portion of my as seen in our tribute to the late Queen – various medical conditions that may
life and even more so in recent years, a poignant flight where almost all pilots well prevent me from flying P1 again,
having been in a number of formations and crew had served her in one form or and with that in mind, I thought about
he’s taken photos of. I’ve been slowly another. We were certainly working hard, setting up a sim of some sorts at home.
accumulating an understanding of how to and our A game showed – possibly one Unfortunately, I am something of a
fly a camera ship for other photographers of my most rewarding flights. technophobe and I haven’t the faintest
too – and like all aviation beyond the idea of where to start.
norm, it is very rewarding. So, to open up Chris Fopp, owner of I have seen technology accelerate
the latest Pilot magazine this morning to Bulldog G-BZXZ/XX629 phenomenally over the years. Modern
find a brilliant article by him about air-to- light aircraft cockpits look incredible. My
air photography with one of my favourite thoughts here, and I’m sure I’m not alone
pictures – one that I’d like to recreate, are, would it be a worthy subject for a
the University of London Air Squadron
formation – made my day.
A plea for few articles in Pilot on how to purchase,
set up, operate a sim and what options
I know I echo all my Bulldog and more sim coverage are out there to purchase and so on etc.
Chipmunk pilot colleagues when I say we etc? The choice is amazing I believe.
not only enjoy seeing Keith’s pictures but I have been an avid subscriber to Pilot Thank you for a wonderful magazine,
enjoy learning from him in our preflight ever since I gained my PPL in 1988. An
briefings and debriefs afterwards. excellent magazine, if I may say so. I Paul Smith, Sible Hedingham,
One of the points highlighted was have nearly 300 hours, but the licence Halstead, Essex
PUSH TO TALK
Testing Times
“T
here’s no such thing time I began to realise something wasn’t up enough courage for a circuit. All
as a routine test right, it suddenly levitated in a three- seemed fine – stability was no longer
flight.” Whoever said point attitude. Intending to fly along just an issue, control around all three axes
that wasn’t wrong, for above the ground, I checked forward felt acceptable and even the 300fpm
sometimes even the on the stick, but the nose kept rising! climb rate was more than I’d hoped for,
most innocuous-looking machine can Distinctly alarmed, I slammed the throttle so on the next flight I laboriously clawed
bite. Sitting on the runway bathed in shut and the contraption flopped untidily my way up to 3,000ft for a look at both
the soft light of a summer evening, the onto the ground, much to my relief. ends of the speed scale. Slow flight
aircraft didn’t look particularly sinister, Taxying slowly back (remember, it was amazing, as it finally and reluctantly
yet I still regarded it with a slightly didn’t have brakes) while my pulse rate stalled at about 20-22kt. With a Vne of
jaundiced air. It was a T.31M, the bastard subsided, I was determined to ascertain only 69kt, describing the next part of
offspring of an ex-ATC Kirby Cadet what was wrong, although I already had the flight test as ‘high speed’ sounds
Mk.III, which at some time in its life had a fair idea. Then I sensed that something, somewhat dramatic, but the mongrel
been converted into a single-seat motor somewhere, had shifted – and within thing hadn’t finished scaring me yet!
glider. Bright yellow with a thick black seconds the nose started to drift left, Of course, I approached this part of
‘racing stripe’ down the fuselage, the towards the fence paralleling the runway. the test very cautiously and increased
myriad modifications included installing Quick – right rudder! Nothing happened. the speed in five-knot increments. This
a small engine and fuel tank where the The nose kept going left, because the proved prudent, because as the speed
front cockpit had been, and replacing tailwheel steering had disconnected. I went through about 60kt on the third
the monowheel, nose and tail skids lunged for the mag switch but a collision dive, the aircraft began to roll almost
with a more conventional tailwheel seemed inevitable, so opted for full right imperceptibly to the left. ‘Slight lateral
arrangement. It had been discovered by rudder, a brief blast of power – and the instability,’ I noted, while moving the
one of the more senior members of the left wing passed over the fence as the stick to the right. Nothing happened. I
club rotting away in a barn, and along thing pirouetted ungracefully around. moved the stick further to the right, and
with an accomplice of similar vintage, he Heartbeat once again back down to a it continued rolling lethargically to the
had retrieved it, restored it, and now all normal level and engine off, it was towed left. Once again, I slammed the throttle
the duo needed was an idiot to test-fly it. back for a ‘Come to Jesus’ meeting closed, and as it decelerated regained
Of course, I said yes. lateral control, crept
The motor was I checked forward on the stick, but the carefully down
particularly intriguing. Most and landed.
T.31Ms are powered by nose kept rising! Distinctly alarmed, Closer inspection
repurposed VW Beetle
engines, but this one had
I slammed the throttle shut revealed that although
everything felt and looked
a 500cc Fuji Robin, a two-stroke inverted with the two old timers. After much right during ‘positive’ and ‘full & free’
twin originally designed for small head-scratching, chin-stroking, musing, checks, if the stick was held rigid, both
industrial applications. Maximum power analysing and pontificating, it was ailerons could still move independently if
wasn’t very much, and was achieved at determined that instead of using a a bit more force was applied! There was
a heady 6,000rpm, although a reduction datum point forward of the leading quite a lot of slack in the aileron circuit,
gear kept the propeller speed down to edge for the W & B calculations, they and at (relatively) high speeds both
a more sensible 2,500. The combination had started from aft of the leading edge. ailerons were being sucked up in the low
of a pylon-mounted 13.2m wing and a Consequently, the centre of gravity pressure area above the wing, but the
narrow-track undercarriage made it was somewhere around the tailplane left aileron had slightly more travel.
quite ungainly on the ground, and just (I exaggerate for comic effect, but you Eventually we sorted it all out – but I
to make it interesting, it had three get the general idea). never really enjoyed flying that T.31M. It
wheels but no brakes. Having sorted out the W & B and really was one of those machines that
After a few hearty pulls on the recoil reconnected the tailwheel steering ‘could just barely kill you’.
starter the Fuji burst into life, and I in a more secure fashion, I foolishly
gingerly trundled out, intending to initially returned to the field the following
try a straight-line ‘test hop’ on the 800m week for another attempt DAVE UNWIN
runway. Opening the throttle produced at persuading this curious Pilot’s Flight Test Editor
more noise than thrust, and as the aircraft contrivance into the air. Initially operates a Jodel D.9 from
‘gathered way’ I eased the stick forward. all went well. The little engine a farm strip and has logged
stick-time on everything from
Nothing happened and the tailwheel buzzed busily, and after a ultralights to fast jets
stayed stuck to the runway. About the couple of test-hops I summoned
Words:
Robin Evans
RIGHT:
Pictured in 1948, a
youthful Sqn Ldr
Jack Hemmings AFC
OPPOSITE:
Jack today, at the
grand old age of 102
V
eteran pilot, ex-RAF honour his wartime service in the 80th
Squadron Leader and anniversary year of D-Day and remember
Mission Aviation Fellowship his late friend, MAF co-founder and
(MAF) co-founder Jack D-Day veteran Stuart King, who passed
Hemmings AFC has away in 2020.
remained connected to the skies. On 5 “Getting in the Spitfire gave all the
February, he also disproved the adage same pleasant feelings of being above
there are no old, bold pilots, flying in the ground, where you can leave behind
Spitfire MT818 at the age 102, thought to all the problems of the world,” said
be the oldest pilot to do so. Jack, born in Bentham, Yorkshire on 10
The special event was courtesy of Fly August, 1921. “210 knots was faster than
a Spitfire (flyaspitfire.com), Biggin Hill to my RAF flying days. I was surprised by
how heavy the controls were, but that’s back and no one commented on the
probably because I’m just a bit rusty. length of that particular circuit!’
