DOUBLE ISSUE NOV. 7 / NOV.

14, 20 22

THE PLANET WE MADE

STARE AT THE GREEN HEART FOR 12 SECONDS,
THEN TURN THE PAGE AND KEEP STARING
DOUBLE ISSUE NOV. 7 / NOV. 14, 20 22

THE PLANET WE NEED

YOU HAVE JUST CREATED A SOCIAL SCULPTURE.
TO PROTECT THE EARTH, WE MUST SEE IT ANEW
ART WORK BY OL AFUR ELIASSON

time.com
CONTENTS

Alexis Grefa, a Kichwa

Indigenous activist, takes a dip
in the Piatúa River, which he
seeks to protect
Photograph by Andrés Yépez for TIME

4 Time November 7/November 14, 2022

 VOL. 200, NOS. 17–18 | 2022

9
The Brief
23
The View
32
Gathering of the Vibes
How voters feel about the candidates
may matter more than the issues
By Charlotte Alter
Plus: Arizona gubernatorial hopeful
Kari Lake, rising Republican star
By Eric Cortellessa 38

41
Climate in the Balance
Appealing to wealthy countries’ sense
of climate justice hasn’t worked, but
reframing the conversation around
issues of self-interest could
By Justin Worland

The importance of loss and damage

By Aryn Baker 45

Viewpoints: The Bridgetown Initiative

By Mia Mottley A climate migrant in
Uganda By Nyombi Morris What the
world can learn from Bangladesh
By Saleemul Huq How Egypt stifles
environmental activism By Sahar Aziz 50

In Ecuador, green-energy developers go

head-to-head with river defenders
By Mélissa Godin 52

60
Disrupter Maestro
Gustavo Dudamel, the Los Angeles
Philharmonic’s artistic director, brings
classical music to the masses
By Ed Leibowitz

65
Time Off
For customer service and our general terms and conditions, visit timeeurope.com/customerservice, or call +44
1858 438 830 or write to TIME, Tower House, Lathkill Street, Market Harborough, LE16 9EF, United Kingdom. In South
Africa, write to Private Bag 1, Centurion 0046. PRINT SUBSCRIPTIONS: Visit time.com/joinus38. REPRINTS AND
PERMISSIONS: Visit time.com/reprints. For custom reprints, visit timereprints.com. ADVERTISING For advertising rates
and our editorial calendar, visit timemediakit.com. TIME is published twice a month by Time Magazine UK Ltd, Suite 1,
3rd Floor, 11-12 St James’s Square, London, SW1Y 4LB. TIME is printed in the Netherlands and the U.K. Le Directeur de
la Publication: Mike Taylor. C.P.P.A.P No. 0127 N 84715. Editeur responsable pour la Belgique: André Verwilghen, Avenue
Louise 176, 1050 Bruxelles. EMD Aps, Gydebang 39-41, DK-3450 Allerod. Rapp. Italia: I.M.D.s.r.l., via Guido da Velate,
11 – 20162 Milano; aut. Trib. MI N. 491 del 17/9/86, poste Italiane SpA - Sped. in Abb. Post. DL. 353/2003 (conv. L.
27/02/2004 -n. 46) art. 1 comma 1, DCB Milano, Dir. Resp.: Tassinari Domenico. Periodicals postage paid at New York,
N.Y., and at additional mailing houses. Additional pages of regional editions numbered or allowed for as follows: National
S1-S2. Vol. 200, Nos. 17–18 © 2022 TIME Magazine U.K. Ltd. All rights reserved. Reproduction in whole or in part without
written permission is prohibited. TIME and the Red Border Design are protected through trademark registration in the U.S.
and in the foreign countries where TIME magazine circulates. ISSN 0928-8430.

5
BEHIND THE COVER

A different way to When TIME declared the “Endangered

Earth” to be Person—or rather Planet—of the
see our planet Year for 1988, the cover featured a plastic-
wrapped globe by the artist Christo. In the
BY D.W. PINE, CREATIVE DIRECTOR years since, despite a trove of urgent scien-
tific facts, the issue has still struggled to gain
Time has released more than 5,000 covers global acceptance. Why do you think that is?
since our founding almost a century ago. But There is a lot of evidence that fear-based com-
this is the first one where the viewer’s eyes cre- munication about the dangers of climate change
ate the image. In the run-up to the COP27 climate are not as effective as communicating concrete
conference—the U.N. meeting at which global actions, but this is still the main way that the cli-
leaders will negotiate the next steps toward man- mate emergency is communicated in the media.
aging that crisis—we sought a cover image that I think the experiences of the pandemic, and
could speak to the intensity of the current climate the struggles to enact comprehensive, science-
situation. So we turned the cover (or rather, cov- based policies to combat the virus, have taught
ers) over to one of the world’s most prominent us a lot about the limits and possibilities for
contemporary artists, Olafur Eliasson. enacting change to habits on a large scale. I
Eliasson creates sculptures and large-scale in- do think that you need to give people a posi-
stallations that employ elemental materials such tive image of the future that they are working
as light, water, and air to enhance the viewer’s ex- toward—a more equitable, sustainable world for
perience of the ordinary. To accomplish the effect all, both humans and nonhumans alike.
on TIME’s cover, the Icelandic Danish artist used
a technique called afterimaging. Following the I love that your work makes the viewer expe-
instructions on the page allows your eye to “re- rience something—whether it’s the sun in-
imagine” our overheated planet in the greens and side the Tate Modern or huge chunks of gla-
blues that are the colors of a healthy earth. cial ice for Ice Watch. Can you talk about the
“An afterimage is basically created within your importance you place on actually experienc-
own perceptual apparatus—by your eyes and ing nature and the climate through your art?
brain, that is—whenever you look at something. There is something extraordinary about the di-
You don’t generally see or notice them unless you rect experience that art can offer at a moment
look at something for a long time and then turn when so many of us encounter the world via
away to look at a blank surface,” he says. Look- digital devices. Whether it is a live music perfor-
ing twice is what Eliasson’s cover asks us all to mance, theater show, or art exhibition, there is
do, and it’s no coincidence that the visual an- something about being in one’s body at a certain
chor at the center of it all is a heart. “This image place and at a certain time, sharing an experi-
is not actually there on the page but inside you,” ence with others, that cannot be replaced by our
he says. “You create it. You make the world.” He devices—as we learned during the pandemic.
spoke to TIME about the thinking behind the Especially when you think about something
cover. Read more on time.com. △ as large-scale and seemingly distant as climate
Eliasson, top, uses change, it is often precisely this experiential
Can you point to a singular moment when an optical illusion level that is missing in motivating action.
you discovered that you could tell the story of to create a new
the climate and nature through your art? image of our planet What would you like the reader to experience
Like many people of my generation, I grew up on what looks like in the afterimage on this cover? It is my hope
taking nature for granted as something un- a plain gray page that viewers take away from this some idea of
changing. My interest in working with materi- how much their own perception of the world
als like light, color, water, fog, and other natural contributes to making it. And if we can see the
phenomena grew out of my desire to demateri- world anew—or even just our representations of
alize the art object, to make things that were less the world—then we can think about it in a new
physical than, say, ephemeral or atmospheric. way too, and I hope even change it.
In 2003, around the time I created The Weather
Project—the artificial sun in the Tate Modern, in What gives you hope for the future of our
London—I began thinking about the weather, planet and the climate? I have the feeling that
about how it affects our lives, and our moods, the young people today are thinking very much
and our experiences, and how we in turn affect from a standpoint of the future—unlike my gen-
it. From there, it was not a great leap to thinking eration, which often seeks refuge in history and
L ARS BORGES

about how we are affecting the planet as a whole visions from the past. This gives me great hope
through human-induced climate change. for the future of our planet. □
6 Time November 7/November 14, 2022
 CONVERSATION
C L O C K W I S E F R O M T O P : N I N A W E S T E R V E LT — VA R I E T Y/G E T T Y I M A G E S; C R A I G B A R R I T T — G E T T Y I M A G E S F O R T I M E ; K E V I N M A Z U R — G E T T Y I M A G E S F O R T I M E ; J P Y I M — G E T T Y I M A G E S F O R T I M E ; N I N A W E S T E R V E LT — VA R I E T Y/G E T T Y I M A G E S

See all the newsletters

Keke Palmer kept the mood bright as host and M.C. of the TIME100 Next Gala in New York City

TIME100 Next Gala

At the TIME100 Next Gala,
held on Oct. 25 in New York
Looking for a
City and hosted by actor and
specific cover?
honoree Keke Palmer, emerging
leaders and rising stars from Order your favorites at
across the 2022 TIME100 Next timecoverstore.com
list walked the red carpet and
enjoyed dinner and cocktails.
Artists, activists, athletes, and TA L K T O U S
government officials mingled
and shared ideas while listening ▽
send an email:
to toasts by their peers, [email protected]
including environmental activist Please do not send attachments
Nalleli Cobo, author George M.
Johnson, and actors Simone ▽
follow us:
Ashley and Lily Collins. See full facebook.com/time
coverage of the gala at time @time (Twitter and Instagram)
.com/next2022

Letters should include the writer’s

full name, address, and home
telephone, and may be edited for
purposes of clarity and space

Back Issues
Contact us at customerservice@time
.com, or call 800-843-8463.
Reprints and Permissions
Information is available at time.com/
reprints. To request custom reprints,
visit timereprints.com.
Advertising
For advertising rates and our editorial
calendar, visit timemediakit.com.
Clockwise from left: Bridgerton actor Simone Syndication
Ashley embraces Doctor Who star Ncuti For international licensing and
syndication requests, contact
Gatwa; actor Ayo Edebiri with comedian Joel [email protected]
Kim Booster; musician Machine Gun Kelly on
the red carpet; and Emily in Paris star Lily Please recycle
Collins gives a toast this magazine, and
remove inserts or
samples beforehand

7
 THE FUTURE OF

Featuring:
Join TIME for a series of conversations highlighting essential Padma Lakshmi
perspectives at the forefront of food. Key themes will include TV Host, Author and Producer
innovation in the food industry, combating food insecurity,
and shaping the future of food sustainability and agriculture.
Natasha Pickowicz
Pastry Chef

WATCH LIVE at Omar Tate

time.com/time100-talks Chef and Co-founder,
Honeysuckle Projects

Ghetto Gastro
Culinary Collective

PRESENTED BY
Abhi Ramesh
CEO and Founder, Misfits Market
 THE
BATTLE FOR
UKRAINE’S
INTERNET
BY VERA BERGENGRUEN

Attempts to maintain online

infrastructure—seen here
in Kharkiv—have become
critical in the ongoing war
S

THE FIGHT OVER SOMALIA'S SLOW-MOTION THE TROUBLE

STUDENT-LOAN FORGIVENESS HUMANITARIAN CRISIS WITH AMBITION

PHOTOGR APH BY LEO CORREA 9

THE BRIEF OPENER

I
n the wake of the counteroffensive that Ukrainian telecommunications workers have restored
reclaimed vast swaths of Ukraine from Russian 1,232 base stations in areas occupied by the Russians
forces, teams of local technicians and engineers since March. Before repairs are even completed, officials
quietly arrived. Wearing helmets and bulletproof have been setting up makeshift wi-fi spots where locals
vests amid the ongoing shelling, often escorted by Ukrai- stand in long lines to access the internet for 15 minutes
nian troops to avoid land mines, the workers barely apiece to avoid overwhelming flimsy connections.
waited to see the last of the retreating Russian soldiers
before beginning to repair the damaged base stations and This work has come at great risk to the technicians them-
fiber-optic cables that left hundreds of towns and villages selves. A vehicle carrying four employees of Ukrtelecom, one
cut off from the outside world. of the country’s leading service providers, recently drove
Ukraine’s dogged efforts to restore internet and mo- over a land mine in the Sumy region, injuring three people
bile connection underscore the urgency with which gov- and killing the driver. In Russian airstrikes on Oct. 10—some
ernment officials view the communications blackout in of which targeted telecommunications buildings—four em-
previously occupied areas. “The first thing the Russians ployees of Ukraine’s department overseeing digital infra-
do when they occupy these territories is cut off the net- structure were killed. “These restorations are being made
works,” says Stas Prybytko, head with some really heroic efforts
of mobile broadband develop- from these guys,” says Prybytko.
ment in Ukraine’s Ministry of “It’s still very dangerous to do
Digital Transformation. “The
people living there don’t know
what’s happening in Ukraine,
‘It’s not a this work, but we can’t wait to
do this, because there are a lot of
citizens in liberated villages who
they can’t call family to describe
the situation, they don’t know
situation urgently need to connect.”
Prybytko’s 11-person team
whether their relatives are alive.”
The battle for control over someone in Ukraine’s digital ministry are
spending their days trying to

could imagine
Ukraine’s internet shows how navigate a patchwork of basic
both sides view online access as a fixes to restore a connection
critical weapon in a 21st century to parts of the country and
war. After Russian troops invaded
Ukraine in February, their occupa- in the meeting with other government
officials in a new working group
tion of Ukrainian towns followed
a pattern. Upon establishing con-
trol, their first stop was often the
21st century.’ set up to coordinate these
efforts with local authorities
and mobile providers. They
offices of the local internet service —STAS PRYBYTKO, have scrambled to make safety
UKRAINE’S MINISTRY OF
provider, Ukrainian officials tell DIGITAL TRANSFORMATION assessments, provide military
TIME. There the Russians often escorts to areas that were
seized telecommunications net- occupied by Russian troops
works at gunpoint. until recently, and find the
More than 4,000 base stations belonging to Ukrai- necessary equipment in local warehouses. Many recently
nian telecommunications providers have been seized or liberated areas are without power, requiring teams to run
destroyed by Russian soldiers since the beginning of the manual diesel generators.
war, according to Ukraine’s Special Communications Ser- The biggest challenge has been ensuring the physi-
vice. More than 60,000 km of fiber-optic lines used for cal safety of the repair teams. In addition to the threat of
the internet have been captured or damaged, and Russian bombardment, “the mining of base stations is a big prob-
forces destroyed 18 broadcasting antennas that provided lem,” Prybytko says, because the Russians have used land
television and radio signals. In some areas of southern mines “to avoid faster restoration of service.”
Ukraine, Russia appears to have rerouted internet traffic While the war continues, Ukrainian officials and
through their own providers, exposing it to the Kremlin’s internet providers say they’ve already won on the digital
vast system of surveillance and censorship. Since the in- front. Rival carriers have worked together to provide
vasion began, the number of users connecting to the in- roaming coverage for Ukrainian users, who are able to
ternet in Ukraine has shrunk by at least 16%, according to jump from one network to another if their provider’s
London-based industry research group Top10VPN. coverage goes down. They’ve also collaborated to repair
Ukrainian telecom workers have been working just one another’s bombed-out base stations. “We really
as hard to get the country back online. Mobile opera- have brave technical teams and mobile operators,” says
tors have rebuilt 71 of their base stations in areas liber- Prybytko. “They know the importance of what many
ated from Russian occupation since the beginning of people treated as trivial before: make a phone call, browse
the counteroffensive in September, according to figures the news. It’s not a situation someone could imagine in
shared with TIME by Ukraine’s digital ministry. In total, the 21st century.” 
The Brief is reported by Tara Law, Sanya Mansoor, and Julia Zorthian
 Artists’ statement
Iranian artists unfurled banners with the face of Mahsa Amini—the 22-year-old who died in Iranian police custody in
September after being arrested for wearing her headscarf improperly—at the Guggenheim Museum in New York City on
Oct. 22. The artists were protesting what they see as inaction by Western museums to human-rights abuses in Iran.
O P E N I N G PA G E : A P ; T H I S PA G E : G U G G E N H E I M : C O U R T E S Y A N O N Y M O U S A R T I S T S F O R I R A N ; S U N A K : D A N K I T W O O D — G E T T Y I M A G E S

WORLD

Britain’s newest leader faces a tough road

BRITONS HAVE CERTAINLY HEARD POUNDS AND SENSE The scale of chal- TORY TROUBLES Aside from the steep
this one before: after a period of tu- lenges facing Britain obscures the his- economic challenges, Sunak will have
mult and uncertainty, the U.K. has toric nature of Sunak’s premiership. to go about the difficult business of
a new Conservative Prime Minister. His in tray is filled with problems left uniting his fractious party, which is
The Tory is Rishi Sunak, who en- over from his recent predecessors, in- polling at its lowest level since modern
tered 10 Downing Street less than two cluding a cost-of-living crisis, rising polling began. While Sunak claimed
months after losing his first leader- energy costs, and soaring infla- the support of the majority of Con-
ship bid to Liz Truss, who took over tion. While Sunak’s reputation servative lawmakers, they can be
from Boris Johnson in September. for fiscal conservatism may work a mutinous bunch. The fact that
to calm financial markets and polls show the Tories facing oblit-
HISTORY- MAKING Sunak’s appoint- help balance the government’s eration at the next election—
ment may mark one of the swiftest books, it will do little to which is due to take place
political comebacks in British history. comfort many Britons brac- by January 2025—might
Sunak, who is of Indian origin, is the ing for the return of auster- keep rebellious MPs in
country’s first Prime Minister of color. ity. That budget-tightening line. That, of course, could
At the age of 42, he is also one of the measures will be intro- all be moot if Sunak suc-
youngest British leaders yet. And with duced by a millionaire may cumbs to intense pub-
a net worth of over $800 million, he make them particularly lic pressure to call a snap
is likely the first Prime Minister to be hard for ordinary people to election long before then.
wealthier than even the royal family. swallow. —YASMEEN SERHAN
11
THE BRIEF NEWS

BUSINESS

Student-debt forgiveness is on hold—for now

GOOD QUESTION

What’s next in the fight over debt forgiveness?

