Philipp J. Vet. Anim Sci, 2000 41-50: (Trichoderma Harzianum, Aspergillus Niger, Rhizopus Ojigosporus)
Philipp J. Vet. Anim Sci, 2000 41-50: (Trichoderma Harzianum, Aspergillus Niger, Rhizopus Ojigosporus)
Philipp J. Vet. Anim Sci, 2000 41-50: (Trichoderma Harzianum, Aspergillus Niger, Rhizopus Ojigosporus)
ABSTRACT
The study was conducted to develop a feed product from sweet potato
pulp through the adoption of protein enrichment technology modified to suit farm
level conditions. Specifically, the most appropriate degree of wetness ofthe pulp,
fungal culture used in fermentation, non-protein nitrogen source/s for the nutrient
mixture and technique of sterilizing the fermentation substrate to produce a
protein-rich broiler feed from sweet potato pulp were investigated.
Sweet potato pulp (fiber), a solid waste from starch processing, was
gathered from two commercial plants in the towns of Calasiao and Rosales, in
Pangasinan. Protein-enriched sweet potato pulp was produced using three non-
protein nitrogen sources (urea, ammonium phosphate, ammonium sulfate) in the
preparation of nutrient mixture for the substrate; three fungal cultures
(Trichoderma harzianum, Aspergillus niger, Rhizopus oJigosporus) for substrate
fermentation; two degrees of wetness (low-moisture vs. high-moisture) of the
pulp; and two substrate sterilization techniques (aseptic vs. semi-aseptic). The
protein-rich feed products resulting from various treatments were sampled for
determination of proximate composition and test-fed to broilers through feeding
trials.
There were 17 to 20-fold increases in the crude protein content of sweet
potato pulp after protein enrichment, compared to the original material. High-
moisture sweet potato pulp contained higher percentage of crude protein than
low-moisture pulp. T. harzianum-fermented sweet potato pulp contained 7-9%
more crude protein than protein-enriched sweet potato pulp fermented by R.
oJigosporus or A. niger.
Feeding trial results showed 0.7-3.8% improvement in gain in weight and
6.4-15.8% improvement in feed conversion when protein-enriched sweet potato
pulp was incorporated in the finisher ration. Cost efficiency analysis revealed
that savings on feed cost range from PhP2.54-3.81 per bird (finishing stage)
and PhPO.49-3.06 per bird (growing-finishing stage).
INTRODUCTION
The present trends in animal production call for the use of high nutrient density
rations in order to sustain the requirements of genetically improved strains of farm
animals. Therefore, research efforts must be focused on developing feed materials
that could ensure optimum growth and production , cost efficiency as well as sustainability.
Experimental Variables
Several experiments were conducted to test different variables. The effect of
some factors or conditions on the feeding value of the fermented sweet potato pulp
were evaluated. These are as follows:
Effect of Degree of Pulp Wetness. High-moisture (fresh) and low-moisture (33
% water) pulps were compared .
Effect of Substrate Sterilization Technique. The aseptic and semi-aseptic ways
of sterilizing the substrates were compared. The aseptic method was done by pressure
sterilization at 20 psi for 30 min. The semi-aseptic technique was performed by steaming
the substrates in covered drums for at least 3 hrs.
Effect of Fungal Species. Three species of fungi were used as inoculants and
their efficiency were compared. These were Trichoderma harzianum, Aspergillus niger,
and Rhizopus oligosporus.
Effect of Non-Protein Nitrogen Source. Three non-protein nitrogen sources were
used separately as part of the nutrient solution and compared. These were urea,
ammonium sulfate and ammonium phosphate.
44 Demo-os et a/.
Feeding Trials
Four feeding trials were conducted . Experimental treatments in each feeding
trial were replicated three times following the Completely Randomized Design with 10
broiler chicks per replication. Standard management practices were employed uniformly
to all experimental birds. PESPP was used as partial replacement for commercial broiler
rations. Growth, feed intake, feed efficiency and feed costs were evaluated . These
data were analyzed using analysis of variance and treatment means were compared
using Duncan's Multiple Range Test.
Nutrient Composition
Fresh sweet potato pulp, a solid waste resulting from the production of starch
from sweet potato is almost devoid of nutritive value as it contained 87.59% water with
no detectable quantity of protein (Table 1). Drying this solid waste to 90% dry matter
still resulted in very low crude protein (CP) value of only 1.79%. However, the nitrogen-
free extract (NFE), which represents the soluble sugars and starches, was high at
72.14%.
