Submission - Forcedmarriage Nhri India
Submission - Forcedmarriage Nhri India
Submission - Forcedmarriage Nhri India
General context:
With reference to the last report of the Secretary-General on the issue of child,
early and forced marriage (A/75/262), the key recommendations implemented
are as under:
i) The minimum age for marriage in India is already 18 years as per the
Prohibition of Child Marriage Act, 2006.
ii) There are no discriminatory provisions existing in the country that require
legislative measures to be introduced for addressing such issues.
iii)The measures to promote the access to education, sexual and reproductive
healthcare services include the schemes such as BetiBachao, BetiPadhao;
Right to Education Act, SABLA Scheme, SwadharGreh, et cetera.
iv) Strengthening and facilitating access to protective mechanisms and services,
including legal services, safe accommodation and psychological support
include the Mahila Police Volunteers Scheme, the SwadharGreh Scheme,
NariNiketan trust, Ujjwala Scheme, et cetera (mentioned in detail with
reference to the 5th question of this report).
v) The Prohibition of Child Marriage Act (2006) ensures that the girls who are
in informal unions enjoy the same level of protection as girls in child
marriages.
vi)National Crime Records Bureau (NCRB) shows that 785 cases were
registered across the country under the Prohibition of Child Marriage Act in
1
2020.
vii) National Human Rights Commission had organized two conferences on
Child Marriage in January and August, 2018, collaborating with the
significant stakeholders for better track of such cases and for the dynamics
of child marriage to be deliberated upon.
2. What legislative actions have you taken to address the root causes of child,
early and forced marriage? Any examples of legislation enacted, beyond the
minimum age of marriage, such as laws repealing or amending provisions
that enable perpetrators of rape, sexual abuse or abduction to be exempted
from prosecution and punishment by marrying their victims?
The legislative actions taken so far to address the root causes of child, early and
forced marriage are as under:
2
Whoever performs, conducts or directs or abets any child marriage shall
be punishable with rigorous imprisonment which may extend to two years
and shall be liable to fine which may extend to one lakh rupees.
On an application of the Child Marriage Prohibition Officer or on receipt
of information through a complaint or otherwise from any person, a
Judicial Magistrate of the first class or a Metropolitan Magistrate shall
issue an injunction against any person including a member of an
organisation or an association of persons prohibiting such marriage.
The Court of the Judicial Magistrate of the first class or the Metropolitan
Magistrate may also take suo motu cognizance on the basis of any
reliable report or information.
An offence punishable under this Act shall be cognizable and non-
cognizable.
3
speedy trial of offences against children or of violation of child rights and for
matters connected therewith or incidental thereto.
vii) On December 16, 2021, the Union Cabinet approved a proposal to raise the
legal age of marriage for women from 18 to 21, based on the recommendations
of a NITI Aayog task force. On December 20, the Prohibition of Child Marriage
(Amendment) Bill, 2021, was introduced in the Lok Sabha. It has been sent to a
Parliamentary Standing Committee on Education, Women, Children, Youth and
Sports, for further deliberations and making recommendations. According to the
Bill, a child is defined as “a male or female who has not completed 21 years of
age”.
4
a. Lajja v. State
The Delhi High court held that the Prohibition of Child Marriage
Act (PCMA) prevails over personal laws.
b. Independent Thought v. Union of India
In the landmark judgement; the Supreme Court of India on 11th
October 2017 ruled that sexual intercourse or sexual acts by a man
with his minor wife would amount to rape for the purposes of
Section 375 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860. The Court has read
down Exception 2 to Section 375 which reads Sexual intercourse
or sexual acts by a man with his own wife, the wife not being
below 15 years of age, is not rape to hold that sexual activity with a
minor would constitute rape and the exception will not be
applicable in cases where the wife is between the ages of 15-18.
c. P. Venkataraman v. State
The only consequence of child marriage is that persons concerned
are liable for the punishment under sec18 of Hindu Marriage Act,
1955, and a decree of divorce is liable to be given to the parties, if
they wish so.
