CAA, NRC & NPR in India….

1) Do you want get the ENTIRE concept ? And not let any media/politician/friend FOOL you on
this matter ?
2) Will it be LEGALLY possible to be adopted by Modi Govt ? Yes.
3) Can Illegal Migrants be RELEASED from Detention Centres ? Yes.
…my ONE YEAR’s of research study will take you 30 minutes of reading and at the most One
day’s reflection J …read on…..

I will not ask the question to SANE people, if NRC & NPR is REQUIRED in India or not.

CAA-2019 is surely a welcome law, required to be done by India, WILL be won in Supreme Court
battles in the coming years ( but at the same time this BJP-RSS-propaganda of population
reduction FIGURES of Hindu’s in Pakistan/Bangladesh, is complete Hogwash )

Let me start the discussion with a JOKE-kind-of kissaa which is/was true state of
affairs…CORRUPTION along the borders of India-Bangladesh was RAMPANT until a few years back.
The border check posts in India, its Incharge used to take money from Bangladesh Checkpost Incharge
and infiltrate people into India. And the JOKE is that the Bangladeshi man used to reach the border and
start running in the direction of Bangladesh itself !! He used to be caught by the Bangla Security Force,
beaten to pulp and taken to the Indian check post and complain that this guy was running “into”
Bangladesh FROM India !!! and then pushed “BACK” INTO India !!! Llo kallo baat !!!!

Anyways coming back to the topic of CAA-NRC/NPR……

Media of today has inculcated a culture of shallowness/superficialness/non-seriousness.

Everything in Media today is run by/for Rumours

We responsible citizens of India, need to discuss important things, go to their ROOTS……

CAA, NRC & NPR needed detailed legal study….these are my views…They are in bullet point format
and hence would seem very disconnecting, but the FACTS presented are extremely important and deep.
You are open to discuss/debate/correct/discard ….most welcome…..

What is Citizenship :
It is defined as a Right to have Rights ( all, or maximum rights are usually with the Citizens of a country.
Non-citizens have LESSER rights than citizens ). Refer Article 14, Article 21, Article 25, Article 32, of
our constitution, for rights to all “People” in India. For “Citizens” additionally, you may refer to Article
nos 15, 16, 19, 29 & 30

Basic reasons leading to have a necessity of a certain country’s citizenship – INEQUALITY in many
aspects of living, success, persecution by the majority, war, etc.

Non-Citizens : Legal foreigners, Illegal Foreigners, Refugees, Stateless

To understand Indian Citizenship, read Constitution Part 2, Articles 5 to 11

Articles 5 to 8 : Who were granted Citizenship on 26/11/1949.
Article 5 : Domicile – who stayed in India and were willing to stay there.
Article 6 : Those who came to India latest by 19/7/1948 to be a domicile of India, they were given Indian
citizenship
Article 7 : Those who went to Pakistan after partition but came back to India ( called by Paki’s as
Muhaajir, etc ) – latest date given : 19/7/1948
Article 8 : Who were not residents INSIDE India and staying in other countries at the time of
independence (PIO’s to apply citizenship at Indian Embassy’s within 1 year or so ).

Article 9 : India will not allow Dual Citizenship.

1
Article 10 : All citizens as on 26/11/1949 – would remain as Indian citizens with all the rights and laws
applicable on them.
Article 11 : Citizenship shall be allowed only by Central Government ( Union List ). Constitution gives
all rights to Central Government to make any laws on Citizenship – PERIOD.

Who can become Indian Citizens AFTER 19/11/1949 : To make this clear, the Citizenship Act 1955 was
passed. Amendments came up in 1984, 85, 92, 2003, 05 & 2019.
CA,1955 there are 19 Sections : Important topics are How to acquire citizenship and How the Indian
citizenship would be terminated.
Acquisition of Citizenship :
Sections 3 : Jus Soli – or Citizenship by Birth – whoever is born in India shall have the right to be an
Indian Citizen
Section 4 : Jus Sanguinis - which means “by blood relation / descent” but born in a different country and
the child can also be an Indian citizen, provided the child’s registration of birth is done within 1 year of
birth. In 1955, father was to be an Indian citizen.
( Jus Soli & Jus Sanguinis were amended in 1985 & 2003 ).
Section 5 : Citizenship by Registration
– if a PIO wants to become a Citizen of India – he/she should do the registration within 1 year.
Here he/she should be staying 6 years ( out of 8 years ) in India and the 7th year full continuous
stay in India.
- Spouse of foreign national also can do the registration - example Sonia Gandhi
Section 6 : Citizenship by Naturalisation
- Special Right : A foreign national but a BIG name in the field of Science, Arts, Literature, etc
and wants to have an Indian citizenship – example Adnan Sami
- Normal Right : example who has come for doing a job ( Expertise in certain fields ) and stayed
for many years. Here he should be staying 11 years ( out of 14 years ) in India and the 12th year
full continuous stay. Few conditions like he must know at least 1 Indian language, etc.
Section 7 : Citizenship through incorporation of territories. Examples 1961 we got Goa from the
Portugese, 1962 we got Pondicherry in France, 1974-75 we got Sikkim, Behrubari, and also 2014
adjustments by Modi with Bangladesh on border villages.

