Getting It Right With Growth
Getting It Right With Growth
Getting It Right With Growth
with growth:
How to be a great
CFO in the new
growth economy
As companies focus on
growth, Chief Financial
Officers are now assuming
a more strategic role and
are expected to deliver
real insight to the C-suite.
Reporting and closing
the books are no longer
enough. CFOs must drive
operational gains and
steer their companies’
growth strategies.
Contents
Features
2014
05
Readying the growth
foundation: CFOs
take the big view
11
Four paths to
growth for CFOs
29
Five actions for the
growth-oriented CFO
CFO insights
and special
considerations
07
ADP: Driving growth
through innovation
14
Tax strategy: Getting it right
during growth
21
ARRIS: Two steps ahead
26
Euro-Pro: A multipronged
approach to growth
30
Minding the details: A CFO’s
reporting and compliance tip
sheet for growth
01
Executive summary
1. 17th Annual Global CEO Survey: Fit for the Future. (2014)
2. Five Global Megatrends. (2014)
02 Getting it right with growth: How to be a great CFO in the new growth economy
the department’s routine control, Big Data and advanced analytics also
compliance, and reporting functions expand the CFO’s vision at a lower cost
are now automated, generating faster than ever before. Using increasingly
and more accurate results, and giving available digital data, he or she can
finance a highly granular, real-time model various scenarios to get a better
view of the organization’s performance. picture of the future. “Finance sits at the
In addition, technology advances such intersection of a tremendous amount
as cloud computing have the potential of data,” says Gary Apanaschik, a
to bring a range of benefits to finance, partner at PwC. “Not only the financial
including significant cost savings, numbers coming in, but also the
operational efficiencies, flexibility in profitability of individual products
integration and deployment, improved and services, and how markets and
access for employees, and more robust competitors are performing. So they
disaster recovery. This has come can use these new technologies to sift
at a good time and organizations through that information and identify
need to prepare for adoption. the most promising path for growth.”
03
04 Getting it right with growth: How to be a great CFO in the new growth economy
Readying the growth
foundation: CFOs
take the big view
Getting the core capabilities The bottom line is that as the
primed for increased activity organization begins to grow, the
finance function will need to be able
There is a set of baseline capabilities to scale rapidly, without reinventing
that must be well developed before itself or serving as a drag on the
executing a plan for growth. Growth will process. “Whatever finance does
put stress on the model, and this could has to be scalable,” says Apanaschik.
degrade the ability of finance to deliver “As the company’s growing,
on its basic transactional, compliance finance has to be able to absorb
and reporting responsibilities. Just as that quickly and keep executing
importantly, finance needs to provide on its baseline responsibilities.”
services to the business in the areas
of operational excellence (shared Hiring ahead of growth
services), specialty knowledge (i.e.,
corporate accounting, tax, and treasury) A critical aspect of these foundational
and customer intimacy (FP&A and capabilities is talent. The finance
business unit finance). The ability of function needs to be hiring ahead of the
the finance function to provide these company’s growth trajectory. Growth
services is critical to the success of any inevitably requires special projects
growth strategy. The level of maturity and task forces. People get pulled into
needed across these services will vary various commitments and obligations,
by strategy. For instance, the need for putting greater pressure on the core
highly specialized knowledge in tax reporting and control functions. If the
and treasury surrounding transactions finance organization is staffed to meet
in foreign currency is probably more current requirements and no more, it
important for a growth strategy will soon fall behind. Hiring people
focused on emerging markets than for takes time, and CFOs can’t realistically
a strategy focused on innovation. expect to recruit, evaluate, hire, and
train new people at the height of a
growth wave. To support sustainable
growth, finance must hire ahead of the
curve, ensuring that it has the capacity
needed to meet future demands.4
4. People Performance: How CFOs can build the bench strength they need today… and tomorrow.
05
Minimizing risk to prepare Knowing where to
for new development increase R&D investment
Risk is growing across many fronts— within the company
regulatory, cyber-security, and Virtually all growth strategies involve
operations—and finance’s relationship investment, and the CFO understands
to risk has changed. In the past, areas which components of the company’s
such as compliance and cyber risk offerings could benefit from increased
were handled within the office of investment in R&D, new markets or
the general counsel. In today’s risk M&A. They have the numbers at their
environment, the office of the general fingertips to substantiate or refute a
counsel often doesn’t have sufficient business case for a particular growth
access to operational data and analytical strategy. But most importantly, the
modeling capabilities to understand CFO is uniquely qualified to put the
growth-related business risk. right principles and guidelines around
those investments, and to make
By contrast, as stewards of the sure that the organization is asking
company’s financial performance, the right questions to minimize risk
CFOs are intimately connected with and maximize upside potential.
risk. Since any growth strategy involves
risk, the role of the CFO in assessing
risk, determining acceptable levels, Perfecting company
and providing insight regarding
transparency as a
how it can be mitigated, has become
increasingly important. New foundation for expansion
technology provides sophisticated Transparency (both external and
models. “By leveraging some of the internal) is an overarching imperative
new analytical tools, CFOs can foster for any growth model. All growth
greater insight and transparency strategies are now and will continue
into the organization, including the to be executed against the backdrop
company’s risk profile,” says Houser. of an intensive focus on transparency.
