MIS Ch01
MIS Ch01
MIS Ch01
Business Today
LEARNING OBJECTIVES
After reading this chapter, you will be able
Smart Stores Reinvent the Retail Space
to answer the following questions:
Will the Coronavirus Pandemic Make
1-1 How are information systems Working from Home the New Normal?
transforming business, and why are Digital Transformation of Healthcare at
they so essential for running and Singapore's Jurong Health Services
managing a business today?
Changes in the Financial Industry: Adyen and
1-2 What is an information system? How does it Fintech
work? What are its management,
organization, and technology components?
Why are VIDEO CASES
complementary assets essential Business in the Cloud: Facebook, Google,
for ensuring that information and eBay Data Centers
systems provide genuine value for UPS Global Operations with the DIAD and
organizations? Worldport
1-3 What academic disciplines are used Instructional Video:
to study information systems, and Tour IBM's Raleigh Data Center
how does each contribute to an
understanding of information systems?
1-4 How will MIS help my career?
Mylab MIS
Discussion Questions: 1-4, 1-5, 1-6; Hands-On MIS Projects: 1-7, 1-8, 1-9, 1-10;
eText with Conceptual Animations
34
Smart Stores Reinvent the Retail Space
A
lthough there has been an upsurge in online shopping, retail stores are
not going away. Some traditional retailers are fighting back by using
in formation technology to provide new ways to bring people into
physical
stores or enhance their in-store experiences, even with new requirements for
social distancing.
Acrelec, a French digital signage company, is piloting technology to help
retailers manage store curbside pickups by customers placing orders online.
Customers can use a retailer's smartphone app to indicate they are coming to
pick up an order, and the Acrelec system will estimate when a customer will
arrive at a particular store. Object-recognition cameras identify exactly when a
customer's car arrives and where it is parked. Acrelec
is especially useful for big-box retailers, grocery
stores, and home-improvement stores.
Shelves have become more than just a surface
for storing and displaying objects. New systems for
"smart" shelves use proximity sensors, 3D cameras,
microphones, RFID readers, and weight sensors to
enable interactions between shoppers in physical
stores and the shelves they're standing in front of.
These systems can create a highly personalized
shop ping experience that fundamentally improves
the way shoppers move inside physical stores.
Brands and retailers such as Pepsi, Walmart, and
Albertsons are starting to use Smart Shelf by AWM
to replicate the benefits of the online experience in IC> Eric Eric/123RF
physical retail environments. Using super-wide-an
gle low-light HD cameras, retailers deploying Smart Shelf are able to view
and track their products in real-time. The solution improves operational
efficiencies by highlighting specific shelves that need product stocking and
allows for real time on-shelf marketing to consumers. When retailers connect
Smart Shelf to their mobile apps, they can help shoppers locate products
themselves through their smartphones and tablets.
AWM Frictionless is a walk-in, walk-out solution enabling customers to shop
as normal and check out by simply exiting the store. The system uses digital
shelving and object-recognition cameras to keep track of which customers leave
with which items. When customers enter a store, they are required to have
mobile device and facial recognition scans, which allow the system to charge
their digital accounts when they leave with purchases and receive a receipt via
email or text message.
35
3 Part One Organizations, Management, and the Networked
In March 2020 AWM opened a low-contact cashierless micromarket called QuickEats at a luxury
AWM Smart Shelf is able to personalize shoppers’ experiences when they are in stores based on th
AWM also offers an anonymous consumer behavior tracking application that can direct custome
Sources: accessed April 29, 2020; AWM SmartShelf Launches Southern California’s First Autonomous Microma
Business
Challenges
• Revise jobfunctions
• Revise business
processes
LJIII---
I ,
Organization
Information
System
• Increase sales
• View and track products • Improve service
in real time • Improve operations
• Smartphones
• Object-recognition • Personalize shopper
Technology
technology experiences
• HDcameras
• Sensors
55
50 IT Equipment, Software, & R&D 46.8%
45
40
35
30
25
20
15
10
5
in jeopardy. Facebook and other social networking sites such as YouTube, Twit-
ter, and Tumblr, along with Netflix, Apple Music, and many other media firms,
exemplify the new face of e-commerce in the twenty-first century. They sell
services. When we think of e-commerce, we tend to think of selling physical
prod- ucts. While this iconic vision of e-commerce is still very powerful and the
fastest- growing form of retail worldwide, growing up alongside is a whole new
value stream based on selling services, not goods. It’s a services model of e-
commerce. Growth in social commerce is spurred by powerful growth of the
mobile platform: 98 percent of Facebook’s users access the service from mobile
phones and tablets. Information systems and technologies are the foundation of
this new services- based e-commerce. Mobile retail e-commerce worldwide
approached $2.55 billion in 2020 (and is growing at almost 20 percent a year)
(eMarketer, 2020).
Management Changes The management of business firms has changed: With
new mobile smartphones, high-speed wireless Wi-Fi networks, and tablets, re-
mote salespeople on the road are only seconds away from their managers’ ques-
tions and oversight. Management is going mobile. Managers on the move are
in direct, continuous contact with their employees. The growth of enterprise-
wide information systems with extraordinarily rich data means that managers
no longer operate in a fog of confusion but instead have online, nearly instant
access to the really important information they need for accurate and timely
decisions. In addition to their public uses on the web, social networking tools,
wikis, and blogs are becoming important corporate tools for communication,
collaboration, and information sharing.
Changes in Firms and Organizations Compared to industrial organizations of
the previous century, new fast-growing twenty-first-century business firms put
less emphasis on hierarchy and structure and more emphasis on employees
taking on multiple roles and tasks and collaborating with others on a team. They
put greater emphasis on competency and skills rather than position in the
hierarchy. They em- phasize higher-speed and more-accurate decision making
based on data and analy- sis. They are more aware of changes in technology,
consumer attitudes, and culture. They use social media to enter into conversations
with consumers and demonstrate a greater willingness to listen to consumers, in
part because they have no choice.
They show better understanding of the importance of information technology in
creating and managing business firms and other organizations. To the extent organi-
zations and business firms demonstrate these characteristics, they are twenty-first-
century digital firms.
You can see some of these trends at work in the Interactive Session on
Organizations, which examines the impact on work and management as many
companies had their employees work remotely during the coronavirus pan-
demic of 2020.
Will the Coronavirus Pandemic Make Working from Home the New Normal?
