War On Waste
War On Waste
War On Waste
http://www.metromagazine.com.au
© ATOM 2017
AUSTRALIAN HOUSEHOLDS
AND BUSINESSES THROW OUT
3.3 MILLION TONNES OF FOOD
ANNUALLY, ENOUGH TO FILL
THE MCG SIX TIMES OVER.
BUT…BACK IN THE
1960S WE PIONEERED
RECYCLING PROGRAMS.
© ATOM 2017
2
I I
A STUDY GUIDE
GUIDE OUTLINE
Part 1:
Introductory Material - Overview,
Curriculum Guidelines, Introductory
material about the presenter and the
series, Vocabulary, Pre-viewing questions.
Part 2:
Episode 1 viewing and responding,
Episode 2 viewing and responding,
Episode 3 viewing and responding
Part 3:
Post-viewing questions and activities for
research and extending the study
© ATOM 2017
Part 4:
References and Resources
3
I I
what will happen if we do nothing? Is it time for us as a capacity of earth to maintain all life.
nation to seriously re-examine the ways we consume and
dispose of consumer items?
4
I I
At Year 9 in Unit 2 – The Geographies of Interconnections, Teachers are advised to select from these three episodes
students study ‘the effects of the production and con- and the related parts of this guide that best suit the inter-
© ATOM 2017
sumption of goods on places and environments through- ests and abilities of their students.
out the world’ – ACHGK 068
5
I I
THE SERIES
Much of the waste shown in these programs reflects the
problems created by over-consumption of products and
the consequent need to dispose of them and their packag-
ing. In identifying and illustrating the extent and range of
the problem, Craig Reucassel shows us how we all need
to become part of the solution through taking personal
responsibility for our waste. What does break down and
what stays around for generations? Is convenience any
longer the most important consideration in our shopping?
While also working on River Cottage Australia, filmed in Episode 3 looks at the impact of takeaway coffee cups
Central Tilba on the south coast of NSW, Jodi led a com- and fast fashion that is creating textile waste everywhere
munity campaign to ban the plastic bag as people continually replace perfectly wearable clothes
for new cheaper ones. Do we need all these clothes and
what’s the problem with taking your own cup or mug for a
refill?
Presenter – Craig Reucassel
6
I I
13. Are you aware of where any of your waste ends up?
PRE-VIEWING QUESTIONS
14. Have you ever visited your local municipal depot/rub-
Some of these questions are about your household while bish tip/transfer station/dump? If you have, how is the
others are about your own throwing out habits. Try to area divided up for receiving and processing different
answer the questions as honestly as possible and then types of waste? Is there a tip shop for buying discard-
return to them after you have watched the program. Most ed items or a ‘help yourself to garden mulch’ area?
of these questions could be responded to in a classroom
through group sharing of ideas, but for younger students it 15. What do you think dumpster divers do?
may be best to focus on one group at a time, e.g. 1-5.
16. Have you or your family ever re-homed discarded furni-
1. In what ways do you think your household does ‘better ture or other items left out for rubbish collections?
than average’ in the waste generation stakes, i.e. are
you less wasteful than you think others might be? 17. Does food waste contribute to greenhouse gases?
What form of emissions does rotted food give off?
2. Do you have a compost bin or maybe a worm farm
where food waste can break down to be used to enrich **
soil?
18. What kind of waste and landfill might the first non-
3. About what percentage of your purchased food do you indigenous arrivals on the first fleet have seen in the
think ends up in the bin? landscape and in the sea in 1788?
4. Do you bring your shopping home from the supermar- 19. In what ways can our waste generation and reluctance
ket in plastic bags or cloth bags? to dispose of it responsibly be evidence of our ‘trashing
the earth and its natural resources’?
5. When choosing fruit and vegetables at the supermarket
or fruit and vegetable shop, what are the things impor- 20. How is First Nation Australians’ priority of ‘caring for
tant to you when selecting produce – price, appear- country’ important to all of us in relation to managing
ance, in season etc? waste on land and sea?
