December 2022 A Development Monthly: Special
December 2022 A Development Monthly: Special
December 2022 A Development Monthly: Special
SPECIAL
Re-structuring Urban Galaxies
Dr Balkrishna Doshi
Focus
Central Vista Redevelopment Project
Dr Bimal Patel
Development of Historic City Centres
Ratish Nanda
Issue on Tribal India affairs. As it is the real essence of current affairs related
to government policies etc., so, civil services aspirants
I am a regular reader of Yojana. The articles in the July
and others who are preparing for competitive exams
issue were very helpful and informative. I enjoyed reading
should make use of this.
them. With useful facts and figures, every author presented
the tribe-development continuum. I am very grateful to the – Nikhil Yadav
editor for this marvelous and collectible issue. The editorial Uttar Pradesh
was also on point. I thank the whole team of Yojana for Managing Water Resources
their consistent dedication and hard work.
Both the articles ‘Water Governance’ and ‘Our Water
– Prabhat Kumar Mishra Heroes’ in the October issue gain utmost importance at a
Uttar Pradesh time when the monsoon woes this year have been causing
Promoting Indigenous Medicinal Plants ample anxiety, especially to agrarian communities. This
indicates that we have to manage our water resources with
Respected Editorial Team, I am grateful for the
professionalism since no one is aware of the water shortage
October issue on Our Ecosystem. I would like to send
during the ensuing summer. We must learn the value of
my regards to the editorial team, for publishing a
natural resources.
specific section on the North Eastern Region through
the article titled, ‘Indigenous Bio-resources of the – Susheela B. R. Ramanna
NE Region.’ While the article provided good insights Karnataka
on the medicinal plant species of the region and the Epitome of Knowledge
conservation techniques, it also reminded me of the
fact that from a very young age, I was introduced with Your monthly magazine is amazing, wonderfully
these very medicinal plants specifically mentioned in blended with authentic data and analysis because of the
the article as these plants were very much part of our way you make each topic easy-to-read and one can retain
daily consumption practices. I believe that community these for longer periods of time. Your content is full of
awareness on the importance of such medicinal plants insights and one can trace what is going on in our country
may also further the conservation process as most in general and those who are preparing for civil services,
indigenous communities use such medicinal plants. in particular, will gain heavily. Your every edition is the
It is interesting how our elders without any scientific epitome of knowledge enhancement. Thank you for such
knowledge have long known the importance of these an amazing journal.
medicinal plants and made it a part of our daily – Shubham Kumar
consumption practices. Bihar
– Lukumoni Sonowal Subscribing Yojana
New Delhi I have been reading Yojana for the past nine months.
Useful for Civil Services Aspirants Subscribing and reading Yojana was one of the best
All aspirants for every competitive exam look for decisions of my life. It has helped me to expand and
resources to tackle current affairs for which they search acquire relevant knowledge on various topics. Every
for every corner of books and resources available in the article helps create a deeper understanding of the issues
market and social platforms. But I believe selection and rather than surface-level knowledge. Thank you for being
quality of material matter a lot and it is not easy to find instrumental in my UPSC preparation.
out. But going through Yojana editorials, I say that it – Anjana R
is a must read. It is helping me a lot to cover current Kerala
When we see the map of India, we realise a unique characteristic – there is a hierarchical network
of dots of varied sizes with names of large metropolises, cities, and towns. They appear like
‘urban galaxies’ – with naturally developed scales between entities, interconnected and located
within easy reach. Further exploration suggests that these networks have their unique lifestyles,
unique pattern of habitat based on local resources, climate, and available characteristics of
land. The connections and the spread of the developments appear like a ‘biological’ growth, with
adaptation, mutation and replication after a certain growth tipping point that are essential for
sustenance and preservation. These multi-nodal conglomerates expand infinitely absorbing
smaller entities on the way and obliterating their strengths.
T
here is a great talk nowadays about sustainable overburdening the mega-cities– which will eventually get
development in Indian cities and towns. crushed under their own burden of management, complexity,
However, we need to understand this fully and affordability. Expansion means larger distances, and
and see how these goals can trigger other more time and energy to commute for living, working, or
developments without harming the region or the lifestyle. cultivating the mind and the spirit.
For me, sustainability ensures long-lasting development Expanding mega-cities today can only afford to sell
without becoming unduly centralised– similar to a biological branded and mass-produced goods to greater numbers,
order, therefore, we should consider a way that replicates and which needs larger centralised production centres, industrial
triggers the creation of another similar or mutated unit. For complexes, the greater network of transport facilities, large
example, an elephant or a human being, or
even an ant, after maturity, does not grow
beyond its ‘ultimate’ size– if it does, it
automatically gets destroyed, succumbing
to external pressures by internal failure. I
am reminded of the large dinosaurs of the
Jurassic Age.
Likewise, we need to review our
present mega-cities and metropolises.
By improving their infrastructure, we
will surely improve their functioning, but
we may not upgrade the quality of life.
