Tat Bank Limited: Marketing Town, Business Land
Tat Bank Limited: Marketing Town, Business Land
Tat Bank Limited: Marketing Town, Business Land
By
Keith Inniss
Contents
Executive Summary.............................................................................................................2
1. Introduction....................................................................................................................3
1.1 Background..............................................................................................................3
1.2 Purpose and Objectives............................................................................................3
2. Analysis of the Environment.........................................................................................4
2.1 External Analysis.....................................................................................................4
2.1.1 Macro-environment...........................................................................................5
2.1.1.1 Demographic, Cultural & Social................................................................5
2.1.1.2 Political.......................................................................................................5
2.1.1.3 Economic....................................................................................................6
2.1.1.4 Technological.............................................................................................7
2.1.2 Market...............................................................................................................7
2.1.3 Competition.......................................................................................................8
2.2 Internal Analysis......................................................................................................9
2.2.1 Performance.......................................................................................................9
2.2.2 Management and Staff.....................................................................................10
2.2.3 Infrastructure and Delivery.............................................................................10
2.2.4 Customers........................................................................................................11
3. SWOT Analysis...........................................................................................................11
3.1 Opportunities..........................................................................................................11
3.2 Threats....................................................................................................................13
3.3 Strengths.................................................................................................................14
3.4 Weaknesses............................................................................................................16
4. Fundamental Marketing Strategies..............................................................................17
4.1 Supply Strategies....................................................................................................17
4.2 Demand Strategies.................................................................................................17
4.3 Positioning Strategies.............................................................................................17
4.4 Competition Strategies...........................................................................................18
5. Marketing Mix Strategies............................................................................................18
5.1 Product...................................................................................................................18
5.2 Price.......................................................................................................................19
5.3 Place.......................................................................................................................19
5.4 Promotion...............................................................................................................19
5.5 Personnel................................................................................................................20
6. Implementation and Control........................................................................................20
6.1 Implementation......................................................................................................21
6.2 Control...................................................................................................................23
7. Financial Forecast........................................................................................................24
8. Conclusion...................................................................................................................24
2
1
Executive Summary
ARYA Solar Company develops the wind and Solar (PV) Systems. This marketing plan
illustrates our market segments and the strategies we are employing to get customers and
create a solid revenue stream. We are not just any photovoltaic Systems developer. Our
unique focus of creating solar panels gives us an advantage over our competitors by
We will fund development of our own systems by providing consulting services to create
similar services for corporations who are looking to design wind & solar systems for
sponsorship relationships that we will establish with companies who are interested in
embedding their brand and offers inside our other products and would also like
something more custom that they can offer as their own products. In the next year of the
.
2
2. The Challenge
The Government of the country, shareholder of Tat Bank Ltd, as part of its proposed
housing development program for the country, has directed the Bank to approve 100%
mortgage financing for public servants. These mortgages will carry a maximum
repayment term of 25 years and will attract interest at 7.75% per annum. A study
conducted by PKF Consultanus for the Government has shown that the demand for
financing under the new mortgage plan will amount to $10 million in the first year, $18
million in the second year and $37 million in the third year. The Bank’s five years
strategic plan for the period 2001 to 2005 does not include this estimated growth, and the
competition for deposits is currently very stiff. The Bank could face great difficulty in
meeting the Central Bank’s accepted loans-to-deposits ratio of between 75% and 85% if
it fails to secure the required funding. Also, it could miss out on a golden opportunity to
The purpose of this project is to steer the Bank on a course that will enable it to secure
the required deposits to fund the new mortgage plan, while at the same time strengthen its
position in the local industry and achieve greater levels of profitability year after year. To
Increase profit by 15%, 22% and 35% respectively over the next three years, and
ultimately increase ROA from the current 0.56% to 0.95% at the end of year 2004
To accomplish these objectives, the project, after analysing the external and internal
environments of the Bank, identified the various marketing strategies designed to bring
success. It then tabled the implementation and control mechanisms aimed at ensuring that
An analysis was carried out on both the external and internal environments of the bank
The external analysis looked at the macro-environment, the market and the competition
2.1.1 Macro-environment
The local population which currently stands at approximately 116 thousand is young
and is expected to increase by just 800 by the end of the year 2003 The over 50 age
The population until recent times was predominantly religious, however with the
introduction of American television in our homes there is a big swing to the American
As a result of the advocating of equal rights for women, we have seen that women are
now taking on more leading roles in the society. The education system allows for
equal opportunities for men and women, and it appears that the women are currently
achieving better grades than men. Women currently make up 50 % of the workforce.
2.1.1.2 Political
The country is currently black listed by the Financial Actions Task Force (FATF), but
the Government has recently passed a new anti money laundering act, which it hopes
will result in the removal of the Country’s name from the list.
5
The other seven countries in the ECCB currency union also have stable governments.
2.1.1.3 Economic
The economies of the other states in the ECCB currency union are also stable and
A new cruise ship berth was built, and plans are underway for the construction of a
Tourism is growing and the hotel industry is developing. A 10% increase in tourist
arrivals was recorded last year. The events of September 11, 2001 (the terrorist
A securities exchange market (the ECSE) was recent established across the eight
member countries of the ECCB currency union to aid in the economic development
of the region.
2.1.1.4 Technological
payment system.
ATMs are currently in operation at all the local commercial banks. The other four
commercial banks provide online service through a network of ATMs in the region.
