DECISIONS PENNED BY JUSTICE CAGUIOA

FOR 2022 BAR TAKERS

CIVIL LAW
1. SPOUSES MARCELIAN TAPAYAN and ALICE TAPAYAN, G.R. No.
petitioners, vs. PONCEDA M. MARTINEZ, respondent 207786,
January 30,
2017
2. SAN FRANCISCO INN, hereto represented by its authorized G.R. No.
representative, LEODINO M. CARANDANG, petitioner, vs. SAN 204639,
PABLO CITY WATER DISTRICT, represented by its General February, 2017
Manager ROGER F. BORJA and the SPCWD INVESTIGATING
BOARD, respondents
3. AMA LAND, INC., petitioner, vs. WACK WACK RESIDENTS’ G.R. No.
ASSOCIATION, INC., 202342. July
19, 2017
4. PRIVATIZATION AND MANAGEMENT OFFICE, petitioner, vs. G.R. No.
EDGARDO V. QUESADA, MA. GRACIA QUESADA-MANALO, 224507.
ELIZABETH QUESADA-JOSE, EUGENIO V. QUESADA, September 20,
represented by their Attorney-in-Fact, EUGENIO V. QUESADA, 2017
respondents.
5. JOSE SANICO and VICENTE CASTRO, petitioners, vs. G.R. No.
WERHERLINA P. COLIPANO, respondent. 209969.
September 27,
2017
6. G. HOLDINGS, INC., petitioner, vs. CAGAYAN G.R. No.
ELECTRIC POWER AND LIGHT COMPANY, INC. 226213.
(CEPALCO) and FERROCHROME PHILIPPINES, INC., September 27,
respondents. 2017.
7. REPUBLIC OF THE PHILIPPINES, represented by the G.R. No.
REGIONAL EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR, DENR, REGION 218418.
IV, MANILA, petitioner, vs. THE HEIRS OF MEYNARDO November 8,
CABRERA, as herein represented by MEYNARDO 2017.
CABRERA, JR. and ALMA RODRIGUEZ CABRERA, THE
HEIRS OF CONSOLACION DIMACULANGAN
CABRERA, as herein represented by ALEXANDER
CABRERA, MANIBI CABRERA, MILAGROS CABRERA
GARA, and RAUL CABRERA, JACKSON CINCO DY,
LORETA AGBAYANI, GLORIA SORIANO, CRIS CALMA,
NORA LIWANAG and the REGISTER OF DEEDS OF
ORIENTAL MINDORO, respondents.
8. COCA-COLA BOTTLERS PHILS., INC., petitioner, vs. G.R. No.
ERNANI GUINGONA MEÑEZ, respondent. 209906.
November 22,
2017.
9. ARACELI MAYUGA, substituted by MARILYN MAYUGA G.R. No.
SANTILLAN for and on behalf of all the heirs, petitioners, 208197.
vs. ANTONIO ATIENZA, representing the heirs of January 10,
ARMANDO** ATIENZA; BENJAMIN ATIENZA, JR., 2018.
representing the heirs of BENJAMIN A. ATIENZA, SR.,
respondents.
10. REPUBLIC OF THE PHILIPPINES, represented by the G.R. No.
 DIRECTOR of the LAND MANAGEMENT BUREAU 189803. March
(LMB), petitioner, vs. FILEMON SAROMO, respondent. 14, 2018.
11. REPUBLIC OF THE PHILIPPINES, G.R. No.
petitioner, vs. NORTHERN CEMENT CORPORATION, 200256. April
respondent. 11, 2018.
12. ASTRID A. VAN DE BRUG, MARTIN G. AGUILAR and G.R. No.
GLENN G. AGUILAR, petitioners, vs. PHILIPPINE 207004. June 6,
NATIONAL BANK, respondent. 2018.
13. D.M. RAGASA ENTERPRISES, INC., petitioner, vs. G.R. No.
BANCO DE ORO, INC. (formerly Equitable PCI Bank, 190512. June
Inc.), respondent. 20, 2018.
14. SPOUSES ABRAHAM AND MELCHORA ERMINO, G.R. No.
petitioners, vs. GOLDEN VILLAGE HOMEOWNERS 180808. August
ASSOCIATION, INC., represented by LETICIA** C. 15, 2018.
INUKAI, respondent.
15. BENEDICTO V. YUJUICO,** petitioner, vs. FAR EAST G.R. No.
BANK AND TRUST COMPANY (now Bank of the 186196. August
Philippine Islands), substituted by PHILIPPINE 15, 2018.
INVESTMENT ONE (SPV-AMC), INC.,***respondent.
16. JOSE A. BERNAS and the WHARTON RESOURCES G.R. No.
GROUP (PHILIPPINES), INC., petitioners, vs. THE 195908. August
ESTATE OF FELIPE YU HAN YAT, represented by HERO 15, 2018.*
T. YU, respondent.
17. FELOMENA S. MEJIA (duly substituted by heirs G.R. No.
CARMELITA S. PONGOL and MAGDALENA S. 195910. August
TUMAMBING), petitioners, vs. FELIPE YU HAN YAT, 15, 2018.*
respondent.
18. SPOUSES ANTONIO BELTRAN and FELISA BELTRAN, G.R. No.
petitioners, vs. SPOUSES APOLONIO CANGAYDA, JR. 225033. August
and LORETA E. CANGAYDA, respondents. 15, 2018.*
19. REPUBLIC OF THE PHILIPPINES, represented by the G.R. No.
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC WORKS AND HIGHWAYS 208956.
(DPWH), petitioner, vs. HEIRS OF ELIGIO CRUZ, October 17,
represented by CRISANTA OLIQUINO, and HEIRS OF 2018.*
ELIGIO CRUZ, represented by MAXIMINO AGALABIA,
respondents.
20. REPUBLIC OF THE PHILIPPINES, petitioner, vs. SPS. G.R. No.
ILDEFONSO ALEJANDRE and ZENAIDA FERRER 217336.
ALEJANDRE, respondents. October 17,
2018.*
21. NARCISO MELENDRES, substituted by his wife, OFELIA G.R. No.
MELENDRES and children JOSE MARI MELENDRES, 198026.
and NARCISO MELENDRES, JR., petitioners, vs. ALICIA November 28,
CATAMBAY, LORENZA BENAVIDEZ, in substitution of 2018.*
her husband EDMUNDO BENAVIDEZ, and the
REGISTER OF DEEDS OF RIZAL (MORONG BRANCH),
respondents.
22. JUN MIRANDA, petitioner, vs. SPS. ENGR. ERNESTO G.R. No.
and AIDA MALLARI and SPS. DOMICIANO C. REYES 218343.
and CARMELITA PANGAN, respondents. November 28,
2018.*
23. VDM TRADING, INC. and SPOUSES LUIS and NENA G.R. No.
DOMINGO, represented by their Attorney-in-Fact, ATTY. 206709.
F. WILLIAM L. VILLAREAL, petitioners, vs. LEONITA February 6,
CARUNGCONG and WACK WACK TWIN TOWERS 2019.*
CONDOMINIUM ASSOCIATION, INC., respondents.
24. ANACLETO ALDEN MENESES,** petitioner, vs. JUNG G.R. No.
 SOON LINDA LEE-MENESES, respondent. 200182. March
13, 2019.*
25. UNITRANS INTERNATIONAL FORWARDERS, INC., G.R. No.
petitioner, vs. INSURANCE COMPANY OF NORTH 203865. March
AMERICA, UNKNOWN CHARTERER OF THE VESSEL 13, 2019.*
M/S “DORIS WULLF” and TMS SHIP AGENCIES,
respondents.
26. HEIR OF PASTORA T. CARDENAS AND EUSTAQUIO G.R. No.
CARDENAS, namely REMEDIOS CARDENAS-TUMLOS, 222614. March
represented by her Attorney-In-Fact JANET TUMLOS- 20, 2019.*
QUIZON, petitioner, vs. THE CHRISTIAN AND MISSIONARY
ALLIANCE CHURCHES OF THE PHILIPPINES, INC., represented
by REO REPOLLO and LEOCADIO DUQUE, JR., respondent.
27. DOMESTIC PETROLEUM RETAILER CORPORATION, G.R. No.
petitioner, vs. MANILA INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT 210641. March
AUTHORITY, respondent. 27, 2019.*
28. ROGELIO LOGROSA, petitioner, vs. SPOUSES CLEOFE G.R. No.
and CESAR AZARES, SPOUSES ABUNDIO, JR. and 217611. March
ANTONIETA TORRES, SPOUSES NELSON SALA and 27, 2019.*
ARLENE ANG, and SPOUSES BONIFACIO, JR., and
WELHELMINA BARUIZ, respondents.
29. HUN HYUNG PARK, petitioner, vs. EUNG WON** CHOI, G.R. No.
respondent. 220826. March
27, 2019.*
30. KAREN NUÑEZ** VITO, LYNETTE *** NUÑEZ MASINDA, G.R. No.
WARREN NUÑEZ, and ALDEN**** NUÑEZ, petitioners, vs. 224466. March
NORMA MOISES-PALMA, respondent. 27, 2019.*
31. SPOUSES JOHN T. SY AND LENY N. SY, AND VALENTINO T. SY, G.R. No.
PETITIONERS, VS. MA. LOURDES DE VERA-NAVARRO AND 239088, April
BENJAEMY HO TAN LANDHOLDINGS, INC., HEREIN 03, 2019
REPRESENTED
BY GRACE T. MOLINA, IN HER CAPACITY AS CORPORATE
SECRETARY, RESPONDENTS.
32. HIPOLITO AGUSTIN AND IMELDA AGUSTIN, PETITIONERS, VS. G.R. No.
ROMANA DE VERA, RESPONDENT. 233455, April
03, 2019
33. PHILIPPINE COMMERCIAL AND INTERNATIONAL BANK (NOW G.R. No.
BANCO DE ORO UNIBANK, INC.), PETITIONER, VS. WILLIAM 195372, April
GOLANGCO CONSTRUCTION CORPORATION, RESPONDENT. 10, 2019
34. SEBASTIAN M. QUINOL,** ALIMITA RENDAL-QUINOL, G.R. No.
PORFERIA QUINOL-MACATIGUIB, MARCELO 213517. April
MACATIGUIB, BALTAZAR QUINOL, ELAINE 10, 2019.*
KILAPKILAP-QUINOL, and PATRICIA QUINOL,
petitioners, vs. LORENZA INOCENCIO, EPIFANIA POA,
JIMMY POA, ARTEMIO QUINOL, and JESUS QUINOL,
respondents.
35. MA. LUISA A. PINEDA, petitioner, vs. VIRGINIA G.R. No.
ZUÑIGA VDA. DE VEGA, respondent. 233774. April
10, 2019.*
36. SPOUSES ISIDRO R. SALITICO AND CONRADA C. G.R. No.
SALITICO, petitioners, vs. HEIRS OF 240199. April
RESURRECCION** MARTINEZ FELIX, namely: 10, 2019.*
LUCIANO, CORAZON and CONCEPCION, ALL
SURNAMED FELIX, RECAREDO P. HERNANDEZ, in his
capacity as Administrator of the Estate of AMANDA H.
BURGOS, and THE REGISTER OF DEEDS, respondents.
37. SPS. TEDY GARCIA and PILAR GARCIA, petitioners, vs. G.R. No.
 LORETA T. SANTOS, WINSTON SANTOS and 228334. June
CONCHITA TAN, respondents. 17, 2019.*
38. RIZAL COMMERCIAL BANKING CORPORATION, G.R. No.
petitioner, vs. PLAST-PRINT** INDUSTRIES INC., and 199308. June
REYNALDO***C. DEQUITO, respondents. 19, 2019.*
39. HEIRS OF SPOUSES MONICO SUYAM and CARMEN G.R. No.
BASUYAO** (both deceased), namely: OLIVER B. SUYAM, 209081. June
MABLE B. SUYAM, CHRISTOPHER B. SUYAM, ABEL B. 19, 2019.*
SUYAM, and CHESTER B. SUYAM, represented by their
attorney-in-fact and on his own behalf, TELESFORO B.
SUYAM, petitioners, vs. HEIRS OF FELICIANO
JULATON @ PONCIANO, namely: LUCINA J. BADUA,
SEMEON JULATON, JULIANA J. BUCASAS,
ISABEL*** J. ALLAS, RODOLFO JULATON, CANDIDA**** J.
GAMIT, represented by their attorney-in-fact and on her own
behalf, CONSOLACION JULATON, respondents.
40. CHEVRON PHILIPPINES, INC. (formerly known as G.R. No.
CALTEX PHILIPPINES, INC.), petitioner, vs. LEO Z. 211533. June
MENDOZA, respondent. 19, 2019.
