Materials Today: Proceedings 45 (2021) 6818–6821

Contents lists available at ScienceDirect

Materials Today: Proceedings

journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/matpr

An experimental study on hybrid fiber reinforced concrete beams

subjected to torsion
Saravanakumar P ⇑, Sivakamidevi M, Meena K, Yamini S.P
Department of Civil Engineering, Sri Krishna College of Engineering and Technology, Coimbatore, India

a r t i c l e i n f o a b s t r a c t

Article history: Experimental investigations were carried out to study the mechanical performance and torsional beha-
Received 16 November 2020 viour of hybrid fiber reinforced concrete beams. Steel fibers and Glass fibers were used with varying fiber
Received in revised form 14 December 2020 content such as 0% 0.5% 1.0% and 1.5% by volume of concrete to cast the specimens for this study. The
Accepted 24 December 2020
experimental study results confirmed that the mechanical performance of the concrete was remarkably
Available online 15 February 2021
improved with the addition of hybrid fibers upto 1% by volume of concrete. The torsional strength in the
cracking state and post cracking state was improved in hybrid fiber reinforced concrete and this depends
Keywords:
on the volume of fiber content in concrete.
Steel fibers
Glass fibers
Ó 2020 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
Hybrid fiber reinforced concrete Selection and peer-review under responsibility of the scientific committee of the International Confer-
Mechanical performance of concrete ence on Mechanical, Electronics and Computer Engineering 2020: Materials Science.
Torsional strength

1. Introduction fibre used for the fibre reinforcement exclusively for retrofittings
and also helps the cracked structure to regain its original strength
Fiber reinforced concrete was extensively experimented by [7].
employing various types of fibers like steel, glass, organic polymers The structural members which are subjected to eccentrically
(synthetic fibers) and natural fibers and reported by many load are significantly affected by torsion in addition to bending,
researchers. Steel fiber reinforced concrete has wide scope of shear and axial forces. However, in some cases like beams curved
regions such as floors, marine structures, fixing and retrofitting in plan, spandrel beams and cantilever beams, the torsional beha-
solid structures etc. Silica has kept being the most important and viour was dominated than bending behaviour. In the past few dec-
generally used mineral admixture between the pozzolonic materi- ades wide-ranging of research works had been carried out on
als [1]. increasing the torsional resistance of concrete structures.
By adding fibers in the reinforced concrete, significant improve- Eventhough the failure pattern of cracks in beams subjected to
ment in strength and durability characteristics were reported by shear or torsion is same the behaviour of beams are different. Shear
researchers. The fiber addition improves the post cracking behavior crack were developed in the same way on either sides whereas the
of concrete by bridging the cracks through tension stiffening effect crack due to twist will spread in the opposite direction on opposite
[2]. faces [8,9].
The rise in fiber aspect ratio and fiber volumetric proportion in Many researchers have researched the characteristics of fiber
concrete brings about an increase in the energy absorption and strengthened beams under twist. The essential test factors were
mechanical characteristic strength of concrete. When this rise sur- fiber type, fiber proportion and the percentage of steel reinforce-
passes a specific volumetric level, the rise in the property turns out ment. At the point when fibers are added to plain concrete both
to be less [3–5]. The past study reports confirmed that the applica- torsional quality and energy engrossing limit increases [10,11].
tion of two or more fiber combination in fiber reinforced concrete The consideration of fibers in concrete improved a definitive tor-
improved the post cracking behaviour and it was influenced by sional quality and conferred significant flexibility and durability
fiber content and fiber mixture [6]. Jute is a long, delicate vegetable to the beams [12]. The ability to absorb energy and load carrying
capacity of beams were found to increment with increment in
fibervolume fraction and aspect ratio. The addition of steel fibre
⇑ Corresponding author. in addition to reinforcement in beams resulted in increase in the
E-mail address: [email protected] (P Saravanakumar). torsional capacity along with the energy absorption capacity and

https://doi.org/10.1016/j.matpr.2020.12.1003
2214-7853/Ó 2020 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
Selection and peer-review under responsibility of the scientific committee of the International Conference on Mechanical, Electronics and Computer Engineering 2020:
Materials Science.
P Saravanakumar, M Sivakamidevi, K Meena et al. Materials Today: Proceedings 45 (2021) 6818–6821