Besides, due to our development focus of
concentrating around one place/city, all the
institutions and employment opportunities,
we are denuding the smaller towns in
the region of their small-scale crafts and
Wide panoramic view of Mumbai city
industries, and encouraging migration and
The author is the first Indian architect who was awarded the Pritzker Prize, along with the Padma Bhushan, the Padma Shri, and other
international accolades. In a long and illustrious career spanning over seven decades, Dr Doshi has completed more than 100 projects,
many of which are iconic public institutions that include IIM Bangalore, IIM Udaipur, the National Institute of Fashion Technology,
New Delhi, the Tagore Memorial Hall in Ahmedabad, the IFFCO Township of Kalol, and Amdavad di Gufa. Email: [email protected]
multi-storeyed complexes on prime lands, relying on larger local resources, climate, and availability characteristics
banking systems with higher interest rates, finally resulting of the land. Sharing these common renewable resources,
in our colossal agglomerations like Delhi, Mumbai, Kolkata, (and here I must include human energies), and sustaining
Bengaluru that are struggling with their size and yet think within its available means, each place has its unique quiet
that they have to rely on it, and depend overly on exhaustible lifestyle, development of agriculture, different crafts, and
resources– oil, water, land, human energies that keep getting cultural values. This lent a close-knit character and easy
expensive while the quality of life keeps dropping. Needless communication. The use of time and energy and family life
to say, as against ‘small is beautiful’ we are then talking of was linked to the 24-hour cycle and the seasons. Smaller
‘bigger is better’, and only looking towards the West who towns developed organically and over time extended their
have traversed this path, for their approval and funding. homes, created shops, schools, and public places to become
When we see the map of India, we realise a unique smaller towns, and act as nerve centres.
characteristic – there is a hierarchical network of dots of On studying closely, there are further important
varied sizes with names of large metropolises, cities, and lessons for our planning today. Planning is not merely
towns. They appear like ‘urban galaxies’ – with naturally physical growth, but also spiritual and cultural growth, all
developed scales between entities, hinged on the availability of resources.
interconnected and located within easy Visiting several towns and cities in
reach. There are necessarily empty Planning is not merely physical different parts of India, one notices
tracts between entities, and then we see growth, but also spiritual and the unique and regionally-connected
shorter movements linked by locally- cultural growth, all hinged on lifestyle and virtuous skills of the local
developed transport systems, with many the availability of resources. population. They could only do this
pedestrians, bicycles, animal carts, and by decentralisation and by allowing
Visiting several towns and
few accessible points to heavy motorised self-discovery for the human energy to
cities in different parts of find particular avenues of exploration
traffic. I would call it organically
India, one notices the unique within the regional context of resources
developed interdependent habitats.
and regionally-connected and values. Such amalgamation also
Further exploration suggests that lifestyle and virtuous skills of expressed unity amidst diversity as if
these networks had their unique lifestyles, to weave the region holistically. The
and unique patterns of habitat based on
the local population.
connections and the spread of the
Central Vista is a national icon for India. Located at the heart of New Delhi, the three km stretch
between Rashtrapati Bhavan and India Gate is the administrative centre of the country’s Union
Government, the venue for India’s national events, a precious civic garden, and a popular destination
for the residents of Delhi and tourists. This piece reflects on the vision and the experiences on the
ground while working on this architectural Project of national importance.
A
s a part of our history as a nation, Central India Gate became a national monument, the lawns flanking
Vista was designed by the British architects the processional axis became public gardens, and the North
Edwin Lutyens and Herbert Baker as the and South Blocks that symbolised the might of colonial
seat for the British Raj and adopted by rule over India at the time of their construction became
independent India as our own on 15 August 1947. Central the offices of the Indian government. The contemporary
Vista is a symbol of our victory over British imperialism. vibrance of Central Vista and the historic significance
The Indian Constitution was written here, we adopted that it holds make it a humbling and exciting project for
the imperial Council House as the Parliament of India, me as an architect. I would like to take this opportunity
Viceroy’s House was adopted as Rashtrapati Bhavan, to talk about our work, the challenges that we face, and
The author is currently working on the Central Vista Redevelopment Project and is the President & Acting Director, CEPT University,
Ahmedabad. As an architect, urban designer, urban planner, and academic for over 30 years, he has crisscrossed disciplinary, professional,
and institutional boundaries to explore how architecture, urban design, and urban planning can enrich the lives of people in Indian cities.
Email: [email protected]
building and we used 3D printing technology to create this intention, soon after the project was awarded to us,
many options while developing and analysing the section. I travelled extensively– giving presentations to fellow
Sinking the well down was deemed the most feasible architects, academics, landscape designers, engineers, etc.,
solution and the same was incorporated into the design. and seeking their opinions. I also interacted with the press
and gave talks at conclaves and conventions to understand
Engaging Experts
what the people are saying about the project and what their
A project of the scale and complexity of Central Vista queries and concerns are. While we were constantly talking
can be successful only if a large team of professionals to the press and to the people– responding to queries and
works on it in proficient cooperation. Along with this, putting information out– we were also confident that
expert knowledge is also important for such a project. once the people see the project for themselves and use
While it is quite routine for architects to work with other the facilities that we designed, most of their queries will
experts such as structural engineers and the like, for be resolved. In the week following the inauguration of
Central Vista, however, expert knowledge in a variety Kartavya Path, that is exactly what we saw happening.