41. MAKATI WATER, INC., petitioner, vs. AGUA VIDA SYSTEMS, G.R. No.
INC., respondent. 205604. June
26, 2019.*
42. MAXIMA P. SACLOLO and TERESITA P. OGATIA, G.R. No.
petitioners, vs. ROMEO MARQUITO, MONICO 229243. June
MARQUITO, CLEMENTE MARQUITO, ESTER M. 26, 2019.*
LOYOLA, MARINA M. PRINCILLO, LOURDES
MARQUITO and LORNA MARQUITO, respondents.
43. HEIRS OF SPOUSES GERVACIO A. RAMIREZ AND G.R. No.
MARTINA CARBONEL, represented by CESAR S. 222916. July
RAMIREZ and ELMER R. ADUCA, petitioners, vs. JOEY 24, 2019.*
ABON and THE REGISTER OF DEEDS OF NUEVA
VIZCAYA, respondents.
44. SPS. JULIAN BELVIS, SR., and CECILIA BELVIS, SPS. G.R. No.
JULIAN E. BELVIS, JR., and JOCELYN BELVIS, SPS. 239727. July
JULIAN E. BELVIS III and ELSA BELVIS, and JOUAN 24, 2019.*
E. BELVIS, petitioners, vs. SPS. CONRADO V. EROLA
and MARILYN EROLA, as represented by
MAUREEN**FRIAS, respondents.
45. THE HEIRS OF ALFREDO CULLADO,** namely LOLITA G.R. No.
CULLADO, DOMINADOR CULLADO, ROMEO 212938. July
CULLADO, NOEL CULLADO, REBECCA LAMBINICIO, 30, 2019.*
MARY JANE BAUTISTA and JIMMY CULLADO,
petitioners, vs. DOMINIC V. GUTIERREZ, respondent.
46. JOCELYN MODOMO and DR. ROMY MODOMO, G.R. No.
petitioners, vs. SPOUSES MOISES P. LAYUG, JR. and 197722. August
FELISARIN** E. LAYUG, MOISES P. LAYUG, JR., 14, 2019.*
substituted by his heirs, namely: his wife, FELISARIN E.
LAYUG, and Children, MA. CELESTE LAYUG CO,
EUGENE ESPINOSA LAYUG, FRANCIS ESPINOSA
LAYUG and SHERYL ESPINOSA LAYUG, respondents.
47. ELMER MONTERO, petitioner, vs. SANTIAGO G.R. No.
MONTERO, JR. and CHARLIE MONTERO, respondents. 217755.
September 18,
2019.*
48. FRANCISCO C. DELGADO, represented by JOSE MARI G.R. No.
DELGADO, petitioner, vs. GQ REALTY DEVELOPMENT 241774.
CORP., MA. ROSARIO G. MEYER, KARL KURT September 25,
EDWARD MEYER, and THE REGISTRY OF DEEDS OF 2019.*
 MAKATI CITY, respondents.
49. CAMARINES SUR TEACHERS AND EMPLOYEES G.R. No.
ASSOCIATION, INC., represented by its President, DR. 199666.
ANTONIO RALUTA, petitioner, vs. PROVINCE OF October 7,
CAMARINES SUR, represented by Governor LUIS 2019.*
RAYMUND F. VILLAFUERTE, JR., respondent.
50. CHUA PING HIAN, also known as JIMMY CHING, G.R. No.
petitioner, vs. SILVERIO MANAS (deceased), substituted 198867.
by his heirs, namely, CARIDAD MANAS, surviving spouse, October 16,
and children, NESTOR MANAS, ROLANDO MANAS, 2019.*
RENE MANAS and BENILDA MANAS, respondent.
51. PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, plaintiff-appellee, vs. G.R. No.
CESARIA BASIO VERTUDES and HENRY BASIO 220725.
VERTUDES, accused-appellants. October 16,
2019.*
52. REPUBLIC OF THE PHILIPPINES, represented by THE G.R. No.
REGIONAL EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR, DEPARTMENT OF 223822.
ENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES (DENR), October 16,
REGIONAL OFFICE NO. III, petitioner, vs. TANDUAY 2019.*
LUMBER, INC., VERBO REALTY AND DEVELOPMENT
CORP., SPOUSES CLEMENTE and MA. LOURDES
GARCIA, JOHN MICHAEL H. ARTIENDA, SPOUSES
TEODORO D.G. CHAN and ANGELITA G. CHAN,
LICERIO M. LIBUNAO, MARICRIS A. MELCHOR,
MARICRIS C. ARMADO, WINSTON T. CAPATI and THE
REGISTER OF DEEDS OF BULACAN, respondents.
53. PABLO UY, substituted by his heirs, namely: MYLENE D. G.R. No.
UY, PAUL D. UY and PAMELA UY-DACUMA, petitioners, 227460.
vs. HEIRS OF JULITA UY-RENALES, represented by: December 5,
JESSICA R. ROSERO, JOSELITO RENALES and JANET 2019.*
U. RENALES; JOVITO ROSERO and MARILYN
RENALES, respondents.
54. ATTY. LEONARD FLORENT O. BULATAO, petitioner, vs. G.R. No.
ZENAIDA C. ESTONACTOC, respondent. 235020.
December 10,
2019.*
55. REPUBLIC OF THE PHILIPPINES, petitioner, vs. G.R. No.
REMAR A. QUIÑONEZ, respondent. 237412.
January 6,
2020.*
56. QUINTIN ARTACHO LLORENTE, petitioner, vs. STAR G.R. No.
CITY PTY LIMITED, represented by the JIMENO AND 212050.
COPE LAW OFFICES as Attorney-in-Fact, respondent. January 15,
2020.*
57. CYNTHIA A. GALAPON, petitioner, vs. REPUBLIC OF G.R. No.
THE PHILIPPINES, respondent. 243722.
January 22,
2020.*
58. D.M. CONSUNJI, INC., PETITIONER, V. REPUBLIC OF THE G.R. No.
PHILIPPINES AND THE HEIRS OF JULIAN CRUZ, REPRESENTED 233339,
BY MACARIA CRUZ ESTACIO, RESPONDENTS. February 13,
2019
59. REPUBLIC OF THE PHILIPPINES vs SIXTO SUNDIAM, L & F G.R. No.
MARKETING, INC., JOSE MA. 236381, August
LOPEZ, ROSENDO D. BONDOC, 27, 2020
AUGUSTO F. DEL ROSARIO, and
LIBERTY ENGINEERING
CORPORATION,
60. SPOUSES ROMEO ANASTACIO, G.R. No.
SR. and NORMA T. ANASTACIO, vs HEIRS OF THE LATE 224572, August
SPOUSES 27, 2020
JUAN F. COLOMA and JULIANA
PARAZO,
61. DR. NIXON L. TREYES, PETITIONER, VS. ANTONIO L. LARLAR, G.R. No.
REV. FR.EMILIO L. LARLAR, HEDDY L. LARLAR, ET AL., 232579,
RESPONDENTS. September 08,
2020
62. MARIO M. MADERA, BEVERLY C. MANANGUITE, CARISSA D. G.R. No.
GALING, 244128,
AND JOSEFINA O. PELO, PETITIONERS, VS. COMMISSION ON September 08,
AUDIT 2020
(COA) AND COA REGIONAL OFFICE NO. VIII, RESPONDENTS.
MERCANTILE LAW
63. JOSE M. ROY III, petitioner, vs. CHAIRPERSON G.R. No.
TERESITA HERBOSA, THE SECURITIES AND 207246.
EXCHANGE COMMISSION, and PHILIPPINE LONG November 22,
DISTANCE TELEPHONE COMPANY, respondents. 2016.*
64. JOSE M. ROY III, petitioner, vs. CHAIRPERSON G.R. No.
TERESITA HERBOSA, THE SECURITIES AND 207246. April
EXCHANGE COMMISSION, and PHILIPPINE LONG 18, 2017.*
DISTANCE TELEPHONE COMPANY, respondents.
WILSON C. GAMBOA, JR., DANIEL V. CARTAGENA,
JOHN WARREN P. GABINETE, ANTONIO V. PESINA,
JR.,
65. PRUDENTIAL BANK (now BANK OF THE PHILIPPINE G.R. No.
ISLANDS), petitioner, vs. RONALD RAPANOT and 191636. January
HOUSING & LAND USE REGULATORY BOARD, 16, 2017.*
respondents.
66. ALLAN S. CU, petitioner, vs. SMALL BUSINESS G.R. No.
GUARANTEE AND FINANCE CORPORATION through 211222. August
MR. HECTOR M. OLMEDILLO, respondent. 7, 2017.*
67. SYMEX SECURITY SERVICES, INC. and RAFAEL Y. G.R. No.
ARCEGA, petitioners, vs. MAGDALINO O. RIVERA, JR. 202613.
and ROBERTO B. YAGO, respondents. November 8,
2017.*
68. INDUSTRIAL PERSONNEL AND MANAGEMENT G.R. No.
SERVICES, INC., petitioner, vs. COUNTRY BANKERS 194126. October
INSURANCE CORPORATION, respondent. 17, 2018.*
69. QUINTIN V. BELTRAN,* PETITIONER, VS. AMA COMPUTER G.R. No.
COLLEGE-BIÑAN/AMA EDUCATION SYSTEM, CHERYL ROJAS, 223795, April
EVANGELINE BONDOC, AND AMABLE R. AGUILUZ V, 03, 2019
RESPONDENTS.
70. ZUNECA PHARMACEUTICAL, AKRAM ARAIN AND/OR VENUS G.R. No.
ARAIN,M.D., AND STYLE OF ZUNECA PHARMACEUTICAL, 211850,
PETITIONERS, VS. NATRAPHARM, INC., RESPONDENT. September 08,
2020
71. QUINTIN ARTACHO LLORENTE, PETITIONER, VS. STAR CITY G.R. No.
PTY 212050, January
LIMITED, REPRESENTED BY THE JIMENO AND COPE LAW 15, 2020
OFFICES AS ATTORNEY-IN-FACT, RESPONDENT.

STAR CITY PTY LIMITED, REPRESENTED BY THE JIMENO COPE G.R. No.
& 212216, January
DAVID LAW OFFICES AS ITS ATTORNEY-IN-FACT, 15, 2020
PETITIONER, VS.
QUINTIN ARTACHO LLORENTE AND EQUITABLE PCI BANK
(NOW BDO UNIBANK, INC.), RESPONDENTS.
CRIMINAL LAW
72. PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, PLAINTIFF-APPELLEE, V. G.R. No.
RUBEN 214771, August
"ROBIN" BONGBONGA Y NALOS, ACCUSED-APPELLANT. 09, 2017
73. PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, plaintiff-appellee, vs. EDDIE G.R. No.
OLAZO, MIGUEL CORDIS, CHARITO 220761.
FERNANDEZ and ROGELIO LASCONIA, accused, CHARITO October 3,
FERNANDEZ, accused-appellant. 2016.*
74. PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, plaintiff-appellee, vs. G.R. No.
DANDITO LASTROLLO y DOE, accused-appellant. 212631.
November 7,
2016.*
75. PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, plaintiff-appellee, vs.ANTONIO G.R. No.
DACANAY y TUMALABCAB, accused- 216064.
appellant. November 7,
2016.*
76. PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, PLAINTIFF-APPELLEE, V. G.R. No.
MARVIN MADRONA OTICO, ACCUSED-APPELLANT. 231133, June
06, 2018
77. ZENAIDA P. MAAMO and JULIET O. SILOR, petitioners, G.R. No.
vs. PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, respondents. 201917.
December 1,
2016.*
78. PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, plaintiff-appellee, vs. G.R. No.
ROQUE DAYADAY y DAGOOC,1 accused-appellant. 213224.
January 16,
2017.*
79. PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, plaintiff-appellee, vs. G.R. No.
LORENZO RAYTOS y ESPINO, accused-appellant. 225623. June 7,
2017.*
80. CORAZON M. LACAP, petitioner, vs. SANDIGANBAYAN G.R. No.
(Fourth Division) and PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, 198162. June
respondents. 21, 2017.*
81. PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, plaintiff-appellee, vs. G.R. No.
FEDERICO GEROLA y AMAR alias “FIDEL,” accused- 217973. July
appellant. 19, 2017.*
82. PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, plaintiff-appellee, vs. G.R. No.
RUBEN “ROBIN” BONGBONGA y NALOS, accused- 214771. August
appellant. 9, 2017.*
83. PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, plaintiff-appellee, vs. G.R. No.
PAUL DURAN, JR. y MIRABUENO, accused-appellant. 215748.
