VNA Operating Guide For The MSA
VNA Operating Guide For The MSA
VNA Operating Guide For The MSA
2/1/10
The MSA as VNA
Introduction
This Guide contains individual pages to describe the use of the MSA in Trans-
mission Mode [functioning as either a Scalar Network Analyzer (SNA) or a
Vector Network Analyzer (VNA)], or in Reflection Mode. The pages can be
accessed by clicking on the blue headings below, or by using the Bookmarks
tab. This Guide assumes familiarity with the operating procedures set forth in
the Spectrum Analyzer Operating Guide for the MSA.
The first several pages include material that is relevant to a wide range of
measurements:
Fixtures. Basic fixtures for interfacing the DUT to the MSA.
Shunt Fixtures. Specifics on shunt fixtures.
Series Fixtures. Specifics on series fixtures.
Bridges. General description of reflection bridges.
Cal--Transmission. Calibration procedures for Transmission Mode.
Cal--Reflection. Calibration procedures for Reflection Mode
OSL Standards. Construction and characterization of OSL cal standards.
Basic Transmission. Basic procedures for measurement in Transmission
Mode.
Basic Reflection. Basic procedures for measurement in Reflection Mode.
Plane Extension. Eliminating unwanted signal delays from measurements.
The following pages cover what are called Functions, available under the
Functions menu:
Filter. Analysis of filter transmission peaks.
Crystal. Determination of crystal parameters for use in creating filters.
Component Meter. Component measurements similar to an LCR meter.
RLC--Transmission. Modeling devices as RLC combinations, using
Transmission Mode measurements.
RLC--Reflection. Modeling devices as RLC combinations, using
Reflection Mode measurements.
Coax. Measuring characteristics of coax cable or other transmission
lines.
Generate S21--Generating S21 data from S11 measurements for “two
terminal DUTs”
The following pages contain additional measurement procedures:
Coax Z0--Determining characteristic impedance of transmission lines.
Reference Lines--Creating Reference Lines for display or math.
There are three basic types of fixtures for interfacing the MSA to the
device under test (DUT) in SNA and VNA modes. Attenuators may be
external or may be built into the fixture. Buffer amplifiers may be used
in place of attenuators to maintain higher dynamic range.
The main purpose of the attenuators is to present the DUT with a pre-
cise impedance, which is referred to as the R0 of the fixture. Home-
made attenuators are far better for this purpose than commercial
attenuators. R0 may be a value other than 50 ohms if the attenuators
are designed to transform the impedance.
Shunt
6-10 dB
6-10 dB
DUT
But the return loss and attenuation values are based on the assumption of a
50-ohm source and load. In the shunt fixture, the input attenuator sees a
load consisting of the DUT in parallel with the output attenuator, so a zero-
ohm DUT creates a zero-ohm load. This can make the return loss from the
outside of a 7.7 dB attenuator as low as 15 dB.
This design can significantly improve accuracy for low impedance DUTs if
the source or load has return loss worse than about 25 dB, because it
reduces reflections off the outside of the attenuators.
Note that for Reflection Mode measurements when OSL calibration is used
(rather than the simpler Reference calibration), the issue described above is
not important, as the calibration will compensate for the impedances seen
by the DUT.
Series Fixture Specifics
The section discussing shunt fixtures describes resistor values for home-
made attenuators, and discusses the fact that simply attaching standard
attenuators to a fixture does not produce optimal results. For example, in the
case of the series fixture, if the DUT has a large impedance, each attenuator
sees a large load, rather than the 50 ohms that its design assumes. This
causes the return loss at the outside of the attenuators to be very low, caus-
ing large reflections.
The design in the schematic below solves this problem and achieves a
worst-case return loss of 20 dB (with an infinite DUT).
Note that the low values of R3 and R4 also make the return loss from the
outside of the attenuators relatively insensitive to the DUT impedance, so
this fixture also solves the problem discussed above, and could be used for
purposes other than crystal testing.
