Study On Functional Outcome of Bimalleolar Ankle F
Study On Functional Outcome of Bimalleolar Ankle F
Study On Functional Outcome of Bimalleolar Ankle F
DOI: https://dx.doi.org/10.18203/issn.2455-4510.IntJResOrthop20211604
Original Research Article
1
Department Of Orthopaedics, KMCT Medical College, Calicut, Kerala, India
2
Department Of Orthopaedics , Pushpagiri Insititue of Medical Sciences, Thiruvalla, Kerala, India
*Correspondence:
Dr. Nithin Gangadhran,
E-mail: [email protected]
Copyright: © the author(s), publisher and licensee Medip Academy. This is an open-access article distributed under
the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution Non-Commercial License, which permits unrestricted non-commercial
use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.
ABSTRACT
Background: Ankle injury is the most common weight bearing orthopaedic musculoskeletal trauma encountered in
emergency medicine and practice. Ankle joint is highly congruous and any disturbance of normal articular relationship
may result in some progressive arthrosis of biomechanical dysfunction. As with all intra-articular fractures it
necessitates accurate reduction and stable internal fixation. The objectives were to study the functional outcome of
surgical treatment of bimalleolar ankle fractures and to know the complications of open reduction internal fixation of
bimalleolar fractures.
Methods: 45 patients with malleolar fractures were included in this prospective longitudinal interventional study.
Patients who underwent operative treatment were followed up regularly for 6 months with OPD visits and X-ray
imaging at each stage. Patient parameters were recorded at immediate post op period, 6 weeks, 12 weeks and 24 weeks.
Baird and Jackson scoring system for ankle were used for the functional outcome measurement.
Results: Most common type of injury pattern was supination-external rotation with 21 cases (47% of cases). The results
are excellent to good in 65% of patients, 27% of patients had fair and 8% had poor result. Syndesmotic screw fixation
was done with 4.5 mm cortical screw in 7 cases. Most common complication was surgical site infection in 3 cases
(6.67%). 2 patients underwent implant removal due to unresolved infection at 3 months.
Conclusions: The results of operative fixation were satisfactory in 90% of patients. Most of the complications were
minor and resolved within three weeks.
Keywords: Bimalleolar fracture, Baird and Jackson scoring, Functional outcome of ankle fracture, Operative
management
International Journal of Research in Orthopaedics | May-June 2021 | Vol 7 | Issue 3 Page 518
Gangadhran N et al. Int J Res Orthop. 2021 May;7(3):518-525
treatment have been thoroughly demonstrated in the analyzed using SPSS software. Association between
literature.2 various factors were assessed using chi square test and p
value <0.05 was set as statistically significant.
Malleolar fractures are one of the most common fractures
in orthopaedic traumatology. As with all intra articular RESULTS
fractures, malleolar fractures necessitate accurate
reduction and stable internal fixation. Lateral malleolar Forty five cases of bimalleolar fractures managed
fractures in the setting of a competent deep deltoid surgically by various techniques are presented. The study
ligament can usually be treated non-operative with good comprises of 56% female patients and 44% male patients.
results. In contrast, a lateral malleolar fracture with an Most common age group affected is 61-70 years (32%, 14
incompetent deep deltoid ligament is clinically equivalent cases). Right side was involved in 26 cases (58%)
to a bimalleolar ankle fracture and may result in talar compared to left side (19 cases). Twisting injury following
subluxation and degenerative arthritis when treated non- domestic fall was major cause of injury constituting 71%
operative.3 The objective of this study was to study the of the patients. Supination-external rotation injury type
functional outcome of surgical treatment of bimalleolar was the most common fracture pattern constituting 47% of
ankle fractures and to know the complications of open the cases. Surgical techniques used were open reduction
reduction internal fixation of bimalleolar fractures. and internal fixation of lateral malleolus with 1/3rd tubular
plate/recon plate with or without syndesmotic screw
METHODS fixation and the medial malleolus with 4 mm cannulated
cancellous/malleolar screws or tension band wiring. Most
Prospective interventional study was done on patients with common complication faced was postoperative skin
bimalleolar fractures of ankle who attended Pushpagiri infection in 3 cases and 2 patients among them had to
institute of medical science and research centre, undergo implant removal at 3 months. Chances of non-
Thiruvalla, Kerala between December 2012 and union of medial malleolus due to periosteal interposition is
November 2014. Study was conducted after obtaining avoided by open reduction. Understanding the mechanism
prior approval from ethics committee of the institution. A of injury is essential for good reduction and internal
written informed consent was taken from all patients after fixation. The bend of lateral malleolar should be
explaining the detailed nature of the study. During the reproduced during lateral plating for fibula. Fibular length
study all consecutive subjects with bimalleolar fractures of should be maintained for good ankle stability. Good
ankle in age group of 20 to 70 years were selected and anatomical reduction is essential for good clinical outcome
operated upon by same team of orthopaedic surgeons and irrespective of the type of fracture. At the end of the study
followed up for a period of 6 months. excellent to good results were seen in 29 (65%) cases, 12
(27%) cases had fair results and 4 (8%) had poor result.