November 20,
2017.*
84. PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, plaintiff- G.R. No.
appellee, vs. DELIA CALLEJO y TADEJA and SILVERA 227427. June 6,
ANTOQUE y MOYA @ “INDAY,” accused-appellants. 2018.*
85. PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, plaintiff-appellee, vs. G.R. No.
OSCAR GIMPAYA and ROEL GIMPAYA, accused, OSCAR 227395.
GIMPAYA, accused-appellant. January 10,
2018.*
86. PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, plaintiff- G.R. No.
appellee, vs. HESSON CALLAO y MARCELINO and 228945. March
JUNELLO AMAD, accused, 14, 2018.*
HESSON CALLAO y MARCELINO, accused-appellant.
87. PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, plaintiff- G.R. No.
appellee, vs. JOEL DOMINGO, accused-appellant. 204895. March
 21, 2018.*
88. PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, plaintiff- G.R. No.
appellee, vs. BASHER TOMAWIS y ALI, accused- 228890. April
appellant. 18, 2018.*

89. PRESIDENTIAL COMMISSION ON GOOD G.R. No.

GOVERNMENT, petitioner, vs. OFFICE OF THE 195962. April
OMBUDSMAN, PLACIDO L. MAPA, JR.,** RECIO M. 18, 2018.*
GARCIA, LEON O. TY, JOSE R. TENGCO, JR.,
ALEJANDRO MELCHOR, VICENTE PATERNO, RUBEN
ANCHETA, RAFAEL SISON, HILARION M. HENARES,
JR., CARMELINO G. ALVENDIA and GENEROSO F.
TENSECO,***respondents.
90. PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, plaintiff- G.R. No.
appellee, vs. NARCISO SUPAT y RADOC alias “ISOY,” 217027. June 6,
accused-appellant. 2018.*
91. PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, plaintiff- G.R. No.
appellee, vs. JENNIFER GA-A y CORONADO, accused, 222559. June 6,
2018.*
AQUILA “PAYAT” ADOBAR, accused-appellant.
92. PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, plaintiff- G.R. No.
appellee, vs. NORJANA SOOD y AMATONDIN, accused- 227394. June 6,
appellant. 2018.*
93. PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, plaintiff- G.R. No.
appellee, vs. DELIA CALLEJO y TADEJA and SILVERA 227427. June 6,
ANTOQUE y MOYA @ “INDAY,” accused-appellants. 2018.*
94. MA. SUGAR M. MERCADO and SPOUSES REYNALDO G.R. No.
and YOLANDA MERCADO, petitioners, vs. HON. JOEL 230170. June 6,
SOCRATES S. LOPENA [Presiding Judge, Metropolitan 2018.*
Trial Court, Branch 33, Quezon City], HON. JOHN
BOOMSRI S. RODOLFO [Presiding Judge, Metropolitan
Trial Court, Branch 38, Quezon City], HON. REYNALDO
B. DAWAY [Presiding Judge, Regional Trial Court, Branch
90, Quezon City], HON. ROBERTO P. BUENAVENTURA
[Presiding Judge, Regional Trial Court, Branch 86, Quezon
City], HON. JOSE L. BAUTISTA, JR. [Presiding Judge,
Regional Trial Court, Branch 107, Quezon City], HON.
VITALIANO AGUIRRE II (In His Capacity as Secretary of
Justice), HON. DONALD LEE (In His Capacity as the
Chief of the Office of the City Prosecutor of Quezon City),
KRISTOFER JAY I. GO, PETER and
ESTHER GO, KENNETH ROUE I. GO, CASEY LIM
JIMENEZ, CRISTINA PALILEO, and RUEL BALINO,
respondents.
95. PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, plaintiff- G.R. No.
appellee, vs. MARVIN MADRONA OTICO, accused- 231133. June 6,
appellant. 2018.*
96. PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, plaintiff- G.R. No.
appellee, vs. GERRY AGRAMON, accused-appellant. 212156. June
20, 2018.*
97. PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, plaintiff- G.R. No.
appellee, vs. LEONARDO B. SIEGA, accused-appellant. 213273. June
27, 2018.*
98. PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, plaintiff- G.R. No.
appellee, vs. XXX,**accused-appellant. 225059. July
23, 2018.*
99. PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, plaintiff- G.R. No.
 appellee, vs. JACINTO ANDES y LORILLA, accused- 227738. July
appellant. 23, 2018.*
100. PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, plaintiff- G.R. No.
appellee, vs. HENRY DE VERA y MEDINA, accused- 218914. July
appellant. 30, 2018.*
101. PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, plaintiff-appellee, vs. G.R. No.
RICKY GONZALES y COS and RENE GONZALES y COS, 218946.
accused, September 5,
RICKY GONZALES y COS, accused-appellant. 2018.*
102. PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, plaintiff- G.R. No.
appellee, vs. AQUIL PILPA y DIPAZ, accused-appellant. 225336.
September 5,
2018.*
103. PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, plaintiff-appellee, vs. G.R. No.
WILLIAM VILLAROS y CARANTO, accused-appellant. 228779.
October 8,
2018.*
104. PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, plaintiff- G.R. No.
appellee, vs. WELITO 224894.
October 10,
SERAD y RAVILLES a.k.a. “WACKY,” accused-appellant. 2018.*
105. ALBERTO GRANTON, petitioner, vs. PEOPLE OF THE G.R. No.
PHILIPPINES, respondent. 226045.
October 10,
2018.*
106. PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, plaintiff- G.R. No.
appellee, vs. RENATO BACOLOT y IDLISAN, accused- 233193.
appellant. October 10,
2018.*
107. PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, plaintiff-appellee, vs. G.R. No.
ALGLEN REYES y PAULINA, accused-appellant. 225736.
October 15,
2018.*
108. PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, plaintiff- G.R. No.
appellee, vs. PATRICK JOHN MERCADO y ANTICLA, 218702.
accused-appellant. October 17,
2018.*
109. PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, plaintiff- G.R. No.
appellee, vs. XXX**accused-appellant. 226467.
October 17,
2018.*
110. PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, plaintiff- G.R. No.
appellee, vs. ARMANDO BAGABAY y MACARAEG, 236297.
accused-appellant. October 17,
2018.*
111. PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, plaintiff- G.R. No.
appellee, vs. ALVIN 218805.
FATALLO y ALECARTE a.k.a. “ALVIN November 7,
FATALLO y ALECARTE,” accused-appellant. 2018.*
112. PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, plaintiff- G.R. No.
appellee, vs. RODEL 227865.
MAGBUHOS** y DIOLA alias “BODIL,” accused-appellant. November 7,
2018.*

113. PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, plaintiff-appellee, vs. G.R. No.

NADER MUSOR y ACMAD, accused-appellant. 231843.
November 7,
 2018.*
114. PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, plaintiff-appellee, vs. G.R. No.
BOBBY PACNISEN y BUMACAS, accused-appellant. 234821.
November 7,
2018.*
115. PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, plaintiff- G.R. No.
appellee, vs. JULIET RIVERA y OTOM and JAYSON 225786.
LACDAN y PARTO, accused, JULIET RIVERA y OTOM, November 14,
accused-appellant. 2018.*
116. PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, plaintiff-appellee, vs. G.R. No.
ANGEL ANGELES y ARIMBUYUTAN, accused-appellant. 237355.
November 21,
2018.*
117. PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, plaintiff-appellee, vs. G.R. No.
MARLON CASCO y VILLAMER, accused-appellant. 212819.
November 28,
2018.*
118. PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, plaintiff- G.R. No.
appellee, vs. NOVA DE LEON y WEVES, accused- 214472.
appellant. November 28,
2018.*
119. PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, plaintiff- G.R. No.
appellee, vs. EDWIN CABEZUDO y RIEZA, accused- 232357.
appellant. November 28,
2018.*
120. PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, plaintiff- G.R. No.
appellee, vs. MARIO BULUTANO y ALVAREZ, accused- 232649.
appellant. November 28,
2018.*
121. PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, plaintiff-appellee, vs. G.R. No.
CHRISTOPHER ILAGAN y BAÑA alias “WENG,” accused- 227021.
appellant. December 5,
2018.*
122. PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, plaintiff-appellee, vs. G.R. No.
NILA MALANA y SAMBOLLEDO, accused-appellant. 233747.
December 5,
2018.*
123. PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, plaintiff-appellee, vs. G.R. No.
CESAR DELA CRUZ y LIBONAO alias SESI of Zone 3, 234151.
Macanaya, Aparri, Cagayan, accused-appellant. December 5,
2018.*
124. REYNALDO ARBAS RECTO, petitioner, vs. THE PEOPLE G.R. No.
OF THE PHILIPPINES, respondent. 236461.
December 5,
2018.*
125. PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, plaintiff-appellee, vs. G.R. No.
BRYAN LABSAN y NALA and CLENIO DANTE y PEREZ, 227184.
accused-appellants. February 6,
2019.*
126. PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, plaintiff-appellee, vs. G.R. No.
BENJIE CARANTO y AUSTRIA, accused-appellant. 217668.
February 20,
2019.*
127. PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, plaintiff-appellee, vs. G.R. No.
REYNALD** 240914. March
ESPEJO y RIZALDO, accused-appellant. 13, 2019.*
128. PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, plaintiff- G.R. No.
 appellee, vs. GARRY BRIONES y ESPINA, accused- 239077. March
appellant. 20, 2019.*

129. ROLANDO P. DIZON, petitioner, vs. PEOPLE OF THE G.R. No.

PHILIPPINES, respondent. 239399. March
25, 2019.*
130. PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, plaintiff- G.R. No.
appellee, vs. DON VEGA y RAMIL, accused-appellant. 216018. March
27, 2019.*
131. PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, plaintiff- G.R. No.
appellee, vs. LARRY LUMAHANG y TALISAY, accused- 218581. March
appellant. 27, 2019.*
132. PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, PLAINTIFF-APPELLEE, VS. G.R. No.
DAVE 219852, April
CLAUDEL Y LUCAS, ACCUSED-APPELLANT. 03, 2019
133. PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, PETITIONER, VS. NOVO TANES G.R. No.
Y 240596, April
BELMONTE, RESPONDENT. 03, 2019
134. PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, plaintiff- G.R. No.
appellee, vs. ROMEO ASENIERO, accused-appellant. 218209. April
10, 2019.*
135. PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, plaintiff- G.R. No.
appellee, vs. SUSAN SAYO y REYES and ALFREDO 227704. April
ROXAS y SAGON, accused-appellants. 10, 2019.*
136. PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, plaintiff- G.R. No.
appellee, vs. EDGAR GAYON y FERRERAS, accused- 230221. April
appellant. 10, 2019.*
137. PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, plaintiff-appellee, vs. G.R. No.
ANGEL GURO y COMBO alias “JASON,” accused- 230619. April
appellant. 10, 2019.*
138. PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, plaintiff- G.R. No.
appellee, vs. ALEX ESCARAN y TARIMAN, accused- 212170. June
appellant. 19, 2019.*
139. PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, plaintiff- G.R. No.
appellee, vs. CESAR VILLAMOR CORPIN @ “BAY,” 232493. June
accused-appellant. 19, 2019.*
140. PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, plaintiff-appellee, vs. GARRY G.R. No.
PADILLA y BASE and FRANCISCO BERMAS y ASIS, accused, 234947. June
FRANCISCO BERMAS y ASIS, accused-appellant. 19, 2019.*
141. PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, plaintiff- G.R. No.
appellee, vs. JIMMY FULINARA y FABELANIA,1 accused- 237975. June
appellant. 19, 2019.*
142. PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, plaintiff- G.R. No.
appellee, vs. ARNALDO ENRIQUEZ, JR., accused- 238171. June
appellant. 19, 2019.*

143. PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, plaintiff-appellee, vs. EDWIN G.R. No.

NIEVES y ACUAVERA a.k.a. “Ading,” accused-appellant. 239787. June
19, 2019.*
144. PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, plaintiff- G.R. No.
appellee, vs. FERDINAND BUNIAG y MERCADERA, 217661. June
accused-appellant. 26, 2019.*
145. PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, plaintiff- G.R. No.
appellee, vs. JERRY DAGDAG a.k.a. “TISOY,” accused- 225503. June
appellant. 26, 2019.*
146. PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, plaintiff- G.R. No.
appellee, vs. SPO2 EDGARDO MENIL y BONGKIT, 233205. June
 accused-appellant. 26, 2019.*
147. PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, plaintiff- G.R. No.
appellee, vs. RESSURRECCION 231361. July 3,
RESSURRECCION y ROBLES,** JONATHAN 2019.*
MANUEL y OTIG, ANICETO DECENA y GONZAGA,
JERRY ROBLES y UNATO, accused,
CAROL ALCANTARA y MAPATA and JOSELITO CRUZ y DE
GUZMAN, accused-apellants.
148. PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, plaintiff-appellee, vs. G.R. No.
LYNDON CAÑETE 242018. July 3,
**y FERNANDEZ and PETERLOU 2019.*
PIMENTEL y BENDEBEL, accused-appellants.
149. PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, PLAINTIFF-APPELLEE, V. G.R. No.
ARMIE 241254, July
NARVAS Y BOLASOC, ACCUSED-APPELLANT. 08, 2019
150. PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, plaintiff- G.R. No.
appellee, vs. MARIO MANABAT y DUMAGAY, accused- 242947. July
appellant. 17, 2019.*
151. PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, plaintiff- G.R. No.
appellee, vs. HAVIB GALUKEN y SAAVEDRA, accused- 216754. July
appellant. 17, 2019.*
152. EDWIN DEL ROSARIO, petitioner, vs. PEOPLE OF THE G.R. No.
PHILIPPINES, respondent. 235739. July
22, 2019.*
153. PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, plaintiff-appellee, vs. FABIAN G.R. No.
MABALATO @ “BOY,” JULIO CARTUCIANO and ALLAN 227195. July
CANATOY @ “ALLAN EDWARD,” accused, 29, 2019.*
ALLAN CANATOY @ “ALLAN EDWARD,” accused-appellant.
154. CICL XXX,** petitioner, vs. PEOPLE OF THE G.R. No.
PHILIPPINES and GLENN REDOQUERIO, respondents. 237334. August
14, 2019.*
155. PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, plaintiff-appellee, G.R. No.
vs. ALLAN NIEVERA, accused-appellant. 242830. August
28, 2019.*
156. PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, plaintiff-appellee, G.R. No.
vs. DENNIS SARABIA y REYES, accused-appellant. 243190. August
28, 2019.*
157. XXX,** petitioner, vs. PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, G.R. No.
respondent. 243151.
September 2,
2019.*
158. PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, plaintiff-appellee, vs. G.R. No.
HILARIO DE CASTRO y SANTOS alias “DACOY,” 243386.
accused-appellant. September 2,
2019.*
159. PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, plaintiff-appellee, G.R. No.
vs. JOSE JAMILLO QUILATAN y DELA CRUZ, 218107.
accused-appellant. September 9,
2019.*
160. PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, plaintiff-appellee, vs. G.R. No.
ORLANDO RAMOS ORDIZ, accused-appellant. 206767.
September 11,
2019.*
161. DANILO DE VILLA y GUINTO, petitioner, vs. PEOPLE G.R. No.
OF THE PHILIPPINES, respondent. 224039.
September 11,
2019.*
162. PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, plaintiff-appellee, vs. G.R. No.
NOEL CARDENAS y HALILI, accused-appellant. 229046.
September 11,
2019.*
163. PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, plaintiff-appellee, vs. EMALYN G.R. No.
N. 234273.
MORENO, accused-appellant. September 18,
2019.*
164. CARLOS A. CATUBAO, petitioner, vs. SANDIGANBAYAN G.R. No.
and THE PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, respondents. 227371.
October 2,
2019.*
165. PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, plaintiff-appellee, vs. G.R. No.
JEFFREY FAYO y RUBIO a.k.a. “JEFF,” accused- 239887.
appellant. October 2,
2019.*
166. GIL “BOYING” R. CRUZ, petitioner, vs. PEOPLE OF THE G.R. No.
PHILIPPINES, respondent. 197142.
October 9,
SERAFIN N. DELA CRUZ and DENNIS C. CARPIO, 2019.*
petitioners, vs. PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES,
respondent. G.R. No.
197153.
October 9,
2019.*
167. PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, plaintiff-appellee, vs. G.R. No.
ROMELO DORIA y PEREZ, accused-appellant. 227854.
October 9,
2019.*
168. REPUBLIC OF THE PHILIPPINES, represented by THE G.R. No.
REGIONAL EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR, DEPARTMENT OF 223822.
ENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES (DENR), October 16,
REGIONAL OFFICE NO. III, petitioner, vs. TANDUAY 2019.*
LUMBER, INC., VERBO REALTY AND DEVELOPMENT
CORP., SPOUSES CLEMENTE and MA. LOURDES
GARCIA, JOHN MICHAEL H. ARTIENDA, SPOUSES
TEODORO D.G. CHAN and ANGELITA G. CHAN,
LICERIO M. LIBUNAO, MARICRIS A. MELCHOR,
MARICRIS C. ARMADO, WINSTON T. CAPATI and THE
REGISTER OF DEEDS OF BULACAN, respondents.
169. XXX, G.R. No.
[1] PETITIONER, VS. PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, 242101,
RESPONDENT. September 16,
2019
170. PETE GERALD L. JAVIER AND DANILO B. TUMAMAO, G.R. No.
PETITIONERS, VS. 237997, June
SANDIGANBAYAN AND PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, 10, 2020
RESPONDENTS.
171. P02 BERNARDINO CRUZ y BASCO vs, PEOPLE OF THE G.R. No.
PHILIPPINES, 216642.
September 8,
2020
LABOR LAW
172. EVIC HUMAN RESOURCES MANAGEMENT, INC., FREE BULKERS G.R. No.
S.A. and/or MA. VICTORIA C. NICOLAS, petitioners, vs. 206890. July 31,
ROGELIO O. PANAHON, respondent. 2017.*
173. SAN FERNANDO COCA-COLA RANK-AND-FILE UNION G.R. No.
(SACORU), represented by its President, ALFREDO R. 200499. October
MARAÑON, petitioner, vs. COCA-COLA BOTTLERS PHILIPPINES, 4, 2017.*
INC. (CCBPI), respondent.
174. YIALOS MANNING SERVICES, INC., OVERSEAS G.R. No.
SHIPMANAGEMENT S.A., RAUL VICENTE PEREZ, and 227216. July 4,
MINERVA ALFONSO, petitioners, vs. RAMIL G. BORJA, 2018.*
respondent.
175. RICKMERS MARINE AGENCY PHILS., INC., GLOBAL G.R. No.
MANAGEMENT, LIMITED and/or GEORGE C. GUERRERO, 220949. July 23,
petitioners, vs. EDMUND R. SAN JOSE, respondent. 2018.*
176. RAMCHRISEN H. HAVERIA, petitioner, vs. SOCIAL SECURITY G.R. No.
SYSTEM, CORAZON DE LA PAZ, and LEONORA S. NUQUE, 181154. August
respondents. 22, 2018.*
177. AMALIA S. MENEZ** In behalf of the late JONATHAN E. G.R. No.
MENEZ), petitioner, vs. STATUS MARITIME 227523. August
CORPORATION, NAFTOTRADE SHIPPING AND COMMERCIAL 29, 2018.*
S.A., and MOILEN ALOYSIUS
VILLEGAS, respondents.
178. CHRISTIAN ALBERT A. CARIÑO, petitioner, vs. MAINE MARINE G.R. No.
PHILS., INC., MISUGA KAIUN CO. LTD., AND CORAZON 231111. October
GUESE-SONGCUYA, respondents. 17, 2018.*
179. HENRY R. ESPOSO, petitioner, vs. EPSILON MARITIME G.R. No.
SERVICES, INC., W-MARINE INC. AND MR. ELPIDIO C. 218167.
JAMORA, respondents. November 7,
2018.*
180. MARVIN O. DAGUINOD, petitioner, vs. SOUTHGATE FOODS, G.R. No.
INC., represented by MAUREEN O. FERRER and GENERATION 227795.
ONE RESOURCE SERVICE AND MULTI- February 20,
PURPOSE COOPERATIVE,** represented by RESTY CRUZ, 2019.*
respondents.
181. BIGG’S, INC., petitioner, vs. JAY BONCACAS, THELMA DIVINA, G.R. No.
ALLAN DY, CHARVIE NEO, RICHARD SABATER, ARACELI 200487. March
ENRIQUEZ, MA. REBECCA SAN JOSE, ALFREDO ODIAMAR, JR., 6, 2019.*
MICHAEL MAPA, DANTE BAYTA, GLEN REBUSI, RACHELLE MEA,
ALBERT TINASAS, WILHELMN JARDINERO,** JUN LADABAN,
ARLENE COMIA and PURA SABATER, respondents.
182. AIRBORNE MAINTENANCE AND ALLIED SERVICES, INC., G.R. No.
PETITIONER, V. ARNULFO M. EGOS, RESPONDENT. 222748, April
03, 2019 ]
183. ELPIDIO** T. QUE, petitioner, vs. ASIA BREWERY, INC. G.R. No.
and/or MICHAEL G. TAN, respondents. 202388. April
10, 2019.*
184. JEBSENS MARITIME, INC. and/or STAR CLIPPERS, G.R. No.
LTD., petitioners, vs. EDGARDO M. MIRASOL, 213874. June
respondent. 19, 2019.*
185. JOSE ASPIRAS MALICDEM, petitioner, vs. ASIA BULK G.R. No.
TRANSPORT PHILS., INC., INTER-OCEAN COMPANY 224753. June
LIMITED (formerly OCEAN SHIPPING COMPANY) and 19, 2019.*
ERNESTO T. TUVIDA, respondents.
186. ARNULFO M. FERNANDEZ, petitioner, vs. KALOOKAN G.R. No.
SLAUGHTERHOUSE, INCORPORATED**/ERNESTO CUNA-NAN, 225075. June
 respondents. 19, 2019.*
187. THE HERITAGE HOTEL, MANILA, G.R. No.
petitioner, vs. LILIAN SIO, respondent. 217896. June
26, 2019.*
188. RODESSA QUITEVIS RODRIGUEZ, G.R. No.
petitioner, vs. SINTRON SYSTEMS, INC. and/or 240254. July 24,
JOSELITO CAPAQUE, respondents. 2019.*
189. EFREN J. JULLEZA, petitioner, vs. ORIENT LINE G.R. No.
PHILIPPINES, INC., ORIENT NAVIGATION CORPORATION 225190. July 29,
and MACARIO DELA PEÑA, 2019.*
** respondents.
190. JULIETA T. VERZONILLA, petitioner, vs. EMPLOYEES’ G.R. No.
COMPENSATION COMMISSION, respondent. 232888. August
14, 2019.*
191. MAGSAYSAY MARITIME CORPORATION, PRINCESS G.R. No.
CRUISE** LINES LTD., and/or GARY M. CASTILLO, 230901.
petitioners, vs. ALLAN F. BUICO, respondent. December 5,
2019.*
192. NEREN VILLANUEVA, petitioner, vs. GANCO RESORT G.R. No.
AND RECREATION, INC., PETER MARASIGAN, 227175. January
BENJIE MARASIGAN, LUZ MARASIGAN, BOYA 8, 2020.*
MARASIGAN, and SERGE BERNABE, respondents.
193. BSM CREW SERVICE CENTRE PHILIPPINES, INC., PETITIONER, G.R. No.
VS. ROY JASON P. JONES, RESPONDENT. 240518,
December 09,
2020
194. ALBAY ELECTRIC COOPERATIVE, INC. (ALECO) vs ALECO G.R. No.
LABOR EMPLOYEES ORGANIZATION (ALEO) 241437,
September 14,
2020
195. ALBERT · B. DEL ROSARIO,. REYNALDO TUGADE, ROLANDO . G.R. No.
BARRON, 'GEORGE MACASO, · REY I. SANTIAGO, · 202481
ROBERTO B. DEL CASTILLO, PAUL VIRAY, ISMAEL DABLO, consolidated
TOMMY ANACTA, ISAGANI TAOATAO, ROLIO ANDREW. case, September
RA.MANO, ARTHUR DUNGOG, EDWIN SAGUN,.APOLINAR DEL 8, 2020
GRACIA, SENGKLY ESLABRA, ERIC BIGLANG-A WA, REYNALDO
CRUZ, CARLO DIONISIO, ERNESTO CRUZ,
LORENZO ALANO, CRISANTO PANLUBASAN, ROBERTO
SANCHEZ, NELSON LUCAS, and PHILBERT ACHARON,
Petitioners,
- versus -

ABS-CBN BROADCASTING
CORPORATION, Respondent.
196. FACT-FINDING INVESTIGATION BUREAU MILITARY AND G.R. No.
OTHER LAW ENFORCEMENT 218155,
'OFFICES (FFIB-MOLEO), September 22,
Petitioner, vs MAJOR ADELO B. JANDA YAN 2020
(RET.),
POLITICAL LAW
197. LAND BANK OF THE PHILIPPINES, petitioner, vs. SPOUSES G.R. No.
JOSE AMAGAN and AURORA AMAGAN, doing business under the 209794. June
trade name and style “A & J Seafoods and Marine Products,” 27, 2016.*
and JOHN DOE, respondents.