It was rather bumpy up there, but the The Blenheim at RAF Upwood,
overall experience really was absolutely Cambridgeshire came next. “The Mk.IV
delightful.” [had] an elongated nose to make a
navigator’s office and a backward firing
OPERATIONS IN INDIA gun [that] seemed to rob its sparkle.
This was the latest escapade to go in Upwood was a bit like a speed-dating
the logbook since Jack learned to fly event. It was here we met navigators and
in 1940. “I was nineteen years old and wireless-operators/gunners and were
volunteered for aircrew. When I first told to form ourselves into crews.’
joined the RAF I thought, ‘If I am going Instead of orders to Bomber
to fight, I may as well do it sitting down!’” Command, Jack’s cohort was dispatched
He learned to fly the Tiger Moth at to RAF Oulton, Norfolk for training on
Marshall’s, Cambridge and the Airspeed the Lockheed Hudson. ‘Converted to
Oxford at Little Rissington. ‘Selection warplanes by the addition of gun turrets
tests had put me in the multi-engine and bomb racks. They still retained their
(plodding) stream, not in the single soundproofing and automatic pilots and
engine (dashing) stream,’ wrote Jack in a were very comfortable.’ Ground-looping
wartime account provided by MAF. was the Hudson’s Achilles’ Heel. ‘The
Jack confesses he and the Oxford turret at the back was a big, heavy affair,
didn’t quite gel, after a night circuits it made it a bit difficult to control on the
mishap. Climbing crosswind he lost ground… Often the broken undercarriage
sight of the flarepath. ‘Whether a leg would go up into the wing and burst
patch of cloud had intervened or I had the petrol tank, so a ground loop and
wandered off track, I don’t know, but I broken undercarriage, [ending up] on fire
was suddenly alone with no radio and was not rare.’
nothing but blackness around me… my After six weeks, orders arrived to
first experience of real fear when the ferry the Hudsons to Calcutta. ‘A simple
realisation dawns you’ve got to sort a enough task but not without hazards
problem out alone. I did find my way when carried out by inexperienced
Jack peers out from the rear cockpit of Fly a Spitfire’s Biggin Hill based T9
during his flight in February this year
FATEFUL MOMENT
While in India in 1945, one of the airmen
at his Delhi station discovered a copy
of the Mildmay Outlook, a Christian
PHOTO: MAF
Back home by 1946, Jack’s CPL and a healthy dose of humour. Stuart aircraft across 25 low-income countries,
conversion was thwarted on eyesight and Jack established connections with delivering aid, medical care and
grounds. “This left future plans looking remote mission stations, confirming the emergency evacuations in some of the
rather blank,” he said, instead visiting the only way to deliver life-saving help in world’s most isolated locations.
one room, Islington office of the Mildmay the wilderness was via air. Small aircraft
Movement – the forerunner of MAF. The could save days of travel on treacherous CONNECTIONS
MAF men believed that wartime had or non-existent roads. Jack began a career in accountancy, but
given them a skill that could serve peace, Returning to Nairobi in July, 1948, the remained connected to MAF through his
even if missionary services remained Gemini was climbing through the valleys unyielding friendship with Stuart King. He
sceptical of their realism without military of the Burundi Foothills when caught returned to flying in retirement and flew
resources. in a downdraught, clipping a tree. “The privately for twenty years, winning the
“I went in for two weeks and stayed war had accustomed us to crashes, 1985 Dungeness – Le Touquet race and
for four years,” said Jack, appointed disasters and the unexpected. But this training in aerobatics.
Chief Pilot of the first MAF survey flight was different,” observed Stuart. “This “Getting into an aeroplane gives a
from Croydon on 13 January 1948. wrecked plane was not one of thousands sense of pleasant expectation, I’ve never
Accompanying him in their 1947 Miles of military aircraft. It’s broken remains got into one and regretted it,” he says.
Gemini was MAF co-founder and RAF symbolised our own shattered hopes.” “I love flying because it gives a feeling
Engineer Stuart King. The pair plotted a “Neither of us were injured except a of detachment from all the problems
route through Libya, Egypt and Sudan bruise and a cut on my little finger,” Jack in the world – and there are a lot.
using the Nile as a guide, the first British revealed, confessing the affectionate During wartime, aircraft were used for
airmen to survey the needs of isolated nickname ‘Crasher Jack’ stuck. Despite destruction; but it has always been my
Central Africa. this, the pioneering sortie launched desire that they be used for good. That
It was an adventure of a lifetime, the world’s largest humanitarian air is what MAF does today, it is more than
embraced with fearless determination service. Today, the charity operates 118 a bright idea that stayed in someone’s
PHOTO: MAF
Jack returned to flying in retirement and flew privately for twenty years, winning the 1985 Dungeness – Le Touquet race. He marked
his 100th year with an aerobatic flight in a Slingsby Firefly from White Waltham, piloted by Nigel Rhind
head, it has grown to become the Good meeting folk from MAF and the BBC to of his adventures across Africa in the tiny
Samaritan of the air.” see the Gemini and watch my flight in the Gemini, but when you see footage from
His adventures are all the more Robin I used to co-own was thoroughly those times, it really is very impressive.
remarkable after emergency heart enjoyable.” He received a smoke salute At the age of 25 he flew thousands
surgery in 2020. “Jack is an awesome, from the Red Arrows as they overflew his of miles across uncharted territory. It’s
amazing man,” says wife, Kate. “He is home on his 102nd birthday, commenting quite extraordinary. It has been a very
the oldest patient to have received this it made him feel like the King. wonderful day and he has achieved so
operation and we believe the motto In November 2023, Jack spoke at a many inspiring things. We should never
‘Fear Not’ from his 353 Squadron days, MAF event at the RAF Museum, reunited take that for granted.”
along with firm Christian faith has helped with the Hudson for the first time in fifty RAF Chief Chaplain, Air Vice-Marshal
him through.” years. “Flying the Hudson was very Giles Legood was among the guests
A contender for oldest invited to celebrate
Briton still flying, Jack
returns skyward for an
“It’s not incredible being 102. Jack’s achievement. He
said: “It was wonderful
annual treat. His 2021
centenary involved
You just get up every day and to see this inspirational
man fulfilling one of his
aerobatics in a Slingsby go about your business...” dreams. Having helped
Firefly at White Waltham. win the peace as a WWII
Jack was then reunited with the Miles comfortable indeed,” he said. “A nicely pilot, Jack was a huge force for good in
at Shuttleworth in March 2022, flying in balanced aircraft with all the American co-founding MAF, which has changed the
Stu Blanchard’s Gemini at a MAF event mod-cons. If you’re going to spend eight lives of countless millions in delivering
in memory of late friend and co-founder hours looking at salt water, you want to humanitarian aid.”