When the matter came up before a Division Bench, the minor girl
appeared and filed an affidavit that she had fallen in love with a
person and married him in July this year. After considering the
rival submissions, the Bench directed that the girl be kept in a
government's children's home.
5
It referred the matter to a Full Bench to decide the questions,
including whether a marriage of a person with a female of less than
18 years could be said to be a valid marriage and the custody of the
girl be given to the husband, and whether a minor could be said to
have reached the age of discretion and, thereby, walk away from
the lawful guardianship of her parents and refuse to go in their
custody.
3. What measures have you adopted to support girls that are already married
or in informal unions?
i) Under the provision of Prohibition of Child Marriage Act, 2006, the court can
order for the girl to be provided a safe home to reside in and an amount in lieu
of maintenance from the time of the annulment of marriage till her remarriage.
ii) Legal Service Committee provide help and various schemes exist for their
welfare.
iii) UNICEF and UNFPA have joined forces through a Global Programme to
Accelerate Action to End Child Marriage, where for the first time existing
strategies in areas such as health, education, child protection, nutrition and
water and sanitation have been brought together to address child marriage in a
holistic manner. The approach is to address child marriage through the entire
lifecycle of a child especially by addressing persisting negative social norms
which are key drivers for the high prevalence of child marriage in India. The
programme works in partnership with governments, civil society organizations
and young people themselves and adopts methods that have proven to work at
scale.
4. What actions do you take to support girls and women affected or at risk of
child, early and forced marriage; especially those who have fled such a
marriage or whose marriage has dissolved, and to support widowed girls or
women who were married as girls?
The girls and women affected or at risk of child, early and forced marriage, and
6
the widowed girls or women who were married as girls can take advantage
through the following schemes in order to be protected under the provisions laid
down by the government:
i) To support girls and women affected or at risk of child, early and forced
marriage, the Government has implemented the Rajiv Gandhi Scheme for
Empowerment of Adolescent Girls (RGSEAG)–‘Sabla’, a Centrally-sponsored
scheme in 205 districts selected from all the States/UTs. The scheme Sabla aims
at empowering Adolescent Girls (AGs) (11-18 years) through nutrition, health
care and life skills education. Nearly 100 lakh adolescent girls per annum are
expected to be benefitted under the scheme.
ii) Under the Scheme Swadhar Greh (by Ministry of Women and Child
Development, 2015), shelter homes are set up in every district with capacity of
30 women with the following objectives:
a) To cater to the primary need of shelter, food, clothing, medical treatment and
care of the women in distress and who are without any social and economic
support.
b) To enable them to regain their emotional strength that gets hampered due to
their encounter with unfortunate circumstances.
c) To provide them with legal aid and guidance to enable them to take steps for
their readjustment in family/society.
d) To rehabilitate them economically and emotionally. e) To act as a support
system that understands and meets various requirements of women in
distress.
f) To enable them to start their life afresh with dignity and conviction
iii) The Right of Children to Free and Compulsory Education Act or Right to
Education Act (RTE), is an Act of the Parliament of India enacted on 4 August
2009, which describes the modalities of the importance of free and compulsory
education for children between 6 and 14 in India under Article 21A of the
Indian Constitution.
iv) In 2015, the Indian government introduced the Beti Bachao, Beti
Padhao (BBBP) scheme to address concerns of gender discrimination and
women empowerment in the country. The name Beti Bachao, Beti
Padhao translates to ‘Save the girl child, educate the girl child’. The scheme
aims to educate citizens against gender bias and improve the efficacy of welfare
services for girls. It was launched with an initial funding of Rs. 100 crore (US$
13.5 million).
vi) Dhan Laxmi Yojana: In 2009, the MWCD introduced a pilot scheme
(Dhanalakshmi) in selected backward districts of the country, as a conditional
cash transfer scheme providing cash to the family of the girl child (preferably
the mother) on fulfilling certain conditionalities for the girl child, such as birth
registration; immunisation; enrolment retention in school; and delaying the
marriage age beyond 18 years. The scheme also included a sub-component for
providing insurance cover to the girl child.
State governments too have launched conditional cash transfer schemes.
