Answer of Case Study
Answer of Case Study
Answer of Case Study
TUTORIAL
EXERCISES
Page |1
Discussion questions:
Question 1. As the top managers of their company what type of issues might Bert
and John have to deal with? Be as specific as possible, which management
functions might be most important to them? Why?
Answer 1. The number and type of issues may vary from time to time or may arise
as influenced by many factors, however, few of the issues which they might face is
as tabulated under.
1. Issues. As the top managers of their company, Bert and John have to
establish the plans and goals and make some big decisions, such as which market
do they want to develop, how much money they want to earn next year, which
partner they want to cooperate and so on. As the top managers of the company Bert
and John might face following issues:-
a. Leadership
f. Creating Team Unity. Being Leaders they are often responsible for
helping build unity between staff members. It can take a bit of time for
workers to develop trusting relationships with one another, and the role
of a supervisor or managers is to set the proper framework to
encourage these relationships to grow.
2. Most important management function. There are five basic functions tabulated
as under:
3. All managers at all levels of every organization perform these functions, but in
this particular case Controlling would be the most important function, which gives the
basic drive to run the business. Because Life is good company is a mature company,
which has mature rules, middle managers and first line managers. It also has mature
markets. As the top managers, the most important function is controlling now.
Question 2. Using descriptions from the case, describe Bert and Jhon’s managerial
style. Would this approach work for other organizations? Why or why not?
Page |4
Answer 2. Bert and John’s managerial style is managing people who take action.
It can work for other organizations as well. For Bert and John, they set up the motto
and enhance the company’s culture to let employees feel themselves to be
constructive parts of the company.
Question 3. How do you think the company’s motto “Do what you like, Like what
you do” might affect how mangers manage? Be specific.
Answer 3. The motto “Do what you like. Like what you do.” might affect that which
kind of employees the managers want to hire and how they encourage their
employees to work hard. The motto is a kind of company’s culture. And it can help
employees to identify the company. It can be claimed that the motto Do what you
like. Like what you do works as a catalyst in the positive growth of the company.
Question 4. What managerial challenges might there be in having friends work for
your business? How could these challenges be kept inconsequential?
Answer 4. The challenges in having friends work for your business might be hard to
manage. Sometimes they don’t think you are the boss, they think you are just their
friend. But it is easy to deal with talk to your friends and make sure they know their
roles. Let them know here is the business, and there are rules in the company.
Everybody should follow the rules, nobody except.
Question 5. Would you want to work for a company like this? Why or why not?
Answer 5. To answer that would I work for a company like Life is Good? yes
would be my reply. Foremost of the reason would be that the company promotes and
maintain a stress free environment for all employees. This good management style
encourages the employees to learn new things and improve their performance and
thus leading to a positive productivity note.
Question 6. In what ways would the Life is Good managers (corporate and retail
stores) have to deal with the challenges of customer services, innovation and
sustainability? Be specific in your description.
Answer 6. Managers at Life is Good are requires to utilize their skills and bring on
the right amount of motivation to run the company.
Page |5
company like Life is Good managers must be abreast with the latest ideas and global
trends.
3. Importance of sustainability. Sustainability is the ability to maintain a certain
status or process in existing systems or company’s ability to achieve its business
goals and increase long term shareholder value by integrating economic,
environmental, and social opportunities into business strategy. For a company like
Life is Good it becomes important because all the goals they pursue, and all the
actions taken today will affect it in the future. Before sustainability can be fully
integrated into a company’s core business, though, top managers have to take
following important actions:
The answer to this question used to be straightforward, but the line between
managerial and non-managerial employees has blurred as more employees take on
task once reserved for managers. To keep the answer from becoming too
complicated, the best way to address this question is to focus on the fact that a
manager’s job is about helping others do their work.
2. Is your course instructor a manager? Discuss in terms of managerial functions,
managerial roles, and skills.
Course instructors (in contrast to individuals who hold positions such as department
head) are not usually classified as managers. In most situations, a course instructor
Page |7
does not fall within the definition of a manager when utilizing managerial functions,
mainly because students are clients rather than employees. In some cases, an
instructor has little input about course content or how it is to be taught. In these
instances, the instructor makes few managerial decisions.
In terms of managerial roles, course instructors may be involved in some ways in
the interpersonal, informational, and decisional roles. For example, a course
instructor could be seen as a liaison (interpersonal role), a monitor and disseminator
(both informational roles), and a disturbance handler and negotiator (both decisional
roles).
Regarding managerial skills, course instructors certainly need technical skills—
knowledge about the latest research and conceptual developments in a particular
discipline. They also need significant human skills as they interact with their
students. To a limited extent, the instructor utilizes conceptual skills as courses are
planned or as departmental curriculums are debated.
4. Explain the universality of management concept. Does it still hold true in today’s
world? Why or why not?
Management principles are needed for the efficient and effective operation of
organizations, regardless of the level of the manager or the industry in which they
operate. This is true for today’s organizations now more than ever. The global
environment of today ensures that organizations will face staunch competition.
Failure and weakness on the part of management ultimately lead to loss of market
Page |8
share and organizational closure. Also, gone are the days when managers could
‘bluff’ their way through their dealings with employees who have become more
demanding and aware of their legal rights.
No, there’s probably not one single “best” style of management. Organizational
situations vary and what works best in one organization may not necessarily work
best in another. Point out to students that they will find a variety of managerial
“styles” illustrated throughout the textbook in different boxes, examples, and cases.
Each individual tends to develop his or her own preferred “style” of managing.
7. Does the way that that contemporary organizations are structured appeal to you?
Why or why not?
Exhibit 1-10 lists some of the important differences between the traditional
organization and the contemporary organization. These differences include flexible
Page |9
9. Researchers at Harvard Business School have found that the most important
managerial behaviors involve two fundamental things: enabling people to move
forward in their work and treating them decently as human beings. What do you
think of these two managerial behaviors? What are the implications for someone,
like yourself, who is studying management?
Students vary in the degree to which they see businesses as entities that care and
concern for their employees. However, most managers realize that it is a
manager’s jobs to develop an employee’s skill level and to make sure that they are
also developing as individuals. Both of these practices, in the end, will increase an
employee’s performance. Skills of job candidates have become important to
employers because of today’s demanding and rapidly changing workplace and
employees need to be self-motivated to constantly upgrade their skills and take on
extra work outside of their own specific job area. In addressing the implications of
these behaviors with students, the discussion could include what happens when
organizations treat their employees well or poorly.
While most people do not see ‘management’ as an invention, it is safe to say that
without the principles of management and the guidance of managers in
organizations, we as a society would not have reached the level of development
that we enjoy today. The goal of management centers on the art of getting things
done. Without organizations and their managers, it would be impossible to
accomplish what has been done in history so far. It is has always been up to
managers to coordinate and oversee work activities in the art of getting things done
in the areas of agriculture, medicine, science, and manufacturing.
The “Out of Control” case is related to the chapter in several ways however; we will
summarize how the issues presented in this case are directly related to
organizational culture. As a brief background, organizational culture is the shared
values, principles, and traditions, and overall ways of doing things that influence the
way organizational members act. In “Out of Control” the company wanted to try
new ways to reduce cost and achieve a greater portion of their industry’s market
share. By doing so however, Toyota shifted its organizational culture to a less
favorable one by their stakeholders. Though all the dimensions of organizational
culture presented in exhibit 2-5 on pg. 52 were affected by Toyota’s actions, the
primary dimensions affects were the company’s stability due to dishonorable
innovation and risk taking.
Discussion Questions:
Question 1: Using Exhibit 2-5 and the information from the case. Describe the
culture at Toyota Motor Corporation. Why do you think this type of culture might be
important to a carmaker?
Answer 1: Toyota is a well-recognized company with the title of being known as the
world’s largest carmaker. In order to have achieved such a title, Toyota has to have
key values that are deeply held and widely shared by its employees. Based on the
exhibit 2-5 Toyota has an innovative culture that is team oriented which allows them
to remain stable even while taking on risks. This type of culture might be important
to carmakers because Toyota owns 11.7 percent of the car industry’s market and
despite their organizational culture shift due to poor innovative risk taking when it
came to quality, other carmakers should find Toyota’s initial culture to be the reason
for their long-term success and growth.
