Cost MGMT Accounting U1
Cost MGMT Accounting U1
Cost MGMT Accounting U1
Unit 1
BAC 301/05
Cost and Management
Accounting
Management
Accounting and Cost
Concepts
ii WAWASAN OPEN UNIVERSITY
BAC 301/05 Cost and Management Accounting
COURSE TEAM
Course Team Coordinator: Dr. Loo Choo Hong
Content Writers: Mr. Lok Char Lee and Dr. Loo Choo Hong
Instructional Designer: Ms. Toh Chee Leng
Academic Members: Ms. Deehbanjili Lakshmayya and Mr. Lim Peng Keat
COURSE COORDINATOR
Dr. Loo Choo Hong
PRODUCTION
Editor: Pelangi Sdn. Bhd.
In-house Editor: Mr. Khoo Chiew Keen
Graphic Designer: Ms. Leong Yin Ling
Wawasan Open University is Malaysia’s first private not-for-profit tertiary institution dedicated to
adult learners. It is funded by the Wawasan Education Foundation, a tax-exempt entity established
by the Malaysian People’s Movement Party (Gerakan) and supported by the Yeap Chor Ee Charitable
and Endowment Trusts, other charities, corporations, members of the public and occasional grants
from the Government of Malaysia.
The course material development of the university is funded by Yeap Chor Ee Charitable and
Endowment Trusts.
All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system or
transmitted, in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording or
otherwise, without prior written permission from WOU.
Contents
Unit 1 Management Accounting and
Cost Concepts
Course overview 1
Unit overview 3
Unit objectives 4
Objectives 5
Introduction 5
Organisation structure 14
Profesional ethics 16
Objectives 23
Introduction 23
Objectives 41
Introduction 41
Cost-volume-profit (CVP) 41
Summary of Unit 1 59
References 75
Glossary 77
UNIT 1 1
Management accounting and cost concepts
Course Overview
BAC 301/05 Cost and Management Accounting covers a variety of internal company
accounting practices in planning, control and decision-making by management.
While the general subject of accounting can be defined as the identification,
measurement, accumulation, analysis, preparation and communication of the
quantification of economic events within a particular firm, management accounting
can be considered to fulfil these duties with a particular emphasis on cost and price
data. A major means of emphasising cost and price data is to develop budgets and
standards to plan and subsequently monitor the firm’s operations. Since price data
directly affect revenue and cost data directly affect expenses, accurate and useful
management accounting information helps to increase the profits by either increasing
revenue or reducing expenses. Obviously, competent and timely management
accounting is vital for making crucial decisions related to adjusting the revenue or
expenses.
Unit 1 deals with the cost and management accountant’s role in the organisation,
cost terms and purposes, and cost-volume-profit relationship. The unit describes
how cost accounting supports management accounting and financial accounting.
Professional ethics issues related to management accounting are also discussed. The
unit further distinguishes between the different types of costs (direct and indirect
costs, fixed and variable costs, unit and total costs). The unit will also cover the
concepts and mechanics of calculating the break even point.
Unit 2 deals with cost behaviours and cost estimation. Accountants are required to
make management planning and control decisions. They need to understand cost
behaviour so that they can make better planning and control decisions.
Unit 2 also discusses how costs behave and explains the techniques of estimating
costs. In order to be more accurate in estimating costs, accountants must understand
the make-up and the behavioural aspects of costs.
The unit will cover some elements of statistics. The high-low and regression analysis
methods, the estimation of regression equation and the goodness of fit will be covered.
Unit 3 explains how the job-order costing system is used by manufacturing and
service companies. Activity-based accounting system, activity-based management
and process product-costing systems are introduced in this unit.
2 WAWASAN OPEN UNIVERSITY
BAC 301/05 Cost and Management Accounting
Unit 4 covers budgeting techniques which comprise master budgets, flexible budgets
and standard costs. You will be introduced to standard costing. You will be able to
prepare a budgeted statement of comprehensive income, budget schedules, cash
budgets and budgeted statement of financial position. Flexible and static budgets
are also illustrated. Variance analysis techniques which you will use in your work
to control and measure management’s performance are also discussed in this unit.
The course concludes with Unit 5 which covers product costing and inventory
valuation. The various methods of inventory valuation will also be discussed in
this unit.
Unit Overview
Many large companies are run by senior executives with accounting background. As
a result, the study of cost accounting enables us to understand how managers and
accountants can contribute to the success of their businesses.
Web Reference
This unit describes how cost accounting supports management accounting and
financial accounting. Professional ethics issues related to management accounting
are also discussed. The unit further distinguishes between the different types
of costs (direct and indirect costs, fixed and variable costs, unit and total costs)
and the three types of companies in terms of their inventory sections (service
sector, merchandising sector and manufacturing-sector companies). Statements of
comprehensive incomes for a merchandising sector company and manufacturing
sector company are illustrated to help learners visualise the differences between
these two companies. The later part of the unit covers the concepts and mechanics
of calculating the breakeven point (using equation method, Contribution method,
and graph method) and targeted income.
1
This is the final examination of the Chartered Institue of Management Accountants, UK, a profes-
sional body dealing with management accounting.