Termination of Citizenship :
Section 8 : Renunciation - Own will
Section 9 : Termination ( for example India does not allow Dual Citizenship and his citizenship can be
terminated if found )
Section 10 : Deprivation. Central Govt has the right to remove for other reasons with Due Legal Course
( wrong documentations submitted on purpose, always in Jail after getting citizenship, etc ).

Indian Refugee Policy – India did not agree to International conventions of 1951, 1967 ( many countries
agreed to a fixed Refugee Policy ). India decided it to be Ad-hoc or case to case basis

Pakistan had 24% Hindu’s in 1947 and today its 1.8%. But this is not correct and its all a propaganda by
RSS/BJP. In 1941, West Pakistan had 14% Hindu’s and 10% in East Pakistan. In 1951, in West Pakistan
the Hindu’s became 1.3%. Same thing happened in Indian state of Punjab ( 32% Muslims in 1941 and 0.8
Muslims in 1951 !!! ). Biggest reason of declines were Migration/Immigration ( small reason were
killings during partition ). Thus “percentages” ALSO changed.
East Pakistan had 28% Hindu’s in 1941. In 1951 it was changed to 22%. Obviously mostly its
Migration/Immigration. And Assam faced the biggest brunt. Thus “percentages” ALSO changed.
2018 the Hindu’s in Bangladesh became 8.5%.

1950 onwards Refugees/Illegals :

- Hindus/Sikhs from Afghanistan wanted to become Indian Citizens due to
exploitation/persecution there – approx. 15k
- Hindus/Sikhs from Pakistan wanted to become Indian Citizens due to exploitation/ persecution
there – approx. 20k

2
 - in 1959 Tibetans along with Dalai Lama wanted to become Indian Citizens due to
exploitation/persecution there – approx. 80k followers
- Sri Lanka – after independence, in 1948 a law was passed whereby 700,000 Indian Origin
Tamil’s became Stateless !! Till today 450k are ALREADY made Indian citizens!