Outside the organization, the company
must be able to give a clear indication
of its current performance, operational
soundness and its future prospects
to stakeholders such as investors and
“By leveraging some of the new regulators, particularly in heavily
analytics tools, CFOs can foster regulated industries such as financial
services and healthcare. And in those
greater insight and transparency industries, transparency needs to
into the organization, including happen in a protean context where
the regulations themselves are often
the company’s risk profile.” being revamped and reinterpreted.
06 Getting it right with growth: How to be a great CFO in the new growth economy
ADP: Driving growth
through innovation
With over $11 billion in annual “The ability for finance to provide
ADP has more than revenues, ADP is one of the largest internal business partners with solid
providers of global Human Capital analytics that inform decisions allows
600,000 clients in over Management (HCM) solutions, us to balance revenue growth with
100 countries, and has spanning payroll, HR, benefits cash flows for future investment,”
grown as a result of its administration and more. The company says Mike Burns, vice president of
has more than 600,000 clients in corporate finance and head of Financial
strategy to continually over 100 countries, and has grown as Planning and Analysis at ADP.
evolve its solutions a result of its strategy to continually
and service offerings evolve its solutions and service Finance in ADP goes through a highly-
offerings through innovative design detailed annual planning process
through innovative and technological enhancements. that includes information down to an
design and technological ADP’s finance organization, led by individual salesperson’s productivity.
enhancements. CFO Jan Siegmund, former chief This data is then aggregated up to a
strategy officer and head of corporate product-level and then enterprise-
development, is a key partner in wide view of performance across the
executing against this business strategy. company. In addition, finance runs
scenarios for how sales growth might be
“ADP’s finance organization functions impacted by modeling specific factors.
as a business partner and advisor For example, ADP might look at how
with our internal business units a change in tenure in the salesforce
and is involved in every phase of or geographical variations in the
planning, decision making and sales mix would change outcomes.
resource allocation,” says Siegmund.
While the finance insights described
For example, finance relies heavily above are impressive, they don’t
on analytics to evaluate the lifetime completely rely on complex technology.
profitability of ADP solutions and Most operations use a fairly standard
client segments to determine where Hyperion system. Where ADP shows
the company should invest and innovative thinking to provide
allocate sales resources. In addition, enhanced levels of analytical support
as part of ADP’s annual planning is in establishing true finance centers
process, finance reviews and analyzes of excellence and in implementing
contributions from the different sales clear data definitions that enable
channels and products, including their uniform governance across the
respective profit margins. Using this enterprise. An example of this would
information, finance recommends be the creation of data warehouses
how ADP should allocate sales that unify many sources of data to
resources, funding for R&D, and other enable the company to move faster
investments to best influence revenue and provide more accurate analysis.
growth and overall profitability.
07
“We’re reformulating our finance So we had to find new methods of
organization to give it a much controlling and monitoring R&D
stronger analytical foundation,” investments. Through team-based
says Siegmund. “We are setting decisions, shorter review cycles and a
higher expectations for how quickly willingness from finance to modify our
we can deliver quality service and approach, ADP is able to move faster
support to our management team.” and mimic the compressed innovation
cycles of smaller start-up companies.”
An example of how ADP is increasing
the quality of finance reports, while Another example of positive change
simultaneously compressing the time within ADP’s finance organization
it takes to complete projects, is how is in the amount of time spent on
the U.S. and India teams collaborate. standard FP&A functions. Finance
ADP is able to use differing time zones used to forecast annual revenues
as a strategic advantage, whereby on a monthly basis in very granular
the US finance team is able to work detail. Today, finance has simplified
through an analytical process during the this process and only generates
workday in the US and then hand it off detailed revenue forecasts at the end
to India for virtually around-the-clock of each quarter, when management
attention until a project is completed. really needs this information.