198. LEOVIGILDO A. DE CASTRO, petitioner, vs. FIELD G.R. No.
INVESTIGATION OFFICE, OFFICE OF THE 192723. June 5,
OMBUDSMAN and the COMMISSIONER OF CUSTOMS, 2017.*
respondents.
199. CITY OF BATANGAS, represented by Hon. Severina G.R. No.
Vilma Abaya,1 in her capacity as City Mayor of Batangas, 195003. June 7,
petitioner, vs. PHILIPPINE SHELL PETROLEUM 2017.*
CORPORATION and SHELL PHILIPPINES
EXPLORATION B.V., respondents.
200. DENMARK S. VALMORES, petitioner, vs. DR. CRISTINA G.R. No.
ACHACOSO, in her capacity as Dean of the College of 217453. July
Medicine, and DR. GIOVANNI CABILDO, Faculty of the 19, 2017.*
Mindanao State University, respondents.
201. REPUBLIC OF THE PHILIPPINES, represented by the G.R. No.
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC WORKS AND HIGHWAYS, 204530. July
petitioner, vs. POTENCIANO A. LARRAZABAL, SR., 26, 2017.*
VICTORIA LARRAZABAL LOCSIN and BETTY
LARRAZABAL MACATUAL, respondents.
202. GMA NETWORK, INC., petitioner, vs. NATIONAL G.R. Nos.
TELECOMMUNICATIONS COMMISSION, respondent. 192128 &
192135-36.
September 13,
2017.*
203. PHILIPPINE ASSOCIATION OF DETECTIVE AND G.R. No.
PROTECTIVE AGENCY OPERATORS (PADPAO), 223505.
REGION 7 CHAPTER, INC., petitioner, vs. COMMISSION October 3,
ON ELECTIONS (COMELEC) and/or its COMMITTEE 2017.*
ON THE BAN ON FIREARMS AND SECURITY
PERSONNEL (CBFSP), respondents.
204. GOV. AURORA E. CERILLES, petitioner, vs. CIVIL G.R. No.
SERVICE COMMISSION, ANITA JANGAD-CHUA, MA. 180845.
EDEN S. TAGAYUNA, MERIAM CAMPOMANES,** November 22,
BERNADETTE P. QUIRANTE, MA. DELORA P. FLORES 2017.*
and EDGAR PARAN, respondents.
205. REPUBLIC OF THE PHILIPPINES, represented by the G.R. No.
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC WORKS AND HIGHWAYS 212786. July
(DPWH), petitioner, vs. ESTRELLA R. DECENA, 30, 2018.*
MARIETA DECENA BRAZIL, NOLAND D. BRAZIL,
HEIRS OF EDITA R. DECENA, as represented by
VIRGILIO C. BRAZIL, SR., respondents.
206. PHILIPPINE NATIONAL POLICE-CRIMINAL G.R. Nos.
INVESTIGATION AND DETECTION GROUP (PNP- 219771 &
CIDG), petitioner, vs. P/SUPT.** ERMILANDO O. 219773.
VILLAFUERTE, respondent. September 18,
2018.*
207. COUNCIL OF TEACHERS AND STAFF OF COLLEGES G.R. No.
AND UNIVERSITIES OF THE PHILIPPINES 216930.
(CoTeSCUP), SENTRO NG MGA NAGKAKAISANG October 9,
PROGRESIBONG MGA MANGGAGAWA (SENTRO), 2018.*
FEDERATION OF FREE WORKERS (FFW), NATIONAL
CONFEDERATION OF LABOR (NCL), PUBLIC
 SERVICES LABOR INDEPENDENT CONFEDERATION
(PSLINK), PARTIDO MANGGAGAWA (PM), ADAMSON
UNIVERSITY FACULTY AND EMPLOY EES ASSOCIATION,
FACULTY ALLIED AND WORKER
UNION OF CENTRO ESCOLAR UNIVERSITY,
FACULTY ASSOCIATION MAPUA INSTITUTE OF
TECHNOLOGY, FAR EASTERN UNIVERSITY FACULTY
ASSOCIATION, HOLY ANGEL UNIVERSITY
TEACHERS AND EMPLOYEES UNION, LYCEUM
FACULTY ASSOCIATION, SAN BEDA COLLEGE
ALABANG EMPLOYEES ASSOCIATION, SILIMAN
UNIVERSITY FACULTY ASSOCIATION, UNIVERSITY
OF THE EAST RAMON MAGSAYSAY EMPLOYEES
ASSOCIATION-FFW (UERMEA-FFW), UNION OF
FACULTY AND EMPLOYEES OF ST. LOUIS
UNIVERSITY, UNIVERSITY OF SANTO TOMAS
FACULTY UNION, PROF. FLORDELIZ ABANTO (in her
capacity as Vice President of St. Scholastica’s College
Faculty Association), PROF. REBECCA T. AÑONUEVO (in
her capacity as President of Miriam College Faculty
Association), PROF. MARIA RITA REYES CUCIO (in her
capacity as Faculty of San Beda College), and MR. JOMEL
B. GENERAL (in his capacity as employee of Philippine
School of Business Administration and officer of the FFW),
petitioners, vs. SECRETARY OF EDUCATION,
SECRETARY OF LABOR AND EMPLOYMENT,
CHAIRPERSON OF THE COMMISSION ON HIGHER
EDUCATION, SECRETARY OF THE TECHNICAL
EDUCATION AND SKILLS DEVELOPMENT
AUTHORITY, SECRETARY GENERAL OF THE HOUSE
OF REPRESENTATIVES, and MIRIAM COLLEGE,
respondents.
208. MARLON DOMINGUEZ y ARGANA, G.R. No.
petitioner, vs. PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, 235898. March
respondent. 13, 2019.*
209. PROCESO T. DOMINGO, ANGELITO D. TWAÑO and G.R. Nos.
SUSAN M. SOLO, petitioners, vs. HON. EXECUTIVE 226648-49.
SECRETARY PAQUITO N. OCHOA, JR., respondent. March 27,
2019.*
210. NATIONAL TRANSMISSION CORPORATION, petitioner, G.R. No.
vs. BERMUDA DEVELOPMENT CORPORATION, 214782. April 3,
respondent. 2019.*
211. PERLY TUATES y CHICO, petitioner, vs. PEOPLE OF G.R. No.
THE PHILIPPINES, respondent. 230789. April
10, 2019.*
212. RAMON PICARDAL y BALUYOT, petitioner, vs. PEOPLE OF G.R. No.
THE PHILIPPINES, respondent. 235749. June
19, 2019.*
213. PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, plaintiff- G.R. No.
appellee, vs. DAN DUMANJUG y LOREÑA,** accused- 235468. July 1,
appellant. 2019.*
214. JULIETA T. VERZONILLA, petitioner, vs. EMPLOYEES’ G.R. No.
COMPENSATION COMMISSION, respondent. 232888. August
14, 2019.*
215. PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, plaintiff-appellee, vs. G.R. No.
RODEL VELASCO y LUZON, accused-appellant. 231787. August
19, 2019.*
216. MR HOLDINGS, INC. and MARCOPPER MINING G.R. No.
 CORPORATION, petitioners, vs. ROLANDO A. DE 217837.
JESUS, in his official capacity as the OFFICER-IN- September 4,
CHARGE (OIC)-Regional Director, MINES AND 2019.*
GEOSCIENCES** BUREAU (MGB), Region IV-B
(MIMAROPA) and VICENTE S. PARAGAS, CESO III, in
his official capacity as the Regional Executive Director,
DENR Region IV-B (MIMAROPA), respondents.
217. PAULO JACKSON POLANGCOS y FRANCISCO, G.R. No.
petitioner, vs. PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, 239866.
respondent. September 11,
2019.*
218. PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, plaintiff-appellee, vs. G.R. No.
JOSE RASOS, JR. y PADOLLO @ “JOSE,” accused- 243639.
appellant. September 18,
2019.*
219. REPUBLIC OF THE PHILIPPINES, represented by the G.R. No.
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC WORKS AND HIGHWAYS, 205473.
petitioner, vs. SPOUSES MARCELINO BUNSAY and December 10,
NENITA BUNSAY, respondents. 2019.*
220. RICARIDO** GOLEZ, in his own behalf and his children G.R. No.
CRISPINO GOLEZ, ISIDRO GOLEZ, EMMA G. DE LOS 191376.
SANTOS, HELEN G. CABECO, VICTORIA G. NORBE,*** January 8,
ANTERO GOLEZ, SIMON GOLEZ and GRACE G. 2020.*
BACLAY, in substitution of the deceased PRESENTACION
GOLEZ, petitioners, vs. MARIANO ABAIS,**** respondent.
221. DANGEROUS DRUGS BOARD, petitioner, vs. MARIA G.R. No.
BELEN ANGELITA V. MATIBAG, respondent. 210013.
January 22,
2020.*
222. DANILO ROMERO, VICTORIO ROMERO and EL G.R. No.
ROMERO, representing their deceased father LUTERO 241353.
ROMERO, petitioners, vs. CRISPINA SOMBRINO, January 22,
respondent. 2020.*
223. PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, petitioner, vs. G.R. No.
ROBERTO REY E. GABIOSA, SR., respondent. 248395.
January 29,
2020.*
224. MARIO M. MADERA, BEVERLY G.R. No.
C. MANANGUITE, CARISSA D. 244128,
GALING, AND JOSEFINA 0. September 8,
PELO, vs COMMISSION ON AUDIT (COA) 2020
AND COA REGIONAL OFFICE
NO. VIII,
REMEDIAL LAW
225. REPUBLIC OF THE PHILIPPINES, petitioner, vs. G.R. No.
CAPITAL RESOURCES CORPORATION, ROMEO 217210.
ROXAS, and the REGISTER OF DEEDS OF THE November 7,
PROVINCE OF LA UNION, respondents. 2016.*
226. REPUBLIC OF THE PHILIPPINES, petitioner, vs. G.R. No.
ALFREDO R. DE BORJA, respondent. 187448. January
9, 2017.*
227. SUSAN A. YAP, petitioner, vs. ELIZABETH LAGTAPON, G.R. No.
respondent. 196347. January
23, 2017.*
228. PHILIPPINE BANK OF COMMUNICATIONS, petitioner, G.R. No.
vs. HON. COURT OF APPEALS, HON. HONORIO E. 218901.
GUANLAO, JR., in his capacity as Presiding Judge of the February 15,
Regional Trial Court, Makati City, Branch 56, 2017.*
TRAYELLER KIDS INC., CELY L. GABALDON-CO and
JEANNIE L. LUGMOC, respondents.
229. VICTORIA SEGOVIA, RUEL LAGO, CLARIESSE JAMI G.R. No.
CHAN, representing the CARLESS PEOPLE OF THE 211010. March
PHILIPPINES; GABRIEL ANASTACIO, represented by 7, 2017.*
his mother GRACE ANASTACIO, DENNIS ORLANDO
SANGALANG, represented by his mother MAY ALILI
SANGALANG, MARIA PAULINA CASTAÑEDA,
represented by her mother PATRICIA ANN CASTAÑEDA,
representing the Children of the Philippines and Children
of the Future; and RENATO PINEDA, JR., ARON KERR
MENGUITO, MAY ALILI SANGALANG, and GLYNDA
BATHAN BATERINA, representing Car-Owners who
would rather not have cars if Good Public Transportation
were Safe, Convenient, Accessible and Reliable, petitioners,
vs. THE CLIMATE CHANGE COMMIS SION, represented by its
Chairman, HIS EXCELLENCY
BENIGNO S. AQUINO III, and its COMMISSIONERS
MARY ANN LUCILLE SERING, HEHERSON ALVAREZ
and NADAREV SANO; DEPARTMENT OF
TRANSPORTATION AND COMMUNICATIONS (DOTC)
represented by its Secretary, HONORABLE JOSEPH
ABAYA; DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC WORKS AND
HIGHWAYS (DPWH) AND THE ROAD BOARD,
represented by its Secretary, HONORABLE ROGELIO
SINGSON; DEPARTMENT OF THE INTERIOR AND
LOCAL GOVERNMENT (DILG), represented by its
Secretary, HONORABLE MANUEL ROXAS;
DEPARTMENT OF ENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL
RESOURCES (DENR), represented by its Secretary,
HONORABLE RAMON PAJE; DEPARTMENT OF BUDGET AND
MANAGEMENT (DBM), represented by its
Secretary, HONORABLE FLORENCIO ABAD;
METROPOLITAN MANILA DEVELOPMENT
AUTHORITY (MMDA), represented by its Chairman,
FRANCIS TOLENTINO; DEPARTMENT OF
AGRICULTURE (DA), represented by its Secretary,
HONORABLE PROCESO ALCALA; and JOHN DOES,
representing as yet Unnamed Local Government Units and
their respective Local Chief Executive, Juridical Entities,
and Natural Persons who Fail or Refuse to Implement the
 Law or Cooperate in the Implementation of the Law,
respondents.
