Coordination Polymers: Stuart R. Batten
Coordination Polymers: Stuart R. Batten
Coordination Polymers: Stuart R. Batten
Review
Coordination polymers
Stuart R. Batten*
Department of Chemistry, PO Box 23, Monash University, Victoria 3800, Australia
Abstract
The crystal engineering of coordination polymers has always held great potential for applications in many areas, such as molecular
magnetism, heterogeneous catalysis, molecular sieving and non-linear optics. In recent times that potential has been realised, with many
new materials with useful applications reported. In addition, many new interesting network topologies and unusual modes of
interpenetration have been discovered. 2001 Elsevier Science Ltd. All rights reserved.
1359-0286 / 01 / $ – see front matter 2001 Elsevier Science Ltd. All rights reserved.
PII: S1359-0286( 00 )00031-0
108 S.R. Batten / Current Opinion in Solid State and Materials Science 5 (2001) 107 – 114
been reported [**6]. The cyanide moieties bridge between the coordination polymers of the dicyanamide (dca,
clusters and metal ions to give 2D and 3D networks. The N(CN) 2 2 ) ligand. The a-[M(dca) 2 ] compounds all have
colour of two of these compounds is reported to change rutile-like structures (Fig. 1) in which octahedral metal
with exposure to various chemical vapours. For example, centres are bridged by three-connecting dca ligands (which
the colour of one compound changes from orange to an coordinate through all three nitrogen atoms). Despite their
intense blue–violet on exposure to diethyl ether vapour. isomorphous structures, the magnetic properties vary wide-
The recent discovery [**7–9] of a new class of magneti- ly: Cr, Mn and Fe are spin-canted antiferromagnets (T N 5
cally ordering compounds has sparked a surge in interest in 47, 16, 19 K), Co and Ni are ferromagnets (T c 59, 20 K),
and Cu is a paramagnet. The b-[M(dca) 2 ] phase is formed potential for greater control over pore size and shape. Until
by tetrahedral metals [10], and is composed of (4,4) 2D recently, however, the usefulness of such materials was
sheets of metals bridged by m 2 ligands (the amide nitrogen limited by the loss of crystallinity of such materials after
does not coordinate). The effect of structure on magnetic removal of guest solvent molecules from the lattice, which
properties is illustrated by the fact that both phases can be was interpreted as a collapse of the porous framework.
isolated for M5Co, however while the a phase is a Recent work has reported a number of new coordination
ferromagnet, the b phase is a spin-canted antiferromagnet polymers that retain their porosity, and in some cases
(T N 59 K). The dimensionality of the dicyanamide coordi- remain single crystals, upon removal of solvent.
nation polymers can also be reduced by the introduction of One of the leading researchers in this area has been
terminal solvent ligands such as H 2 O, MeOH, EtOH, DMF Yaghi. He has synthesised a number of interesting such
and pyridine [11]. An unusual tube-like 1D polymer is materials using the polycarboxylate donor ligands bdc
formed when 2-aminopyridine is added to the reaction (1,4-benzenedicarboxylate) and btc (1,3,5-benzenetricar-
mixture [**12]; the topology of the tube is identical to the boxylate) [17–20]. The structure of Tb(bdc)NO 3 has a
square channels in the a-[M(dca) 2 ] rutile-like networks microporous (3,4)-connected net which is capable of
(Fig. 1). reversible molecular sorption and is stable in the absence
Polymorphism and pseudo-polymorphism is common in of guests [17]. The thermal removal of coordinated water
dca coordination polymers. In addition to the a and b molecules from the structure of Tb 2 (bdc) 3 (H 2 O) 4 results
forms of [M(dca) 2 ], a-[Cu(dca) 2 (pyz)] contains two inter- in a microporous structure which also has accessible metal
penetrating a-Po-like 3D networks, while the b form sites which may be used by re-absorbed water or ammonia
contains 2D (4,4) sheets [13]. Two compounds are isolated ligands [18]. Desolvation of Zn 2 (btc)NO 3 ?(EtOH) 5 H 2 O
from a reaction mixture containing Cu(I), dca and 4,49- results in a material in which reabsorption of ethanol
bipyridine whose formulae differ only by the number of vapour occurs in several stages that indicate the coordina-
solvent molecules in the structure; one contains 1D ladder- tively unsaturated zinc centres increase their coordination
like polymers while the other has a thick 2D layer structure number from 3 to 4, 4 to 5, and then 5 to 6 [19]. The most
[*14]. This latter compound displays 2D parallel inter- remarkable compound in this series to date is Zn 4 O(bdc) 3 ?