Another benefit ADP has experienced “We basically abolished two months of
from faster analytics is better decision forecasting each quarter so the finance
support for product teams that are organization could free itself to focus
focused on innovation. In late 2013, on more meaningful scenario-based,
ADP announced its intention to open data-driven, and more strategic work,”
the company’s second Innovation says Siegmund. “We’re moving away
Lab, in Manhattan. Both house from purely transactional elements of
engineers, anthropologists and data finance, evolving into a true business
scientists, who look for new ways partner that helps drive ADP’s
to deliver intelligent solutions to strategic and operational results.”
ADP clients through technologies
such as search, mobile and social. Overall, the evolution of the finance
function at ADP has made the company
“The Labs’ pace of innovation—and more nimble, provides deeper
emphasis on getting new technologies financial insight to internal partners
to market quickly—required finance and is supporting a more innovative
to change its style to become more and fast-paced company culture.
entrepreneurial,” says Siegmund.
“Some of the traditional review and
approval processes related to technology
investments were simply too slow.
08 Getting it right with growth: How to be a great CFO in the new growth economy
Internally, the same demand applies. CFOs can create those analytical models
As business gets more complex and and mitigate somewhat the inherent
companies offer a wider array of uncertainty of future performance.
products and services, the goal for
finance should be to synthesize all of Taking the lead on service
that performance information (and definition and delivery to
relevant external data) into a clear provide company perspective
story that other C-suite executives,
the board, and other stakeholders On the organizational side, new
can quickly grasp. The information models that integrate finance with
doesn’t need to be overly simplified, other functional competencies (e.g.,
but it needs to give a clear and marketing and sales, R&D, etc.) are
transparent indication of what’s giving finance greater insight into
really going on inside the company. business operations. More broadly, the
CFO is often closely involved in how
Leadership teams will need more back office functions deliver services on
in-depth, real-time data on the impact a global basis. Finance is taking the lead
of their growth strategy—what’s going in setting the bar for delivery of services
well and what’s not going well—and through shared services, outsourcing
the CFO can create that transparency. and centers of excellence, and these
Similarly, management will need to get models are increasingly being adopted
a good view of the future, extrapolating by IT and HR. The organizational
from current performance indicators impact is the ability to generate
and developing realistic scenarios efficiencies across the enterprise and
across various contingencies. Again, ensure that growth initiatives don’t
get bogged down unnecessarily.
Staffing
To support sustainable growth, finance must hire ahead of the curve,
ensuring that it has the capacity needed to meet future demands.
R&D investment
CFO is uniquely qualified to put the right principles and guidelines
around R&D investments.
Transparency
All growth strategies are now and will continue to be executed
against the backdrop of an intensive focus on transparency.
09
10 Getting it right with growth: How to be a great CFO in the new growth economy
Four paths to
growth for CFOs
There are many avenues for growth, associated risks. The traditional
both organic and inorganic. No strategies have been in widespread
single strategy is the right one for all use for many decades while the
companies. It’s a question of fit, and breakthrough strategies (digital and
fit can be a function of a company’s aspects of innovation) are a more recent
appetite for risk, its ability to invest, phenomenon, often arising from the
the speed with which it needs to technological advancements of the past
grow, its access to capital, company few years. These have enabled new
culture, economic factors, etc. The and disruptive ways to interact and
list is almost endless, and many communicate with customers, vendors,
companies will employ a combination and stakeholders in general. They all
of strategies across their business. have something in common, though:
the role of visionary CFOs in enabling
What follows is a discussion of four these strategies. The rest of the paper
common growth strategies (see will discuss PwC’s point of view on
Figure 1) and the role the CFO can how this role varies depending on the
play in supporting them within their selected growth strategy, including
organizations. Each growth strategy opportunities to realign finance,
has its benefits, shortcomings and risks and other considerations.
Digital
Innovation
Traditional
Emerging
M&A
markets
Inorganic Organic
11
1) Growth through mergers The right deal structure? Is the potential
and acquisitions partner aligned with our operations?
Creating and analyzing better Similarly, CFOs are now tasked with
models for mergers modeling various scenarios in order
to help the executive team consider
In mergers & acquisitions, the CFO has
likely outcomes. To a great degree, this
long held a mandate for conducting
can be enabled by advanced analytics.
due diligence on the array of potential
Companies that build out their data and
targets (this typically includes looking at
analytics capabilities are better equipped
operations and finance, as well as IT and
to “see around the corner.” They can
other back-office functions) along with
quantify opportunities more accurately,
vetting individual candidates on the
and develop a more realistic range of
short list, and kicking the tires to make
potential scenarios, giving the executive
sure their financials and operations
team greater confidence in a particular
are sound. As the deal moves through
plan moving forward. The CFO can
subsequent steps, the CFO is directly
oversee this analytics build out, a point
involved to ensure the right alignment.