Biggest issue became Refugees and Illegals from BANGLADESH in Assam/WestBengal

In 1826 Assam, Manipur etc were under the control of Burma. In the Anglo-Burmese war, East India
company won those areas. Oil & tea were the main natural resources and a huge labor force was
required. Bengal speaking states had abundant labor supply. 1931 census said that original Assamese
people became a minority. 1947 partition saw illegal migration of most Bengali-Speaking people to West
Bengal and Laborers to Assam. In 1950 Nehru was so afraid with the migrant numbers, that he made a
law “Immigrant Expulsion from Assam Act” – said to expulse all back to Bangladesh but the
MINORITIES CAN STAY IN INDIA. In 1950-51 also came the Nehru Liaqat pact, which allowed
Minorities to come to each other’s countries.
IN 1951 NEHRU CARRIED OUT NRC IN ASSAM (ONLY) – process completed in 20 days ( based on 10 year
census ). Did not PUBLISH the data and kept it secret !!!
In 1952, Bengalis in East-Pakistan started revolting against compulsion of Urdu Language. Till it
culminated in a revolt in 1971 ! Pakistan started making their lives a HELL. Hence the there was a SURGE
of illegals coming into INDIA ( Vijayalakshmi Pandit said this in the UN in 1951, that in last 5 years 23 lakh
illegals came into India ! )
This illegal migration continued for DECADES. 1964 saw Lal Bahadur Shastri as a PM and tried to UPDATE
the NRC. He also said to start the process of making National Identity Card. Shastri brought out RULES in
the “Foreigner’s Act 1946” which gave freedom to India to arrest Illegals, run foreign tribunals and it
would be that illegal’s onus to prove his Indian Nationality and fast expulsion of them out of India. 1965
saw a war with Pakistan and more illegals came into India.
1970 elections East Pakistan saw huge seats win by MujeebUrRehman 167 seats in the Parliament – a
clear majority. Bhutto got only 81 seats. West Pakistan was always hungry for power. MUR claimed to
form a new country on 26/3/71. West Pakistan military started Operation Searchlight. 3 Lakh to 30 lakh
people were killed in Genocide !!
MARCH 1971 saw Indian elections and IG became PM. She was fearing MASS ILLEGAL migration of the
ENTIRE BANGLADESH into India. USA & China was with Pakistan. IG made friendship with Russia – a pact
of 25 years. 16 Dec 1971 Bangladesh became Free under Indira Gandhi’s leadership.
Between March and December 1971 around 10 million people came into Assam and West Bengal ( and
“they say” that 9 million went back to Bangladesh after independence ).
1972 there was a Pact between CONgress & Bangladesh that whoever has come into India AFTER 25th
March 1971 ( Operation Searchlight ), Bangladesh will take back those 4 million Illegals. CONgress did
not do ANY followup for next many years, on this pact with Bangladesh.
Janata Party came into power in 1977 and here the Assam-Movement started by AASU & AAGSP !!
Assam Vidhansabha Elections in 1978 was also won by Janata Party. Now Janata Party made sure that
the PENDING PROBLEM kept by CONgress was raised ( 1972 Pact with Bangladesh ).
1978 Loksabha Seat Mangaldoi – after death of the MP Mr. Hiralal Patwari – Bi Elections were
announced. Election commission found that the Electoral List of 1978 was very different from 1971
Voter List. Most were added because of Illegals ( Approx 4 million in Assam !!! ). Original Assamese
wanted to protect their majority because of this Election Commission Report. All Assam Students Union
(AASU) started a revolt in Assam. All Assam Gan Sangram Parishad (AAGSP) joined AASU in the revolt.
They put condition in front of the Central Government that Elections of Mangaldoi would not happen till
a) All Illegal Migrants are not detected & arrested b) Delete them from the Voter’s List 3) Deportation to
Bangladesh.
1979 : Indira convinced Chaudhry Charan Singh to remove his backing of Janata Party and Government
was brought down. She backstabbed CCS and did not support him to be the PM as promised. Re-Election
was decided with the same Voter List of Assam!!
Thus 8th June 1979 Assam Revolt Started.
Assam had 14 Loksabha Seats and there were no nominations allowed on these seats by the
revolutionaries ( Loksabha elections happened eventually only in 2 seats out of 14 ). Indira became PM
3
once again. Indira used Presidential powers to remove Assam State Government. Next 3 years Assam
had Presidential Rule !! Nothing much happened with the assam Movement. Indira and Zail Singh had
meetings with AASU-AAGSP. They demanded that the 1951-NRC of Nehru Census should be brought in
force and all others should be declared as Illegal Immigrants. Indira Denied and said that all should
accept Nehru-Liaqat Pact. Indira proposed the 1971 Pack once again ( 25/3/1971 base line ). CONmen
did not make any agreement !!
1983 – Turning Point in Assam :
1983 Vidhan Sabha Elections were anyways due and Indira decided to have the elections with the FOUR
MILLION ILLEGAL IMMIGRANTS in the voters list !!!!!
AASU-AAGSP said that they would not allow elections if 4 million illegal migrants were not removed
from the Voters List !! Indira put all Assam Revolutionaries into Jail, Censorship on all Media happened
in Assam !!! KPS Gill advised Indira not to do elections because of safety reasons. Indira did not agree
and she brought ELEVEN ARMY BRIGADES, around 500 paramilitary companies, Civil Service Police
PROBATIONERS Forces ( first time in Indian Elections ) – to SATISFY HER EGO.
Elections happened with 32% voter turnover and CONgress naturally got majority from this 32% turnout
!!
Nellie Massacre : Local Assamese people of Nagaon district – nearby Nellie – 14 villages – 18th Feb 1983
( 2 days after elections ) – a HUGE crowd went to these villages and MASSACCRED around 2191 people (
government figure – UNOFFICIAL figure is around 10,000 people massacred in ONE DAY ).
Tiwari Commission was appointed and that report came in 1984. And believe it or not : that report is
seen/read till today, only by Indira and her CONmen !!!!
Indira passed one ACT just to SHOW to people that she was doing something – an ACT with no
substance. Illegal Migrants Determination by Tribunals Act 1983 (2005 Supreme Court ABOLISHED this
act !! ). IMDT-1983 said the SAME things that Shastri decided in 1964, mentioned above ( Foreigner
Tribunals, etc ). Just that the ONUS was put on the GOVERNMENT to prove that a person was ILLEGAL –
but she did not give powers to the police to proper investigation or search warrants of homes of the
illegals !! Indira had FULL chance to apply this act on ENTIRE INDIA. Indira had full chance to implement
her 1972 pack with Bhutto, mentioned above ( 25/3/1971 cut off date ). So, it was only a MAKE OVER
operation carried out by Indira. Evident from the Conviction-Rate of ONLY 0.5% of illegal migrants !!!!
Assam was made into a JOKE by Indira. Her core vote bank became Muslims who sympathized with
Pakistan/Bangladesh.