Exclusion criteria Statistical analysis was done and found that age of the
patient was a significant determinant of postoperative
Patients below 20 and above 70 years of age, with medical functional outcome and pain. (p value 0.002 and 0.011
contraindications to surgery, with paralytic limb, open respectively).There was no statistical significance of
fractures and other associated fractures in the same limb postoperative outcome with respect to sex of the patient,
were excluded from the study. mode of injury, type of injury, co-morbidities.
International Journal of Research in Orthopaedics | May-June 2021 | Vol 7 | Issue 3 Page 519
Gangadhran N et al. Int J Res Orthop. 2021 May;7(3):518-525
Younger patients had better tolerance level to pain and Analysis of mode of injury and complications was done
hence their functional outcome was better with respect to and chi-square value was 9.844 and p value 0.363 which
older patients in this study. was found to be statistically insignificant (Figure 3).
44% 19
right
male
left
female 26
56%
International Journal of Research in Orthopaedics | May-June 2021 | Vol 7 | Issue 3 Page 520
Gangadhran N et al. Int J Res Orthop. 2021 May;7(3):518-525
Analysis of type of injury and complications was done and Analysis of DM and complications was done and chi-
chi-square value was 23.444 and p value was 0.661 which square value was 8.068 and p value was 0.527 which was
was statistically insignificant. statistically insignificant.
Analysis of type of injury and pain was done and chi- Analysis of DM and pain was done and chi-square value
square value was 2.414 and p value was 0.878 which was was 4.675 and p value was 0.097 which was statistically
statistically insignificant. insignificant.
Analysis of type of injury and result was done and chi- Analysis of DM and result was done and chi-square value
square value was 5.187 and p value was 0.818 which was was 7.361 and p value was 0.061 which was statistically
found to be statistically insignificant. insignificant.
Implants used
International Journal of Research in Orthopaedics | May-June 2021 | Vol 7 | Issue 3 Page 521
Gangadhran N et al. Int J Res Orthop. 2021 May;7(3):518-525
International Journal of Research in Orthopaedics | May-June 2021 | Vol 7 | Issue 3 Page 522
Gangadhran N et al. Int J Res Orthop. 2021 May;7(3):518-525
a b c d
e f g
h i j k
l m n
Figure 8: Clinical and radiological pictures of cases supination external rotation injury; (a) pre-operative
X-ray, (b) post-operative X-ray (ORIF with 4 mm CCS and 1/3rd tubular plate); (c, d) follow up at 6 months
(dorsiflexion of ankle and plantar flexion of ankle), pronation external rotation injury; (e, f) pre-operative X-ray;
(g) post-operative X-ray (ORIF with 4 mm CCS and 1/3rd tubular plate); (h and i) follow up at 6 months
(dorsiflexion of ankle and plantar flexion of ankle), pronation abduction injury; (j, k) pre-operative X-ray; (l) post-
operative X-ray (ORIF with 4 mm CCS, 1/3rd tubular plate and syndesmotic screw); (m, n) follow up at 6 months
(dorsiflexion of ankle and plantar flexion of ankle).
