Unit 9 Social Welfare: Concept, Approaches and Policies : Structure
Unit 9 Social Welfare: Concept, Approaches and Policies : Structure
Unit 9 Social Welfare: Concept, Approaches and Policies : Structure
9.0 OBJECTIVES
After reading this Unit, you should be able to:
Understand the concept and importance of social welfare;
Describe the constitutional provisions with regard to weaker sections of
society in India; and
Evaluate the main polices and legislation relating to women and children in
India.
9.1 INTRODUCTION
India, like many other countries, is a committed to the welfare of its people. The
Constitution of India - - through its Preamble, the provisions on Fundamental
Rights and Directive Principles of State Policy - - and several central and state
legislations and national policies seek to provide to the people of India a wide
range of services to meet their social, economic, and educational and health
needs.
* Contributed by Dr. R.K. Sapru, Professor of Public Administration (Retired), Panjab University,
Chandigarh 119
Social Welfare Though law and order and tax collection have been the primary functions of the
Administrations
state social welfare has become its major responsibility in the 20th and 21
centuries, especially in democratic countries. Indeed, the modern state has
assumed the role of an agent of social-economic change. The necessity for the
state to assume a dominant role in welfare field was recognised in the First Five-
Year Plan, which pronounced: “As the social structure becomes more complex,
the state is called upon to play an increasing role providing service for the welfare
of the people”. In fact, this welfare function absorbs a steadily growing share of
the resources of the state. It is, therefore, important for the government to meet
basic needs of individuals, especially the weaker sections of society.
The concept of social welfare and its scope of operation vary from country to
country, depending upon their stage of historical development, the degree of
prominence given to development and welfare goals and the evolution of state
structures for delivery of services. Encyclopaedia Britannica defines social welfare
as a system of laws and institutions through which a government attempts to
protect and promote the economic and social welfare of its citizens, usually based
on various forms of social insurance against unemployment, accident, illness
and old age. According to Friedlander social welfare consists of the organised
services and institutions, designed to aid individuals and groups to attain satisfying
standards of life and health, and personal and social relationships which permit
them to develop their full capacities and to promote their well-being in harmony
with the needs of their families and the community (Friedlandar, 1967).
Wayne Vasey notes that social welfare includes two main characteristics – (a)
the utilisation of welfare measures to support or strengthen the family as a basic
social institution through which needs are met, and (b) the intent to strengthen
the individual’s capacity to cope with his life situation (Vasey, 1958).
But the family approach has some limitations. One of them is the near extinction
of the extended family system, more so in the urban areas. Secondly, it does not
look at the role of gender in the family. Thirdly, there are financial and spatial
issues, which constrain universalistic reliance on the family approach.
The residual approach is followed in a few countries only. It suffers from many
limitations; chief among them is the ‘means’ or eligibility test. Fulfilling the
residency requirements becomes problematic for the beneficiaries if the schemes
are intended for the residents of a given state or ‘territory’ in a federal system.
The residual approach does not also touch issues like housing shortage. In this
approach, the benefits for the needy are very few and even the eligible recipients
get discouraged to go after them.
In this model, public and private sectors come together in managing welfare
policies in a more efficient manner than in a bureaucracy-centric operation.
However, a major limitation of this approach is that public-private partnerships
do not operate in many countries in the best possible manner.
The institutional approach appears to be elegant, but many people would not
extend support to this approach and pool their resources, just as the way they do
for community works. In practice, the institutional approach to social welfare,
therefore, lacks adequate public support, except in the spheres of education and
health.
Check Your Progress 1
Note: i) Use the space given below for your answers.
ii) Check your answers with those given at the end of the Unit.
1) Define the concept of social welfare and discuss its significance.
.......................................................................................................................
.......................................................................................................................
.......................................................................................................................
.......................................................................................................................
122
2) Examine various approaches to social welfare. Social Welfare: Concept,
Approaches and Policies
.......................................................................................................................
.......................................................................................................................
.......................................................................................................................
.......................................................................................................................
The Protection of Civil Rights Act, 1955: This Act was enacted in pursuance of
Article 17 of the Constitution of India under Fundamental Rights. The Act extends
to the whole of India and is implemented by the state governments and union
territories.
The Act and the Rules framed under it prescribe the scale of punishments for
various categories of offences relating to the propagation or practice of
untouchability in any form. The punishments invariably include a prison term
and fine. Any person who justifies, whether on historical, philosophical, cultural
or religious grounds or any other ground, the practice of untouchability in any
form shall be considered as an offender. Repeaters of the offence shall get more
stringent punishments.