Finally 1984 - Punjab saw separatism/terrorism ( Bhindranwale ). Operation Bluestar was carried out by
Indira, thousands died. Indira was killed. Rajiv Gandhi became PM, elections happened and he got an
unprecedented majority. He decided to get back to the major issue that Indira was involved - Assam. 22
days later he made the very important ASSAM ACCORD ( on paper on 15th Aug 1985 ) !! Three parties
signed the Assam Accord – Home Secretary, Assam State Govt Chief Secretary & 3 leaders of Assam
Movement Leaders. Provisions of Assam Accord – most important Clause 5 said the following :
1) Cut off Date would be 1st Jan 1966 or 1967 Voter’s list for making then Indian Citizens.
2) 1/1/66 to 25/3/71 – People who came in India , they have to register themselves with
Government ( under Foreigners Act 1939 ). They would not be considered in the voter’s list for
max. of 10 years and would be given all civil rights including passport.
3) After 25/3/71 – To be detained, deleted & deported

1985 Vidhansabha Elections were called for again. New party Assam Gan Parishad ( Aasuu & AAGSP ).
ASG won by a huge margin.
Then came CAA-1985 ( yes CAA was done first by Rajiv Gandhi ). They inserted Clause 5 of Assam
Accord !!
CAA-1986 – Section 3 was modified ( Born by birth ). Till 1986 India had the law as USA i.e. if born in
India, then only that child has a choice to get Indian citizenship. CHIDDU was the home minister then
and this (Jus Soli) was amended in 1987 – At least the father or mother was to be an Indian National and
only then their child born on Indian soil could have the choice to become an Indian citizen.
CONgress then ( conveniently ) almost forgot about the GROUND LEVEL Implementation of this
Assam Accord !!! Indira’s IMDT (see above) was still continued in Assam in spite of the Assam Accord
been passed !!!
4
1991 Assam elections – CONgress won the State elections and did nothing for Illegal Bangladeshi’s.

CAA-1992 : Section 4 earlier said that if a Father was an Indian, only then the child born in foreign
countries could be an Indian. If Mother was an Indian, the child could not be an Indian citizen. This
gender bias was abolished.

1996 Assam elections. ASG wanted to IMPLEMENT the earlier Assam Accord provisions.

2001 to 2016 Assam had CONgress government !! Not much was done for Illegal Immigrants !
In fact in 2001 CONgress said to Supreme Court that IMDT was good for Assam ( in spite of the Assam
Accord ALREADY done by Rajiv Gandhi in 1985 !! I have no words for this SHOCKING decision of
CONgress in 2001 )

Supreme Court finally abolished IMDT in 2005 ( simply logic that Conviction rate was very low, Assam
Accord was already there and IMDT was contradicting it and there cannot be a law in Assam for the
“government” to prove that a person is an illegal migrant and in rest of India the person had to prove his
citizenship ).

CAA 2005 – Some more facilities given to OCI’s

2010 : NRC was done as a PILOT project in 2 regions of Assam ( basically trying to implement Assam
Accord ). Violent reactions and hence CONgress stopped NRC in Assam.

2013 : Petition in Supreme Court that what the HELL is going about in the past 28 years that Assam
Accord was not implemented by CONmen !! Supreme Court ordered NRC to be done. Nothing was done
by CONmen in the State Govt of Assam till 2016.

2016 government in Assam changed to NDA partner. AND both the Center and State completed NRC in
Assam in 2019 !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Vajpayee government started to build the foundation - fundamental changes :

Year 2000 : Amended the Passport Entry Into India Act 1920. Earlier illegal immigrant was jailed ONLY
for 3 months. ABV changed it to 5 years Jail !!

CAA-2003 ( SUPPORTED by CONgress and CPM !!!!! ) :

- Section 2 consists of “Definitions” and NOW an Illegal Migrant was defined for the first time !!
- Section 3 : Both parents need to be Indian Citizens, or one foreigner-parent should not be an
illegal migrant !!
- Section 4 & 6 : No illegal migrant can get a citizenship under these sections ( Registration or
Naturalization )
- Section 7 new additions were made : OCI were included in the Act
- New section 14-A was included. It was related to NRC and Central Govt had right to make rules
of NRC and detailed rules were proposed.
Mannu told LKAdvani in the parliament that this CAA-2003 was excellent step, but NDA government
should be lenient towards Bangladeshi Persecuted Illegal Immigrants !! LKA said to Mannu that the
persecuted illegals would be considered as Bonafide Refugees !!

CAA-2003 : Rules were made for NPR/NRC !!

2004 : Changes in Foreigners Act 1946. Amendment in Foreigners Act 2004 : Various Jail terms for
various crimes of illegal citizenship – 2 years upto 8 years !!!

2014 – Election manifesto of Modi : Illegal Migrants to be removed from India &
Hindu’s/Sikhs/Jain/Bauddha who are persecuted, to get Indian citizenship.