As COVID-19 continued to spread around the globe,
companies large and small started to make changes laptop computers, tablets, smartphones, email, mes
saging, and videoconferencing tools. As companies
to the way they work, shuttering their offices and
shift their work from face-to-face to remote, video con
requiring most or all of their employees to work
ferencing is becoming the new normal for meetings.
remotely from their homes.
People are trying to have good conversations, share
• During the pandemic, ClearRisk, which offers critical information, generate new ideas, reach con
integrated, cloud-based software solutions for sensus, and make decisions quickly on this platform.
claims, fleet, incident, and insurance
Although less than ideal for face-to-face interac
certificate management had its entire staff
tions, videoconferencing is becoming more
working from home.
powerful and affordable. There are many options,
• Many large law firms, including Reed Smith,
includ-
Baker McKenzie, and Nixon Peabody, closed
offices and required work at home during the ing Skype, Skype for Business, Zoom, Microsoft
pandemic. The law firms emphasized that they Teams, Amazon Chime, BlueJeans, Cisco's WebEx,
could continue to serve clients despite office GoToMeeting, and Google Meet. Some business
closings and remote work. peo ple are using the same tools they do in their
• OpenText Corp., a Canadian provider of personal communications, such as FaceTime and
enter prise information management products, Facebook Messenger. (FaceTime now supports
plans to eliminate more than half of its 120 group video chat with up to 32 people.)
offices globally, with 2000 of its 15,000- Video conference software such as WebEx and
person work force working from home BlueJeans appears designed for more corporate
permanently. uses. Other software such as Microsoft's Skype and
• In mid-May 2020, 'Twitter Inc. notified employ Zoom feels more consumer-friendly and easier to
ees that most of them could work from home set up, with free or low-cost versions suitable for
indefinitely. smaller businesses. Skype works for video chats,
According to a recent MITreport, 34 percent of calls, and instant messaging and can handle up to 50
Americans who previously commuted to work people in a single video call. Skype allows calls to
stated that they were working from home by the first be recorded in case someone misses a meeting.
week of April 2020 due to the coronavirus outbreak. Skype also pro vides file-sharing capabilities, caller
Prior to the pandemic, the number of people ID, voicemail, a split view mode to keep
regularly working from home remained in the single conversations separate, and screen share on mobile
digits, with only about 4 percent of the US devices.
workforce work ing from home at least half the Up to 1,000 users can participate in a single
time. However, the trend of working from home had Zoom video call, and 49 videos can appear on the
been slowly gaining momentum thanks to advances screen at once. Zoom includes collaboration tools
in information tech nology for remote work and like simul taneous screen-sharing and co-
changes in corporate work culture. The coronavirus annotation, and the ability to record meetings and
pandemic may mark a tipping point. generate transcripts. Users can adjust meeting times,
It's likely that many people who started working select multiple hosts, and communicate via chat if
from home for the first time during the pandemic microphones and cameras are turned off.
will continue to do so thereafter. New health guide There are definite benefits to remote work: lower
lines about distancing will require some workplaces overhead, more flexible schedules, reductions in
to expand to accommodate all their employees or to employee commuting time and attrition rates, and
have a significant percentage of employees work increases in productivity. (Many companies reported
per manently from home. that productivity did not suffer when employees
Information technologies driving these changes worked at home during the pandemic.) According to
include broadband high-speed Internet connections, Global Workplace Analytics, a typical company saves
about $11,000 per half-time telecommuter per year.
Working remotely also poses challenges.
Chapter 1 Information Systems in Global Business Today 41
Not all employees have access to the Internet connection of face-to-face conversations. Remote
at home, and many work in industries that work also inhibits the creativity and innovative
require on-site work. About 80 percent of thinking that take place when people interact with
American adults each other face-to-face, and videoconferencing is
have high-speed broadband Internet service at home. only a partial solution. Studies have found that peo
However, according to a Pew Research Center study, ple working together in the same room tend to solve
racial minorities, older adults, rural residents, and problems more quickly than remote collaborators,
people with lower levels of education and income and that team cohesion suffers when members work
are less likely to have in-home broadband service. remotely.
In addition, one in five American adults access the
Internet only through their smartphones. Employees Sources: Dana Mattioli and Konrad Putzier, 'The End of the Office:
with little children or small apartments find Wall Street Journal, May 16-17, 2020; Rani Molla, "This Is the End
working at home more difficult. of the Office as We Know It,• Vox, April 14, 2020; Josh Lowy,
"Over coming Remote Work Challenges,• MIT Sloan Management
Full-time employees are four times more likely to ReView, April 9, 2020; Cate Pye, "Coronavirus: What Does the
have remote work options than part-time employees. 'New Normal• Mean for How We Work?• Computer Weekly, April
According to Global Workplace Analytics, a typical re 3, 2020; Lindsey Jacobson, 'As Coronavirus Forces Millions to
Work Remotely, the US Economy May Have Reached a 'Tipping
mote worker is college-educated, at least 45 years old, Point' in Favor of Work ing from Home,• CNBC, March 23, 2020;
and earns an annual salary of $58,000 while working Derek Thompson, 'The Coronavirus Is Creating a Huge, Stressful
for a company with more than 100 employees. Experiment in Working from Home,• The Atlantic, March 13, 2020;
Kevin Roose, 'Sorry, but Working from Home Is Overrated,• New
Although email and text messaging are very use York nmes, March 10, 2020.
ful, they are not effective tools for communication
compared to the information exchange and personal
and strengthened the benefits that flow from trade, and also created
significant dislocations in labor markets.
In 2005, journalist Thomas Friedman wrote an influential book declaring
the world was now flat, by which he meant that the Internet and global
communi cations had greatly expanded the opportunities for people to
communicate with one another and reduced the economic and cultural
advantages of developed countries. The United States and European countries
were in a fight for their economic lives, according to Friedman, competing for
jobs, markets, resources, and even ideas with highly educated, motivated
populations in low-wage areas in the less developed world (Friedman, 2007).
This globalization presents you and your business with both challenges and
opportunities.
A growing percentage of the economy of the United States and other ad
vanced industrial countries in Europe and Asia depends on imports and
exports. In 2019, an estimated 30 percent of the world economy resulted from
foreign trade of goods and services, both imports and exports. Half of
Fortune 500 US firms obtain nearly 50 percent of their revenue from foreign
operations. For instance, more than 50 percent of Intel's revenues in 2019
came from overseas sales of its microprocessors.