of disciplines becomes very crucial. Therefore, we are When people saw what we had achieved at the avenue,
working with more than sixty consultants and advisors on the fears of encroachment of public space and destruction
the project. For example, the scale of the project and the of lawns disappeared. Kartavya Path’s success and the
vast public space implied that we work with a signage and people’s positive reception of the space is the proof that if
way-finding consultant. We also have an archives expert we give people the right information and facts, and if we
to work on the National Archives and other buildings that explain our projects with reason and respect, people can be
need such services. In order to design efficient parking, we brought together behind large-scale public projects.
are working with a parking expert. For the lawns and their
Working with Timelines
flora, we are working with a horticulture expert and a tree
surveyor along with landscape designers. We also have a Design is an iterative process and as architects, we
stonework advisor to make sure that we do justice to the always wish for more time to design. Sometimes, however,
details and the cladding. Working with such a diverse array as in the case of Central Vista, the timeline of the project
of disciplinary and technical experts, our role, as architects is a part of the challenge of design and coordination. A
of the project, is to bring their expert knowledge and team of dedicated professionals and strategies of design
incorporate it into our design. management have made it possible for
Kartavya Path’s success and us to work at an astronomical pace. One
Engaging the People
the people’s positive reception of the strategies that we adopted was
Central Vista is a project of national to stack various stages of the design
importance. It is a public project being of the space is the proof that
process and compress the overall
undertaken by the Government. It is, if we give people the right timeline. In an architect’s office, every
therefore, imperative that a project of information and facts, and if we design begins with a concept stage. This
this nature generates a spirited debate. explain our projects with reason is followed by presentation drawings,
I believe that as architects, we have a and respect, people can be schematic drawings, all the way up
responsibility to explain our public
brought together behind large- to the drawings that are finally issued
projects to the people, just like we for construction. But while working
explain our projects to our clients. With scale public projects.
on Central Vista Project, we worked
Kartavya Path
‘Kartavya Path’ symbolises a shift from the erstwhile Rajpath being an icon of power
to being an example of public ownership and empowerment.
O
ver the years, Rajpath and adjoining areas of water features, and haphazard parking. Also, a need
Central Vista Avenue had been witnessing was felt to organise the Republic Day parade and
pressure of increasing traffic of visitors, other National events less disruptively with minimal
putting stress on its infrastructure. It lacked restrictions on public movement. The redevelopment
basic amenities like public toilets, drinking water, has been done bearing these concerns in mind while
street furniture, and adequate parking space. Further, ensuring the integrity and continuity of architectural
there was inadequate signage, poor maintenance of character.
I
ndia boasts of several millennia of built heritage and living culture
represented in the traditional architectural crafts. In the 21st
century, it may now be time to reflect on a truly Indian approach
India’s monuments
to conservation, one that allows leveraging our historical assets to
are irreplaceable and improve socio-economic conditions of residents of our historic cities.
significant asset for The residents of our numerous historic city centres can benefit from greater
the nation and its integration of preservation and conservation efforts with public policies and
schemes for development measures. To demonstrate such an approach, the Aga
people with associated Khan Trust for Culture in partnership with the Archaeological Survey of India,
emotional, religious, Central Public Works Department and the Municipal Corporation of Delhi
economical, historic, have undertaken a 15-year urban renewal project at the Humayun’s Tomb–
Nizamuddin area in Delhi. Here, conservation efforts have incorporated local
architectural, and area development through employment generation, boosting local crafts and
archaeological values arts, building of infrastructure, environmental conservation, and landscaping.
amongst others. Their The Archaeological Survey of India is taking several steps to ensure long
term, sustainable preservation of our nation’s heritage in a manner that is based
conservation efforts
on increased awareness amongst the public of the significance of our heritage
require craftsmen and increased involvement of civil society in the preservation effort. Over the
using traditional last two decades there has been increased awareness of the value of the urban
setting of our sites in ensuring that the historic character is retained. This led
materials, tools, and to guidelines issued in 1992 and the formation of the National Monument
building techniques Authority, mandated to create guidelines for new buildings in the setting of each
and can also become one of nation’s protected monuments. However, rather than be prohibitive, the
guidelines should stress on improvement measures and incentives that enable
a significant employer. improving of the historic urban environment as well improvement of the quality
Unlike the West, we of life for local residents.
in India are fortunate
that our craft traditions
have survived to the
present times, and it
is recommended an
emphasis on a
craft-based approach
to conservation as
well as modern public
buildings.
Conservation efforts have incorporated local area development through employment generation,
boosting local crafts and arts, building of infrastructure, environmental conservation, and landscaping.
The author is Conservation Architect & CEO, Aga Khan Trust for Culture. Email: [email protected]
In 1997, on the occasion of the 50th anniversary of Similar treatment was meted out to many of India’s
India’s independence, the garden restoration of Humayun’s monuments where well-meaning past repairs were
Tomb– a designated World Heritage Site was initiated. After carried out using inappropriate modern materials not only
the project was completed in 2003, within a few months, compromised the original design intention but also set in
after the restoration of the Mughal Garden and flowing water, a process of accelerated decay. At Humayun’s Tomb, the
it led to a 1000% increase in visitor numbers to Humayun’s Conservation Plan prepared and agreed at the onset with
Tomb. Following the success of the garden restoration, the the Archaeological Survey of India, established the intent of
Aga Khan Trust for Culture (AKTC) was asked, by the the AKTC conservation initiative to remove inappropriate
Government of India, to undertake further work in India past repairs and replace these with authentic repairs
and it was agreed that AKTC would build up on the garden using traditional materials used with traditional building
restoration to undertake a large urban renewal project that techniques by master craftsmen.