Cody Hounanian submiTTed His concrete, imminent injury in order to
application for student-loan forgiveness bring a lawsuit. Student-loan balances
as soon as the site launched on Oct. 14. can’t be forgiven until there’s a ruling
The executive director of the nonprofit from the appeals court.
Student Debt Crisis Center is himself “I think this is the case that is
among the 22 million borrowers who most likely to get the farthest of all
have already applied to receive up to the lawsuits that have been brought,”
$20,000 in debt relief under the Biden says Tara Grove, a University of Texas
Administration’s program. School of Law professor who focuses
“It shows you how eager and, in some on the federal judiciary and separation
cases, desperate these borrowers are to get of powers. “And even this one, I think,
this relief,” Hounanian says. is a stretch under current
But a week later, the case law.”
program—and any potential ‘Even this No matter what happens
debt cancellation—was put [lawsuit], with this case, more legal
on hold as a federal appeals challenges are sure to
court considers one of several I think, is follow, possibly halting
legal challenges brought a stretch.’ the process again. There’s
against the program. Legal —TARA GROVE, widespread debate about
experts are skeptical that UNIVERSITY OF TEXAS the shaky legal justification
this case, or the others, will SCHOOL OF LAW for Biden’s policy, but
ultimately prevail in court opponents of the plan have
and reverse the student-loan forgiveness struggled to find someone with standing
B I D E N : J O S H U A R O B E R T S — R E U T E R S; D E B T: S E T H W E N I G — A P

program, which could affect 40 million to sue over the program. And once
borrowers. borrowers begin receiving debt relief,
The case now before the U.S. Court it will become much harder to reverse,
of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit was legal experts say.
brought by six Republican-led states, Meanwhile, the Education Depart-
which argue that President Biden ment and advocates have encouraged
overstepped his authority and that the borrowers to apply as soon as possible.
plan will cost them future tax revenue. “We are optimistic,” Hounanian says.
The states appealed a decision by a “We do not want borrowers spending
district judge, who had dismissed the their energy and worry on tracking a
lawsuit for lack of legal standing—which multitude of lawsuits that are already
requires a plaintiff to have suffered a going out the door.” —kaTie reilly
12 Time November 7/November 14, 2022
Y E : R A N D A L L H I L L— R E U T E R S; M A N N : S PA C E X / N A S A

DIED

FALLEN
CHARGED

REJECTED
APPOINTED

SENTENCED
MILESTONES

SPLIT
LAUNCHED
THE BRIEF NEWS

TECH

Alaska this year canceled its lucrative snow crab harvest for the first time

CLIMATE were on the rise, spiking several degrees

The curious case of from 2017 to 2019 and causing the crusta-
ceans to speed up their metabolisms. “All
the cannibal crabs of a sudden you had this huge number of
BY ARYN BAKER
little crabs coming up, eating themselves
out of house and home,” says Jones. “Then
the water warmed, which meant they had
Snow crab legS, The cenTerpiece of to eat more.” It was a double whammy, he
any self-respecting seafood platter, are no says, and the results were inevitable for a
longer on the menu. hungry, omnivorous species that has run
They are the victim of a massive popula- out of its usual food source: “They basi-
tion crash that led Alaska to cancel its Ber- cally cannibalized each other.”
ing Sea snow crab harvest for the first time Snow crabs are only the latest victims
in recorded history this year. The $132 mil- of climate change in the Bering Sea. Rising
lion-a-year industry saw the state’s snow temperatures have often led to unpredict-
crab population drop 87%, from 8 billion able boom-and-bust cycles, which have
in 2018 to 1 billion last year. Officials sug- had unanticipated consequences up and
gested that climate change might be to down the food chain. A population explo-
blame; Alaska is the fastest-warming state sion of sockeye salmon is one likely reason
in the U.S. But that’s only part of the story, for the recent collapse of Alaska’s red king
says Wes Jones, an Alaska-based fisheries crab harvest, which was also canceled this
expert. According to the marine biologists year. Meanwhile, the warming waters of
he works with, the most immediate cause the Bering Sea have opened the door for
of snow crab death is something even sea- Pacific cod, a predator of juvenile crabs.
soned fishermen didn’t see coming: a mass It will be years before the Alaskan
cannibalism frenzy. snow crab population recovers to harvest-
Back in 2017, Jones says, local crabbers worthy levels, says Jones. And that’s only
started reporting a population explosion if temperatures in the Bering Sea stay cool
of juvenile snow crabs. The boom contin- enough for the cold-loving juveniles—
ued into 2019, creating what Jones says and climate change is making everything
was the largest population on record. harder to predict. “When you start seeing
At the time, the young crabs were too things outside of the range of what you’ve
small for a legal harvest—juvenile snow seen before,” says Jones, “you don’t
SHUT TERSTOCK

crabs take four to five years to mature. know how that’s gonna affect something
Meanwhile, Bering Sea temperatures, until it’s happened.” Like rising water
which usually hover around freezing, temperatures. And cannibalism. □
14 Time November 7/November 14, 2022
The ocean’s rights are
being ignored. Make sure
they’re heard by adding your
name to this global petition,
which will be presented in
conjunction with the UN
General Assembly in
September 2023.

onebluevoice.net
#ONEBLUEVOICE
THE BRIEF WORLD

Somalia faces its worst drought

ever, as the world looks away
BY BELINDA LUSCOMBE

AfTer A series of pArTiculArly devAsTATing fAm-

ines in East and West Africa in the early 1980s—the ones
that sparked the Live Aid concert and set Bono on his path
from rock star to humanitarian dynamo—the U.S. set up an
early-warning system for when a region’s food supply was
going to fail. The Famine Early Warning Systems Network,
or FEWS-NET, as it’s known, monitors weather patterns,
agricultural production, conflict, and aid budgets to give
wealthier nations and relief agencies timely information
about likely crises. With enough awareness, the thinking
was, there would be time to head off the worst ravages.
For months now, that system has been sounding a major
alarm about the situation in the Horn of Africa, which, after
four meager rainy seasons over two years, is enduring its
worst drought in recorded history. Many aid agencies be-
lieve that a declaration of famine is imminent. Such decla-
rations are made only under extreme conditions: when a
third of a region’s children are severely malnourished, a fifth
of the population has no access to food, and there are two
hunger-related deaths per 10,000 people each day. The only
two official famines ever declared using this system were in
South Sudan in 2017 and Somalia in July 2011. On Oct. 18,
UNICEF warned that the current situation in Somalia looks
even more dire than in 2011, especially for children.
Despite the precision and volume of the data, however, △
many people are unaware of the situation. A recent poll of Somalians line IT’S A SLOW-MOVING CRISIS
Americans ages 19 to 34 conducted by the International up for water at In 2011, when famine was declared in
Rescue Committee (IRC) and YouGov found that almost a camp near Somalia, things escalated to a critical
70% did not even know there was a drought in East Africa Dollow for point, but only briefly. This time—
until they took the survey. This is despite the U.S.’s having those who have partly because of the early warnings—
given over $700 million in aid this year to the region, more fled drought- the situation is grinding inexora-
stricken farms
than the rest of the world combined. “This seems to be an bly on. December to March are dry
invisible famine,” says Gayle Smith, CEO of One.org and months in Somalia, and the 2023 rainy
former U.S. Agency for International Development (USAID) season is predicted to be sparse. Thou-
administrator. “It’s on the horizon; it’s happening. There’s sands more people will leave the land
been plenty of warning from the Somalian authorities, from to gather in camps, which could spark
NGOs, from others. I think there’s some awareness, but it disease or overtax the water supply
has not triggered the kind of international response that and eventually lead to many more
one would expect.” deaths than in prior crises. So even
The low profile has surprised even longtime watchers if famine is not declared, says Max-
of the region. “It has been, you know, third- or fourth-page well, “we may not avert the kind of
news,” says Daniel Maxwell, the Henry J. Leir Professor in mass mortality that we saw last time,
Food Security at Tufts University, and a member of the Fam- just because of the magnitude and the
ine Review Committee for Somalia. While there were big likely duration of the problem.”
awareness campaigns for Darfur and Sudan in prior years,
he says he doesn’t see efforts for the region gaining the same IT ISN’T JUST A NATURAL DISASTER
traction. “I don’t know what it is that captures the imagina- People understand and respond
tion of the public.” quickly to tsunamis and earthquakes,
Obviously, the war in Ukraine is dominating the attention but famine is about more than bad
of news outlets and humanitarian agencies, especially those weather and failed crops. A lot of the
in Europe. But that’s not the only reason this famine is get- failures are social or economic. Soma-
ting less attention. Here’s what else experts think is going on. lia has been terrorized by militants
16 Time November 7/November 14, 2022
 medical checkup than a visit to the ER. “Governments and
international actors are still responding to the impacts of the
drought, instead of managing the risk ahead of the drought,”
read an Oxfam report in May.

SOME WEALTHY COUNTRIES ARE STRUGGLING

The U.N. allocated $100 million to address the crisis in So-
malia in April. In July, the head of USAID, Samantha Power,
said the agency would provide $476 million. In September
she added $151 million, noting the “narrow window of op-
portunity to stave off famine in the Horn.” Later that month
President Biden announced that the U.S. would contribute
$2.9 billion to address the global hunger crisis, $2 billion
of which was direct food aid. But other countries have not
stepped up. “One of our key partners has been the U.K.,
which has unfortunately dramatically reduced its aid bud-
get,” says Smith. “So there’s a deficit.”

IT SEEMS LIKE THE FUNDING SHOULD COVER IT

The amounts of money that have been donated sound huge
enough that people could believe the problem is solved. But
money doesn’t go as far as it used to. “Food prices were at
near record levels [in Somalia] even before the invasion of
Ukraine,” says Maxwell. The aid has helped, but “we’re still
at a worse place now than we were in February.” As prices
went up, people lost their livelihoods. Drought “reduces
the value of anything that people have to sell to buy food—
either livestock or their own labor,” says Maxwell. “So we’re
at near historic lows in terms of people’s purchasing power.”
At a recent IRC presentation, one of the Somalian field-
workers noted that Plumpy’Nut, the nutritious food used
linked to al-Qaeda, decreasing the by UNICEF and other aid organizations in emergency situa-
West’s ability—and appetite—to offer tions, had more than doubled in price from $50 per 15 kg to
help. South Sudan is still dealing with $130—and that’s before the cost of transport.
long-running civil unrest. Ethiopia has
seen regional skirmishes. And the war THERE ARE MANY DISASTERS
in Europe has made unstable econo- Conflicts in Ukraine, Syria, Afghanistan, South Sudan,
mies even less viable. Much of the food and Yemen, plus floods in Pakistan and an earthquake in
consumed in the Horn of Africa is im- Haiti, are taxing the world’s main providers of aid—and the
ported. Broken supply lines do not world’s attention. “We’re dealing with more crises than we
feel as urgent as crop failures, yet they ever have,” says Smith. “And stretching the funding risks
make a disastrous situation more per- elongating the crises and failing to assist people we can
ilous. “It is probably the most severe actually reach.” Smith would like aid budgets to be bigger.
combination of drivers [of famine], but “To mobilize the kind of response that’s needed, you not
also ones that are likely to last for a lon- only need to get the attention of governments,” she says,
ger period,” says Maxwell.
‘Food “you have to get the attention of the public.”
prices were
PREVENTION IS BETTER THAN CURE, already at THE ATTENTION ECONOMY IS FRAGMENTED
BUT LESS URGENT Back when Live Aid was shown on TV globally, snagging a
During the famine in Somalia in 2011, near record few key media outlets meant catching the eyes of millions
a quarter of a million people died, half of levels even of viewers, with headlines the next day. This year’s Global
them children, many before the famine before the Citizen concert, featuring Mariah Carey and Metallica, was
declaration drew the world’s attention. streamed on outlets from Amazon Music to YouTube, but
The humanitarian sector vowed to head invasion of seemed to make little dent in the news cycle. And it too had
Ukraine.’
J E R O M E D E L AY— A P

off such disasters. But it’s difficult to a long list of causes it needed to support. “We’ve got a very
direct hard-won funding to something crowded media space,” says Smith, “and we’ve got multiple
—DANIEL MAXWELL,
that may happen, in the same way that PROFESSOR IN FOOD issues on the international agenda, and unfortunately, this
it’s tougher to make time for a regular SECURITY, TUFTS falls near the bottom.” 
17
THE BRIEF TIME WITH

In search of a hero,
biographer Stacy Schiff
pulled Samuel Adams
out of the shadows
BY KARL VICK

WiTh our foamy liTTle coffees, sTacy

Schiff and I have set up at a small, round, metal
table under the trees of Bryant Park, the great
green oasis that shares a block of midtown Man- Long distance
hattan with the New York Public Library. It’s in
that grand building at the other end of the block.
Or so one assumes.
“We’re sitting on the stacks,” Schiff announces
with a smile and a nod toward the ground. She’s
serious. Beneath the walkways and the grass and
the squirrels—all the things that make a park—
is most of what makes a library. “I’ve been down
there twice,” she says. “Crazy. It’s this amazing Tinseltown
warren of books. It’s just, like, miles and miles.”
This is not only a genuine secret of New York, it’s
one Schiff imparts with a particular kind of arch
humor, a pleasure gathered from the informa-
tion being shared. These are qualities familiar to
readers of her best-selling, award-winning, really
good biographies, the latest of which, The Revo-
lutionary: Samuel Adams, she spent many months
researching at the other end of the block. Prescient began her project with much more
It wasn’t easy. Samuel was the Adams who did than a glimpse of the fellow.
not save his papers—partly because he cared so “If you read his contemporaries,
little whether he was remembered. In this he dif- everybody else says he was the most
fered, Schiff notes, from his cousin John, who, active, the earliest, the most perse-
like many of the founders, turns out to have been vering man of the Revolution—the
deeply preoccupied with what today would be Father of the Revolution,” she says.
called brand but was known at the time as poster- “And he’s ... gone. So what did the
ity. “The John Hancocks of this world, the John founders know that we don’t? That’s
Adamses of this world, they’re always the people just pretty much the question I was
who succeed because they seem to let everyone trying to answer.”
know they succeed,” she says. As a biographer, she is drawn to
The other reason Samuel Adams is so hard to the underdocumented. Her 2000
capture is the reason to try: more than anyone Pulitzer Prize was for Vera (Mrs.
else, he led the effort to break the American colo- No cigar Vladimir Nabokov), all of whose letters
nies free of Britain. Much of that work was done were “lost.” In Cleopatra: A Life,
in secret, and an effective conspirator takes pains Schiff revivified the most powerful
to hide what he’s doing while he’s doing it. The ruler of her era by drawing from the
Revolutionary includes a scene of Samuel Adams likes of images on coins and a text
scissoring incriminating letters to scatter like written 100 years after her death.
confetti out a window, “sparing his associates After Schiff’s last book, The Witches:
if stopping the biographer’s heart.” Salem, 1692, she found herself craving
He is the hole in the center of the nation’s ori- “someone noble, someone who I could
gin story. Every schoolchild remembers Paul Re- admire, someone who stood up for
vere’s midnight ride. But who recalls whom he what he believed in ... someone who
galloped to warn—the man the British were com- could fairly be said rerouted history.
ing for? Not even Schiff, who (“so embarrassing”) And that’s not that many people.”
grew up in Adams, Mass., a town named for him, But Samuel Adams filled the bill.
18 Time November 7/November 14, 2022
 The whole idea that the elite is deaf to everyone
else.” She pauses. “It seems like it’s that same
kind of crease in history, when some of us are
thinking: When is the world going to go back to
normal? But it’s already changed. You don’t re-
alize that the evolution has already been done.”
Samuel Adams has something for every
modern patriot. His passion for personal lib-
erty chimes for conservatives. Liberals can
hark to his calls for activism. But the man had
no truck for insurrection. The revolt he led by,
as Schiff puts it, taking “ambient ideas” and
“wrestling them on the page” was against an
overseas despot. When, in 1787, former sol-
diers attacked courthouses and other govern-
ment properties in the newly minted United
States, Adams urged hanging for the ringlead-
ers of Shays’ Rebellion. His view, Schiff says,
came down to legitimacy: “Once it is the gov-
ernment that you yourself have established,
there’s a legitimate means of redress, and that
is called elections.”
If he’d kept his letters, Schiff might have
been able to put her finger on what she consid-
ers the central question. “What is the moment at
which resistance melts for him into revolution?”
she asks. Instead, she’s fashioned Adams’ story
from the accounts of others, often his enemies.
“You’re having to piece together, you know,
△ who’s creating a loophole, who’s lunging through
About the beer. The real Samuel Adams was Schiff at the the loophole, and then there’s covering up the
not a brewer. He drove the family malt business New York loophole after that,” she says. “So it is a book of
into the ground and, Schiff writes, “was called Public Library, skulduggery, in a way.”
many names in his life, but one thing he was home of what But the hero is finally drawn into the light,
never called was Sam.” papers Samuel having found a biographer who also writes
He was a downwardly mobile yet powerfully Adams left in longhand, and can make fresh the history
driven man, animated by idealism, liberty, and we all thought we knew already. At about the
a Puritan sense of righteous justice. If we don’t midpoint of the book, Schiff describes the re-
always know what Samuel Adams did (the Bos- lationship between the English King and the
ton Tea Party almost certainly belongs on his Massachusetts colony in the mid-1760s. “A
résumé, but was never put there), it was never dangerous dance, familiar to every adolescent,
hard to see what he thought. He published con- had begun: hints of refractory behavior pro-
stantly, if pseudonymously, in the colonial Mas- duced assertions of authority, which produced
sachusetts newspapers that drove the Crown’s refractory behavior.”
men batty. “The officials are often saying, How When I ask Schiff what counts as a good
do you govern a colony with five newspapers?” day, she lights up. “This is the best thing for me
Schiff says. “And it’s not unlike today, where ev- about writing ever, ever, ever,” she says. “You sit
eryone is tweeting, and everybody’s on social down and you have a thought you didn’t know
media. What does that do to government stabil- you had. Suddenly there’s this explosion on the
ity? There’s this question of how much does rev- page. And you didn’t see it coming. And only as
olution, or at least an upsurge in thinking, coin- you’re writing your way past do you even realize
cide with an explosion of new media?” ‘One thing it’s happening. And, like, you’re so excited that
The author raises her voice to be heard above you can barely sit to write the next line.
the thuddering of construction equipment in- he was “My thinking gets done as I’m writing,
A D A M PA P E F O R T I M E

stalling the Bryant Park ice rink. “There are a lot never which is perhaps why I write longhand. But
of resonances,” she says, meaning between the that’s something that you hope the reader is
1770s and the 2020s: “The feeling that people called coming to the same way you’re coming to it:
have that their rights are not being attended to. was Sam.’ fresh and unexpectedly.” 
19
LIGHTBOX

Another aftermath
Students grieve together after a gunman opened fire at
Central Visual and Performing Arts High School in St. Louis
on Oct. 24. The shooting left a 16-year-old student and
a teacher dead, and seven others injured. The gunman,
a 19-year-old former student, armed with an AR-15-style
rifle, was killed after a shoot-out with police. So far in
2022, 28 students and six adults have been killed in U.S.
school shootings, according to a tally by Education Week.