4 Part One Organizations, Management, and the Networked
It’s not just goods that move across borders. So too do jobs, some of them
high- level jobs that pay well and require a college degree. For instance, since
2000, the United States has lost an estimated 5 million manufacturing jobs to
offshore, low-wage producers, so manufacturing is now a small part of US
employment (less than 9 percent). In a normal year, about 300,000 service jobs
move off- shore to lower-wage countries, many of them in less-skilled
information system occupations but also in tradable service jobs in architecture,
financial services, customer call centers, consulting, engineering, and even
radiology.
On the plus side, the US economy created 2.6 million new jobs in 2018.
Employment in information systems and the other service occupations listed
previously has rapidly expanded in sheer numbers, wages, productivity, and
quality of work. Outsourcing has actually accelerated the development of new
systems in the United States and worldwide by reducing the cost of building
and maintaining them. In 2019 job openings in information systems and tech-
nologies far exceeded the supply of applicants.
The challenge for you as a business student is to develop high-level skills
through education and on-the-job experience that cannot be outsourced. The
challenge for your business is to avoid markets for goods and services that can
be produced offshore much less expensively. The opportunities are equally im-
mense. Throughout this book you will find examples of companies and indi-
viduals who either failed or succeeded in using information systems to adapt to
this new global environment.
What does globalization have to do with management information systems?
That’s simple: everything. The emergence of the Internet into a full-blown
international communications system has drastically reduced the costs of
operating and transacting on a global scale. Communication between a fac-
tory floor in Shanghai and a distribution center in Rapid City, South Dakota,
is now instant and virtually free. Customers can now shop in a worldwide
marketplace, obtaining price and quality information reliably 24 hours a day.
Firms producing goods and services on a global scale achieve extraordinary
cost reductions by finding low-cost suppliers and managing production facili-
ties in other countries. Internet service firms, such as Google and eBay, are
able to replicate their business models and services in multiple countries
without having to redesign their expensive fixed-cost information systems
infrastructure. Briefly, information systems enable globalization.
Operational Excellence
Businesses continuously seek to improve the efficiency of their operations in
order to achieve higher profitability. Information systems and technologies are
some of the most important tools available to managers for achieving higher
4 Part One Organizations, Management, and the Networked
systems and technologies to achieve customer intimacy. These hotels use com-
puters to keep track of guests’ preferences, such as their preferred room tem-
perature, check-in time, frequently dialed telephone numbers, and television
programs, and store these data in a large data repository. Individual rooms in
the hotels are networked to a central network server computer so that they can
be remotely monitored and controlled. When a customer arrives at one of these
hotels, the system automatically changes the room conditions, such as dim-
ming the lights, setting the room temperature, or selecting appropriate music,
based on the customer’s digital profile. The hotels also analyze their customer
data to identify their best customers and to develop individualized marketing
campaigns based on customers’ preferences.
Charles Tyrwhitt, a UK retailer specializing in dress shirts, and JCPenney,
a US department store chain, exemplify the use of information systems to en-
able supplier and customer intimacy. Every time a dress shirt is bought one of
their stores, the record of the sale appears immediately on computers in Hong
Kong at their supplier. TAL Apparel, a contract manufacturer that produces one
in six dress shirts sold in the United States. TAL runs the numbers through a
computer model it developed and then decides how many replacement shirts
to make and in what styles, colors, and sizes. TAL then sends the shirts to each
store, bypassing the retailer’s warehouses. These systems reduce inventory
costs and ensure that what customers want are actually on the shelves.
Competitive Advantage
When firms achieve one or more of these business objectives—operational ex-
cellence; new products, services, and business models; customer/supplier inti-
macy; and improved decision making—chances are they have already achieved
a competitive advantage. Doing things better than your competitors, charging
less for superior products, and responding to customers and suppliers in real
time all add up to higher sales and higher profits that your competitors cannot
match. Apple Inc., Walmart, and UPS, described later in this chapter, are indus-
try leaders because they know how to use information systems for this purpose.
Chapter 1 Information Systems in Global Business 4
Survival
Business firms also invest in information systems and technologies because
they are necessities of doing business. Sometimes these "necessities" are
driven by industry-level changes. For instance, after Barclays Bank introduced
the first automated teller machines (ATMs) in London in 1967, its
competitors rushed to provide ATMs to their customers to keep up. Today,
virtually all large banks around the world have regional ATMs and link to
national and international ATM networks, such as Cirrus. Providing ATM
services to retail banking cus tomers is simply required in the retail banking
business.
Most nations have statutes and regulations that create a legal duty for compa
nies and their employees to retain records, including digital records. For instance,
the European Council's Regulation on Registration, Evaluation, Authorization, and
Restriction of Chemicals (REACH) and the U.S.Toxic Substances Control Act (1976),
which regulates the exposure of employees to toxic chemicals, require firms to re
tain records on employee exposure for a certain period of time. Many other pieces
of national and regional legislation impose significant information retention and
reporting requirements on US businesses. Firms tum to information systems to
provide the capability to respond to these record management requirements.
331 Brite Dish Soap 1.29 Sales Region: Northwest Store: Superstore #122
863 BL Hill Coffee 4.69 ITEM NO. DESCRIPTION UNITS SOLD
173 Meow Cat .79 Information
331 Brite Dish Soap 1.29
663 Country Ham 3.29
System 331 Brite Dish Soap 7,156
524 Fiery Mustard 1.49 YTD SALES
113 Ginger Root .85 $9,231.24
331 Brite Dish Soap 1.29
ENVIRONMENT
Suppliers Customers
\\
,,' ,
'
ORGANIZATION
INFORMATION SYSTEM
\
I
GI
Processing
.. Classify
'I
Input Arrange
I Calculate
/ t
•
Feedback
,, ' I I
\
\\
' '
I
/m m
,
Technology
lnfonnation
Organization s
Management
Organizations
Information systems are an integral part of organizations. Indeed, for some com
panies, such as credit reporting firms, there would be no business without an in
formation system. The key elements of an organization are its people, structure,
business processes, politics, and culture. We introduce these components of
orga nizations here and descnbe them in greater detail in Chapters 2 and 3.