123
Social Welfare ii) National Commission for Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes: In addition
Administrations
to these two Acts, the National Commission for SCs and STs (NCSC) which
was set up under Article 383 of the Constitution in 1990 was bifurcated into
two Commissions, namely, National Commission for Scheduled Castes and
National Commission for Scheduled Tribes after the 89th Constitutional
(Amendment) Act, 2003. These two Commissions are responsible for
monitoring the safeguards provided for SCs & STs respectively. Further,
they have to review issues concerning their welfare.
For the educational advancement of SC & ST students there are schemes such as
Pre-matric scholarships, National Overseas Scholarships, Babu Jagjivan Ram
Chhatrawas Yojana, Rajiv Gandhi National Fellowships. In most of the states
and UTs hostel facilities are provided for them from KG to PG level. The central
schemes are also supplemented by other allowances so that the entire expenditure
of SC/ST students is taken care of.
There are also scheduled castes development corporations in states and UTs,
besides a National Scheduled Castes Finance and Development Corporation,
and a National Safari Armchairs Finance and Development Corporation. There
are also a Venture Capital Fund and a Credit Enhancement Guarantee Scheme
for Scheduled Castes to extend financial support and seed capital to them in
start-ups of enterprises or other industrial ventures.
With a view to safeguarding the interests of Scheduled Tribes with regard to land
alienation and other social factors, provisions of the “Fifth Schedule” and “Sixth
Schedule” have been enshrined in the Constitution. The Fifth Schedule under
Article 244 (1) of Constitution defines “Scheduled Areas” as such areas as the
President may by Order declare to be Scheduled Areas after consultation with
the Governor of the state. The Sixth Schedule under Article 244(2) of the
Constitution relates to those areas in the states of Assam, Meghalaya, Tripura
and Mizoram which are declared as “Tribal Areas” and provides for District
Councils and /or Regional Councils for such Areas. With a view to later to the
welfare of STs. These Councils have been conferred with wide ranging legislative,
judicial and executive powers.
Scheduled Castes and the Scheduled Tribes (Prevention of Atrocities) Act, 1989:
As noted earlier, the purpose of this Act is to prevent commission of offences
against scheduled castes and scheduled tribes. Its scope and operation in the
case of STs are similar to that of the SCs.
Then there are schemes for the economic development of ST women and micro-
credit schemes to provide financial assistance for self-employment ventures/
activities by STs. There is also a scheme for providing financial assistance to ST
students for pursuing higher studies and for post-doctoral research programmes
abroad. The Ministry of Tribal Affairs also provides adequate educational
infrastructure for STs and several incentives including scholarships for education
of ST students. By enacting the Forest Rights Act, 2006, the STs and other
traditional forest dwellers are vested with forest rights and allowed occupation
of forest land.
With a view to give focused attention to different policy issues and meaningful
thrust to the activities aimed at welfare and empowerment of the persons with 125
Social Welfare disabilities, a separate Department of Disability Affairs was carved out of the
Administrations
Ministry of Social Justice and Empowerment in 2012. This Department now
acts as a nodal agency for matters relating to disability and persons with disabilities
besides enabling closer coordination among different stakeholders: related central
ministries, state/UT governments, NGOs etc., in matters pertaining to disability.
Thus the Indian Constitution protects the interests of, persons suffering from
certain disabilities.
The Rehabilitation Council of India (RCI) is a statutory body and is the apex
body of the Union Government to regulate training programmes and courses
targeted at disabled, disadvantaged, and special education requirement
communities. The Council is required to maintain the Central Rehabilitation
Register which mainly documents details of all qualified professionals in this
field.
In the Sixth Plan, there was a shift in the approach from ‘welfare’ to ‘development’
of women, with special emphasis on the three core sectors of health, education
and employment. The Seventh Plan stressed on raising their economic and social
status, with a focus on beneficiary oriented schemes and the generation of both
skilled and unskilled employment though proper education and vocational
training. One of the objectives of the Eighth Plan was to ensure that the benefits
of development would flow to women to enable them to function as equal partners
and participants in the development process Besides a focus on the
“Empowerment of Women”, theNinth Plan worked out a Women’s Component
Plan’. Gender budget was introduced in 2007.
To deal with child abuse cases the Government has brought a special law “The
Protection of Children from Sexual Offences Act, 2012. The Act provides for
stringent punishment, which ranges from simple to rigorous imprisonment of
varying periods. The National Commission for the Protection of Child Rights
(NCPCR) and State Commissions for the Protection of Child Rights (SCPCRs)
have been made the designated authority to monitor the implementation of the
Act.