Photograph by David Carson—St. Louis Post-Dispatch/AP

▶ For more of our best photography, visit time.com/lightbox
Strive for growth Practice gratitude
ECONOMY

A PAINLESS
INFLATION FIX
BY ZACHARY KARABELL

INSIDE

EMMANUEL MACRON’S CREATIVE READING THE ART OF PERSUASION

DOMESTIC BATTLES OF POLLS IN AN AGE OF DIVISION

23
THE VIEW OPENER

The Fed’s moves represent a broad

consensus that high inflation imperils
the stability of the system, erodes liv-
ing standards, and must be brought
down even at the risk of squashing
growth and triggering a recession.
The lack of doubt by the Fed, most
economists, and many businesses
about what the problem is and what to
do about it is a troubling sign of eco-
nomic groupthink. In short, the Fed is
making an epic mistake. It should not
have done what it has done, should
not be doing what it’s doing, and
should not do what it plans to do. Past
mistakes can’t be undone, but future
ones can be avoided. Groupthink is
standing in the way.
There is, of course, inflation right
now, in the U.S. and in most countries
throughout the world. There’s also
broad agreement about what caused
this inflation: too much government Federal Reserve Board Chairman Jerome Powell at a news conference in
spending as the pandemic began sub- Washington on Sept. 21
siding in the spring of 2021; too much
pent-up demand from pandemic lock-
downs exploding in the summer of demand, and high wages. That is not recession. Recession means a halt to a
2021 onward, which created massive the case. This time it’s different. stupendous rise in wages that has seen
supply-chain bottlenecks and demand Inflation as a statistic measures the bottom quartiles reap meaning-
for labor; too much easy money from year-over-year price increases, which ful wage gains for the first time in de-
global central banks that kept assets means that until October, all the high cades, and the deflation of asset prices
such as stocks and homes elevated; inflation was relative to depressed ranging from stocks (and hence retire-
too little action from the Fed until it economic activity caused by pandemic ment funds) to houses in the belief
was too late; and Russia’s invasion of shutdowns. Inflation started to rise in that doing so is necessary medicine.
Ukraine leading to a doubling or more May 2021, with a reading of 5%, rose With signs of a sharp slowing of the
of the price of oil and gas. to 7.5% as markets began anticipat- economy, with the housing market not
The belief that this period of infla- ing the disruptive energy effects of just cooling but nearing freezing, as-
tion is so dangerous that it is worth the Ukraine war, then accelerated to sets prices dropping, and the public
the price of squashing the strongest 9.1% before moderating over the past mood darkening, the Fed can at least

P O W E L L : D R E W A N G E R E R — G E T T Y I M A G E S; M A C R O N : M O H A M M E D B A D R A — A F P/G E T T Y I M A G E S
job and wage market in a generation months to 8.2%. stop what it is doing, halt its interest-
has taken hold in almost every central Starting now, inflation will be mea- rate increases, and slow its attempts
bank and every government in the de- sured from a much higher base. That to shrink its balance sheet. It doesn’t
veloped world. means inflation is peaking regardless even have to admit mistakes. And in
of whatever the Fed did and will do. It doing so, it might just stave off a future
But that leaves one rather cru- is commonly understood that interest- where unemployment surges, wages
cial question: is it true? Must central rate increases work on a substantial stagnate, retirement funds bleed value,
banks take aggressive measures to cool lag, that it takes many months before and vast numbers of people are made
the labor market, dampen financial the effect of those increases show up even more economically insecure in
markets, and likely cause a recession? in changing spending patterns and order to satisfy economic orthodoxies.
Is it a fact that waiting longer would falling prices. The recent softening of There is still time to halt the on-
lead to elevated levels of inflation be- inflation, therefore, cannot be attrib- ward rush. Pulling back from an out-
coming intractable and entrenched? If uted primarily to rising rates. As the moded script will at least avoid fur-
you listened to what the Fed and many effects of pandemic stimulus and the ther damage. Or else we may end up
economists are saying, you’d hardly commodity-price shock of the Ukraine burning the village to save it.
be aware that this has been a two-year invasion wear off, and as supply chains
period unlike any other. You’d think slowly work through bottlenecks, in- Karabell is the author of Inside Money:
today is a normal and regrettable flation is moderating—on its own. Brown Brothers Harriman and the
bout of too much money, too much Now the Fed is poised to force a American Way of Power
The View is reported by Mariah Espada and Anisha Kohli
THE RISK REPORT BY IAN BREMMER

25
THE VIEW INBOX

◁
More than 7 million
votes had already been
cast as of Oct. 24

should control Congress next year, Re-

publicans appeared to have a 4-point
advantage over Democrats; read
the actual numbers, it’s closer to 2.5
points. Negligible? Sure. But not en-
tirely a rounding error in a survey that
drew headlines over the 49% to 44%
GOP advantage.
Go a little downstream in the poll-
ing numbers, and it gets far dicier. The
Times’ September poll showed inde-
pendent women favoring Democrats
by a fulsome 14 points. A month later,
they were backing Republicans by 18
points. That’s an epic 32-point swing,
one that is almost impossible to imag-
ine in practice. But then you look at
the details; the embedded margin of
The D.C. Brief error for the small sample size is 20
By Philip Elliott points. Put simply: they didn’t talk to
enough of those independent women
WASHINGTON CORRESPONDENT
to know what they’re talking about,
but the rest of us can’t shut up about
FOR MOST OF ANY TWO-YEAR ELEC- finance reports, TV ad reservations, the finding.
tion cycle, but especially as we get digital and social outlays, candidate
closer to Election Day, we are flying visits, voter-registration data, even AND THIS IS THE PROBLEM with poll-
blind. Despite all the campaign ads armchair psychoanalysis of the con- ing right now: we treat it as gospel.
and rehearsed speeches and faux scan- tenders and consultant gossip about Sometimes, some of them are garbage.
dals and, in some rare cases, actual in- who’s in and who’s out. But we lean There’s a reason the industry-wide
person debates, we don’t know which more on polling than any of those standard of accuracy is only 95%—
team is going to do better. We don’t other vices. And the problem there is meaning one of every 20 results is
like that uncertainty. As in sports, we that what should be just another in- simply a statistical outlier.
like to glance at a scoreboard to have formative input is too often treated as Polls have consistently—with the
a clear marker about whether the Red predictive. exception of 2012—given Democrats
Team or the Blue Team is up. So in the “You’re reading these as tea leaves. too much of a leg up in recent cycles.
interim, we turn to the political junk- They’re hieroglyphics,” one pollster Pollsters have missed on turnout by
ie’s drug of choice: polls. told me. “If you don’t know how to measures of 2 to 8 points. The Trump
Voting began way back in the tail read them, you’re doing major harm.” era contributed to a surge in voters re-
end of summer, when the most ag- That’s not an uncommon grievance fusing to engage with pollsters, result-
gressive early-voting states of Minne- among polling pros, for good reason. ing in bogus numbers. The pros are
sota and South Dakota started casting And I am as guilty as anyone. already anticipating garbage data in
ballots in September. The first batch Public-opinion surveys have be- the stream. And fickle analysis has left
of real results don’t come until after come a substitute for actual analysis. confidence in the polls shaky at best
polls close on Election Day, and at that Take, for instance, the shift in a recent and ruinous in reality.
point, they come with such ferocity New York Times/Siena poll’s most- Still, most of the armchair politi-
J O H N T U L LY— T H E N E W YO R K T I M E S/ R E D U X

that it’s easy to lose track of surprise predictive question. When asked who cal analysts look at the numbers as
wins—and losses—as all 435 House though they hold answers. Frank
seats, roughly a third of the Senate, talk: they do not. They inform part
and three dozen governorships are of the discussion. They spot which
decided. ‘If you don’t know how campaigns might be toast. The polls
While we wait, those of us who can help decide whether a campaign
make careers in the political ecosys- to read them, you’re should follow Twitter’s advice and
tem substitute proxies: campaign- doing major harm.’ make social justice the hill to die on
26 TIME November 7/November 14, 2022
or stick with the economy. Kitchen-
table issues like inflation and gas
prices have dinged Democrats plenty
hard, but it’s also been a half century
since abortion was as in play the way
By Belinda Luscombe
it is now. Polling provides some hints
as to what is resonating and what
isn’t, but no politician who wants to
be seen as a leader defaults to what a
pollster tells them.
In this, Speaker Nancy Pelosi
wasn’t wrong when in recent weeks
she began telling allies that every
single race is its own universe with
its own peculiarities. National head-
winds don’t necessarily blow so hard
in the Richmond suburbs, for in-
stance, as they do for a presidency.
Then there’s this fact that House
Democrats have been passing around
as a salve for their chapped optimism:
if the GOP holds every seat that was
in Trump’s column in 2020 and car-
ries all of the Biden districts that ‘I think
Biden won by five points or less, Re-
publicans will still have only a six-seat
faith can be
majority—hardly a landslide. At that restored by
margin, Republicans would have to getting it
remain unified on an agenda, some-
thing no one believes can happen in a right.’
caucus where fringe figures like Rep-
resentative Marjorie Taylor Greene
and pals could wield effective veto
power, much the way the Freedom
Caucus did when it badgered Speak-
ers John Boehner and Paul Ryan into
early exits from the top of their party.
While there’s plenty—emphasis:
plenty—of reason to roll eyes at the
assertion that Democrats could gain
seats this cycle, there’s at least a ra-
tional argument that things might
not turn out as dire for them as na-
tional forecasts anticipate. Anecdot-
ally, it doesn’t feel so despondent out
there for liberals. The airwaves are
packed with ads, and residents of
competitive House races have come
to dread the doorbell again, the pan-
demic canvassing reprieve over.
But there’s no real evidence to
support that optimism for Demo-
crats. At least none beyond the cre-
ative reading of polls.

For more from Washington, sign

up for TIME’s politics newsletter
at time.com/theDCbrief

27
THE VIEW ESSAY

POLITICS

The art of persuasion in a polarized age

BY ANAND GIRIDHARADAS

The holidays are around organizers, who I believe show a way

forward even when things can feel so

the corner. A time for families

perilous and bleak.
Though their projects differ, what
this group shared was an approach
to come together and, more to changing minds in the face of
rampant disinformation; social
and more, to come apart. media platforms that reward dunking
and hate rather than the pursuit
As the nation fractures politically, so do our households, of common ground; lie- and hate-
neighborhoods, and communities. For the majority of spewing demagogues; and more.
Americans who still believe in liberal democracy, in the idea Their methods aren’t useful just for
that humans are created equal, and in fact-based reality, policymakers and party leaders.
talking to those we care about on the other side can feel I believe they have much to teach all
hopeless. Is there any point trying to reach these people? Is of us who want to get the country back
changing minds that don’t want to change a lost cause? on track, protect liberal democracy,
It isn’t. heal our divides, and change what
A few years ago, as I felt myself succumbing to the needs changing—if that is work we
same fatalism afflicting so many Americans, I set out are ready and willing to do.
to report a book on people swimming against the tide, What follows are some of the
refusing to write their fellow citizens off, pursuing lessons I learned from these gifted
persuasion in a time of polarization. I came upon a citizens about how you and I,
group of educators, activists, elected leaders, scientists, working in our own communities,
cult deprogrammers, messaging experts, and, above all, can be better persuaders.
28 Time November 7/November 14, 2022
1.Dig for what’s reasons, and they never want to visit that on anyone. A
remarkable experiment called deep canvassing, in which
going on beneath organizers around the country are going door to door,
the opinion ▽ spending extended time with their neighbors, eliciting
their opinions and trying to get them to grapple with these
sources of dissonance, has shown great promise in pitting
In an age of dIvIsIon, we tend to beliefs against other deep-seated intuitions people hold but
assume that people on the far side of perhaps haven’t connected to their prejudices.
an issue from us are fervently commit- What also often lurks beneath opinions is pain, stress,
ted to that stance. We know ourselves confusion, fear, and anxiety, especially in moments of
to be complicated and torn, subject to profound change. In every area of American life, dramatic
all sorts of doubts, but we deny others shifts over the last generation—in technology; trade; race
that complexity. We imagine them to and demographics; gender and sexuality; the economy;
have a single story. and more—have left Americans unsure of who they will be
There are at least two problems and how they will fit on the far side of change.
with this attitude. One, it’s empiri- This doesn’t excuse the racism and misogyny that
cally false. Two, it’s self-defeating. grow out of an allergy to change. But it does suggest that
Sure, some of our fellow citizens— the remedy is helping more people make sense of these
a large minority—are passionately changes and find a healthier relationship to progress. It
committed to their ideological stands isn’t enough to be right about the future you seek. You have
and have buttressed them with their to sell it, even to those you fear and those who fear you.
reading and watching and associa-
tions. But a great many others are less
steeped in the thinking behind the po-
sitions, more joiners than vanguards,
more open to completely opposite
ideas, too. This latter group holds
strong opinions lightly.
What many of the persuaders
I studied for my book taught me is
that this less certain group is ripe
with opportunity. But winning them
over requires discipline, empathy,
and strategy.
Above all, it requires digging for
what is going on beneath the outward
stance—the candidate they adore, the
position they hold on the border issue,
the aversion they have to a policy you
care about. “If we approach people
with the idea that it’s normal to have
complicated feelings, even if they
have a Trump sign on their front yard,
even if their public face expresses one
thing—if we approach them with the
assumption of ‘There’s something
more going on underneath,’ often-
times we find out that there is,” Steve
Deline, a veteran organizer on LGBT
rights issues, told me.
What may lurk underneath is the
seedling of a contradictory opinion:
they may fear invasion by “the
illegals,” but they may also identify
as champions of the underdog. They
are put off by a trans relative, but
they may once have been scorned
and marginalized for their own
ILLUSTR ATIONS BY K ATIE K ALUPSON FOR TIME
THE VIEW ESSAY

2.Focus on the world is a bad conversation to have, because it takes place on the
terrain of those who despise and degrade immigrants. Your
you want, not what position is the accurate one, but you are living inside their
you oppose ▽ mental frame.
This has been a reality for millions of us in recent years.
There are so many outrages all around us, 24/7—shocking
as i was reporting The Persuaders, legal infractions, barbaric comments, brazen power grabs.
one of the most meaningful lessons I It can feel like a moral duty for a well-meaning citizen to
learned came from the political com- pay attention to these outrages and respond to each one,
munications expert Anat Shenker- to register that this is not okay, to tweet and vent to friends
Osorio. In discussions about politics, and family, so as not to let the unconscionable slowly be-
she explained to me, the most impor- come normal.
tant thing isn’t what you’re saying in a But here’s the thing. These outrages have locked many
given conversation. It’s what conversa- of us in perpetual reaction mode. The first thought we have
tion you’re having. in the morning and the last thought we have at night are
If someone at work or at the rooted in something They Did. Not in the world we want,
Thanksgiving table says to you, “Im- not in the beliefs we have, not in the policies we favor. Even
migrants are animals,” and you re- in feeling like we are civically engaging by paying heed to
spond that “Immigrants are not moral outrages, we are living on the conversational turf of
animals”—well, you’re right. But others. We are kept off our game. We are living in someone
here’s the problem: you have now got- else’s moral universe.
ten yourself into a conversation about Instead, Shenker-Osorio says, “say what you’re for.”
the animalness of immigrants. This Paint for your relatives and friends and co-workers and
neighbors a vivid picture of the community and country
you want to see. Make them see it. By no means should you
ignore the monstrosities around you. But fit them into a
bigger story of those who seek to obstruct the good things
you’re fighting for, for their own narrow, nefarious ends. A
great deal of research shows that what moves persuadable
voters isn’t watering down your views, despite this being
the common approach of so many politicians. It’s making
undecided voters feel that your ideas are the more nor-
mal ideas, that they are common sense, that everyone they
admire subscribes to them. Make the people around you
know that’s true.

3.Don’t blame the

victims of disinformation.
Help them ▽
Frighteningly powerFul actors are, for purposes of
profit, spewing false information into the ether. Millions
of our fellow citizens are ingesting it and poisoning their
minds. By some estimates, more than 40 million Americans
believe in the delusions of the QAnon conspiracy complex
alone—beliefs that helped motivate the deadly insurrection
at the U.S. Capitol on January 6, 2021. Media barons and
conspiracy theorists are minting money and influence by
spreading lies about vaccines, about racial “replacement”
theories, about mass shootings.
These lies aren’t finding their deserved place in an open
marketplace of ideas. They are forced into the minds of
millions by people with the influence to make their content
unignorable and the ability to calibrate them to the fears
and anxieties permeating society.
30 Time November 7/November 14, 2022
 When our friends and neigh-
bors fall prey to these cons, we in the
evidence-based world often make
the mistake of condemning them as
harshly as those who have conned
them. On one level, this is natural. We
know our outlandish climate-denier
uncle and can access him; we don’t
know Rupert Murdoch or have his cell
number. But on another level,
it makes no sense. If we truly believe
the spewers of disinformation are
abusing their power and manipulating
people who lack the resources to
resist their sway, why do we also
blame their manipulees?
This isn’t just a moral issue. It’s a
practical one. When we make people
who have succumbed to disinforma-
tion or cultlike manipulation feel stu-
pid, we can drive them further into the
arms of the con, as the cognitive sci-
entist John Cook, who studies disin- 4. Talk less. Do more ▽
formation and its remedies, explained
to me. What I learned from Cook
and others is that there is a primal The anger and viTriol and division all around us
need all of us have that disinforma- seem to suggest the need for more dialogue as a path to
tion taps into: the desire to have the healing. But something I learned from many of the or-
world make sense. ganizers and educators I studied for The Persuaders is
But there is a second need we tend that dialogue stands on a foundation of trust and good
to share, which has the potential to faith—and words actually may not be the best way to lay
compete with that first need: the de- that foundation.
sire not to be anyone’s fool. What What if, as Americans, we need to do more with each
works in winning people back from other in this moment rather than talk more? Attend
disinformation and manipulation is meetings together, build things together, administer
showing genuine concern for them— bodies of water and develop kids’ sports leagues and build
concern that people with a vested in- community centers together?
terest in toying with their minds for The kind of civic repair America requires depends on
selfish purposes are tricking them people not thinking their peers are out to destroy them. It
through classic methods of manipula- depends on a reduction in the present levels of contempt
tion. If explained, these methods can and dismissal in society. Anger and division are one thing—
be seen for what they are. and frankly, they’re normal in a democracy. But contempt
For his part, Cook has created a and dismissal, which have exploded in the U.S. in recent
project called Cranky Uncle, which is years, are different. They don’t drive people toward further
teaching people how to talk more ef- engagement with the ideas of others; they turn people
fectively to their own relatives and away from engagement. They undermine the premise of
friends. And he is building a suite of democracy: that it is possible to choose the future together.
educational tools to help fortify the And we’re not going to fix that by talking. Not at first.
next generation of students against Instead, find ways to associate again—association being
disinformation by teaching them the one of the key words used by the French aristocrat who
most common tactics employed by best observed America in the 19th century, Alexis de
those who would con them. Tocqueville. Focus on creating spaces where it is possible
for people to meet and engage and trust each other despite
their differences. Let the talk happen when it does.