Organizations have a structure that is composed of different levels and
spe cialties. Their structures reveal a clear-cut division of labor. Authority
and re sponsibility in a business firm are organized as a hierarchy, or a
pyramid struc ture. The upper levels of the hierarchy consist of managerial,
professional, and technical employees, whereas the lower levels consist of
operational personnel. Senior management makes long-range strategic
decisions about products and services as well as ensures financial
performance of the firm. Middle management carries out the programs
and plans of senior management, and operational management is
responsible for monitoring the daily activities of the business. Knowledge
workers, such as engineers, scientists, or architects, design products or
services and create new knowledge for the firm, whereas data workers,
such as secretaries or clerks, assist with scheduling and com munications at
all levels of the firm. Production or service workers actually
produce the product and deliver the service (see Figure 1.6).
Experts are employed and trained for different business functions. The major
business functions, or specialized tasks performed by business
organizations, consist of sales and marketing, manufacturing and production,
finance and ac counting, and human resources (see Tuble 1.1). Chapter 2
provides more detail on these business functions and the ways in which they
are supported by infor mation systems.
An organization coordinates work through its hierarchy and through its busi
ness processes. Most organizations' business processes include formal rules that
5 Part One Organizations, Management, and the Networked
have been developed over a long time for accomplishing tasks. These rules
guide employees in a variety of procedures, from writing an invoice to respond
ing to customer complaints. Some of these business processes have been
writ ten down, but others are informal work practices, such as a requirement
to return telephone calls from coworkers or customers, that are not formally
docu mented. Information systems automate many business processes. For
instance, how a customer receives credit or how a customer is billed is often
determined by an information system that incorporates a set of formal
business processes.
Each organization has a unique culture, or fundamental set of assumptions,
values, and ways of doing things, that has been accepted by most of its mem
bers. You can see organizational culture at work by looking around your
univer sity or college. Some bedrock assumptions of university life are that
professors know more than students, that the reason students attend college is
to learn, and that classes follow a regular schedule.
Parts of an organization's culture can always be found embedded in its infor
mation systems. For instance, UPS's first priority is customer service, which is
an aspect of its organizational culture that can be found in the company's pack
age tracking systems, which we describe in this section.
Middle Management
Scientists and knowledge workers
Management
Management’s job is to make sense out of the many situations faced by
organiza- tions, make decisions, and formulate action plans to solve organizational
problems. Managers perceive business challenges in the environment, they set
the organiza- tional strategy for responding to those challenges, and they allocate
the human and financial resources to coordinate the work and achieve success.
Throughout, they must exercise responsible leadership. The business
information systems described in this book reflect the hopes, dreams, and
realities of real-world managers.
But managers must do more than manage what already exists. They must
also create new products and services and even re-create the organization from
time to time. A substantial part of management responsibility is creative work
driven by new knowledge and information. Information technology can play
a powerful role in helping managers design and deliver new products and ser-
vices and redirecting and redesigning their organizations. Chapter 12 treats
management decision making in detail.
Information Technology
Information technology is one of many tools managers use to cope with change.
Computer hardware is the physical equipment used for input, processing, and
output activities in an information system. It consists of the following: comput-
ers of various sizes and shapes (including mobile handheld devices); various
input, output, and storage devices; and telecommunications devices that link
computers together.
Computer software consists of the detailed, preprogrammed instructions
that control and coordinate the computer hardware components in an infor-
mation system. Chapter 5 describes the contemporary software and hardware
platforms used by firms today in greater detail.
Data management technology consists of the software governing the orga-
nization of data on physical storage media. More detail on data organization and
access methods can be found in Chapter 6.
Networking and telecommunications technology, consisting of both
physical devices and software, links the various pieces of hardware and
trans- fers data from one physical location to another. Computers and
communica- tions equipment can be connected in networks for sharing voice,
data, images, sound, and video. A network links two or more computers to
share data or resources, such as a printer.
The world’s largest and most widely used network is the Internet. The
Internet is a global “network of networks” that uses universal standards (de-
scribed in Chapter 7) to connect millions of networks in more than 230 coun-
tries around the world.
The Internet has created a new “universal” technology platform on which to
build new products, services, strategies, and business models. This same
technol- ogy platform has internal uses, providing the connectivity to link
different sys- tems and networks within the firm. Internal corporate networks
based on Internet
5 Part One Organizations, Management, and the Networked
to carry out inspections and surveillance. In addi Sources: "Combating Covid-19: A Birth of Innovations,» The
tion, as an immediate response to the pandemic, and Straits Times, September 29, 2020; Salma Khalik, "Singapore on
as a longer-term solution to infection control, new 1tack to Have One of World's Most IT-enabled Healthcare
Systems,• The Straits Times, June 2, 2017; JurongHealth, 'Awards &
touch-free technology has been introduced to operate Accolades,• wwwjuronghealth.com.sg, accessed January 5, 2017; P.
patient and visitor lifts. Bhunia, 'The JurongHealth ITJourney-Integrating IT from the
IT has played a key role in enabling Ground-Up into a New Digital Hospital,• opengovasia.com,
November 13, 2016;
JurongHealth to achieve its mission of providing !HIS, 'Ng Tong Fong General Hospital Becomes First in Singapore
world-class medical care at an affordable cost. As a and ASEAN to Achieve HIMSS Analytics EMRAM Stage 7
result, JurongHealth has developed a reputation as a Award,• Press Release, www.ihis.com, October 7, 2016; •our
lead ing technology-driven healthcare provider as Milestones,• wwwjuronghealth.com.sg, October 2016; Ai Lei Too,
'Singapore's Jurong Health Services: nansforming Healthcare
well as a role model not only in Singapore but also Through Data Tochnologies,• computerweekly.com, April 16,
the entire region. This is also evident from its many 2016; A. Shukla, 'Singapore Hospitals Deliver Enhanced Care to
accolades, which include awards for IT-driven Patients by Integrating Their IT Systems,' www.cio-asia.com,
March 17, 2016;
transformation and for overall organizational !HIS, 'Integrated Healthcare IT Systems at Ng Tong Fong General
transformation. Hospital and Jurong Community Hospital Win the Project of the Year
Award at the SPMI Symposium 2016,• Press Release, www. ihis.com,
March 14, 2016; J. Kellehei; "JurongHealth Services CIO Discusses
the Fully Integrated EMRSuite, Hospital JCTSystems and Achieving
CASE STUDY QUESTIONS HIMSS EMRAM Stage 6,• opengovasia.com, February 18, 2016.
1. What technologies are used by
JurongHealth? What purpose do they serve? 3. What information systems are implemented by
2. Search the web for RFID. Suggest an example
JurongHealth? Describe the input, processing, and
output of any one such system.
of how RFID can be used for locating and
tracking people. 4. Why are information systems important
Case contributed by Neerja Sethi and Vijay Sethi, for JurongHealth?
