2009 Two Pitchstone Obsidian Assemblages
2009 Two Pitchstone Obsidian Assemblages
2009 Two Pitchstone Obsidian Assemblages
NORTH AYRSHIRE
Giants Graves (Kilbride parish) Beverley Ballin Smith (GUARD)
Prehistoric settlements; lithic assemblages Torben Bjarke Ballin (Lithic Research)
NGR NS 04131 25035 In May 2009, Beverley Ballin Smith led a field trip to Arran with
students from Auchincruive Agricultural College, Ayr. In connection with a visit to the Giants
Graves chambered tomb, Glenashdale, it was noticed that a new hair-pin path to the monument
had been constructed, and that the spoils along the path included worked pitchstone. Mrs Ballin
Smith and the students from Auchincruive Agricultural College collected a number of pitchstone
artefacts, which were subsequently brought to lithics specialist Torben Bjarke Ballin for com-
ment. In response to the finds, Dr Ballin surveyed the entire length of the new path, and two
concentrations were noticed. Concentration 1 was located around the uppermost hair-pin curve,
immediately next to a small burn (the NGR given above), and Concentration two was located
approximately 75-100 m towards the east, where the path curves gently towards the Giants
Graves. Samples were collected from both sites.
Both assemblages include broad blades, suggesting Neolithic dates, but a detailed typo-
technological breakdown indicates different dates within this general chronological frame. As-
semblage 1 includes 46 pieces of pitchstone, almost equally distributed across almost aphyric
(lightly porphyritic) and more notably porphyritic pitchstone. Four pieces are burnt. A total of 42
pieces are debitage, two are cores (one single-platform core/one Levallois-like core), and two are
tools (one flake and one blade w edge-retouch). Two blanks have finely faceted platform rem-
nants, defining them as deriving from Levallois-like cores. Assemblage 2 includes 19 pieces of
pitchstone, all of which are aphyric. Three pieces are burnt. Ten pieces are debitage, seven are
cores (four platform/three bipolar), and two are tools (one double-scraper/one bifacial rough-
out).
Aphyric pitchstone from Monamore Mill and porphyritic pitchstone from Cnocan a’ Chrannchuir, near Blackwaterfoot
(photos courtesy of the Hunterian Museum, University of Glasgow).
Most likely, the aphyric pitchstone from Concentration 2 was procured from sources in
Monamore Glen, whereas the porphyritic pitchstone from Concentration 1 most likely derives
from local sources in the general Glenashdale area. The different raw material preferences, and
the differences in terms of assemblage composition, suggest that Concentration 2 may date to
the Early Neolithic period (although not the very earliest part), and Concentration 1 to the Mid-
dle or Late Neolithic period.
Note: One of the authors has since published a monograph on Arran pitchstone (Ballin 2009:
BAR British series 476), as well as an overview of Arran pitchstone outcrops (the latter is availa-
ble through Academia):
Ballin, T.B., & Faithfull, J. 2009: Gazetteer of Arran Pitchstone Sources. Presentation of exposed
pitchstone dykes and sills across the Isle of Arran, and discussion of the possible archaeolog-
ical relevance of these outcrops. Scottish Archaeological Internet Reports (SAIR) 38.
[http://www.sair.org.uk/sair38].