Bridges
Bridges are normally used only in reflection mode. They are designed so
that their output is proportional to the signal reflected b y the DUT. The
reflection coefficient is then that signal divided by the output level with an
open DUT (since an open creates a 100% reflection). In dB, that division is
done by subtraction.
Their quality can be judged by their directivity, which is the reflection coeffi-
cient (in dB) with a 50-ohm DUT (which should have zero reflection), and by
whether the open and short reflections have equal magnitude but opposite
phase. A bridge with good directivity and well matched open/short can be
used with just Reference calibration. In fact, it can even be used in Transmis-
sion Mode, by doing a scan of the bridge with the Open attached, and compar-
ing that level to a scan with the DUT attached. The difference is S11.
The Active Bridge is constructed with two op amps, and has extremely high
precision to 30 MHz and very good precision beyond 100 MHz, and thus is suit-
able for use with Reference calibration. Its active components allow it to mea-
sure reflections accurately with minimal signal loss.
Most passive bridges involve baluns with ferrite cores. The basic bridge design,
with optional modest attenuators at the input and output, typically result in loss
of 14-20 dB with passive bridges. That is, the maximum output (with an open or
short DUT) is 14-20 dB below the input level.
The Parallel Line Bridge is a passive bridge good from 1 MHz to beyond 1 GHz.
Its directivity is excellent over a broad range, but its open/short match is not
ideal. It therefore can be used with Reference calibration for measuring return
losses of 20 dB and higher, where directivity is the primary consideration. With
OSL calibration, its performance is excellent.
5. Click Perform Band Cal. The MSA will conduct one sweep to gath-
er calibration Data. During the calibration sweep, a minimum Wait
time of 110 ms is used, regardless of your Wait time setting. Howev-
er, if your setting is greater than 110 ms, that longer time will be
used.
6. If you want to save the Band Cal as a Base Cal file, click Save
Base Cal.
7. Click Done. You may now attach a DUT and click Restart.
Shunt
6-10 dB
6-10 dB
Series
6-10 dB
6-10 dB
2. Open Operating Cal-->Perform Cal. Click Perform Band Cal to open the
reflection mode calibration window.
3. Select whether you want to use Reference calibration (one standard; gen-
erally not used above 150 MHz) or Full OSL (three standards; highest
accuracy.)
4. For Reference calibration, select the fixture type. If Shunt Fixture, you
may enter the connector delay time. A delay of 0.115 ns is typical for an
SMA connector.
5. Attach the appropriate calibration standard and click the button “Perform
X”, where X is the name of the standard. For Full OSL, there will be a button
for each of the three standards, and a sweep must be performed for each
one. For Reference calibration, only one sweep is needed.
7. When finished, click Done. You will be back to the Perform Calibrations
window. If you want to save the Band Cal internally as a Base Cal, click Save
Base Cal.
8. Click Done. You may now attach a DUT and click Restart.
OSL Calibration Standards
We will consider here the construction of calibration standards to attach to a
male SMA connector coming from the test fixture. The standards will be mounted
on female connectors as shown below:
The legs are broken off the female connector (two can be left in place if desired).
The Open is constructed by grinding the center pin flush on the back of the female
connector. That pin is also ground almost flush for the Short and Load. The Short
has a piece of brass sheet (with a hole poked in the center) soldered on the back;
if the corners are notched with a Nibbler tool, the resulting cross shape sits nicely
between the stubs of the broken-off legs, which hold it in place during soldering.
The Load is made by soldering two 100-ohm 0805 resistors on the back in opposite
directions; or four 200-ohm 0603 resistors can be used.
It is important to note where the test fixture ends and the DUT begins. If we are
going to solder DUTs on the back of similar connectors, then the back plane of the
female connector is where the DUT starts; everything left of that, including the
front of the calibration standard connector, is part of the test fixture. In this case,
the standards are properly described as an open, short and load without any con-
nector delay--the connector is not part of the standard. The dividing point between
the test fixture and the DUT is called the Calibration Plane or Reference Plane.