4 WAWASAN OPEN UNIVERSITY
BAC 301/05 Cost and Management Accounting
Unit Objectives
By the end of Unit 1,you should be able to:
4. Explain the relationship among cost drivers, variable costs and fixed costs.
3. Define professional ethics and explain the standards of ethical conduct for
the management accountant.
Introduction
In this section, you will learn that the management accountant provides information
for managers to make decisions to fulfil the goals of the organisation. The
management accountant also provides information that can affect strategic decisions
and influence the planning and control system of an organisation.
Table 1.1 summarises the major differences between management accounting and
financial accounting:
Management accounting was a new invention in the first three decades of the 20th
century. The need to quantify production costs as the reason why “cost accounting”,
the original form of management accounting was needed. The Industrial Revolution
in the United Kingdom, Europe and the United States meant manufacturing evolved
from the simple cottage industry to mass production in a factory.
UNIT 1 7
Management accounting and cost concepts
Strategy cost management focuses on how cost information is applied to the strategic
direction of the organisation’s products and services. Management accountants help
managers to formulate strategy by providing answers to the following questions:
Questions Answers
• Who are the most important • Selling books online.
customers? • Produce a variety of cars in response
• How to be competitive? to changing customer tastes.
• How to deliver value to customers?
• What are the substitute products in • Designs and fixes the price of new
the marketplace? products after comparing the
• How do they differ in terms of price functionality and quality of other
and quality? products in the marketplace.
• What is our most critical capability? • Uses the reputation of existing brand
• Is it technology, production or to introduce new types of products.
marketing?
• How can we leverage it for new
strategic initiatives?
• Will adequate cash be available to • Issues new debt and equity to fund
fund the strategy, or do we need to strategic acquisition.
raise additional funds ?
1. Value-chain analysis
Products pass through a sequence of activities in the value chain and gain
some value in each activity.
Depending on the time and industry, some activities are more critical than
others. For example in the pharmaceutical industry, R&D and design of
products and processes are more important than other activities.
Management accountants help managers to track the costs in the value chain,
eventually reducing costs and improving efficiency. Cost-benefit analysis is
usually performed to find out whether it is cheaper to buy or to manufacture.
A supply chain is the flow of goods, services and information from supplier
to customer. It is the system of organisations, people, technology, activities,
information and resources related to moving products and services.
Value-chain and supply chain analyses and execution of key success factors are
important in the strategic planning process. However, the success of a strategy
depends on many decisions that managers make to develop, integrate and implement
their strategies.
Steps Details
Identify the problem and • Problem on how to increase revenues.
uncertainties • Uncertain about the demand for products resulting
from a change in selling price.
Obtain information • Talk to existing and potential customers.
• Review the results of past actions.
• Collect and analyse information regarding
competitors.
Make predictions about • Predict the future on the basis of information
the future gathered.
• Recognise that making predictions requires
judgement.
• Retest the assumptions.
• Review the thinking.
Make decisions by • Align decisions with strategy.
choosing among
alternatives
Implement the decision, • Prepare and implement budget.
evaluate performance • Collect information on how actual performance
and learn compares to planned performance.
• Provide feedback and learning for future decision
making.
The performance report prompts investigation and learning. Learning is useful for
making better-informed decisions and plans in the future. Management accountants
may raise several questions regarding problems and opportunities. The possible
questions are:
• Did the marketing and sales department make sufficient efforts to attract new
customers?
12 WAWASAN OPEN UNIVERSITY
BAC 301/05 Cost and Management Accounting
• Why is the actual selling price different from the target price?
Answers to the above questions could prompt the company to take subsequent
actions to improve its performance.
Activity 1.1
Multiple-Choice Questions
A. Supplier
B. Bank
C. Customer
D. Production manager
A. Sales manager
B. Shareholder
C. Controller
D. Production manager
A. Government pressure
B. Ethical guidelines published by the professional accounting
organisations
C. Increased global competition
D. None of the above
UNIT 1 13
Management accounting and cost concepts
Management accountants follow three guidelines to provide the most value to their
companies:
Guidelines Details
Cost-benefit approach Resources should be allocated if the expected benefits
exceed the expected costs.
Different costs for There are alternative ways to compute costs in different
different purposes decision-making situations. The cost concept used for the
external reporting may not be an appropriate concept for
internal reporting to managers.
Organisation structure
Management accounting and finance functions support managers in attaining the
goals of the organisation.
Staff management provides advice, support and assistance to line management. They
consist of management accountants, information technology and human resource
managers.
Normally, a decision making will involve both line management and staff
management. For example, a plant manager (line function) needs to get detailed
budget from management accountant (staff function) before investing in new
equipment.
The chief financial controller (CFO) or financial director is the person responsible
for overseeing the financial function of an organisation. In most organisations, the
CFO directly reports to and supports the chief executive officer (CEO).
UNIT 1 15
Management accounting and cost concepts
Functions Details
Controllership • Provide financial information to managers and other
stakeholders.
• Oversee the accounting information system.
Treasury • Arrange banking facilities and manage the cash flows.
• Invest excess funds in money market.