Giridharadas is the author, most recently, of The Persuaders:

At the Front Lines of the Fight for Hearts, Minds, and
Democracy, from which this essay is drawn
31
BY CHARLOTTE ALTER/PHILADELPHIA

Plus
POLITICS

JOHN
FETTERMAN IS
A VIBE GUY.
It’s the salt-and-pepper goatee and the
tattoos, the shorts and Carhartt sweat-
shirts instead of suits, the campaign
merch with local slang like yinz. (That’s
Pittsburgh for y’all.) If the Pennsylva-
nia lieutenant governor and Democratic
nominee for the U.S. Senate is able to
prevail in November, it will be thanks
to his everyman vibe.
The race in Pennsylvania could de-
termine control of the Senate, and for
much of it, Fetterman had the clear
edge when it came to vibes. He was
able to tag his Republican opponent,
Dr. Mehmet Oz, a longtime New Jersey
resident, with carpetbagger vibes, rich-
guy vibes (Fetterman mocked Oz for
owning 10 homes and using words like
crudité), and quack-doctor vibes (sev-
eral Fetterman videos lampoon Oz’s
history of pushing “miracle cures” as a
daytime-TV doc).
But at the candidates’ lone tele- Ezra Klein,” Fetterman told me earlier Mike Pence has a church-deacon
vised debate on Oct. 25, the vibes on this year. But for most voters, “it’s not vibe that plays with conservatives
display were very different. Fetter- like they have their position papers laid but not with the MAGA crowd; Pete
man suffered a stroke in May and has out.” He’s hoping they don’t care much Buttigieg’s what-a-nice-young-man
been dealing with the lingering effects about debates, either. vibe wins over educated boomers but
of what his doctor calls an “auditory- doesn’t particularly endear him to his
processing disorder.” Even with the What’s a political vibe, anyway? own generation. Vibes are so power-
aid of closed captioning, he struggled If a candidate’s character is revealed ful, they can overcome policy differ-
mightily to string basic sentences to- by their choices, and their personality ences or political gaffes. Just ask Joe
gether. Suddenly, a contest the Fetter- is observed through their public ap- Biden, who won the presidency partly
man campaign had cast as a Pennsyl- pearances, then their vibe is a vapor- on the strength of his grandpa-with-
vania native son vs. a slick huckster ous mixture of both of those things: ice-cream vibe. Or Donald Trump, the
seemed to morph into a race be- the general impression they make ultimate vibes guy, whose I-win-you-
tween a stroke survivor grasping for on a normal person who isn’t paying lose vibe was powerful enough to pro-
words and an articulate doctor with close attention. (Which is, of course, pel him through countless scandals
plenty of them. the vast majority of Americans.) Your and usher in a new political era on the
If Fetterman is able to eke out a win vibe is what people who don’t think force of his personality alone.
in November despite the debate disas- about politics think about you. Un- The 2022 midterms should be a rel-
ter and the political headwinds buffet- like a brand, which can be constructed atively straightforward referendum
ing the Democrats, it will be a valida- and curated, a vibe can be enhanced or on the party in power. But the Demo-
tion of his central political insight. You shaded but cannot truly be faked. An cratic Senate candidates who may buck
might call it the Vibes Theory of Poli- image is crafted by strategists; a vibe is the historical trend are doing it partly
tics. The people who decide elections, experienced by the voters. with vibes. In Arizona, Democrat Mark
Fetterman thinks, don’t obsessively Most very good politicians have a Kelly maintains his Senate lead partly
follow the polls or listen to wonky definable vibe. John McCain was the because of his Buzz Lightyear vibe.
podcasts. They vote based on vibes. war-hero maverick. Bernie Sanders is The Ohio Senate race is competitive
“People assume that everyone reads the gadfy uncle, cranky but authentic. because Democrat Tim Ryan has
34 Time November 7/November 14, 2022
 of those ads have been about the can-
didates’ personalities, according to an
Oct. 24 analysis from AdImpact. Even
as consequential events unfolded across
America, it has been a vapid election
fought through memes and defined by
ad hominem attacks, and for much of
the summer, Fetterman seemed to be
winning it. Answering common
But lately the vibes have started to questions about how
crash against the real issues at play in to cast your ballot
the race. Republicans have whacked By Solcyre Burga, Mariah Espada,
Fetterman for his flip-flop on frack- Anisha Kohli, and Simmone Shah
ing. They’ve pummeled him on
drug policy—accusing him of wanting
to decriminalize heroin and fentanyl—
and portrayed him as soft on crime
based on his record of supporting clem-
ency during his time serving on Penn-
sylvania’s board of pardons. Fetterman
is the “most pro-murderer candidate
in the nation,” says Oz communica- Is it better to
tions director Brittany Yanick. (Fetter- vote early, by mail,
man regularly cites his work granting or on Election Day?
clemency to people unjustly impris-
oned and supports marijuana legal- The best option for voting is the
one that works best for you.
ization, but a campaign spokesperson
Every vote is counted equally,
says he does not support decriminaliz-
whether it is cast early or on
ing heroin or fentanyl.) Election Day, in person or via a
Then came Fetterman’s stroke. He mail-in ballot. “People should
△ was off the campaign trail for three vote the way that they’re most
Fetterman on Aug. 12 at months, and when he returned in Au- comfortable, but make sure that
his first campaign rally since gust, he was visibly affected by the lin- they know their state’s rules,”
suffering a stroke in May gering auditory-processing disorder. says Sean Morales-Doyle, the
He mushed words together and re- director of the Brennan Center for
lied on closed-captioning aids in in- Justice’s Voting Rights Program.
a hometown- quarterback vibe—a terviews. Dr. Oz’s response was ruth-
favorable contrast with Republican less: a campaign spokesperson for Oz’s What’s the best
F E T T E R M A N : D U S T I N F R A N Z— A F P/G E T T Y I M A G E S; I L L U S T R AT I O N B Y B R O W N B I R D D E S I G N F O R T I M E

J.D. Vance’s Trump-suck-up vibe. Dem- campaign said Fetterman wouldn’t time to vote to
ocratic incumbent Raphael Warnock is have had a stroke if he “had ever eaten
holding his own in the Georgia Senate a vegetable in his life.” Fetterman, in avoid long lines?
race at least partly because his affable contrast, tried to embody the role of Long lines can be a strong
pastor vibe strikes many as more ap- the relatable underdog. His team cut deterrent to voting, especially in
pealing than Republican Herschel an ad about how the stroke made him Black and Latino communities,
Walker’s domestic-abuse vibe. realize that “politicians spend so much where the wait is often longer
“Voters aren’t issue calculators,” says time fighting about the things that than in white communities,
J.J. Balaban, a veteran Democrat poll- don’t matter.” according to a June 2020
report by the Brennan Center
ster from Pennsylvania. Issues are ob- “Let’s also talk about the elephant in
for Justice. Wait times at
viously important, Balaban adds, but the room: I had a stroke, he’s never let polling places can often
“that tends not to be how people decide. me forget that,” Fetterman said in one of be unpredictable and vary
It really is a feeling that people get of: his smoother moments at the debate. “It significantly by location. But
‘Will this person look out for me? Do I knocked me down, but I’m gonna keep early mornings, lunch hours,
trust them?’” coming back up.” and late evenings tend to be
The Pennsylvania Senate race has That’s the thing about vibes: they the busiest hours as people
been heavier on vibes than perhaps can change. try to vote around their work
any other key contest in the coun- schedules. And lines tend to
try. More than $167 million has been about 10 days before the debate, I be longer on Election Day
spent on ads, and roughly a quarter interviewed Fetterman for the first than during early voting.
 time since his stroke. We had spoken a
couple of times a year since 2018, each
time on the phone or in person. This
time, we talked on Google Meet so he
could use closed captioning. “I don’t
want to put you on the spot,” he asked.
“Do I sound differently after we spoke
for years?”
Fetterman remembered details from
Can I still vote if I our earlier conversations with perfect
don’t have a valid ID? clarity. I detected nothing different
The rules around identification about his ability to recall facts, even if he
and voting vary by state. If you’re flubbed some words and his communi-
a first-time voter, federal law cation was slightly garbled. Then again,
requires that you show ID if you he has never been particularly smooth
did not register in person, but on this score. Even before the stroke,
otherwise whether you need an Fetterman spoke haltingly, frequently
ID to vote depends on where you interrupting himself before he finished
live. Thirty-five states require a thought. He has often seemed self-
voters to show some form of
conscious or tongue-tied, an incongru-
identification. Some of them, like
Wisconsin and Missouri, have
ous personality for his towering frame.
strict photo-ID requirements An adviser once described him to me as
at the polls, while other states “shy.” He bombed the Democratic pri-
allow voters to sign an affidavit mary debate that took place before his
or have their signature verified stroke, sometimes stammering to de-
against their record if they fend himself as his opponents presented
don’t have a valid ID. deft arguments and fluent attacks.
Supporters say this lack of polish
is also part of his vibe. “There is no
How do I know if question to me that the fact that he is
my mail-in ballot 6-ft. 8-in., goes around in hoodies, talks
was received? like a normal person,” the veteran Dem- can understand and bring in words, but
ocratic political strategist Lis Smith told just in terms of captioning, it helps to
Most states offer online ballot
tracking for all mailed ballots,
me before the debate, “that all these make sure, to be precisely.” (He meant
according to Vote.org. In things have helped inoculate him from “be precise.”)
Illinois, New York, Texas, and some of the typical attacks you get from The conversation convinced me that
Wyoming, online ballot tracking Republicans.” Fetterman’s mind was clear, even though
is offered only in some districts But the effects of the stroke are harder his language was more disjointed than
or for overseas and military to spin. How, I asked Fetterman, could usual. This was also the assessment of
voters. If you live in Mississippi he serve as a U.S. Senator if he struggles his physician: after weeks of demands
or Missouri, you can’t track to conduct in-person conversations? to be more transparent about his condi-
your ballot online. Each state’s How could he huddle with Pennsylvania tion, Fetterman released a statement on
tracker is a little different, but Senator Bob Casey, or schmooze with Oct. 19 from his doctor confirming that
most allow you to log in with your Democratic leader Chuck Schumer, or he “can work full duty in public office.”
voter-registration information. woo Joe Manchin? “Having a conversa- (He still refused to release his full medi-
In states that don’t offer ballot tion, that’s not the same as having an in- cal records.)
tracking, your local election terview on a national network,” he told But the Fetterman who showed up
administrator might be able me. “It’s just about the reality of where at the debate sounded much worse than
to answer questions about I’m at in terms of my abilities to fully the one I heard in our one-on-one con-
your ballot status. make sure I’m being understanding.”
(He meant “being understood.”) When
he’s at home with his family, he told me,
he doesn’t use captioning. “When it’s ‘VOTERS
very specific kind of questions in that
kind of situation, it’s important to fully AREN’T ISSUE
understand so I can give you the right
answer,” he said. “It’s part of under- CALCULATORS.’
standing exactly what’s being asked. I —POLLSTER J.J. BALABAN
 It was part of Oz’s ongoing effort to
make the race about Fetterman’s soft
spots instead of his own New Jersey
mansion or his stint promoting prod-
ucts like “sea buckthorn” on TV. He’s
trying to transform the campaign from
a contest of vibes to a battle of issues,
where Oz has a better chance to win in
a year when polls show that many of the
top ones—the economy, immigration,
crime, inflation—favor Republicans.
Talking briefly to reporters after the
event, Oz recalled asking his father—an
immigrant from Turkey—why they were
Republicans. “Republicans have better
ideas,” said Oz, his monogrammed cuff
flashing beneath his suit. “So if I’m in
the U.S. Senate, the No. 1 thing to hold
me accountable for is: make sure that
I have better ideas.”
What exactly Oz’s ideas are can be
difficult to discern. He seems to be try-
ing to craft a talk-about-the-issues vibe
without actually talking about the is-
sues. He does not have a drug-addiction
plan on his website. He didn’t offer his
own vision to combat illegal guns at the
Safer Streets event, and only released a
detailed crime plan on Oct. 24, roughly
two weeks before Election Day. Oz’s
△ advisers did not return at least a dozen
Oz, with supporters on of the city’s “newest upscale catering calls seeking to schedule an interview
Oct. 13, has made crime a facilities,” which normally specializes with him or return emails seeking de-
centerpiece of his closing pitch in wedding receptions and funeral lun- tails about his drugs plan.
cheons. Just beyond a lobby with white But the man emptying the dumpster
leather couches and fake flowers in outside of Galdo’s was happy to talk.
versation. Facing rapid-fire questions crystal vases, Oz was delivering a grim “You can’t trust nothing Oz says.
before a national audience, looking un- diagnosis about Philadelphia’s prob- All these pills supposed to help you,
comfortable in a suit and tie, he was rat- lems with drugs and crime. Drugs, he it’s a bunch of crap,” says Anthony
tled and unsteady, laboring mightily to warned, were “the gateway to hell.” Matthews, 44. “Ain’t he from Jersey?”
express his positions. It was a drubbing The event had the vibe of a daytime
O Z : M A R K M A K E L A — G E T T Y I M A G E S; I L L U S T R AT I O N S B Y B R O W N B I R D D E S I G N F O R T I M E

his team seemed to expect. Ahead of the talk show. The doctor held court in the candidate vibes aren’t the only
debate, Fetterman’s advisers circulated middle and called on various support- ones that matter. Party vibes, economic
a memo attempting to lower expecta- ers who had been invited by the cam- vibes, and historical vibes all play a
tions for his performance. “We’ll admit: paign to share their own experiences. role too. Across the country, Demo-
this isn’t John’s format,” they wrote. (A recent investigation by the Intercept cratic candidates are struggling to sur-
“John did not get where he is by winning found that on at least one occasion, a mount their woke-liberal vibes while
debates or being a polished speaker. He tearful “community member” at Oz’s Republicans are battling against scary-
got here because he truly connects with event was actually a paid staffer.) conspiracy-theorist vibes. The econ-
Pennsylvanians.” “What should we do with all the il- omy has been giving off bad vibes for
legal guns in Philadelphia?” Oz asked months, which is usually disastrous for
Until recently, Oz’s vibe didn’t the group. After each confessional, the the party in power. Add in the historical
seem to be going over too well. I fi- guests would clap, as if they were both precedent of the President’s party los-
nally caught a glimpse of it at a “Safer talk-show guests and studio audience, ing big in the midterms, and it’s look-
Streets” campaign event in South Phila- and Oz would thank them for sharing ing like a bad year for Democrats. Polls
delphia on Oct. 13. The candidate had and turn back toward the cameras. “One suggest that Republicans are more mo-
gathered friendly supporters for a dis- of the most important things a doctor tivated to vote than Democrats heading
cussion on violent crime, at Galdo’s, one does,” he announced, “is listen.” into November, and that the GOP has
37
POLITICS

regained its edge on the generic ballot.

“If it is a wave year, vibes matter less,”
says Smith, the Democratic strategist.
All this put Fetterman’s vibes offen-
sive to the test. At a recent campaign
event in Bucks County, the candidate
climbed onstage to the sounds of AC/DC
and immediately gestured across the
river behind him. “That, over there,
that’s New Jersey,” he told the crowd of
roughly 1,200 people. “The land of Oz!”
The Fetterman supporters at the
event in Bucks County all had different
priorities: abortion, union wages, de- BY ERIC CORTELLESSA
mocracy reform. But Fetterman’s “vibe
goes a long way,” says Bob Cook, 59, an
energy-management technician. “He
seems like a real person.” Nathan Frey,
who works in manufacturing, nodded to
Fetterman’s unique candidate uniform
of a hoodie and shorts. “If you wear a
suit or something all the time when
you don’t have to, that turns me off,”
says Frey, 47. Fetterman, he added, has
“appeal for people who like his vibe.”
None of the voters I spoke with then
seemed concerned about his stroke.
Whether that changes in the wake of
his debate performance is an open ques-
tion. At the Bucks County event, Jim
Hendricks, a 55-year-old steamfitter,
cited Fetterman’s vibes as a key part of
his support for the candidate. “It’s just
something you can feel,” he says. “He’s
not phony at all.”
After the debate, I checked with
Hendricks to see if his impression had
changed. The performance, he acknowl-
edged, could taint Fetterman’s vibe with
voters who were not paying close at-
tention to the race. But his own faith
in his candidate had not faltered. “His
vibe can still be as an everyday person,”
Hendricks told me, “and everyday peo-
ple have strokes and other issues that
they have to fight and battle back from.”
Will voters decide that Fetterman is
not up to the demands of the Senate be-
cause of his health condition? Will they
view his willingness to soldier through
those challenges as a test of character
that shows he will be a champion for
struggling Pennsylvanians? Or will the
whole thing amount to a pundit obses-
sion that voters basically ignore? At
the moment, it’s hard to read the vibe.
—With reporting by LesLie DicksTein
and JuLia ZorThian □
38 Time November 7/November 14, 2022
△
 -

What should I do if
someone tries to stop
me from voting?
Voter intimidation is illegal
and relatively rare. If someone
tries to stop you from voting,
you should alert nearby poll
workers and your local election
officials, who can determine
if law enforcement should be
involved, says Morales-Doyle.
You should also contact the
nonpartisan Election Protection
hotline for assistance: English -
speakers should dial 866-OUR-
VOTE; Spanish speakers can
call 888-VE-Y-VOTE; speakers
of Asian languages can call
888-API-VOTE; and Arabic
speakers can call 844-YALLA-US.

What if I planned to
vote in person but I get
sick on Election Day?
Check your state’s guidelines
on emergency voting. Some
states offer emergency absentee
ballots for voters who are in the
hospital. If you’re concerned
that your health may prevent you
from voting on Election Day, it
may make sense to plan to vote
early or absentee to ensure your
vote is cast. “It’s always a good
idea to vote as soon as you can,”
says Jeanette Senecal, the senior
director for mission impact for
the League of Women Voters.