Stuart King. He made the BBC News, be comfortable. It’s wonderful to see the When asked how he maintains so
raising £40,000 for MAF. Lockheed again – just like old times.” much energy into his centenary, Jack
He met the Gemini again on his 101st Flying alongside the Spitfire in the concluded: “It’s not incredible being 102.
birthday later that year at Spilstead accompanying chaser was proud son You just get up every day and go about
Farm, Kent, flying in a Robin DR400 with Adrian. “Dad had a few bad crashes your business. It’s the present moment
his son-in-law. Jack said: “There were during the war and the early days of which counts – and this one was very
whispers yesterday about a surprise, but MAF. We’ve been brought up on stories special indeed.”
FREE
Scan the QR code or visit our website
below to order your FREE copy.
20
RRP £
Please allow 21 days for delivery
www.maf-uk.org/beyond
Registered charity in England and Wales (1064598) and in Scotland (SC039107) ® Registered trademark 3026860, 3026908, 3026915
Jonathan Buckmaster
Bob Grimstead
AIRWAYS
The rebranded Airshows 2024 ‘Old Timers’). Built by Cross made its first flight on 2002, subsequently landed
Downunder Shellharbour Famous Australian Aircraft at 14 August 1987. Unfortunately, on effectively one wheel and
(previously Wings over Parafield in South Australia, it shed its starboard main badly damaged its starboard
Illawarra) organised by the reproduction Southern wheel strut on take-off in May wing. HARS acquired the
the AMDA Foundation at
Shellharbour Regional Airport
in New South Wales on 1-3 2
March 2024 was an excellent
warbird gathering, reports
‘Pilot’s’ Antipodean traveller,
Nigel Hitchman.
The highlights included
two quite different ‘Southern
Crosses’: one, the resident
Historical Aircraft Restoration
Society’s (HARS) record-
setting 1926 Fokker
FVIIB/3m VH-USU replica
[1], the other, Paul Bennet’s
newly-imported Sea Fury
FB11 VH-HPB [2] (see March
PHOTO: FIO
FIO President Carlos Valle completing preflight checks before making Aeronca 100 EC-NZI/G-AEXD’s first Spanish flight
The Fundación Infante de provided Pilot with more Aeronca for a while on the stayed close to the ground
Orleans’ (FIO) 1937 Aeronca information on this vintage terrain runway and, satisfied for a while before climbing to
100 EC-NZI/G-AEXD took light-plane’s long-awaited first with its performance on the circuit altitude (3000 ft ASL)
to the air at Cuatro Vientos Spanish flight. Foundation ground, decided to go ahead. for three circuits. After landing,
on 20 February 2024. FIO President Carlos Valle, he After obtaining authorisation Carlos smiled and commented
administrator Darío Pozo said, ‘was taxying with the from the tower, he took off and that “it flies very well”.
Replica Plans SE5a G-SEVA The irrepressible Gregory saluted Sheffield’s famous Endcliffe Park was arranged
has been ‘retired’ to the displayed it at airshows with memorial to B-17G Flying for the eightieth anniversary
Montrose Air Station Heritage the team until 2012, then the Fortress 42-31322 Mi of Mi Amigo’s crash there
Centre in Angus. Built by following year made one last Amigo and its ever-devoted while returning from its final
Great War Display Team flight (loop included!) for his caretaker, eighty-seven- daylight bombing mission to
founder and longest-serving ninetieth birthday. Ownership year-old Tony Foulds, with RAF Chelveston, Northants
member, the late Ivan ‘Doug’ of the aeroplane was a low and noisy flypast by (see ‘Old Timers’ April 2019).
Gregory, the seven-eighths transferred to the G-SEVA two F-15E Strike Eagles on Schiphol-based DDA
scale SE5a made its first Trust in August 2013. 22 February 2024. Their Classic Airlines, which
flight on 16 September 1987. The present-day USAF dramatic appearance over operates D-Day and Arnhem
veteran DC-3C PH-PBA
Prinses Amalia is to cease
flying on 1 October 2024,
after forty years in business.
It is becoming prohibitively
costly to hangar and insure
the aeroplane, the operator
explained, especially since
PHOTO: PETER R MARCH
End of the road for the Skymaster Trust and its C-54 56498/N44914’s restoration to flight at North Weald
Winter maintenance on Swordfish W5856, with its engine away for examination by Retro Track and Air at Cam, Glos
PHOTO: PETER R MARCH
PHOTO: ANDREW MARCH
Flight Tests
Our experts put you in the pilot’s seat of everything from the
latest ultralight to historic warplanes
REASONS TO
SUBSCRIBE
1 Delivery to
your home
2 Receive our
weekly newsletter
3 FREE Where to
Fly Guide mailed
to you annually
4 Save up to 45%
off the full price*
NEVER
MISS AN
ISSUE!
SUBSCRIBE TODAY
Print only subscriptions.
Visit https://pilotweb.aero/subscribe/
Call 01858 438741
Or Scan the QR code to order.
Y
Visiting France in a ou may think aviation is ex-
pensive, but it doesn’t have
pair of vintage aircraft to be. My sixty flying years
sans electrics? With a have been dedicated to
minimum outlay. Our two aer-
bit of imagination and oplanes cost £6,000 in 1988 and £15,000
ingenuity, it can be in 2008. They were comparatively cheap
because neither has electrics and there-
done – and done at fore neither has a starter motor – nor
minimal expense does either have any avionics. I share
a single Icom handheld portable radio
between them, significantly reducing the
Words: licence fee.
But this lack of electrics doesn’t
Bob Grimstead prevent me from flying all around Europe.
You may remember my March 2014
article on touring Norway and Sweden
by Fournier. I have also flown to many
displays in France and Germany. But until
this year I hadn’t felt comfortable taking
our two-seat Champ, Champie abroad.
But now its engine has been zero-timed
I felt confident to cross the English
Channel, and of course SkyDemon takes
care of all the bureaucratic requirements
nowadays, so it’s easy.
Twenty-first Century European touring
without avionics requires nothing but a
little courage and a smartphone. But don’t
mount it in the panel, on your yoke or in
your lap. Put it high in your windscreen
so you can still see outside while using it.
