10 Reasons to Support

The Health Care Reform Bills

The health reform debate is in full swing and proposals are taking shape. Even though key
decisions are still being made, it is clear we have gained significant ground. There is much to be
excited about in these proposals: Millions more people will gain health insurance, coverage will
be more affordable, and people will have access to the health services they need. These provi-
sions will improve the lives of millions of Americans and give us the peace of mind that comes
with knowing that we have coverage no matter what. But the road ahead will not be easy. We
must continue to work for improvements and we must ensure that we do not lose the gains
we have made so far—they are worth fighting for. Below are some highlights in the health care
reform proposals.

What we’ll get from health reform:

1. A major expansion of Medicaid coverage—fully federally funded—for millions of low-income
working families who currently fall through the cracks
2. A regulated marketplace that clamps down on insurance company abuses so people can
no longer be denied coverage
3. Requirements that insurance companies spend more of the premium dollars they collect
on patient care
4. Sliding-scale subsidies so middle-class, working families can afford the coverage they need
to keep their families healthy
5. A strong public plan option that will provide choice, stability, and an honest yardstick to
keep costs down
6. Limits on out-of-pocket spending, giving Americans real health security and peace of mind
7. Much-needed relief for small businesses so they can afford to offer coverage to their
employees
8. Improvements to Medicare that will help seniors and people with disabilities afford their
drugs and their cost-sharing
9. Better access to coverage for uninsured children so they can get the care they need
10. Long overdue steps to modernize the system, improve the quality of care provided, and curb
unnecessary spending so our American health care system delivers the best possible care

Families USA • July 2009

2 10 Reasons to Support the Health Care Reform Bills

1 A major expansion of Medicaid coverage—fully federally funded—for

millions of low-income working families who currently fall through the
cracks
What’s in the bills:
The national floor for Medicaid eligibility would be set at at least 133 percent
of poverty ($24,352 for a family of three in 2009), which could expand coverage
to well over one-third of the uninsured (more than 17 million people).
Why this change is needed:
Contrary to popular perception, the Medicaid program does not provide cover-
age for all low-income people. In fact, in 43 states, adults without dependent
children cannot enroll in Medicaid today, even if they are penniless.
Only 16 states and the District of Columbia cover parents up to the poverty
level; nationally, the median eligibility level for parents is a mere 67 percent of
the poverty level ($12,268).1
Medicaid is designed to meet the health care needs of people with very low
incomes. It has a comprehensive benefits package, strict limits on out-of-pocket
costs, and strong consumer protections to make sure that people who can’t
otherwise afford health care get the care they need.

2 A regulated marketplace that clamps down on insurance company

abuses so people can no longer be denied coverage
What’s in the bills:
Health reform will bring long-overdue regulations to the private health
insurance market so that people can no longer be denied coverage or charged
exorbitant premiums because of pre-existing health conditions, health status,
gender, or age.
The new market (the “exchange” or “gateway”) will offer standardized plans
so that consumers can clearly understand the terms and coverage of their plan
choices.
Why this change is needed:
In all but five states, most insurance companies in the individual market are
free to deny coverage to applicants because of health problems, health risks,
or age.2
 10 Reasons to Support the Health Care Reform Bills 3

3 Requirements that insurance companies spend more of the premium

dollars they collect on patient care
What’s in the bills:
Health reform will require health insurers to spend a minimum amount of their
premium dollars—85 percent in the House bill—on medical care. If they do
not spend a large enough proportion of the premiums collected on medical
care, they must issue refunds to consumers.
Why this change is needed:
In the majority of states, there are no protections to ensure consumers’ premiums
will be used for medical services rather than for excessive insurance company
administration, advertising, and profit. In fact, without adequate consumer
protections, insurance companies sometimes spend only 60 cents of every
premium dollar on actual health care.3

4 Sliding-scale subsidies so middle-class, working families can afford the

coverage they need to keep their families healthy
What’s in the bills:
Although it is unclear how the subsidies will be structured, one thing is
apparent: Health reform legislation will include significant subsidies to help
middle-class, working Americans purchase health coverage.
Why this change is needed:
Insurance premiums are rising steeply, making private insurance unaffordable
for many Americans. Between 1999 and 2008, average job-based family health
premiums grew from $5,791 to $12,680, an increase of 119 percent.4
Today, middle-class, working families who are not eligible for Medicaid or
Medicare do not receive any federal assistance to help them purchase insurance.
As a result, millions of people go without the coverage and care they need.