Risk management • Manage the financial risk such as interest rate risk and
foreign exchange risk.
• Manage the derivative instruments.
Taxation • Liaise with tax agent and tax authority.
• Advise management on tax planning.
Investor relations • Communicate and respond to shareholders regarding
external reporting.
Internal audit • Ensure integrity of the financial information.
The following diagram shows the reporting relationship for the CEO, CFO and
Controller.
CEO
CFO
Figure 1.1 Reporting relationship for the CEO, CFO and Controller
Figure 1.1 shows the formal reporting relationships. In most organisations, there are
informal relationships such as friendship among managers and personal reference
of top management.
Professional ethics
Professional ethics for accountants primarily refer to moral values and judgements of
accountants when they perform their duties. Subsequent to accounting scandals of
large corporations, attention has been drawn to ethical standards accepted within the
accounting profession. In order to restore the public’s confidence in the profession
and prevent fraudulent accounting, various accounting bodies and governments
have developed regulations and taken actions to improve ethical conduct among
the accounting profession.
1. Integrity
2. Objectivity
4. Confidentiality
5. Professional Behaviour
6. Public Practice
8. Accountants in Business
Institutional support
Accounting organisations and regulators have issued new legislations and standards
on how to improve internal control, corporate governance, monitoring of managers
and disclosure practices of public companies.
Professional accounting bodies have issued ethical guidelines to govern the conduct
of their members. Generally, the guidelines discuss issues relating to competency,
confidentiality, integrity and credibility.
UNIT 1 17
Management accounting and cost concepts
Management accountants may face ethical dilemmas when performing their duties.
Examples of real-life problems are:
Issues Dilemmas
Capitalise or expense The line manager wants to capitalise the development costs
the development but no credible evidence is available to support that the
costs new product is commercially viable.
Accepting “favour” Supplier is bidding for a new contract and the cost issues
are critical to winning the new contract.
Activity 1.2
Multiple-Choice Questions
A. Problem-solving
B. Attention directing
C. Scorekeeping
D. Planning
A. budget
B. data warehouse
C. statement of financial position
D. performance report
A. behavioural
B. benefit
C. cost
D. expense
UNIT 1 19
Management accounting and cost concepts
A. Treasurer
B. Auditor
C. Controller
D. Finance director
A. competence
B. integrity
C. objectivity
D. confidentiality
Summary
Supply chain describes how the goods and services are delivered
from initial sources to end users.
The key success factors of a company are cost and efficiency quality
time and innovation.
Self-test 1.1
Feedback
Activity 1.1
1. D
2. B
3. C
4. B
5. C
Activity 1.2
1. C
2. D
3. A
4. C
5. B
22 WAWASAN OPEN UNIVERSITY
BAC 301/05 Cost and Management Accounting
UNIT 1 23
Management accounting and cost concepts
3. Explain the relationship between cost drivers, variable costs and fixed costs.
Introduction
Companies emphasise costs because every dollar in cost reduction is additional
dollar of operating income. It is essential to understand how to calculate the cost of
products. When times are bad, it is necessary to take measures to reduce the costs.
Unfortunately, some companies collapsed due to higher fixed costs and lower sales.
For example, General Motor (GM) was forced to file for bankruptcy protection
in 2009.
Actual cost is the historical amount spent whereas budgeted cost is the predicted or
forecasted amount of cost. Managers need to know both budgeted costs and actual
costs in order to evaluate how well they have performed and learn how they can do
better in the future.
Cost object is anything for which a separate cost measurement is recorded. For
example, a product, an assembly line, a product line, or a department can be a cost
object.
24 WAWASAN OPEN UNIVERSITY
BAC 301/05 Cost and Management Accounting
Activity 1.3
Cost system determines the costs of various cost objects in two basic stages: cost
accumulation, followed by cost assignment.
Cost accumulation is the collection of cost data in some organised manner by means
of an accounting system. Costs in various categories such as materials and labour
costs are accumulated by means of an accounting system.
Accumulated costs are then assigned to various cost objects. Cost assignment
involves tracing and allocating costs to a product, an assembly line, a product line,
or a department.
Managers use a five-step process when making decisions and evaluating performance.
Costs are classified into direct costs that are traced to the cost object, and indirect
costs that are allocated to the cost object.
Direct costs are costs that can be traced to a cost object in an economically feasible
(cost -effective) way. It is not always practical to trace the costs to cost object from
a cost-benefit perspective. Direct costs include direct materials and direct labour.
Direct materials are materials that go into the production of the product. For example,
steel and tyres are direct materials to manufacture cars.
Direct labour is cost of labour that can be easily traced to a product. For example,
the wages paid to workers who spend time working on a model of cars.
Indirect costs are also called manufacturing overhead which are related to the cost
object but cannot be traced in an economically feasible way. For example, the salary
paid to a factory manager working on various models of cars.
Indirect costs are not be traced to cost object, they are assigned to a cost object by
allocation. For example, the cleaners who clean the toilets at WOU are indirect
costs to the university. Although the work of the cleaners are integral to the running
of the university, they contribution cannot be directly seen in the course material.