P a g e | 12
Question 2: How do you think a long-standing culture that had such a strong
commitment to quality lost its ability to influence employee behaviors and actions?
What lesson can be learned about organizational culture from this?
A lesson that could be learned from the Toyota case is that companies should
realize that sacrificing quality or any other critical factors that can affect negatively
the stakeholders of your entity should be fully analyzed. Also, the risks and
outcomes should be examined and weighted to see is it worth doing and how will
those risks and outcomes will affect the company in the future. The overall lesson is
geared towards companies and it teaches them that gains should be achieved in a
less risky way in order for the organization to be successful and experience growth.
Question 3: Do you think that it was important for Mr. Toyoda to apologize for the
company’s decisions? Why?
Answer 3: We strongly feel that Mr. Toyoda apology was necessary and important.
For Mr. Toyoda to publicly apologize for the company’s quality mistake showed the
public that the company actually cared about the casualties that may have been
could due to their lack of attention to detail and poor outcome orientation. It also
P a g e | 13
showed that the company has a strong culture where key values that may be
presented throughout the organization are safety, creditability, and honesty.
The apology was also important because it allowed the company to state how they
were going to improve the quality of their products and also showed their future
initiatives for the company. In the long run, Toyota will be able to become more
successful because their stakeholders will be able to trust that the steps that they
are taking will result in continuous improvement for the overall organization.
Question 4: What could other organizations learn from Toyota’s experiences about
the importance of organizational culture?
Answer 4: There are many lessons that other organizations could learn from
Toyota’s experiences about the importance of organizational culture. We have
broken the lessons down by type of organization. If a company is a more stable
company, they could analyze Toyota’s issue and note that though their company is
more stable and mature, they should take on less risky innovative techniques or
strategies to assure that they are keeping the organizational culture that allowed
them to become a mature and stable company.
When it comes to newer companies, they could analyze Toyota’s experiences and
understanding that establishing an organizational culture that also benefits their
stakeholders will allow them to be an extremely successful company in the future.
This is because companies that have a strong culture, like Toyota, have a greater
connection with their stakeholders. Which allows for these companies to bounce
back when they may fail due to unsuccessful risks?
The external environment consists of numerous factors that have an impact on the
organization. Political and legal factors (such as government regulations),
demographics that affect labor supply, and technological developments directly
affect the management of an organization, including planning and decision-making.
3. Describe an effective culture for (a) a relatively stable environment and (b) a
dynamic environment. Explain your choices.
An effective culture for a relatively stable environment would likely emphasize
outcomes such as quality and productivity and would give significant attention to
detail. It would not require high levels of innovation, risk taking, or aggressiveness.
Conversely, an effective culture for a dynamic environment would likely em-phasize
aggressiveness, innovation, risk taking, and team orientation. To stay on top of
P a g e | 15
4. “Businesses are built on relationships.” What do you think this statement means?
What are implications for managing the external environment?
5. Refer to Exhibit 3-3. How would a first-line manager’s job differ in these two
organizations? How about a top-level manager’s job?
In Organization A, strong attention would be given to detail, with little innovation and
risk taking. Teamwork would not be encouraged, and employees would be viewed
as a means to an end. Strict controls would be placed on workers, and task
achievement would be most important. The supervisor would have little latitude and
would do things “by the book.”
In Organization B, innovation and risk taking would be highly encouraged. The
supervisor would have more autonomy in how to achieve goals. Employees would
be given the opportunity to provide input, and a team approach would be used.
People would be viewed as important contributors. The supervisor’s job would be
more like that of a coach, encourager, and facilitator.
6. Classrooms have cultures. Describe your class culture using the seven
dimensions of organizational culture. Does the culture constrain your instructor?
How?
P a g e | 16
Answers to this question will vary. Have students look at the seven dimensions of
organizational culture described in the text and rate them from high to low for the
class. One point you might want to explore: What role does your instructor play in
establishing the culture of the classroom? Ask students to relate this information to
the role a manager might play in establishing the culture of a business organization.
process by which employees learn the culture. They do this from learning the
company’s philosophy, artifacts, ceremonies, and language.
This movement is important for several reasons. First, as work becomes more
hectic and jobs uncertain, employees are looking for ways to cope with the stresses
of a turbulent pace of life. Second, contemporary life styles have shown the lack of
community many employees feel, and baby boomers are looking for something
meaningful beyond their work.
These terms differ by degree to which the organization is willing to go past what is
legally required and engage in behavior is more altruistic and serving the public
good. Social obligation occurs when a firm engages in social actions because of its
obligation to meet certain economic and legal responsibilities. Social
responsiveness is seen when a firm engages in social actions in response to some
popular social need. Social responsibility is a business’s intention, beyond its legal
and economic obligations, to do the right things and act in ways that are good for
society.
2. What does social responsibility mean to you personally? Do you think business
organizations should be socially responsible? Explain.
Students’ answers to this question will vary. Their responses should indicate an
understanding that social responsibility means going “beyond the minimum required
by law.” Students should pinpoint and discuss why they feel business firms should
or should not be socially responsible.
Green management occurs when organization align their goals with those that
preserve the natural environment. Approaches to going green include the legal (or
light green) approach, the market approach, the stakeholder approach, and the
activist approach. Each of these varies with respect the company’s commitment to
protecting the environment. Organizations can go green by producing products that
are safer for the environment or produce less waste, encourage employees and
customers to engage in environmentally friendly behavior (i.e. drive less and bike to
work), or donate to foundations that promote projects for saving the natural
environment.
This issue is addressed in Section 5.3 and Exhibit 5-3 shows the complex
interactions that influence whether a person acts ethically or unethically when faced
with an ethical dilemma. Students may focus on all eight factors or choose those
that they see as more pertinent.
The text list eight suggestion: employee selection, establishing a code of ethics, top
management leadership and commitment, realistic employee goals, aligning
performance appraisals with high ethical standards, ethics training, independent
social audits, and protective mechanisms to help employees who report ethical
violations within the company. Companies may use a variety of methods to
encourage ethical behavior and are not limited to those given in the text.
7. Internet file sharing programs are popular among college students. These
programs work by allowing non-organizational users to access any local network
where desired files are located. Because these types of file sharing programs tend
to clog bandwidth, local users’ ability to access and use a local network is reduced.
What ethical and social responsibilities does a university have in this situation? To
whom do they have a responsibility? What guidelines might you suggest for
university decision makers?
Students will probably come up with different answers to this question. Answers
may indicate whether they believe the network system belongs to them, based on
the payment or nonpayment of campus computing fees. A discussion of the
P a g e | 20
particular view of ethics (utilitarian versus rights) should be included. You may also
want to discuss current offerings of various Internet file sharing programs, the
concept of unlimited access on demand, and related litigation issues.
8. What are some problems that could be associated with employee whistle-blowing
for (a) the whistle-blower and (b) the organization?
The whistleblower might find that peers, managers, and other company employees
ostracize him or her. For example, the whistleblower may encounter difficulty in
accomplishing tasks and/or obtaining needed resources while remaining employed
at the organization.
The organization itself may struggle with a tarnished reputation if the whistle-
blowing incident becomes public. Other employees may watch to see what happens
and how the organization treats whistleblowers. A pattern for future ethical or
unethical behavior can be set by the organization’s response to a whistleblower.
Ethical individuals are likely to have a strong values system that they use to
distinguish right from wrong. Ethical persons will probably be in Stage 4, 5, or 6 of
moral development. These individuals will likely have strong convictions; that is,
their ego strength will be high. This person will probably have an internal locus of
control.
Ethical managers make decisions and engage in work activities that support their
values. These managers probably challenge what they perceive as ethically
questionable decisions or actions. If an organization wants its managers to uphold
high ethical standards, ethics must be included in the organization’s performance
appraisal process.