A strong public plan option that will provide choice, stability, and an

5 honest yardstick to keep costs down

What’s in the bills:
A public insurance option would be created to compete with private insurance
plans to help make health care affordable for families and small businesses.
4 10 Reasons to Support the Health Care Reform Bills

Why this change is needed:

Insurance premiums are rising steeply, making private insurance unaffordable
for many Americans. Between 1999 and 2008, average job-based family health
premiums grew from $5,791 to $12,680, an increase of 119 percent.5
Public plans have the purchasing power needed to negotiate lower prices, and
they have lower administrative costs. Private insurers will have to compete
with these lower costs.
Currently, many private insurance companies devote substantial portions of
premium dollars to administration, marketing, and profits. Some insurance
companies earn billions of dollars in profits.6 The public plan would deliver
quality, accessible care, and constrain costs—not earn profits for shareholders.

6 Limits on out-of-pocket spending, giving Americans real health security

and peace of mind
What’s in the bills:
Health reform will include caps on how much individuals are required to pay
out of pocket for their health expenses.
Why this change is needed:
Even when people have coverage, the high cost of health care can—and
does—send millions of people into debt every year.
In 2009, an estimated 53.2 million Americans with insurance will spend more
than 10 percent of their income on health expenses.7
Nearly two-thirds (62.1 percent) of bankruptcies in 2007 were due, at least in
part, to medical causes.8

7 Much-needed relief for small businesses so they can afford to offer

coverage to their employees
What’s in the bills:
Health reform will provide tax credits to a growing number of small businesses
to make coverage more affordable.
Why this change is needed:
More than half of the uninsured—26 million Americans—are small-business
owners, employees, or their dependents.9
Small businesses pay higher premiums than their larger counterparts, and
many cannot afford to offer coverage as a result. Among firms with 3 to 9
workers, fewer than half are able to offer health benefits to their workers. 10
 10 Reasons to Support the Health Care Reform Bills 5

Our current system, where some employers offer coverage and others do not,
promotes so-called “job lock,” which happens when people stay in a job just
for the health insurance. Leveling the playing field so that all workers have
coverage no matter what will increase job mobility, labor market efficiency,
and economic growth.

8 Improvements to Medicare that will help seniors and people with

disabilities afford their drugs and their cost-sharing
What’s in the bills:
It is likely that health reform will eliminate or significantly reduce the so-called
“doughnut hole” in the Part D Medicare prescription drug benefit. This will
help ensure that seniors and people with disabilities get the medications they
need without breaking the bank or going without other necessities.
Health reform will expand and simplify eligibility for the Medicare Savings
Programs and the Medicare Part D low-income subsidy, which should
substantially increase enrollment of low-income seniors and people with
disabilities they are intended to serve.
Why this change is needed:
In 2009, the gap in Medicare Part D prescription drug coverage—the so-called
“doughnut hole”—begins after beneficiaries incur a total of $2,700 in drug
costs. Coverage does not resume until they have spent a total of $6,154—a
gap of $3,454. In these tough economic times, seniors and people with dis-
abilities with significant drug costs—generally those with more serious health
care needs—may be unable to afford the medications they need.11
Medicare’s out-of-pocket costs have risen significantly. Median out-of-pocket
spending on health care for Medicare beneficiaries increased from 11.9 percent
of income in 1997 to 16.1 percent in 2005.12 From 2008 to 2009 alone, Part D
premiums increased by 25 percent.13

9 Better access to coverage for uninsured children so they can get the
care they need
What’s in the bills:
Health care reform will expand Medicaid eligibility for parents that will allow
whole families to qualify for Medicaid together. Research shows that when par-
ents and kids have the same coverage, kids are more likely to get enrolled and
get necessary care.14
Reform efforts include a guarantee that all babies born in this country start life
with health coverage.
6 10 Reasons to Support the Health Care Reform Bills

Uninsured children in middle-class working families with incomes that make

them ineligible for Medicaid and CHIP will be able to get coverage with their
families in the exchange. Subsidies for families with moderate incomes will
help families with incomes as high as 400 percent of the federal poverty level
($88,200 for a family of four in 2009) afford coverage.
Improved outreach and retention policies will make it easier for families get
their children covered and keep them covered.
Why this change is needed:
8.6 million children are uninsured.15 CHIP reauthorization is expected to cover
approximately 4 million of these children, but many uninsured children live in
families with incomes too high to qualify for CHIP. Health reform will help
uninsured children get coverage by providing new assistance to moderate-
income families.