Nanyang 'Thchnological University
DDDD
Business Processes
DDDM
/ Supply Enterprise Customer Knowledge
Chain Management Management Management
•mMt
Data
Dissemination
""DDDD
Collection Transfor
and mation
Storage into Business
Systems
Business Value
firm profitability. Although there are other reasons why systems are built,
their primary purpose is to contribute to corporate value.
The business perspective calls attention to the organizational and managerial na
ture of information systems. An information system represents an organizational
and management solution, based on information technology, to a challenge or
problem posed by the environment. Every chapter in thisbook begins with a
short case study that illustrates this concept. A diagram at the beginning of each
chapter illustrates the relationship between a business challenge and resulting
manage ment and organizational decisions to use IT as a solution to challenges
generated by the business environment. You can use this diagram as a starting
point for ana lyzing any information system or information system problem you
encounter.
Review the diagram at the beginning of this chapter. The diagram shows how
the AWM Smart Shelf system helps solve the business problem of brick-and
mortar stores losing market share to online retailers. This system provides a
so lution that takes advantage of opportunities provided by new object-
recognition and wireless digital technology.
AWM Smart Shelf digitally enables keybusiness processes for inventory
man agement, sales, and marketing, helping retailers improve their overall
business performance. The diagram also illustrates how management,
technology, and organizational elements work together to create the systems.
4.0
• 2
2.0
•
Productivity
(relative to 1.0
industry
average)
.5
.25
3 4
others invest little and receive little (quadrant 3). This suggests that investing
in information technology does not by itself guarantee good returns. What ac-
counts for this variation among firms?
The answer lies in the concept of complementary assets. Information
tech- nology investments alone cannot make organizations and managers
more effective unless they are accompanied by supportive values, structures,
and be- havior patterns in the organization and other complementary assets.
Business firms need to change how they do business before they can really
reap the ad- vantages of new information technologies.
Complementary assets are those assets required to derive value from a pri-
mary investment (Teece, 1998). For instance, to realize value from automobiles
requires substantial complementary investments in highways, roads, gasoline
stations, repair facilities, and a legal regulatory structure to set standards and
control drivers.
Research indicates that firms that support their technology investments
with investments in complementary assets, such as new business models, new
business processes, management behavior, organizational culture, or training,
receive superior returns, whereas those firms failing to make these comple-
mentary investments receive less or no returns on their information technol-
ogy investments (Brynjolfsson, 2005; Brynjolfsson and Hitt, 2000; Laudon,
1974). These investments in organization and management are also known as
organizational and management capital.
Table 1.2 lists the major complementary investments that firms need to
make to realize value from their information technology investments. Some
of this investment involves tangible assets, such as buildings, machinery,
and tools. However, the value of investments in information technology de-
pends to a large extent on complementary investments in management and
organization.
Key organizational complementary investments are a supportive busi-
ness culture that values efficiency and effectiveness, an appropriate business
model, efficient business processes, decentralization of authority, highly dis-
tributed decision rights, and a strong information system (IS) development
team.
Important managerial complementary assets are strong senior man-
agement support for change, incentive systems that monitor and reward
individual innovation, an emphasis on teamwork and collaboration, training
programs, and a management culture that values flexibility and knowledge.
Important social investments (not made by the firm but by the society at
large, other firms, governments, and other key market actors) are the Internet
and the supporting Internet culture, educational systems, network and com-
puting standards, regulations and laws, and the presence of technology and
service firms.
Throughout the book, we emphasize a framework of analysis that considers
technology, management, and organizational assets and their interactions.
Perhaps the single most important theme in the book, reflected in case stud-
ies and exercises, is that managers need to consider the broader organization
and management dimensions of information systems to understand current
problems as well as to derive substantial above-average returns from their in-
formation technology investments. As you will see throughout the text, firms
that can address these related dimensions of the IT investment are, on aver-
age, richly rewarded.
Chapter 1 Information Systems in Global Business 6
Technical Approach
The technical approach to information systems emphasizes mathematically
based models to study information systems as well as the physical technology
and formal capabilities of these systems. The disciplines that contribute to the
technical ap proach are computer science, management science, and operations
research.
Computer science is concerned with establishing theories of computabil
ity, methods of computation, and methods of efficient data storage and
access. Management science emphasizes the development of models for
decision making and management practices. Operations research focuses on
mathemat ical techniques for optimizing selected parameters of
organizations, such as transportation, inventory control, and transaction
costs.
Behavioral Approach
An important part of the information systems field is concerned with behavioral
issues that arise in the development and long-term maintenance of
information systems. Issues such as strategic business integration, design,
implementation,
Technical
Approaches
MIS
6 Part One Organizations, Management, and the Networked
utilization, and management cannot be explored usefully with the models used
in the technical approach. Other behavioral disciplines contribute important
concepts and methods.
For instance, sociologists study information systems with an eye toward how
groups and organizations shape the development of systems and also how
systems affect individuals, groups, and organizations. Psychologists study
information sys- tems with an interest in how human decision makers perceive
and use formal information. Economists study information systems with an
interest in under- standing the production of digital goods, the dynamics of
digital markets, and how new information systems change the control and cost
structures within the firm.
The behavioral approach does not ignore technology. Indeed, information
systems technology is often the stimulus for a behavioral problem or issue. But
the focus of this approach is generally not on technical solutions. Instead, it
concentrates on changes in attitudes, management and organizational policy,
and behavior.
TECHNOLOGY ORGANIZATION
Alternative Alternative
1 - 1
Alternative Alternative
-
2
- 2
. ..
Alternative
3
Alternative
3
FinalFinal
Design ofDesign of
TechnologyOrganization
The Company
Power Financial Analytics Data Services, a data and software company serving
the financial industry with offices in London, New York, Sydney, and
Singapore, is looking to fill an entry-level position for a financial client support
and sales assistant. The company has 1,600 employees, many of whom are
consultants showing clients how to work with its powerful financial analytics
software and data products.
Position Description
The financial client support and sales assistant will be part of a team in the
company's consulting services. Consulting teams combine a thorough under
standing of finance and technology with specific expertise in Power Financial
Analytics Data Services software and assist clients in a variety of ways. The
Chapter 1 Information Systems in Global Business 6
Job Requirements
• Recent college graduate or investment professional with one to two years
of experience. Applicants with backgrounds in finance, MIS, economics, ac-
counting, business administration, and mathematics are preferred
• Knowledge of or interest in learning about financial markets
• Sound working knowledge of spreadsheets
• Very strong communication and interpersonal skills
• Strong desire to learn in rapidly changing environment
Interview Questions
1. What is your background in finance? What courses did you take? Have you
ever worked in the financial industry? What did you do there?