Collisions kill!
Most Fournier enthusiasts belong to
Club Fournier International (CFI). Twice-
yearly they get together for a grand tour,
flying, feasting and camaraderie. René
Fournier usually attends. 2023’s event
was a mass circuit of Brittany ending at La
Baule on France’s west coast. I couldn’t
undertake the whole Brittany tour but
Heading out
across the
Channel, Karen’s
view of Bob’s
‘Wagon’ from the
back seat of
the Champ
PHOTO: BOB GRIMSTEAD
PHOTO: KAREN GRIMSTEAD
intended joining them at La Baule. Pilot contributor Manuel Queiroz. He charts, documents, smokes, pyrotechnics,
My Fournier RF4D Wagon (RedHawk was kind enough to make up a portable tools, spares, pickets and cover, Wagon
when it’s displaying) has only one seat, so assembly. Of course, it didn’t have Mode was well laden. Jon and I packed smaller
I persuaded long-time friend Jon Marten- C or ADS-B because without electrics I items in our overalls, and on the first leg
Hale to take my wife Karen in Champie couldn’t have an encoding altimter. we wore our lifejackets.
on this four-day, eight-leg journey. I already had an antenna in one of Departing from our Guildford airstrip
Knowing only the bigger French airport Wagon’s under-belly inspection panels. on Thursday 7 Sept, the weather was
controllers speak English, I mugged up a A gell-cell battery went on the floor and I perfect, with blue sky and a slight
few French aviation phrases and took a slung the main unit under the instrument easterly breeze, but the day was warm.
crib-sheet. panel crossmember with a pair of cable Nevertheless, Wagon’s performance was
ties so the whole lot could be removed reasonable. Jon and Karen in Champie
TRANSPONDER REQUIRED quickly for aerobatics. With clothes, below eased gently into the air and
Most French airfields, particularly
those with Customs facilities, require
transponders nowadays, so I bought a
second-hand Garmin unit through fellow
PHOTO: JONATHAN MARTEN-HALE
I dived down alongside to set off in remembered 123.450 for inter-pilot them for Cessnas and Pipers too.
formation south around Gatwick’s zone. chats. Why Britain doesn’t, I have no We climbed high for the Channel
I normally cruise at 105mph, but idea. I suspect some lazy bureaucrat crossing; SkyDemon assured us that
Champie is more comfortable at 85 and skulking in his lair said “Boo-hoo, that Wagon could glide engine-out to either
that’s a good sightseeing speed. side from the middle and
As former professionals, Jon
and I used CRM to our strengths.
Fortunately the enlightened Champie could go almost
as far. Le Touquet ATC was
ecisio a d the
French have a frequency v y
t
u, u v
oast direct to final
r dedicated to Fourniers m l
n ra
n n
FRATERNITY AND
FIREWORKS were approaching Britain from the west have adequate obstacle clearance. But
Over the weekend we had the best and Tuesday looked absolutely unflyable, our lifejackets were in the baggage
possible time with our Belgian, French, so we planned to leave early on Monday compartments. Oh well, hitting an
Finnish and German chums. Nearly morning. obstacle was a more likely hazard than
a hundred CFI members attended, We had to wait while ground staff dealt ditching a wooden aeroplane, and with
flying more than thirty Fourniers. On with another departing airliner, and the more serious consequences. Cloud
the Saturday evening, I flew a twilight cloudbase was reported as 1,500 feet, bases varied from 1,200 to 800 feet,
pyrotechnics display (see ‘Fournier but when we got airborne it seemed although the visibility below was good,
Fireworks’, Pilot January). rather less. We did at least get good but the many seaside resorts with their
On Sunday, after queuing for fuel, we views of Honfleur as we flew over. myriad beach huts looked bleak under
left at noon. Now the threatening
confident we could
safely fly for at least
The many seaside resorts... looked overcast.
Our looming
two hours, and with bleak under the threatening overcast problem came via
a gentle tailwind, a text message
we skipped Rennes, routeing direct to We were again cleared via the delicate from Matt Hill in Sussex forecasting a
Deauville in a comfortable 2:10. tracery of le Pont du Normandie and to line of Cunimbs advancing northwards
I had texted Benôit with our ETA, the east of Le Havre. We then deviated across Normandy, probably those
and he met us outside the terminal from our planned route by turning left and troughs depicted on yesterday’s charts.
with his Tesla. On our way into town following the coast, initially just inland, but Le Touquet Tower again came up trumps,
he delightedly demonstrated its as we encountered lower clouds we flew despite poor radio reception because of
acceleration. Once checked in, we did just offshore of the Etretat cliffs, which our low height, clearing us direct to base
more sightseeing, liking this quaint and looked rather less white than they had in leg. As we turned off the runway,
colourful little town ever better with each the sunshine five days earlier. he asked, “For parking, how long will
visit. We would have liked to stay another We routed out to sea around that you be staying?” Given the weather
day to see the art galleries and museums, nuclear power station because the cloud we’d just flown through, Jon replied,
but a couple of nasty-looking cold fronts was too low over land to be sure we’d “We will be staying overnight.”
Low cloud out to sea close to Deauville-Le Touquet: not what you want to see when
contemplating a Channel crossing
Google map shows the route flown by Bob’s Fournier ‘Wagon’ in the company of his
Champ carrying Karen and flown by Jon
But after shutting do , I trotted over although he w uld break for lunch t 1330 just u the band between 1, 00ft an
’
there were fine as the were ever where transmittin blind and he would activate ettin home?
else in southern England. I reckoned that our flight plan. In the event, he not only did In fact, b the time we approached
if we refuelled and cleared immigration that but stayed on duty while we started, Ambleteuse the weather had cleared
quickly, we should get away before the taxied out, took off and disappeared into significantly, so we climbed to 6,000 feet
, . .
chance this low cloud would clear we were beyond radio range. pretty sight, but we were lad to ee it.
somewhere over the Channel. Jon Now we encounter the dangerous Over those five days, our no-
,
and shot off to pay landing fees and our side of the Channel. The French are single operational hiccup, mainly
empty our bladders. decent enough to limit the top of their thanks to SkyDemon’s comprehensive
drone airspace grab to 500 feet, a height capabilities. Careful husbandry ensured
SUPERLATIVE SUPPORT below which we would never fly anyway. the smartphone batteries lasted through
I phoned the tower to check they had But the British have stolen airspace from each day’s flying. There was still plenty
our flight plan filed via SkyDemon surface up to 1,500 feet across three- of power left in the transponder’s battery,
PH TO: BOB GRIMSTEAD
that morning, and to see if they would quarters of the Channel, giving us the and my Icom only died fifteen minutes
let us go. Again their assistance was choice of either riskily entering cloud before landing back at base.
superlative, the controller explaining with no gyro instruments or penetrating That trip was so succes ul we’ve
that we could legally depart with cloud th .