(Some distinguish between these two terms; we use them interchangeably.)
If the DUT already has its own connector, then the DUT will begin at the mating
plane. In that case, our standards consist of the entire female connector, including
what is on the backside. We must then describe the Open and Short standards as
having some built-in delay, which we measure in ns. In addition, the Short will have
some loss due to skin effect, which we describe as a parallel resistor||inductor. As
long as the connector characteristic impedance is 50 ohms, the connector and
Load resistors will still appear together as a perfect 50 ohms, so we do not need to
specify a delay. It is permissible for the resistance to be a few tenths off of 50
ohms, as long as the true resistance is known.
When performing OSL calibration, the calibration window allows the characteris-
tics of the standards to be entered, or the standards can be specified as pre-
measured standards, which are still under development.
Basic Transmission Mode Measurements
VNA or SNA Transmission Mode
MSA
Video Filter=Mid or Narrow
Wait Time>=15
TG IN
Shunt Series
6-10 dB
6-10 dB
6-10 dB
6-10 dB
Fixture OR Fixture
DUT
DUT
Calibration
Preliminary measurements in Transmission Mode are sometimes
made without calibration, to get a general idea where dramatic
changes occur. But such measurements are generally preceded by
reference calibration, to establish a signal level and phase against
which to compare the DUT’s transmission.
Settings:
Wait time should be >=15 ms, but should be 50-150 ms for precision
work, and should be at least 50 ms if video filter is Narrow.
MSA
Video Filter=Mid or Narrow
Wait Time>=15
TG IN
Shunt Series
6-10 dB
6-10 dB
6-10 dB
6-10 dB
6-10 dB
6-10 dB
Fixture OR Fixture OR Bridge
DUT
DUT
DUT
Calibration
Measurements in Reflection Mode are virtually meaningless unless pre-
ceded by calibration. Reference calibration can be used up to 150 MHz,
depending on the quality of the fixture and the required accuracy. OSL
calibration can be used with any fixture for any frequency range.
Settings:
Wait time should be >=15 ms, but should be 50-150 ms for precision
work, and should be at least 50 ms if video filter is Narrow.
Transmission Mode
The device being tested may include connectors or other causes of sig-
nal delay that we don’t actually consider part of the DUT. Extra delay
typically causes the phase graph to tilt downward to the right, as any
given distance will cause more phase delay at higher frequencies, caus-
ing phase to become more negative (or less positive). Plane Extension
can eliminate that tilt.
Reflection Mode
The device being tested may be connected to the test fixture with a con-
nector, or PCB trace that we don’t consider part of the DUT. Plane
Extension can extend the Calibration Plane (which is essentially the
dividing line between fixture and DUT) to a point closer to the true DUT.
The unwanted signal delay causes a phase delay that increases at high-
er frequencies and shows up on the Smith chart as a clockwise rotation
that increases with frequency. It also shows up on a regular graph of
S11 as a downward tilt similar to that described for Transmission Mode.
Procedure
Plane Extension is accomplished by entering an adjustment factor in the
Plane Extension box in the Sweep Parameters window. That factor is the
delay, in nanoseconds, that needs to be eliminated. The effect of the
extension can be viewed immediately by clicking the Recalc button
underneath the box.
MSA
Video Filter=Mid or Narrow
Wait Time>=15
TG IN
Shunt Series
6-10 dB
6-10 dB
6-10 dB
6-10 dB
Fixture OR Fixture
Filter
Filter
4. Quit the function window. The desired points are marked and
information is displayed in and next to the marker info area.
5. Continue the scan, and the markers and other information will
be updated at the end of each scan.
MSA
Video Filter=Narrow
Wait Time>=50
TG IN
Series
6-10 dB
6-10 dB
Fixture
XTAL
1. Perform a line calibration with a short in a Series Fixture. A 12.5-ohm
fixture is the standard for crystal analysis, but a 50-ohm fixture works well.