2. What is your proficiency level with spreadsheet software? What work have
you done with Excel spreadsheets? Can you show examples of your work?
3. Are you able to discuss current trends in the financial industry and how they
impact Power Financial’s business model and client base?
4. Did you ever work with clients? Can you give examples of how you provided
client service or support?
5. Can you give us an example of a finance-related problem or other business
problem that you helped solve? Did you do any writing and analysis? Can
you provide examples?
Author Tips
1. Use the web to learn about financial markets and the financial industry.
2. Use the web to research the company, its financial products, and the tools
and services it offers customers. Learn what you can about its consulting
services. Additionally, examine the company’s social medial channels, such
as LinkedIn and Facebook, for trends and themes.
3. Inquire exactly how you would be using spreadsheets for this job. Pro-
vide examples of how you used spreadsheets to solve problems in the
classroom or for a job assignment. Show the spreadsheet work you did in
finance.
4. Bring examples of your writing (including some from your Digital Port-
folio described in MyLab MIS) demonstrating your analytical skills and
project experience. Be prepared to discuss how you helped customers
solve a business problem or the business problem solving you did for your
courses.
62 Part One Organizations, Management, and the Networked Enterprise
1-1 How are information systems transforming business, and why are they so essential for running and
managing a business today?
Organizations are trying to become more competitive and efficient by digitally enabling their
core business processes and evolving into digital firms. The Internet has stimulated globalization by
dra matically reducing the costs of producing, buying, and selling goods on a global scale.
Newinformation system trends include the emerging mobile digital platform, big data (including
IoT), more remote management, democratization of decision making, machine learning systems,
and the growing use of social media in business.
Information systems are a foundation for conducting business today. In many industries, survival
and the ability to achieve strategic business goals are difficult without extensive use of information
technology. Businesses today use information systems to achieve six major objectives: operational
excellence; new products, services, and business models; customer/supplier intimacy; improved
deci sion making; competitive advantage; and day-to-day survival.
1-2 What is an information system? How does it work? What are its management, organization, and
technology components? Why are complementary assets essential for ensuring that information
systems provide genuine value for organizations?
From a technical perspective, an information system collects, stores, and disseminates
information from an organization's environment and internal operations to support organizational
functions and decision making, communication, coordination, control, analysis, and visualization.
Information sys tems transform raw data into useful information through three basic activities:
input, processing, and output.
From a business perspective, an information system provides a solution to a problem or challenge
facing a firm and represents a combination of management, organization, and technology elements.
The management dimension of information systems involves issues such as leadership, strategy,
and management behavior. The technology dimension consists of computer hardware, software, data
man agement technology, and networking/telecommunications technology (including the Internet).
The organization dimension of information systems involves issues such as the organization's
hierarchy, functional specialties, business processes, culture, and political interest groups.
In order to obtain meaningful value from information systems, organizations must support their
technology investments with appropriate complementary investments in organizations and manage
ment. These complementary assets include new business models and business processes, supportive
organizational culture and management behavior, and appropriate technology standards,
regulations, and laws. New information technology investments are unlikely to produce high returns
unless busi nesses make the appropriate managerial and organizational changes to support the
technology.
1-3 What academic disciplines are used to study information systems, and how does each contribute
to an understanding of information systems?
The study of information systems deals with issues and insights contributed from technical and
be havioral disciplines. The disciplines that contribute to the technical approach focusing on formal
mod els and capabilities of systems are computer science, management science, and operations
research. The disciplines contributing to the behavioral approach focusing on the design,
implementation, man agement, and business impact of systems are psychology, sociology, and
economics. A sociotechnical view of systems considers both technical and social features of systems
and solutions that represent the best fit between them.
Chapter 1 Information Systems in Global Business 6
Key Terms
Business functions, 49 Information technology (IT) infrastructure, 52
Business model, 44 Input, 47
Business processes, 42 Internet, 51
Complementary assets, 57 Intranets, 52
Computer hardware, 51 Knowledge workers, 49
Computer literacy, 48 Management information systems (MIS), 48
Computer software, 51 Middle management, 49
Culture, 50 Network, 51
Data, 46 Networking and telecommunications
Data management technology, 51 technology, 51
Data workers, 49 Operational management, 49
Digital firm, 42 Organizational and management capital, 57
Extranets, 52 Output, 47
Feedback, 4 7 Processing, 47
Information, 46 Production or service workers,
Information system, 46 49 Senior management, 49
Information systems literacy, 48 Sociotechnical view, 59
Information technology (IT), 46 World Wide Web, 52
Mylab MIS
To complete the problems with Mylab MIS, go to the EOC Discussion Questions in Mylab MIS.
Review Questions
1-1 How are information systems transforming • Explain why organizations have a
business, and why are they so essential for struc ture composed of different levels
running and managing a business today? and specialties.
• Describe how information systems • Describe how the parts of an
have changed the way businesses organization's culture can be found
operate and their products and services. embedded in its infor mation systems.
• Identify three major new information • Describe the features of an
sys tem trends. organization's information value chain.
• Describe the characteristicsof a digital firm. • Based on what you have read, identify
• Describe the challenges and opportunities the key elements of organizational and
of globalization in a "flattened" world. man agement capital.
• List and descnbe six reasons why 1-3 What academic disciplines are used to study
information systems are so important for information systems, and how does each
business today. contribute to an understanding of
1-2 What is an information system? How does it information systems?
work? What are its management, organization, • List and describe each discipline that con
and technology components? Why are tributes to a technical approach to
complementary assets essential for ensuring informa tion systems.
that information systems provide genuine value • List and describe each discipline that
for organizations? con tributes to a behavioral approach to
• Explain the differences between infor mation systems.
informa tion and data. Why is the former • Describe the sociotechnical perspective
essential to the latter? on information systems.
• Describe the three activities in an
informa tion system that produce the
information that organizations need.
6 Part One Organizations, Management, and the Networked
Discussion Questions
1-4 Information systems are too important to be
1-6 What are some of the organizational,
MyLab MIS MyLab MIS
left to computer specialists. Do you agree? managerial, and social complementary
Why or why not? assets that help make UPS’s information
1-5 If you were setting up the website systems so successful?