Rajasthan had launched the Raj Lakshmi Scheme in 1992, Haryana initiated
Apni Beti, Apna Dhan – ABAD scheme (My Daughter, My Pride) in 1994.
Karnataka launched the Bhagyalaxmi Scheme in 2004. In 2005 and 2006, Delhi
and Madhya Pradesh too launched the Ladli Yojana and the Ladli Laxmi
Yojana, respectively.
5. What measures are in place to facilitate access by girls and women at risk
and for already married girls and women to protective mechanisms and
services, including legal services, safe accommodation and psychosocial
support?
The existing measures and schemes to facilitate access by girls and women at
risk and for already married girls and women to protective mechanisms and
services, including legal services, safe accommodation and psychosocial
support are as under:
i) The Mahila Police Volunteers (MPVs) Scheme is in practice by the Ministry
of Women and Child Development from 2016. MPVs are envisaged to act as a
link between police and the community and facilitate women in distress. MPVs
serve as a public-police interface in order to fight crime against women and
report incidents of violence against women such as domestic violence, child
marriage, dowry harassment and violence faced by women in public spaces.
ii) The Swadhar Greh Scheme was actualized by the Ministry of Women and
Child Development in 2015. The scheme envisions a supportive institutional
framework for women victims of difficult circumstances so that they could lead
their life with dignity and conviction. It envisages that shelter, food, clothing,
and health as well as economic and social security are assured for such women.
It also envisions that the special needs of these women are properly taken care
of and under no circumstances they should be left unattended or abandoned
8
which could lead to their exploitation and desolation.
The scheme includes legal services, vocational training, medical facilities and
counselling.
viii) Under the Juvenile Justice Act(2015), there are provisions for four different
types of homes for the children (depending upon the different provisions and
needs to be addressed), namely, observation home, special home, children
homes and open shelters for safe accommodation when needed.
a. The State Government shall establish and maintain in every district or a
group of districts, either by itself or through voluntary or non-
governmental organisations, observation homes, which shall be registered
under section 41 of this Act, for temporary reception, care and
9
rehabilitation of any child during the pendency of any inquiry under this
Act.
b. The State Government may establish and maintain either by itself or
through voluntary or non-governmental organisations, special homes,
which shall be registered as such, in the manner as may be prescribed, in
every district or a group of districts, as may be required for rehabilitation
of children there by an order of the Juvenile Justice Board made under
section 18.
c. The State Government may establish and maintain, in every district or
group of districts, either by itself or through voluntary or non-
governmental organisations, Children’s Homes, which shall be registered
as such, for the placement of children in need of care and protection for
their care, treatment, education, training, development and rehabilitation.
d. The State Government may establish and maintain, by itself or through
voluntary or non-governmental organisations, as many open shelters as
may be required, and such open shelters shall be registered as such, in the
manner as may be prescribed.
7. What research has been conducted on married girls, including widow girls
and women, and whose husbands have left them to fight or seek refuge
internally or across borders, or who have been detained or disappeared?
The relevant researches and efforts on this issue are laid down as:
i) to make all marriages below 16 years age to be ‘void’ and between 16-
18 years to be ‘voidable’ through amendment of the Prohibition of
Child Marriage Act, 2006;
ii) the term ‘Compulsory education’ under RTE Act, 2009 Act may be
extended up to the age of 18 years and completion of Senior Secondary
Education i.e. till Class 12 instead of 14 years and completion of
elementary education at present;
12
Common Minimum Programme to combat child marriage; registration
of marriages to be made compulsory, etc.
13
F. As per JJ Act 2015, Special Juvenile Police Unit is working in the States
for protection of the rights of children in need of care and protection.
HAQ: The India: Child Rights Index developed by HAQ: Centre for Child Rights
shows that the top five states with the highest GDPs rank low on child marriage and
the best performing states in child marriage are Nagaland, Arunachal Pradesh and
Manipur, which are amongst the lowest GDP states of India.