** 21. List what you think are the most damaging conse-
quences of thoughtless waste disposal in 2017.
6. In what areas do you think your household could de-
crease the amount of waste they generate?
© ATOM 2017
7
I I
Craig Reucassel kicks off the War on Waste by tackling • Who do you think is responsible for the push for cos-
the issue of food waste as a staggering amount ends up in metically perfect and uniformly sized produce?
landfill every year. On average, Australians are throwing out
a fifth of all food that they buy - a fact Craig demonstrates • What does ‘ugly’ fruit and vegetables really mean?
at the local supermarket on unsuspecting shoppers.
• Which supermarket chain introduced ‘the odd bunch’
After learning that a huge amount of food waste happens range in 2014?
on farms, Craig travels to far North Queensland and meets
banana farmers where he discovers just how much they’re o Who is the public face on television advertising of
forced to throw away because of the strict cosmetic this scheme?
standards forced upon them by supermarkets. It raises
more questions - have we been conditioned to demand o What does it offer to customers and suppliers?
perfect produce that’s impossible to grow? If so, who’s
responsible? Craig contacts the major supermarket retail- o Have you ever bought odd bunch fruit and
ers to try to get some answers. He also takes to the streets vegetables?
to discover if we really are that fussy when it comes to the
look of our fresh produce.
Craig challenges a neighbourhood of ten Sydney families The average family of two
to live as ‘waste free’ as they possibly can. Over the next
month, they’ll try to reduce their household waste. But adults and two children
first he wants to see what they waste, so he borrows their
garbage bins and sorts through the contents – it’s a messy, throws out over $3,500
stinky job! When confronted with their waste the families
have more questions than answers to the problem.
worth of food a year –
• What is the first area of waste Craig looks into in North
Queensland?
this is one in every five
• How is the rejected produce shown visually? bags of groceries they buy.
© ATOM 2017
8
I I
Too fat, too thin, too short, too long, too marked,
too ugly – a banana producer
• How does Craig demonstrate the average level of • Do you think it is fussy consumers or supermarkets
a household’s weekly food waste to supermarket wanting their fresh food to look perfect that results in
shoppers? the amount of produce being discarded?
• List some of the reasons why we all bin food every • List some of the initiatives Craig takes to find some
week? answers to the ‘ugly’ fruit issue? How far does he get?
9
I I
The war on waste local bin challenge in a street in Sydney’s southern suburbs.
TABLE 1
NUMBER OF FILLED BINS TYPICAL CONTENTS OF THE WHAT GOES INTO THE HOW FULL TO THE TOP IS EACH
EACH HOUSEHOLD USES GENERAL RUBBISH BIN? RECYCLE BIN? BIN?
EACH WEEK
Week 1 of challenge
Week 3 of challenge
• What are the four piles into which Craig sorts the contents of the families’ bins?
• What are the two areas of rubbish that most surprise the participants?
How do they these neighbours use social media to keep up their interest in this war on waste challenge?
© ATOM 2017
10
I I
COMPOSTING
• What food and other waste materials can be compost-
ed for breaking down to feed soil and plants?
• Does every fruit and vegetable product need to be • Who collects, delivers, prepares and cooks the food
packaged in plastic wrap before it is cocooned for the that comes through Foodbank?
home trip in a lightweight plastic bag?
• Who eats these meals?
Name several fruits and vegetables that have their own
natural protective covering, such as sweet corn. • Make a list of any organizations in your suburb or state
that are involved in feeding people in need of meals,
• How does Craig test the truth of the supermarkets’ whether through homelessness, poverty, illness or for
claims that the millions of plastic bags put in recycle any other reason.
bins, either at your place or at the supermarket, do end
up being recycled and reused in some way? Dumpster Diving
• Angus Harris of Harris Farm Markets claims that his • Craig spends time with a ‘dumpster diver’. What do
customers have no problem with buying so-called these individuals do and what are some of the possible
‘Imperfect’ products. legal issues that might arise from their activities?