230. PHILIPPINE PORTS AUTHORITY (PPA), represented by G.R. No.
Oscar M. Sevilla, General Manager, Benjamin B. Cecilio, 214864. March
Assistant Manager for Operations, and Sisali B. Arap, Port 22, 2017.*
Manager, petitioner, vs. NASIPIT INTEGRATED
ARRASTRE AND STEVEDORING SERVICES, INC.
(NIASSI), represented by Ramon Calo, respondent.
231. JONA BUMATAY, petitioner, vs. LOLITA BUMATAY, G.R. No.
respondent. 191320. April
25, 2017.*
232. SUMIFRU (PHILIPPINES) CORP. (surviving entity of a G.R. No.
merger with Fresh Banana Agricultural Corporation and 202091. June 7,
other corporations), petitioner, vs. NAGKAHIUSANG 2017.*
MAMUMUO SA SUYAPA FARM1 (NAMASUFA-NAFLU-
KMU), respondent.
233. DONALD FRANCIS GAFFNEY, petitioner, vs. GINA V. G.R. No.
BUTLER, respondent. 219408.
November 8,
2017.*
234. PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, plaintiff-appellee, vs. G.R. No.
LIBERATO PENTECOSTES y CRONICO, accused- 226158.
appellant. November 8,
2017.*
235. PUBLIC ATTORNEY’S OFFICE, petitioner, vs. OFFICE OF THE G.R. No.
OMBUDSMAN and ATTY. TERENCIA S. ERNI- 197613.
RIVERA, respondents. November 22,
2017.*
236. LOURDES M. PADAYHAG (or HEIRS OF LOURDES M. G.R. No.
PADAYHAG), petitioner, vs. DIRECTOR OF LANDS and 202872.
SOUTHERN MINDANAO COLLEGES, represented by its November 22,
President, respondents. 2017.*
237. PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, petitioner, vs. AMADO G.R. No.
“JAKE” P. MACASAET,** ENRIQUE P. ROMUALDEZ and JOY 196094. March
P. DELOS REYES (deceased),*** respondents. 5, 2018*
238. ATTY. BERTENI C. CAUSING and PERCIVAL CARAG OCA I.P.I. No.
MABASA, complainants, vs. PRESIDING JUDGE JOSE 17-4663-RTJ.
LORENZO R. DELA ROSA, Regional Trial Court, Branch March 7, 2018.*
4, Manila, respondent.
239. TEE LING KIAT, petitioner, vs. AYALA CORPORATION G.R. No.
(substituted herein by its Assignee and Successor-in- 192530. March
Interest, BIENVENIDO B.M. AMORA, JR.), respondent. 7, 2018.*
240. READY FORM, INCORPORATED, complainant, vs. ATTY. A.C. No. 11774.
EGMEDIO J. CASTILLON, JR., respondent. March 21,
2018.*
(formerly CBD
Case No. 14-
4186)
241. PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, plaintiff- G.R. No.
appellee, vs. RICHAEL LUNA y TORSILINO, accused- 219164. March
appellant. 21, 2018.*
242. HILARIO B. ALILING, petitioner, vs. PEOPLE OF THE G.R. No.
PHILIPPINES, respondent. 230991. June
11, 2018.*
243. CONSOLIDATED DISTILLERS OF THE FAR EAST, G.R. No.
INC., petitioner, vs. ROGEL N. ZARAGOZA, respondent. 229302. June
20, 2018.*
244. LOLITA ESPIRITU SANTO MENDOZA and SPS. G.R. No.
ALEXANDER and ELIZABETH GUTIERREZ, 220517. June
petitioners, vs. SPS. RAMON, SR. and NATIVIDAD 20, 2018.*
PALUGOD, respondents.
245. SM INVESTMENTS CORPORATION, petitioner, vs. MAC G.R. Nos.
GRAPHICS1 CARRANZ INTERNATIONAL CORP., 224131-32. June
respondent. 25, 2018.*
246. MICHAEL V. RACION, petitioner, vs. MST MARINE G.R. No.
SERVICES PHILIPPINES, INC., ALFONSO RANJO DEL 219291. July 4,
CASTILLO and/or THOME SHIP MANAGEMENT, PTE. 2018.*
LTD., respondents.
247. EDITHA S. MEDINA, RAYMOND A. DALANDAN, and G.R. No.
CLEMENTE A. DALANDAN, as their Attorney-in-Fact, 185303. August
petitioners, vs. Sps. NICOMEDES and BRIGIDA LOZADA, 1, 2018.*
respondents.
248. SHERWIN T. GATCHALIAN, petitioner, vs. OFFICE OF G.R. No.
THE OMBUDSMAN and FIELD INVESTIGATION 229288. August
OFFICE OF THE OFFICE OF THE OMBUDSMAN, 1, 2018.*
respondents.
249. PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, plaintiff- G.R. No.
appellee, vs. XXX,**accused-appellant. 205888. August
22, 2018.*
250. JOANNE KRISTINE G. PIMENTEL, petitioner, vs. REY- G.R. No.
NALDO ADIAO, CRISTY** ADIAO-NIERVES and 222678. October
CHRISTIAN ADIAO, respondents. 17, 2018.*
251. PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, plaintiff- G.R. No.
appellee, vs. SEGUNDO BRICERO y FERNANDEZ, 218428.
accused-appellant. November 7,
2018.*
252. JAMES S. PFLEIDER, petitioner, vs. HON. COURT OF G.R. No.
APPEALS-CEBU CITY, ATTY. MARIE LUISE PFLEIDER 196058.
ALBA, as substituted by her heirs, namely: DAVID JOHN November 12,
THADDEUS P. ALBA, FERDINAND REY P. ALBA and 2018.*
JOHANNA A. BILBAO, and the former REGISTER OF
DEEDS OF NEGROS OCCIDENTAL, ATTY. MILAGROS
S. DELA CRUZ, respondents.
253. PHILIPPINE INVESTMENT TWO (SPV-AMC), A.M. No. RTJ-
INCORPORATED, represented by NICANOR M. 18-2538.
COLLADO, complainant, vs. HON. BERNABE B. November 21,
MENDOZA, Presiding Judge, Branch 23, Regional Trial 2018.*
Court (RTC), Roxas, Isabela, respondent.
254. PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, plaintiff- G.R. No.
appellee, vs. BENIE MON y ABARIDES @ “BALENTO,” 235778.
accused-appellant. November 21,
2018.*
255. HEIRS OF GEMINIANO FRANCISCO, as represented by G.R. No.
Orlando Francisco; HEIRS OF MARCIANO FRANCISCO, 215599.
herein represented by Vicente Francisco; HEIRS OF November 28,
ISIDORA DAGALEA, herein represented by Erasmo F. 2018.*
Dagalea; HEIRS OF PRESENTACION F. BRAGANZA,
herein represented by Cirio F. Braganza; IGMIDIO
FRANCISCO, herein represented by Ludgarda F. Limen;
DONATO FRANCISCO, herein represented by Raquel
Gazmin; and PERFECTA F. GARCIA, herein represented
by Maria Luisa G. Gaspar, petitioners, vs. THE HON
COURT OF APPEALS SPECIAL FORMER TWENTY-
SECOND (22nd) DIVISION, WELLINGTON VELASCO,
and his Attorney-in-Fact Dr. Emiliano Torralba,
 respondents.
256. PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, plaintiff- G.R. No.
appellee, vs. DONDON GUERRERO y ELING, accused- 228881.
appellant. February 6,
2019.*
257. LOCAL GOVERNMENT UNIT OF SAN MATEO, G.R. No.
ISABELA, represented by CRISPINA R. AGCAOILI, 214262.
Municipal Mayor, ARMISTACIO VILORIA, BEATRIZ February 13,
RAMOS, JOSEFINA CABANILLA, HONORATO 2019.*
CALANTES, LORNA BUSTO, FLORDELIZA DELOS
TRINOS, ROMEO REGINALDO, GUDIE REGINALDO,
FRANCISCO RICAFORT, FELICIANO AGUSTIN,
REGIDOR DIZON, ISABELO BRILLANTES, OLIVER
MALAPIT, FERNANDO QUIPSE, FLOR VISAYA
CADELIÑA, RUEDA MARQUEZ, MERCEDES CADIZ,
PROCESO CADIZ, ANTONIO MANZANILLO, VIDAL
CADIZ, WILSON VISAYA, NOIMI VDA. DE CADIZ,
GERARDO CABANTUNGAN, LORENZO GANNABAN,
ANTONIO GANNABAN, JOSE SALVADOR, VIRGINIA
SALVADOR, CONSTANTE BURGOS, LORETO JUAN,
LORENZO SIA, ENCARNACION FLORENDO, PAULINA
TABALNO, BENITO FLORENDO, ROGELIO
FLORENDO, ROMULO FLORENDO, JESSIE
CLEMENTE, PEDRO CIRINEO, CRESENCIO BARBASA,
BARTOLOME DURAN, PRIMITIVO SIA, PLACIDO
CUNANAN, REYNALDO CUNANAN, FLAVIANO
CUNANAN, ROGELIO CUNANAN, ANDRES VIERNES,
GERARDO CAYMO, BENJAMIN SANTOS, ISMAEL
ESCOBIA, VICTORIA VDA. DE ESCOBIDO, ABRAHAM
FLORES, MARIA VDA. DE BARBERO, ROMULO
ALCOREZA, VICTORINO LUGA, JR., FRANCISCO
COMA, FABIAN TAGANAS, ROSALINA TAGANAS,
SANTIAGO MANUEL, EDGARDO VISPERAS, CARLITO
JUAN, ARMANDO YAP, MARITES FERRER, MARIANO
FERRER, PERLITO YABUT, DAMIAN FERRER,
NECITAS MARCELINO, BONIFACIO GUILLERMO,
AURELIO CASTILLO, DANILO GONZALES, EPIFANIO
SORIANO, LIWLIWA EPISTOLA, JOEL EPISTOLA,
MAYA FERRER, SANAITA OLA, ROMEO BAUTISTA, ANTONIO
VICTORIA, CARLOS SINAGUB, REYDANTE
RODRIGUEZ, SILVIO DEL ROSARIO, FERNANDO
COMA, FLORDELIZA SALVADOR, NENITA A. ABAD, JERTHEY
PASCUA, TERESITA MATEO, TERESITA
ARELLANO, JAKIE RUIZ, LEONORA PALACIO,
FELICITAS DELOS TRINOS, WINNIE DELOS TRINOS,
PRISILLA MARIANO, LUCILA ALCOREZA, BRUGILDA
BAYSA, MELENCIO DOMINGO, MARTIN CALIGAN,
JESUS G. BERMUDEZ, LEO R. DELOS TRINOS,
CONSTANTE BURGOS, CONSORCIA L. BURGOS,
LAUREANA L. UMIPIG, PEPITO PUCUT, EVARISTO
SORIANO, LOLITO RAMOS, JUANITO TUNGPALAN,
JONATHAN BARANGAN, PATROCINO ALCOREZA,
LINDON BAGAYAN, RAUL FERRER, VIRGILIO
FRANCISCO, ERNESTO PADUA, TERESITA PINTO,
MELANIO PASCUA, RAYMUNDO PRIETO,
FLORENTINO GALASINAO, CRISPULO DATU,
ANGELITA PASCUA, GREG JUANGA, LOLITA REYES,
EDUARDO VELASCO ABAD, SAN MATEO DWELLERS,
 ROMMEL JUANGA, EDGAR GARCIA, JAIME CALIGAN,
SR., RUDY TIMBREZA, DIONICIO FERRER,
INOCENCIO MANUEL, JESUS PALOMO, FE
MENDOZA, OFELIA GAVANES, LITO LAURESTA,
EMELITA TAGUIMCOM, ROBERT YUSON, ELPIDIO
MACALANDA, ROGELIO RIVERA, ANDRES ANTOLIN,
ERNESTO ADION, ICHAEL ADION, JUANITO IDOS,
ROSALIA SINAGUB, ROMY YUSON, WILSON YUSON,
DELIA GARO, MANUEL CASTRO, SR., AURELIO
TUMAMAO, LOLITO RAMONES, BERNARD REGANIT,
CATALINO ABAD, MARTIN CALIGAN, RELY ROY
PESING MARIANO, BRIGIDA BAYSON, ALICE
CORTEZ, GIL TENEFRANCIA, EVELYN GARCIA, JESS
MARTINES, FEMIA JUANGA, MAGDALENA
BENONILLA, GERRY V. ROY, JUANITO TUNGPALAN,
JR., GEORGE BARBOZA, LITO SANTIAGO, JAIME ROY,
CESARIO MALLARI ROY, LOLITA TOLENTINO, MARVI
ROY, BENJAMIN RETOTAR, JOSEPHINE MANEJA,
PETRONILA SINOTO, ESTELITA PUCUT, LUISITO FERNANDEZ,
MANUEL ENCARNACION, JULIE RUIZ, GAUDENCIO SOLOMON,
MARITES YANOS, JEFFERSON SANIDAD, JAIME
GAUIRAN, ELMER YUZON, RODRIGO CASTILLO, SR.,
FLORENCIO BLANCHE, NELSON YUSON, MARY ANN
RUMBAOA, TIOFILO SARABIA, AMADO GAMINO,
REMEDIOS ROQUE, CARLITO VILORIA, RODOLFO
SAMBRANO, EMILIO DE LEON, TERESITA SUMAWAY,
WILLY BAQUIL, MERILOU BAQUIL, MARIA MARTIN,
EDITHA SINAGUB, LORETO SOLOMON, ALBERTO
LADERAS, LEONORA OLA, petitioners, vs. ESTEFANIA
MIGUEL VDA. DE GUERRERO, respondent.