that will be discussed in more detail
Increasingly however, CFOs are being
in “Growth through digital” below.
called on to deliver insight into other
parts of the deal-making process. Analyzing public data
For example, CFOs are now better
more accurately
equipped to assess the degree of risk in Given that there is now far more
a particular deal. Is this the right target? public data available regarding the
competition, companies that know how
to access that data and make sense of
it will give themselves an edge in the
vetting and due diligence processes
12 Getting it right with growth: How to be a great CFO in the new growth economy
Forging finance capabilities to the company (i.e., the CFO) tailor the
right message and get it out quickly,
support more frequent M&A
before any misperceptions or confusion
Serial acquirers become highly proficient regarding the deal can set in. “This is
at doing deals and have more advanced more important today than in the past,”
finance capabilities tied to delivering the says Apanaschik. “New technologies and
necessary services both to support M&A operating models have led to a blurring
and to realize the return on acquisitions. of the lines that divide one industry
They analyze and measure all aspects from another, and deals between non-
of the finance function related to M&A traditional partners are becoming more
and are highly focused on excellence common. That puts a greater emphasis
in integration and the corresponding on understanding the financials behind
process improvement. Key to evolving the deal strategy and communicating
this capability is the use of an M&A this effectively to Wall Street.”
playbook to support the implementation
of a disciplined approach through the
deal continuum including strategy
validation, assessment of options,
evaluation of deals, negotiation & close, The CFO’s challenge is to root out individual
integration, and value captured.
biases, look at all the angles, and continually
Communicating with Wall Street
ask whether the deal is in the best interests
For public companies, communicating
the deal’s strategic objectives with
of the company long-term.
outside investors can have a significant
impact on the overall deal outcome
and earnings per share. In some cases,
the simple combination of revenue
may be the sole objective. But in
more complex deals, where there are
substantial synergies to unlock, and
new product offerings may not be
immediately apparent, it’s critical that
13
Tax strategy: Getting it right
during growth
14 Getting it right with growth: How to be a great CFO in the new growth economy
For the CFO, growth through Lastly, the IRS has recently expanded its Organization for Economic Cooperation
emerging markets requires an information reporting requirements and and Development’s (OECD) base
examination of the multinational increased its collaboration with foreign erosion and profit-sharing (BEPS)
corporation’s tax attributes, the tax authorities to improve voluntary project includes a focus on the global
location of its taxable profits compliance and tax collection. This tax impact of IP and the need for reform
and capital, an analysis of new activity has created new challenges in order to stem declining government
intercompany transactions that result for multinational corporations, tax bases. Moreover, many tax rules
from operational changes, and a many of whom lack an operational are outdated because technology
means to address new customs and structure that provides for the efficient changes quickly, making it difficult to
duty liabilities due to changes in management and implementation apply the rules to new developments.
product flows, among other issues. of new information reporting and
withholding requirements. Companies CFOs at highly innovative companies
For companies that revamp their supply that are not compliant with US and need to execute a robust analysis
chain, CFOs will need to consider the global information reporting and of these issues and document
location of manufacturing and plant withholding rules face a variety of tax the appropriate transfer price for
facilities (e.g., moving them to Africa implications and significant exposure. intercompany transactions involving IP,
or Asia) and whether joint ventures As a result, multinational CFOs must selecting a business model that yields
with local businesses may enable a take a proactive approach that reduces tax savings and operational efficiencies
more efficient supply chain from a cost cost and exposure, and drives additional (such as choosing which legal entity
and resource consumption perspective. value for their organizations. should own the resulting IP). They
Any relocation or restructuring should also track current and future
involving the supply chain triggers a research and investment tax credits and
host of corporate income and indirect Innovation incentives, and analyze how the indirect
tax issues that can occur at each stage taxes apply to licensing transactions,
of implementation. Creating the overall Whenever a company launches a new along with satisfying registration and
plan must take into account taxes product or makes substantial design filing requirements.
incurred during the transition, as well changes that impact the business
as under the revamped supply chain. model or delivery of products/services,
there are tax planning and compliance
Similarly, the shift of economic implications. For example, technological Michael J. Shehab is the US leader
power megatrend will likely cause a breakthroughs will likely cause the of the Tax Reporting & Strategy
heightened competition for talent. creation of intellectual property (IP). practice working with organizations to
Businesses will need to expand The ownership and licensing of such redesign, redefine, and redeploy their
the number of employees crossing IP across borders can have significant tax departments. He is a recognized
borders to get the right talent in the tax consequences, depending upon the industry leader in helping clients
right location, triggering a host of tax rates and rules applicable to the analyze and improve the ways they
corporate and individual-level tax licensor and licensee. Also, investments use their people, processes, data,
issues and planning opportunities. in research and development potentially and technology to make their tax
While global tax compliance may be could qualify for the favorable research operations more effective and efficient.