CLIMATE

NO NATION CAN ESCAPE THE IMPACTS OF

CLIMATE CHANGE—AND WEALTHY COUNTRIES
WILL HAVE TO GIVE THEIR VULNERABLE
NEIGHBORS MORE THAN JUST SYMPATHY

MUTUALLY
ASSURED
SURVIVAL
ILLUSTR ATION BY GREG MABLY FOR TIME 41
CLIMATE

THE SELFISH
CASE FOR
CLIMATE
JUSTICE
Appealing to rich countries’ self-interest may be
the best way to their wallets By Justin Worland

The year is 2040. CounTries have blown Office of the Director of National Intelligence.
past global targets to limit temperature rise, and The U.S. intelligence community is in the busi-
the world is paying the price. The migrant flow ness of gathering information and analyzing how
north from Central America and the Caribbean it may shape the future, not offering policy rec-
has become a flood, but government cooperation ommendations. But it doesn’t require a huge
on national security has waned. In the worst-hit stretch of the imagination to understand the in-
nations, some leaders are considering the last- terplay between these scenarios and government
resort method of trying to lower temperatures on decisionmaking. Wealthy countries can embrace
the ground by spraying sulfur aerosols into the an agenda that helps the most vulnerable parts of
stratosphere, a bit of geoengineering that no one the world address catastrophic flooding, deadly
heretofore has dared risk. famines, and unchecked migration, and in doing
This is not the grim vision of science-fic- so help prevent destabilizing ripple effects. Or
tion writers but rather drawn from the assess- wealthy countries can dismiss the concerns of their
ment laid out in a U.S. National Intelligence Es- developing counterparts and hunker down to await
timate last year. Government analysts warn of 15 the inevitable shock waves.
climate-related threats to U.S. interests that orig- “If you’re not going to address climate change
inate abroad but have a medium or high likeli- equitably, then you will have conflict,” says Sherry
hood of threatening the country by 2040; seven Rehman, Pakistan’s climate minister. “Multilateral
of those threats stem directly from countries in systems will start breaking down.”
the Global South lacking the resources, capac- For years, decades even, providing assistance
ity, and support to manage the realities of climate to the Global South has been framed as a “climate
change. “When instability happens in a coun- justice” agenda. The justice framing was straight-
try, it doesn’t usually remain contained within forward: wealthy countries have spent more than
that single country,” says Maria Langan-Riekhof, a century emitting carbon dioxide unchecked,
director of the Strategic Futures Group at the and they owe it to the rest of the world to pay for
42 Time November 7/November 14, 2022
 △
the damage they have caused. Words like justice, this year as COP27, and to be held this November The border wall
equity, and responsibility sat at the center of the in Sharm el-Sheikh, Egypt—offers an opportunity between the
plea. This logic is understandable, and the moral to embrace the reality that when it comes to cli- U.S. and Mexico
case is compelling, often poignant, even. mate, helping poorer countries helps everybody. at the Pacific
But after some 30 years of the climate-justice ar- “At the moment, there’s a lot of discussion about Ocean
gument delivering mixed results, a new framing is the moral objective that anyone can forget once the
slowly gaining traction: an appeal to self-interest. meeting is closed,” says Laurence Tubiana, the pres-
European Commission Executive Vice President ident of the European Climate Foundation and a key
Frans Timmermans, who oversees climate policy in framer of the Paris Agreement. “This could really
the E.U., says that the moral argument can lack per- be a problem of macroeconomic and global stabil-
suasive power for some audiences—even if there’s ity; the discussion should move in that direction.”
“some truth in that argument.”
“‘You have had 200 years of fossil fuels, that’s For the past three decades, the moral case for
what’s created the problem’ . . . I could take that aggressive climate action has been front and cen-
argument to my constituents, but I don’t think it ter in international climate talks—and with good
would convince them,” he says. “What does con- reason. A century of industrial development and
vince them is that if we don’t increase our efforts in high-carbon living in the Global North has directly
this area, there will be even more disruption; there caused problems of cataclysmic proportions in the
will be more migration; there will be less opportu- Global South. In any typical conception of fairness,
nity for investment and economic development.” the parties most responsible for causing the prob-
The challenge now is to make that under- lem should be responsible for cleaning it up.
standing sink in—not just among the politicians Developed countries, most prominently the
and policymakers who consult with experts, U.S. and European nations, are responsible for
but among the citizens who put them in power. 79% of historic emissions despite being home to
The annual U.N. climate conference—known just a fraction of the global population. And yet the
NICOLÒ FILIPPO ROSSO
CLIMATE

▷
Flood victims
relocate in
Pakistan’s Sehwan
Sindh province in
September 2022

effects of climate change are—at least for now— to help their poorer counterparts adapt. The year
being felt disproportionately in places that did lit- 2020 passed without countries in the Global
tle to cause the problem. Flooding now regularly North meeting their longtime promise to provide
puts 25% of Bangladesh underwater. Countries on $100 billion in climate finance annually beginning
the African continent have emitted less than 3% of that year, half of which was supposed to finance ad-
global emissions but are experiencing the brunt aptation. About $80 billion flowed from north to
of the impacts in the form of drought, flooding, south in 2020, according to the Organisation for
and coastal degradation. Drought-driven famine Economic Cooperation and Development. Some
in East Africa is killing a person every 36 seconds. assessments suggest that countries in the Global
The continent already loses up to 15% of its annual North will make up for that deficit in the coming
GDP per capita because of climate effects; that fig- years, but that number is now outdated. Trillions
ure could double in the coming decades. will be needed because of the effects we’ve now
Many prominent climate advocates have high- baked in with decades of inaction.
lighted this sheer and in some ways outrageous These failures have put finance for what’s
injustice, from leaders of small island nations to known as loss and damage—essentially funds
Greta Thunberg to Pope Francis. And international to address the unavoidable harm from climate
climate agreements have reflected climate justice change—at the center of international discussions.
over and over again, emphasizing the principle of The climate costs to physical infrastructure, indus-
“common but differentiated responsibilities,” a try, and economic output will be enormous, poten-
wonky way of saying that wealthy countries owe tially adding up to $1 trillion annually by 2040,
it to the rest of the world to move aggressively. according to a 2019 study. The risk of having to
But they haven’t followed through. The poli- pay up is precisely what has historically kept the
cies countries have enacted to cut emissions would U.S. and European countries from a full-throated
J A N A L I L A G H A R I — A N A D O L U A G E N C Y/G E T T Y

limit global warming to around 2.7°C, according embrace of policies to address loss and damage.
to Climate Action Tracker. That’s far greater than But there are risks in sidestepping the issue too.
the “well below 2°C” that countries agreed to in It’s impossible to know exactly how the effects of
the Paris Agreement. At the current expected level, climate change will unfold and how these damages
we will likely see the inundation of small island will ripple across the globe, but the vast body of
states and tens of millions of climate migrants in research, government analysis, and academic lit-
sub-Saharan Africa, according to the Intergovern- erature on future scenarios suggests some com-
mental Panel on Climate Change. Developed coun- mon expectations. Chief among them is migration.
tries have also failed to live up to their commitment Already, drought has uprooted communities in
44 Time November 7/November 14, 2022
Central America, driving migrants to cities and,
eventually, to the U.S. Meanwhile, drought in Syria
has contributed to the struggles driving over a mil-
lion migrants from the war-torn country to Europe.
These movements of people have, respectively,
stoked political upheaval in the U.S. and helped By Aryn Baker
topple governments in Europe. And it’s just a taste
of the expected hundreds of millions of migrants
expected in the coming decades.
There’s also the economic damage that may
begin in the Global South but is likely to spill over.
A 2018 study from Cambridge University, for ex-
ample, found that extreme weather events may
begin in one country but create economic waves
elsewhere, affecting everything from household
income to bond yields thousands of miles away.
Global supply chains will struggle to rearrange
themselves in a constantly evolving constellation
of climate risks—harming consumers and busi-
nesses in the north.

All of these chAllenges, and many more, cre-

ate a threat to the geopolitical order that the U.S.
has seeded, fostered, and administered for most
of the past century. The U.S. and Europe will have
less credibility as countries grapple with the dam-
age caused by a century of unchecked emissions.
Countries crippled by internal conflict may see
governance break down, allowing extremist fac-
tions to rise in the vacuum and creating space for
terrorist cells. As the climate situation gets more
extreme, some may experiment with untested
technologies to try to shape weather patterns in
their favor. A few billion dollars, for example, can
buy a country the technology to spray sulfur diox-
ide into the upper atmosphere to reduce tempera-
tures in a target region. That may be cheap in the
scheme of a country’s budget, but these technolo-
gies, known broadly as geoengineering, have un-
known implications for the global climate.
It may be too late to avoid some of these conse-
quences, but there’s still an opportunity to reduce
their impact. Funding adaptation measures—think
of education for rural farmers or upgraded munici-
pal infrastructure—will help reduce the impact of
a disaster and the chance that its effects will ripple
across the globe. When disaster does hit, paying
to help communities rebuild will help limit spill-
over and keep the global economy humming. The
most important thing may simply be engaging ear-
nestly to build confidence that the Global North
can still be trusted and that all countries can work
together—on climate and other issues.
If the coming U.N. climate conference can fos-
ter a renewed sense of mutual faith, it will have
succeeded, by many accounts. “One of the main
objectives that we are aiming for is to regain the
trust between the parties,” says Sameh Shoukry,
CLIMATE

the Egyptian Foreign Minister who is also lead- publicly committed the U.S. to advancing policy
ing COP27, “to provide the confidence that we on loss and damage at COP27 and said the U.S. will
are all in this together and that no one is going double down on climate funding initiatives in the
to be left behind.” Global South. “We have to find a way for more cap-
For anyone with a sense of humanity, it can be ital to flow into developing countries,” he told me
downright depressing that it takes hearing about on Oct. 26. And leaders from both developing and
the threats to their own self-interest to make lead- developed nations have supported a wholesale re-
ers in wealthy countries pay up to save lives in the form of the Bretton Woods institutions—the World
Global South. And some may recoil at the focus Bank and International Monetary Fund—with cli-
on secondary effects in the Global North rather mate change in mind. The World Bank could com-
than the immediate effects on the ground. And mit to taking the “first loss” on big climate projects,
yet there’s a simple logic to it: it works. for example, and in doing so make such projects
Dallas Conyers, international liaison at the U.S. more attractive for private-sector investors. The
branch of the activist group Climate Action Net- IMF could allocate hundreds of billions in finance
work, says that officials in the Global North need to give developing countries the space to pursue
to be spoken to in terms that they care about. “Be- climate projects. These moves could, in turn, cata-
cause of the history of our government, there’s very lyze trillions in investment from the private sector.
specific language that we have to use,” she says. “There is more of a willingness on the part of all
“We need to start talking to them about money.” the parties to come together and try and move this
discussion forward,” says Alok Sharma, a former
NoNe of this is going to be easy. Last year, I minister in the British government who led last
spoke with John Kerry, the former U.S. Secretary year’s COP26 conference in Glasgow. “It is a very
of State and current climate envoy, on the sidelines difficult discussion; that’s why it’s taken so long.”
of the U.N. General Assembly in New York City. By all accounts, the weight of recent climate-
Climate watchers were waiting in anticipation to related disasters has helped move the needle. From
see whether President Joe Biden would commit the Nigeria to Germany to India, the world has been
U.S. government to upping its financial commit- inundated with a tide of extreme weather events
ment to aid developing countries’ climate efforts. in recent months signaling that the era of loss and
Kerry described such a commitment as “the damage has indeed arrived.
ticket of admission” for the U.S. to remain cred- The conversation about the on-the-ground dev-
ible, and said he was “optimistic” it would come astation in the most vulnerable parts of the world
through. But he also said it was politically chal- needs to continue. But the reality is that we also
lenging for the Administration as it sought to pass need to be talking about the ripples. Pakistan offers
infrastructure legislation and manage other con- a prime example of the selfish case for the Global
cerns in Washington. “It’s just that it comes at a North. It’s a nuclear-armed state that collaborates
tricky time,” he told me. “The bandwidth can only with the U.S. to address terrorism in South Asia. It
take so much.” exports billions in textile and food products around
The next day, Biden committed the U.S. to con- the world, including to the U.S., its largest trading
tributing more than $11 billion annually to climate partner, and Europe.
initiatives for developing countries; climate advo- Sending aid to Pakistan will help it cope with
cates from the Global South dismissed it as the bare its precarious climate. Glaciers in its mountaintops
minimum. A few months later at the U.N. climate are melting, contributing to flooding. Meanwhile,
conference in Glasgow, delegates from the Global the country is home to some of the hottest spots in
South demanded recognition of loss and damage the world, where heat waves already kill residents
and took negotiations into overtime until the U.S., on a regular basis. Pakistan now estimates recent
the E.U., and other reluctant flooding will cost it $40 billion;
parties agreed to a “dialogue” as of late October, it had re-
on the topic—a small step for- ‘IF YOU’RE ceived $129 million in aid.
ward with only a few details
agreed at the outset.
NOT GOING But helping tackle Pakistan’s
issues will help everyone else
But since then, a surprising TO ADDRESS too. “The entire bargain in cli-
momentum has emerged. With CLIMATE CHANGE mate negotiations now is pre-
the support of partner coun-
tries in the G-7, Germany pro- EQUITABLY, THEN mised on climate justice,” says
Rehman. “And that bargain be-
posed an insurance scheme to YOU WILL HAVE tween the North and the South
help protect the most vulnera-
ble countries from the costs of
CONFLICT.’ has to be working now.” —With
reporting by Simmone Shah/
—SHERRY REHMAN,
climate disasters. Kerry has PAKISTANI CLIMATE MINISTER new York 
46 Time November 7/November 14, 2022
 O N O C T. 2 , 2 0 2 2 I N S I N G A P O R E , T I M E B R O U G H T T O G E T H E R E X T R A O R D I N A R Y L E A D E R S
A N D C H A N G E M A K E R S W H O H AV E M A D E A L A S T I N G I M PA C T O N T H E I R I N D U S T R I E S
F O R T H E T I M E 1 0 0 L E A D E R S H I P F O R U M A N D T H E T I M E 1 0 0 I M PA C T AWA R D S .
D B S B A N K C E O P I Y U S H G U P TA , S I N G E R A N D A C T O R L E A S A L O N G A , S C H M I D T F U T U R E S
C O - F O U N D E R E R I C S C H M I D T, A N D A C T O R A N D P R O D U C E R A L I A B H AT T W E R E A M O N G T H O S E
W H O S H A R E D T H E I R I N S P I R I N G STO R I E S A N D I N S I G H TS .

EXPERIENCE MORE
T I M E . C O M / I M PA C T

T H A N K YO U T O O U R PA R T N E R S

F O U N D I N G PA R T N E R K N O W L E D G E PA R T N E R I N N O VAT I O N PA R T N E R
Last year, Sam was too sick to dream.
He has Primary Immunodeficiency or PI.
Thanks to the Jeffrey Modell Foundation,
he has been properly diagnosed and treated.
Now he’s head of the class.

helping children reach for their dreams

info4pi.org
CLIMATE

BANGLADESH’S
MEDIA LESSON
By Saleemul Huq

All lighTs Are ouT here in my Climate change is therefore a life-

home city of Dhaka as I write these and-death issue for Bangladesh, and
words. Cyclone Sitrang has knocked our media cover it accordingly. Most
out the electricity in Bangladesh’s news outlets—TV, radio, print, and
capital, plunging this city of 22 mil- digital—run climate stories on a reg-
lion people into darkness. ular basis. And they play the story
But one thing we Bangladeshis big. State-run channels such as Ban-
are not in the dark about is climate gladesh Television as well as private
change. We understand that overheat- competitors such as Channel i run
ing the planet has made cyclones—or well-informed climate stories at the
hurricanes, as they’re called in other top of their broadcasts, and explore
parts of the world—stronger and more the issue in popular talk shows.
destructive. We know this largely be- Bangladeshi journalists and news-
cause our media have long treated rooms woke up to the climate story
climate change as a major news story because they were lobbied by experts
that the public needs to know about. and, not least, by reality. Extreme
As record heat, drought, fires, and weather events kept illustrating how
floods afflict more and more of hu- vulnerable our country was. Cyclone
manity, it is clear that our planetary Sidr, a category 4 storm that struck
house is on fire. Our experience in in November 2007, particularly got
Bangladesh illustrates that more and newsrooms’ attention.
better news coverage is also an es- When world leaders met at COP26
sential climate solution, because it in November 2021, three Bangladeshi
fosters the broad awareness and pub- TV channels traveled to Glasgow
lic pressure on governments that’s to report live on the deliberations.
needed to put the fire out. As a result, the average person in By Mia Mottley
Unfortunately, mainstream news Bangladesh is quite well-informed
outlets in the U.S. have a long history about climate change and what can be
of downplaying or misreporting the done about it.
climate story. During Obama’s presi- The contrast with the U.S. is
dency, U.S. news outlets devoted 40 stark. When Hurricane Ian was
times as much coverage to the Kar- bearing down on Florida, only 4%
dashians as to how global warming was of U.S. national-TV networks’ initial
overheating the oceans, analysis by the coverage even mentioned climate
nonprofit watchdog Media Matters change. Is it any surprise, then,
found. In 2021, climate stories still ac- that Americans know so little about
counted for only 1% of total coverage climate change? For example, only
by ABC, CBS, NBC, and Fox News. 39% of Americans know that most
Not so in Bangladesh. Situated scientists agree that climate change is
on the delta of two of the world’s happening today.
biggest rivers—the Ganges and the More and better news coverage is
Brahmaputra—Bangladesh has a very not a silver bullet. It cannot defuse
low-lying coastal region that fronts the climate emergency by itself. But
on the Indian Ocean. Tens of millions it is indispensable to changing course
of people live in that coastal region, in time to preserve a livable planet,
where they are threatened by flood- for all of us.
ing from the rivers as well as cyclones
from the ocean and sea level rise, Huq is director of the International
which is gradually making coastal soil Centre for Climate Change and
saltier and endangering rice yields. Development in Dhaka
50 Time November 7/November 14, 2022
◁
I AM A
CLIMATE
MIGRANT
By Nyombi Morris

I was 10 when floodIng dIsplaced

my family from the Butaleja District of
eastern Uganda in 2008—illegal sand
mining along the riverbanks exacer-
bated flooding already made worse by
climate change. We lost our farm and
home, so we moved over 130 miles
away to Kampala, Uganda’s capital
city, where we lived with my maternal
grandma. But her home quickly be-
came crowded, so we moved to a one-
room rental—much smaller and less
beautiful than our old home. It was too
much for my father. My mother raised
my siblings and me after he left. She
often struggled to find enough food or
money. I can’t count how many times
we went to sleep hungry because we
couldn’t afford food. Back on our farm,
we had plenty to eat.
And we still couldn’t escape the
impacts of climate change. I’ll never
forget one night in November 2014. It
began to rain, the power went out, and
water flooded our room. We stood out-
side all night. The next morning, we
moved back into our grandmother’s
house for four months until my mom
could afford to rent a new home.
Living through endless flooding
made me realize I had to protect the
environment. In 2020, I founded Earth
Volunteers, a climate-justice nonprofit
currently supporting youth climate ed-
ucation. That knowledge is essential:
I believe my father wouldn’t have aban-
doned us if he had known why those
floods hit in 2008, or how to respond.
We had no help or compensation for
losing our home. To this day my family
still lives in a single room. I’ve wanted
to go back to my old village many
times, but people there are now living
in a swamp. This doesn’t need to be the
story for the rest of the Global South.