rr n l
‘
QFI LOGBOOK
assume that the canopy of the aircraft requires any technical ‘this scenario can be ruled out since it does not explain how
modifications, as a mere precautionary measure the the locking mechanism opened and released the remaining
carbon fibre canopy frame shall be further improved and parts of the canopy frame. It is incomprehensible [that] the
strengthened by reworking of the adhesive glue bonding continuing air flow loads on the pieces of the broken canopy
between the inner and outer canopy frame’. frame attached to that section wrenched the shoot bolts out
The AAIB concluded that the canopy of the aircraft of their roller lugs, as… described in the [AAIB] analysis. Any
suffered a catastrophic failure in flight due to fatigue cracking airflow during forward flight will create strong forces directed…
of the acrylic transparency. The cracking was initiated by aft, which will force the locking mechanism into the locked
differential forces acting on the canopy frame, induced by position and not open it.
inadequate bonding between the inner and outer frame. This, ‘Taking all facts into account, especially the undamaged
in turn, caused localised stresses being imparted into the shoot bolts and lugs, it is most probable that the canopy
transparency, presenting conditions which promoted fatigue was not completely locked prior to the flight and the locking
crack development. This resulted in a catastrophic failure of mechanism opened completely at some point, due to air loads
the canopy when cracks reached a critical length. and vibration. Even if one would expect that such an event
However, the Bundesstelle für Flugunfalluntersuchung would more likely occur during aerobatic flight, it is anything
(BFU, the German Federal Bureau of Accident Investigation) but unlikely during level flight. Finally, the draft does not
representing the state of design and manufacture, does include any facts which contradict this scenario”. Considering
not agree with the analysis resulting in a scenario of a the cockpit design and the experience of the pilot, the BFU
canopy failure in flight, due to fatigue cracking of the acrylic agreed that it is quite unlikely that the pilot opened the
transparency. In its rebuttal of the AAIB’s conclusions, it said canopy inadvertently.
Slow in a Sukhoi
Aircraft Type: Sukhoi SU-29 field to the side of the runway. The passenger was able
Date & Time: 16 September 2023 at 1310 to free herself from the aircraft, but the pilot required
Commander’s Flying Experience: PPL, 1,950 hours assistance. Both escaped with only minor injuries.
(of which 600 were on type) The pilot reported that he did not know what
Last 90 days: 5 hours happened and believed there was nothing wrong with
Last 28 days: 5 hours the aircraft. He thought he must have let the airspeed
reduce on short final. He reported he had been flying
The aircraft was making an approach to Runway 09 the aircraft for fifteen years so could not understand why
at Andrewsfield Aerodrome. The pilot sat in the rear he would have allowed this to happen. The passenger
seat and the passenger, who was a recently qualified reported that the approach had seemed normal until the
pilot, sat in the front. Airfield CCTV showed that as the wing dropped.
aircraft approached the runway the left wing dropped. ‘It is likely the airspeed reduced on short final causing
The wingtip struck the ground causing the aircraft to the left wing to stall and the aircraft to roll to the left,’
cartwheel and it came to rest inverted in a ploughed concluded the AAIB.
Sirius misjudgement
Aircraft Type: TL-3000 Sirius 600 the runway was ‘somewhat impaired’. Despite the
Date & Time: 10 August 2023 at 0800 poor acceleration, the takeoff was continued and the
Commander’s Flying Experience: NPPL, 252 hours aircraft briefly left the ground but settled back on the
(of which 49 were on type) runway twice, before becoming airborne much further
Last 90 days: 24 hours down the runway than anticipated. Once airborne the
Last 28 days: 4 hours aircraft ‘would not accelerate’ and the stall warning
horn sounded continuously. Having only attained a
The pilot intended to fly to Blackpool Airport with a height of ten to fifteen feet, the aircraft rolled to the
passenger. He elected to take off using the slightly left and struck the ground. Damage to the aircraft was
uphill Runway 26, as the wind was calm and the extensive and hindered the pilot’s egress from the
runway was aligned with his intended direction of wreckage, but only minor injuries were sustained by
travel. The temperature was 21°C, the dewpoint 16°C the pilot and passenger, who were both wearing full
and the aircraft’s weight and centre of gravity were harnesses.
within limits. On application of full power, the pilot No definitive cause was established for the aircraft’s
reported that the engine rpm indicator and engine poor acceleration, but the use of a ‘stop-go’ point and
sound were consistent with the engine delivering takeoff decision making is covered in the UK CAA’s GA
full power, but he noticed that the acceleration along update of January 2023.
www.seht.co.uk
Calendar
Compiled by Paul Fiddian
To see the
monthly calendar
online, visit
www.pilotweb.aero
Remember to check with the organiser before setting out – events may be changed at short notice
Air-Britain’s traditional
fly-in will this year be part
of Private Flyer Fest at
Wycombe Air Park
on 17-18 May
Collection’s stunning
Hawker Fury that will
make its Old Warden
debut (and post-
pandemic return)
on 12 May
JUNE 2024
1 Halfpenny Green-
Wolverhampton, W Midlands,
Gyro Record-Breaker 2024,
britishrotorcraftassociation.org/
TO SUBSCRIBE :
GO TO SHOP.KELSEY.CO.UK/NPW
OR USE THIS QR CODE TO GO DIRECTLY
TO OUR WEBSITE
*UK DIRECT DEBIT OFFER ONLY. SAVINGS BASED ON THE STANDARD BASIC ANNUAL RATE OF £104.88 WHICH INCLUDES THE COVER PRICE OF £5.99 PLUS KELSEY MEDIA’S