Activity 1.4
Why may the same cost be direct or indirect? Is the salary of line
supervisor direct cost or indirect cost?
Tracing Allocation
Cost object
Accurate cost allocation for manufacturing overhead can be a challenging task. For
example, it is difficult to allocate electricity costs to various products manufactured
in the same factory. Supervision costs are more difficult to assign than materials and
labour costs. Supervisor costs must be allotted based on a certain predetermined basis
such as units produced or hours worked factored into the cost of the product itself.
There are several factors that affect the classification of costs as direct or indirect.
Three of these factors are:
1. Materiality of the cost. The smaller the amount of the cost, the less likely
that it is economically feasible to trace that cost to a particular cost object.
For example, the cost of packing material is classified as indirect cost because
it is not economical to trace it to the product.
The classification of direct or indirect costs also depends on the definition of cost
object, the broader the definition of the cost object, the higher the proportion of
total costs that are direct costs. For example, salary of a supervisor can be classified
as direct cost to assembly department but it is classified as indirect cost if the cost
object is a particular model of car.
Broader cost object and higher proportion of direct costs result in more accurate
cost amounts.
Fixed costs remain constant with changes in the units produced. For example, if
units produced doubles, rental of factory does not increase.
UNIT 1 27
Management accounting and cost concepts
A variable cost changes in total in proportion to changes in the activity level. However,
the variable cost per unit remains constant regardless of units produced. For example,
material cost will increase in the same ratio as the increase of units produced.
Costs are defined as fixed or variable with respect to a specific activity and within
specific period.
To illustrate these two basic types of costs, consider the following cost behaviour
patterns.
$25,000.00
$20,000.00
$15,000.00
$10,000.00
$5,000.00
$0.00
0 100 200 300 400 500
Total material cost is represented by a straight line that climbs from left to
right. Material cost is an example of variable cost. As more units are produced,
proportionately more materials are acquired and incurred.
28 WAWASAN OPEN UNIVERSITY
BAC 301/05 Cost and Management Accounting
$35,000.00
$30,000.00
$25,000.00
$20,000.00
$15,000.00
$10,000.00
$5,000.00
$0.00
0 100 200 300 400 500
Fixed costs cannot be quickly and easily changed to match the resources needed or
used.
Individual cost items are not inherently variable or fixed. For example, if wages are
calculated based on a per-shirt-sewed basis, then they are classified as variable costs. In
contrast, if workers are paid on a monthly basis, then they are classified as fixed costs.
Some costs give both fixed and variable elements and are called mixed or semi-
variable costs. For example, selling cost includes basic salary and sales commission.
Sales
Quantity sold Sales commission Basic salary Selling cost
commission
(Units) per unit (RM) (RM) (RM)
(RM)
0 20 0 10000 10000
100 20 2000 10000 12000
200 20 4000 10000 14000
UNIT 1 29
Management accounting and cost concepts
$25,000.00
$20,000.00
$15,000.00
$10,000.00
$5,000.00
$0.00
0 100 200 300 400 500
Cost drivers
An activity is an event, task or unit of work which causes the cost to change, for
example, testing is an activity cost driver. There is a cause-and-effect relationship
between the level of activity and the cost incurred.
Fixed costs have no cost driver in the short run but may have a cost driver in the
long run. For example, in the short run, volume of production is not a cost driver of
testing department. In the long run, however volume of production is a cost driver
because the company can increase or decrease the testing department’s equipment
and staff.
Relevant range
Relevant range is the range of activity within which there is a specific relationship
between the level of activity and the cost in question. Outside this level of activity,
costs behave differently. For example, rental of factory is only fixed in relation to a
given range of activities and specific period of time.
The concept of relevant range is also applicable to the variable cost. For example,
outside the relevant range, direct materials may not change proportionately with
changes in units produced. Observation of the actual costs must be done in order
to determine this range.
30 WAWASAN OPEN UNIVERSITY
BAC 301/05 Cost and Management Accounting
Based on two classifications of costs into direct or in direct and variable or fixed,
costs may be grouped into:
Cost behaviour pattern
Assignment of costs
Direct Indirect
Variable Direct materials such as steels Variable manufacturing
used to manufacture cars. overheads such as electricity cost.
Fixed Direct labour costs such as Fixed manufacturing overheads
salary of the production such as rental of factory.
supervisor of assembly line.
Activity1.5
Unit costs
Unit costs or average costs are calculated by dividing total costs incurred by the
number of units produced. Managers use unit cost information to decide on the
products they should invest more resources in, such as R&D and marketing, and
the prices they should charge.
If the total cost to produce 500,000 units of chairs is RM4,000,000, then the unit
cost for one chair is calculated as follows:
UNIT 1 31
Management accounting and cost concepts
Unit cost can also be calculated for all activities in the value chain such as product
design, sales visit and customer service. The unit cost of a product is the summation
of unit costs of all activities in the value chain.
An overreliance on unit cost could lead to an error in estimating total cost. Managers
should think in terms of total costs rather than unit costs for many decisions.
Assume that the total manufacturing cost to produce 500,000 units of a product
consists of RM15,000,000 of fixed costs and RM25,000,000 of variable costs.