the focus, global payroll compliance tax credit or similar incentives.
and foreign asset reporting are Office: +1 (313) 394 6183 |
also key considerations when Another issue is the evolving Mobile: +1 (313) 212 2245
talent moves across borders. regulatory landscape. For example, the Email: [email protected]
15
Smoothing post-merger integration Knowing when to walk away
from a bad deal
Clearly, CFOs are now driving more
aspects of post-merger integration— Finally, the CFO has a critical role to
often across people, process, and play during the deal process in knowing
technology—to ensure that a deal when the deal may no longer make
achieves its target objectives and sense for the company. Deals sometimes
captures all projected synergies. Such take on a momentum of their own,
metrics are often difficult to track, since frequently because there are multiple
they don’t appear anywhere in a general participants with individual agendas and
ledger—either in the form of new biases. For example, other executives
revenue or direct cost savings resulting in the C-suite may want to burnish
from the deal. Quantifying these gains their reputation as a company builder.
entails assembling an off-line model Operational unit heads may want to
that lays out specific cost reduction give themselves greater responsibilities
steps and cost drivers. The task falls to under the new structure. Advisors and
finance to provide oversight and validate investment bankers may have a purely
that the model is as comprehensive financial motive: their commission.
and detailed as possible, to make
sure that the proposed steps actually And the economic principle of sunk
happen, and to hold people accountable costs becomes a factor as well. Once
in situations when they don’t. large amounts of transaction costs are
already spent, some companies may feel
they have no choice but to move ahead.
16 Getting it right with growth: How to be a great CFO in the new growth economy
If companies are looking at the same familiar
markets as everyone else, they may not be
looking widely enough, leading them to miss
true growth potential.
17
81% of US CEOs say that technological
18 Getting it right with growth: How to be a great CFO in the new growth economy
CFOs need to add insight, objectivity
and business judgment to help their
companies enable and execute a digital
growth strategy. Specifically, CFOs
are in a unique position to provide the
following value to their organizations:
19
for many finance organizations, but as from digitally enabled competitors),
with deals, innovation, and emerging yet deciding how best to move forward
markets, CFOs can and should be requires a careful analysis. Digital
directly involved in digital initiatives. evolves faster than other disruptive
shifts, requiring that companies
Deciding if the company has determine the “right” level of digital—
invested enough in digital the optimal allocation of R&D and IT
At a strategic level, CFOs need to help investments, management attention,
determine whether the company is process re-engineering and capital to
leveraging digital technology and ensure that the company is pursuing
business models to a sufficient degree. new opportunities prudently without
While the impact will vary among overcommitting. As in other areas,
organizations and industries, such this involves an analysis of risk. Can
technologies can have a transformative the organization afford to pursue a
effect on customer intimacy and specific technology? Or more to the
business models. Most companies point, can it afford not to? Clinging
recognize the growth opportunity to the status quo often introduces
surrounding digital (as well as the threat real financial risks. These are thorny
challenges, and the CFO is the executive
best positioned to address them.
Ensuring the
company’s cybersecurity
Any digital initiative has the potential
to introduce new vulnerabilities to
the organization. Working with the
Chief Information Officer and Chief
Sales Officer, the CFO needs to help
determine the right cybersecurity
posture to ensure that the company is
reaching for new opportunities without
leaving itself exposed to unnecessary
risk. This is a delicate balance—it’s
easy to say no to all digital growth
In typical firms, nearly twice as efforts in the name of cybersecurity,
yet this isn’t a realistic position for
much time is spent on data gathering, most organizations. In fact, this is often
trading cybersecurity risk for a larger
compared to the time spent on analysis.
20 Getting it right with growth: How to be a great CFO in the new growth economy
ARRIS: Two steps ahead
21
media space are extensions of existing However, the company’s not done yet. A
technology. In growth through deals, by critical factor was ensuring that the deal
contrast, the goal is to leapfrog forward didn’t overload ARRIS, and thus prevent
in either technology, geographic reach, it from seeking new deals in the future.
or both. For example, after a series of “Once you’ve absorbed the deal, you
modest deals dating back to 2007, ARRIS want the capital structure to evolve so
announced a major acquisition in 2012 that you’re still in a place where you can
to buy Motorola Home, a maker of set- continue to execute on M&A—and other
top boxes that Motorola had actually things as well,” Potts says. In meeting
sold to Google. It was a transformative with analysts and investors lately, he
deal. At the time, ARRIS had about hears a common refrain: What’s next?