10. Explain the ethical and social responsibility issues facing managers today.
P a g e | 21
These issues fall within three categories: managing ethical lapses, social
entrepreneurship and promoting positive change. Ethical lapses can occur at all
levels of the organization, however, we certainly hear more about the unethical
behavior of top management and leaders than individuals with less power. Included
with the issue of ethical lapses are the people who raise ethical issues of
organizations in the press (i.e. whistleblowers). Social entrepreneurs are individuals
who seek opportunities to improve society, for example the opening Manager’s
Dilemma and CEO of TOMS shoes. Promoting positive social change is another
important issue and includes the efforts of the organization which donate to
charitable organizations and individual employees who volunteer their own time to
make an impact.
Discussion Questions:
Question 2: What criteria did NBC use in evaluating its initial decision to move Leno
and O’Brien? Was that criteria appropriate? Why or why not?
Answer 2: “Once a manager has identified a problem, he or she must identify the
decision criteria that are important or relevant to resolving the problem.” In “The
Curtain Fall” case, NBC evaluated the problem by looking at the host, other
networks related shows at the same given time, audience happiness, the talent, and
the advertisers. The criteria of looking at the primary stakeholders of the show
allowed NBC to make a critical decision in determining that Leno should return to
the Tonight Show and that O’Brien should leave with incentive. This was a great
criteria to follow because the ratings after the decision was made increased and
everyone was content with the change.
Question 3: Evaluate Jeff Gaspin’s Statement, “ I don’t think its wrong to take
chances…Sometimes they work. Sometimes they don’t.” What does it say about his
decision making style?
P a g e | 23
Answer 3: Jeff Gaspin’s statement implies that he has a nonlinear thinking style,
which is characterized by a preference for internal sources of information (feelings
and intuition) and processing such information with internal insights, feelings, and
hunches to guide decisions and actions. Because of this, Jeff’s decision-making
style is centered around how he feels about the decision rather than logical facts
and context clues. Jeff believes in taking chances/calculated risks despite the
uncertainty of the results. In some business setting this mentality would work
perfectly fine, but with an industry such as television, which is heavily dependent on
viewership and advertisement, taking chances may or may not work.
Question 4: Describe how NBC executives could have used each of the following to
make better decisions: (a) Rationality, (b) Bounded rationality, (c) Intuition, and (d)
evidence-based management
Answer 4:
(a) NBC executives could have used rationality to make logical decision choices to
maximize their value. We feel that the NBC executives used rationality when
deciding that Leno should return to the Tonight Show because when looking back
on the shows most successful years, Leno was the host, so when thinking rationally,
the executive decided to have Leno return to the Tonight Show to increase ratings
and overall value.
(b) NBC executives could have used bounded rationality to make decisions
rationally by looking at the ways they were limited to how they processed
information. In the case, the executives did use bounded rationality because they
were able to identify the problem and address it accordingly by making substantial
changing to their programming for their long-term success.
(c) NBC executives used intuition because from the basis of their experience,
feeling and accumulative judgment of what was happening to the future of their late
night programming, they were able to make a decision that allowed for the
progression of their most valued show (The Tonight Show).
P a g e | 24
(d) NBC executives used evidence based management when they developed a
systematic way of evaluating the evidence that showed rating droppings.
Accordingly, the executives were able to make a decision to move Leno back to the
Tonight Show and save the future of the programming itself.
1. Why is decision making often described as the essence of the manager’s job?
4. How might an organization’s culture influence the way in which managers make
decisions?
5. Explain the two types of problems and decisions. Contrast the three decision-
making conditions.
6. All of us bring biases to the decisions we make. What types of biases might a
manager have? What would be the drawbacks of having biases? Could there be
any advantages to having biases? Explain. What are the implications for managerial
decision making?
7. Would you call yourself a systematic or intuitive thinker? What are the decision-
making implications of these labels? What are the implications for choosing an
employer?
Student responses to these questions will vary. A systematic thinker is one who is
more logical and rational in searching for and processing information. An intuitive
thinker relies more on instincts and past experiences in searching for and
processing information. The decision-making implication of this label is that it
describes the way we think or process information and in turn, influences how we
tend to make decisions. Organizations need both systematic and intuitive thinkers.
Each of these styles provides a different perspective.
8. “As managers use computer and software tools more often, they’ll be able to
make more rational decisions.” Do you agree or disagree with that statement?
Why?
Although computer and software tools allow managers to gather information and
analyze it more efficiently, utilizing computers does not necessarily allow managers
to be more rational. Looking at the assumptions of rationality (see Exhibit 7.7), it is
apparent that adding computers to the decision-making process does not guarantee
perfectly rational decision making by managers.
9. How can managers blend the guidelines for making effective decisions in today’s
world with the rationality and bounded rationality models of decision making, or can
they? Explain.
10. Is there a difference between wrong decisions and bad decisions? Why do
good managers sometimes make wrong decisions? Bad decisions? How can
managers improve their decision-making skills?
Discussion questions:
Question 1: What role do you think goals would play in planning the change in
direction for the company? List some goals you think might be important. (Make
sure these goals have the characteristics of well-written goals.)
Answer 1: I think goals are essential for this company when it comes to planning the
change in direction because they need to have an idea in mind and where exactly
they want to go, or their outcome with a new direction, which will lead to figuring out
how they are going to get there. Some goals that may be important are: have a
contract with Honda and Toyota for dashboard systems in the Asian market within
the next five years, add three more new features to the next Garmin product within
the next three years to compete with smartphone GPS, and promote innovative and
“out-of-the-box” style thinking in the workplace daily where all organizational
members feel they contribute.
Question 2: What types of plans would be needed in an industry such as this one?
(For instance, long-term or short-term, or both?) Explain why you think these plans
would be important.
Answer 2: I believe this industry, or any industry, should always have long-term and
short term plans and goals. Two of the goals I listed above would be long-term ones
with a time frame beyond three years. I believe they should have short-term plans
when it comes to details on new products or designs catering to how they want to
improve the product and sales. They should also have specific plans for how exactly
they want this new direction to go while having directional plans to promote the
creativity in the workplace, which could lead to new ideas. I believe all these kinds
of plans are important because a company should always be goal-oriented and
have the future in mind being as prepared as possible for any outcome or change.
Question 3: What contingency factors might affect the planning Garmin executives
have to do? How might those contingency factors affect the planning?
P a g e | 29
Answer 3: The contingency factors that might affect the planning Garmin executives
have to do are commitment concept and environmental uncertainty. Garmin
executive may have big goals they want to accomplish with shifting in a whole new
direction, but it will take time to transition the company, system, and structure to
meet these future commitments. Therefore their new ideas may have to be longer-
term goals in order to meet them. Environmental uncertainty is when the factors or
changes in the external environment are unknown, especially in the marketplace, so
managers have to be prepared to change when necessary and go with the flow so
to speak.
Question 4: What planning challenges do you think Garmin executives face with
continuing to be the global market leader? How should they cope with those
challenges?
Answer 4: I believe this company just needs to remember they are a global leader;
so many competitors are vying to be in their position and one-up them. They must
have planning as an ongoing process, constantly wanting to improve and stay on
top as well. They should utilize environmental scanning by screening information to
detect emerging trends and be ready to follow or move with those trends and
changes. They must also stay up to date on their competitors to they can anticipate
what they may do next instead of being caught off guard, just reacting to them, or
even falling behind.
1. Explain what studies have shown about the relationship between planning and
performance.
It should be noted that one cannot say that organizations that formally plan always
outperform those that don’t plan. However, studies have indicated that formal
planning is often associated with positive financial results. Generally, performance
is also higher in those organizations where planning is present. And, when higher
performance is not the result of formal planning, often the reason is due to
P a g e | 30
something in the external environment. Finally, studies indicate that at least four
years of formal planning are necessary before performance is affected.
4. Will planning become more or less important to managers in the future? Why?
Planning will become more important to managers in the future because of the
uncertainty in an increasingly dynamic environment. Changes constantly occur in
both the general and specific environments of organizations, and many of these
changes take place rapidly. Planning helps managers cope with the uncertainty by
forcing managers to look ahead, anticipate change, consider the impact of the
change, and develop appropriate responses.
5. If planning is so crucial, why do some managers choose not to do it? What would
you tell these managers?
Managers may choose not to devote time to planning because they do not know
how to plan or feel that they do not have the necessary time. Others may say that
planning is a waste of time, that the future is going to happen whether or not they
P a g e | 31
plan. However, these reasons do not discount the importance of planning. Every
manager should engage in planning.
