LEV Demo No Video - by John Dobbie

Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 44

Joint IOSH/BOHS Control Event

Local Exhaust Ventilation Demo


John Dobbie & Emma Thomson
13th November 2014
Types of ventilation
• Local exhaust ventilation (LEV)
– Potentially very effective way to prevent hazardous
materials entering the workplace atmosphere
– Should collect at source and remove contaminants
away from the worker
– However, in many cases LEV is poorly designed, poorly
used or maintained and is ineffective
• Dilution ventilation
– Reduces background concentration of contaminant by
introducing fresh air. However, little reduction of
contaminant concentration near the source
General Features of an LEV System

Source: Adrian Hirst


General Considerations

Source: UK HSE
Three basic types of LEV hood
Enclosing (Contain and remove)

Receiving (Receive and remove)

Capturing (Capture and remove)

Source: HSE
Enclosing Hood
Potentially most effective type

Contaminant released inside enclosure

Kept separate from worker

Full enclosure
– glove box, shot blast cabinet

Partial enclosure
– fume cupboard, paint spray
booth

Compatibility with work?


Source: HSE
Receptor Hoods

Takes advantage of any directional velocity of contaminants


- from grinding / cutting etc
- from hot processes Source: HSE

Can be affected by other air currents in area


Capturing Hoods
The process, Hood has to generate sufficient
source and airflow at and around the source to
contaminant cloud ‘capture’ and draw in the
are outside the contaminant-laden air
hood
Inlets need to be positioned near
source

Source: HSE (adapted from Hemeon’s Plant and Process Ventilation)


Sometimes the failure is blatant

Source:UK HSE
Sometimes the failure is more subtle

Source:UK HSE
Air flow characteristics of
blowing and extracting
Blowing
d
Approximately 10% of face velocity at
60 diameters away

Exhausting
d
Approximately 10% of face velocity at one
diameter away from exhaust opening

NB: Try sucking out a lighted match!


Inlets - Effective capture zone of
an LEV hood
Flange

Source: UK HSE
Capturing hoods – design considerations

• Size, shape and position of source


• Nature of the contaminant
• Speed and direction of contaminant source
• Type of process and operator requirements
• Process induced air movement and draughts

• These all affect the required capture velocity,


capture distance, airflow etc

Source: HSE
Capture velocities by process
Process Capture velocities

Evaporation from liquids 0.25 – 0.5 m/s

Spraying in large booth, filling, low- 0.5 – 1.0 m/s


speed conveyors
Spraying in small booth, conveyor 1.0 – 2.5 m/s
loading, crushers
Grinding, disc cutting, abrasive 2.5 – 10.0 m/s
blasting
Capture of vapour-laden air:
evaporation
Air velocity required
at this point to
“capture” vapour-laden
air ~0.5 metres per
second (m/s)

Source: UK HSE
Capture of vapour-laden air:
drum filling
Air velocity required
at this point to
“capture” vapour-laden
air ~ 1.0 metres per
second (m/s)

Source: UK HSE
Example: Processed induced air
movement Video clip

Source: UK HSE
Capturing hood capture zone

Source: UK HSE
Rosin solder fume control by capturing hood

Source: UK HSE
Ductwork
Ductwork carries the extracted air and the contaminant from
the inlet to the air cleaning device.

– Velocity must be high enough to keep particulates airborne


(recommended duct or transport velocities)

– Should be sufficiently strong, adequately supported and


capable of withstanding normal wear and tear
– The number of changes of directions should be kept to a
minimum and should be made smoothly
– Access to ducting may be required.
Duct Velocity
Type of contaminant Duct velocity(m/s)
Gases (non-condensing) No minimum limit

Vapours, smoke, fume 10


Light/medium density dust 15
(e.g. sawdust, plastic dust)
Average industrial dusts (e.g. grinding dust, 20
wood shavings, asbestos, silica)
Heavy dusts, (e.g. lead, metal turnings and 25
dusts which are damp or that tend to
agglomerate)