How fussy are you about the look and shape of your fruit • What are some of the risks people expose themselves
and vegetables? to when they go out at night dumpster diving? How are
these potential dangers shown in the program?
Do you prefer fresh or processed fruit and vegetables?
11
I I
We also hear about how productive some recycling can be, HISTORY
and see products made from recycled plastic. Craig also
takes our waste-free street residents to a repair café where From the mid-1980s onwards, plastic bags became com-
they learn the undervalued and surprisingly emotional joys mon for carrying groceries from shops to cars and homes
of fixing and restoring rather than disposing and replacing. throughout the developed world. They were light, cheap
and convenient. As plastic bags increasingly replaced
paper bags, and as other plastic materials and products
replaced glass, metal, stone, timber and other materials,
a packaging materials war erupted, with plastic shopping
bags at the centre of highly publicized disputes about their
less desirable side effects.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Plastic_shopping_bag
As a nation, we use
over 10 million plastic
bags a day, causing
a crisis in our oceans.
12
I I
13
OBJECT USES AFTER USE FINAL DESTINATION AGE AT POINT OF ONGOING HARMS
DISINTEGRATION
The lightweight grey As many as you can Bags journey once Where do they end up How long does it What do they hurt and
supermarket plastic think of binned take for a plastic how
bag bag to break down
(decompose or
degrade) in landfill or
the ocean?
PLASTIC BAGS
Fill out the second row in Table 2 to illustrate the extent of the plastic bag problem in Australia.
I I
© ATOM 2017
14
I I
Do any of these products have their own natural protec- Create a 3-column list of - Yes, No and Don’t Know for
tive wrapping such as banana skins or crusts and cheese your recycle bin contents or highlight each type of listed
rinds? rubbish in three different colours- green for Yes, red for No
and yellow for Don’t Know.
Many countries in the world have banned plastic shopping
bags. Many others charge for them or tax them. Countries Drink cans, food scraps, ice cream containers, milk bot-
where bags are banned include China, Kenya, South Africa tles, milk cartons, broken glass, pot plants, newspapers,
and Eritrea. See the list at http://www.bigfatbags.co.uk/ plastic bags, takeaway coffee cups, magazines, waste
bans-taxes-charges-plastic-bags/ paper, metal cookware, printer cartridges, metal food cans,
cereal boxes and their inner bags, egg cartons, disposable
What is the situation in Australia? Name any states or terri- nappies, broken ceramic crockery, aerosol cans, house
tories that have banned the bag. Which state is introducing paint tins, soft drink bottles and lids, batteries, light globes.
a ban in 2018?
You can always check with your local council or on their
To encourage people to bring along their reusable cloth bags website under Waste Disposal to see if an item like aerosol
to the supermarket from the car boot or from home, what cans can be recycled.
price do you think would really put shoppers off paying for
plastic bags at the checkout: 10 cents, 20 cents, 50 cents, $1 • How do the residents in Sydney’s more waste aware
per bag or more? Take a straw poll in your class group. street manage the grey or white soft plastic bags that
are still clean?
Who would be the big losers if a ban on so-called single
use plastic bags went national? Where do they take these plastics for recycling?
So, what can we do if we think banning the bag is the best Check out whether your local supermarket has a recycling
solution? bin for soft plastics.
Email or write to the Premier or Environment Minister in Redcycle.net.au is the site to check to see if any of the 530
your state and tell them what you think about plastic bags Coles and 100 Woolworths stores that say they have red
and their alternatives. bins for recycling plastic are in your area.
• What device does Craig put into one of the bags col-
lected for recycling to check where it ends up and how
RECYCLING – YES, NO, MAYBE,
it is recycled?
OR TOO EXPENSIVE?
© ATOM 2017
• Make a list of household items you are not sure can be • Where did one lot of plastic waste end up as shown on
recycled in a recycle bin. the tracking GPS placed in a bag?