Morris is a climate activist in Uganda

C A R O LY N VA N H O U T E N — T H E W A S H I N G T O N P O S T/G E T T Y I M A G E S
CLIMATE
 A
RIVER’S
DAY IN
COURT
An Indigenous community
in Ecuador fights to save
its river from the green-
transition fallout
By Mélissa Godin | Tena, Ecuador
PHOTOGR APHS BY
ANDRÉS YÉPEZ FOR TIME

Juan Grefa, an
Indigenous activist
who lives near and
works to protect the
Piatúa River
CLIMATE

What Clemente Grefa remembers

most about his childhood are
the sounds of the Piatúa River:
the hum of insects, the chatter
of children playing, the women
whistling as they clean clothes,
and the burble of water trickling.
“Living here has always been magnificent,” says
Clemente, a 67-year-old Kichwa man who lives off
the land. “We’ve been blessed with all the enchant-
ments of the river.” The Piatúa, a tributary of the
Amazon located in the Pastaza region of Ecuador,
is thought to be millions of years old. It is one of
the most biodiverse areas of the world; scientists
believe it is home to many flora and fauna yet to
be cataloged by academia. For the Kichwa Indig-
enous people of Piatúa, the river is sacred. It is a
living being, with its own temperament, mood
swings, and pulse. It is revered and feared, loved
and protected.
Early one morning in 2018, while Clemente and
his family gathered around the fire to drink their
daily wayusa tea, they heard a crash. Upstream, a
hydropower-dam company was blasting dynamite
to clear the way for a $60 million project that if
built would generate some 30 MW of electricity—
but would also threaten the river’s ecosystem, and
the lifestyle and cosmologies of the people who △
inhabit the area. Since 2014, the Ecuadorean elec- Clockwise from say they feel the project is being pushed on them.
tricity company Genefran S.A. has been approved top left: Mónica The people of Piatúa have not relented: while
by the Ministry of the Environment, Water, and Tanguila near a a date has not yet been set, they hope their case
Ecological Transition to build a hydro dam along cable car connecting will soon be heard at the Constitutional Court, the
the Piatúa River. Though the project is part of the communities on country’s most powerful judicial body. It would
government’s larger strategy to shift away from fos- opposite sides of be the first time a renewable-energy project is ac-
sil fuels toward clean energy, the people of Piatúa the river; a sign in a cused of violating the rights of nature as enshrined
local tourist center
don’t see it as a green endeavor. For them, the in Ecuador’s constitution. “This case could set a
reading “I defend
dam’s construction is an environmental death sen- my Piatúa River”;
precedent worldwide for how we think about the
tence: an estimated 90% of the river’s water vol- impacts of renewables,” says Natalia Greene, a
ume would be lost, according to Yajaira Curipallo, rights-of-nature expert and an executive commit-
who works for a governmental environment watch- tee member of the Global Alliance for the Rights of
dog, and a potentially dangerous flood risk would Nature. But for the Indigenous communities, there
be created at the nearby Jandiayacu River. “If they is a bigger question at stake: Will their voices be
B O T T O M L E F T: C O U R T E S Y T H E P I AT Ú A R E S I S T E D E F E N S E F R O N T

destroy the [Piatúa] river that gives us life,” says heard in the green transition?
Clemente, “what will we be left with?”
For years, the people of Piatúa have resisted Ecuador madE history in 2008 when it be-
the dam. In 2018, when the initial construction came the first country in the world to recog-
began, Kichwa people took their case to the pro- nize, and legally protect, nature’s right to exist
vincial courts. The judges granted the river partial and thrive under its constitution. The goal was
protection, ruling the hydro dam could not be built to incorporate Indigenous worldviews into the
until Genefran S.A. received consent from the In- country’s legal system, and to reflect the belief
digenous people. But in interviews, multiple river that nature is alive and thus has value that can’t
defenders reported receiving threatening phone be accounted for in a capitalist market system.
calls and being told not to protest. Though they “When we’re talking about the rights of nature,
could not prove whom the calls came from, they we’re not just talking about protecting plants
54 Time November 7/November 14, 2022
 justify biodiversity loss and injustice on the basis
that a project creates clean energy.”
Many experts feel the outcome of the Piatúa
trial will reveal a lot about whether the movers
of the green transition will be made to uphold
their ostensible commitment to biodiversity and
Indigenous rights—or if these companies will
drive yet another industry that destroys Indig-
enous communities. “If the judges rule in favor
[of the river], it will send the message that no
activity—regardless of whether it’s extractive or
renewable—can be allowed to cause damage to
biodiversity,” says Greene.

When a group of men from Genefran S.A. came

to visit Ines Alvarado’s community in 2016, prom-
ising jobs for the people of the Piatúa River, she
was wary. Alvarado, a 58-year-old Kichwa woman
living along the river, had heard of outsiders mak-
ing promises to Indigenous communities, only
to turn around and destroy their environment.
“I might not be educated, but I have the wisdom
of my ancestors,” she says. “It never even crossed
my mind to sign their paper.”
But many others living along the Piatúa signed,
thinking it would be a financial boon for their fami-
lies. And many say they didn’t know what they were
signing. Some didn’t even know Genefran S.A. was
an electricity-generation company: they say they
were told by Genefran S.A. that it would be doing
some nonintrusive work upstream, and that if
communities agreed, it would bring scholarships
and animals, but about respecting nature’s cos- an image of Yaku and jobs to the region. They didn’t hear back from
mologies and its spiritual worlds,” says Greene. Warmi, which Genefran S.A. for two years. “We just assumed they
Although Ecuador’s constitution states compa- means “woman of were another group of people promising us things
nies have to get prior free and informed consent the water” in the and failing to deliver,” says Clemente, who signed
from Indigenous communities before an infra- Kichwa language their paper. Then, in 2018, the company returned
structure project begins, there is no clear definition and is the name to the region not with jobs or scholarships but with
of what consent entails. Oil and mining companies given to the sacred bulldozers and dynamite.
rock of the Piatúa,
have exploited this legal loophole by withholding where a mermaid
“We did not know what we had signed,” says
information about their activities when consult- is said to live; the Clemente’s brother Juan Grefa, 68, who lives along
ing with communities, in order to secure a few sig- Genefran S.A. dam the river. “They took advantage of our needs and
natures of consent, and both Indigenous people project area on our innocence. But we fought back.” Shortly after
and environmentalists have grown to expect this April 27 the first blasts of dynamite were heard that year,
behavior from them. But these groups are disap- over 19 communities in the region gathered in the
pointed to see renewable-energy companies in- town of Santa Clara to talk about what they could
creasingly taking advantage of the same loopholes. do to stop the construction. As night fell, around
Ecuador is not the only country grappling with 300 women, men, and children headed to the con-
this issue. Around the world, some clean-energy struction site along the Piatúa River, armed with
companies are being scrutinized for wreaking hand-carved wooden spears. People piled onto
havoc on biodiversity, and perpetuating many of motorbikes and into cars; taxis gave protesters
the same human-rights abuses as polluting indus- free rides to the site. When the workers arrived,
tries, with Indigenous communities often paying the crowd surrounded them, as Kichwa leaders
the price. Experts say part of the challenge in hold- told the company they had 24 hours to get out.
ing these industries to account is that people are The government sent in the police, then the milita-
hesitant to critique the renewables sector over rized police. Eventually, the Confederation of In-
fears this may temper enthusiasm to move away digenous Nationalities of the Ecuadorean Amazon
from fossil fuels. But as Greene notes, “You cannot (CONFENIAE) reached an accord with the head
55
CLIMATE

of Genefran S.A., who said the company would re-

move its machinery from the site if the protesters
dispersed.
In the following days, however, CONFENIAE
realized Genefran S.A. was not going to comply; it
was keeping vital machinery next to the river, sug-
gesting the company was pausing, not halting, its
work. Kichwa communities responded by closing
the main road between Puyo and Tena, piling rocks
into the middle of the street and bringing a criti-
cal highway in the Amazon to a stop. “It doesn’t
take very long for people to pay attention when
you close that road,” says Darling Kaniras, 29, an
environmental engineer, river defender, and local
tourist guide.
Company records show that Genefran S.A. is
majority-owned by ElitCorp, an energy and infra-
structure company, with a minority share held by
Gustavo Rafael Villacreces Oviedo, an ElitCorp ex-
ecutive who appears to be related to the listed gen-
eral manager for Genefran S.A., Roberto José Villac-
reces Oviedo. TIME reached out to both companies
to comment on the nature of their relationship and
this story, but did not hear back from either.
The battle eventually moved from the road to
the provincial court in May 2019, after the case
was brought to the court’s attention by Curipallo,
who heads the provincial office for a branch of
the government that serves as a watchdog to en-
sure the state upholds the rights of people and na-
ture. Curipallo was convinced the evidence clearly △
showed that Genefran S.A. had failed to explain Alexis Grefa, problem is that Indigenous communities have to
to those who signed the contracts what its activ- a 26-year-old demonstrate their expansive land-based world-
ities in the area would entail. But the provincial activist with the view within the logic of the courtroom, the same
court judges ruled in favor of Genefran S.A., on Piatúa Resiste logic that has brought about colonization and re-
the basis of what they said was insufficient evi- Defense Front, source extraction,” says Alex Knott, an anthropolo-
dence that the river was home to a “culturally and near one of the gist working with Piatúa River defenders to docu-
river’s sacred
spiritually significant” community. In September rocks
ment cultural heritage. “They are being asked to
2019, Aurelio Quito, one of the judges who pre- show that their culture still exists by pointing to
sided over the hearing, was arrested over accusa- things that can be easily seen and heard, but so
tions by a colleague that Quito had been bribed much of culture is intangible.”
by the construction company and tried to bribe Curipallo hopes the Constitutional Court will
another judge to vote in favor of the dam’s con- rule in favor of the river, protecting it from exploi-
struction. A new hearing was held later that month tation once and for all. But it’s not just about the
in which the river was granted partial protection: outcome for Curipallo; it’s also about how the case
the court ruled that Genefran S.A. could not con- is argued. While the prosecutors could build their
tinue construction until it redid proper technical case on the grounds that the dam would lead to the
studies of the project’s environmental impacts and extinction of certain plant species and cause irre-
got informed consent from communities. Kichwa versible damage to the river’s life cycles, Curipallo
communities celebrated, but Curipallo was wor- thinks there is a bigger argument to be made: “The
ried there would be further issues on the horizon. rights of Indigenous people have to be upheld by
That’s because the court had not actually agreed renewable companies.”
that the Kichwa people of the Piatúa constituted
a “culturally and spiritually significant” commu- Over the past 10 years, the Ecuadorean gov-
nity. The court cited the Kichwa witnesses’ lack ernment has embarked on a mass effort to intro-
of traditional dress, and the fact that they gave duce hydroelectricity throughout the country. In
their testimonies in Spanish, as evidence that 2015, then President Rafael Correa announced
these Indigenous cultures no longer exist. “The eight new hydropower plants would be operational
56 Time November 7/November 14, 2022
 This report was made possible in part by the
Fund for Environmental Journalism of the
Society of Environmental Journalists

All of the elders who have lived their lives on

the banks of the Piatúa will tell you stories of the
wilder river they knew in their youth: it stole ani-
mals and gifted them; it made some people sick
and healed others; its spirits appeared in the form
of superhuman beings. The people of Piatúa fear
that a hydro dam could bring an end to their way
of life. “There are spirits here because there is bio-
diversity,” explains Knott, the anthropologist. “If
you cut off the river and kill the biodiversity, you
would in essence be severing people’s connection
to their spirituality.”

IndIgenous communItIes across Ecuador are

watching closely for the moment when the river
gets its day in court. Until then, the people of
Piatúa are continuing to push back attempts by
Genefran S.A. to get the project restarted, by orga-
nizing gatherings to educate the public about what
signing consent forms actually means, and work-
ing with anthropologists to help classify the river
as a cultural-heritage site. “We’re doing what we
have to do,” says Alexis Grefa, 26, a Kichwa river
defender (who is not related to Clemente and
Juan). “We’re defending our part of the earth.”
For many, such resistance has taken a toll. Some
of those who have been outspoken about the proj-
ect report receiving menacing phone calls or being
followed, with those threatening them demand-
ing they back down from their activism. Though
they do not know if Genefran S.A. is behind these
in 2016. But the projects have been delayed be- threats—many river defenders said the actions
cause of their failure to meet environmental and were carried out by third parties and cannot be
engineering standards. One of the dams, the Coca traced back to the company—the threats have
Codo Sinclair, caused a river to dry up and the caused many river defenders to uproot their lives.
country’s highest waterfall to disappear; ero- Cristian Aguinda, the former president of the Na-
sion from the project also ruptured two pipelines, tive People of the Kichwa Nationality of Santa Clara
causing an oil spill. The people of Piatúa care Canton, spent much of the past decade leading the
deeply about the climate crisis. But for them, the movement against the hydro dam. But eventually
hydro dam is not a path away from environmen- he moved away from the area, fearing for his fami-
tally harmful industries: it is a new form of eco- ly’s safety. “I’ve had to give up jobs and have missed
logical devastation. “It is the same injustice and my oldest daughter’s childhood,” he says.
destruction,” says Kaniras, the engineer and river The younger generation is now picking up the
defender, “it’s just being called green to get the per- fight. Clemente’s children had left for Santa Clara,
missions and satisfy the international community.” a nearby town, but are now moving back to the
Along the Piatúa River, people young and old re- river’s banks. For young people, the river is a sanc-
peated that they were not interested in the money tuary where nature and Indigenous culture can
a hydro dam would generate. This is partly because thrive, in a region increasingly under pressure
they do not believe they would reap the financial from extractive industries and globalization. “It’s
benefits of the project. “Look at what is happen- the only place where there is peace,” says Kaniras.
ing with petroleum elsewhere in the Amazon,” says “The river is like a part of me.” Like many others
Clemente. “The money leaves.” More important, fighting the project, he dreams of a future where
many people living along the river care more about the transition away from fossil fuels allows Indig-
maintaining their spiritual, cultural, and ecologi- enous communities to finally live peacefully, not
cal richness than about filling their bank accounts. in resistance. “I don’t want my daughter to inherit
“The river gives us water, and the land gives us fights or conflicts,” says Kaniras. “I just want her to
food,” Alvarado says. “Yes, we are poor, but we swim in the river, to fish, and to know the people
don’t need more.” of the communities.” □
57
CLIMATE

WHAT EGYPT’S to support government policies have had their

assets frozen, leaders arrested, and activities
surveilled by security forces. Some civil-society
MISSING AT COP27 leaders have been kidnapped and tortured.
Environmental activists are among those tar-
By Sahar Aziz geted by the state’s crackdown on dissent. A re-
cent report by Human Rights Watch found, for
example, that when environmental groups op-
posed the government’s reintroduction of coal
in cement factories, campaign supporters were
summoned by the state security forces, harassed
at airports, or threatened with terrorism-related
charges. An Egyptian law passed in 2019 re-
stricts NGOs from conducting opinion polls or
field research without government approval.
In the rare case when approval is granted, the
NGO can’t publish results without further gov-
ernment blessing. Nor can civil society cooper-
ate with foreign organizations or receive foreign
funding without prior government assent—
rarely given. Further, the government can at
any point declare illegal any activity that under-
mines “national security, public order, or public
morals”—based on opaque, unilateral criteria.
Civil-society organizations that fail to follow
the law are subject to fines or dissolution. Their
△ leaders are arrested and charged with trumped-
climaTe change has no regard for sTaTe A mural of up terrorism charges while their personal assets
borders. Nor does a nation’s wealth or power im- Egyptian are frozen, all without due process. Moreover,
munize it from the annual rise in temperatures President Sisi, the Egyptian government has blocked more than
exacerbating extreme flooding, droughts, and who came to 500 websites and severely restricted access to
storms. This reality is bringing together nearly power in 2013 information and reporting on human rights and
200 nations for COP27, to be held in Egypt—a and has not environmental issues. Debates that implicate
nation highly vulnerable to climate change but been a friend of industrial pollution, as well as corporate inter-
environmental
antagonistic toward an essential stakeholder in activists in the
ests in real estate, tourism development, and
the climate conversation: independent civil soci- country agribusiness that exacerbate the impacts of cli-
ety. Indeed, the Egyptian government has given mate change, are politically off-limits. The con-
summit access only to local nongovernmental or- sequence is an absence of climate activism and
ganizations (NGOs) that support the regime. public awareness about the grave environmen-
With only 3.4% of its land arable and more tal challenges facing Egypt. Field research, data
than 30% of its population living in poverty, collection, and policy recommendations by in-
Egypt cannot afford contractions to its domes- dependent experts are vetted by government
tic food and water supply. Rising temperatures, security forces whose priority is preserving the
water scarcity, and soil salinity are shrinking regime—not saving Egypt from natural disasters.
crop yields in the Nile Delta, which account for The stakes of climate change are too high for
nearly all the nation’s domestic food supply, 11% this punitive approach to an engaged, indepen-
of gross domestic product, and 21% of its labor dent civil society. Widespread hunger and water
force. Egypt has failed to fully address climate shortages are potent ingredients for civil unrest
realities and stymied Indigenous voices calling and revolution—the very thing the Egyptian gov-
N AT H A L I E G U I R O N N E T — H A N S L U C A S/ R E D U X

for more progressive approaches to the changing ernment wants to prevent. COP27 should be a
environment. COP27 should be an opportunity wake-up call for autocratic regimes across the
for Egypt to lead by example; instead, hosting world that the effects of climate change will end
the event seems to be political cover for its self- their rule long before any real or imagined politi-
defeating repression of civil society. cal opposition.