penetration, with each layer interlocked with four others. (DMF) 8 C 6 H 5 Cl, which is stable in air to 3008C and has a
The mean planes of the layers, however, are parallel but free pore volume of 55–60% [19,20]. The removal of the
not coincident, and thus the interlocking generates an solvent can be achieved without damage to the single
overall 3D structure rather than the usual formation of 2D crystals. The structure consists of an a-Po-like 3D network
layers. Cu(dca)(bpe), bpe51,2-bis(4-pyridyl)ethene also in which Zn 4 O(RCO 2 ) 6 clusters, acting as the six-connect-
has an a phase (two-fold parallel interpenetration of (4,4) ing nodes, are connected by the bridging bdc ligands (Fig.
2D sheets) and a b phase (five interpenetrating diamond 2).
like nets in which the topology of interpenetration is
unprecedented) [*14].
A number of coordination polymers of the related
tricyanomethanide (tcm, C(CN) 2 3 ) ligand have also been
reported. Like their dca analogues, the M(tcm) 2 com-
pounds have rutile like networks, but the larger size of the
ligand results in two interpenetrating networks (Fig. 1)
[15]. An interesting series of compounds are formed by
Cu(I), tcm and either hexamethylenetetramine, 4,49-
bipyridine or 1,2-bis(4-pyridyl)ethene [*16]. All three
compounds have topologically identical 2D (4,4) sheets
but display different methods of maximising packing
efficiency in the structure: interdigitation, interpenetration
and intercalation, respectively.
3. Microporous materials
6. Self-penetration
8. Conclusions
[8] Kurmoo M, Kepert CJ. Hard magnets based on transition metal [*24] Sharma CVK, Broker GA, Huddleston JG, Baldwin JW, Metzger
complexes with the dicyanamide anion, hN(CN) 2 j 2 . New J Chem RM, Rogers RD. Design strategies for solid-state supramolecular
1998;22:1515–24. arrays containing both mixed-metalated and freebase porphyrins. J
[9] Manson JL, Kmety CR, Huang Q, Lynn JW, Bendele GM, Pagola S, Am Chem Soc 1999;121:1137–44. Coordination polymers based on
Stephens PW, Liable-Sands LM, Rheingold AL, Epstein AJ, Miller freebase porphyrins show heterogeneous absorption of metal ions
JS. Structure and magnetic ordering of M II [N(CN) 2 ] 2 (M5Co, Ni). from solution.
Chem Mater 1998;10:2552–60. [25] Kondo M, Okubo T, Asami A, Noro S, Yoshitomi T, Kitagawa S,
[10] Jensen P, Batten SR, Fallon GD, Moubaraki B, Murray KS, Price Ishii T, Matsuzaka H, Seki K. Rational synthesis of stable channel-
DJ. Structural isomers of M(dca) 2 molecule-based magnets. Crystal like cavities with methane gas adsorption properties:
structure of tetrahedrally coordinated sheet-like b-Zn(dca) 2 and [hCu 2 (pzdc) 2 (L)j n ] (pzdc5pyrazine-2,3-dicarboxylate; L5a pillar
b-Co / Zn(dca) 2 , and the octahedrally coordinated rutile-like a- ligand). Angew Chem Int Ed 1999;38:140–3.