5
So after winning Modi-Govt decided 6 persecuted religions Hindu, Sikh, Bauddha, Jain, Christian, Parsi
from 3 neighboring countries Bangladesh, Pakistan, Afghanistan ( Excluded : Atheists, Jews, Specific
sub-muslims like Shia’s, Ahmadiah’s, Hazaaraa’s, Sufi’s, etc )
Date decided was the above persecuted people who ALREADY came and SETTLED in India BEFORE
31st Dec 2014, would be given an Indian citizenship ( NorthEast region was not happy with this, Assam in
particular )
Modi-Govt is NOT making Persecuted Hindu’s as citizens if they are illegals and came AFTER 31st
Dec 2014 !! So there is no BIAS here at all with respect to religion and Modi-Govt just wants to say
that all illegal immigrants who came into India in the “CONgress times” or BEFORE “Modi-
AmitShah times” have to be treated with a LAW !! Simple !!!

2015 – Passport Act was amended : 5 year jail term not applicable to above-mentioned persecuted
people.
2016 – Same amendment of Passport Act was included in the rules of Foreigners Act 1964.

2016–CAB proposed that the above-mentioned persecuted people were removed from the “Illegal
Migrants” definition. CAB-2016 was rejected by Joint Parliamentary Committee & the upper house. JPC
recommended to remove the names of religions and put the word “Persecuted Minorities – and define the
minorities in the RULES of CAA-2016. But Modi-Govt knew that “RULES of an Act” are easy to change
than to change an ACT itself and that the “next” government can easily change the RULES. So basically
it was a PLAY of words of politicians, whereas Modi was DIRECT to the point.

2017 Myanmar - a law was passed whereby Rohingya’s became Stateless! Approx 30k Rohingya’s
entered India in just one year in 2017 through the Eastern states of WestBengal, etc. All CONmen are
supporting these illegal Rohingyas !!!

CAB-2019, following changes were proposed with respect to CAB-2016 :

• Date of citizenship shall be “from” the date of their entry into India. This helped them to be legal
residents of India and if any children born lateron to them, those children could also be Indian
citizens.
• Period of Naturalization (to get Citizenship ) was reduced to 6 years from the earlier rule of 12
years stay in India ( 5 years + 1 continuous year in India )
• All immigration related court cases on those people would be abolished.
• North East Solution : All provisions of CAB-2019 would not be applicable to regions which have
6th Schedule or Inner Line Permit ( ILP ) system.
o Constitution marks some areas called as 6th Schedule under its Article 244 ( Part 10 )
marks certain Districts/Areas called as Scheduled Areas. They are some districts
governed by an Autonomous District Council (ADC) & some areas governed by an
Autonomous Regional Council ( ARC) . They have some specific Legislative powers, some
specific executive powers & some specific Judicial powers.
6th Schedule is currently in India in some areas of 4 states : Assam (3 areas – 30%),
Tripura ( 70% in one area ), Mizoram ( almost all area of the state, 3 areas ) &
Meghalaya ( 3 areas, almost all area of the state except Shillong )
o Inner Line Permit ( ILP ) : 1873 Regulations to protect tribal areas in North East a permit
is required to visit these states. They brought a regulation: The Bengal East Frontier
Regulation. A permit is required ILP to visit these tribal areas. ILP is STILL applied in the
entire states of Arunachal Pradesh, Nagaland, Mizoram & Manipur
o ADC, ARP & ILP were brought in India under constitutional Article 19/5 to achieve
reasonable restrictions to Indian citizens to BUY land in any part of India. These
reasonable restrictions are brought in for the protection of the Tribal Areas ( Also
applied in other areas of the areas like Andaman-Nicobar, etc )

CAA-2019 : JPC finally passed the bill and next day it was passed in Lok Sabha and the following day in
Rajya Sabha !!

6
Rules of CAA-2019 were to be made by Home Ministry and yet to be presented to Loksabha and
RajyaSabha because of Covid-19 emergencies and Home Ministry staff is extremely busy elsewhere.
Opposition say it is to please Assam State election voters – whereas these very CONmen have NO right
to speak about Assam matters as they were sleeping from 1947 till 2014 for illegal migrants issues in
Assam that has ALREADY changed the demographics of Assam’s ethnic population. RULES are
expected to be presented in April & July to LS & RS respectively.
People need to know the ENTIRE background explained above regarding Illegal migrants, so that ANY
politician of ANY party cannot put anything wrong in our minds.
----------------------------------------------------

Legality of CAA-2019 in Supreme Court :