National Nutrition Policy
The National Nutrition Policy was formulated in 1993, and as a follow up the
National Plan of Action was developed in 1995. The National Plan of Action
identified the different sectors in the government for taking up coordinated action
to combat malnutrition.
In addition to the above, the National Plan of Action for Children (N P A C) was
introduced in 2016, which keys upon four priority areas: survival; health and
nutrition; education and development; protection; and participation. The Ministry
has also been making efforts for a more effective involvement of non-
governmental organisations in women and child welfare programmes.
Welfare of people in distress
People affected by the disasters such as flood, cyclone, earthquake, drought,
landslide, major fire, major accidents, etc., need immediate rescue & can make
legitimate claims on the state for rescue, relief as well as long-term rehabilitation
assistance The Disaster Management Act (2005) has provided the legal
framework under which the National Disaster Response Fund (NDRF) and State
Disaster Response Fund (SDRF) have come into operation to meet rescue and
relief expenditure of a notified disaster event. Relief includes items for survival
such as food, water, health, medical assistance, clothing, shelter, etc. Relief and
other services are provided on an ad hoc basis for a few weeks or months to
enable the disaster victims to recover to a state of normalcy. The state government
concerned has the primary responsibility for providing rescue and relief. The
District Collector/ Magistrate is empowered to take emergency measures to deal
with disaster situations. NGOs like Red Cross play important roles in the relief
and rehabilitation process.
Check Your Progress 2
Note: i) Use the space given below for your answers.
ii) Check your answers with those given at the end of the Unit.
1) What has been done by the Central Government for the welfare of women in
India?
.......................................................................................................................
.......................................................................................................................
.......................................................................................................................
.......................................................................................................................
129
Social Welfare 2) Enlist the measures initiated towards holistic development of the children.
Administrations
.......................................................................................................................
.......................................................................................................................
.......................................................................................................................
.......................................................................................................................
9.5 CONCLUSION
The Preamble and the chapters on the Fundamental Rights and Directive Principles
of State Policy of the Indian Constitution stand testimony to India’s commitment
to the objectives of a welfare state. Successive governments have played an
important role in achieving these objectives. Specifically, the judiciary has played
a pivotal role in making a liberal interpretation of the relevant statutes and
programmes, thereby ensuring that the objectives of welfare-oriented
constitutional provisions are realised.
There were apprehensions that after the dawn of liberalisation (1991) in India
the state would withdraw from its commitments to the poor and marginalised.
Contrary to such fears, the Union government and that of the states/ union
territories have accelerated the tempo of welfare programmes. Indeed, new recipes
have been added to the welfare menu partly because of the growth of the Indian
economy enabling the centre and the states to increase their budgetary
commitments for welfare schemes. Another compelling reason is the growing
tendency of competitive populism among political parties driving them to embrace
more and more new schemes/ freebies, often beyond the notion of a welfare
state. An open democratic system with periodic elections makes this possible.
There are schemes for free supply of gas stoves for the poor; supply of laptops
and bicycles for school and college students freely; subsidised cooking gas,
comprehensive health insurance schemes (eg. PMJY); heavily subsidised
breakfast and lunch – for Rs 5/-each; free distribution of mobile phones, grinders
and other kitchen items; full fee reimbursement for bulk of the school and college
students; grant of land (in a few cases), house sites / pucca houses for the poor
and slum dwellers; grants in lump sum to meet marriage expenses; special doles
of essential goods for festivals, to mention only a few. These and many other
welfare schemes have been operational in various states. Those lagging behind
have been catching upfast. .Conventional welfare schemes like pensions have
been augmented both by increasing the sum (by ten-fold in some states) or by
reducing the age limit, or both. Overall, welfarism found a new lease of life in
democratic India in which it will only flourish, but not diminish.
9.6 GLOSSARY
Social Services: Social services are those services whose aim is the protection
and enhancement of the social welfare of the individual or the community either
through social legislation or by social action.
9.7 REFERENCES
Bose, A.B. (1987). Encyclopaedia of Social Work, Ministry of Welfare. New
Delhi, India: Government of India.
Government of India. (2018). India Year Book. New Delhi, India: Publications
Division.
Government of India. (1951). First Five Year Plan. New Delhi, India: Planning
Commission.
131
Social Welfare 2) Your answer should include the following points:
Administrations
ICDS
Nutritional programme for the adolescent girls (11-18 years)
Commission for protection of Child Rights
Enactment of Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act.
132