Source: HSE
Air cleaners
• Gas and vapour removal
• Chemical absorption
• Combustion
• Condensation
• Air filters
– Mainly used in ventilation and air conditioning systems
– Handle high volumes of air with low resistance to air
flow
– High resistance, high efficiency (HEPA) filters used for
ultra-clean applications and hazardous dusts e.g.
asbestos
Air cleaners
Particulate and fume collectors – extract large
amounts of particulate at high inlet
concentrations
• Cyclones
– better at collecting larger (>10 micron)
particles
• Fabric filters
– collect particles down to approximately 1
micron (or less)
• Wet collectors
– collect particles down to approximately 5
micron
• Electrostatic precipitators
– collect particles down to approximately 1
micron (or less)
Air Cleaners - Filters

Source: Adrian Hirst


Air Cleaners - Cyclones

Source: Adrian Hirst


Air Movers - Fans

Centrifugal
Axial
Source: US EPA
Fans - Centrifugal
• Air enters fan – exits at right
angle

• Can work against high


resistance

• Usual type of fan for all but the


simplest of LEV systems

• Reverse impeller direction –


gives reduced air flow (in
correct direction)
Fans - Axial
• Air enters along line of axis

• Best for high volumes BUT


against very low resistance

• Not for use with flammable


vapours!

• Reverse direction = reverse


flow
Discharge to atmosphere

• Additional ductwork may be required after the fan to


ensure that any discharges do not re-enter the building via
inlets / windows

• Discharge stacks may need to be extended above roof level


and particular attention should be paid to the design of the
discharge terminal
Discharge to Atmosphere

Source: UK HSE
Maintenance, Examination and Testing
of LEV Systems
In order to function correctly it must be in good
working order.
• Legal requirements
• In UK COSHH Regulations require LEV systems to
be examined / tested at least every 14 months
• Weekly visual check
• Records to be kept for 5 years
• Regular Maintenance
• Thorough Examination and Testing.
Maintenance of LEV systems
Maintenance should include
– Regular inspections, including weekly visual check
• Ensure correct positioning of hoods
• Identify obvious faults
• Signs of malfunction or damage to hoods, ducts or air
cleaners
– Monitoring of performance indicators
• Air velocities, static pressures etc
– Routine replacement of components with limited
working life
– Prompt repair / replacement of damaged components
Thorough Examination and Testing of
Ventilation Systems
A periodic audit of the LEV system and its performance
– Thorough examination of all parts of the system
– Assessment of adequate control
• Using dust lamps, smoke tubes, air monitoring
– Measurement of plant performance
• Static pressures measurements
• Air velocities at inlets and in ducts
• Pressure drops across filters
• Power consumption
• Assessment of filter performance
Smoke Tubes/Tracers

• Useful where
contaminant is not
visible

• Contents may be
harmful / acidic

• Useful to determine
DIRECTION of air
flow!
Visibility of particle clouds

• What you see is not necessarily what’s there

• Fine “respirable” airborne particles are invisible


under normal lighting
Dust Lamp/Tyndall Beam
Tyndall illumination shows more
clearly airborne particles of all sizes
e.g. grain and wood dust

Grain dust

Source: UK HSE
Sanding without Tyndall lighting

Source: UK HSE
Sanding with Tyndall lighting

Source: UK HSE
Measurement of velocity

• Rotating vane anemometers


• Thermal anemometers
• Pitot tube and electronic manometer
– All above need regular calibration
Rotating vane anemometers
• Various sizes
– 25 mm and 100 mm most common

• Averages air flow over a period

• Used for large openings


– Where measurement area is large
relative to instrument size

• Avoid standing in front!


Thermal (hot-wire / thermistor
bead) anemometers
• Air flow cools hot wire / thermistor
– Fast response – difficult to average

• Not intrinsically safe


– Do not use in flammable atmospheres!

• Small sensor head – may be used in


ducts
– Care – easily damaged by particulates

• Hold at arms length with probe in plane


of opening
– May need to rotate probe - particularly at
edges of hood/duct
Face Velocity Measurements
• Air velocity at opening to hood or enclosure
– Indicates capacity to control contaminant

• Measured in the plane of the opening

• Single measurements or grid


measurements for large openings
Measurement – Booths /
fume cupboards
• Face velocities measured in the
‘plane’ of the opening
– Typically 0.5 – 0.7 m/s

• Divide face area into imaginary


equal area rectangles
– take velocity in the centre of each
– investigate readings more than +/-
20% from average

You might also like