* Several petitions are there in SC now. Fundamental Rights is in question THEY say and THEY wanted
a Stay !! SC refused a Stay and asked for a constitutional bench of 5 judges. But Constitutional Bench
already has too many tasks at hand ( eg Shabrimala, etc )
* THEY say it violates Article 14 ( Right to equality before law and equal protection of law ). There
cannot be equality found in everything. It should not be ( for example Reservation system in India
violates the very concept of equality, Colorblind person cannot become a IPS but can become a IAS, there
is no Uniform Civil Codes in India, etc ). Government will present CAA as a Reasonable Classification
(RC) & “not” an Arbitrary Classification (AC).
Reasonable Classification (RC) 2 criteria :
a) Intelligible Differentia ( easy to comprehend ) & Rational Nexus ( logical connection with the
differentia & motive/purpose ) : Modi-Govt will give various explanations : “Religious Persecution” in
the CAA-2019 description itself gives an “Intelligible Differentia”, as only MINORITIES can be
subjected to Religious Persecution. Govt will also give the example of Nehru-Liaqat Ali pact of 1950-51
which allowed MINORITIES to enter India because they COULD get exposed to Religious persecution.
Purpose served to such Religiously Persecuted people is to give a Citizenship.
b) Presumption : SC will go with a thought that CAA brought by Legal method is RIGHT and the onus is
on THEM to prove it is a Wrong Act !!
c) THEY say that it violates the concept of SECULARISM ( article 25 especially ) : Modi Govt. will give
an explanation that Indian secularism is Positive Secularism ( and not Negative Secularism found in
countries like France ). Supreme Court has already MANY TIMES said this that India is a Positive
Secular State. SC will say that our own Indian Minorities ( Article 29 & 30 ) have special
rights/provisions/protection ALREADY given. For example Article 30-1-A has a provision that
Government can confiscate land of a certain institution ( School/college/etc ) if it belongs to a
MINOROTY religion ONLY if the Govt gives Market-Value of the land, to such Minority owner.
Another Example can be given – like by Article 15-5 Government can make RESERVATION in college
admissions/fees/etc for all other institutions, except Minority-Run-Institutions !!! So why not give
protection to minorities of our Neighbor Countries ? Which country would the Hindu’s Sikhs, Jains go to
if they are religiously persecuted ( Uganda, SriLanka, etc minorities were allowed in India in the past ).
Same discussion would also lead to Nehru-Liaqat pact. One of the GREATEST Indians considered by
CONgress, empathizes with the MONORITIES illegal immigrants :
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cmBqCWbqL_I
d) THEY say that CAA will promote under-inclusivity ( why only 3 countries, why only religious
persecutions, why only 6 religions chosen, and why the cut off date of 31st Dec 2014 ) : Government will
give the following explanations :
- Only 3 BORDERING countries have a “state-sponsored-religion” and hence there is a possibility of
minority persecution. No other bordering countries have DECLARED themselves as a Religious-State.
- Why Religious-Persecuted only – answer of the Government would be very simple – Why not OBC
from 1947 onwards and why OBC reservations started in ONLY in 1990 ? Similarly why Economically
Weaker Section (EWS) reservations from 2019 onwards and why not from 1947 onwards itself ? etc.
Quite logical arguments that – why Not religious-persecuted now and other categories/religions at other
times in future ? SC will keep its mouth shut on this.
- Why only 6 religions included ? Govt’s arguments would be Muslims in Pakistan-Bangladesh-
Afghanistan would NOT be “religiously” persecuted because they are Muslim-SelfDeclared-countries and
a Majority cannot be religiously persecuted. Sub-religious Muslims COULD be considered IN FUTURE.
Jews already have a place to go ( Israel ); also NO complaints received in India for religious persecution

7
of Jews and population is extremely low for e.g. Afghanistan has 1 (ONE) Jew citizen only ! Atheists
would be dealt one to one as there are very few cases like these.
- Why only 31st Dec 2014 ? Government will then ask the opposition or the Supreme Court to chose a
date J Also second argument would be that 2014 is when Modi came into power !! 31st December or 1st
January is always a good date for EASE of implementation.

Difference between CENSUS and NRC/NPR :

Census : Done by Home Ministry ( Registrar of General Census, Census Commissioner, Registrar of
Birth & Death) every 10 years ( 1872 was the first time done in India ). Census Act 1948 defines the
Rules and procedures. Birth & Death Act 1969 helps this department to update records as they happen.
Specific phases of CENSUS every 10 years ( in 2 stages – House Listing & Enumeration/counting ).
Because of Covid, the 2021 Census procedures will start late. Census looked only if a person is SC or ST
( 1931 was the last time where sub caste/religion counting was done ….and the WORST part that
CONgress did was that they did not do OBC from 1990 to 2011 and the Census done in 2011, is were not
PUBLISHED by the DIRTY conGRESS government till 2014…reason was that Hindu’s for the first time
came below 80% !! ). Language, Literacy, Electricity availability, Drinking Water availability, Divyaang
and other socio economic parameters like Urbanization, Agricultural population, other economic activity,
etc.

NPR/NRC first time was mentioned in the CAA-2003 Rules. Both NRC & NPR are to be done by the
same Registrar/Commissioner that is mentioned above !!