would include conservation of several monuments coupled It is well established that using traditional building
with major initiatives in socio-economic development materials– stone, earth, bamboo, timber, brick– our
focused on the residential communities of the adjoining forefathers built splendid structures, from modest residences
Hazrat Nizamuddin Basti as well as landscaping over 200 in wonderful cities to grand palaces, monasteries, temples,
acres of a designated district park with a focus on ecological tombs, stupas, amongst others. For anyone who bothers to
restoration. compare buildings built only a few decades ago to what
Building archaeology of the Humayun’s Tomb World is mushrooming in Indian cities today, it is not easy to
Heritage Site, a precursor to the more famed Taj Mahal, understand how our design and craft capabilities were lost
revealed that the building had suffered within a few years of materials such as
over a century of inappropriate The Archaeological Survey of cement, steel, and glass becoming easily
conservation work. A million kilos of available. In the shift from the traditional
India is taking several steps to
concrete was required to be removed to the ‘cheap’ modern, we have lost
ensure long term, sustainable architectural craft skills that had the
from the roof– laid here in the 20 th
century to prevent rainwater ingress; preservation of our nation’s capability of creating millions of man-
over 200,000 square feet of cement heritage in a manner that is based days of employment while ensuring that
plaster was similarly required to be on increased awareness amongst our cities had both a unique identity as
removed and replaced with traditional the public of the significance well as a higher quality of life.
lime plaster. Original doors had been of our heritage and increased Conservation effort requires
removed for firewood in the 20th century involvement of civil society in the craftsmen using traditional materials,
and the remnant tilework on the interiors tools and building techniques and can
preservation effort.
removed and replaced with plain plaster. also become a significant employer.
The Big Temple of Thanjavur (Tanjore) is a stunning monument that speaks volumes about the
architectural mastery of the Chola era. This Shiva temple is home to one of the largest Shiva
Lingas of the country. A majestic Nandi (bull) stands guard over the temple. This is the second
largest Nandi in India and is carved out of a single stone. The temple is recognised as a part of
the UNESCO World Heritage Sites. Everything about this temple is big, majestic. No wonder it is
referred as Brihadeeshwara or The Big Temple.
T
he ancient city of Thanjavur (Tanjore) is the cultural capital of the Kaveri delta region. The city and its
cultural legacy are the end product of three vibrant kingdoms that have ruled this part of Tamil Nadu over the
past millennium– the Cholas, the Vijayanagar, and the Maratta kings. Of these three, the Cholas take credit for
identifying the town as a potential political capital when it was captured by Vijayalaya Cholas early in the 9th
century. From then on, his successors were busy expanding the monarch’s boundary in all possible directions. Rajaraja-I,
who was engaged in several military expeditions, should have been inspired by the fine temple architecture patronised by
the Pallavas and other predecessors. His ancestors, who have been devout Saivites have contributed to the development of
many popular temples of Siva, and should have also inspired him. So, it is only natural for Rajaraja-I to take upon himself
this mammoth task of constructing what probably should have been the grandest humble offering to Siva.
The temple complex measuring about 244 metres on the east-west and 122 metres north-south is placed inside what is
referred to as Sivagangai little fort. This fortification is an addition taken over during the renovation by Sevappa Nayaka
around 17th century. There is also a moat running around this fortification which we cross as we enter the temple complex.
A well-decorated arched entranceway built during Maratta period welcomes us with various deities fixed as stucco images.
As we pass the Maratta entrance, we are welcomed by a classic Rajaraja period gopuram named as Keralanthakakan
Thiruvasal measuring 29.25 metres X 17.4 metres.
This 5-tiered gopuram has a cellular ambulatory
on either side. Sixty metres from here is the second
gopuram called as Rajarajan Thiruvasal. On the
eastern side of this gopuram are massive monolithic
dwarapalakkas or door guardians. Also, the stone
base of this gopuram has bas-relief panels depicting
episodes from puranas. On entering this gopuram the
visitor is treated with an aesthetically pleasing grand
panorama of the Sri Vimanam and the sub-shrines. All
around the circumference of the compound wall, two-
storeyed cloistered halls had been constructed to be
used as multipurpose space. There are sub-shrines built
in between these cloistered halls housing shrines for
the ashtadikpalaka (deities guarding the 8 directions),
Ganesha, and the temple yagasalai.
The author is an architect who is an expert on temple architecture and is on several committees constituted by the central and state
government on temple conservation. Email: [email protected]
Architectural Grandeur
The sanctum sanctorum is approached by a series of mandapams from the eastern side. The mukha mandapam is a
later-time addition and it now serves as the portico for visitors. It is followed by a grand maha mandapam, a beautifully
executed cloistered hall with rows of tall columns. The walk across this hall is a humbling experience in itself. Next, we
enter the ardha mandapa, a relatively smaller space with tall columns again. The access to the first floor happens from
this mandapam. The antarala is accessed from a fleet of stairs on the north and south sides. This is where devotees stand
to offer their worship in front of Sri Rajarjeshwaram Udaiya Paramaswami, as the deity was called by Rajaraja himself.