In general, fermentation of sweet potato pulp increased the CP content of the
product by 4-17 times. This was brought about by the conversion of carbohydrate
materials present in the pulp into amino acids by microbial synthesis in the presence of
sufficient amounts of nitrogen and minerals, particularly sulfur and phosphorus. After
fermentation, PESPP is a combination of microbial biomass and residual substrate
materials. The latter contained soluble soluble sugars which had not undergone
fermentation, hence, the NFE of the product was still relatively high. Likewise, fungal
fermentation caused increases in ether extract (EE), ash and gross energy (GE) values.
Table 1. Nutrient composition of wet and dry sweet potato pulp before and after protein
enrichment.
Type % % % % % % % % Kcal
DM CP EE CF NFE Ash Ca P GE
Fresh 12.41 NO 0.25 2.82 8.87 0.47
Dry 90.06 1.79 0.25 13.26 72.14 2.62 0.64 0.03 3323
PELM 89.96 6.27 0.61 13.29 64.63 5.16 0.59 0.15 3396
PEHM 87.73 30.20 1.20 10.69 38.47 7.17 0.24 0.16 3627
*PELM: protein-enriched low moisture; PEHM: protein-enriched high moisture; nd: not
detected
Feeding value of sweet-potato pulp 45
Schulz and Oslage (1977) also reported increases in crude fat and total fat after bacterial
fermentation of starchy materials and increases in phosphorus, magnesium, iron and
zinc contents after fermentation by yeast.
Effect of Degree of Pulp Wetness. Results of the experiment on the use of two
degrees of pulp wetness showed that protein enrichment by fermentation was more
effective when high-moisture (65% moisture content) pulp was used as substrate than
when low-moisture (33% moisture content) pulp was used. The average CP content of
PESPP from high-moisture substrate was 30.20% compared to the 6.27% average CP
content of PESPP from low-moisture pulp (Table 1). The higher amount of moisture in
the substrate during fermentation provided ideal conditions for fungal growth and
multiplication. Hence, the fermentation process was efficient, producing more fungal
biomass that contributed to the higher CP content of the fermented feed. Similar results
were obtained by Pham et al. (1992a and 1992b) using cassava as substrate. A
maximum protein content of 31 % was obtained when cassava substrate contained
60% initial moisture, and as the initial moisture was decreased to 50%, 40% and 30%,
the protein content of the fermented products was proportionately reduced to 26%,
15% and 7 .7% protein, respectively.
In terms of the other feed components, higher percentages of ash, EE and GE
were obtained from fermentation of high-moisture substrate compared to low-moisture
substrate. However, crude fiber (CF), NFE and calcium contents were reduced as a
result of microbial activity converting NFE and cellulosic materials to protein while Ca
was utilized by the microorganisms for their own metabolism.
The marked increase in the CP content of PESPP was brought about by the
bio-conversion of carbohydrate materials present in the pulp into amino acids by
microbial synthesis in the presence of sufficient amounts of nitrogen and minerals
particularly sulfur and phosphorus. In order to obtain rapid microbial growth in the media
and obtain maximum yield of product, Corbett (1980) stressed that substrates must
contain adequate supplies of nitrogen which the organism cannot manufacture itself.
Since as much as 15% of the mycelial dry weight may be composed of nitrogen, he
recommended that the medium must contain up to this amount of a suitable source of
nitrogen.
PESPP, being a fermentation product, is a combination of microbial biomass
and residual substrate materials. These residual substrate materials provide available
soluble sugars which had not undergone fermentation, hence, the nitrogen-free extract
content of PESPP, in general, was still high although much of it had been utilized
during microbial synthesis of proteins. Furthermore, the phosphorus content was also
increased after fermentation . This was brought about by the addition of phosphate in
the nutrient mixture. The CF content, on the other hand, decreased after fermentation
due to the fact that microbial action promoted the conversion of fiber compounds into
protein.
Table 5. Performance of broilers (10-38 days) fed ration with 10% PESPP produced
with different non-protein nitrogen sources.
Production Efficiency 0% 10% PESPP 10% PESPP 10% PESPP
Parameters PESPP with Urea with NH 3P04 with NH 3S04
Feed intake, g 2568.81a 2575.08 a 2564.95 a 2733.89 a
Gain in weight, g 1246.67 a 1244.00 a 1257.33 a 1282.11a
FCR , kg feedlkg gain 2.06 a 2.07 a 2.04 a 2.13 a
Feed cost/kg broiler
produced, PhP 26.99 25.29 24.96 26.07
Savings on feedslkg
broiler, PhP 1.70 2.02 0.92
Note: Values with different superscripts in the same row are different (P<0.05).