15
I I
• How do most households or house owners pay for • Who are the biggest losers?
rubbish collection and disposal when their bins are col-
lected and emptied? • What sort of public pressure might persuade state
governments to act on this issue?
• What costs are involved in sorting rubbish at municipal
tips/dumps/landfill/council depots? • What might be the economic consequences for com-
panies manufacturing, wholesaling and retailing plastic
• What can you safely dispose of at many council depots bags used by supermarkets?
that will become a reusable resource?
Suggest bags these companies might be able to develop
if the currently available plastic bags are nationally or
globally banned… as everyone still needs to transport their
THE TASMANIAN INITIATIVE
shopping home or to the car.
• Explain what happened to plastic bags in the town of
Coles Bay in Tasmania in 2003. • What are the less damaging alternatives to these plas-
tic bags for other uses such as bin liners and picking
• How did the rest of the state follow up on this initiative up dog pooh?
in 2013?
16
I I
When it comes to our Are we too busy, don’t know how, can’t be bothered, it’s
too expensive and we want new things anyway?
plastic waste it’s clear • How does Guido Verbist, manager of the Bower Repair
Café in Sydney, try to help people hang onto their
that we’ve hit crisis stuff?
point…both on land • Are price and convenience the most important consid-
erations in upgrading and replacing items?
and in our oceans.
• What are some of the items the waste free Sydney
street residents bring in for repair?
The current bans on
plastic bags in Australia
turn out to be full of
loopholes. Currently only
a tiny percentage of our
soft plastic gets recycled.
– Craig Reucassel.
17
I I
EPISODE 3
BYOCOFFEECUP
COFFEE CUPS AND FASHION WASTE
up in landfill each year. age them to make changes for the better. Will he have an
impact?
18
I I
2. How often do you buy an item of clothing or shoes 8. What are some of the advantages of buying fashion
– weekly, monthly, every few months, at change of online?
seasons?
9. How important is price as a consideration on what you
3. How many t-shirts that you wear do you own? spend on clothes?
4. What about jeans, shorts, shoes, hoodies, leggings, Do you buy mainly at discounted prices or at sales?
dresses, skirts?
10. Do you ever buy second-hand clothes from Op Shops
5. Do you mostly clothes shop for a special occasion or other second-hand shops? Why or why not?
such as a friend’s party, a date night, a holiday, school
formal, wedding or engagement party?
three years..
19
I I
FASHION FACTS
CLOSE VIEWING ACTIVITY
Who are some of the fashion retailers that have entered
•
09.03 – 11.03
the Australian market over the past five years?
WHERE DO ALL THOSE BAGS OF
• What does ‘high volume, low margin’ mean in retail THROWN - OUT CLOTHES GO?
sales and how does it compound the landfill problem?
• What kind of organisation is the Smith Family? What do
• Where have most textiles and clothes been made over they do to help the communities where they work?
the past 50 years?
• How does the visit to the Smith Family warehouse give
• Under typically what conditions is fast fashion (and the young women some information about what hap-
even slower fashion) made? What does the term pens to their discarded clothes?
‘sweated labour’ mean to you?
• What percentage of the 13 million kilos of discarded
• What are some of the natural resources used in the clothes donated to the Smith family annually goes into
manufacture of textiles? their retail stores (op shops)?
• How long do you think it would take you to make a What happens to most of the clothes?
lined woollen jacket?
• What does it cost the Smith Family to recycle, clean,
sell and dispose of clothes?
THE FASHION DIET
Craig challenges four fashion obsessed friends to find out
RE-USING, RECONSIDERING,
why fashion is so addictive.
REPURPOSING BUT NOT RE-BUYING
• What is fashion stylist Aleysha’s task in relation to the
girls’ clothes shopping?
clothes?