A plant manager who uses the unit cost of RM80 will be under actual total costs.
Based on the following table, the actual cost should be RM25,000,000 and the
actual unit cost should be increased to RM125.
Fixed costs, when expressed on a unit basis can be misleading. As a general rule, it
is necessary to calculate total costs before making a particular decision.
32 WAWASAN OPEN UNIVERSITY
BAC 301/05 Cost and Management Accounting
Activity 1.6
Required:
Sectors Activities
Manufacturing Purchase materials and convert them into various finished
goods. One example is the factory that makes your IPhones.
Merchandising Purchase and sell tangible products without changing their
basic form. The shop that you purchased your IPhone is an
example of a form of business that does merchandising.
Service Provide services to their clients. The phone operator Celcom
which you subscribed is an example of a service provider.
Types of inventory
Service sector companies do not hold inventories except for some office supplies
such as papers and stationery.
Manufacturing cost
1. Direct material costs are the costs of materials that become part of the cost
object and can be traced to the cost object in an economically feasible manner.
For example, woods used to manufacture tables and chairs.
3. Indirect costs or overhead costs are all manufacturing costs that are related
to the cost object but cannot be traced to that object in an economically
feasible manner. For example, electricity used in the factory for production
and lighting. Overhead costs are allocated rather than traced.
Inventoriable costs
Inventoriable costs, also known as product costs, include all costs of a product that
are considered assets before they are sold. After they are sold to customers, these
costs will become cost of goods sold.
Period costs
Period costs are all costs other than manufacturing costs and are treated as expenses
for the period in which they are incurred. These costs include marketing, distribution
and customer service costs. They are not expected to benefit revenues in future
periods. Expensing period costs in current year is necessary so that they are matched
against the current year revenues.
All manufacturing costs are classified into prime costs and conversion costs.
Conversion costs are all manufacturing costs other than direct material costs; these
costs represent all the manufacturing costs to convert direct materials into finished
goods.
Overtime premium is the wage rate paid to workers in excess of their regular straight-
time wage rate. It is considered as overhead because the particular job performed
during overtime hours is a matter of chance.
If overtime is not random and relates to a particular job, then it can be classified
as direct labour cost.
Idle time is wage paid for unproductive time caused by lack of orders, machine
breakdowns, work delays, or poor scheduling. Idle time is an overhead because it is
not related to a particular product. For example, the wages paid to your operators
during a work stoppage as a result of raw materials being shipped late into the factory
are a form of idle time.
Activity 1.7
Muttu is paid RM40 an hour for normal working hours and RM60
an hour for overtime. In one week he worked 52 hours, which
included 12 hours of overtime, and 4 hours of idle time caused by
material shortages.
Required:
Payroll fringe costs such as health care and pensions may be classified as direct or
indirect labour costs. Most companies prefer to classify these costs as direct costs
in order to increase the ratio of direct labour costs over total costs. Tax authorities
may consider the fringe costs as overhead. In addition to fringe costs, sick leave
and overtime premium also need to be clearly defined in the contracts and laws to
prevent disputes.
36 WAWASAN OPEN UNIVERSITY
BAC 301/05 Cost and Management Accounting
Activity 1.8
Cost accounting and cost management are commonly used for cost calculation,
planning, control, performance evaluation and decision-making.
The costing system traces direct costs and allocate indirect costs to products and
services. The purpose of cost accounting is to calculate total costs and unit costs of
products and services.
A budget forces managers to plan ahead, to coordinate and communicate the plans
within the organisation. It also provides a benchmark to evaluate performance.
Managers compare actual results to planned performance at the end of the financial
period. Variances are differences between actual and planned performance.
UNIT 1 37
Management accounting and cost concepts
The accountant will begin by preparing the Schedule of Cost of Goods Manufactured.
The preparer will then transfer the Cost of Goods Manufactured to the Statement
of Comprehensive Income.
38 WAWASAN OPEN UNIVERSITY
BAC 301/05 Cost and Management Accounting
Summary
Self-test 1.4
35,000 units were sold during the year for RM25 per unit.
UNIT 1 39
Management accounting and cost concepts
Required:
Feedback
Activity 1.3
Activity 1.4
Depending on the cost object, the same cost can be direct or indirect.
A line supervisor in a factory could be a direct cost if the cost object
is the particular assembly line, but would be indirect if the finished
product is the cost object.
Activity 1.5
Activity 1.6
Activity 1.7
Activity 1.8
5. Construct a P/V chart by using available data and explain its salient features.
Introduction
Cost-Volume-Profit (CVP) analysis is naturally appealing to managers because it
provides a simple relationship between the effects of cost and volume to profit. Users
should be aware of its limitations before applying this simple approach for planning.
This section discusses the limiting assumptions of the CVP model along with the
importance of the decision situation and the time horizon.
Cost-Volume-Profit (CVP)
Cost-volume-profit (CVP) analysis is the study of effects on total revenues, total
costs, and operating income when changes occur in units sold, selling price, variable
cost per unit, or fixed costs of a product.
Managers use CVP analysis to help answer important “what-if ” business questions.