National Population Register – NPR

What ? – Population consists of “Usual Residents” i.e. those who stay in a local resident area for 6
months, or who intend to stay in an area for 6 months. Not necessarily “citizens”.
When ? in 2010 NPR was done for the first time along with Census - because CONgress had agreed to
Vajpayee’s 2003-CAA Rules of doing a NPR !!!!! In 2015 it was updated by Modi-Govt. Because of
Covid 2020 NPR exercise was postponed ( it was to be done along with Census Housing Listing ).
Documentation ? In the NPR done in 2010 by CONgress, the CONmen took 14 details from the
population. Modi-Govt has increased those details to 21 and told that those who do not know the answers
to those details, it is NOT COMPULSORY !! Additional 7 details : Mother’s place of birth, Father’s
place of birth, Passport No, Voter Card No (even a verbal confirmation that his parents/grandparents had
VOTED and were in the voter’s list ! ), Driving License No, Mobile Phone No, Aadhaar Card No. Local
Registrar can take an Affidavit that the person cannot find his document ( Voter Card, Birth Certificate,
etc ).
Just answer - You Have or Do not have. Then just SHOW these documents.
These documents are not required to be SUBMITTED to the government.

National Register of Citizens – NRC

What ? Make a LIST of Indian Citizens, including NRI’s !!!!!!!!!
When ? Nehru did NRC in 1951 ONLY in Assam ( See details given above ). CONmen did not do NRC
after the Assam Accord for vote-bank reasons !! CONmen tried to do NRC in 2010 in Assam. A Pilot
project was done in 2 districts. There was Violence all over the 2 districts and CONgress stopped the
process. SC gave orders in 2015 to do NRC in Assam to fulfill the Assam Accord 1984. It was completed
in 2019.
Documentation ? NONE - if NPR details were given by the citizens satisfactorily.
2003-CAA which was passed (accepted) by CONgress and other parties in the parliament, rules
mentioned clearcut the method of doing NRC. Local Registrar LR ( Panchaayat level ), Sub District
Registrar/magistrate SDR & District Registrar/magistrate DR, State Registrar SR, and National Registrar
NR, mentioned above - are the guys responsible to do NRC. The Local Registrar will just put
DOUBTFUL (D) in front of the name written down at the time of doing NPR !! Then a notification would
be made to that person and chance of scrutiny would be given to that doubtful person. He brings
documents or witnesses and a decision is made by the Local Registrar. The LR then makes a DRAFT
LOCAL NRC (list) is made and submitted to SDR. All complaints against the LR shall be submitted by
people as an appeal, to the SDR for a decision. Then SDR will publish the LOCAL NRC (list) and then
8
send it to DR. People can also appeal against these Decisions made by SDR to the DR. Then DR will
collect the final list from all districts and send it directly to NR ( not SR).

Modi-Govt has already CLARIFIED that there is no relation between CAA-2019 & NRC & no relation
between CAA-2019 & NPR !!! Just that they all are mentioned in the CAA-2013-RULES and CAA-2003
was also SUPPORTED by CONgress and CPM, etc. Rules say that NPR would be done FIRST. Next will
come NRC which people will not even realize because NPR was already done earlier and authorities
already have the data that they want !

Assam NRC 2019 :

Why ? Because Assam Accord-1985 of Rajiv Gandhi mandated it and CONgress did not IMPLEMENT
the NRC for Assam for many decades. Supreme Court, disgusted with CONmen’s lack of actions for
decades, decided in 2015 that they will supervise the NRC of Assam !!!!!!!!
How ? NRC Seva Kendra ( like Passport Centres ) were setup.
Documents ? Legacy Data was most important reference document : People whose family was in 1951
NRC-list and/or 1971 Voter List did not have to show ANY documentation !! This data was scanned and
made available ON INTERNET to ALL people ( searchable in English/Bangla/Assamese ) and also in the
NRC Kendra’s !!!
Application was to be done by all Assamese people. Other 13 other documents were also acceptable to
prove Indian Citizenship ( for eg. Any citizenship certificate issued to them/parents/grandparents, any
land ownership by them/parents/grandparents, etc )
Primary Draft of NRC was done at Local Panchayat levels. Secondary Verifications were carried out
with the doubtful people. In 2018 a final Draft was made with 40 lakh Illegal Migrants !! Once again
objections/appeals were provided to all those 40 lakh people. Finally around 20 lakh people were declared
as Illegal Migrants, with more than 50% Hindu’s and 60 to 70% were Females ( 3.3 crore applications,
3.11 crore granted NRC entry ) !!!!!! Amit Shah was expecting 60 lakh and he was disappointed J

CORRUPTION being rampant in India and all documents like telephone numbers, driver license, ration
cards, aadhaar cards, etc can be achieved by sitting at home. Modi-Govt asked SC that they wanted to
scrutinize 10 to 15% people ( on the border of Assaam ) ONCE AGAIN , but SC said that already 27% of
the Assamese population was scrutinized VERY well and more scrutiny is not needed. SAME this will
happen for PAN India when Pan India NRC would be done !!!