48 Demo-os et al.
Table 6. Performance of broilers (10-38 days) fed ration with 10% PESPP fermented
by different species of fungi.
Production Efficiency 0% 10% PESPP by 10% PESPP 10% PESPPby
Parameters PESPP T. harzianum by A. niger R. oligosporus
Feed intake, g 2545.67 a 2712.33 a 2668.00 a 2679.00 a
Gain in weight, g 1174.67a 1337.67 a 1208.33 a 1198.6r
FeR, kg feed/kg gain 2.17 a 2.06 a 2.22a 2.23 a
Feed cost/kg broiler
produced, PhP 27.82 25 .21 27.13 27.33
Savings on feeds/kg
broiler, PhP 2.61 0.69 0.49
Note: Values with different superscripts in the same row are different (P<0.05).
Effect of Two Levels of PESPP on Finishing Broilers. The feeding trial conducted
on finishing broilers showed no significant differences among birds in terms of
performance parameters, except on feed intake. Table 7 shows that with 10% and 15%
PESPP substitution of commercial broiler finisher ration, 2.2% and 11.2% reduction in
feed intake was noted, respectively. On the other hand, gain in weight was improved by
0.7% when 10% PESPP was used, but this further improved by 3.8% when the level of
substitution was increased to 15%. Efficiency of feed utilization was similar among
birds in the control and in the treated lots, however, improvement in feed conversion
Table 7. Performance of broilers during the finishing stage fed ration with 10 and 15%
PESPP.
Performance 0% 10% Percentage 15% Percentage
Parameters PESPP PESPP Improvement PESPP Improvement
{Reduction} {Reduction}
a
Feed intake, kg 1.34 1.31 a (2.20) 1.19b (11.20)
Gain in weight, g 793.75 a 798.96 a 0.70 823.96 a 3.80
FeR, kg feed/kg
gain 1.71 a 1.60 a 6.40 1.44a 15.79
Note: Values with different superscripts in the same row are different (P<0.05).
Feeding value of sweet-potato pulp 49
ratio (FeR) was from 6.4-15.79% with 10% and 15% allowance of PESPP in the diet,
respectively. Improvement in performance was brought about by the improvement in
the nutritive value of the finisher diet when portions of it were substituted with PESPP.
Table 8. Performance of broilers (10-38 days) fed ration with 0,10 and 15% PESPP.
REFERENCES
Baldensperge J, Le Mer J, Hannibal L and Quinto P. 1985. Solid state fermentation of banana
wastes. Biotech Letters 7: 743-748.
Corbett K. 1980. Preparation, Sterilization and design of media. In: Fungal Biotechnology. London:
Academic Press.
Gaden EL, Mandels M, Keese ET and Spano LA. 1976. Enzymatic Conversion of Cellulosic
Materials: Technology and Applications. New York: John Wiley & Sons.
National Academy of Sciences. 1979. Microbial Processes: Promising Technologies for Developing
Countries. Washington, D.C.: NAS.
Pham CB, Sedano SA, Ramirez T J and Velasco AVB. 1991. Selection of fungi for protein
enrichment of carbohydrate agricultural wastes. Proceedings of the Asia-Pacific
Biotechnology Congress, SEARCA, UPLB , May 26-28.
Pham CB, Lat MRLY, Ramirez T J, Quinlat MJ and Pham LJ. 1992. Enriching cassava protein
using solid state fermentation. BIOTECH, UPLB.
Pham CB, Pham LJ and Ramirez T J. 1992. Simultaneous bioconversion of carbohydrate and
biodegradation of cyanide in cassava meat to increase nutritive value. Proceedings of
International Conference on Food PreseNation and Security.
Pham CB, Ramirez T J,Velasco AVB, Pham LJ, Quinlat MJ, Sedano SA and Oliveros BA. 1993.
Evaluation of protein-enriched agricultural carbohydrates for animal feeds. Proceedings
of the 22nd Annual Convention of the Philippine Society for Microbiology, University of
San Agustin, Iloilo City, April 14-16.
Raimbult M, Descharmps F, Mayer F and Senez JC. 1977. 5th International Conference on
Global Impact of Applied Microbiology. Bangkok, Thailand, November 21-26.
Schulz E and Oslage HJ.1977. Microorganisms as protein feed in animal nutrition. Anim. Res.
Dev. 6: 7-35.