$1.5 billion in revenue, and Motorola
Home was about three times that Regardless of how ARRIS continues its
size. “We went from 1,500 employees growth trajectory, Potts will be at the
to 6,500 employees,” Potts says. table during strategic deliberations. “To
me, CFOs are successful when they’re
ARRIS financed the deal through debt— viewed by the leadership as a valued
thanks to favorable interest rates—but partner, not just providing back-office
there were some wrinkles to sort through. support. CFOs need to be formulating
Google wanted to retain a slice of equity strategy, thinking through the bigger
in the new venture, and one of ARRIS’s decisions, and then going off and
customers did as well, requiring that getting those decisions implemented.”
Potts sort through all the ramifications
of those terms. Integrating the two
businesses—one essentially a carve-out
from Google—was a major challenge
as well, particularly with respect to
financial processes, which needed to
be compliant with filing requirements
within 12 months of the close. Since
the deal was announced in December
2012, ARRIS’s stock price has roughly
doubled, from $15 to $30 as of Q3 2014.
22 Getting it right with growth: How to be a great CFO in the new growth economy
financial risk—the lost opportunity always sound? Is this attitude based on
cost associated with clinging to older, bias or objective information? The CFO
non-competitive products and services needs to be able to spot and eliminate
in an increasingly digital world. biases by asking the right questions
and determining the relative risks
It’s also easy to go to the other and benefits among potential digital
extreme and spend unnecessary partners. Companies need to apply the
amounts of capital trying to fortify concept of diversity—in geography,
the organization’s cyber defenses and in talent, and in mindset—to avoid
prevent all breaches. The right posture is letting outdated traditions, protocols,
somewhere in the middle, and the CFO or attitudes leave them blind to a new
is the executive tasked with determining development. This applies to all areas of
the right balance of risk and return using the business and to all growth agendas.
objective data and analytical models.
Bottom line for CFOs
Keeping an open mind
and eliminating bias Net, net—every industry must now
think more like a technology company,
Technology evolves quickly, and the constantly figuring out how to stay
universe of outside vendors and partners ahead of existing competitors or
changes constantly. For example, a tiny new entrants against a backdrop of
cybersecurity startup with little brand constant change and disruption. This
cachet or track record could have the means not only providing the digital
best technology to address a particular channels and services customers have
problem, yet many organizations may come to expect, but also improving
be hesitant to give it a look. Instead, those services, lowering their price and
they may want a familiar, “known” bringing them to market in innovative
brand—not realizing that its solution ways that leverage the transformative
is growing obsolete. Is this approach capabilities of digital technology.
23
4) Growth through Once a company selects innovation
innovation as a growth strategy, the CFO should
assess opportunities for innovation
Being the CFO who asks, what through a strictly financial lens, to
is the cost of doing nothing? identify the revenue stream and the
Most companies understand that potential business opportunity. This
innovation is an imperative. But what is critical, given that many other
does that mean, exactly? Without participants in the innovation process—
the proper guidelines and analysis, particularly engineering and product
companies can end up chasing development teams—often focus
innovation for its own sake, or because more on functionality and design
they see competitors doing it. A better rather than the rubber-meets-the-road
approach is for the CFO to ask some issues of distribution, sales, and cash
insightful questions regarding the flow. The answers to these questions
organization and the competitive could mean the difference between a
landscape. Specifically, what is the cost profitable venture and a money-loser.
of doing nothing? How quickly would
the company’s market share drop and
Implementing financial
what would the competitive situation
discipline around investments
look like in 12 months if it didn’t By definition, digital and innovation
innovate? Companies—and specifically as growth strategies often involve trial
CFOs—should be asking this question and error, and they can frequently be
all the time because the answer gives an expensive. New projects invariably
indication of how much the company fail—often multiple times—before
should be focusing on innovation. they succeed. From a cost perspective,
this can seem like wasted capital, and
many organizations seek to cut costs
by scaling back on R&D or process
improvement or taking an overly
simplistic view of the relationship
between investment and results. In
other cases, organizations try to “throw
money at the problem,” believing that
the next product or initiative will be
the home run that recoups all prior
costs. Neither extreme is right.
24 Getting it right with growth: How to be a great CFO in the new growth economy
Organizations that plan to grow through innovation
should have a strong financial model in place for
how they will fund and govern the R&D or process
innovation process.