5. You may create a list of crystals with their parameters by clicking Add
To List. You must quit the function to do a scan for another crystal, but the
list will continue until you close its window. Crystals in the list are num-
bered sequentially, but you may change the current number by clicking Set
ID.
Component Meter Function
Reflection Mode or VNA/SNA Transmission Mode
Continuously measures and displays the values of resistors, inductors or capaci-
tors. Measurements are made at relatively low frequencies to avoid self-resonance
effects. More extensive capabilities are available in the RLC Analysis Functions.
MSA
Video Filter=Narrow
TG IN
LPF
attenuate signals
Compon=Single Resistor, from 1 GHz-1.1GHz
Inductor or Capacitor
6-10 dB
6-10 dB
Shunt Series Bridge
6-10 dB
6-10 dB
6-10 dB
6-10 dB
Fixture OR Fixture OR
Compon
Compon Compon
1. (Optional) Attach a low pass filter if you will be measuring larger components
that the MSA will choose to measure at 100 kHz to 500 kHz. This will filter out high
frequency TG signals that increasingly limit the dynamic range below 500 kHz.
3. Select the fixture type being used, and enter its R0, which is the resistance seen
by the DUT looking into each attenuator. For the Shunt Fixture, you may enter the
connector delay, in ns; 0.115 ns is typical for an SMA connector. Attach the proper
Open or Short connection and click Calibrate. In Reflection Mode, click Calibrate
first, and enter the fixture information in the Reflection Calibration window if neces-
sary. (It is not necessary for full OSL.)
4. Select the checkbox for the type of component to measure, attach it to the fixture
and click Measure. The Measure button will change to Stop and the component
value will be measured and displayed continuously until you click Stop. You may
swap components while the measurement is in progress.
5. Once you click Stop, you may click +Freq or -Freq to obtain measurements at
other frequencies.
RLC Analysis Function
VNA or SNA Transmission Mode
MSA
Video Filter=Mid or Narrow
Wait Time>=15
TG IN
Shunt Series
6-10 dB
6-10 dB
6-10 dB
6-10 dB
Fixture OR Fixture
R
L
R C
R L C L R L C
C
3. Select the fixture type being used, and enter its R0, which is the resis-
tance seen by the DUT looking into each attenuator. For the Shunt Fixture,
you may enter the connector delay, in ns. 0.115 ns is typical for an SMA con-
nector.
5. Click Analyze; the results will be displayed. You may then click +Freq
or -Freq to change the frequency for which results are displayed.
RLC Analysis Function
VNA Reflection Mode
Models a circuit as a combination of a resistor, inductor and capacitor,
which may be actual components or parasitics. Calculates the values
of those components, and Q factors, and also creates graphs of those
values which can be viewed after exiting the function.
MSA
Video Filter=Narrow
Wait Time>=50
TG IN
Shunt Series
6-10 dB
6-10 dB
6-10 dB
6-10 dB
6-10 dB
6-10 dB
Fixture OR Fixture OR Bridge
RLC
R
R L C R
L
L C
C
Open or
Shorted
3. Click Analyze, which will display the R, L and C values, and the Q, all
at a specified frequency. You may temporarily move to a different fre-
quency by clicking +Freq or -Freq.
MSA
Video Filter=Narrow
Wait Time>=50
TG IN
Shunt
6-10 dB
6-10 dB
6-10 dB
6-10 dB
OR Bridge
Fixture
TERM
TERM
4. Click Analyze. The resonant frequency, length, velocity factor and loss
factor (A0, dB per hundred feet) are displayed, and the Analyze Z0 button
appears.