STANDARD POSTAGE AND PACKING PRICE PER SINGLE ISSUE FOR ONE FULL YEAR (12 ISSUES). YOU WILL PAY £57.50 PER YEAR. OFFER ENDS 31ST DECEMBER 2024. YOUR
SUBSCRIPTION WILL START WITH THE NEXT AVAILABLE ISSUE AND YOU WILL RECEIVE 12 ISSUES IN A YEAR. PRICES CORRECT AT TIME OF PRINT AND SUBJECT TO CHANGE. FOR
FULL TERMS AND CONDITIONS, VISIT SHOP.KELSEY.CO.UK/TERMS. IF YOU DECIDE TO CANCEL YOUR SUBSCRIPTION WE WILL PUT A STOP TO ANY FURTHER PAYMENTS BEING
TAKEN AND WILL SEND THE REMAINING ISSUES THAT YOU HAVE ALREADY PAID FOR. FOR OFFERS OUTSIDE THE UK VISIT SHOP.KELSEY.CO.UK/NPW. DATA PROTECTION: WE TAKE
GREAT CARE IN HANDLING YOUR PERSONAL DETAILS AND THESE WILL ONLY EVER BE USED AS SET OUT IN OUR PRIVACY POLICY WHICH CAN BE VIEWED AT
SHOP.KELSEY.CO.UK/PRIVACY-POLICY
Calendar
5 Twente, Netherlands, Aero 25-26 Augusta Regional Airport, 1-2 Terre Haute Regional 9 RDAF Aalborg, Denmark,
Club 60th Anniversary Fly-in, nvav. Augusta, Georgia, USA, Augusta Airport, Terra Haute, Indiana, Danish Air Show,
nl/activiteiten/fly-vliegveld-twente Air Show, augustaairshow.com USA, Terre Haute Air Show, forsvaret.dk/danishairshow
11 Muret-Lherm, Toulouse, 25-26 Central Coast facebook.com/terrehauteairshow 14-16 Greenwood Lake Airport,
France, AirExpo, airexpo.org Airport, NSW, Australia, 1-2 Pardubice Airport, West Milford, New Jersey, USA,
11 Oostwold, Groningen, Central Coast Airshow, Pardubice, Czech Republic, Greenwood Lake Air Show,
Netherlands, Pancake Fly-in, centralcoastairshow.com.au Aviatická Pouť, facebook.com/ greenwoodlakeairshow.com
oostwold-airport.nl/pancake-fly-in/ 25-26 Gap-Tallard, Provence- aviaticka.pout.pardubice 14-16 Rickenbacker
11-12 Antwerp International Alpes-Côte d’Azur, France, 2 Cuatro Vientos Airport, International Airport, Columbus,
Airport, Flanders, Belgium, Meeting Aérien, Madrid, Spain, Fundación Infante Ohio, USA, Columbus Air Show
Stampe Fly-in, stampeclub.com/ meeting-aerien-gap-tallard.com de Orleans Flying Day, fio.es 2024, columbusairshow.com
events--news.html 25-26 Jones Beach State 2 Holloman AFB, Alamogordo, 15-16 CFB Borden, Ontario,
11-12 Fort Lauderdale, Florida, Park, Wantagh, New York, New Mexico, USA, Legacy of Canada, CFB Borden Armed
USA, Bethpage Air Show, Forces Day, bordenairshow.ca
USA, Fort Lauderdale Air Show, Liberty Air Show, holloman.af.mil/
bethpageairshow.com 15-16 Gilze-Rijen Air Base, North
fortlauderdaleairshow.com Home/2024-Air-Show/
25-26 South Beach, Miami Brabant, Netherlands, Wings &
11-12 MCAS Cherry Point, 2 Kjeller flypass, Skedsmo,
Beach, Florida, USA, Miami Wheels, classicwings-wheels.nl
North Carolina, USA, Beach Air & Sea Show, Norway, Kjeller Flyday,
MCAS Cherry Point Air Show, flydagen.no 15-16 Grant County International
usasalute.com Airport, Moses Lake,
cherrypointairshow.com 25-26 Stephens County 2-15 Hutchinson, Kansas,
12 Biel-Kappelen, Berne, USA, Pan-American Gliding Washington, USA, Moses Lake
Airport, Breckenridge, Texas, Air Show, moseslakeairshow.com
Switzerland, Ex-Swiss military USA, Breckenridge Airshow, Championship, fai.org/events
fly-in, lszp.ch/fly-in-2024 5-9 Berlin ExpoCenter Airport, 15-16 La Crosse Regional
breckenridgeairshow.com Airport, La Crosse, Wisconsin,
15-22 Strausberg Airport, 25-26 Warnervale Airport, Schönefeld, Germany,
Brandenburg, Germany, ILA Berlin Air Show, ila-berlin.de USA, Deke Slayton Airfest,
Warnervale, NSW, Australia, airfest.com
Grunau Baby meet, Central Coast Airshow, 6-8 Lyon-Bron, Auvergne-
fliegerclub-strausberg.de/ Rhône-Alpes, France, 15-16 Liepājā International
centralcoastairshow.com.au Airport, Liepājā, Latvia,
grunau-baby-treffen 26 Karlstadt-Saupurzel, Bavaria, France Air Expo - Salon de
Baltic International Airshow,
17-18 Illinois Valley Regional Germany, Saupurzel Fly-in, wpr. l’Aviation Générale Lyon,
balticairshow.com
Airport, Peru, Illinois, USA, lsck.de/saupurzel-fly-in-2024/ franceairexpo.com
15-16 Old Rhinebeck
TBM Avenger Gathering, 28-30 Geneva Airport, 6-9 Kjevik, Kristiansand,
Aerodrome, New York, USA,
tbmreunion.org Switzerland, European Business Norway, Nordic Europa Fly-in,
Aviation Convention & Exhibition History of Flight (Sat) & World
17-19 Portland-Hillsboro theeuropaclub.org/events War I (Sun) Air Shows,
Airport, Hillsboro, Oregon, USA, (EBACE), ebace.aero/2024/ 7-9 Midden Zeeland, Zeeland,
29-2 Jun Djerba–Zarzis oldrhinebeck.org/airshows
Oregon International Air Show, Netherlands, Fun Fly-in, [+ each weekend until 20 Oct]
oregonairshow.com International Airport, Djerba, funflyin.nl
Tunisia, IADE Tunisia 2024, 15-16 Stavanger Sola Airport,
18 CFB Comox, British 8 Fassberg Air Base, Lower Sola, Norway, Sola Airshow,
Columbia, Canada, Spectacle iadetunisia.com Saxony, Germany, Open Day,
30-2 Jun Kehl-Sundheim, solaairshow.no
Aérien, comoxairshow.com bundeswehr.de 15-16 Vaasa Airport, Vaasa,
18-19 Duluth International Kehl, Germany, Flying Days, 8 Höga Kusten, Sweden, 50th
kehler-flugtage.de Finland, Vaasa International
Airport, Duluth, Minnesota, anniversary airshow, facebook. Airshow, vaasaairshow.fi
USA, Duluth Air & Aviation Expo, 31-1 Jun Borlänge, com/hogakustenairport
Dalarna County, Sweden, 16 Sabadell Airport, Barcelona,
duluthairshow.com 8 Holzdorf Air Base, Spain, Fundació Parc Aeronàutic
EAA Fly-in, eaa.se
18-19 La Ferté-Alais, Cerny, Saxony-Anhalt, Germany, de Catalunya Open Day,
France, Fête Aérienne Les Temps Open Day, bundeswehr.de fpac.org/calendari/
JUNE 2024
des Hélices, letempsdeshelices.fr 1 Newcastle, KwaZulu-Natal, 8-9 Eesti Lennundusmuuseum, 21 Texel, North Holland,
19 Sabadell Airport, Barcelona, South Africa, Newcastle Air Tartu, Estonia, Estonian Aviation Netherlands, Sunset Fly-in,
Spain, Fundació Parc Aeronàutic Show, airshowsa.org.za Days, lennundusmuuseum.ee texelairport.nl/event/
de Catalunya Open Day 1-2 Amiens, Hauts-de-France, 8-9 Selfridge ANGB, Mt 21-22 Leszno-Strzyżewice,
fpac.org/calendari/ France, 20,000 Leagues Air Clemens, Michigan, USA, Leszno, Poland, Antidotum