258. D.M. CONSUNJI, INC., petitioner, vs. REPUBLIC OF G.R. No.
THE PHILIPPINES and THE HEIRS OF JULIAN CRUZ, 233339.
represented by MACARIA CRUZ ESTACIO, respondents. February 13,
2019.*
259. PILLARS PROPERTY CORPORATION, G.R. No.
petitioner, vs. CENTURY COMMUNITIES 201021. March
CORPORATION, respondent. 4, 2019.*
260. JESUS CONCEPCION y TABOR a.k.a. “BAKLA/BONG,” G.R. No.
petitioner, vs. PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, 243345. March
respondent. 11, 2019.*
261. SPOUSES EDILBERTO & EVELINE POZON; G.R. No.
EDILBERTO POZON, deceased, substituted by his heirs, 210607. March
namely, wife EVELINE POZON and daughters 25, 2019.*
GERALDINE MICHELLE POZON and ANGELICA
EMILIA POZON, petitioners, vs. DIANA
JEANNE** LOPEZ, respondent.
262. FIL-ESTATE MANAGEMENT, INC., MEGATOP REALTY G.R. No.
DEVELOPMENT, INC., PEAKSUN ENTERPRISES AND 192393. March
EXPORT CORPORATION, ARTURO E. DY and ELENA 27, 2019.*
DY JAO, petitioners, vs. REPUBLIC OF THE
PHILIPPINES and SPOUSES SANTIAGO T. GO,** and
NORMA C. GO, represented by their son and Attorney-in-
Fact, KENDRICK C. GO, respondents.
263. FILIPINAS ESLON MANUFACTURING CORP., G.R. No.
petitioner, vs. HEIRS OF BASILIO LLANES, namely: 194114. March
CASIANO LLANES, DOMINGO LLANES, FABIAN 27, 2019.*
LLANES, VICTORINA L. TAGALIMOT, PACENCIA L.
MANALES, NORMA L. BACALARES, LOURDES L.
 PAJARDO, JOSEPHINE LLANES, JOSEFA LLANES and
JOVENCITA LLANES; ROLYNWIN Q. LAMSON;
PHILIPPINE AMANAH BANK, also known as AL AMANAH
ISLAMIC INVESTMENT BANK OF THE
PHILIPPINES; SPOUSES MEDEL and CARMEN
JUSTINIANO a.k.a. CARMEN & MEDEL JUSTINIANO;
RUFINO V. GENILO; MARIA SOL A. SEVESES;
SPOUSES SALVADOR and CHEQUETHELMA GERONA;
CRESOGONO R. SEVESES, MONERA M. LALANTO;
CLAUDIO M. CLOSAS; SPOUSES SERAFIN and ELSA
FERRAREN; EDILBERTO V. PAZA** and GENEROSO
EMPUESTO, respondents.
264. UNITED COCONUT PLANTERS BANK, G.R. No.
petitioner, vs. SPS. ALISON ANG-SY and GUILLERMO 204753. March
SY, RENATO ANG, NENA ANG, RICKY ANG, and 27, 2019.*
DERICK CHESTER SY, respondents.
265. PUERTO DEL SOL PALAWAN, INC., petitioner, vs. HON. G.R. No.
KISSACK B. GABAEN, Regional Hearing Officer, Regional 212607. March
Hearing Office IV, National Commission on Indigenous 27, 2019.*
Peoples and ANDREW ABIS, respondents.
266. VICTORIA** T. FAJARDO, petitioner, vs. BELEN CUA- G.R. No.
MALATE, respondent. 213666. March
27, 2019.*
267. CARMELITA V. DIZON, petitioner, vs. JOSE LUIS K. MATTI, G.R. No.
JR., respondent. 215614. March
27, 2019.*
268. DAVAO ACF BUS LINES, INC., petitioner, vs. ROGELIO G.R. No.
ANG, respondent. 218516. March
27, 2019.*
269. SEVERINO A. YU, RAMON A. YU, and LORENZO A. YU, G.R. No.
petitioners, vs. DAVID MIRANDA, MORNING STAR 225752. March
HOMES CHRISTIAN ASSOCIATION-SAN JOSE BIÑAN- 27, 2019.*
HOMEOWNERS ASSOCIATION, INC., TIMMY
RICHARD T. GABRIEL, and LILIBETH GABRIEL,
respondents.
270. REPUBLIC OF THE PHILIPPINES, represented by the G.R. No.
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC WORKS AND HIGHWAYS 199705. April 3,
(DPWH), petitioner, vs. ROGUZA DEVELOPMENT 2019.*
CORPORATION, respondent.
271. WILFREDO CABUGUAS, RENATO CABUGUAS, ALEJANDRO G.R. No.
"TABOY" CANETE AND ELEAZAR MORTOS, • PETITIONERS, VS. 219915, April
GALLANTS. TAN NERY, •• REPRESENTED BY KATHERINE TAN 03, 2019
NERY-TOLEDO, RESPONDENT.
272. VALENCIA (BUKIDNON) FARMERS COOPERATIVE MARKETING G.R. No.
ASSOCIATION, INC., REPRESENTED BY THE BOARD OF 219984, April
DIRECTORS OF FARMERS COOPERATIVE MARKETING 03, 2019
ASSOCIATION (FACOMA) AS TRUSTEES, HEREIN
REPRESENTED BY DAVID M. PORTICOS, BOARD CHAIRMAN,
PETITIONER, VS. HEIRS OF AMANTE P. CABOTAJE, NAMELY:
ESTHER M. CABOTAJE, AMANTE M. CABOTAJE, JR., JULINDA M.
CABOTAJE, FERNANDO
M. CABOTAJE, CHRISTINA IMELDA M. CABOTAJE-NELAM, ALL
HEREIN REPRESENTED BY ESTHER M. CABOTAJE,
RESPONDENTS.
273. MA. CARMEN ROSARIO ABILLA,* PETITIONER, VS. PEOPLE OF G.R. No.
THE PHILIPPINES, RESPONDENT. 227676, April
03, 2019
274. GENEROSO SEPE, PETITIONER, VS. HEIRS OF ANASTACIA G.R. No.
 *KILANG, REP. BY HER CHILDREN MARIA, DONATA, 199766, April
FELICIANA, 10, 2019
DOMINGA AND SEVERO ALL SURNAMED SOLIJON,
RESPONDENTS.
275. SPOUSES JOSE and CORAZON RODRIGUEZ, G.R. No.
petitioners, vs. HOUSING AND LAND USE 183324. June
REGULATORY BOARD (HLURB), SPS. JOHN 19, 2019.*
SANTIAGO and HELEN KING, IMELDA ROGANO and
SPS. BONIE GAMBOA and NANCY GAMBOA,
represented by JOHN SANTIAGO, respondents.
276. YOUNG BUILDERS CORPORATION, G.R. No.
petitioner, vs. BENSON INDUSTRIES, INC., respondent. 198998. June
19, 2019.*
277. ILUMINADA C. BERNARDO, petitioner, vs. ANA MARIE G.R. No.
B. SORIANO, respondent. 200104. June
19, 2019.*
278. MARIA NYMPHA MANDAGAN, petitioner, vs. JOSE M. G.R. No.
VALERO CORPORATION, respondent. 215118. June
19, 2019.*
279. ALFREDO PILI, JR., petitioner, vs. MARY ANN G.R. No.
RESURRECCION, respondent. 222798. June
19, 2019.*
280. RCBC BANKARD SERVICES CORPORATION, G.R. No.
petitioner, vs. MOISES ORACION, JR. and EMILY** L. 223274. June
ORACION, respondents. 19, 2019.*
281. TRADE AND INVESTMENT DEVELOPMENT G.R. No.
CORPORATION OF THE PHILIPPINES also known as 233850. July 1,
PHILIPPINE EXPORT-IMPORT CREDIT AGENCY, 2019.*
petitioner, vs. PHILIPPINE VETERANS BANK,
respondent.
282. PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, plaintiff- G.R. No.
appellee, vs. EDSON BARBAC RETADA, accused- 239331. July 10,
appellant. 2019.*
283. IN RE: THE WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS FOR MICHAEL G.R. No.
LABRADOR 232006, July 10,
ABELLANA (PETITIONER, DETAINED AT THE NEW BILIBID 2019 ]
PRISONS, MUNTINLUPA CITY), VS. HON. MEINRADO P.
PAREDES, IN HIS CAPACITY AS PRESIDING JUDGE, REGIONAL
TRIAL COURT OF CEBU CITY BRANCH 13, PEOPLE OF THE
PHILIPPINES, S/SUPTBENJAMIN DELOS SANTOS (RET.), IN HIS
CAPACITY AS CHIEF OF BUREAU OF CORRECTIONS,
RESPONDENTS.
284. HEIRS OF LEONARDA NADELA TOMAKIN, namely: G.R. No.
LUCAS NADELA, OCTAVIO N. TOMAKIN, ROMEO N. 223624. July 17,
TOMAKIN, MA. CRISTETA** T. PANOPIO and 2019.*
CRESCENCIO*** TOMAKIN, JR. (deceased), represented
by his heirs, BARBARA JEAN R. TOMAKIN
RAFOLS**** and CRISTINA JEAN R. TOMAKIN,
petitioners, vs. HEIRS OF CELESTINO NAVARES,
namely: ERMINA N. JACA, NORMITA NAVARES,
FELINDA N. BALLENA, RHODORA N. SINGSON,
CRISTINA N. CAL ORTIZ, ROCELYN N. SENCIO,
JAIME B. NAVARES, CONCHITA N. BAYOT, PROCULO
NAVARES, LIDUVINA N. VALLE, MA. DIVINA N. ABIS, VENUSTO
B. NAVARES and RACHELA N. TAHIR, respondents.
285. PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, plaintiff- G.R. No.
appellee, vs. WILLIAM CEPEDA y DULTRA** and LOREN DY y 229833. July 29,
SERO, accused, LOREN DY y SERO, accused-appellant. 2019.*
286. PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, plaintiff- G.R. No.
appellee, vs. ROLANDO SOLAR y DUMBRIQUE, accused- 225595. August
appellant. 6, 2019.*
287. REPUBLIC OF THE PHILIPPINES, represented by DR. G.R. No.
RUBINA O. CRESENCIO, OFFICER-IN-CHARGE of the 201273. August
BUREAU OF ANIMAL INDUSTRY and MARILYN V. 14, 2019.*
STA. CATALINA, OFFICER-IN-CHARGE,
DEPARTMENT OF AGRICULTURE - REGIONAL FIELD
UNIT - CORDILLERA ADMINISTRATIVE REGION (DA
RFU-CAR), petitioner, vs. HEIRS OF IKANG PAUS,
namely: (1) OLARTE A. PAUS, SR., (2) HEIRS OF DAVID
PAUS, represented by PETER PAUS, (3) JOSEPHINE
BASIL, (4) HEIRS OF MACARIO A. PAUS, SR.,
represented by NORBERTO D. PAUS, (5) HEIRS OF
MONTO PAUS, represented by ELIAS PAUS, SR., and (6)
HEIRS OF FORBASCO PAUS, represented by DOLOR
PAUS MALLARE, THE REGISTRY OF DEEDS OF
BAGUIO CITY, represented by its REGISTRAR, ATTY.