also the precracking behaviour [13,14]. For FRC it was reported

that among the available theories plastic theory predicted very clo-
sely the ultimate torque value [15].The volume of the steel fiber
part was not suggested more than 3–4%. Be that as it may, the use-
fulness of cement past a fiber volume division of 2% is exception-
ally troublesome [14].
Research indicates that the incorporation of glass fiber in con-
crete resulted in the reduction of micro cracks at the initial stage
itself. The silica fume simultaneously increases the strength and
rigidity of the structures [16]. The past research study reported
that using Hybrid fibers gave much befit than using single type
of fibers in concrete. As two types of fibers are used, one will be
good in strength and stiffness and the other will be strong in dura-
bility. Similarly one will treat the initial micro cracks and the other
will take care of the macro cracks. This is the major benefit
achieved by using variety of fibers in single concrete [17,18]. In this
paper an attempt was made to study the behavior of hybrid fiber
reinforced concrete (HFRC). Glass fibers and Steel fibers were used
to prepare the hybrid fiber reinforced concrete for this study. The Fig. 2. Torsional Test Setup.

main objective of the study was to study the improvement of

mechanical properties for various percentage addition of hybrid of 150 mm diameter and 300 mm length for split tensile strength
fibers and the failure mode of HFRC beams subjected to pure tor- and prism of 100  100  500 mm size for flexural strength were
sion was also analyzed and compared with reinforced concrete cast and tested at 7, 14 and 28 days. The reinforced concrete beam
beams. The optimum percentage addition of fibers was identified. of size 1.2 m length, 0.15 m width and 0.23 m depth were cast to
More number of cracks and lesser crack width were also reported study the torsional behaviour of HFRC. Preparation of concrete,
for HFRC beams in the experimental study. The post cracking casting of specimens, demoulding and curing was done as per stan-
behavior of HFRC beams were found better than RC beams. dard methods.

2.2. Torsion test on beams

2. Materials and experimental methods
Tests were conducted on reinforced concrete beams of size
2.1. Materials
0.15 m  0.23 m  1.2 m of M20 grade. The beam was reinforced
with main reinforcement of 3 bars of 8 mm a, 2 hanger bars of
For this experimental study OPC 53 grade cement in compliance
8 mm a and 2 legged 8 mm a stirrups at 150 mm c/c (Fig. 1). The
to the standards of IS 269-1979, fine aggregates and coarse aggre-
test setup was shown in Fig. 2. Two torsional brackets were fixed
gates in compliance to the standards of IS 383-1970 were used.
at the ends of the beams. The length of the moment arm was kept
Sulphonated napthalene polymer based super plasticizer SP 430
as 0.60 m. The steel inflexible beam was placed diagonally over the
was used to increase the workability of concrete.
moment arm. The load was applied at the middle of the steel
Corrugated circular steel fiber of size 1 mm  36 mm was used
in this study. The average pitch of steel fibers was 8 mm and rise Table 1
was 2 mm. Average ultimate tensile strength of steel fibers was Strength of the specimen for various percentage additions of fibers.

600 MPa and the modulus of elasticity was 2.1  105 MPa. AR- Designation of Compressive Split Tensile Flexural
Glass fibers having diameter 15.3 lm, relative density of 2.7 g/ specimen Strength Strength Strength
m3, the Ultimate tensile strength is 2900 MPa, the elastic modulus N/mm2 N/mm2 N/mm2

is 73.4 MPa. The properties of fibers were provided by the HFRC0.0 21.5 2.4 3.7
manufacturer. HFRC0.5 23.3 2.8 4.2
HFRC1.0 26.4 3 4.6
Equal amount of steel and AR-Glass fibers were added in con-
HFRC1.5 24.3 2.9 4.4
crete to prepare the specimen. To find the mechanical behaviour
of HFRC, cubes of 100 mm size for compressive strength, cylinder

Fig. 1. Cross Section of the Beam and Reinforcement details. Fig. 3. Percentage increase of strength of HFRC for various fiber content additions.

6819
P Saravanakumar, M Sivakamidevi, K Meena et al. Materials Today: Proceedings 45 (2021) 6818–6821

Table 2
Torsional strength of the beams.