CVP analysis also helps to illustrate how “bottom-line” is affected by changes in
activity levels or selling price or cost components.
Contribution
Contribution (CM) is the difference between total revenues and total variable costs.
Contribution explains how operating income will change at different levels of activity.
Fixed costs will not change no matter how many units of products are sold; total
revenues and total variable costs change as a result of selling different quantities of
products.
Example of Contribution
Apple Tree provides the following information regarding its product selling price
and costs for one month.
RM80
Contribution percentage =
RM200
= 40%
Equation method
This method becomes the basis for calculating operating income for different
quantities of units sold.
Operating income = [(Selling price × Quantity sold) − (Variable cost per unit ×
Quantity sold)] − Fixed costs
Using the information from Apple Tree, the operating income is calculated as follows:
Contribution method
This method illustrates the basic idea of how each unit sold helps the company to
recover its fixed costs.
Using the information from Apple Tree, the operating income is calculated as follows:
Graph method
This method presents total costs and total revenues graphically based on an
assumption that both costs and revenues behave in a linear fashion. We will draw
a break even chart. A break even chart is a graphical representation of the relation
between total value earned and total costs for various levels of productivity.
44 WAWASAN OPEN UNIVERSITY
BAC 301/05 Cost and Management Accounting
in RM
Total costs
Sales/production
(units)
Breakeven
sales/production
3. On another piece of paper sketch the scales that you want to use given the
data, then use this plan on the chart.
4. Plot any two points from the sales revenue data for the sales revenue line
and then draw a straight line for sales revenue (assume that the price per
unit does not change) if the information is not given for sales revenue,
then work out two points, e.g., for 1000 units sold and 1500 units sold.
The start of the line should be through the origin (where the axes meet).
5. Draw a horizontal line for total fixed costs starting at the point on the vertical
axis for the level of costs.
6. At the same starting point it is possible to draw the total costs line. Total
costs are fixed costs plus variable costs. Work out what the total costs are
for say 1000 units and 1500 units. Then draw a straight line starting from
the same point as the fixed costs and then through the two plotted points.
7. Where the sales revenue crosses the total costs line is the breakeven point.
Read off the units of sales to give the breakeven level of sales.
8. The gap between the total costs line and sales revenue line after the breakeven
point represents the level of profit.
UNIT 1 45
Management accounting and cost concepts
CVP assumptions
• Number of units sold is the only revenue and cost driver; revenues and costs
change exclusively due to changes in the number of units sold.
• Total revenues and total costs are linear; it can be represented as a straight
line.
• Selling price, variable cost per unit, and total fixed costs are known and
constant.
Although these assumptions do not hold over time, they can allow meaningful
analysis. For example, a cost is either variable or fixed depending on the relevant
range and the time period of decision. More cost components are fixed if the time
period is shorter.
It is necessary to consider the relevant range, the length of the time period and the
specific purpose of decision when classifying costs as variable or fixed.
The breakeven point (BEP) is the quantity of units sold at which total revenues
equal total costs. It is also the level of activity that a company is making zero profit.
In practice, BEP is calculated using the equation or Contribution method.
Equation method
Using the information from Apple Tree, the BEP is calculated as follows:
Contribution method
Fixed costs
Contribution per unit
Using the information from Apple Tree, the BEP is calculated as follows:
Fixed costs
Contribution ratio
Using the information from Apple Tree, the BEP is calculated as follows:
Managers are also concerned about how they can achieve their goals for operating
profit. Target Operating Income (TOI) is the level of activity needed to attain a
specified dollar amount of operating income.
Using the information from Apple Tree, if the company needs to earn TOI of
RM1,200, the units are calculated as follows:
Using the information from Apple Tree, if the company needs to earn TOI of
RM1,200, the revenues needed are calculated as follows:
Activity 1.9
Required:
1. How many sets of ZEE must be sold to reach BEP for 2012?
The following examples illustrate how to use CVP analysis in determining whether
to increase advertising or reduce the selling price.
48 WAWASAN OPEN UNIVERSITY
BAC 301/05 Cost and Management Accounting
Apple Tree provides the following information regarding its product selling price
and costs for one month.
Without With
advertisement advertisement
(40 units) (46 units)
RM RM
Revenues (40 × RM200); (46 × RM200) 8,000 9,200
Less: Variable costs (40 × RM120); (4,800) (5,520)
(46 × RM120)
Contribution 3,200 3,680
Less: Fixed costs (RM2,000); (RM2,000 + (2,000) (3,000)
RM1,000)
Operating income 1,200 680
Based on the above CPV analysis, the company should not advertise because the
operating income will decrease by RM520.
UNIT 1 49
Management accounting and cost concepts
Apple Tree provides the following information regarding its product selling price
and costs for one month.
The company is considering reducing selling price by RM30 which will increase
sales by 40%.
Based on the above CPV analysis, the company should not reduce the selling price
because the operating income will decrease by RM400.
50 WAWASAN OPEN UNIVERSITY
BAC 301/05 Cost and Management Accounting
In addition to the above decisions, CVP analysis can be used to determine the
target selling price. Using Apple Tree’s information, the target selling price to earn
operating income of RM1,600 at 40 units is calculated as follows:
Apple Tree can compare the changes in Contribution to the changes in fixed costs and
should choose the alterative that provides the highest operating income. However,
the company also needs to consider other factors such as quality of the product,
production capacity and customer service.