6. Explain how planning involves decisions today that will have an impact later.
As managers plan, they make decisions that influence how activities are organized,
how employees are managed, and what control mechanisms are implemented. As
managers look to the future by planning, the decisions they make as they plan will
have an impact on their other managerial activities.
The process of planning is similar, but the content of the plans will differ. The types
of objectives that are established and the plans that are formulated will be
influenced by the fact that a not-for-profit organization does not have profit as its
major objective. However, a not-for-profit organization must devote efforts and
resources to planning how to raise funds and to recruit volunteers to achieve its
mission.
8. What types of planning do you do in your personal life? Describe these plans
in terms of being (a) strategic or operational plans, (b) short or long term plans, and
(c) specific or directional plans.
Students’ responses to this question will, of course, vary. Students may mention
their planning to meet educational and career goals. Encourage your students to
think about their everyday lives and the types of daily, weekly, monthly, and yearly
planning they do.
9. The late Peter Drucker, an eminent management author, coined the SMART
format for setting goals back in 1954: S (specific), M (measurable), A (attainable), R
(relevant), and T (time bound). Are these still relevant today? Discuss.
Of all of the material presented in this chapter, most students will readily recall this
acronym for goal setting. These qualities from Drucker have remained basically
unaltered and have been cited in numerous texts and studies. As a part of student
P a g e | 32
discussion, try to find other application for Drucker’s work in this area beyond the
management of employees. What about for school children? Volunteers working
for a community program?
Discussion questions:
P a g e | 33
Question 2: How might SWOT analysis be helpful to Lady Gaga as she and her
advisors manage her career?
as to counter the declining revenue that many artists struggle with. From this Lady
Gaga and her group invest in large sums of money upfront with expectations of a
greater return. Her ability to capitalize on merchandise, concert tours and
appearances plays to her benefit. Her knowledge of utilizing social media is strength
as well.
To accompany her skill of utilizing her team she also has unique vocals and a
persona to compliment. Weaknesses may include her vibrant personality that the
public may now unfortunately be accustomed to. This adds pressure for Lady Gaga
to consistently or inconsistently find ways to evolve. From an external viewpoint
there are opportunities and threats that she must pay close attention to. The threat
of new entrants is not very likely due to the competitive nature of the business.
While there are several other celebrity figures that strive to differentiate themselves
they generally have their own audience---artists like Nicki Minaj and Rihanna often
come to mind. In terms of threat of substitutes, there is little to none because Lady
Gaga is the only “extremist” in terms of music for that genre. Bargaining power of
buyers is high because this is ultimately what keeps her in business. With today’s
generation Lady Gaga must continuously find ways to appeal to individuals to
legally purchase her materials. Bargaining power of supplies is low because there
are many sources that Gaga can use to help create the final product of her albums
and any other item associated. Lastly, the current rivalry is moderate due to the
celebrities that have already established themselves. Understanding the business
and how to assess it can profoundly helpful to Lady Gaga and advisors manage her
career.
Question 3: What competitive advantage do you think Lady Gaga is pursuing? How
is she exploiting that competitive advantage?
Answer 3: In order for Lady Gaga to remain a relevant entertainer the competitive
strategy she relies on is the differentiation focus. Lady Gaga has a declared target
audience and segment in the market that she makes her music for, her “Little
Monsters”. Through this she created a distribution channel, which receives much of
its credit from the LGBT community that she often highlights in her songs, concerts
and appearances she frequently makes. The actions that Lady Gaga partakes in
P a g e | 35
have the tendency to be outrageous yet feasible. The variety of costumes and
performances are eye-catching and outlandish but she ensures that it does just that.
It is with high intention that she captures and demands the attention to build her
global presence. The teams’ management in emphasizing her decisions has helped
in her chart-topping singles. At only the age of 28 she has been awarded five
Grammy’s, 13 MTV Video Music Awards and has been named as one of the world’s
most influential people from Time Magazine. Her philanthropic endeavors also play
a role in where she is today. Her performances receive positive reviews that are
critically acclaimed. Her competitive strategy is one that dynamically envisions new
possibilities to maintain her success.
Question 4: Do you think Lady Gaga’s success is due to external or internal factors
or both? Explain.
Answer 4: While there are many factors to consider Gaga’s success is arguably due
to her external factors. How well she is able to adapt to the market and her
competitors displays her level of expertise in the business. Understanding the
difficulty it is for new entrants to enter is one major factor, which Lady Gaga has
surpassed and accomplished. So early in her career she was recognized for her
new sound and unique messages. This in turn proves why artists like Britney
Spears, Fergie and New Kids on The Block have all hired her to share her
songwriting skills. With the common saying, “if you can’t beat them, join them” holds
true. Iconic legends like Tony Bennet have recently decided to join forces with the
“Fame” artist herself. She continuously pushes the envelope and is proactive in her
approach. Rather than wait to see what her competitors will do she does exactly
what she wants to do, which is a very wise choice for her. Many of her competitors
have an image to uphold so that they can maintain their audience and remain a
certain type of character but due to who she is goes against the popular mainstream
crowd to further distinguish herself.
Question 5: What strategic implications does the suggestion that her ability to
remain a music industry mainstay depends on her ability to evolve have?
P a g e | 36
Answer 5: It is the goal for an individual in the music industry to remain a music
mainstay by their ability to evolve. With Lady Gaga’s first single, “Just Dance” it set
a good level of introduction to the public to show her fun, fierce, edgy side that was
welcoming. As stated in the case it is her persona seems to be a calculated strategy
that spans across dozens of subcultures. Her music style correlates to her
vivacious personality. Lady Gaga redefines herself each and every time she steps
foot in front of the public eye. As a fan the only thing you can expect is that she will
be different but it is always a surprise as to what extent. The strategy of being
unpredictable is not one that anyone can master. It takes a team of creative and
adventurous individuals to spawn these ideas that will launch her career to
something that is far larger than the character she already is. The process of
evolution requires the ability to critically think of what will advance the current and
next generation while avoiding what history has already created. Lady Gaga from
the beginning of her career has executed this tactic phenomenally and serves as a
model to follow in developing an effective strategy.
The six steps in the strategic management process encompass strategy planning,
implementation, and evaluation. These steps include the following: (1) identify the
current mission, goals, and strategies; (2) do an external analysis; (3) do an internal
analysis (steps 2 and 3 collectively are known as SWOT analysis); (4) formulate
strategies; (5) implement strategies; and (6) evaluate strategies. Strengths are any
activities the organization does well or unique resources that it has. Weaknesses
are activities the organization doesn’t do well or resources it needs but doesn’t
P a g e | 37
have. Opportunities are positive trends in the external environment. Threats are
negative trends.
3. How could the Internet be helpful to managers as they follow the steps in the
strategic management process?
All companies, large or small, profit or not-for-profit, domestic or global benefit from
the process of strategy formulation. The major difference that exists between the
different types of companies and the process they go through centers around the
development of their mission and goals. For example, the owners of a small
business might not want to pursue the goal of growth and instead focus on stability.
For not-for-profit organizations, the goal is not about making money for owners or
stockholders but about how to find a way to effectively and efficiently maximize their
resources to benefit others. In a global organization, while the SWOT would be
more involved due to the number of potential elements involved, it remains the
same except the goals extend beyond serving one country or market.
6. Describe the three major types of corporate strategies and how the BCG matrix is
used to manage those corporate strategies.
Not-for-profit and for-profit companies compete for customers. In the case of not-
for-profit companies, those customers are donors and like any market are limited in
size. To be effective non-for-profit companies need something that will attract
P a g e | 39
donors like for-profit companies attract customers. For example, United Way has
an established network of businesses that regularly donate money as part of their
yearly pledge drives. Another example is Mary Komen’s, known for their work with
breast cancer awareness, that has established a series of runs and walks across
the United States and has even had success in publicizing their cause with the NFL.