Designation of specimen Crack initiation Maximum

Torque in kNm % Increase in Torque Torque in kNm % Increase in Torque
HFRC0.0 4.1 – 4.7 –
HFRC0.5 4.5 9.75 5.2 10.64
HFRC1.0 5.2 26.83 6.1 29.78
HFRC1.5 5.45 32.93 6.4 36.17

inflexible beam which becomes disbursed equally at the ends of average 28th day strength of concrete specimen for various per-
the beam. The torsional moment were applied at the ends of the centage additions of fibers was summarized in Table 1.
beam through the torsion bracket. The torque value was computed There was a significant increase in compressive strength of the
by multiplying the applied force on the each side with the moment specimen found upto 1% fiber addition and after that the concrete
arm distance. showed down trend. The mix ratio for 20 MPa was designed and
21.5 MPa was attained after 28 days curing for control specimen.
The 1% HFRC showed the maximum compressive strength increase
3. Results and discussion of 26 MPa. Similarly same observations were made in split tensile
strength and flexural strength also. Fig. 3 showed the percentage
3.1. Mechanical strength increase in strength of concrete for various hybrid fiber percentage
addition (0%, 1% and 1.5%).From the Fig. 3 it was observed that a
The mix ratio adopted to cast the test specimen in this investi- maximum of 23%, 25% and 19% increment was found for compres-
gation is 1:1:41:3.09 with on objective strength of M20 grade of sive, tensile and flexural strength respectively for 1% fiber addition.
concrete. The compressive strength, split tensile strength and flex- For the fiber addition beyond 1%, i.e, 1.5% HFRC the down trend
ural strength of the specimens tested were listed in the Table 1.The was observed in the mechanical strength of the concrete. Irrespec-

Fig. 4. Crack pattern of HFRC beams.

6820
P Saravanakumar, M Sivakamidevi, K Meena et al. Materials Today: Proceedings 45 (2021) 6818–6821

tive of age of concrete the same trend of strength variation was 2. Steel and glass fiber addition of 0.5% each to form 1% HFRC
noticed in 7, 14 and 28 days concrete matrixes. improved around 20% mechanical strength than conventional
The failure pattern of concrete during compression was also concrete.
observed. After the first crack formation the failure took places 3. The HFRC beams showed continuous improvement in torsional
lowly in the fiber added specimen when compare to the control behaviour for the fiber additions. Maximum increase was found
specimen. This showed the improvement in post cracking beha- as 33% in 1.5% HFRC beam.
viour of fiber added specimens. The energy absorption capacity 4. The failure was attained slowly in HFRC beam and after the first
was improved in steel fiber reinforced concrete. The same kind of crack the specimen continues to sustain the load for a long per-
strength improvement and failure behaviour was also noticed in iod than RC beam.
split tensile strength. In flexural strength test the control speci- 5. The hybrid fiber reinforced concrete showed a better post
mens failed immediately when the first crack was observed but cracking behaviour than RCC beam.
in fiber added beams after the first crack the specimen continue
to sustain the load and the failure was slowly took place. From
the results of the experimental study it was concluded that upto Declaration of Competing Interest
1% of steel fiber addition in concrete showed remarkable improve-
ment in the mechanical characteristics of concrete. The authors declare that they have no known competing finan-
cial interests or personal relationships that could have appeared
3.2. Torsional strength to influence the work reported in this paper.