25
Euro-Pro: A multipronged
approach to growth
When CFO Brian Lagarto joined Euro- Euro-Pro has also relied in part on an
Pro Operating LLC, the creator of the international expansion: it now does
Just five years later,
Shark® and Ninja® brands, in February business in more than 30 countries,
Euro-Pro is on track 2009, the company was on the verge growing that component of its
of a major growth spurt. At that time, business from $14 million in sales to
to post more than
Euro-Pro, a private company based in approximately $100 million. Euro-Pro
$1.5 billion in annual Newton, Massachusetts, had about $350 has also built out its digital distribution
million in annual revenue, and a single channel. While the company still has
revenue, with a diverse
product—the original steam mop—that a strong foundation of sales through
lineup of products. made up the bulk of its sales and profits. big-box retailers and direct sales
However, the executive team (including through infomercials, Euro-Pro recently
Notably, that growth
CEO Mark Rosenzweig, President increased its focus on e-commerce.
has all come through Mark Barrocas and Lagarto) knew that
they could not rely on just their steam That kind of speed could only come
organic measures—not through established innovation
category to drive significant growth.
acquisitions—and At some point in the future, the steam expertise. In the past, Euro-Pro relied
category would mature and they needed on external partners, which were
finance has been a critical coordinated through a few internal
to invest in other categories to achieve
partner throughout. the growth targets that were planned. product development staff. Starting
in 2011, Euro-Pro slowly built up its
Just five years later, Euro-Pro is on internal R&D department, which
track to post more than $1.5 billion in today comprises 20 people. That
annual revenue, with a diverse lineup initiative was funded with capital
of products. Notably, that growth has from the steam mop—a deliberate
all come through organic measures— decision by the executive team.
not acquisitions—and finance has Maintaining an internal R&D group
been a critical partner throughout. costs far less than working with third-
party product development firms, and
Most of the company’s growth has allows for much greater coordination
come through product innovation and (particularly with a CEO who is laser-
high quality product. The leadership focused and involved in the product
team and particularly the CEO have innovation process). R&D is charged
a strong focus on developing new not only with developing new products
products (Rosenzweig actually and features, but also, critically, with
hosts all of Euro-Pro’s infomercials). innovating for efficiency and cost.
Initially, the company focused on
vacuums—a natural extension from
its successful steam mop—through the
Shark® brand. At the same time, the
company also created a new kitchen
brand, Ninja®, from scratch, shipping
its first Ninja® product less than nine
months after launching its growth
strategy. The Ninja® brand currently
operates in the small motorized
appliances category within kitchen.
26 Getting it right with growth: How to be a great CFO in the new growth economy
Growth through innovation also requires Shark® vacuums have grown from one
strong oversight from finance. Early on percent of the market to more than
in Lagarto’s tenure, the executive team 30 percent. The Ninja® line of kitchen
made the deliberate decision to reinvest products is on track to hit over $400
income from the steam mop to build million in sales for 2014. Further, Euro-
an innovation capability. Today, the Pro has been named Vendor of the
company uses product roadmaps that Year for several of the top retailers
project forward 18 to 24 months, and it in the U.S. over the last few years.
puts rigorous models into place to make
sure that new products in the pipeline In all three aspects of the company’s
hit their ROI targets. “We work with the growth strategy— product innovation,
R&D team on a week-to-week basis,” product quality and driving consumer
says Lagarto. “Based on the numbers, demand—Lagarto is a strategic partner
we’ll sit down with our CEO and with the CEO and president. That is
president and decide whether to move possible in large part because he has a
forward or to put a particular project on strong controllership team to handle
hold to focus on other opportunities.” closing the books each month. (Lagarto
reviews the results with them and is
This vetting process, he adds, has been responsible for reporting, but he is no
a learning curve for the company. “It’s longer directly involved in the process.)
basic to R&D, but it’s something we This year, his team drove a major
didn’t start thinking about until we project whereby they realigned their
brought innovation in-house. We bring process and controls. The result is a
a lot of projects to the table, but that month-end close that is now six days
means there are a lot of projects where versus 14 days just nine months ago.
we decide not to move forward. We
have to encourage the researchers and “That’s a tremendous change for
innovators, and say, ‘I know you worked this business, but it’s necessary
hard to make this project happen, but because we’re so much bigger now,
if the financial component isn’t there, and because we’re moving so much
we can’t move forward.’” It has required faster,” he says. Because the closes are
some education and communication to more accurate and take less time, he
make sure everyone knows that these is freed up to generate insights that
experiences are not failures—they are an can drive the business forward. “I’m
inevitable part of the innovation process. not the guy just keeping score and
reporting out to other executives,”
Lagarto says. “That’s not the kind of
role that I would ever be happy in.”