Nandhi Pavilion
An equally interesting feature of the temple is the huge monolithic Nandi, the sacred bull, in front of the main shrine.
The pavilion on which the Nandi sits is by itself a later-period addition. The monolithic nandi from the Nayaka period was
brought in to replace the old nandi installed by Rajaraja. The mandapam was also constructed by them and the ceiling of
this mandapam was painted with frescos carrying European influences. This case of the changed nandi, is a lesser-known
fact for many people who visit the shrine. Well, what happened to the Chola nandi? Thankfully, he was placed in the south
side thirumaligaipathi, or the cloistered hall running around the compound wall. We can still stop to take a close-up look
at him near the modern shrine built for Varahi inside the temple.
Arts and Aesthetics
The temple is a grand galore that depicts the seasoned sense of aesthetics and planning that the land and its people had
acquired a millennium back. The outwall of the sanctum sanctorum houses various deities, as prescribed in the agamas. The niches
on the wall are placed in a frequency and ornamented with makaratorana. Ganesha, Brahma, Vishnu, Lakshmi, Saraswathi, and
Durga are some of the deities housed in their respective directions. A series of different forms of Siva are installed in the niches
and the forms are those that have been mentioned in the agamas and sung about in the sacred thevaram texts. The forms of Siva
include Nataraja, Lingodhbawa, Gangadhara, Ardhanareeshwara, Kala Samhara, Harihara, to name a few.
This arrangement continues to the first floor also and the niches there house Siva as Tripurantaka and Vidhyeshwaras. Each
of the deities enshrined in the niche has their attendants and devotees also represented on either side of the niche.
Rajarajeshwaram, as the temple was called by Rajaraja was treated as a lifetime mission of a single man that was realised by
the combined hard work of several lakhs. The dream to commission a mammoth offering to the almighty, without compromising
on traditions has been achieved a millennium back and the concept of temples serving as the central fulcrum of society has been
tested and established. The number of different engineering challenges that Rajaraja has taken up in the construction of this
temple seems deliberate, trying to prove a point. The laying of shallow trench foundations and aiming at a scale that was never
tried before shows the depth to which detailed studies have been done by structural experts.
Filling the structure with earth and covering it as it was being built is the theory that seems convincing for this scale and
size, else mobility to the top-most portions would have been practically impossible by scaffolding support. So, as the layers were
built, they were also filled and covered with earth, thereby forming a ramp that could help the resources reach successive levels.
As the project was completed, the soil was excavated to reveal the grand structure in its full glory. It is certainly an emblem of
pride to us.
Image Courtesy: Vijay Bhat
Brutalist Architecture was a child of a line of thought that, as per its own interpretation, wished to
strip buildings of their unnecessary intricacies, embellishments, superfluous decorations, cover-ups
with the employment of multifarious concealing materials and finishes that hide the core structure
and basic character of it. This is accepted as a specific offshoot of modern architecture. The word
Brutalism doesn’t really come from its harsh aesthetics, but actually from the very material it is made
up of, i.e., the predominant use of reinforced and plain concrete. Béton brut is basically a French
term that means “gross cement” or “raw concrete” and this term is occasionally used to describe the
characteristic looks identifiable as Brutalist Architecture.
I
n contrast with classical Architecture and that hide the core structure and basic character of
its romantic continuity, some bold and it. Started around 1950, this bold new movement
contrasting modernistic trends gradually proclaimed and practised Architecture as muscular,
emerged and ramified into certain sub-trends, simple, undecorated, almost intimidating in its stark and
of which Brutalist Architecture is a prominent player. imposing presence. Brutalist architecture is a trend that
This modern trend germinated not only because of the appeared in Britain, while the society was going through
fresh philosophy propelled by an escape velocity from the post-war reconstruction process. Brutalist buildings
the stale continuum, nor singularly by are marked by a sort of minimalist
any sheer novel artistic urge, neither yet voluminous construction that
as a mere reflection of the remarkable deliberately displays the bare building
social changes, but also due to and materials and structural elements
supported by some new materials and over deceptive manipulations of
new construction techniques. Social decorative design. Some reputed
changes instigated the new style journals called Brutalism as technical-
and technical innovations made it musician architecture, menacing and
possible. stark. Brutalist buildings were and still
are perceived as difficult to maintain
Identification
and demolish. In general, Brutalism in
Trying to grasp in a rather Architecture is accepted as a specific
simple manner, Brutalist Architecture offshoot of modern architecture. The
can be identified by some specific word Brutalism doesn’t really come
markers. Brutalist Architecture was from its harsh aesthetics, but actually
a child of a line of thought that, as from the very material it is made up of,
per its own interpretation, wished to i.e., the predominant use of reinforced
strip buildings of their unnecessary and plain concrete. Béton brut is
intricacies, embellishments, basically a French term that means
superfluous decorations, cover-ups This architecture deliberately displays bare building
“gross cement” or “raw concrete”
with the employment of multifarious materials & structural elements and is marked by and this term is occasionally used
concealing materials and finishes minimalistic yet voluminous construction to describe the characteristic looks
The author is a Professor & Head, Department of Architecture & Planning, Birla Institute of Technology at Mesra, Ranchi, Jharkhand.