Using the Internet, companies have created knowledge bases that employees can
tap into anytime, anywhere. E-business as a strategy can be used to develop a
sustainable competitive advantage; it can also be used to establish a basis for
differentiation or focus. Customer service strategies give customers what they want,
communicate effectively with them, and provide employees with customer service
training. Innovation strategies focus on breakthrough products and can include the
application of existing technology to new uses. An organization that is first to bring a
product innovation to the market or to use a new process innovation is called a first
mover.
Discussion Questions:
P a g e | 40
Answer 1: It is easy for a company to lose sight of their goals. While other lines of
business may be potential money makers, going beyond a firm’s core competence
can lead a firm into financial trouble. In this case, students should see how Charles
Schwab has stayed true to its primary business - making stock trades for investors
who make their own financial decisions. Another goal of Schwab is customer
service. In the example of Cheryl Pasquale, we can see how she uses the
company’s information system to closely monitor her sales representatives to make
sure they are meeting the needs of customers.
Question 2: How might the company’s culture of not buying into hype and not taking
excessive risks affect its organizational structural design?
Question 4: Do you think this arrangement would work for other types of
organizations? Why or why not?
P a g e | 41
Answer 4: This type of customer focus would not work well for firms that operate on
a thin margin. For example, manufacturing firms that operate in the maturity phase
of the industry life cycle focus on keeping production costs as low as possible. This
arrangement may also not work well in situations where organizations are set up
around processes.
1. Discuss the traditional and contemporary views of each of the six key elements of
organizational design.
Traditionally, work specialization was viewed as a way to divide work activities into
separate job tasks. Today’s view is that it is an important organizing mechanism but
it can lead to problems. The chain of command and its companion concepts—
authority, responsibility, and unity of command—were viewed as important ways of
maintaining control in organizations. The contemporary view is that they are less
relevant in today’s organizations. The traditional view of span of control was that
managers should directly supervise no more than five to six individuals. The
contemporary view is that the span of control depends on the skills and abilities of
the manager and the employees and on the characteristics of the situation.
The speed with which structural changes can be implemented depends partly upon
an organization’s size. A small organization is usually able to change its structure
more rapidly than a larger one because a smaller company has fewer employees
who are involved in the restructuring process. However, a large organization can
change its structure and often does in response to changing environmental
conditions and changing strategies.
Students’ answers to this question will vary. Many students prefer the structure
provided by a mechanistic organization, whereas others would be less productive in
an organization with structural rigidity. Note that SAL #III.A.1 “What Type of
Organization Structure Do I Prefer?” addresses whether each of your students
would like to work in a bureaucracy (a mechanistic organization). Students might
want to revisit this assessment in answering this question.
An organization’s structure should support the strategy. If the strategy changes, the
structure also should change. An organization’s size can affect its structure up to a
certain point. Once an organization reaches a certain size (usually around 2,000
employees), it’s fairly mechanistic. An organization’s technology can affect its
structure. An organic structure is most effective with unit production and process
production technology. A mechanistic structure is most effective with mass
production technology. The more uncertain an organization’s environment, the more
it needs the flexibility of an organic design.
8. Researchers are now saying that efforts to simplify work tasks actually have
negative results for both companies and their employees. Do you agree? Why or
why not?
Studies as far back as 1924 show that simplified jobs lead to boredom. In 1950
other researchers found that highly segmented and simplified jobs resulted in lower
employee morale and output. Other consequences of low employee motivation
include absenteeism and high employee turnover, both very costly for businesses.
Discussion Questions:
Question 1: How might the nature of what the virus hunters do affect the most
appropriate structure for getting work done efficiently and effectively?
Answer 1: The nature of what the virus hunters do affects their structure for getting
work done efficiently and effectively simply because their work can never be
completed. They are always working to correct a new problem; as quick as one
virus goes away, two more will probably appear. They also have to research and
find viruses that are out there and tackle them before they do major damage to
many of the networks. In order to keep their customers happy, they have to perform
often and quickly.
Answer 2: There will probably be many challenges when working with a mixed
group of professionals and customer volunteers. First is motivation; professionals
are probably motivated to perform at a higher level and to produce a quality project
because they are in a workplace environment. They are trying to perform well and
earn their wages; they are also competing with each other to be the most efficient
and productive in their team so they will surely take things very seriously. Another is
the level of knowledge. As professionals they will be experts but the volunteers
won’t be able to communicate as well with the professionals due to potential gaps in
knowledge of the subject. While customers do have some personal motivation in
terms of their network security, their professional success is not contingent on their
level of performance. Customers who are volunteering could potentially be helpful
but they could also slow the progress of a lot of research and development.
Question 3: What types of adaptive organizational designs discussed in this
chapter might be most appropriate for Symantec to most effectively manage its
professionals and its customer volunteers? Explain your choices.
P a g e | 45
1. Describe the four contemporary organizational designs. How are they similar?
Different?
In a team structure, the entire organization is made up of work teams. The matrix
structure assigns specialists from different functional departments to work on one or
more projects being led by project managers. A project structure is one in which
employees continuously work on projects. A virtual organization consists of a small
core of fulltime employees and outside specialists temporarily hired as needed to
work on projects. A network organization is an organization that uses its own
employees to do some work activities and networks of outside suppliers to provide
other needed product components or work processes. A learning organization is
one that has developed the capacity to continuously learn, adapt, and change. It
has certain structural characteristics including an emphasis on sharing information
and collaborating on work activities, minimal structural and physical barriers, and
empowered work team.
A project structure, unlike the matrix structure, has no formal departments where
employees return at the completion of a project. Instead, employees take their
P a g e | 46
specific skills, abilities, and experiences to other projects. Also, all work in project
structures is performed by teams of employees.
4. The boundaries organization has the potential to create a major shift in the way
we work. Do you agree or disagree? Explain.
Students’ responses to this will vary. This question could serve as an interesting
springboard for a class debate. Students could break into teams, with each team
taking the opposite position in the debate. Give students an opportunity to discuss
their strategy as a team before presenting their viewpoints to the class.
In all of these types of organizations, flexibility and adaptability are critical. In the
project structure, conflict management skills are particularly useful. In a boundaries
organization, the ability to interact effectively with people at all levels and in all areas
of the organization is crucial to success. In a learning organization, a manager
needs the ability to communicate both by listening and by speaking because of the
frequency and importance of sharing information in this type of organization.
6. How does each of the different types of collaboration (both internal and external)
contribute to more coordinated and integrated work efforts?
P a g e | 47
8. Does the idea of a flexible work arrangement appeal to you? Why or why not?
Students may respond several ways to this question. Flexible work arrangements
are not for everyone. An analogy is internet classes. While these classes offer the
student greater flexibility and help with scheduling issues, some students find that
they do not get as much from the class or that they lose focus and let the class
assignments build up.
9. What structural issues might arise in managing contingent workers? Again, think
about what you’ve learned about organizational design. How might that information
help a manager address those issues?
This question seems strange with all of the communication technology available
today (i.e. cell-phones, e-mail, electronic meeting software, etc…). However, with
organizations adopting more flexible structures and flexible work arrangements,
employees are dispersed throughout the organization and the world. In addition,
with the introduction of team and project environments, it is possible that employees
will be working on so multiple projects at once. Considering these factors, it is
difficult to make sure everyone has the necessary information when and where they
need it.
Discussion Questions:
P a g e | 49
Question 1: What are advantages and drawbacks of using social media in the
recruiting process for an applicant and a company?
Answer 1: Social media has completely revolutionized the way in which people all
around the world communicate. This form of communication has branched off from
just an individual level to a company level. Companies are now using social media
to both recruit and screen applicant. These methods for attracting top talent for
organizations are both beneficial and detrimental. The advantages of this
recruitment platform reach both an individual and organizational level.
On an individual level some of the benefits include, not being limited to the jobs
within your geographic location, access to recruiters at all levels, and being able to
learn about the company culture in an untraditional way. Corporations benefit from
this form of recruiting because it gives them access to a large number of potential
applicants. An added benefit to the large applicant pool is that many young college
students use social media. This allows a company to create relatable and flexible
systems for attracting young talent to entry level positions. Additional social media
recruitment has a low cost and a potentially high return on investment, it essentially
allows companies to screen applicants before they bring them in for an interview.