Since coming to power in 2013, the regime Aziz is a professor of law at Rutgers University
of President Abdul Fattah al-Sisi has treated civil and author of The Racial Muslim: When Racism
society as enemies of the state. NGOs that refuse Quashes Religious Freedom
58 Time November 7/November 14, 2022
 MAKE THE MOST
OF YOUR SUBSCRIPTION
Digital access is free to print subscribers.
Visit TIME.com/login to link your account

Not a subscriber?
Visit TIME.com/EMEAOFFER
IN DUDAMEL’S 13 YEARS WITH THE
L.A. PHILHARMONIC, AUDIENCE SIZE
AND REVENUES HAVE SKYROCKETED

60 Time November 7/November 14, 2022

 LEADERSHIP SERIES

PRE-EMINENT CONDUCTOR
GUSTAVO DUDAMEL
WANTS TO TAKE CLASSICAL
MUSIC OFF ITS PEDESTAL
BY ED LEIBOWITZ

Gustavo DuDamel has been lureD back onto the

stage for his second encore.
It’s Oct. 9, opening night of the Los Angeles Philhar-
monic’s 2022–23 season. As the crowd spots the conduc-
tor, the volume inside the Walt Disney Concert Hall surges.
He acknowledges the accolades, steps onto the podium,
tilts his head back, lifts his arms, and hurls himself forward
like a battering ram as the orchestra explodes into the first
note of the Star Wars theme.
Dudamel’s curly mop of brown hair has a touch of gray
now, but at 41, over a decade into his time as the L.A. Phil’s
music and artistic director, it roils atop his head with as
much vigor as when he conducted in his 20s. His pat-
ent leather shoes are a riot of activity.
When Dudamel is done, the audience leaps to its feet
with the kind of reaction you’d expect to see at a Taylor
Swift concert. Dudamel doesn’t take a bow—he never
bows. Instead, he motions for the orchestra to stand up and
share in the acclaim. He gives a big hug to Anne-Sophie
Mutter, the virtuoso violinist and tonight’s featured solo-
ist, and another to John Williams as the 90-year-old com-
poser of the scores for Star Wars, Jaws, and many other
classic movies navigates his way toward center stage. Wil-
liams and Mutter keep waving Dudamel over to join them,
but he refuses to make it a trio. Instead, he stays on the
sidelines, turning toward them in profile, just one more
adoring face in the crowd.
“Music is not only an element of entertainment in the
society,” Dudamel says. “It is a power of transformation.
You’re sitting there for a symphony that is, like, 30 or 50
minutes, and time is gone. It unites us, even if we come in
feeling completely different.”
Under Dudamel’s aegis for the past 13 years, the L.A.
Phil has spread classical music’s unifying power well past
its traditional confines—across divides of class, race, gen-
der, and age. It’s an eventuality the New York Times did
not envision in June 2005, when it published an article
titled Decline in listeners worries orchestras.
In places, the piece, written by the Times’ classical-music
PHOTOGR APH BY JEENAH MOON 61
C U LT U R E

critic, reads like the prelude to an obituary:

“Orchestra subscription sales are drop-
ping widely, in some cases by as much as two
percentage points a year. Ensembles are not
balancing their budgets. Audiences are get-
ting older; young people are turned off by
classical music.”
What was creeping toward death’s door
wasn’t classical music itself, but classi-
cal music as an elite and exclusionary art
form. Within this framework, the great or-
chestras were dominated by towering white
men of genius who safeguarded and ele-
vated a canon dominated by towering dead
white men of genius—among them Mozart,
Beethoven, and Tchaikovsky. Performances
of these masterworks were geared to an au-
dience prideful of its refined tastes and get-
ting a bit long in the tooth.
The emergence of Dudamel as per-
haps our greatest living conductor is itself
a disruption. Dudamel and the L.A. Phil
often provide orchestral accompaniment
for pop icons like Billie Eilish, who bring
in hundreds of millions of teens and
20-somethings. Their Youth Orchestra Los
Angeles (YOLA) has outfitted 1,500 of the
city’s most vulnerable children with free vi- DUDAMEL LEADS YOLA, them that he couldn’t stay for the meal—he’d de-
olas, trumpets, and other instruments; pro- A YOUTH ORCHESTRA
THAT PROVIDES FREE
cided to celebrate at a local hot dog stand. He left
vided free lessons; and put them on a stage. INSTRUMENTS AND LESSONS the room and flew out of town the next day. “I love
(The high school graduation rate for YOLA this, because it’s so authentically Gustavo,” says
musicians stands at 100%; 90% of them go Chad Smith—then with the New York Philhar-
on to attend college. By contrast, the Los Angeles Unified School District monic, and now the L.A. Phil’s CEO. “At a time
has a preliminary graduation rate of 85%, and about 61% of the district’s when any other conductor would be working
students attend college, according to the latest data available.) And two everyone—‘What have you got for me?’—he was
mentees of the L.A. Phil’s Dudamel Fellowship Program have gone on telling them, ‘I’m not interested. This is not what
to break crystal-chandeliered ceilings before they turned 29. In 2016, I want to do.’ It was a really eye-opening experi-
Lithuanian-born Mirga Grazinyte-Tyla became the first female music ence, that he had the wherewithal to do that and
director in the history of the City of Birmingham Orchestra, while next just didn’t play the game.”
fall, Jonathon Heyward will become the first Black music director to
lead the Baltimore Symphony. DuDamel wasn’t born to play that game,
Business-wise, it’s all working. During the pandemic, the Phil ex- nor was he nurtured, educated, or socially situ-
panded free online access to Dudamel’s concerts; the 2021–22 season ated to play it. Classical music as he first experi-
opening gala, virtually streamed from Disney Hall, garnered 2.2 million enced it was an art without hierarchy—where no
views. For fiscal year 2018–19, the last before the pandemic struck, the one was to be excluded from the orchestra or the
New York Philharmonic took in $24.8 million in concert sales, whereas audience on the basis of race, ethnicity, or class.
the L.A. Phil realized $93.9 million. Dudamel was raised in a working-class family in
Three months after the Times article appeared, Dudamel made his Barquisimeto, Venezuela. His mother was a voice
U.S. debut at the Hollywood Bowl. The previous year, in Bamberg, Ger- teacher, and his father played trombone in a salsa
many, Dudamel had taken first prize in the first ever Mahler Conducting band. But perhaps more important to his musical
Competition for young maestros. With that win, at age 23, he’d become development was El Sistema, Venezuela’s nation-
a piping-hot commodity in an ailing industry. The moment he walked wide classical-music education and performance
into his first L.A. Phil postconcert artist’s dinner, he realized that he’d program for disadvantaged youth.
been put on the menu as the evening’s main entrée. Gathered around El Sistema welcomed a 5-year-old Dudamel
the table were the executives of eight major American orchestras, who into its fold and first put a violin in his hands
had flown to L.A. to catch the concert and acquaint Dudamel with what three years later. Founded in 1975 by the late con-
their organizations had to offer. ductor and philanthropist José Antonio Abreu,
Dudamel politely greeted the executives one by one. Then he told El Sistema continues to provide free instruments,
62 Time November 7/November 14, 2022
 The TIME100 Leadership Series, presented in partnership with Rolex,
profiles members of the TIME100 community—the world’s most influential
people. For video conversations and more, visit time.com/leaders

one-on-one lessons, and social support to led by Dudamel performed with Coldplay at the
its students, as well as a sense of agency and Super Bowl L halftime show in 2016. Last fall, the
self-worth that for many of them had been conductor’s collaboration with Eilish was released
in short supply. After Dudamel traded in his as a concert film on Disney+. Thousands packed
bow for a conductor’s baton, Abreu would the Hollywood Bowl for an evening of Dudamel
become his teacher, mentor, and greatest and Gwen Stefani this past June. “I’m so blessed
artistic influence. Dudamel still calls him to have the chance to work with all of these great
“my maestro.” artists,” Dudamel says. “And to break these barri-
L.A. Phil launched its YOLA program in ers of what is classical and what is pop.”
2007 after Dudamel took Smith, then the As the L.A. Phil’s chief executive, Chad Smith
orchestra’s director of artistic planning, and sees opportunity where Dudamel sees art. “I try to
Deborah Borda, then its CEO, on a guided spend as much time with Gustavo as I can, because
tour of El Sistema’s good works in Vene- I never know when that moment, that spark of an
zuela. To many of the musicians of YOLA, idea, will make itself known,” Smith says. “And
Dudamel has become what Abreu was to then my job is, ‘How do we make this happen?’”
him—a teacher, a cheerleader, and a re- In the Dudamel era, the L.A. Phil has the
sounding reminder of what’s achievable. will and the means. In fiscal year 2009–10,
Dudamel had only been playing violin a which coincided with the conductor’s first sea-
few months when he was assigned to the back son leading the orchestra, the organization re-
of the second-violin section of an El Sistema ported $33 million in charitable donations. Nine
600-piece orchestra, scheduled to perform years later, the total had risen to double that—
at the anniversary celebration of his city’s $66 million. This season’s opening gala alone
founding. He could coax only three notes yielded $3.5 million in giving.
out of his instrument, and quickly decided
to quit. “I said to my teacher, ‘I cannot play although there’s been no shortage of out-
this,’ ” Dudamel recalls. “And he says, ‘Just side interest, Dudamel has just extended his con-
enjoy, live the moment—and you will see.’” tract with the L.A. Phil through the 2025–26 sea-
He did. “We played that first note,” Dudamel says, “and this feel- son. The roots he put down in Los Angeles have
ing went across my body and my ears. The music transformed me. We spread far beyond Disney Hall. In October 2021
were all transformed that day.” the Beckmen YOLA Center opened its doors in
As Dudamel remembers it, even after he became a teenage conducting the historically Black (and often neglected) city
sensation, he wasn’t so much intent on leading a great orchestra someday of Inglewood after months of COVID-related de-
as on making a living playing music with his El Sistema friends. “That lays. On his first tour, Dudamel took in the prac-
was the most wonderful thing,” Dudamel says. “We were all creating our tice studio, the ensemble room, the choir rooms,
own path as a group. That’s why, the parents’ lounge, the two
as a conductor, I feel like another light-drenched performance
musician in the orchestra.” ‘MY MAESTRO ALWAYS SAID spaces with 45-ft. ceilings, engi-
neered by the same acoustician
When the virtuoso pianist THAT THE CULTURE FOR who fine-tuned Disney Hall.
Yuja Wang teams up with THE POOR PEOPLE CANNOT And the conductor wept. “In the
Dudamel, they usually tackle end, the worst thing about being
BE A POOR CULTURE.’
P R E V I O U S PA G E : T H E N E W YO R K T I M E S/ R E D U X ; T H I S PA G E : D A M I A N D O VA R G A N E S — A P

some of the most technically poor is to be no one,” Dudamel

difficult compositions ever writ- —GUSTAVO DUDAMEL says. “It’s not just a material
ten. In 2017 they performed thing. It’s knowing you are sep-
the full cycle of Béla Bartók’s arate from the rest.”
nearly impossible-to-play piano concertos. In February 2023 they’ll The conductor recalls something his mentor
be doing the same with Rachmaninoff. However bruising the material, Abreu once told him—how the destitute young
Wang expects the rehearsals and performance to be stress-free. musicians of El Sistema shouldn’t have to make
“The vibe with Gustavo is ‘We’re just having fun with the music,’ ” do with what’s merely adequate; how they must
Wang says. Dudamel’s musicians hear little from him about technical be provided with the best instruments, the best
adjustments and a lot about a composition’s spiritual dimension. As the teachers, and the most inspired spaces in which
L.A. Phil’s longtime jazz chair, pianist and composer Herbie Hancock has to grow and thrive.
been a close observer of Dudamel’s improvisational approach to the clas- “My maestro always said that the culture
sical canon. “With all the experience that Gustavo’s had,” Hancock says, for the poor people cannot be a poor culture,”
“I think he feels comfortable enough to try something new—to not always Dudamel says. “That’s beautiful! Give these chil-
do this like that—and still remain true to the composer of the piece. He’s dren the resources, and they will create their own
living in the moment when he conducts, and that’s jazz: in the moment.” future—their own dimension.”
Crossing genre barriers is Dudamel’s specialty. A YOLA orchestra Obi-Wan Kenobi couldn’t have put it better. □
63
CLIMATE IS EVERYTHING
In-depth articles, key updates, and trusted
analysis in one weekly newsletter.

TIME.COM/CLIMATE-EVERYTHING

JOIN TODAY
 HEAVY
IS THE
CROWN
BY ELIANA DOCKTERMAN

At a particularly
precarious moment
for the monarchy,
The Crown dredges
up the new King’s
darkest chapter
S

ANTHONY HOPKINS BRINGS WARMTH TO CORMAC MCCARTHY RETURNS FROM 8 NEW RELEASES TO WATCH, READ,
AN ’80S COMING-OF-AGE DRAMA A LONG HIATUS WITH TWO NOVELS AND LISTEN TO THIS MONTH

PHOTO-ILLUSTR ATION BY AMY FRIEND FOR TIME 65

TIME OFF OPENER

T
he British royal family would
like to remind you that The Crown
does not reflect real life inside Wind-
sor Castle. Ever since the show’s 2016
debut, royalists and historians have worried that
the drama would tarnish the legacy of Queen
Elizabeth II and that of her family. In 2020, then
U.K. culture secretary Oliver Dowden pleaded
with Netflix to include a disclaimer on its Emmy-
winning show. The streamer staunchly refused—
until this year.
The new season of The Crown, which debuts
on Nov. 9, promises to be its most controversial
to date. It will dramatize a particularly dark mo-
ment in the newly named King Charles III’s his-
tory and the monarchy at large: his divorce from
Diana Spencer, and the events leading up to her
death. British papers have reported that the royal
family has been wringing its hands over how the
show might hinder the new King’s efforts to win
over his subjects. Before the series has even de-
buted, Dame Judi Dench has sprung to Charles’
defense, writing in a letter to the Times that she
fears “a significant number of viewers, particu-
larly overseas, may take its version of history as
being wholly true.” John Major, the British Prime
Minister played by Jonny Lee Miller this season, Commonwealth nations’ desire to disavow the
called it a “barrel-load of nonsense.” So Netflix
Debicki’s British monarchy. Even within England, grum-
finally relented. The streamer added a line to the empathetic bling over the cost of the family grows louder;
trailer’s description, calling it a “fictional drama- portrayal taxpayers spent £86.3 million on them last year.
tisation” inspired by true events. These threats to the monarchy carry signifi-
The royal family’s concerns are not completely sets cant financial, geopolitical, and even existen-
misplaced. In the week after the Queen’s death, Charles tial consequences. And talk of abolition aside,
viewership of the first season of the six-year-old up as a bad Charles would no doubt prefer to be liked by his
series surged to the third spot on Netflix’s Top 10 subjects. Elizabeth was beloved for her stead-
Most Watched, with 40.8 million hours streamed. guy—even fastness. That’s not an adjective many would use
Unlike the subjects of other recent ripped-from- if that’s not to describe Charles. It’s up to the new King to se-
the-headlines shows about Jeffrey Dahmer or Pa- cure his subjects’ faith and loyalty: the very fate
mela Anderson, the public has very little access to the intent of the monarchy may lie in his hands. And now
the royals, who share nary a detail about their per- he has to earn that trust right as The Crown re-
sonal lives. The Crown purports to offer insight minds the public of his gravest mistakes.
into an otherwise inscrutable family. The fictional
narrative has thus become the dominant one. series creator Peter Morgan is an avowed
Perception matters, especially in this precari- royalist, but he understands Diana is the inevita-
ous time for the monarchy. Few royals have mis- ble star of this drama. The season begins in 1992,
managed their public image quite like Charles. the year of Diana and Charles’ separation. Morgan
His affair with Camilla Parker Bowles, his con- handles headlinemaking moments, like the much-
tentious divorce, and, more recently, his reported anticipated reveal of Diana’s “revenge dress,” with
falling-out with Prince Harry have defined his a light but satisfying touch and deploys the Queen,
patchy reputation. Now Prince Andrew’s trans- played by Imelda Staunton, sparingly.
gressions and Harry and Meghan’s departure But it’s Elizabeth Debicki’s empathetic por-
from royal life have shaken faith in the institu- trayal of Diana that sets Charles up as a bad
tion. Prince William and Princess Kate’s disas- guy—even if that’s not Morgan’s intent. Captur-
trous tour of the Caribbean, during which they ing the iconic Princess is no easy feat. In recent
were greeted with protests for slavery repara- years, many talented actors have tried, includ-
tions, reminded the world that even the younger ing Kristen Stewart in Spencer, Jeanna de Waal in
royals might not be suited for the modern world. Diana: The Musical, and Emma Corrin in an ear-
The Queen’s death brought new attention to lier season of The Crown. They have exaggerated
Time Off is reported by Solcyre Burga and Leslie Dickstein
 ◁
West and Debicki lead
The Crown’s most
contentious season

his parents failed to offer the affection he so clearly

needed. In Season 5, Dominic West takes over the
role from Josh O’Connor, who won an Emmy for
his portrayal, and does find some sympathetic mo-
ments: West somehow imbues the embarrassing
and awkward phone-sex conversation with his
now wife, Camilla, which will eventually domi-
nate the tabloids, with sweetness, casting their
relationship in a rather sympathetic light. The au-
dience will be outraged by the British press’s inva-
sion of his privacy when they publish their pillow
talk. And Morgan plays up Charles’ modern vision
for the future of the monarchy, a preview of what
may come to pass under his rule.
Yet faced with the charm offensive that is
Diana, it’s difficult to side with the onscreen
Prince. Early in the season, he chides Diana for
her lack of interest in history on a family trip to
Italy. (Harry, still a boy, gets little screen time
compared with William. But small acts like his
attempt to stand up for his mother in that scene
her shyness and vulnerability through fragile telegraph eventual fissures in the family.)
affectations. But Debicki (whom you may rec- West excels at embodying morally corrupt
ognize from compelling turns in Widows and characters who are utterly convinced of their
Tenet) offers the most realistic take on Diana yet. heroism: in The Wire and The Affair, he evolves
Debicki matches not only her physical stature— from charming cad to outright monster. His take
playing the 5-ft. 10-in. Diana, the 6-ft. 3-in. actor on Charles is less exaggerated than The Wire’s
slouches slightly as if to disguise her imposing compromised cop McNulty, but equally deluded.
beauty from the paparazzi cameras—but also her He begins one episode with a woe-is-me mono-
complexity. An entire episode is dedicated to dis- logue about his untapped potential; it plays as
secting Diana’s decision to speak to a biographer the backdrop to images of the Prince enjoying
against the royal family’s wishes. Andrew Morton’s the privileges of royal splendor.
real-life book unveiled details about Charles’ af- Staunton plays Ultimately, The Crown’s portrayal of Charles
fair and Diana’s struggles with disordered eating the Queen in is not as harsh as the real-life royals may fear.
and thoughts of self-harm. Debicki doesn’t shy a Diana-and- Morgan emphasizes that the King was an early
away from the bitterness and rebelliousness of this Charles-centric environmentalist, a relative populist compared
supposedly saintly figure. Her Diana turns to the season with his stodgier siblings, and a man loyal to one
biographer because she feels trapped and manipu- ▽ woman throughout his life. (Unfortunately, that
lated, yes, but also resentful of her treatment by woman was not his first wife.) He even writes a
the family. Other accounts of Diana tend to flatten post-divorce dialogue for Charles and Diana that
P R E V I O U S S P R E A D S O U R C E P H O T O : T I M G R A H A M — P H O T O L I B R A R Y/

her into a wronged wife and exceptional mother. offers Charles more grace than he’s usually af-
Debicki’s version can be vapid and vengeful, in forded in the demise of their relationship.
G E T T Y I M A G E S; T H E S E PA G E S : T H E C R O W N : N E T F L I X (3)

addition to nurturing and charitable. She proves Charles has done decades of image rehabili-
truer to the real Diana, as suggested by the histori- tation since Diana’s tragic death. Now, ahead of
cal record—and more entertaining to watch. The Crown’s premiere, the King has set out on
a trip across the U.K. to win hearts and minds,
CHARLES DOESN’T STAND a chance. Compared breaching protocol by accepting cheek kisses
with Diana, who arrived last season played by from fans and seeking out a corgi, his mother’s
Corrin, we’ve spent ample time with him on favorite breed, to pet on one rope line. He will
The Crown. The audience has come to un- never match the stateliness of his mother, the
derstand him: we’ve followed Charles, por- magnetism of his ex-wife, or the presence of
trayed by three different actors, through years the stars who play him on TV. But duty calls,
of bullying at boarding school and watched as and Charles has no choice but to try. 
67
TIME OFF MOVIES