Email: [email protected], [email protected]
Mann ki Baat
Kabaad se Jugaad
M
eerut Municipal Corporation has beautified Corporation was selected for the ‘Indian Cleanliness
the intersections and parks of the city League’ award under the Swachhata Survey Award by the
with the ‘Kabaad Se Jugaad’ initiative Government of India. It is planned by the Corporation that
undertaken by their team. Prime Minister city beautification work will be taken further by linking it
Narendra Modi appreciated this initiative in his ‘Mann with public participation.
ki Baat’ programme, which boosted the enthusiasm of (Excerpts from Mann ki Baat booklet brought out every
the entire team of the Municipal Corporation. When month by Publications Division, Ministry of Information &
single-use plastic was banned by the Government, it was Broadcasting)
thought that whatever scrap or junk is lying in sanitation
store should be connected with the city beautification
work, and that is how the ‘Kabaad se Jugaad’ programme Scan the QR code to watch a
was started. Old tyres, drums, and plastic scrap lying in special report on the 'Kabaad se
the store were used to make various shaped installations Jugaad' programme.
installed in the squares of the city. The Meerut Municipal
Statue of Unity
Prof Dr P S N Rao
Prof Dr Anil Dewan
The Statue of Unity is a testimonial to the life of Sardar Patel, a role model of unity and
statesmanship. The tallest statue in the world enjoys a splendidly scenic location facing the
Sardar Sarovar Dam, 3.2 kilometres away. This colossal statue stands on the isle of Sadhu-Bet in
River Narmada, at Ekta Nagar, District Rajpipla in the Indian State of Gujarat, with the majestic
Vindhyachal and Satpuda Mountain Ranges in the backdrop. The statue is fast becoming one of
the country’s top tourist attractions. Aimed to inspire generations, the Statue showcases Sardar
Vallabhbhai Patel’s vision of unity, patriotism, inclusive growth, and good governance.
A
tributary endeavour to the Iron Man of India, makes it an ideal destination for eco-tourism. The bronze
the Statue of Unity is an iconic 182-metre- statue of Sardar Vallabhbhai Patel, the first deputy prime
tall statue situated on the isle of Sadhu-Bet. minister of India took four years to build and eight years
Located between the Mountain Ranges of to design. The monument, created by Indian sculptor Ram
Vindhyachal and Satpuda, this monument has many other V. Sutar, stands almost 50-storey tall and rests on a base
attractive tourist spots in its proximity such as the Valley with three tiers, setting a world record for height. The
of Flowers, the Shoolpaneshwar Sanctuary and sacred geometrically designed base is situated on its own riverine
temple, the Sardar Sarovar Dam and its water dykes, the island and is linked to the main land mass by a bridge
scenic Zarwani Falls and majestic palaces of Rajpipla. for vehicles and pedestrians. A visitor’s centre, hotel, and
The grand monument along with a picturesque backdrop exhibition hall are all located inside, and the top of each is
Prof. Dr. P.S.N. Rao is the Director and Professor of Housing, School of Planning and Architecture, New Delhi. Email: [email protected]
Prof. Dr. Anil Dewan is Head of the Department & Professor of Architecture, School of Planning and Architecture, New Delhi.
Email: [email protected], [email protected]
Our Books
Earthquake-Resistant Construction
I
ndia on account of its unique geophysical while the national capital of Delhi is in Zone IV, and the
setting is highly prone to earthquakes of mega cities of Mumbai, Kolkata, and Chennai are in Zone
varying intensities. The country has faced III. 38 cities with a population of half a million and above
several devastating earthquakes in the past each and a combined population of a million are located
resulting in a large number of deaths and severe property in these three regions.
damage. During the last century, five earthquakes
Multi-storeys constructed with thermocol could be the
measuring M8 or more struck different parts of the
future earthquake-resistant buildings
country. In recent years damaging earthquakes had been
experienced in different parts of the country. Thermocol could be the material of the future for
the construction of earthquake-resistant buildings,
Seismic Zoning
with thermal insulation, and could also save energy
The country has been classified into different zones required to develop construction materials. Researchers
indicating the intensity of damage or frequency of at IIT Roorkee have found that thermocol or Expanded
earthquake occurrences. These zoning maps indicate Polystyrene (EPS) is used as a composite material in
broadly the seismic coefficient that could generally be the core of reinforced concrete sandwich, could resist
adopted for the design of buildings in different parts of earthquake forces on up to four-storey buildings. The
the country. These maps are based on subjective estimates researchers tested a full-scale building and a number of
of intensity from available information on earthquake wall elements constructed with thermocol sandwiched
occurrence, geology, and tectonics of the country. The between two layers of concrete at the National Seismic
Indian seismic zoning is a continuous process that Test Facility (NSTF) of the Department of Earthquake
keeps undergoing changes as more and more data on the Engineering, IIT Roorkee, developed under the Fund for
occurrence of earthquakes becomes available. Improvement of S&T Infrastructure (FIST) programme
Considering the recorded history of earthquakes in of Department of Science & Technology (DST),
the country, seismologists have classified 59% of the Government of India.
land mass of India as prone to earthquakes of different Besides resisting earthquakes, the use of an expanded
magnitudes– 11% in very high-risk Zone V, 18% in polystyrene core in the concrete walls of a building
high-risk Zone IV, and 30% in moderate-risk Zone III. can result in thermal comfort. The core provides the
Guwahati and Srinagar are located in Seismic Zone V, necessary insulation against the heat transfer between
Factory-made EPS core panel and welded wire mesh Building skeleton made of factory-made
reinforcement EPS core panels
Spraying and pouring of concrete over the EPS core skeleton and finished building model
In a heterogeneous society, the goal of every state is to provide equal access to its citizens. When
it comes to physical-public domain design, infrastructure for persons with disabilities assumes
another dimension of architecture. It has certain implications from the special-need quotient
of demography, and disability as an asocial construct. The international community is building
competencies for delivering quality governance on universal designs. India too has initiated
Sugamya Bharat Abhiyan as a credible step towards sustainable goals in universal designs.