Excel spreadsheet is used to process the decision data. The effect and interaction
of changes in selling price, variable cost per unit, fixed costs and target operating
income can be instantly seen on the spreadsheet.
Excel can calculate the required number of units sold to achieve particular operating
income levels, given alternative levels of fixed costs and variable cost per unit.
For example, Apple Tree has a new product with the following information:
The number of units to achieve the target operating income of RM4,000 is computed
as 96 units. This can easily be calculated using a spreadsheet like MS-Excel.
UNIT 1 51
Management accounting and cost concepts
Margin of safety is the amount by which the current level of sales exceeds the
breakeven point. It may be expressed in units, dollars, or as a percentage and is a
measure of how much sales can decline and still be above breakeven point.
Using the information from Apple Tree, the margin of safety is calculated as follows:
RM3,000
Margin of safety percentage =
RM8,000
= 37.5%
From the above calculations, if sales decrease by 20% which is smaller than margin
of safety, Apple Tree is still making profits.
52 WAWASAN OPEN UNIVERSITY
BAC 301/05 Cost and Management Accounting
In making strategic decisions, managers use CVP analysis to plan the levels of variable
and fixed costs for their organization.
The cost structures determine the risks and returns when fixed costs are substituted
for variable costs. For example, there is an alternative between automation and
labour-based manufacturing operation.
Sensitivity analysis can be utilised in making the decision to substitute fixed costs
for variable costs in the cost structure. The effects of a choice of fixed over variable
in the cost structure are illustrated as follows:
Apple Tree presents the following cost structures. Selling price of the product is
RM200.
Target operating
Fixed cost Variable cost BEP
Options income of RM2,800
(RM) (RM) (Units)
(Units)
Automation 3,000 100 30 58
Labour- based 2,000 120 25 60
Automation has a higher BEP or more risk of loss than labour-based but requires
fewer units to earn target operating income of RM2,800.
CVP analysis can help managers to evaluate the effects of various cost structures.
UNIT 1 53
Management accounting and cost concepts
The selling price is RM200 and the variable cost (excluding sales commission) is
RM120 per unit.
Target operating
Fixed cost Variable cost BEP
Options income of RM2,800
(RM) (RM) (Units)
(Units)
Option 1 2,000 120 25 60
Option 2 800 150 16 72
Option 3 0 180 0 140
Option 1 has the highest BEP or the highest risk of loss if the sales are low. It has the
highest contribution per unit and hence the highest reward if the sales are high.
Option 3 has the lowest BEP or the lowest risk of loss if the sales are low. It has the
lowest Contribution per unit and the lowest reward if the sales are high.
The choice will be influenced by the confidence in the level of demand for the
product and the risk preference of the managers. For example, managers who are
willing to take higher risk will choose option 1 with high potential rewards.
Operating leverage
Contribution margin
Degree of operating leverage (DOL) =
Operating income
If DOL is higher, small increases in sales will lead to large increases in operating
income. For example, if DOL is 4 for a company then its operating income will
increase four times following the change in revenues.
Using the information from Apple Tree and with sales of 80 units, the DOL is
calculated for the three options as follows:
The effects on the operating income if the sales increase by 50% are as follows:
DOL changes at different levels of sales; its value is dependent on the level of sales.
High DOL is a major reason for financial distress for large corporations with heavy
investments in fixed costs. Managers must understand the trade-off between having
high DOL, high risk and the potential rewards.
Most companies sell a large variety of products. Sales mix is the quantities or ratios
of various products or services that constitute the total sales of a company. In CPV
analysis, managers will assume that sales mix of multiple products remains constant
as total units sold changes.
The total number of units that must be sold to BEP in a multiproduct company
depends on the sales mix. CVP analysis with multiple products is performed by
calculating a weighted average Contribution based on a constant sales mix percentage.
UNIT 1 55
Management accounting and cost concepts
Apple Tree produces two different products with the following information.
Assume that the budgeted sales mix is constant at 2:3 (GREEN: RED).
The BEP is calculated for the bundle of 2 units of GREEN and 3 units of RED as follows:
Units Revenues
BEP of GREEN (10 bundles × 2 units); (20 units × RM200) 20 RM4,000
BEP of RED (10 bundles × 3 units); (30 units × RM400) 30 RM12,000
BEP RM16,000
56 WAWASAN OPEN UNIVERSITY
BAC 301/05 Cost and Management Accounting
Apple Tree produces two different products with the following information.
Revenue of
the bundle
GREEN (2 units × RM200) RM 400
RED (3 units × RM400) RM1,200
RM1,600
= RM520 / RM1,600
= 0.325
Fixed costs
BEP revenues =
Contribution margin ratio
= RM5,200 / 0.325
= RM16,000
UNIT 1 57
Management accounting and cost concepts
Summary
Self-test 1.5
Feedback
Activity 1.9
Summary of Unit 1
Summary
• Fresh fruit and vegetables are delivered and prepared every day.