2 2
Co(dca) 2 , where dca 5dicyanamide, N(CN) 2 , and magnetism of [**26] Noro S, Kitagawa S, Kondo M, Seki K. A new, methane adsorbent,
b-Co(dca) 2 . Chem Commun 1999:177–178. porous coordination polymer [hCuSiF 6 (4,49-bipyridine) 2 j n ]. Angew
[11] Batten SR, Jensen P, Kepert CJ, Kurmoo M, Moubaraki B, Murray Chem Int Ed 2000;39:2082–4. Describes a porous coordination
KS, Price DJ. Syntheses, structures and magnetism of a-Mn(dca) 2 , polymer which shows greater absorption of methane than even the
Mn(dca) 2 (H 2 O) 2 ?H 2 O, Mn(dca) 2 (C 2 H 5 OH) 2 ?(CH 3 ) 2 CO, best zeolite currently known.
Fe(dca) 2 (CH 3 OH) 2 and Mn(dca) 2 (L) 2 , where L5pyridine, CH 3 OH, [**27] Kiang Y-H, Gardner GB, Lee S, Zu Z, Lobkovsky EB. Variable pore
2 2
DMF and dca 5dicyanamide, N(CN) 2 . J Chem Soc Dalton Trans size, variable chemical functionality, and an example of reactivity
1999:2987–2997. within porous phenylacetylene silver salts. J Am Chem Soc
[**12] Jensen P, Batten SR, Moubaraki B, Murray KS. Infinite molecular 1999;121:8204–15. Describes a clever piece of crystal engineering
tubes: structure and magnetism of M(dca) 2 (apym), M5Co, Ni, in which side chains with varying size and functionality are added to
2
apym52-aminopyrimidine, dca5dicyanamide, N(CN) 2 . Chem the framework forming ligands without affecting the topology of the
Commun 2000:793–794. Describes the structures and magnetic framework formed. Thus the size and chemical environment of the
properties of novel tube-like 1D coordination polymers. cavities and channels can be manipulated.
[13] Jensen P, Batten SR, Fallon GD, Hockless DCR, Moubaraki B, [*28] Ranford JD, Vittal JJ, Wu D, Yang X. Thermal conversion of a
Murray KS, Robson R. Synthesis, structural isomerism and magnet- helical coil into a three-dimensional chiral framework. Angew Chem
ism of extended framework compounds of type [Cu(dca) 2 (pyz)] n , Int Ed 1999;38:3498–501. Dehydration of a compound composed of
2
where dca5dicyanamide (N(CN) 2 ) and pyz5pyrazine. J Solid 1D helices results in formation of a chiral 3D network; the process
State Chem 1999;145:387–93. is guided by N–H???O hydrogen bonds in the former structure.
[*14] Batten SR, Harris AR, Jensen P, Murray KS, Ziebell A. Copper(I) [**29] Seo JS, Whang D, Lee H, Jun SI, Oh J, Jeon YJ, Kim K. A
dicyanamide coordination polymers: ladders, sheets, layers, homochiral metal–organic porous material for enantioselective
diamond-like networks and unusual interpenetration. J Chem Soc separation and catalysis. Nature 2000;404:982–6. Describes a chiral
Dalton Trans 2001: in press. A series of related coordination coordination polymer which shows size and enantioselective cata-
polymers which include novel interpenetration motifs. lytic and inclusion properties.
[15] Batten SR, Hoskins BF, Moubaraki B, Murray KS, Robson R. [30] Biradha K, Seward C, Zaworotko MJ. Helical coordination poly-
Crystal structures and magnetic properties of the interpenetrating mers with large chiral cavities. Angew Chem Int Ed 1999;38:492–5.
rutile-related compounds M(tcm) 2 [M5octahedral, divalent metal; [31] Ezuhara T, Endo K, Aoyama Y. Helical coordination polymers from
tcm 2 5tricyanomethanide, C(CN) 2 3 ] and the sheet structures of achiral components in crystals, homochiral crystallization, homo-
[M(tcm) 2 (EtOH) 2 ] (M5Co or Ni). J Chem Soc Dalton Trans chiral helix winding in the solid state, and chirality control by
1999:2977–2986. seeding. J Am Chem Soc 1999;121:3279–83.
[*16] Batten SR, Hoskins BF, Robson R. Interdigitation, interpenetration [32] Barnett SA, Blake AJ, Champness NR, Wilson C. An unusual
and intercalation in layered cuprous tricyanomethanide derivatives. (CuSCN) ` structural motif in the non-centrosymmetric coordination
Chem Eur J 2000;6:156–61. Three closely related compounds with polymer [(CuSCN) 2 (pyrimidine)] ` . Cryst Eng Comm 2000:5.
topologically equivalent networks show three different techniques [*33] Blake AJ, Champness NR, Cooke PA, Nicolson JEB. Synthesis of a
for maximising packing efficiency. chiral adamantoid network–the role of solvent in the construction of
[17] Reineke TM, Eddaoudi M, O’Keeffe M, Yaghi OM. A microporous new coordination networks with silver(I). Chem Commun
lanthanide–organic framework. Angew Chem Int Ed 1999;38:2590– 2000:665–666. Clever ligand design allows the formation of a chiral
4. diamondoid network despite the fact that the diamond prototype is
[18] Reineke TM, Eddaoudi M, Fehr M, Kelley D, Yaghi OM. From achiral.
condensed lanthanide coordination solids to microporous [34] Evans OR, Wang Z, Lin W. An unprecedented 3D coordination
frameworks having accessible metal sites. J Am Chem Soc network composed of two intersecting helices. Chem Commun
1999;121:1651–7. 1999:1903–1904.
[19] Eddaoudi M, Li H, Yaghi OM. Highly porous and stable metal– [*35] Evans OR, Xiong R-G, Wang Z, Wong GK, Lin W. Crystal
organic frameworks: structure design and sorption properties. J Am engineering of acentric diamondoid metal–organic coordination
Chem Soc 2000;122:1391–7. networks. Angew Chem Int Ed 1999;38:536–8. Design of acentric
[**20] Li H, Eddaoudi M, O’Keeffe M, Yaghi OM. Design and synthesis of materials for NLO applications through use of unsymmetric ligands
an exceptionally stable and highly porous metal–organic framework. and formation of odd numbers of interpenetrating networks.
Nature 1999;402:276–9. An exceptionally porous and stable frame- [*36] Lin W, Wang Z, Ma L. A novel octupolar metal–organic NLO
work. material based on a chiral 2D coordination network. J Am Chem
[21] Goodgame DML, Grachvogel DA, Williams DJ. A new type of Soc 1999;121:11249–50. Describes a coordination polymer with
metal–organic large-pore zeotype. Angew Chem Int Ed NLO properties significantly better than the standard KDP.
1999;38:153–6. [37] Ma L, Evans OR, Foxman BM, Lin W. Luminescent lanthanide
[22] Diskin-Posner Y, Dahal S, Goldberg I. Crystal engineering of coordination polymers. Inorg Chem 1999;38:5837–40.
metalloporphyrin zeolite analogues. Angew Chem Int Ed [**38] Batten SR, Robson R. Interpenetrating nets: ordered, periodic
2000;39:1288–92. entanglement. Angew Chem Int Ed 1998;37:1460–94. A com-
[23] Lin K-J. SMTP-1: the first functionalized metalloporphyrin molecu- prehensive review of interpenetrating networks. A continually
lar sieves with large channels. Angew Chem Int Ed 1999;38:2730– updated list of all known interpenetrating frameworks may be
2. obtained from the author (SRB).
114 S.R. Batten / Current Opinion in Solid State and Materials Science 5 (2001) 107 – 114
[*39] Kepert CJ, Prior TJ, Rosseinsky MJ. A versatile family of inter- [*50] Kuhlman R, Schimek GL, Kolis JW. Inorganic–organic composites
convertible microporous chiral molecular frameworks: the first from solvothermal routes: Extended structures of [CuX(pyrazine)] `
example of ligand control of network chirality. J Am Chem Soc (X5CN, Cl, CF 3 CO 2 ), and Cu(NO 2 ) 2 (pyz). Polyhedron
2000;122:5158–68. Describes formation of compounds containing 1999;18:1379–87. No comment is made of the fact that the structure
two or four homochiral interpenetrating (10,3)-a networks which are of Cu(CN)(pyz) contains two interpenetrating diamondoid networks.
nonetheless microporous. Chirality of the frameworks can be [*51] Choe W, Kiang Y-H, Xu Z, Lee S. Coordination networks of C3 v and
controlled by the chirality of a diol template. C2 v phenylacetylene nitriles and silver(I) salts: interplay of ligand
[*40] Reineke TM, Eddaoudi M, Moler D, O’Keeffe M, Yaghi OM. Large symmetry and molecular dipole moments in the solid state. Chem
free volume in maximally interpenetrating networks: the role of Mater 1999;11:1776–83. The structure of complex 10 actually
secondary building units exemplified by Tb 2 (ADB) 3 [(CH 3 ) 2 SO] 4 ? contains four interpenetrating (10,3)-b networks.
16(CH 3 ) 2 SO. J Am Chem Soc 2000;122:4843–4. Twofold inter- [**52] Jensen P, Price DJ, Batten SR, Moubaraki B, Murray KS. Self-
penetration of a-Po-like networks fails to prevent the formation of a penetration – a structural compromise between single networks and
highly porous structure. interpenetration: magnetic properties and crystal structures of
[*41] Carlucci L, Ciani G, Macchi P, Proserpio DM, Rizzato S. Complex [Mn(dca) 2 (H 2 O)] and [M(dca)(tcm)], M5Co, Ni, Cu, dca5
interwoven polymeric frames from the self-assembly of silver(I) dicyanamide, N(CN) 2 2
2 , tcm5tricyanomethanide, C(CN) 3 . Chem
cations and sebaconitrile. Chem Eur J 1999;5:237–43. Variation of Eur J 2000;6:3186–95. Describes a novel example of crystal
network topology upon variation of counterion, with eightfold engineering in which a series of new structures ([M(dca)(tcm]) are
interpenetrating diamondoid networks, interpenetrating SrAl 2 -like successfully predicted through replacement of the dca.H 2 O motif in
networks, and unusual 2D parallel interpenetration being among the [Mn(dca) 2 (H 2 O)] with the identical (with respect to topology and
motifs observed. size) tcm ligand. The networks are self-penetrating and magnetically
[42] Biradha K, Domasevitch KV, Hogg C, Moulton B, Power KN, ordered at low temperature (except [Cu(dca)(tcm)]).
Zaworotko MJ. Interpenetrating covalent and noncovalent nets in the [**53] Abrahams BF, Batten SR, Grannas MJ, Hamit H, Hoskins BF,
crystal structures of [M(4,49-bipyridine) 2 (NO 3 ) 2 ]?3C 10 H 8 (M5Co, Robson R. Ni(tpt)(NO 3 ) 2 – a three-dimensional network with the
Ni. Cryst Eng 1999;2:37–45. exceptional (12,3) topology: a self-entangled single net. Angew
[*43] Aakeroy¨ CB, Beatty AM, Leinen DS. A versatile route to porous Chem Int Ed 1999;38:1475–7. Describes the first chemical example
solids: Organic–inorganic hybrid materials assembled through hy- of a (12,3) net, and introduces the necessary conditions for a
drogen bonds. Angew Chem Int Ed 1999;38:1815–9. The only network to be described as self-penetrating.
example of inclined interpenetration of three mutually perpendicular [**54] Withersby MA, Blake AJ, Champness NR, Cooke PA, Hubberstey P,
stacks of 2D sheets, a mode of interpenetration which was predicted ¨
Schroder M. Assembly of a three-dimensional polyknotted coordina-
in Ref. [**38]. tion polymer. J Am Chem Soc 2000;122:4044–6. A self-penetrating
[44] Tong M-L, Chen X-M, Ye B-H, Ji L-N. Self-assembled three- network based on interpenetrating ladders that are cross-linked into
dimensional coordination polymers with unusual ligand-unsupported a single network by nitrate anions.
Ag–Ag bonds: synthesis, structures, and luminescent properties. [*55] Plater MJ, Foreman MRStJ, Gelbrich T, Hursthouse MB. Synthesis
Angew Chem Int Ed 1999;38:2237–40. and characterisation of infinite di- and tri-nuclear zinc co-ordination
[45] Carlucci L, Ciani G, Proserpio DM, Rizzato S. Chiral packing of networks with flexible dipyridyl ligands. J Chem Soc Dalton Trans
chiral quintuple layers polycatenated to give a three-dimensional 2000:1995–2000. Compound 1 has a self-penetrating network.
network in the coordination polymer [56] Hagrman PJ, Bridges C, Greedan JE, Zubieta J. A three-dimensional
[Co 5 (bpe) 9 (H 2 O) 8 (SO 4 ) 4 ](SO 4 )?14H 2 O [bpe51,2-bis(4- organic–inorganic composite material constructed from copper–
pyridyl)ethane]. Chem Commun 2000:1319–1320. triazolate networks linked through vanadium oxide chains:
[*46] Chesnut DJ, Kusnetzow A, Birge R, Zubieta J. Ligand influences on [hCu 3 (trz) 2 jV4 O 12 ]. J Chem Soc Dalton Trans 1999:2901–2903.
copper cyanide solid-state architecture: flattened and fused ‘slinky’, [57] Hagrman D, Hagrman PJ, Zubieta J. Solid-state coordination
corrugated sheet, and ribbon motifs in the copper–cyanide–triazo- chemistry: the self-assembly of microporous organic–inorganic
late–organoamine family. Inorg Chem 1999;38:5485–95. Com- hybrid frameworks constructed from tetrapyridylporphyrin and
pound 1 is composed of 2D layers which interpenetrate, although the bimetallic oxide chains or oxide clusters. Angew Chem Int Ed
interpenetration is incorrectly assigned as inclined interpenetration. 1999;38:3165–8.
The interpenetration is in fact parallel interpenetration, with each [**58] Hagrman PJ, Hagrman D, Zubieta J. Organic–inorganic hybrid
layer interlocked with two others whose mean planes are parallel but materials: from ‘simple’ coordination polymers to organodiamine-
not coincident; an overall 3D structure thus results. Each layer is templated molybdenum oxides. Angew Chem Int Ed 1999;38:2638–
also interdigitated with two others. 84. An excellent review of the authors’ metal oxide work, and of
[**47] Carlucci L, Ciani G, Moret M, Proserpio DM, Rizzato S. Polymeric coordination polymers in general.
layers catenated by ribbons of rings in a three-dimensional self- [59] Munakata M, Wu LP, Ning GL, Kuroda-Sowa T, Maekawa M,
assembled architecture: a nanoporous network with spongelike Suenaga Y, Maeno N. Construction of metal sandwich systems
behaviour. Angew Chem Int Ed 2000;39:1506–10. First example of derived from assembly of silver(I) complexes with polycyclic
interpenetration between 1D networks and 2D networks. aromatic compounds. J Am Chem Soc 1999;121:4968–76.
[48] Sharma CVK, Rogers RD. ‘Molecular Chinese blinds’: self-organi- [60] Ning GL, Wu LP, Sugimoto K, Munakata M, Kuroda-Sowa T,
zation of tetranitrato lanthanide complexes into open, chiral hydro- Maekawa M. Construction of 2-D multilayer structures: silver(I)
gen bonded networks. Chem Commun 1999:83–84. complexes with linear aromatic compounds. J Chem Soc Dalton
[49] Yeung W-F, Wong W-T, Zuo J-L, Lau T-C. Synthesis and structures Trans 1999:2529–2536.
of novel heterobimetallic Cu(II)–Au(I) complexes [61] Munakata M, Wu LP, Sugimoto K, Kuroda-Sowa T, Maekawa M,
Cu(cyclen)[Au(CN) 2 ] 2 and Cu(pyz)[Au(CN) 2 ] 2 . J Chem Soc Dalton Suenaga Y, Maeno N, Fujita M. Silver(I) complex assemblies with
Trans 2000:629–631. non-planar aromatic compounds. Inorg Chem 1999;38:5674–80.