D
iversity is everywhere, be it in culture, for indexing in terms of life quality. Nordic countries
language, climate, topography, gender and for instance and universal design is a good example of
abilities of people; inclusion stands for vision for inclusive growth. There are three vital aspects
giving freedom for access for all and building of inclusive designs in any situation. One is the social
commonalities. When it comes to residential space, the responsibility or commitment of the entity that evolves
requirements of people vary as per their taste, economic strategies for inclusion. Secondly, the reward to such
means, and functional requirements. But, most of the organisations which initiate such changes, and finally, the
times housing solutions are standardised for common users sustainability of such initiatives.
and not for special needs. There is a standard approach Challenges
for building residential space which traditionally does
not focus people with special needs. But when it comes A major challenge in implementing such changes is
to physical public domain design it assumes another on emphasising the value of such indicatives at the policy
dimension of architecture. It has certain implications for level and at the execution level. Inclusive design is about
the vision of a country on development, accountability
in the use of state’s budgeted funds, and the special need
quotient of demography. When administrators consider
people with all kind of abilities and their accessibility
issues while building public utilities and spaces, it can be
coined as universal design. Universal or inclusive design
provides for a holistic approach in designing public spaces
and utilities.
The UN Convention on the Rights of Persons
with Disabilities (UNCRPD) inspires and focuses on
universal design. It highlights the sovereign government’s
responsibility to make improvements since accessibility is
a right. Member States are responsible for systematically
removing obstacles and creating inclusive solutions
for everyone, irrespective of their functional capacity,
characteristics and preferences (Maria, 2018). When we
look at those countries with high living standards and
An accessible corridor developed in Maulana Azad Medical College,
quality of life, universal design certainly forms a modality Delhi for Persons with Visual Impairment.
The author is an Assistant Professor in Commerce and Research Supervisor at Govt. Arts and Science College, Ambalapuzha, Kerala
University and is visually challenged. Email: [email protected]
Conclusion Reference
Manmade physical environment is posing enormous 1. Maria Montefusco [email protected]
pressure in the lives of persons with disabilities. Disability Publisher: Ewa Persson Göransson
YE-2127/2022
‘We shape our buildings, and afterwards, our buildings shape us.’ – Winston Churchill
W
e have started to spend an extraordinary on simply eradicating the disease. But in reality, the wide
time indoors, which is in contrast to the spectrum of health encompasses preventive, promotive,
earlier times when our lives were in constant curative, rehabilitative and palliative care. India has
sync with nature. Our routines were aligned taken steps in this direction under the Ayushman Bharat
to the rising of the Sun and our circadian rhythms were where we are now opening Health and Wellness Centres.
matched to the Sun’s. In our current lifestyles, we are This shifts the Indian healthcare approach from selective,
fast dependent on the building amenities and utilities that curative healthcare to the one which includes concepts of
power us on a day-to-day basis. This includes artificial well-being embedded into it.
lighting and artificial means of ventilating space. The
indoor-based lifestyle that we have chosen for ourselves, Let us see some historical perspectives. All India
if not possible to be reversed, should most definitely be Sanitary Conference that was held in Lucknow in 1914
optimised so that it must take care of our health and well- laid the foundation of the current paradigm of building and
being. Contrary to our general perception linked only to city planning, by including the concepts of health and well-
its relation with diseases, the World Health Organization being. The concept of having an appropriate light place in
gives a more wholesome definition of health which is the streets was introduced and the width of the abutting
‘a state of complete physical, mental and social well- streets was made in accordance to the light. This would
being and not merely the absence of disease and infirmity.’ ensure adequate sunlight supply to the interior spaces of
This definition breaks the bounds in which the erstwhile the buildings. This forms the basis of all urban bylaws and
global thought was headed to, i.e., having a concentration city plans made later in India. Sunlight, along with natural
The author is visiting faculty in the Department of Architecture, School of Planning and Architecture, New Delhi where he is currently
also teaching an elective on Building Laws and Public Health. Email: [email protected]
YE-2114/2022
T
he Group of Twenty (G20) is the premier in focus areas that impact the most vulnerable and
forum for international economic disadvantaged.
cooperation. It plays an important role in The G20 mantra is - One Earth, One Family, One
shaping and strengthening global architecture Future. It is these thoughts and values of India that pave
and governance on all major international economic issues. the way for the welfare of the world. India’s Presidency
The G20 members represent around 85% of the global will not only be a memorable one for the country, but the
GDP, over 75% of the global trade, and about two-thirds of future will also assess it as a momentous occasion in the
the world population. history of the world.
