Scribd Logo
Upload

Welcome to Scribd!

  • 9 views

    PTCPLZ23 TR4 Preliminary Data Analysis ASM Mar 08 2023 v1

    Uploaded by

    andrew.vpci
    The document analyzes two curtain wall designs - a baseline and an upgraded design - for a building project to identify the most energy efficient and cost-effective option. Quantitative and qualitative evaluation matrices were used to rate and score the designs against criteria such as energy use, costs, and environmental impacts. The results showed the upgraded design met or exceeded criteria in all cases, with higher ratings and total scores. It was concluded to have better thermal resistance and reduce annual energy use and costs. The document recommends using the upgraded curtain wall to support sustainable construction goals.

    Copyright:

    © All Rights Reserved
    Download as PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd

    PTCPLZ23 TR4 Preliminary Data Analysis ASM Mar 08 2023 v1

    Uploaded by

    andrew.vpci
    9 views2 pages
    The document analyzes two curtain wall designs - a baseline and an upgraded design - for a building project to identify the most energy efficient and cost-effective option. Quantitative and qualitative evaluation matrices were used to rate and score the designs against criteria such as energy use, costs, and environmental impacts. The results showed the upgraded design met or exceeded criteria in all cases, with higher ratings and total scores. It was concluded to have better thermal resistance and reduce annual energy use and costs. The document recommends using the upgraded curtain wall to support sustainable construction goals.

    Original Title

    PTCPLZ23_TR4_Preliminary_Data_Analysis_ASM_Mar_08_2023_v1

    Copyright

    © © All Rights Reserved

    Available Formats

    PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd

    Did you find this document useful?

    Is this content inappropriate?

    The document analyzes two curtain wall designs - a baseline and an upgraded design - for a building project to identify the most energy efficient and cost-effective option. Quantitative and qualitative evaluation matrices were used to rate and score the designs against criteria such as energy use, costs, and environmental impacts. The results showed the upgraded design met or exceeded criteria in all cases, with higher ratings and total scores. It was concluded to have better thermal resistance and reduce annual energy use and costs. The document recommends using the upgraded curtain wall to support sustainable construction goals.

    Copyright:

    © All Rights Reserved
    Download as PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
    Download as pdf or txt
    9 views2 pages

    PTCPLZ23 TR4 Preliminary Data Analysis ASM Mar 08 2023 v1

    Uploaded by

    andrew.vpci
    The document analyzes two curtain wall designs - a baseline and an upgraded design - for a building project to identify the most energy efficient and cost-effective option. Quantitative and qualitative evaluation matrices were used to rate and score the designs against criteria such as energy use, costs, and environmental impacts. The results showed the upgraded design met or exceeded criteria in all cases, with higher ratings and total scores. It was concluded to have better thermal resistance and reduce annual energy use and costs. The document recommends using the upgraded curtain wall to support sustainable construction goals.

    Copyright:

    © All Rights Reserved
    Download as PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
    Download as pdf or txt
    You are on page 1of 2

    MALLARI A CONSTRUCTION LTD

    1234 Mountain Rd, Moncton, NB E1C 8H9

    MEMORANDUM
    To: Mr. Robert Streatch Date: March 08, 2023

    From: Andrew Steven G. Mallari Cc: Mr. Chris Chapman

    Subject: TR4 – Preliminary Data Analysis, Project No. COMM1022.2022.23.01

    Our group aims to demonstrate to Collaborative Developments the evaluation methods intended to
    increase energy effectiveness and reduce carbon emissions. In order to achieve sustainable construction
    and lower operating costs, the approach required applying the evaluation matrix and financial analysis
    to identify the economic factors. Refer to Table 1 and Table 2 for the preferred design analysis.
    Table 1. Quantitative Evaluation Matrix Criteria and Rating Scale
    Wall 1 – Rear Side Baseline Wall 2 – Rear Side
    Curtain Wall Upgraded Curtain Wall
    Criterion Weight Rating Score Rating Score
    RSI / U 25(p) 5 125 5 125
    Energy Use 25(p) 5 125 5 125
    Operational Cost 25(p) 4 100 5 125
    Green House Gas Production / 25(p) 4 100 5 125
    Carbon Emissions
    Total Score Σ100 Σ450 Σ500

    Table 2. Qualitative Evaluation Matrix Criteria and Rating Scale


    Wall 1 – Rear Side Baseline Wall 2 – Rear Side Upgraded
    Curtain Wall Curtain Wall
    Criterion Weight Rating Score Rating Score
    User Comfort / User 5(p) 5 25 5 25
    Performance
    Environmental Stewardship / 15(p) 5 75 5 75
    Morale
    Aesthetics 10(p) 4 40 5 50
    System Compatibility 5(p) 4 20 5 25
    Quality / Durability of Material 20(p) 4 80 5 100
    or Service
    Constructability 15(p) 5 75 5 75
    Safeguards and Security 15(p) 5 75 5 75
    Material Availability 15(p) 5 75 5 75
    Total Score Σ100 Σ465 Σ500
    Scale Description Interpretation
    5 Always Satisfied Meets the design and code in all cases.
    4 Often Satisfied Meets the design and code in most cases.
    3 Fairly Satisfied Meets the design or code in cases.
    2 Less Satisfied Neither meets to design nor code.
    1 Not Satisfied Never meets the design and code.
    0 Not at all Nothing at all.

    Phone: +1 (506) 850-4139 www.maconstructionltd.com Page | 1


    MALLARI A CONSTRUCTION LTD
    1234 Mountain Rd, Moncton, NB E1C 8H9

    Conclusion and recommendation

    The evaluation results show that the Wall 2 – upgraded curtain wall meets all the design and codes in all
    cases. The group concluded that the upgraded curtain wall rating and score are evaluated higher than
    the baseline curtain wall. According to the design, the thermal resistance of the baseline curtain wall
    and high-performance curtain wall are 0.69 W/m² K and 0.51 W/m² K, respectively, with the annual
    energy use of 168,562 MJ and 124,590MJ, respectively, resulting in annual energy costs of $5,216 and
    $3,855 with a return on investment of 6.7%. This data came from the calculation of spatial separation
    analysis and energy uses.

    The group recommends building commissioning processes that are as efficient as possible toward
    achieving sustainable construction using upgraded curtain walls.

    Andrew Steven G. Mallari


    Mallari A Construction Ltd

    Phone: +1 (506) 850-4139 www.maconstructionltd.com Page | 2

    You might also like