International Journal of Research in Orthopaedics | May-June 2021 | Vol 7 | Issue 3 Page 523
Gangadhran N et al. Int J Res Orthop. 2021 May;7(3):518-525
London in the year 1756. He sustained compound fracture The first and perhaps the most important contribution to
of ankle due to fall while riding a horse. The treatment the understanding of ankle fractures is credited to Lauge-
during this period was amputation for compound fracture Hansen in 1942. His doctoral thesis was not widely read or
having suffered he made a detailed description and studied appreciated until his first english publication in 1948. This
the pathological anatomy of ankle fractures. He introduced was followed by other important articles further defining
the reposition in semi flexion to reduce the fracture.4 and explaining the basis of sequential ankle fracture injury
based on experimental and radiographic studies. Two
In 1771, Jean Pierre David was the first to try to explain additional periods developed since Lauge-Hansen
the mechanism of injury in fractures of ankle and wrote classification. The AO-ASIF period (1957) of ankle
that ligaments that held the fibula in combination with fracture case was pioneered by Willenegger Allgrower,
outward movement of the foot (external rotation) resulted Muller and Schneider. Collectively this group pursued on
in a fracture of the distal fibula. During the next 150 years, bold new course of operative treatment based on unique
most experimental studies on the production of ankle metallic implants and bio-mechanical principles. Weber
injuries were done by French. In 1816, Dupuytren used a devised a classification scheme based on the original
cadaver experiments to produce ankle fractures by principles of Danis (1947-1949) which became known as
abduction or outward movement of foot.5 In 1822, Sir the Danis-Weber classification of AO (1972-1975).
Astley Cooper of London, described a wide range of ankle
fractures including the anterior and posterior margins of In 1994, Wilson et al described the malleolar fractures
lower end of tibia. resulting from isolated plantar flexion injuries both
malleoli are fractured obliquely in the sagittal plank,
In 1828, Earl was the first to describe the posterior lip though the lateral malleolar fracture runs posteriorly and
fracture of tibia.6 upwards, whereas medial malleolar fracture courses
posteriorly and downward. The results of 144 malleolar
In 1840, Maisonneuve, a pupil of Dupuytren was the first fractures during a 10 year period that were classified and
and almost only surgeon before 20th century to emphasize treated according to the AO system. Assessment of
the role of external rotation in the production of ankle outcome was done using the scoring system of Baird and
fractures showing how the external rotation of the talus in Jackson. Excellent and good results were achieved in 107
the ankle mortise could produce the high fracture of fibula of the 144 patients surgically treated.17
that bears his name.7 In 1848, Tillaux described an external
rotation fracture in which the anterolateral corner of the Majority of bimalleolar fractures that we studied were
lower tibia was avulsed by the tibio-fibular ligament.8 In supination external rotation injuries. The most common
1875, Wagstaffe described a fibular counterpart of the aetiology being road traffic accident. Females are more
tillaux fracture. In 1894, Lane was the first to recommend prone with age incidence of 61-70 years. Understanding
operative treatment in order to achieve an anatomic the mechanism of injury is essential for good reduction and
reduction of ankle. internal fixation. The bend of lateral malleolus should be
reproduced during lateral plating for fibula. Fibular length
In 1911, Destot described the comminuted fracture of the should be maintained for good ankle stability. Good
tibial plafond that has since been referred to as pilon or anatomical reduction is essential for good clinical outcome
pestle fracture.9 Destot used roentgenographic imagines to irrespective of the type of fracture. The results of operative
enhance his observations of ankle fractures. In 1922, fixation are satisfactory in 90% of patients. Chances of
Ashurst and Bromer, published a classic study on non-union of medial malleolus due to periosteal
classification and mechanism of fractures of leg bones interposition is avoided. Most of the complications were
involving ankles.10 They divided the fractures into minor and resolved within three weeks. Tension band
categories of adduction, abduction, external rotation and wiring is the method preferred for small fragments and
compression. Ashurst and Bromer were the first USG osteoporotic bone. Cast immobilization for four weeks did
anatomic, surgical and radiographic studies to postulate not affect movements at ankle because the duration was
their classification scheme, but they emphasized the bony very short.