MyLab MIS
for a professional football team, what
management, organization, and technology
issues might you encounter?
1-9 In this project, you will start out with raw transactional sales data and use Microsoft Access database
software to develop queries and reports that help managers make better decisions about product pricing,
sales promotions, and inventory replenishment. In MyLab MIS, you can find a Store and Regional
Sales Database developed in Microsoft Access. The database contains raw data on weekly store sales
of computer equipment in various sales regions. The database includes fields for store identification
number, sales region, item number, item description, unit price, units sold, and the weekly sales period
when the sales were made. Use Access to develop some reports and queries to make this information
more useful for running the business. Sales and production managers want answers to the following
questions:
• Which products should be restocked?
• Which stores and sales regions would benefit from a promotional campaign and additional marketing?
• When (what time of year) should products be offered at full price, and when should discounts be used?
You can easily modify the database table to find and report your answers. Print your reports and results of
queries.
Chapter 1 Information Systems in Global Business 6
Improving Decision Making: Using the Internet to Locate Jobs Requiring Information
Systems Knowledge
Software skills: Internet-based software
Business skills: Job searching
1-10 Visit a job-posting website such as EURES, the European Job Mobility Portal run by the European Com-
mission. Spend some time at the site examining jobs for accounting, finance, sales, marketing, and human
resources. Find two or three descriptions of jobs that require some information systems knowledge. What
in- formation systems knowledge do these jobs require? What do you need to do to prepare for these jobs?
Write a one- to two-page report summarizing your findings.
A
lthough 2020 was a very difficult year for and requires several companies to work together to
many companies, it was a very successful ensure that the payment is successful. To start with,
one for Adyen, a Dutch company that there is, of course, the merchant, but there are also
mostly companies providing a gateway for the payments, as
focuses on processing Internet payments. As the sessing the risk, and so on. Because of this crowded
COVID-19 pandemic boosted the volume of online field of facilitators, many things can go wrong. For
payments, business soared. Ayden announced in instance, software may be outdated, or programs used
November 2020 that it was expanding in the Middle
by one provider may be incompatible with those of
East, opening a new office in Dubai. Earlier that
another.
year, Internet retailer Zalando chose Adyen to pro
According to Forrester, a market research firm
cess its credit card payments in all European mar
that focuses on information technology, around 10
kets. Raffies Hotel Singapore selected Adyen as its
percent of all payments fail for "technical" reasons.
preferred payment provider to offer a seamless and
Adyen is reducing this performance gap by integrat
more customer-centric digital payment experience
ing several components of the payment chain (such
across all of the hotel's touchpoints. The company
as the gateway, risk assessment, and processing)
also signed a new agreement with Microsoft,
into one platform. It has thus been successful in
expand ing and deepening their cooperation on
ensuring a higher success rate in its payments chain
payments processing. These are just the latest in a
than other facilitators.
long series of successes for Ayden. In 2018,
Ayden's second advantage is that its payments
American Internet giant eBay announced that
platform is connected to most payment systems
Adyen would become eBay's primary payments
being used in the world. Payment systems can differ
provider. This wassignifi cant for two reasons. First,
greatly from country to country. In the Netherlands,
eBay is, of course, a huge company: in 2019, the
for instance, most online payments are done through
value of goods sold on the platform amounted to a
the iDEAL system, which links payments to check
staggering $90.2 billion. For Adyen, this meant a
ing accounts. In other countries, most payments are
huge increase of its business.
done through credit cards or debit cards like Visa
Second, and perhaps more importantly, eBay gave
or Mastercard. When it comes to processing pay
preference to Adyen over PayPal, which is very
ments, this variety of methods complicates things
often the first choice of online companies. For a
enormously, as the payment processors need to have
startup like Adyen to beat a market leader like
several platforms. Adyen, however, has one integrated
PayPal was remarkable.
platform that can link with most payment methods
As a result of all these successes, Adyen has been
being used all over the world. This is, of course, an
the star of the Amsterdam stock exchange for several
attractive option for merchants or online companies
years. In 2018, Adyen had a very successful initial
that sell their goods worldwide. When eBay decided
public offering (IPO) and its shares, which were
to work with Adyen, it gave two reasons for its
priced at €240, nearly doubled in price during the
decision: Adyen processes payments more cheaply
first trading day. Since then Adyen's share price has
and gives more control to merchants that use the
continued to increase, reaching over €740 by the end
platform.
of 2019. Then the coronavirus crisis broke and more
Adyen is a good example of a company that
and more people started to shop online and make
works in the field of fintech (financial technology).
payments through Adyen. The company's share price
Companies that use technology to facilitate
more than doubled over the following months and by
financial transactions have been highly successful
December 11, 2020, it had risen to €1834.50.
over the last decade. Founded in 2006, Adyen is
What explains Adyen's success? The answer to
relatively old for
that rests primarily in the technology it uses. To put
a fintech company, but it has grown enormously-
it simply, Adyen makes payment transactions easier.
in 2019 it had €240 billion in processed volume.
Making payments on the Internet is a much more
Remarkable as Adyen's case is, it is definitely not
complicated business than many people think it is,
unique; other firms have used technology to find a
Chapter 1 Information Systems in Global Business 6
As consumers and firms have moved towards mobile expectations that it will surpass all of those bench
and online payments, many traditional banks have marks for 2020. Myen illustrates how fintech startups
invested heavily in new technologies in part using are changing the traditional bank and payment sys
the funds saved by closing down traditional physical tems using new technologies and business models.
bank branches. Where in-house innovation has not
Sources: Bernard Vogelsang, "AEX Lager Het Weekend In
worked, the large banks have purchased fintech firms
Door Brexit-Zorgen,» Telegraaf, December 11, 2020; •Adyen
and folded them into their existing business and tech Breidt Samenwerking Met Microsoft Uit,• deaandeelhouder.
nology platforms. Traditional banks have a decided nl, December 10, 2020; Ayden, "Raffles Hotel Singapore Tokes
advantage over fintech startups: extraordinary cash Its Legendary Guest Experience to the Next Level with Adyen,•
www.adyen.com, November 24, 2020; Robert Vink, "How
flow and tens of millions of loyal customers and firms.