Question 2: Is the use of social media in recruiting applicants a way to hire smarter
or a lawsuit waiting to happen? Explain your position.
Question 3: Go to Facebook and check out Ernst & Young’s page. What’s your
impression? Is it an attractive recruiting tool? Why or why not?
Answer 3: While on the Ernest & Young Company Facebook page I noticed that the
company has completely branded the profile with that of Ernest & Young signature
colors and logos. The company also made effort to personalize it to their firm by
placing pictures of the companies surrounding locations on the page. Although the
pictures might attract some potential employees I wasn’t very impressed. There
were multiple Ernest & Young company pages each one for a specific location (Sao
Paulo, Brazil and Mexico City, Mexico) and I appreciate the specificity and
customization of each page to the location. It would help if I was looking for specific
location related information. The profile would give me specific information instead
of general company information that doesn’t pertain to me. I like the break down by
P a g e | 51
location because helps cater the message for people interested in a specifics
offices/ locations it helps filter down the amount of information being uploaded to the
page. There page wasn’t something that would make me want to apply to the
company but there strategic planning behind the page was appreciated.
Since a manager’s most valuable resource are the people who work in the
organization, obtaining the right employees at the right time and placing them in the
right places is essential for managerial success. To motivate, retain, and equip
these employees for optimal performance, a manager must have knowledge and
skill in human resource management.
2. Discuss the external environmental factors that most directly affect the HRM
process.
Student responses to this question will vary. This question provides an excellent
vehicle for class debate. You might let half of the class take the perspective of
supporting government legislation and regulations and the other half assume the
position of opposing government legislation and regulations in this area.
4. Some critics claim that corporate HR departments have outlived their usefulness
and are not there to help employees, but to keep the organization from legal
problems. What do you think? What benefits are there to having a formal HRM
process? What drawbacks?
P a g e | 52
Every organization must recognize the importance of legal and social responsibility
as a corporate citizen in the community. As students learn in the study of this
chapter, HRM is concerned with a wide spectrum of functions, and legal
considerations are a part of each of these HR functions. A formal process helps to
provide objective compliance with the law and promotes an attitude of fairness and
respect for the rights and welfare of all employees.
5. Describe the different selection devices and which work best for different jobs.
The different selection devices include application forms (best used for gathering
employee information), written tests (must be job-related), work sampling
(appropriate for complex nonmanagerial and routine work), assessment centers
(most appropriate for top-level managers), interviews (widely used, but most
appropriate for managerial positions, especially top-level managers), background
investigations (useful for verifying application data, but reference checks are
essentially worthless), and physical exams (useful for work that involves certain
physical requirements and for insurance purposes).
6. What are the benefits and drawbacks of realistic job previews? (Consider this
question from the perspective of both the organization and the employee.)
This question would be a good springboard for debate as well, with half of the class
looking at RJPs from the organization’s viewpoint and the other half of the class
looking at RJPs from the employee’s viewpoint. In addition, students should be
encouraged to describe occasions when they have received an RJP in an interview
setting. Students could also be encouraged to share aspects or characteristics of
jobs they currently hold that should be communicated by an interviewer to
prospective employees as part of an RJP in an employment interview.
7. Describe the different types of orientation and training and how each of the types
of training might be provided.
resignation. The two types of training are general (includes communication skills,
computer skills, customer service, personal growth, etc.) and specific (includes
basic life/work skills, customer education, diversity/cultural awareness, managing
change, etc.). This training can be provided using traditional training methods (on-
the-job, job rotation, mentoring and coaching, experiential exercises,
workbooks/manuals, and classroom lectures) or by technology-based methods
CD/DVD/videotapes/audiotapes, videoconferencing or teleconferencing, or e-
learning).
The factors are: employee’s tenure and performance, kind of job performed, kind of
business, unionization, labor or capital intensive business, management philosophy,
geographic location, company profitability, and size of company.
10. What, in your view, constitutes sexual harassment? Describe how companies
can minimize sexual harassment in the workplace.
You might provide an opportunity for small group discussion of this question and
encourage students to research (perhaps on the Web outside of class) strategies
currently used by large and small companies to minimize sexual harassment in the
workplace. In the class session immediately following the small group discussions,
ask students to share their answers and opinions regarding issues raised by this
question.
Discussion Questions:
P a g e | 55
Answer 1: I always tell students, mergers (like marriages) involve the blending
together of two, or more, different personalities. Because members from both
organizations have established ways of doing things, it would be difficult to get team
members from both cultures to trust and communicate with each other. Managers
will need to give the new group time as well as the necessary resources to develop.
Goals for cooperation will need to be established in addition to rewards for team
success.
Answer 3: The identical office furniture would help maintain equity between team
members – so individuals cannot claim favoritism. In another sense it could be
seen as creating an identity of being on the same team, like jerseys on a sports
team. The open-office space would provide more opportunity for team members to
interact with one another. By changing the physical workplace, the organization is
reinforcing the concept of a new beginning and divesting itself of old artifacts.
1. Describe the different types of groups and the five stages of group development.
2. Explain how external conditions and group member resources affect group
performance and satisfaction.
3. Discuss how group structure, group processes, and group tasks influence group
performance and satisfaction.
Group roles generally involve getting the work done or keeping group members
happy. Group norms are powerful influences on a person’s performance and dictate
things such as work output levels, absenteeism, and promptness. Pressures to
conform can heavily influence a person’s judgment and attitudes. If carried to
extremes, groupthink can be a problem. Status systems can be a significant
motivator with individual behavioral consequences, especially if incongruence is a
factor. What size group is most effective and efficient depends on the task the group
is supposed to accomplish. Cohesiveness is related to a group’s productivity.
P a g e | 57
Group decision making and conflict management are important group processes
that play a role in performance and satisfaction. If accuracy, creativity, and degree of
acceptance are important, a group decision may work best. Relationship conflicts
are almost always dysfunctional. Low levels of process conflicts and low-to-
moderate levels of task conflicts are functional. Effective communication and
controlled conflict are most relevant to group performance when tasks are complex
and interdependent.
The challenges of managing global teams can be seen in the group member
resources, especially the diverse cultural characteristics; group structure, especially
conformity, status, social loafing, and cohesiveness; group processes, especially
with communication and managing conflict; and the manager’s role in making
it all work.
Research on social networks has shown that when people need help getting a job
done, they’ll choose a friendly colleague over someone who may be more capable.
Another recent review of team studies showed that teams with high levels of
interpersonal interconnectedness actually attained their goals better and were more
committed to staying together.
9. How do you think scientific management theorists would react to the increased
reliance on teams in organizations? How would behavioral science theorists react?
Scientific management theorists would likely react negatively to the use of teams in
organizations. Scientific management focuses on the “one best way” for an
individual to do his or her job; searching for the “one best way” could inhibit
creativity and ideas for innovation that would likely come through the use of teams.
Behavioral scientists, on the other hand, would be favorable to the concept of
increased reliance on teams and groups. Because teams utilize input from the
diverse background of several individuals and place responsibility on each team
member, behavioral lists would be in favor of this approach.
10. Why might a manager want to stimulate conflict in a group or team? How could
conflict be stimulated?
A manager might want to stimulate conflict in a group or team in order to help that
group or team generate more creative, innovative solutions to a problem or
challenge. Managers want to stimulate conflict to gain the full benefits of its
functional properties without allowing disagreement to become a disruptive force.
P a g e | 59
Conflict can be simulated by bringing new members to the group, restructuring the
group, appointing a devil’s advocate, attempting to change the group’s culture, and
using open communication.
Discussion Questions:
P a g e | 60
Question 1: What do you think of this situation? Do you agree with the council’s
decision about the firing and refusal to reinstate the employees?
Answer 1: We think that office gossip should not exceed its limits Yes , the council
decision of firing was correct because the office gossip was move toward the
rumors and getting dangerous for the administrator and for its assistant the gossip
was regarding the affair between the administrator and its assistance. So it was a
good decision by the council for the refusal of reinstates the employees because if
the employees came back due to natural phenomena they should again start the
gossips which again lead to the ramous.