Indian states with a high proportion of girls getting married below age 18 are
Bihar (46 percent), West Bengal (41 percent), Rajasthan (40 percent), Jharkhand (36
percent), Uttar Pradesh (33 percent), Madhya Pradesh, Dadra and Nagar Haveli and
Andhra Pradesh (29 percent). In these nine states more than one-fourth of the girls
are married before they are 18 years old and it is more than the national average. In
16 states, less than or equal to one tenth of the girls are married below 18 years;
these states are Himachal Pradesh, Lakshadweep, Goa, Chandigarh, Pondicherry,
Daman and Diu, Uttarakhand, Punjab, Delhi, Andaman and Nicobar Islands,
Manipur, Kerala, Jammu and Kashmir, Arunachal Pradesh, Tamil Nadu and
Mizoram. Despite Himachal Pradesh and Kerala having high female literacy, the
levels of child marriage are noticeably high. Over 45,000 child marriages, bulk of
them from the Muslim community, are reported to have occurred in Kerala since
2001.
9. Please share data and evidence on the impact of the COVID-19 pandemic on the
trend of child, early and forced marriage.
14
Due to the pandemic, girls from poor families are more likely to marry before
the age of 18 than girls from wealthier families. Families who are struggling
economically often see the short-term ‘value’ of their daughters’ marriages as a way
of lifting their own financial burden.
National Crime Records Bureau (NCRB) data found a sharp jump in child
marriages during the Covid-hit 2020. Records show that 785 cases were registered
across the country under the Prohibition of Child Marriage Act in 2020, the highest
in Karnataka at 184, followed by Assam at 138, West Bengal at 98, Tamil Nadu at
77 and Telangana at 62.
In 2019, 523 cases were registered under the act, while in 2018, 501 cases were
lodged. About 50 per cent rise in the cases of child marriages has been recorded in
2020 over the previous year, which does not only mean there has been an increase in
these instances but that there also has been a rise in reporting.
10. What measures are taken to mitigate the impact of COVID-19 on girls and
women survivors of CEFM and at risk? For instance, have you continued or
enhanced provision of protection and support services for survivors of gender-
based violence, and adapted essential health-care services, including sexual and
reproductive health-care services?
i) Measures taken to mitigate the impact of COVID-19 on girls and women survivors
of CEFM and at risk: The NHRC assures proper implementation of such schemes by
issuing Advisories and deciding complaints.
15
b. Direct Benefit Transfer or DBT is an attempt to change the mechanism of
transferring subsidies launched by the Government of India on 1 January
2013. This program aims to transfer subsidies directly to the people
through their bank accounts. With the outbreak of the COVID-19
pandemic and the imposition of lockdown and social distancing norms,
DBT emerged as a boon in providing succour and relief to millions of
citizens whose livelihood was impacted. DBT played a major role in
sustaining life especially of the under-privileged segments of the society
impacted by the COVID-19 crisis, helping millions in providing
immediate relief in tiding over the turbulent period.
ii) NHRC has issued advisories during COVID-19 pandemic in 2020. Two of
them, concerning the issue are:
a. Advisory on Rights of Women
One of the relevant recommendations is: Ensure support and care through
a dedicated campaign by local authorities such as the District Child
Protection Units (DCPU) to identify and support adolescents due to risk
of early marriage due to pandemic.
A link to access the advisory is as under:
https://nhrc.nic.in/sites/default/files/Advisory%20on%20Rights%20of
%20Women.pdf
b. Advisory for Protection of the Rights of Children
An important recommendation is: Strengthen Community-Based Action
and Oversight
Develop mechanisms involving child protection committees and village
vigilance committees, to ensure convergence of entitlements specific to
COVID-19 and ensuring children's protection by tracking violations such
as child trafficking for labour or sexual exploitation and child marriage.
Activating and monitoring of Village Level Child Protection Committees
(VLCPC) must be ensured, as also the DCPU.
A link to access the advisory is as under:
https://nhrc.nic.in/sites/default/files/NHRC%20Advisory%20on
%20Children.pdf
iii) NHRC has published a booklet on “Child Labour and Child Marriage”
in 2020, in order to spread awareness about the issue.
The contents include a detailed explanation of the Prohibition of Child
Marriage Act, voidable and void marriages, the provision of Child
16
Marriage Prohibition Officers, and the Penalties that can occur as a
result of a child marriage.
17
18