The failure of the beam was noticed through cracks on the sur- References
face of the beams. The cracks were started near the supports and it
originates at the bottom and extends to the top of the beam at an [1] P. Subathra, D.S. Vijayan, R. Abirami, M. Kharsati, G. Soshang, D.K. Das,
Experimental investigation on concrete with marble dust and steel fiber, AIP
angle of 45° approximately. The torsional strength of HFRC beams Conf. Proc. 2271 (2020) 030016.
was found to be increased for the increase in fiber addition and the [2] T.D. GopalCharanBeheraa, C.B.K.R. GunneswaraRao, Torsional behaviour of
maximum increase was found as 33%than control specimen for reinforced concrete beams with ferrocement U-jacketing-Experimental study.
Case Studies, Constr. Mater. 4 (2016) 15–31.
HFRC1.5 beam. The Table 2 showed the torque values and the per- [3] P.S. Song, S. Hwang, Mechanical properties of high-strength steel fiber
centage increase in torque for various percentages of hybrid fiber reinforced concrete, Constr. Build. Mater. 18 (9) (2004) 669–673.
additions of beams for first crack load and at ultimate load. The [4] Y. Mohammadi, S.P. Singh, S.K. Kaushik, Properties of steel fibrous concrete
containing mixed fibres in fresh and hardened state, Constr. Build. Mater. 22
ultimate torque capacity increases with the increase in fiber con- (2008) 956–965.
tent after first cracking of beam specimen. The maximum torque [5] F.W. Faisal, A.A. Samir, Mechanical properties of high-strength fiber reinforced
increment of 5% than control beam was noticed in 1.5% HFRC. concrete, ACI Mater. J. 89 (5) (1992) 449–455.
[6] Zuzana Marcalikova, Radim Cajka, Vlastimil Bilek, David Bujdos, Oldrich
But the behaviour after the first crack was significantly improved
Sucharda. Determination of mechanical characteristics for fiber-reinforced
in HFRC beams. The failure was attained slowly even though there concrete with straight and hooked fibers. Crystals 2020;10: 545; doi:10.3390/
was not a remarkable increase in torque value in lower percentage cryst10060545.
[7] V. Gokulnath, D.S. Vijayan, P. Kathirvel et al., Behaviour of retro fitted beams
of fiber additions.
using natural fibers, Mater. Today: Proc.
[8] Fuad Okay, Serkan Engin. Torsion behavior of steel fiber reinforced concrete
3.3. Crack study beams. Constr. Build. Mater. 2012;28(1):269-75.
[9] K.N. Rahal, Torsional strength of reinforced concrete beams, Can. J. Civ. Eng. 27
(2000) 445–453.
The post cracking behaviour of beam specimens were examined [10] A.A. Hameed, M.H. Al-Sherrawi, Torsional strength of steel fibre reinforced
through the crack study. The failure pattern of various percentage concrete beams, Int. J. Civil Eng. Technol. (IJCIET) 9 (6) (2018) 1388–1396.
of HFRC added beams were shown in Fig. 4(a)–(d). The ultimate/- [11] S.B. Kandekar, R.S. Talikoti, Study of torsional behavior of reinforced concrete
beams strengthened with aramid fber strips, Int. J. Adv. Struct. Eng. 10 (2018)
failure torque was attained in a short duration for the beams hav- 465–474.
ing no fiber content. The numbers of cracks were minimum and [12] S. Khan, Performance of steel fibre reinforced concrete specimens under the
very wide in control beam. The numbers of cracks were increased combined state of flexure, torsion and shear, varying its geometry, Int. J. Civil
Eng. Technol. (IJCIET) 8 (6) (2017) 1034–1043.
and also the width of the cracks was reduced in HFRC beams. It was [13] K.S. Sable, A.J. Mehetre, S.B. Kandekar. Performance of concrete beams under
observed that the fibers play a bridging role between the cracks shear and torsion with fly ash and steel fibers. Cement Concr. Compos.
and hence the hybrid fiber reinforced concrete showed a better 2011;41:6005-08.
[14] S. Pant Avinash, R. Suresh Parekar, Steel fiber reinforced concrete beams under
post cracking behaviour than RCC beam.
combined torsion-bending-shear, J. Civil Eng. (IEB) 38 (1) (2010) 31–38.
[15] M.A. Mansur, P. Paramasivam, Steel fibre reinforced concrete beams in pure
4. Conclusion torsion, Int. J. Cement Compos. Lightweight Concr. 4 (1) (1982) 30–45.
[16] R. Sanjay Kumar, D.S. Vijayan, P.A. Mubarak Manzoor, N. Subinjith, Stagain
Santhosh, Effect of silica fume on strength of glass fiber incorporated concrete,
The following are the conclusions derived from the experimen- AIP Conf. Proc. 2271 (2020) 030020.
tal investigation carried out on HFRC specimens. [17] V.S. Vairagade, K.S. Kene, Experimental investigation on hybrid fibre reinforced
concrete, Int. J. Eng. Res. Appl. 2 (3) (2012) 1037–1041.
[18] W. Yao, L. Jie, W. Keru, Mechanical properties of hybrid fiber-reinforced
1. The mechanical characteristics of concrete were improved with concrete at low fiber volume fraction, Cem. Concr. Res. 33 (3) (2003) 27–30.
fiber addition in concrete and ultimate strength improvement
was found in 1% addition in HFRC.

6821