Lab Report Organic Chemistry (Experiment 5) Lim Wey Loon
Lab Report Organic Chemistry (Experiment 5) Lim Wey Loon
Lab Report Organic Chemistry (Experiment 5) Lim Wey Loon
PRACTICAL GROUP: P1
Objectives:
Introduction:
Figure 1: From left to right are primary, secondary and tertiary alcohols respectively
Alcohols are consumed as beverages, antiseptic agent, fuels and preservatives for
specimens in the laboratories. Besides, alcohols are used as an anti-freezing agent with a
mixture of a solution containing ethylene glycol dissolved in water. (Byju’s, 2023)
Chemicals/ Reagents:
Ethanol, Isopropyl alcohol, t-Butyl alcohol, unknown A, unknown B, Lucas reagent, chromic
acid solution and sodium metal.
Glasswares:
Test tubes.
Experimental Procedure:
1. In three separate dry test tubes, about 1 mL of each of the following: ethanol,
isopropyl alcohol and t-butyl alcohol was placed.
2. About 2 mL of water was added to each tube, the solutions were mixed and observed.
The results were recorded on the notebook.
3. The above procedures were repeated with the two unknown liquids and observations
were made.
4. The above steps were repeated using butanol and observations were made.
1. To 1 mL portions of ethanol, isopropyl alcohol and t-butyl alcohol in separate dry test
tubes, 6 mL of Lucas reagent was added at room temperature.
2. The tubes were closed with a cork and were shaken and the length of time it took for
the mixture to become cloudy or separate two layers was noted. The results were
recorded.
3. The above procedures were repeated with the two unknown liquids and observations
were made.
1. To 2 mL portions of ethanol, isopropyl alcohol and t-butyl alcohol in separate dry test
tubes, 1 mL of chromic acid solution was added.
2. Any changes in colour were observed.
3. The above procedures were repeated with the two unknown liquids and observations
were made.
(D) Reaction with metallic sodium
1. To 2 mL portions of ethanol, isopropyl alcohol and t-butyl alcohol in separate dry test
tubes, a small piece of sodium metal was added and any reaction that occurred was
noted.
2. The gas formed from the reaction was determined.
3. The rate of gas evolution relative to each alcohol was compared.
4. The alcohols were arranged in order of increasing acidity based on results and the
reasons were explained.
5. The above procedures were repeated with the two unknown liquids and observations
were made.
Results:
Figure 3: From left to right are the reaction of ethanol, isopropyl alcohol, t-butyl alcohol,
unknown A and unknown B with chromic acid solution
(D) Reaction with metallic sodium
Figure 4: From left to right are the reaction of ethanol, isopropyl alcohol, t-butyl alcohol,
unknown A and unknown B with metallic sodium
Discussion:
Each alcohol consists of a carbon chain (always nonpolar) and a OH group (which is
polar). Water is polar and it attracts OH group by forming hydrogen bonds. Carbon chain on
the other hand as nonpolar is repelled. Solubility of alcohols is therefore determined by the
strength of the two forces. Due to the strength of the hydroxyl group, first three alcohols
(methanol, ethanol and propanol) are completely miscible. They dissolve in water in any
amount. Starting with the four-carbon butanol the solubility of alcohols is starting to
decrease. This is because the hydrophobic chain gets longer. (Solubility of Things, 2023)
However, for isopropyl and t-Butyl alcohol (in Figure 1), the carbon chain is relatively short
compared to n-butanol. Hence, the strength of the repelling hydrophobic hydrocarbon chain is
weaker, thus leading to high solubility of isopropyl alcohol and t-Butyl alcohol in water.
Lucas test is based on the difference in reactivity of alcohols with hydrogen halide.
Primary secondary and tertiary alcohols react with hydrogen halide (hydrochloric acid) at
different rates. It follows the SN1 reaction mechanism. The solution of concentrated
hydrochloric acid with zinc chloride is called Lucas reagent. Lucas reagent forms carbocation
as intermediate with all three alcohols. But the stability of carbocation intermediate differs in
all three reactions. Tertiary alcohol gives instant results with Lucas reagent as its carbocation
is highly stable. While secondary alcohol gives results with Lucas reagent after a long time as
its carbocation intermediate is moderately stable and primary alcohol gives negative result
with Lucas reagent at room temperature because its carbocation is highly unstable.
(Vedantu, 2023)
1. Ethanol:
3C2H5OH + 4H2CrO4 + 12H+ 3CH3COOH + 4Cr3+ + 13H2O
2. Isopropyl alcohol:
3(CH3)2CHOH + 2H2CrO4 +6H+ 3(CH3)2C=O + 2Cr3+ + 8H2O
Chromic acid, H2CrO4, is a strong acid and a reagent for oxidizing alcohols to
ketones and carboxylic acids. Primary alcohols can be oxidized to either aldehydes or
carboxylic acids, depending on the reaction conditions. In the case of the formation of
carboxylic acids, the alcohol is first oxidized to an aldehyde, which is then oxidized further to
the acid. Secondary alcohols are oxidized to ketones. Tertiary alcohols cannot be oxidised by
chromic acid without breaking the C-C bonds. The reason is there is no reactive C-H bond at
the carbon atom where the hydroxyl group attaches to.
The mechanism of oxidation of ethanol by chromic acid:
ROH ⇌ RO- + H+
The acidity of alcohols decreases while going from primary to secondary to tertiary.
This decrease in acidity is due to steric hindrance, the alkyl groups inhibit solvation of the
resulting alkoxide ion. In more alkyl substituted alcohols, the electron density at oxygen atom
increases and increase the activation energy for proton removal. (Cliffsnotes, n.d.)
Since unknown A reacts slowly with Lucas reagent, give positive result to oxidation
by chromic acid and reacts moderately with metallic sodium, A is a secondary alcohol. While
B reacts immediately with Lucas reagent, is not oxidised by chromic acid and reacts slowly
with metallic sodium, thus B is a tertiary alcohol.
Precaution Steps:
In terms of solubility, ethanol, isopropyl alcohol and t-butyl alcohol are soluble in
water. This is due to the ability of alcohols to form hydrogen bonds with water. Unknown A
and unknown B are also water-soluble.
In the Lucas test, primary alcohol gives negative results, secondary alcohol reacts
slowly with Lucas reagent while tertiary alcohol reacts immediately with Lucas reagent.
In the chromic acid test, primary alcohol and secondary alcohols give positive result
to the oxidation by chromic acid while tertiary alcohol cannot be oxidised by chromic acid.
In the reaction with metallic sodium, primary alcohol reacts vigorously with bubbles
released readily. Secondary alcohol reacts moderately with bubbles released slowly. Tertiary
alcohol reacts slowly with bubbles released in a small amount.
Since unknown A reacts slowly with Lucas reagent, give positive result to oxidation
by chromic acid and reacts moderately with metallic sodium, A is a secondary alcohol. While
B reacts immediately with Lucas reagent, is not oxidised by chromic acid and reacts slowly
with metallic sodium, thus B is a tertiary alcohol.
References: