Leadership When No One Is in Charge: A Case Study
Leadership When No One Is in Charge: A Case Study
Leadership When No One Is in Charge: A Case Study
Ballesteros
PhD 720
BACKGROUND: Eddie, Cyndi, Gina, Jennifer, and Ralph, a small work team, were
requested to meet after work to come up with a theme for the company picnic, which
would be held on July 3rd in a park on the outskirts of town. No one was really enthusiastic
about this project—or the thought of staying late. For the first several minutes, everyone
was silent, probably hoping that someone else would come up with a solution to make
this chore go away. When it became clear that no one was going to take the lead, Gina
offered that since no one wants to be there, they just have a Fourth of July celebration
and call it a day. "I'd want to get out of here, too," Ralph said, "but couldn't we come up
with anything a little more innovative than that?" a couple of heads bobbed. You know,
the boss is going to be interested in this." Cyndi laughed and said that Ralph is still after
that raise he didn’t get last quarter. Although they could perceive an underlying tension
between Ralph and Cyndi, other members of the group grinned. "We'd all appreciate that
increase, wouldn't we?" Eddie came to the rescue. Why don't we give this a few more
minutes and see what we can come up with? " Jennifer rose from her seat, took out her
phone, and exited the room. Gina brought up the Fourth of July festivities once more.
"How about a Fourth of July party?" Ralph suggested. " Cyndi reminded the group,
unnecessarily, that it was Gina's idea. "How about expanding on that concept by thinking
was a fine idea and added, "But what about building on that idea by thinking about a
different kind of celebration—maybe something like a circus?" " Gina agreed that it wasn't
a bad idea and proposed that they dress up and put on a parade. Ralph stated that he
enjoys clowns, while Cyndi stated that Ralph is a clown. "No," Ralph stated emphatically.
"We could organize a parade with clowns and animals and everything," Eddie suggested.
"Sure," Eddie agreed, "circus in July!" " The group became energized and began making
serious plans, including assigning duties for pushing the idea forward.
CASE EVALUATION: The group exercised shared leadership wherein everyone was the
leader. When two or more team members share leadership, they are seeking to influence
and steer fellow team members so that the team's effectiveness can be maximized. The
organization, rather than being carried out solely by formal leaders. It's crucial to separate
shared leadership from team leadership, because shared leadership relates to how team
members influence one another and share job responsibilities, whereas team leadership
refers to how a group is led by a single person. Shared leadership occurs when a group
of people work together to achieve a common goal. Shared leadership is a notion that fills
individual's strengths rather than relying on one person to carry the team to victory.
The team had an equal say during the meeting that devoted to decision-making or
encouraging each other to be more collaborative and participatory. The team learned to
brainstorm ideas and build on one another's ideas to come up with new ones. At first,
there was a personality conflict. When left mismanaged, these different personalities can
Since everyone in the group agreed on one plan for celebrating July 3, they began
to energize and pump up the energy in the room. They grew more gregarious, outgoing,
and upbeat. Their mouths were full with ideas. They came up with novel concepts. The
group meeting began in a negative and ineffective manner, eventually devolving into a
little quarrel with no one making any feedback. As a result, the group demonstrated low
emotional intelligence. When the group was on the same page, however, a surge of ideas
emerged, demonstrating their rational intelligence. The group was acutely aware of the
Often times, I have been part of shared leadership. I have noticed that individual
participation and collaboration are increased with shared leadership; each team member
collaborative and share information so that everyone can make better-informed decisions;
the team learns to brainstorm ideas and build off of one another to produce innovative
ideas; the team shares accountability for the choices they make, so if things go wrong,