◁
Repeta and
Hopkins: a bond
that can’t be broken

automatic outsider. He’s just as bright

as Paul and gets into trouble just as
often. Both love space exploration and
dream of working for NASA, even if
they have no idea how to get there.

But Johnny has Been set up to fail,

and he knows it. Paul’s home life, un-
like Johnny’s, is a world of middle-
class privilege, orchestrated by his
harried but conscientious mom (Anne
Hathaway) and his hardworking re-
pairman dad (Jeremy Strong), both of
whom Paul takes for granted. He will
listen to no one except his grandfather
Aaron (played with luminous, lived-
in warmth by Anthony Hopkins), an
English transplant whose mother es-
caped antisemitic persecution decades
earlier in Ukraine. Aaron sees all that’s
REVIEW
special about Paul, things Paul can’t
yet see in himself. At one point the
A filmmaker comes of age, two launch a model rocket together in
uneasily, in 1980s Queens the park; zinging into the sky, it seems
to ignite Paul’s delight in the possibili-
BY STEPHANIE ZACHAREK ties of life.
As much of a screwup as Paul is,
iT’s noble To Think ThaT decisiveness makes us who those possibilities are open to him;
we are. Yet the times we have failed to act are often what we Johnny can barely afford to dream.
remember most vividly. There’s the merest synapse between Repeta is wonderful here, capturing
wanting to do the right thing and actually doing it, and a civi- the ways in which Paul is both porous
lization can rise or fall in that infinitesimal space. and stubborn. But it’s Webb’s perfor-
James Gray’s quietly extraordinary Armageddon Time mance that’s likely to break you. When
is all about that gap. It’s also about growing up in Queens Johnny is with Paul, his face radiates
circa 1980, about parents who want the best for their chil- openness—as if, subconsciously, he
dren—sometimes inadvertently at the expense of other believes that if he sticks close enough
people’s children—about the way an adult’s careless remark to his friend, the good things that hap-
can crush a kid. It’s about a time and a place where people pen to white people, as opposed to the
find themselves at a moral turning point even as they’re bad things that happen to a Black kid
making dinner or sitting at a school desk or spending time like him, will be his destiny too.
with a beloved grandparent. The idea, maybe, is that our Yet everyone, including Paul, lets
moral turning points are small moments, not big ones. Johnny down. To see the blank self-
That’s a lot of weight for a movie to hold. Yet Gray protectiveness that clouds his eyes, as
(The Immigrant, The Lost City of Z) has shaped this semi- one door after another closes on him,
autobiographical work with such a light touch that even Our moral is to see the absolute coldness of our
when it’s finished, it’s not quite finished—as if the movie it- turning own country at work. There’s some
self were a traveler in a folktale, still on its way to a future just joyousness in Armageddon Time. But
out of reach. The picture’s unformed protagonist is PS 173
points this isn’t a movie that allows you to
sixth-grader Paul Graff (Banks Repeta), a bright but smart- are small make peace with yourself, or with our
alecky kid who fails to apply himself in school and gets into moments, highly imperfect world. Instead, it
trouble at every turn. He falls in with another student who’s crackles with urgency. The next failure
always singled out, for different reasons. Johnny (Jaylin not big to act could be just around the corner.
Webb) is one of very few Black students in the class, an ones Better be ready for it. 
68 Time November 7/November 14, 2022
 REVIEW

True crime polished to

a classy, sterile sheen
Few places inspire more anxiety drama A Highjacking) and adapted by
and vulnerability than hospitals, Krysty Wilson-Cairns from Charles
which makes the idea of a serial killer Graeber’s book, The Good Nurse is
prowling the corridors especially tense, all right, sometimes to the
REVIEW unnerving—especially if the killer is a reaches of unpleasantness, but mostly
nurse. That’s the dramatic gamble of just to the point of boredom. Though
The Good Nurse, based on the story of it works hard to make us believe it’s re-
Charles Cullen, currently serving mul- ally a social statement about hospitals’
tiple life sentences for murdering at lack of scruples—pay close attention
least 29 patients across New Jersey and to that hospital risk manager, played
Pennsylvania between 1988 and 2003. by Kim Dickens, who takes great pains
Eddie Redmayne plays Cullen: in the to cover up deaths that happen on her
first scene, he stands back and watches watch—its garden-variety true-crime
blankly as doctors tend to a patient roots are painfully visible.
who’s flatlined. Bad eggs don’t come Redmayne is fine as bad nurse
much worse than this. Charles, until he starts twitching and
Later, having jumped to another overemoting in the finale. Chastain is
hospital, he befriends fellow nurse the saving grace: she’s not playing a
Amy Loughren (Jessica Chastain), a pushover but a woman who desper-
single mom with two small kids and a ately needs kindness and accepts it
heart condition that will require sur- when it’s offered, even if it’s fraudu-
gery, if it doesn’t kill her first. And hav- lent. She sees Charles as a human
ing started her job only recently, she’s being, which means she feels a sharp
still a few months away from getting sense of loss when she discovers the
health insurance. She finds an ally in truth about him. Chastain renders
Charles, who radiates false kindness as every emotional shift in muted tones.
only a truly insidious serial killer can. She’s the movie’s pulse, a vibration that
Directed by Tobias Lindholm registers even amid the bedpan clatter
(whose credits include the 2012 pirate of its dressed-up tawdriness. —s.z.
A R M A G E D D O N T I M E : F O C U S F E AT U R E S; C A L L J A N E : A L A M Y; T H E G O O D N U R S E : N E T F L I X

Redmayne plays a nurse gone dreadfully rogue, while Chastain is good all around
69
TIME OFF BOOKS

REVIEW

Cormac McCarthy that Bobby has book smarts as well. His father
was a scientist on the Manhattan Project who
pushes the boundaries rubbed shoulders with Oppenheimer et al. while
they perfected, as Bobby’s university friend
BY NICHOLAS MANCUSI Long John puts it, “the design and fabrication of
enormous bombs for the purpose of incinerating
CormaC mCCarThy, The now 89-year-old whole citiesful of innocent people as they slept
winner of both a National Book Award and a in their beds.”
Pulitzer Prize, whose work is compared, not in- Bobby gave up physics to travel around Eu-
frequently, to Moby Dick and the Bible, has spent rope as a midtier race-car driver before starting
more than two decades as a senior fellow at the his career in diving. Both pursuits appeal be-
Santa Fe Institute think tank. The list of operat- cause they offer him momentary relief from not
ing principles for the institute (which he wrote) only his own intelligence but also his grief. Long
reads in part: “If you know more than anybody John diagnoses the final integral component of
else about a subject, we want to talk to you.” Bobby’s character: “He is in love with his sister.
With his two staggering new novels, the But of course it gets worse. He’s in love with his
companions The Passenger and Stella Maris, it’s sister and she’s dead.”
clear that McCarthy—best known for delivering McCarthy alternates chapters of The Passen-
stark, gory tales of morality and depravity—has ger between the mystery at Bobby’s hands and
been inspired by his time at the think tank talk- conversations that his younger sister Alicia—
ing to the world’s greatest mathematicians and the most brilliant in a family of prodigies, who
physicists. His first works of fiction to be pub- died by suicide nearly 10 years prior—has with
lished in 16 years begin in familiar territory but figures of her schizophrenic hallucinations.
push his ambitions to the very boundaries of Their ringleader, whom she has come to call
human understanding, where math and science “the Thalidomide Kid,” is a bald, scarred imp
are still just theory. about 3 ft. tall, with “flippers” instead of arms.
In The Passenger, the first of the two books, (“He looked like he’d been brought into the
Bobby Western is a 37-year-old deep-sea salvage world with icetongs.”) The Kid taunts Alicia in
diver operating mostly in the Gulf of Mexico— strange idioms in between discursions on time,
dangerous but lucrative work that’s not unlike language, and perception. From one of his lin-
exploring a foreign planet. One night Bobby and guistically withering rants: “Well mysteries just
his dive partner receive a strange assignment: abound don’t they? Before we mire up too deep
a small passenger jet has crashed in the water in the accusatory voice it might be well to re-
off the coast of Pass Christian, Miss., and they mind ourselves that you can’t misrepresent what
must dive 40 ft. under the surface to assess the △ has yet to occur.” Fans of McCarthy’s work will
situation. When the pair finds the wreck, they McCarthy’s two agree that this novel’s villain is a far sight more
encounter nine bodies sitting buckled in their new novels are loquacious than No Country for Old Men’s Anton
seats, “their hair floating. Their mouths open, his first to be Chigurh. (“Call it.”)
their eyes devoid of speculation.” In addition published in Narratively speaking, the book is more inter-
to the oddly intact fuselage, other things are 16 years ested in expanding the scope of its own mystery
out of place. The pilot’s flight bag is gone. The than in solving it. The Bobby sections depict
plane’s black box has been neatly removed him avoiding the plot entirely—he mostly has
from the instrumentation panel. And a 10th lunch with friends and converses with them
passenger, listed on the manifest, is missing about his past, physics, or philosophy. Don’t
completely. Bobby’s partner is spooked. “You come here for a thriller about a plane crash, but
think there’s already been someone down there, the pages do turn with remarkable ease. From
don’t you?” he asks. the initial mystery of a missing person, the
Soon Bobby is beset by suited men—agents novel explodes outward like an atomic chain
of an unnamed government entity—flipping reaction to the very face of God, at the intersec-
their badges at him and asking him questions. tion of mathematics and faith.
Then his friend goes down on a dive and doesn’t
come back up. Is thIs soundIng like a lot? It is. The Passen-
In many ways, Bobby resembles Llewelyn ger also happens to be something of a master-
BEOWULF SHEEHA N

Moss, the protagonist of McCarthy’s 2005 piece, an unsolvable equation left up on the
novel No Country for Old Men: laconic, capable blackboard for the bold to puzzle over. Readers
if a bit hapless, and the subject of dangerous have been waiting years for this novel, which
intrigues outside his scope. The difference is McCarthy has teased from time to time, dating
70 Time November 7/November 14, 2022
 ◁
McCarthy has won both
a Pulitzer Prize and a
National Book Award

with her psychiatrist after she has in-

stitutionalized herself toward the end
of her life, suffering under the power
of her own intellect. It offers a few
more clues, but mostly deepens the
various mysteries on offer in the first
novel. “Mathematics,” she tells her
doctor, who struggles to keep up, “is
ultimately a faith-based initiative.”

In all of hIs books, McCarthy

is a gearhead, a man obsessed with
hardware and the nuts and bolts of
things. There are no planes and cars
in The Passenger, only “JetStars” and
“1968 Dodge Chargers with 426 Hemi
engines.” A person doesn’t glance at
their watch; they glance at their white
gold Patek Philippe Calatrava. There
are whole sections that could read al-
most as instructional home repair or
auto maintenance: “The teeth had
begun to strip off of the cluster gear
until the box seized up and then the
rear U-joint came uncoupled and the
drive shaft went clanking off across
the concourse ... ” It’s been said that
when McCarthy visited the set of the
movie adaptation of All the Pretty
Horses, he spent most of his time with
the props master talking about guns.
So it makes sense that at this stage
in his career, the author would push in
his chips and attempt to understand
the mechanical clockwork of reality
itself. Like Bach’s concertos, these tri-
umphant novels depart the realm of
art and encroach upon science, aimed
back to before The Road, which he published in
2006. It is his most ambitious work, or perhaps
These at some Platonic point beyond our
reckoning where all spheres converge.
a better word would be weirdest. But it’s held triumphant It’s a rare thing to see a writer
together with wit and chuckle-out-loud humor, novels depart employ the tools of fiction in order
which can be sparse in his other novels (see the to make a genuine contribution to
apocalyptic violence of Blood Meridian). And
the realm what we know, and what we can
it’s genuinely fun to read throughout—although of art and know, about material existence.
readers who come to this book because they en-
joyed an airport paperback edition of The Road
encroach Put differently, the ideal audience
for these books are Fields Medal
while on a short flight might be left wide-eyed upon science recipients, but they’re still a privilege
and blinking. and a hoot for the rest of us to read.
Stella Maris, the slimmer companion, to be And if we can’t understand everything
published in December, is just over 200 pages’ McCarthy is writing about, one
worth of Passenger’s late sister Alicia’s dialogues suspects that he just might. 
71
 D E C I S I O N T O L E AV E : M U B I ; M O O D : N ATA L I E S E E R Y— B B C S T U D I O S/ B O N A F I D E F I L M S
TELEVISION

PODCAST
BOOK
TIME OFF RECOMMENDS

MOVIE

MUSIC

TIME November 7/November 14, 2022

TELEVISION
MOVIE

BOOK

72
 6 QUESTIONS

Dr. Siddhartha Mukherjee The physician and

Pulitzer Prize–winning author talks about cancer,
COVID, and why we’re not all bacteria

Your childhood was not without its have agency. But it’s not the agency
challenges. You have written can- you and I have. Cells behave autono-
didly about a history of schizophre- As Walt mously. They receive signals; they
nia and bipolar disorder in your integrate signals. They have a desire
family. Did that shape your deci- Whitman wrote, to survive. They have a desire to di-
sion to study medicine? From the
time I was a very young child, I was
we contain vide. So I’m not concerned about the
idea of ascribing agency to a cell, as
aware of suffering, and I think that multitudes—of long as we don’t confuse that agency
influenced the way I thought about
sickness. I began to think that sick-
cells. Do you with sentience.

ness is not something that’s treated see a poetry in Unicellular organisms were the
just by a doctor or team of doctors, only form of life on earth until
but by a community that surrounds cellular science? relatively recently in evolution-
a person. For me to want to relieve ary history. If single cells were
your pain or your distress—whether so successful, why did they ever
by making a medicine or developing bother assembling themselves into
a science—is something both human multicellular life forms? Bacteria
and quite beautiful. still exist, and they are very good
at surviving. So I would indeed ask
Cancer, which you wrote about in the question, Well, if bacteria are so
The Emperor of All Maladies, is one successful, why aren’t we all bacte-
disease that often defies our best ria? We aren’t bacteria because at
medicines. The book almost con- some point in time, evolution came
veys a certain grudging wonder to the nonconscious conclusion that
at the malign genius of the cancer in fact, agglomerations of organisms
cell. What is it about cancer that were very effective. In some selected
makes it special? Cancer cells have environments—like a New York City
this mechanism by which they can apartment—it helps not to be a bac-
turn off immune-system recognition. terium. Multicellular organisms can
In the 2000s everyone was talking gather food, they can gather infor-
about how if we sequenced the ge- mation, they can contemplate.
nome of cancer, you would find all
the keys, and all that we would need You write about the COVID-19 pan-
to do would be to find the locks. demic as something of a humbling
But we still don’t have a very good experience for scientists. Yet we’ve
pharmacopoeia of drugs to direct fought back, we’ve developed vac-
against cancer mutations. So I can cines, we’ve reopened the world,
tell a patient, “You have a mutation so how have we been humbled? We
in x, y, z gene.” And then the patient thought we knew everything about
says, “OK, what are you gonna do the immune system and viruses—and
about it?” And I say, “I don’t know. still there have been 6 million deaths.
I don’t have anything to do about it.” I think from global health systems all
the way down to allergies and immu-
Your new book, The Song of the nology, there are some fundamental
Cell, seems at points to anthropo- features we still don’t understand,
MIKE WINDLE— GE T T Y IMAGES

morphize cells. You write about and we haven’t been paying atten-
the subtle intelligence of cells, tion to them. It took a pandemic
or about the T cell as a “discern- to make us wake up and say, “You
ing” cell. Don’t you run the risk know what? This is serious stuff.”
of overestimating the complexity So yeah, I think there’s been some
of the cell? It does sound as if cells humbling. —JEFFREY KLUGER
TIME November 7/November 14, 2022