25 Chambley, Grand Est, Show, aeroclub-picardie-amiens. Selfridge ANGB Open House & Airshow, antidotum.
France, Meeting Aérien com Air Show, teamselfridge.com lotniskoleszno.pl
du Grand-Est, helloasso. 1-2 Beja Air Base, Alentejo, 8-9 Spirit of St Louis Airport, 22-23 CFB Bagotville, Quebec,
com/associations/bleu-ciel- Portugal, Beja International Chesterfield, Missouri, USA, Canada, Bagotville International
organisation/ Airshow, emfa.pt Spirit of St Louis Air Show, spirit- Air Show, saibagotville.com
25 Texel, North Holland, 1-2 Saint-Hubert Airport, airshow.com 22-23 Davenport Municipal
Netherlands, Fly-in Cinema, Quebec, Canada, AeroSalon Air 9 Playa Poniente, Motril, Airport, Davenport, Iowa,
texelairport.nl/event/fly-in- Show, rcaf2024arc.ca/events- Granada, Spain, Festival Aéreo USA, Quad City Air Show,
cinema-2024/ landing/air-shows/ de Motril, motrilairshow.com quadcityairshow.com
O VED
APPR
W
NO TL-3000
SIRIUS
LAA Permit or BMAA Light Sport Microlight
OVED
APPR
TL-2000 W
NO
STING S4
PIPER TURBO LAA Permit or BMAA Light Sport Microlight
SPARKER
...we are working on it!
OFFERED AT
£67,500
TT 880
D
RE
OFFERED AT
£159,995 NO VAT
HRS
U
UNDER OFFER!
TO SUBSCRIBE :
GO TO SHOP.KELSEY.CO.UK/JWO
OR USE THIS QR CODE TO GO DIRECTLY
TO OUR WEBSITE
TERMS & CONDITIONS: *UK DIRECT DEBIT OFFER ONLY. YOU WILL PAY £62.30 EVERY 12 MONTHS. SAVINGS ARE BASED ON THE YEARLY COVER PRICE (£5.99 PER ISSUE) PLUS
POSTAGE. OFFER ENDS 31ST DECEMBER 2024. YOUR SUBSCRIPTION WILL START WITH THE NEXT AVAILABLE ISSUE, AND YOU WILL RECEIVE 13 ISSUES IN A YEAR. PRICES CORRECT
AT TIME OF PRINT AND SUBJECT TO CHANGE. FOR FULL TERMS AND CONDITIONS VISIT SHOP.KELSEY.CO.UK/TERMS. DATA PROTECTION: WE TAKE GREAT CARE IN HANDLING
YOUR PERSONAL DETAILS AND THESE WILL ONLY EVER BE USED AS SET OUT IN OUR PRIVACY POLICY WHICH CAN BE VIEWED AT SHOP.KELSEY.CO.UK/PRIVACY-POLICY. YOU MAY
UNSUBSCRIBE AT ANY TIME
1/6 SHARE FOR SALE
SCOTTISH AVIATION BULLDOG Model 128
ILAFFT
E
very airline pilot settles The enormous Rolls-Royce Trent Some reasonable airports to the West
down after training to 895-17 or General Electric GE 90-85B but a long way off and certainly no BA
a hopefully stimulating engine intake cowls are the same presence nearby.
and satisfying career. diameter as a Boeing 737 fuselage. We were briefed on the usual
Experience brings I reported for work at ‘The Blue weather, navigation and NOTAM –
confidence and lots of spare Lagoon’ BA Flight Operations building Notices To Airmen warnings. As there
capacity for a relaxed operation at Heathrow in January 1998 for was early morning fog forecast at this
and pleasant day out. This is even an evening departure to Almaty in destination new for BA, I loaded lots
on short high workload hops or Kazakhstan. This was a new route of extra fuel. Two things are useless
into difficult challenging worldwide for BA, situated on the old silk trail in aviation – fuel left in the bowser
airports. However, every once in to China a short distance from the and runway behind you. After meeting
a while unforeseen circumstances Chinese border, near Urumqi. The the fourteen cabin crew we all bused
or events can build up to require a silk road followed the Northern out to the aircraft, G-VIIF for a night
concentration and ability to think edge of the mountains where takeoff before the Heathrow noise
clearly under pressure. Marco Polo trekked from Venice in curfew. The flight time for the 3,045
In January 1998 I had packed in a the 13th century. This fascinating nautical mile flight would be about
few months as a Captain on the then place is wedged up against the nine hours, and we had 350-plus
new British Airways Boeing 777-200 foothills of the Himalayas in central passengers on board.
fleet. The aircraft was a delight to fly Asia. There was an exciting mix The night flight route took us East
with many innovations on the flight of East and West here, with exotic across Lithuania, Vilnius and Belarus
deck including fly by wire controls. foods – including mountains of best into Russia. There was the usual
At a maximum takeoff weight of 243 caviar – and fabulous fur coats in ‘outer ring road’ of airways around
metric tonnes and length Moscow and then
209 feet with a wingspan Every once in a while, unforeseen out across the vast
of 199 feet, this was a seemingly endless
large widebody. In spite circumstances or events can build up expanse South East
of this, the handling
was light and precise.
to require a concentration and ability towards Kazakhstan,
passing places like
Lots of safety systems to think clearly under pressure Penza and Samara.
such as overbanking Weather reports of
protection and automatic rudder input the market. Having unshackled the possible alternates along the route
in the event of an EFTO – Engine previous Russian administration revealed mostly snow conditions
Failure on Take Off (switched off on fairly recently, there was a real Wild worsening. As dawn approached,
simulator checks!) The features on West atmosphere with new bars and we were crossing the Steppes of
the flight deck and throughout were restaurants everywhere stocked with Kazakhstan, passing quite close to the
on another level compared to the unlimited Russian vodka, all at very Russian cosmodrome at Baikonur. We
Boeing 747-400. There was automatic reasonable prices. briefed for our approach and landing
downloading of en route winds into In Europe and a large part of the for Runway 23 at Almaty taking careful
the navigation computers. Even the BA network there are lots of available note of the mountains running just to
clock was synchronised with an alternates with good facilities for the South.
atomic clock somewhere in Paris the aircraft and the passengers. Only Category 1 ILS (Instrument
for accuracy. Being a twin-engined This Almaty place seemed to be a Landing Systems) were on offer,
airliner, the engines by definition very long way from anywhere. It was which meant a decision height of
are overly powerful to cope with the wedged up against the Himalayas not less than 200 feet and minimum
asymmetric engine failure situation. to the South and China to the East. RVR (Runway Visual Range) of 600
metres. The freezing fog/low cloud consideration. We had already been Anyway, when it was my turn to
had not burned off after sunrise flying and on duty for at least eight rest for an hour or so, a cabin crew
as forecast, with a ceiling of about hours through the night, and Moscow member sat with Chris, the FO.