Required:
Classify the above activities as primary or supporting activities in the value chain.
Required:
4. Wonder Sdn. Bhd. makes and sells printers. It takes the following actions, not
necessarily in order given.
a. Ask marketing team to consider ways to get back market share from a
competitor.
c. Compare actual costs against budget costs for the production of the new
printer.
e. Estimate the costs that will be incured to sell 100,000 units of new products
in thenext financial year.
Required:
State whether the above actions are planning decisions or control decisions.
5. Money Come Manufacturing has three cost objects that it uses to accumulate
costs for its manufacturing plants. They are:
a. Depreciation on machines
c. Property insurance
d. Supervisors salaries
e. Fringe benefits
UNIT 1 63
Management accounting and cost concepts
f. Property taxes
g. Electricity
Required:
Assign each of the above costs to the most appropriate cost object.
6. Far East Manufacturing Sdn. Bhd. produces electronic storage devices, and uses
the following three-part classification for its manufacturing costs: direct
materials, direct manufacturing labour, and indirect manufacturing costs. Total
indirect manufacturing costs for January were RM300,000, and were allocated
to each product on the basis of direct manufacturing labour costs of each line.
Actual costs incurred in January for the product, Apple Tree, were:
Apple Tree
Direct manufacturing costs RM400,000
Direct manufacturing labour costs RM200,000
Indirect manufacturing costs RM100,000
Units produced 35,000
Required:
a. Compute the manufacturing cost per unit for Apple Tree produced in
January.
7. Top Glass Sdn. Bhd. wants to estimate costs for each product they produce at
the Kedah plant. The Kedah plant produces five products, and runs two flexible
assembly lines. Each assembly line can produce all five products.
Required:
a. Classify each of the following costs as either direct or indirect for each
product.
64 WAWASAN OPEN UNIVERSITY
BAC 301/05 Cost and Management Accounting
b. Classify each of the following costs as either fixed or variable with respect
to the number of units produced for each product.
8. Each of the following items pertains to Supreme Real Estate (a service sector
company). Classify each item as either inventoriable (I) costs or period (P) costs.
9. On the assembly floor, Ahmad is paid RM20 per hour during normal working
hours and RM30 per hour for overtime. In one week he worked 50 hours, which
included 10 hours of overtime.
Required:
10. Good Hope Plastics Sdn. Bhd. provides the following information for the
year 2012:
Revenues RM5,500,000
Variable manufacturing costs RM 900,000
Variable non manufacturing costs RM 810,000
Fixed manufacturing costs RM 700,000
Fixed non manufacturing costs RM 545,000
UNIT 1 65
Management accounting and cost concepts
Required:
a. Compute Contribution.
11. Swiss Club is planning to hold the yearly annual dinner. It has two options for
the banquet:
Required:
c. Which option provides the greatest operating income if 500 tickets were
sold?
d. Which option provides the greatest degree of operating leverage if 500 tickets
were sold?
66 WAWASAN OPEN UNIVERSITY
BAC 301/05 Cost and Management Accounting
12. Arizona Sports Sdn. Bhd. sells sports shoes for men and women. The units sold,
selling price and variable costs for each product are as follows:
Men Women
3,000 pairs 2,000 pairs
Selling price RM200.00 RM250.00
Variable costs RM120.00 RM120.00
Required:
a. What is the breakeven point in units for each type of shoes, assuming the
sales mix is constant?
b. What is the operating income, assuming the sales mix is constant and the
company will sell 5,000 pairs of shoes?
UNIT 1 67
Management accounting and cost concepts
Feedback
Self-test 1.1
Self-test 1.2
Self-test 1.3
Self-test 1.4
Self-test 1.5
Feedback
4. Action Decision
a. Planning
b. Control
c. Control
d. Planning
e. Planning
11. a. Option 1
b. Option 1:
Option 2:
c. Option 1:
Option 2:
d. Option 1:
Option 2:
12. a. The BEP is calculated for the bundle of 3 pairs of Men and
2 pairs of Women as follows:
Pairs Revenues
BEP of Men (200 bundles 600 RM120,000
× 3 pairs); (600 pairs ×RM200)
BEP of Women (200 bundles 400 RM150,000
× 2 pairs); (600 pairs × RM250)
BEP RM270,000
References
Horngren, C T, Datar, S M and Rajan, M V (2012) Cost Accounting: A Managerial
Emphasis, 14th edn, USA: Pearson Education Limited.
76 WAWASAN OPEN UNIVERSITY
BAC 301/05 Cost and Management Accounting
UNIT 1 77
Management accounting and cost concepts
Glossary
Cost management The approaches and activities of managers
in using resources to increase the value to
customers and to achieve organisational goals.
Direct costs Costs that are related to the cost object and
can be traced to it in an economically feasible
(cost-effective) way.
Indirect costs Costs that are related to the cost object but
cannot be traced to it in an economically
feasible way.
Source: The above definitions are adapted from Horngren, C T, Datar, S M and
Rajan, M V (2012) Cost Accounting: A Managerial Emphasis, 14th edn, USA: Pearson
Education Limited.