Answer 2: Office gossip is not always harmful MacDraw says that “If someone
shares gossip with you, it bonds you together,” it create trust between office
colleagues. It is the fact that people automatically think gossip is bad. The people do
not want to hear anything about their self, if the gossip is leaked to the third person
it will create unfavorable atmosphere in the organization which is not good for the
organization.
But sometimes the office gossips can be good for the managers because it is also a
channel of communication the manager are aware about their self what their
employees says about them and about their organization, it can also useful
sometime when employees gossip about the organization for its betterment.
Question 3: In retrospect, what could these four women have done differently?
Answer 3: In retrospect, these four women gossip with each other about their
administrator the one of the woman had used rough language to describe the town
administrator and because all of them had discussed a rumor that he was having an
affair with a female subordinate. All four of the woman acknowledged feeling
P a g e | 61
resentment toward the woman. Who worked in a specially created position and was
paid more than two of the employees, despite having less experience and seniority.
Question 4: What implications from this story can you see for managers and
communication?
Answer 4: The implications we can see from this story is that the managers should
not give preference to only one employee so that other employees start gossip for
that employee and also gossip to the employer. We also see that the employees
should not exceed their gossip limits which create the ramous in the organization.
4. What are the various communication methods managers can use? What criteria
can managers use to evaluate those communication methods?
5. What are the barriers to effective communication? How can those barriers be
overcome?
The two main challenges of managing communication in an Internet world are the
legal and security issues and the lack of personal interaction.
Organizations can manage knowledge by making it easy for employees to
communicate and share their knowledge, which can help them learn from each
other ways to do their jobs more effectively and efficiently. One way is through
online information databases and another way is through creating communities of
practice.
Communicating with customers is an important managerial issue since what
communication takes place and how it takes place can significantly affect a
customer’s satisfaction with the service and the likelihood of being a repeat
P a g e | 64
customer. It’s important for organizations to get input from their employees. Such
potentially valuable information should not be ignored.
Finally, a company’s communication efforts need to be ethical. Ethical
communication can be encouraged through clear guidelines and through answering
questions that force a communicator to think through the communication choices
made and the consequences of those choices.
10. Which do you think is more important for a manager: speaking accurately or
listening actively? Why?
Students’ reactions may vary; however, they need to make a strong case for their
answer. A strong case can be made for each of the two responses. As students
have learned, barriers can occur at any step in the communication process. The
sender is responsible for sending an accurate message and choosing the most
appropriate channel for the message, while considering the receiver’s
characteristics and environment. Active listening is critical so that the receiver can
interpret the message as intended and send valuable feedback to the sender. In
addition, the open communication that is vital between management and employees
in a learning organization depends upon an atmosphere of trust. Employees must
have confidence that their manager will listen actively to their comments and
concerns.
Discussion Questions:
P a g e | 65
Question 1: Describe the elements of ROWE. What do you think might be the
advantages and draw-backs of this program?
2013). Some of the disadvantages, for managers, may be maintaining control of the
workplace. Many employees may take advantage of their freedom and only do
enough work to get by, while others may be contributing more to the organization.
This would create an unfair work environment and cause some employees to leave.
It would also make it difficult for the managers to initiate discipline due to having the
ability to see their employees pulling their weight. This process is intriguing and
would work in less controlled environments; however, maintaining employee
production may be difficult which out being able to visualize employee production
(Ressler, 2013).
Question 2: Using one or more motivation theories from the chapter, explain why
you think ROWE works.
Question 4: Does this sound like something you would be comfortable with? Why or
why not?
Answer 4: The ROWE concept is something that I would be comfortable with and be
able to implement in my organization. In ROWE, this is an excellent chance that
mangers can focus on issues that the organizations are facing instead of the
workflow of each employee. With implanting ROWE into your organizations, you will
have to be a person in leadership that has great confidence in yourself and your
ability of the staff. With the ROWE concepts, you review each per-son positions
and evaluate which individuals have valued employees to the company and
individuals that re lacking in their skill sets. ROWE could be looked at as a concept
that “calls each person out “it is a way to improve the organization. As a CEO, my
whole objective is to have a successful organization with outstanding employees to
get the job done. When ROWE is used in the organization, employees are the
unnamed CEO of the company, this takes the workload off the appointed to CEO.
We would be comfortable with the concept because we have individuals within our
organization that have the proper training tools to be successful with the ROWE
concept. We would designate individuals to be responsible for a certain task of the
job and know how to do the job with the ROWE concept in mind.
Everyone will never work the same as we all have different styles of achieving our
job responsibilities. The ROWE concept is valuable in having satisfied employees
come to work, believe in their abilities and not have the direct oversee of a manger.
P a g e | 68
Question 5: What's your interpretation of the statement that "Work isn't a place you
go--it's something you do"? Do you agree? Why or why not?
Motivation is the process by which a person’s efforts are energized, directed, and
sustained toward attaining a goal. The energy element is a measure of intensity,
drive, or vigor. The high level of effort needs to be directed in ways that help the
organization achieve its goals. Employees must persist in putting forth effort to
achieve those goals.
dissatisfied. Three-needs theory proposed three acquired needs that are major
motives in work: need for achievement, need for affiliation, and need for power.
Goal-setting theory says that specific goals increase performance, and difficult
goals, when accepted, result in higher performance than do easy goals. Important
points in goal setting theory include intention to work toward a goal as a major
source of job motivation; specific hard goals that produce higher levels of output
than generalized goals; participation in setting goals as preferable to assigning
goals, but not always; feedback that guides and motivates behavior, especially self-
generated feedback; and contingencies that affect goal setting—goal commitment,
self-efficacy, and national culture. Reinforcement theory says that behavior is a
function of its consequences. To motivate, use positive reinforcers to reinforce
desirable behaviors. Ignore undesirable behavior rather than punishing it.
Equity theory focuses on how employees compare their inputs–outcomes ratios to
relevant others’ ratios. A perception of inequity will cause an employee to do
something about it. Procedural justice has a greater influence on employee
satisfaction than does distributive justice.
Job enlargement involves horizontally expanding job scope by adding more tasks or
increasing how many times the tasks are done. Job enrichment vertically expands
job depth by giving employees more control over their work. The job characteristics
model says five core job dimensions (skill variety, task identity, task significance,
autonomy, and feedback) are used to design motivating jobs. Another job design
approach proposed looking at relational aspects and proactive aspects of jobs.
5. Explain the three key linkages in expectancy theory and their role in motivation.
Expectancy theory says that an individual tends to act in a certain way based on the
expectation that the act will be followed by a desired outcome. Expectancy is the
effort–performance linkage (how much effort do I need to exert to achieve a certain
P a g e | 70
During tough economic conditions, managers must look for creative ways to keep
employees’ efforts energized, directed, and sustained toward achieving goals. Most
motivational theories were developed in the United States and have a North
American bias. Some theories (Maslow’s need hierarchy, achievement need, and
equity theory) don’t work well for other cultures. However, the desire for interesting
work seems important to all workers and Herzberg’s motivator (intrinsic) factors may
be universal.
Open-book management is when financial statements (the books) are shared with
employees who have been taught what they mean. Employee recognition programs
consist of personal attention, approval, and appreciation for a job well done. Pay-
for-performance programs are variable compensation plans that pay employees on
the basis of some performance measure.
P a g e | 71
9. Most of us have to work for a living, and a job is a central part of our lives. So
why do managers have to worry so much about employee motivation issues?
Even though most of us have to work for a living in order to support ourselves and
those who are dependent upon us, managers still have to worry about employee
motivation because some employees are not always willing to put forth the effort to
do their job to the best of their ability.
Even when employees are willing to put forth their best effort, managers must take
steps to ensure that their motivation will be sustained over time, in spite of personal
or professional setbacks and factors in the external environment over which they
and their employees may have no control. Managers must have knowledge of
motivational theories and understand the individual differences and perceptions of
their employees in order to choose rewards that will be effective in motivating them
to work together to reach organizational goals.
This question can serve as an excellent springboard for small group discussion.
Students may express strong opinions in their answers to this question, depending
upon their employment experiences and the types of managers and employees with
whom they have already worked. Their answers to this question will likely introduce
ethical considerations in relation to motivation and the willingness of some
individuals to lose sight of ethical standards in pursuit of a goal.