For certain types of DUTs, which we call “two-terminal DUTS”, the transmission
characteristics (S21) of the DUT can be calculated from the reflection charac-
teristics (S11). Two-terminal DUTs include devices with exactly two connections,
such as resistors, capacitors and inductors, or series or parallel combinations
of those devices. They also include devices that have one connection plus a per-
manent or implicit ground, such as a wire antenna. Two-terminal DUTs are effec-
tively nothing but an impedance, and we can hypothetically place that imped-
ance in a series or shunt fixture, and calculate the S21 of the device in that
fixture.
1. After proper calibration, do an S11 scan of the DUT. Note that one terminal is
always grounded in S11 scans.
3. The window will close and the generated S21 values will be graphed. As for all
Function graphs, these are temporary graphs created by the function, which are
listed as graph options in the Y-axis windows until the next Restart.
4. If desired, you may re-open Generate S21 to modify the selected fixture or R0.
It is not necessary for the original S11 values to actually be graphed for Gener-
ate S21 to work.
LC Example
If a reflection scan is performed with a parallel or series LC combination, the
resulting S11 values can be used to generate S21 graphs that show how the LC
combination would perform as a filter. The R0 used for the series fixture can be
the actual source/load values of the filter’s intended environment. Or, by using a
very high R0 value, such as 100 kOhms, the S21 graphs will effectively show the
profile of the response of the LC combination with no load (though the absolute
level of the entire response profile will be shifted downward). In the latter case,
Q can be determined by dividing the center frequency by the -3 dB bandwidth,
and that Q value is effectively the unloaded Q (Qu).
Coax Z0
There are several ways on the MSA to measure characteristic impedance (Z0) of
transmission Lines.
RLC References
You can create a reference line from simulated RLC data, just as though the cur-
rent scan contained that data. “RLC data” is a parallel or series RLC combination,
that optionally can be treated as terminating a transmission line. This is useful if
you want to compare graph data to some RLC combination, to see how well the
DUT can be modeled by that combination.
Reference lines are temporary objects, in that they are created for short-term use.
They are not saved when you save Preferences or Test Setups. If you change the
frequency range settings, any Saved Data Reference will disappear, but Fixed
Value or RLC References will survive.
RETURN LOSS REFERENCE
RETURN LOSS AND RELATED QUANTITIES
Return Loss is the negative of S11 magnitude, in dB. The reflection coeffi-
cient magnitude is the S11 magnitude expressed as a ratio from 0 to 1, rep-
resenting the proportion of the signal voltage that is reflected. The square
of that ratio gives the reflected power ratio, expressed above as a percent-
age.
Each value of Return Loss can be generated by two pure resistances, one
greater than 50 ohms and one less than 50 ohms. Those resistances equal
50*SWR and 50/SWR. That Return Loss can also be generated by any resis-
tance in-between those two values combined with the necessary capaci-
tance or inductance.
THE SMITH CHART-PART 1
The impedance at any point on the chart can be read from the grid lines.
The circles represent constant resistance (marked on the center line)
and the arcs represent constant reactance (marked at the boundary).
The impedance at a point is based on the resistance circle and reac-
tance arc that cross at that point.
Thus, the nature of a device can be quickly judged based on where its
reflection coefficient is graphed. Anything with a capacitive component
is in the bottom half; inductive components are in the top half, and pure
resistances are on the horizontal center line.
THE SMITH CHART-PART 2
The Smith Chart is particularly useful for viewing graphs that follow a cir-
cular path. All Smith Chart graphs proceed in a generally clockwise
direction as the frequency increases, but the most interesting ones actu-
ally trace out partial or complete circles. Below are such graphs:
The left graph is a capacitor, and therefore lies entirely on the lower
boundary, starting at high impedance at marker 1 and moving to mark-
er 2 as the frequency increases. The right graph is a parallel coil and
capacitor, which begins as an inductance at marker 1 and moves
clockwise, falling away from the boundary due to inductor losses. At
marker 2 it reaches resonance (because it is crossing the center line
of pure resistances), after which it becomes capacitive and moves on
to marker 3.