150 feet. We were in wonderful was about four hours back the way We finally made our approach in the
sunshine during our descent and we had come. Thus we would grossly dusk or dark now at Sheremetyevo
had great views of the mountains exceed flight time limitations and Moscow and although it was snowing
to the South. A standard copilot- our individual tiredness had to be hard I saw the lights at a reasonable
monitored automatic approach to Cat addressed before another difficult height and landed without incident.
1 limits was performed to minima of approach and landing… anywhere. It was a very careful taxi on the snow
200ft. This would be for my manual After discussion I decided to depart and ice to the gate. The passengers
landing, when I would take control the hold for the long flight back to disembarked and were looked after
only on seeing satisfactory visual Moscow. We adjusted speed and by the BA ground staff. Hotels had
cues. Otherwise P2 would instigate altitude for maximum range and been booked and buses arrived.
a standard go-around. The RVR was monitored weather along the route. We as the crew were not so lucky.
given as ‘above 700 metres’ which I called in to London BA operations We were taken to a shed and there
was above the minimum to we waited... and waited.
start an approach. Eventually a Russian
We performed an The freezing fog/low cloud had not BA person came and
approach and saw nothing burned off after sunrise as forecast, arranged to transit us
at decision height, so went through immigration
around on the published with a ceiling of about 150 feet after another wait. By
go-around procedure this time we were all
away from the mountains. A second using the then new ACARS – Airline very tired and getting fed up. Finally,
approach gave the same result. We Communications And Reporting we were through and onto a hotel
were then invited to join the holding System to get their take on matters. crew bus with the same Russian BA
stack at the approach VOR beacon, They concurred and wished for a person. At the hotel he was there
ALM directly over the airport to wait landing “as far West as possible”. again at reception. It turned out that
for the fog to clear… or not clear. Careful choice of words for he was ex-KGB and was recruited
Decision Time. We were the only addressing the passengers and because he knew everyone at the
aircraft around and had tried twice to cabin crew. They had already been airport and could “make the wheels
get in unsuccessfully. The alternate fully informed about Almaty. In my turn”.
of close-by Bishkek was marked experience if the passengers are kept I was just collapsing in my room
as unusable for some reason and fully in touch and always told the truth when the phone rang. It was a
fogged out anyway. That left Tashkent they will stay on side throughout any passenger wanting to know about his
in Kyrgyzstan and Samarkand in disruption situation. It was paramount luggage! I directed him accordingly.
Uzbekistan – both far to the west, not to use phrases like “I’m afraid we The next morning after proper
again on the old silk trail. Snow are going to be late”. Passengers with flight crew limitations rest time we all
blizzards were reported at both these limited English might only pick up on departed for Almaty again. This time
and worsening conditions were now “I’m afraid”! without incident. By now the whole
forecast. Certainly no BA crew had gelled very
welcome there for the well as a good team
350-plus passengers or We could hold in the stack and wait for and it was a particularly
the aircraft.
So we could hold in the
the fog/low cloud to clear – but what if enjoyable stop over for
a couple of days. This
stack and wait for the fog/ it didnt? We would paint ourselves into was before our return
low cloud to clear – but
what if it didn’t? We would
a corner as the fuel was consumed to London to face the
inevitable paperwork,
paint ourselves into a and forms to complete
corner as the fuel was consumed. A In a non-standard practice I told the on the incident.
careful calculation revealed that if we first officer to sleep in the passenger There were to be several more
departed now we could make it all cabin for at least one hour. Meantime Almaty trips on the B777-200 – all
the way back across the vast void of one cabin crew member would sit excellent and most memorable. Grand
Russia to Moscow with safe margins with me to ensure I was fully awake. municipal buildings everywhere in the
of fuel – but not if we stayed here There was a crew alert warning Russian style and picturesque parks
any longer. Moscow Sheremetyevo system on the B777. If no switch or and gardens. Overall, a great place.
was a main BA destination so the knob was moved for a preset time
passengers, crew and aircraft would period, then a visual alert would start
be looked after properly in this on the master warning system. If not BE PUBLISHED
difficult part of the world. The weather actioned after another shorter period, IN PILOT!
at Moscow was giving blizzards but a loud warning noise would initiate. Do you have your own ILAFFT tale?
Tell us your story in around 1,000 words
aircraft were landing there. (We used to say that maybe there and you could see it in print
However, there was another should be a third physical warning.)
TO SUBSCRIBE :
GO TO SHOP.KELSEY.CO.UK/AMD
OR USE THIS QR CODE TO GO DIRECTLY
TO OUR WEBSITE
*UK DIRECT DEBIT OFFER ONLY. SAVINGS BASED ON THE STANDARD BASIC ANNUAL RATE OF £52.44 WHICH INCLUDES THE COVER PRICE OF £5.99 PLUS KELSEY MEDIA’S STANDARD POSTAGE AND PACKING PRICE PER SINGLE ISSUE FOR ONE
FULL YEAR (6 ISSUES). YOU WILL PAY £28.75 PER YEAR. OFFER ENDS 31ST DECEMBER 2024. YOUR SUBSCRIPTION WILL START WITH THE NEXT AVAILABLE ISSUE AND YOU WILL RECEIVE 6 ISSUES IN A YEAR. PRICES CORRECT AT TIME OF PRINT
AND SUBJECT TO CHANGE. FOR FULL TERMS AND CONDITIONS, VISIT SHOP.KELSEY.CO.UK/TERMS. IF YOU DECIDE TO CANCEL YOUR SUBSCRIPTION WE WILL PUT A STOP TO ANY FURTHER PAYMENTS BEING TAKEN AND WILL SEND THE
REMAINING ISSUES THAT YOU HAVE ALREADY PAID FOR. FOR OFFERS OUTSIDE THE UK VISIT SHOP.KELSEY.CO.UK/AMD. DATA PROTECTION: WE TAKE GREAT CARE IN HANDLING YOUR PERSONAL DETAILS AND THESE WILL ONLY EVER BE
USED AS SET OUT IN OUR PRIVACY POLICY WHICH CAN BE VIEWED AT SHOP.KELSEY.CO.UK/PRIVACY-POLICY
WARBIRD & VINTAGE AIRCRAFT BROKERS
Selling the finest aircraft worldwide CONTACT
Fieseler Storch Fi156 is now exclusively for sale with Eagles Eleven. Robert Stewart Ian Jones
Owned by “Historiske fly AS Ltd” This rare aircraft spent ten years
and over 9000 hours undergoing a full nut and bolt restoration.
Alain Maire Louisa Noël
Currently on the Norwegian register as LN-WNS the aircraft has
Phone: +44 1622 278138
flown just 80 hours and also boasts an original Argus V8 engine.
We are quite sure this beautiful Storch will attract much attention. Email: [email protected]