20
I I
Read the following news item first aired after the first War
on Waste episode about wasted produce went to air:
http://www.abc.net.au/news/2017-05-25/petition-to-
• Make your own suggestions about how to persuade reduce-plastic-in-supermarkets-war-on-waste/8557658
coffee drinkers and cafes not to add disposable coffee
cups to landfill. • What do this and other news reports suggest about
how keen the two big chain supermarkets are to show
• What campaigns in the past have caused massive their green credentials and respond to public disquiet
shifts in people’s behaviour? Did many students and with their current waste, overpackaging and quite lim-
teachers and parents have a problem with students ited recycling efforts?
wearing sunhats and sunscreen on warm and hot days
when this initiative was introduced some years back?
POST VIEWING ACTIVITIES
• How do you change people’s habits in a society where
many people believe they are too busy to bring their Craig Reucassel acknowledges the size of the challenge
own coffee cup to work or their own cloth bags to the of changing habits and behaviours in relation to over-
supermarket? consumption and waste disposal in these programs. He
encounters waste management problems in every state he
visits – Queensland, Tasmania, NSW and Victoria.
THE REDCYCLE BINS?
But he also demonstrates through his challenge with the
• Where can these bins be found? Sydney waste-free street households that small changes
can result in in huge differences in how much waste we
What can be put into them – just soft plastic bags or what create and how we dispose of it.
else?
22
I I
Our waste is growing at double the rate of our population. h) Organise a visit from a council depot worker from
By calling these programs War on Waste, what are the their ‘sustainability’ department to talk about the
filmmakers suggesting about Australia’s mounting waste kind of recycling they are doing.
problems?
i) Research whether there is any such thing as strong
3. Choose one of the following as your challenge for but biodegradable bags to pick up and dispose
change in the next month. We can’t all do everything of all the dog pooh our pets produce daily in back
at once but small changes we each make will certainly yards or parks or on their walks. Where does it all
add up. go?
a) Take the supermarket plastic carry bags back to j) Check out your local supermarket to see if some of
the shop and put them in the store recycle bin the information shown in this program has encour-
which may be labelled Red Cycle. aged plastic bag recycling or at least returning
bags to place of grocery produce. If you learn that
b) Spend $5 on five strong cloth supermarket bags there has been a change, suggest how this new
and put them in the car if you drive to the shops or behaviour can be sustained.
at home if you walk.
4. If there was just one change all of us could be persuad-
c) Encourage all family members to use a ‘keep cup’ ed to make in how we create and dispose of waste,
for the coffee or hot chocolate they have on their what would you select as the most worthwhile change
way to work. for 2017?
d) Set up a simple composting bin with a lid in the 5. If a second series of War on Waste is made, what are
backyard for fruit and vegetable and garden waste. some of the areas of over-consumption and excessive
waste that you would like to see featured?
e) Don’t buy any new clothes or shoes, if possible,
for a month unless they are really essential. Visit an 6. Which of the suggested initiatives featured in Series 1
© ATOM 2017
23
I I
f. Higher penalties for illegal dumping of rubbish, Clean-up Australia’s campaign to clean up Australia and
including cars and mattresses. plastic bags in particular.
You can either argue in favour of this idea or against it. Eco House Challenge, 2007 6-part series shown on SBS,
Prospero Productions
Prepare all your arguments and those of the other view in
point form before you begin writing your piece. Some schools may have retained copies of this series and
there is a study guide at Enhance TVs website at https://
One important point to consider is that banning certain www.enhancetv.com.au/shop/home.php?cat=248
products throughout the world is rarely successful.
Marguerite O’Hara
Should plastic bags be available at supermarkets for a June 28th, 2017
small charge as any full ban is implemented? Revised July 18th, 2017
OR
24
This study guide was produced by ATOM. (© ATOM 2017)
ISBN: 978-1-76061-082-1 [email protected]
To download other study guides,
plus thousands of articles on Film as Text,
Screen Literacy, Multiliteracy and Media Studies,
visit <http://theeducationshop.com.au>.
Join ATOM’s email broadcast list for invitations to
free screenings, conferences, seminars, etc.
Sign up now at <http://www.metromagazine.com.au/email_list/>.
© ATOM 2017
25