27
28 Getting it right with growth: How to be a great CFO in the new growth economy
5 actions for the
growth-oriented CFO
29
Mind the details: A CFO ’s reporting
and compliance tip sheet for growth
30 Getting it right with growth: How to be a great CFO in the new growth economy
Emerging markets Once the company invests in a new
system to enable process innovation and
Growth by expansion into emerging capitalizes that cost, there’s always the
markets raises considerations as well, chance that the system doesn’t deliver
primarily in the treatment of taxes and the desired improvements. Similarly, a
in the way such expansion introduces new software product that costs millions
new risks. “The rapid growth in some in R&D investment could turn out to be
emerging markets is what attracts a flop. In each instance, the company
companies,” says Paul. “Companies would need to assess the fixed asset or
need to be careful to ensure their inventory on its books for impairment.
growth doesn’t get ahead of their In the unfortunate situation when things
local controls and infrastructure.” don’t go as planned, CFOs need to be
That introduces an aspect of risk that aware of the accounting ramifications
must be assessed and disclosed. and plan for communications with
stakeholders.
Innovation
As technology evolves, innovation can
Beth Paul is the Strategic Thought Leader
change the nature of the company’s
in the National Professional Services
offering which can impact revenue
Group of PricewaterhouseCoopers LLP.
recognition and cost capitalization.
In this role, she works closely with the
This is particularly relevant given that
firm’s leadership to determine PwC’s
many businesses are seeking to sell
position on emerging trends in auditing,
add-on services for their products,
accounting and financial reporting matters.
and those services are often delivered
via digital channels over time. In
other cases, “traditional” products
themselves are transitioning to a
service or subscription model. Such
situations may change the way that
the company recognizes revenue and
capitalizes costs, and this can impact a
company’s key financial performance
measures. As a result, the CFO has to
be in the loop during discussions of
the initiative, in order to understand
any potential changes in the income
stream to be able to communicate
effectively to the investor community.
31
Figure 2: Critical Requirements for Finance to Support Growth
Emerging
Innovation Deals Digital
markets
32 Getting it right with growth: How to be a great CFO in the new growth economy
4. Spot and eliminate biases 5. Invest in analytics
A critical and growing responsibility and modeling
among finance organizations is the Just as transparency is needed to give
ability to identify bias in decision- organizations a clearer sense of what’s
making. As executive teams evaluate happening in the organization at a point
a specific market, product, or strategy, in time, analytics and modeling are
they sometimes operate with blinders needed to give organizations a more
on, unintentionally eliminating options accurate understanding of what’s likely
that could represent a better solution to happen in the future. (See Figure 2.)
to the company’s needs. Avoiding these
biases usually requires organizational Analytics and modeling software is
—maturity—companies need to be increasingly available, costs less, and
able to evaluate themselves and their requires less computational power than
competitive environment objectively. even just a few years ago. And just as
As a result, it’s often a bigger challenge importantly, the underlying algorithms
in young and fast-growing companies are becoming more accurate in being
(and those seeking to expand to able to model various scenarios.
emerging markets) which simply may For example, a company looking
not have all the information required to enter a new market can consider
to make the best decision. In all cases, what might happen if that country’s
the CFO can broaden the potential interest rate were to rise 1 percent,
universe of options by seeking to or if unemployment were to fall, or
identify and root out bias, making if certain demographic shifts were to
sure the executive team is asking accelerate or slow down. The result is a
the right questions and applying the greater ability to identify the universe
correct filter to their decisions. of potential outcomes and prepare for
both upside opportunities and downside
risks. This function is becoming so
critical that some organizations now
have a central analytics function that
can work across all business units.
This is becoming a core capability,
particularly in consumer-oriented
organizations. The CFO can oversee this.
33
To have a deeper conversation
about this subject, please contact:
PwC (www.pwc.com) provides industry-focused assurance, tax and advisory services to build public trust and
enhance value for its clients and their stakeholders. More than 155,000 people in 153 countries across our
network share their thinking, experience and solutions to develop fresh perspectives and practical advice.
© 2014 PricewaterhouseCoopers LLP, a Delaware limited liability partnership. All rights reserved. PwC refers
to the US member firm, and may sometimes refer to the PwC network. Each member firm is a separate legal
entity. Please see www.pwc.com/structure for further details. This content is for general information purposes
only, and should not be used as a substitute for consultation with professional advisors. MW-15-0073