components while ignoring the concomitant ligamentous
injuries. CONCLUSION
Almost 50 years after Earl’s report on posterior lip Majority of bimalleolar fractures that we studied were
fractures, Nelaton described fracture of the anterior lip of supination external rotation injuries. The most common
tibia.11 Muller (1945) recommended open reduction and aetiology being road traffic accident. Females are more
internal fixation of the ankle fractures and allowed prone with age incidence of 61-70 years. Understanding
immediate movement of the involved joint and the the mechanism of injury is essential for good reduction and
adjacent muscles. Bosworth in 1947, provided the first internal fixation. The bend of lateral malleolus should be
description of a low, external rotation fracture of the fibula reproduced during lateral plating for fibula. Fibular length
in which the displace proximal fragment became locked should be maintained for good ankle stability. Good
behind the posterior tibia, where it was held by an intact anatomical reduction is essential for good clinical outcome
interosseous membrane.12 irrespective of the type of fracture. The results of operative
International Journal of Research in Orthopaedics | May-June 2021 | Vol 7 | Issue 3 Page 524
Gangadhran N et al. Int J Res Orthop. 2021 May;7(3):518-525
fixation are satisfactory in 90% of patients. Chances of 8. Tillaux D. Recherches clinique setexperimentalessur
non-union of medial malleolus due to periosteal les fractures malleolaires. Bull Acad Med.
interposition is avoided. Most of the complications were 1872;1:817.
minor and resolved within three weeks. Tension band 9. Michelson J, Moskovitz P, Labropoulos P. The
wiring is the method preferred for small fragments and nomenclature for intra-articular vertical impact
osteoporotic bone. Cast immobilization for four weeks did fractures of the tibial plafond: pilon versus pylon.
not affect movements at ankle because the duration was Foot Ankle Int. 2004;25(3):149-50.
very short. 10. Ashurst APC, Bromer RS. Classification and
mechanism of fractures of the legbones involving the
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS ankle: based on a study of three hundred cases from
the episcopal hospital. Arch Surg. 1922;4:51-129.
We would like to thank all our patients who sincerely 11. Nelaton A. Elements of pathologic chirorgicale. 2nd
formed very important part of this study. ed. Paris: Germer-Baillaine; 1874: 296.
12. Bosworth DM. Fracture-dislocation of the ankle with
Funding: No funding sources fixed displacement of the fibula behind the tibia. J
Conflict of interest: None declared Bone Joint Surg Am. 1947;29:130-5.
Ethical approval: The study was approved by the 13. Lauge-Hansen N. Fractures of the ankle. III: genetic
institutional ethics committee roentgenologic diagnosis of fractures of the ankle.
Am J Roentgenol Radium Ther Nucl Med.
REFERENCES 1954;71(3):456-71.
14. Hahn DM, Colton CL. Malleolar fractures. AO
1. Court-Brown CM, Caesar B. Epidemiology of adult Principles of fracture management. New York:
fractures: a review. Injury. 2006;37(8):691-7. Thieme; 2001: 583-4.
2. Weert EMVSD, Lieshout EMMV, Vries MRD, Elst 15. Wilson FC, Phillips HO Gilbert JA. Plantar flexion
MVD, Schepers T. Determinants of outcome in injuries of the ankle. An experimental study. Clin
operatively and non-operatively treated Weber-B Orthop Relat Res. 1994;306:97-102.
ankle fractures. Arch Orthop Trauma Surg. 16. Gougoulias N, Khanna A, Sakellariou A, Maffulli N,
2012;132(2):257-63. et al. Supination-external rotation ankle fractures:
3. Michelson JD. Fractures about the ankle. J Bone Joint stability a key issue. Clin Orthop Relat Res.
Surg Am. 1995;77(1):142-52. 2010;468(1):243-51.
4. Pott P. Some Few general remarks on fractures and 17. Tejwani NC, McLaurin TM, Walsh M, Bhadsavle S,
dislocations. New Antiquarian. 1768;8(4):126. Koval KJ, Egolet KA. Are outcomes of bimalleolar
5. Dupuytren G. Fractures of the lower extremity of the fractures poorer than those of lateral malleolar
fibula, and subluxations of the foot. Med Classic. fractures with medial ligamentous injury. J Bone
1939;4:151-72. Joint Surg. 2007;89(7):1438-41.
6. Earl H. Simple succeeded by compound dislocation
of the inferior extremity of the tibia with fracture of Cite this article as: Gangadhran N, Pillai MG.
its posterior edge comminuted fracture of the fibula. Study on functional outcome of bimalleolar ankle
Lancet. 2:346-8 fractures treated by open reduction and internal
7. Maisonneuve MGT. Resurchessur la fracture du fixation. Int J Res Orthop 2021;7:518-25.
perone. Arch Gen Med. 1940;7:165-87.
International Journal of Research in Orthopaedics | May-June 2021 | Vol 7 | Issue 3 Page 525