Adyen Is Simultaneously Disrupting Banks and the Payments
In this scenario, fintech firms have been early to the Industry,• www.seekingalpha.com, November 18, 2020; Adyen,
partybut typically do not survive to the end of the •Adyen to Expand in the Middle East, Opens Dubai Office,•
party, at least not as independent firms. www.adyen.com, November 10, 2020; Ben Dummet, 'A Little
Known Payments Provider Grows into One of Europe's Most
Myen's founders were very experienced entrepre
Valuable Finance Form,• Wall Street Journal, November 16, 2020;
neurs when they started their company. They had "Quarter of Bank Branches Will Close in Coming Three Years,•
already created another company, Bibit, which they Consultancy.uk, September 14, 2020; Adyen, •Adyen to Process
sold to The Royal Bank of Scotland for €100 million. European Credit Card Payments for Zalando,• www.adyen.
Indeed, the word adyen means •again" in a language com, August 13, 2020; Ryan Browne, "Fintech Firm Adyen Posts
34% Surge in First-Quarter Revenue as Coronavirus Bolsters
from Surinam, meaning that Myen is their second en Online Payments,• www.cnbc.com, April 21, 2020; Adyen, "2019
deavor in the field of financial technology. Myen ap Annual Report,• www.adyen.com, March 24, 2020; eBay, "eBay
pears likely to be one of the survivors. The volume of Inc. Reports Fourth Quarter and Full Year 2019 Results,• www.
payments it processes has grown from €32 billion in ebay.com, January 28, 2020; Tomasz Grynkiewicz, "This Fintech
Attracts 10,000 Customers a Day,• www.netguru.com, December
2015 to €240 billion in 2019. Myen's revenues during
4, 2019; Kamal Ahmed, "Bank of England Chief Economist Warns
this time period have also grown, from €98.5 billion on AI Jobs Threat,• BBC News, www.bbc.com, August 20, 2018;
in 2015 to almost €500 billion by 2019. Unlike many Jan Hammer, •Adyen: A Global Success Born in Amsterdam,•
fintech company, Myen hasalso been able to show Index Ventures, www.indexventures.com, June 13, 2018,; "Bank
Jobs Could Fall by 50% in 10 Years, Says Ex-Barclays Boss,•
a profit, with net income rising from €131 million in
BBC News, www.bbc.com, November 26, 2015.
2018 to €204 million in 2019, up 56 percent, and
with
do investors pay so much for shares of
CASE STUDY QUESTIONS com panies that hardly make any profits?
1-12 According to Adyen, the payments platform 1-14 Explain the term "creative destruction." Is
has two advantages compared to other pay the German bank N26 destroying jobs or
ment platforms. Describe these advantages creating new jobs?
in your own words.
1-15 Explain why such a high percentage offin
1-13 Many fintech companies are very valuable tech startups gobankrupt before making any
on the stock exchange even though they profits at all.
make little or no profit. Explain this
situation. Why Case contributed by Bernard Bouwman
7 Part One Organizations, Management, and the Networked
Chapter 1 References
Baldwin, Richard. The Great Convergence: Information Lamb, Roberta, Steve Sawyer, and Rob Kling. “A Social Informatics
Technology and the New Globalization. Cambridge, MA: Perspective of Socio-Technical Networks.” http://lamb.cba.
Harvard Univer- sity Press (2016).
hawaii.edu/pubs (2004).
Brynjolfsson, Erik. “VII Pillars of IT Productivity.” Optimize (May
Laudon, Kenneth C. Computers and Bureaucratic Reform. New York:
2005).
Wiley (1974).
Brynjolffson, Erik, and Avinash Collis. “How Should We Measure
Lev, Baruch. “Intangibles: Management, Measurement, and Re-
the Digital Economy?” Harvard Business Review (November– porting.” The Brookings Institution Press (2001).
December 2019).
Lipsman, Andrew. “Global E-Commerce 2019.” eMarketer (June
Brynjolfsson, Erik, and Lorin M. Hitt. “Beyond Computation: Informa-
27, 2019).
tion Technology, Organizational Transformation, and Business
Mithas, Sunil, and Roland T. Rust. “How Information Technology
Performance.” Journal of Economic Perspectives 14, No. 4 (2000). Strategy and Investments Influence Firm Performance: Con-
Bureau of Economic Analysis. National Income and Product Ac-
jecture and Empirical Evidence.” MIS Quarterly (March 2016).
counts. www.bea.gov, accessed April 19, 2020.
Nevo, Saggi, and Michael R. Wade. “The Formation and Value of
Chae, Ho-Chang, Chang E. Koh, and Victor Prybutok. “Information IT- Enabled Resources: Antecedents and Consequences of
Technology Capability and Firm Performance: Contradictory
Syner- gistic Relationships.” MIS Quarterly 34, No. 1 (March
Findings and Their Possible Causes.” MIS Quarterly 38, No. 1
2010).
(March 2014). Ross, Jeanne W., and Peter Weill. “Four Questions Every CEO
Dedrick, Jason, Vijay Gurbaxani, and Kenneth L. Kraemer. “Infor- Should Ask About IT.” Wall Street Journal (April 25, 2011).
mation Technology and Economic Performance: A Critical Sabherwal, Rajiv, and Anand Jeyaraj. “Information Technology
Review of the Empirical Evidence.” Center for Research on Impacts on Firm Performance: An Extension of Kohli and
Information Technology and Organizations, University of Devaraj (2003).” MIS Quarterly (December 2015).
California, Irvine (December 2001). Saunders, Adam, and Erik Brynjolfsson. “Valuing Information
eMarketer. “Retail Mcommerce Sales, by Country” (September Technology Related Intangible Assets.” MIS Quarterly (March
2020). 2016).
Friedman, Thomas. The World Is Flat. New York: Picador (2007). Statista Research Department. “Size of the Global Management
Gartner Inc. “Gartner Says Global IT Spending to Reach $3.8 Tril- Consulting Market, from 2011 to 2020.” Statista (April 9,
lion in 2019.” (January 28, 2019). 2020).
Hjartar, Klemens, Krish Krishnakanthan, Pablo Prieto-Muñoz, Teece, David. Economic Performance and Theory of the Firm: The
Gay- atri Shenai. “The CEO’s New Technology Agenda.” Selected Papers of David Teece. London: Edward Elgar Publish-
McKinsey Digital (November 2019). ing (1998).
Hughes, Alan, and Michael S. Scott Morton. “The Transforming US Bureau of Labor Statistics. Occupational Outlook Handbook.
Power of Complementary Assets.” MIT Sloan Management (April 10, 2020)
Review 47, No. 4 (Summer 2006).