JUANITO K. AMPAGUEY, THE NATIONAL
COMMISSION ON INDIGENOUS PEOPLES, represented by its
CHAIRPERSON, ZENAIDA BRIGIDA HAMADA-
PAWID, THE LAND REGISTRATION AUTHORITY, represented by
its ADMINISTRATOR, BENEDICTO B.
ULEP, and HONORABLE CLETO R. VILLACORTA III,
PRESIDING JUDGE, BRANCH 6, REGIONAL TRIAL
COURT, BAGUIO CITY, respondents.
288. HEIRS OF SATRAMDAS V. SADHWANI and KISHNIBAI G.R. No.
S. SADHWANI, represented by RAMCHAND S. 217365. August
SADHWANI and RAJAN S. SADHWANI, 14, 2019.*
petitioners, vs. GOP S. SADHWANI and KANTA G.
SADHWANI, UNION BANK OF THE PHILIPPINES,
PHILIPPINE SAVINGS BANK, and REGISTER OF
DEEDS OF MAKATI, respondents.
289. PAZ MANDINTROTIN,** petitioner, vs. FRANCISCO A. G.R. No.
BONGO, SABINA BONGO-BUNTAG and ARTEMIA 212840. August
BONGO-LIQUIT, respondents. 28, 2019.*
290. DR. RUBEN C. BARTOLOME, petitioner, vs. REPUBLIC G.R. No.
OF THE PHILIPPINES, respondent. 243288. August
28, 2019.*
291. PNOC ALTERNATIVE FUELS CORPORATION, G.R. No.
petitioner, vs. NATIONAL GRID CORPORATION OF THE 224936.
PHILIPPINES, respondent. September 4,
2019.*
292. PAULO JACKSON POLANGCOS y FRANCISCO, G.R. No.
petitioner, vs. PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, 239866.
respondent. September 11,
2019.*
293. XXX,** petitioner, vs. PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, G.R. No.
respondent. 242101.
September 16,
2019.*
294. PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, plaintiff-appellee, vs. G.R. No.
JOSE RASOS, JR. y PADOLLO @ “JOSE,” accused- 243639.
appellant. September 18,
2019.*
295. SIMEONA, GLORIA and RODOLFO (all surnamed PRESCILLA), G.R. No.
ARMENTINA PRESCILLA-PERDES, HERMINIA PRESCILLA- 205805.
CARANDANG, ZENAIDA PRESCILLA-MANUEL and YOLANDA September 25,
 PRESCILLA-MARCIANO, petitioners, vs. CONRADO O. LASQUITE 2019.*
and JUANITO L. ANDRADE, respondents.
296. SPS. LINO REBAMONTE, substituted by his compulsory G.R. No.
heirs namely: LUZVIMINDA R. PANISA, TERYLI M. 237812. October
REBAMONTE, NAIDA R. CERVANTES, JOEREL M. 2, 2019.*
REBAMONTE and heirs of JEMUEL M. REBAMONTE,
represented by JUDITH ANN O. REBAMONTE, and
TERESITA M. REBAMONTE, petitioners, vs. SPS.
GUILLERMO LUCERO and GENOVEVA S. LUCERO,
respondents.
297. PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, plaintiff-appellee, vs. G.R. No.
NOEL DOLANDOLAN, accused-appellant. 232157. January
8, 2020.*
298. ATTY. AROLF M. ANCHETA, petitioner, vs. FELOMINO G.R. No.
C. VILLA, respondent. 229634. January
15, 2020.*
299. THE HEIRS OF MARSELLA T. LUPENA (in substitution G.R. No.
of MARSELLA T. LUPENA), petitioners, vs. PASTORA 231639. January
MEDINA, JOVITO PAGSISIHAN, CENON PATRICIO, 22, 2020.*
and BERNARDO DIONISIO, respondents.
300. *PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, PLAINTIFF-APPELLEE, VS. G.R. No.
JERRY 244045, June
SAPLA Y GUERRERO A.K.A. ERIC SALIBAD Y MALLARI, 16, 2020
ACCUSED-
APPELLANT.
301. MARTIN ROBERTO G. TIROL vs SOL NOLASCO G.R. No.
230103, August
27, 2020
302. VIRGILIO A. BOTE v SAN PEDRO CINEPLEX G.R. No.
PROPERTIES, INC., 203471,
September 14,
2020
LEGAL ETHICS
303. JUDGE GREGORIO D. PANTANOSAS, JR., complainant, vs. A.C. No. 7330.
ATTY. ELLY L. PAMATONG, respondent. June 14, 2016.*
304. AURORA AGUILAR-DYQUIANGCO, complainant, vs. A.C. No. 10541.
ATTY. DIANA LYNN M. ARELLANO, respondent. July 12, 2016.*
(formerly CBD
Case No. 11-
3046)

305. ARTHUR O. MONARES, complainant, vs. ATTY. LEVI P. A.C. No. 5582.
MUÑOZ, respondent. January 24,
2017.*
306. ORLANDO S. CASTELO, ELENA C. CAMA, OSWALDO A.C. No. 11165.
CASTELO, JOCELYN LLANILLO, and BENJAMIN February 6,
CASTELO, complainants, vs. ATTY. RONALD 2017.*
SEGUNDINO C. CHING, respondent.
307. EMMA G. ALFELOR, complainant, vs. HON. AUGUSTUS A.M. No. MTJ-
C. DIAZ, Presiding Judge, Metropolitan Trial Court, 16-1883. July
Branch 37, Quezon City, respondent. 11, 2017.*
(formerly OCA
I.P.I. No. 12-
2497-MTJ)
308. SPOUSES FELIX and FE NAVARRO, complainants, vs. A.C. No. 8450.
ATTY. MARGARITO G. YGOÑA, respondent. July 26, 2017.*
309. ROLANDO SOLIVA, complainant, vs. REYNALDO A.M. No. P-16-
TALEON, Sheriff IV, Regional Trial Court, Branch 10, 3511.
Dipolog City, Zamboanga del Norte, respondent. September 6,
2017.*
310. FERDINAND E. TAURO, Court Interpreter, Regional Trial A.M. No. P-17-
Court, Branch 122, Caloocan City, complainant, vs. 3731. November
RACQUEL O. ARCE, Clerk III, Regional Trial Court, 8, 2017.*
Branch 122, Caloocan City, respondent.
311. DOMINADOR I. FERRER, JR., complainant, vs. JUDGE A.M. No. RTJ-16-
ARNIEL A. DATING, Regional Trial Court, Branch 41, 2478. November
Daet, Camarines Norte, respondent. 8, 2017.*
312. OFFICE OF THE COURT ADMINISTRATOR, A.M. No. P-15-
complainant, vs. MR. ALDEN P. COBARRUBIAS,** Clerk 3379. November
III; and MR. VLADIMIR*** A. BRAVO, Court Interpreter 22, 2017.*
II, both of Metropolitan Trial Court [MeTC], Branch 24,
Manila, respondents.
313. EDGAR R. ERICE, complainant, vs. PRESIDING JUDGE A.M. No. RTJ-15-
DIONISIO C. SISON, Regional Trial Court, Branch 125, 2407. November
Caloocan City, respondent. 22, 2017.*
314. ISAGANI R. RUBIO, complainant, vs. IGMEDIO J. OCA I.P.I. No.
BASADA, Court Legal Researcher II, Branch 117, Regional 15-4429-P.
Trial Court (RTC), Pasay City, respondent. December 6,
2017.*
315. PROSECUTOR LEO T. CAHANAP, complainant, vs. A.M. No. RTJ-16-
JUDGE LEONOR S. QUIÑONES, Regional Trial Court, 2470. January
Branch 6, Iligan City, Lanao del Norte, respondent. 10, 2018.*
316. ATTY. MELVIN M. MIRANDA, complainant, vs. A.M. No. MTJ-
PRESIDING JUDGE WILFREDO G. OCA, Municipal Trial 17-1899. March
Court, Real, Quezon (former Acting Presiding Judge, 7, 2018.*
Metropolitan Trial Court, Branch 71, Pasig City),
 respondent.
317. REPUBLIC OF THE PHILIPPINES, petitioner, vs. ALVIN G.R. No.
C. DIMARUCOT and NAILYN TAÑEDO-DIMARUCOT, 202069. March
respondents. 7, 2018.*
318. ATTY. MAKILITO B. MAHINAY, complainant, vs. HON. A.M. No. RTJ-18-
RAMON B. DAOMILAS, JR., Presiding Judge, and ATTY. 2527. June 18,
ROSADEY E. FAELNAR-BINONGO, Clerk of Court V, 2018.*
both of Branch 11, Regional Trial Court, Cebu City, Cebu,
respondents.
319. PELAGIO VICENCIO SORONGON, JR., A.C. No. 11326.
complainant, vs. ATTY. RAMON Y. GARGANTOS,1 SR., June 27, 2018.*
respondent.
320. COCA-COLA BOTTLERS PHILS., INC., petitioner, vs. G.R. No.
ERNANI GUINGONA MEÑEZ, respondent. 209906.
November 22,
2017.*
321. PHILIPPINE AMUSEMENT AND GAMING G.R. Nos.
CORPORATION (PAGCOR), petitioner, vs. THE 210689-90.
COMMISSIONER OF INTERNAL REVENUE and THE November 22,
HEAD REVENUE EXECUTIVE ASSISTANT, LARGE 2017.*
TAXPAYER SERVICE, in their official capacities as
Officers of the Bureau of Internal Revenue, respondents.
322. MARTIN J. SIOSON, complainant, vs. ATTY. DIONISIO A.C. No. 12044.
B. APOYA, JR., respondent. July 23, 2018.*
323. ATTY. CARLOS D. CINCO, complainant, vs. PRESIDING A.M. No. RTJ-16-
JUDGE ALFONSO C. RUIZ II, Regional Trial Court, 2482. August
Branch 216, Quezon City, respondent. 15, 2018.*
324. ROLANDO N. UY, complainant, vs. ATTY. EDMUNDO J. A.C. No. 11826.
APUHIN, respondent. September 5,
2018.*
325. CARLOS V. LOPEZ, complainant, vs. ATTY. MILAGROS A.C. No. 12146.
ISABEL A. CRISTOBAL, respondent. October 10,
2018.*
326. GOV. EDGARDO A. TALLADO, complainant, vs. HON. A.M. No. RTJ-18-
WINSTON S. RACOMA, Presiding Judge, Branch 39, 2536. October
Regional Trial Court (RTC), Daet, Camarines Norte, 10, 2018.*
respondent.
327. ASUNCION Y. ARIÑOLA, complainant, vs. ANGELES D. A.M. No. P-19-
ALMODIEL, JR., Interpreter II, Municipal Trial Court in 3925. January 7,
Cities, Masbate City, Masbate, respondent. 2019.*
328. ROLANDO T. KO, complainant, vs. ATTY. ALMA UY- A.C. No. 11584.
LAMPASA, respondent. March 6, 2019.*
329. MARILYN PABALAN, complainant, vs. ATTY. ELISEO MAGNO A.C. No. 12098.
C. SALVA, respondent. March 20,
2019.*
330. LUCITA S. PARDILLO, petitioner, vs. DR. EVELYN G.R. No.
DUCAY BANDOJO, Owner and Medical Director of E & R 224854. March
Hospital, respondent. 27, 2019.*
331. RE: INVESTIGATION REPORT OF JUDGE ENRIQUE A.M. No. 15-09-
TRESPECES ON THE 25 FEBRUARY 2015 INCIDENT 102-MTCC. June
INVOLVING UTILITY WORKER I MARION M. 26, 2019.*
DURBAN, MUNICIPAL TRIAL COURT IN CITIES, BR. 9,
ILOILO CITY, ILOILO.
332. PRESIDING JUDGE AIDA ESTRELLA MACAPAGAL, A.C. No. 9298.
REGIONAL TRIAL COURT, BR. 195, PARAÑAQUE CITY, July 29, 2019.*
complainant, vs. ATTY. WALTER T. YOUNG, respondent.
333. CARMELITA CANETE, complainant, vs. ATTY. A.C. No. 10949.
 ARTEMIO PUTI, respondent. August 14,
2019.*
334. THE MERCANTILE INSURANCE CO., INC., petitioner, G.R. No.
vs. DMCI-LAING CONSTRUCTION, INC.,** respondent. 205007.
September 16,
2019.*
335. REPUBLIC OF THE PHILIPPINES, represented by the G.R. No.
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC WORKS AND HIGHWAYS, 203948. January
petitioner, vs. LEONOR A. MACABAGDAL, represented by 22, 2020.*
EULOGIA MACABAGDAL-PASCUAL, respondent.
336. SEVENTH FLEET SECURITY SERVICES, INC., G.R. No.
petitioner, vs. RODOLFO B. LOQUE, respondent. 230005. January
22, 2020.*