Implementation of Assam NRC started one year later ..but the Convener issued an order in Oct 2020 to all
DC’s to check these people and their descendants ( around 8k to 10k ) :
1) How come some people who were declared as Illegal Immigrants in Foreigner Tribunals ( as per the
Foreigners Act 2004 ) became Indian citizens in NRC-2019 ?
2) How come the DOUBTFUL VOTERS tagged people by Election Commissioners become Indian
citizens in NRC-2019 ?
3) How come the PENDING LEGAL cases in Foreigner Tribunals, those people became Indian citizens
in NRC-2019 ?
High Court asked the government what was wrong on the PROCESS in the above mistakes. Govt asked
for the RE-CHECK of the earlier demanded 10 to 15% cases of NRC-2019

If the person gets a REJECTION Slip from NRC authority, then he can appeal to Foreigner’s Tribunal (
around 200 such tribunals are coming up in Assam – Pandemic delay ). If Foreigner’s Tribunal declares
him as a foreigner, then that person STILL has a chance to go to High Court !! VERY rare cases appeals
can go to SC ( i.e. if HC says so ). Deportation and Detention shall be done accordingly ( 10 centres in
India - Assam has 6 centres already, Delhi, Goa, Rajasthan & Bangalore. Govt is talking with States to
build more. USA has around 200. Australia has around 400, China has around 400. USA KEEPS and
deports around 4 lakh people every year from these DETENTION CENTRES. UK around 25k are kept in
these centres every year ).

Supreme Court has told Modi-Govt in 2018 to make a new MANUAL for conditions, systems,
procedures and not treat all as criminals ( many could be innocent ). All HUMAN RIGHTS should
9
be applicable ( schools, water, light, etc ), they could contact their lawyers, they can contact their
respective country’s embassy’s, etc. Supreme Court also gave an order recently that if more than 3
years no decision happens, then they are to be RELEASED to the outside world on bail from 2
Indian citizens ( 1 lakh each ) with periodic attendance in the local police station.

NRC would be done through NPR ( most people would give their details in NPR ). NPR would be done at
the time of Census-Housing-Listing. So the costs to implement NRC in India, would be VERY less.

State government cannot reject to do NRC/NPR :

Refer constitutional Articles 365 ( States not following Centre’s rule, then Centre can go to the President
), Article 356 (president’s rule by the Centre that States are not governing in the way they should) &
Article 256 ( Centre to give proofs to the president, as per this article ). Also District Registrar’s ( IAS
officers, ultimate answerable to Centre ) will see to it that Local Registrars and SDR’s perform their
duties well.

Concerns during/after implementation :

• Opposition State-Ruled Governments - How they can avoid NPR/NRC : State department people
( registrar’s etc ) do not carry out their jobs properly and the process is delayed for unending
amount of time ( till that state is ruled by the Modi-Govt ) – or the Chief Minister (verbally) tells
the Local Registrar to not declare ANYBODY as a “doubtful” case
• Local registrar has to take special care in case of married women ( change of name/surname, no
birth/school certificate, no property certificate, etc )
• Local Registrar has to take extra care about Tribal areas, anaath, abandoned children, beggars,
mentally challenged, third gender, uneducated, etc.
• How many Detention Centres needed with good living conditions ? 3000 to 50000 !!!!! Costs to
run them for maybe 1.5 to 10 crore people ?
• 10 years of Tribunal/Court procedures and their costs !!
• Unproductive costs.
• Social tensions ( riots, etc )
• A genuine fear/relief that millions of homeless will register themselves as Illegals because of 3
years of good living conditions.
• Bangladesh, Pakistan and Afghanistan delay on purpose and refuse to take many of the Illegal
Migrants back into their country.

“MY” CONCLUSION :
These concerns to implement NRC are genuine and ESPECIALLY looking at the estimated
FINANCIAL costs of approx 2 to 3 lakh crore rupees to HANDLE THE ILLEGALS, my
suggestion to the government is :
1) Start the NPR/NRC project and make a definitive list – AFTER due processes at the
Tribunal/High-Court/SupremeCourt. Make these illegal guys traceable by some means
(privacy privileges etc are not applicable to them). Try and deport as many as possible.
2) Lateron, make all DECLARED/PROVED Illegal Migrants, including MUSLIMS, as
Citizens/Refugees, but without-voting-rights-only. Re-locate them to many states ( like 1 lakh
Tibetians were done in Himachal, Karnataka, etc ; like Uganda people were relocated in
various villages of Gujarat, etc )
3) But, lekin, kintu, parantu – make all of them citizens/refugees, ONLY AFTER 100% securing
borders reasonably well in say next 5 years ( laser walls, electrified fences, satellite imagery
detection techniques, etc and spending the SAVED money well J ). At least I will not blame
Trump if he wants to build a Wall…..Illegal migrants this is a GENUINE problem and a
RECURRING problem for any progressing country….yes India IS progressing and soon will be a
developed country – Koii Shaque ??

10