10 Long overdue steps to modernize the system, improve the quality of

care provided, and curb unnecessary spending so our American health
care system delivers the best possible care
What’s in the bills:
Health reform will bring down the cost of health coverage by making sure doctors
and patients have the information they need to work together and decide on
the most appropriate course of care.
To improve quality of care, doctors and hospitals that provide better-quality
care and demonstrate improved health outcomes will be rewarded.
All health care providers will be encouraged to work together to coordinate
care, avoid duplication, develop complementary treatments, and prevent
errors.
Why this change is needed:
100,000 Americans die each year from medical errors that could have been
prevented.16
To truly achieve patient-centered care, patients and their families must be
equipped with tools to make informed decisions about their own treatment.
 10 Reasons to Support the Health Care Reform Bills 7

Endnotes
1
Families USA calculations.
2
Health Policy Institute, Georgetown University, Individual Market Guaranteed Issue, Not Applicable to HIPAA Eligible
Individuals, 2007 (Menlo Park, CA: Kaiser Family Foundation, December 2007), available online at www.statehealthfacts.
org, accessed on July 14, 2009.
3
Ella Hushagen, Cheryl Fish-Parcham, and David Tian, Failing Grades: State Consumer Protections in the Individual Health
Insurance Market (Washington: Families USA, June 2008).
4
Ibid.
5
Gary Claxton, et al., Employer Health Benefits 2008 Annual Survey (Menlo Park, CA: Kaiser Family Foundation and Health
Research and Educational Trust, 2008).
6
Families USA calculations of mean revenue and profits from data reported in Fortune Magazine’s annual Fortune 500
listing for Health Care: Insurance and Managed Care, 2009, available online at www.money.cnn.com/magazines/fortune/
fortune500/2009/industries/223/index.html.
7
Kim Bailey and Laura Parisi, Too Great A Burden: Americans Face Rising Health Care Costs (Washington: Families USA, April
2009).
8
David Himmelstein, Deborah Thorne, Elizabeth Warren, and Steffie Woolhandler, “Medical Bankruptcy in the United
States, 2007: Results of a National Study,” The American Journal of Medicine, prepublication copy, available online at http://
www.pnhp.org/new_bankruptcy_study/Bankruptcy-2009.pdf.
9
Paul Fronstin, Sources of Health Insurance and Characteristics of the Uninsured: Analysis of the March 2008 CPS Survey
(Washington: Employee Benefit Research Institute, September 2008).
10
Gary Claxton, op. cit.
Families USA, Welcome to the Medicare Prescription Drug Benefit: An Illustration of the Doughnut Hole (Washington: Families
11

USA, January 2009).

12
Tricia Neuman, Juliette Cubanski, and Anthony Damico, Revisiting ‘Skin in the Game’ among Medicare Beneficiaries (Menlo
Park, CA: Kaiser Family Foundation, February 2009).
13
Jack Hoadley, et al., Medicare Part D 2009 Data Spotlight: Premiums (Menlo Park, CA: Kaiser Family Foundation, November
2008).
14
Leighton Ku and Matthew Broaddus, Coverage of Parents Helps Children Too (Washington: Center on Budget and Policy
Priorities, October 20, 2006).
15
Jennifer Sullivan and Rachel Klein, Left Behind: America’s Uninsured Children (Washington: Families USA, November, 2008).
16
Institute of Medicine, To Err Is Human: Building a Safer Health System (Washington: Institute of Medicine, November 1999).
1201 New York Avenue NW, Suite 1100 Washington, DC 20005
Phone: 202-628-3030 E-mail: [email protected]
www.familiesusa.org