India’s Presidency New Delhi Summit
India is holding the Presidency of the G20 from The 18th G20 Heads of State and Government Summit
1 December 2022 to 30 November 2023 which offers a will take place on 9-10 September 2023 in New Delhi.
unique opportunity to contribute to the global agenda on The Summit will be a culmination of all the G20 processes
pressing issues of international importance. India maintains and meetings held throughout the year among ministers,
close relations with developed countries on the one hand, senior officials, and civil societies. A G20 Leaders’
and at the same time understands and expresses the views Declaration will be adopted at the conclusion of the New
of developing countries very well. Guided by the Prime Delhi Summit, stating Leaders’ commitment towards the
Minister’s vision, India’s foreign policy has been evolving priorities discussed and agreed upon during the respective
to undertake leadership roles on the global stage. ministerial and working group meetings.
The G20 President
sets the agenda for the
year, identifies the themes
and focus areas, conducts
discussions, and delivers
the outcome documents.
India will identify, highlight,
develop and strengthen
international support for
priorities of vital importance
in diverse social and
economic sectors, ranging
from energy, agriculture,
trade, digital economy,
health, and environment to
employment, tourism, anti-
corruption, and women’s The President of Indonesia, Joko Widodo symbolically handed over the G20 Presidency to
empowerment, including PM Narendra Modi at G20 Summit, in Bali, Indonesia on 16 November 2022.
Address_________________________________________________________________________________________
Email______________________________________________________ Mobile_______________________________
T
his book unveils historic flooring patterns of the H-shaped building. The following two chapters are
the Rashtrapati Bhavan, the residence of the dedicated to the documentation and decoding of the flooring
first citizen of the country, wherein authors patterns where each chapter is a repository of patterns on
have mapped, documented, and thereafter two floors, that is, the Upper Basement Floor and the Main
decoded intricate flooring compositions of the Rashtrapati Floor. These chapters contain multiple architectural floor
Bhavan, New Delhi. The idea of this publication stems plan drawings, flooring pattern drawings, and interpretation
from the inherent importance and value of the complex. sketches to understand the design of flooring in various
An initial reconnaissance survey of the Rashtrapati steps. The authors have done decoding of the patterns
Bhavan revealed exquisite patterns of flooring with unique on the basis of available archival drawings of flooring
geometric layouts and compositions. These flooring created by Edwin Lutyens during the commencement of
patterns, which are both floral and abstract, run through the the project, based upon an understanding of the system of
different areas of the complex proportions and principles of
and yet bind together the design (symmetry, rhythm,
spaces viz. loggias, porticos, balance, order, hierarchy, etc.).
entrance halls, staircases, The volume examines
grand halls, ceremonial halls, around 22 spaces, out
and attendant spaces. The of which a step-by-step
use of various materials such graphical explanation of
as red and buff sandstone, how to understand the
marble, Indian patent stone, design inspiration and
wood, and terrazzo presents geometry of 31 patterns is
a visual aesthetic that carried out. Each of these
enhances the spatial quality, chapters commences with a
sequentially, and the flow key plan of the entire floor
of spaces from one area showing the location of
into another. It is a unique each decoded pattern. The
example where a building decoding of every pattern
of such colossal and palatial starts with an explanation
nature and proportions in of the spatial setting of the
India has deployed the art area showing the floor plan
of geometry in flooring and by way of two-dimensional
this has further enhanced the drawings. Further, steps
exuberance, grandness, and lead to the explanation of
historic value of the residence each flooring pattern with
of the country’s first citizen. respect to the structural
Thus, it became imperative for the authors to document grids, enclosures defined placement of openings, and
this unique repository of flooring patterns designed by Sir visual and spatial axes to understand the overall evolution
Edwin Lutyens for the abode of the Viceroy of India in of the flooring pattern. In the last step, one can find the
1912 (a project that lasted until 1929). complete documented flooring with its colour scheme and
The volume deals with the important halls of the stone cuts. After the decoding steps, a tracing/gateway
central area of the H-shaped building. The introductory sheet is attached with each pattern to highlight detailed
chapter describes the design philosophy and inception of stone cuts documented by the authors on the site.
the Rashtrapati Bhavan on Raisina Hill and the inspiration Note: The motifs used in this issue of Yojana are taken from
that led to the creation of such unique flooring designs in this book.
Visit www.publicationsdivision.nic.in to surf through and buy from a wide range of publications highlighting subjects of national
importance including India’s rich cultural heritage, land and people, Azadi Ka Amrit Mahotsav, art and culture, flora and fauna,
Gandhian literature, biographies and speeches, science, and children’s literature.
Regd. No. RNI 949/57
ISSN-0971-8400 Licenced U(DN)-56/2021-23 to post without
Total pages - 56 pre-payment at RMS, Delhi (Delhi Post
Published on 23 November, 2022 Postal Regd. DL(S)-05/3230/2021-23
Posted on 25 & 26 November, 2022 DL(DS)-40/MP/2022-23-24
YE-2110/2022
Printed & Published by Anupama Bhatnagar, Director General, Publications Division, Soochna Bhawan, C.G.O. Complex,
Lodhi Road, New Delhi-110003. Printed at J.K. Offset, B-278, Okhla Indl. Area, Phase-I, New Delhi. Editor: Shuchita Chaturvedi