Discussion Questions:
Question1: What do you think about Buckley’s statement that leaders and managers
differ? Do you agree? Why or why not?
Question 3: Take each of the six leadership attributes that the company feels is
important. Explain what you think each one involves. Then discuss how those
attributes might be developed and measured.
Answer 3: There are several virtues that appear to emerge as being extra vital than
the other ones. The uplifting report is that every one of these virtues can be
educated, and they must be well-read by preparation and reiteration.
1. Vision: The mainly significant Single value of Leadership, Pioneers have vision.
They can see into what's to come. They have a reasonable, brisk consideration of
where they are departing and what they attempts to finish. This quality isolates them
from administrators. To have a unique vision converts the individual into a unique
sort of individual. These personalities of vision modify a “value-based supervisor”
into a ''transformational leader.'' While a chief takes concern of production, a
genuine pioneer takes advantage of the opinion of his kin.
2. Bravery: The Second Quality That Leaders Have in Common the personality of
bravery involves that you are keen to go for broke in the achievement of your goals
with no certification of achievement. This is the reason mettle is the mainly personal
superficial nature of an incredible pioneer.
3. Uprightness: The Most Respected and Admired Quality of Superior People and
Leaders In each vital organizing assembly that I have directed for expansive and
slight associations, the initial regard that each and every one are assembled
manager concur ahead for their association is honesty. They all concur on the
implication of complete authenticity in all that they do, in cooperation within and
remotely. The centre of honesty is honesty. Honesty requires that you generally
come clean, to all individuals, in each circumstance. Honesty is the establishment
nature of the faith that is essential for the accomplishment of any production.
4. Lowliness: privileged have the safety and Self-Confidence to identify the
importance of others the most excellent pioneers are the individuals who are solid
and definitive additionally humble. Lowliness doesn't imply that you're powerless or
uncertain of yourself. It implies that you have the self-assurance and mindfulness to
perceive the estimation of others without feeling debilitated. It involves that you are
keen to concede you could not be right, that you remember you might not have
P a g e | 75
every single of the answers. Furthermore, it implies that you acknowledge a job well
done.
5. Prescience: Leaders have the capacity to look into the prospect and anticipate
that might happen superb pioneers are great vital masterminds. They can look
ahead, to envision with some exactness where the business and the business
sectors are going. Pioneers can foresee patterns, well ahead of time of their rivals.
They consistently ask, on the basis of what is going on nowadays, where is the
business sector going? Where is it liable to be in three months, six months, one
year, and two years?''
6. Centre: The capability to center energies and capital in the mainly significant
areas pioneers dependably concentrates on the requirements of the association
and the circumstance. Pioneers concentrate on the qualities of the association, on
the things that the organization bests in fulfilling requesting clients in a focused
commercial centre.
Discussion Questions:
Question 1: What do you think of this description of Captain Holly Graf’s leader
style? Do you think that Captain Graf could even be called a leader? Discuss.
Answer 1: This case epitomizes the difference between a manager and a leader.
Students should question whether legitimate power does indeed make a leader. In
other words, does title alone ensure that subordinates will view the person “in
charge” as a leader.
Question 2: What kinds of power do you think Graf used as a ship commander?
Explain your choices.
Answer 2: Though the case may not present a daily log of Graf’s actions, from what
is illustrated, students should be able to point to legitimate power as the obvious
source of power. But, they may also identify coercive power in the way Graf
behaved toward crews.
Question 3: Not surprisingly, this whole scenario rocked the Navy to its core since it
reflected on the way the Navy chooses, promotes, and then monitors its handpicked
leaders. What changes, if any, do you think need to take place in its leadership
training and development?
Answer 3: Student responses will vary, but encourage them to think about the
hierarchy involved. If the students were Graf’s superior officer, how would that
individual view the training process? Or, if one of Graf’s crew members, what would
that person view as important in terms of training and development? Students
might also consider the differences in leadership styles when one is operating in a
time of war versus managing say, a retail store or a restaurant. Is an autocratic
style of leadership necessary on a Navy ship? In every situation?
P a g e | 78
Question 4: Some critics of Graf’s treatment have said that institutional sexism
played a role in her removal. Do you think that could be possible? Discuss. Would
that “excuse” the way she led? Explain.
Answer 4: As students consider this question, have them think about the pioneering
steps Graf took in her career. Being the first woman to command a destroyer is a
significant accomplishment in the U.S. Navy. Have students explore the
contingency theory of leadership. What if a leader chooses the wrong style of
leadership in a given situation? Is it possible that Graf was varying her leadership
style, but in an incorrect fashion – such as using an autocratic style when she
should have been more democratic or even laissez-faire? And, is a military
environment completely different than the private, business sector?
1. Define leader and leadership and explain why managers should be leaders.
Students should be able to provide the definitions in the text – that a leader is
someone who influences others and that leadership is the process of influencing
others to achieve a goal. However, encourage students to think about their own
definitions of who a leader is and how they personally define leadership.
2. What does each of the four behavioral leadership theories say about leadership?
Fiedler’s model proposed that group performance was based upon the leader’s
style and the amount of control in a given situation. After a leader’s style is
assessed through the least-preferred coworker questionnaire, three contingency
dimensions are examined: leader-member relations, task structure, and position
power. Ultimately, the model suggests that effectiveness is achieved when a leader
is matched to a particular situation or if the situation is changed.
Situational leadership theory focuses upon the readiness of followers. It treats the
leader and follower relationship like that of a parent and child. As the child
(follower) matures, the parent (leader) relinquishes more control. Path-goal theory
puts the focus on the leader and his or her ability to guide followers and remove
obstacles.
5. What is leader-member exchange theory and what does it say about leadership?
Leader-member exchange theory states that leaders establish “in-groups” and “out-
groups.” Those in the in-group will have higher performance, lower turnover, and
greater job satisfaction. This is due to the leader and follower investing in the
relationship.
The five sources of a leader’s power are legitimate, coercive, reward, expert, and
referent.
Today’s leaders face the issues of managing power, developing trust, empowering
employees, leading across cultures, and becoming an effective leader.
9. Do you think that most managers in real life use a contingency approach to
increase their leadership effectiveness? Explain.
It is the leader’s ability to get the follower to carry out the goals of the organization
that ultimately determines a leader’s success. However, if the followers are not
skilled or do not have the appropriate knowledge to accomplish the task then the
effectiveness of the leader suffers. You may want to use the example of a coach
P a g e | 81
who has lost key players due to unexpected injuries. If this player is taken out of the
game, then the team may lose the game regardless of the quality of the coaching.
2. What are the three steps in the control process? Describe in detail.
The three steps in the control process are measuring, comparing, and taking action.
Measuring involves deciding how to measure actual performance and what to
measure. Comparing involves looking at the variation between actual performance
and the standard (goal). Deviations outside an acceptable range of variation need
attention.
Feedforward controls take place before a work activity is done. Concurrent controls
take place while a work activity is being done. Feedback controls take place after a
work activity is done.
5. Discuss the various types of tools used to monitor and measure organizational
performance.
Financial controls that managers can use include financial ratios (liquidity, leverage,
activity, and profitability) and budgets. One information control managers can use is
an MIS, which provides managers with needed information on a regular basis.
Others include comprehensive and secure controls such as data encryption, system
firewalls, data backups, and so forth that protect the organization’s information.
Balanced scorecards provide a way to evaluate an organization’s performance in
four different areas rather than just from the financial perspective. Benchmarking
provides control by finding the best practices among competitors or noncompetitors
and from inside the organization itself.
6. What workplace concerns do managers have to deal with? How might those
concerns be controlled?
9. What are some work activities in which the acceptable range of variation might be
higher than average? What about lower than average? (Hint: Think in terms of the
output from the work activities, who it might affect, and how it might affect them.)
Every individual employee plays a role in controlling the quality of goods and
services produced by their company, particularly in organizations where employees
have been empowered by management. Even in organizations where employees
have not been extensively empowered, employees play a role in measuring,
comparing, and correcting performance. In any case, managers remain responsible
for establishing and maintaining standards, approaches, and guidelines for
measuring, comparing, and correcting the work of the organization.