Tat Bank Ltd for the time being provides only local ATM service. Year after year
there is greater demand for ATM services by customers as they come to appreciate
Approximately 20% of the population have access to computers now compared with
10% in 1999.
2.1.2 Market
The market consists of the Government, other public sector bodies, corporate entities,
the UK, Canada and the US. As at June 30, 2001 the total deposits held by the five
commercial banks on the island was $990 million. Of this total the public sector
7
contributed $234 million, business firms $129 million and private individuals $435
million. While Tat Bank Ltd holds a high 69% of the public sector deposits, it only has
23 % of the private individuals and 7% of business firms (see Appendix G). Nationals
over 50 years of age returning home from abroad to invest bring in some $10 million
annually.
2.1.3 Competition
There are four other Commercial banks on the island. These are Barclays Bank PLC,
Scotia Bank, CIBC, and Caribbean Banking Corporation. Unlike Tat Bank Ltd, which
is the only indigenous bank, they are all branches of banks whose head offices are
located abroad, and only one has a second branch on the island. There is a possible
merger of Barclays Bank and CIBC to take place in 2002. The new entity will be
The non-bank financial sector including three credit unions, a savings & loans bank, a
building & loans association and a number of insurance companies, all accepting
globalisation.
The Eastern Caribbean Securities Exchange (ECSE), which was recently opened by
the ECCB across the eight member territories of the ECCB currency union, offers
Some customers prefer to do business with our competitors because Tat Bank Ltd is
Government owned and political interference or changes often affect their confidence
in the Bank.
Tat Bank Ltd may be unable to attract certain customers, particularly the business
community, because it is Government owned and there is the perception that their
Many patriotic Nationals will bank with Tat Bank Ltd because they recognise that the
profits of the Bank belong to the people and are used for the country’s development.
The internal analysis looked at our performance, our internal configuration and our
2.2.1 Performance
Tat Bank Ltd is currently the industry leader in assets, loans and deposits. Comparative
Balance Sheets for the fiscal year 2000 show that Tat Bank Ltd holds 34% of assets, 38%
of loans and 35% of deposits (see Appendix A). Up until 1999, Tat Bank Ltd held 40% of
deposits but it has since lost some of its deposits to its competitors. Despite being the
market leader for a number of years however, profitability has not come up to
expectations. At the end of the fiscal year 2000 our ROA was only 0.65% compared with
the industry average of 0.81%, as can be seen from the Comparative Statements of
9
Income (see Appendix B). The year 2001 has seen a further decline in our net income
resulting in a drop in ROA to 0.56% (see Appendix C). Our loans-to deposits at June
2001 stood at 81% (see Appendix D) within the Central Bank’s guidelines.
Tat Bank Ltd is the only commercial bank on the island with a local Board.
Most of the staff are young and have the requisite capabilities, and are re-trainable for
All members of the staff are locals and have good contact with the community at
large.
Considering that Tat Bank Ltd has over the years served mainly the public sector and
the low and middle income customers, the staff did not receive the necessary
Tat Bank Ltd is not as equipped as its international competitors with research
departments and the qualified staff to keep their institutions in line with legal,
Tat Bank Ltd is the largest bank on the island with seven local branches, a mortgage
The Bank is leading the local competition in information technology, and its core
In some areas, and in particular the Grenadines, we are the only commercial bank and
The Bank does not have branches abroad but has a strong network of regional and
2.2.4 Customers
Tat Bank Ltd has the largest customer base. However, apart from the public sector
accounts, which account for large percentages of its assets and liabilities, its customer
base consists largely of the low and middle-income groups whose needs include home
3. SWOT Analysis
The SWOT Analysis identified the opportunities, threats, strengths and weaknesses of the
bank, as follows:
3.1 Opportunities
11
The Bank is very well placed with a good and assured customer base from the level of
Many patriotic Nationals will do business with Tat Bank Ltd because they know that
the profits of the Bank belong to the people of the country and are used for the
country’s development.
the improvement and strengthening of the Bank’s international business and ATM
The increased access to computers by customers will allow the bank to reach more
The tourism industry is growing - cruise ship berth was built, new international
airport coming, hotel industry developing, new foreign investors- which should
introduce more capital into the country and should spawn employment opportunities
for locals.
The political stability and the economic growth across the eight member countries of
the ECCB Currency Union, including this country, ensures the stability of the EC$,
The establishment of the CARICOM Single Market and Economy can present
opportunities for us to better utilise any excess liquidity through diversification of our
The merger of Barclays Bank and CIBC could result in internal conflicts due to
cultural differences that may cause customers to move to Tat Bank Ltd.
12
3.2 Threats
Some customers prefer to do business with our competitors because Tat Bank Ltd is
Government owned and political interference or changes often affect their confidence
in the Bank.
Tat Bank Ltd may be unable to attract certain customers because it is Government
owned and there is the perception that their account information is open to the
The introduction of American culture and lifestyles into our society could result in
greater external spending and so have a negative impact on the local economy.
With the establishment of the CARICOM Single Market and Economy the Bank will
be faced with competition from regional banks that are better equipped and prepared
We also have to compete with banks and other financial institutions in the
globalisation.
First Caribbean International Bank (the new entity that will be formed from the
merger of Barclays Bank and CIBC) will be a stronger force to recon with, as it will
be able to reach a wider cross-section of the market due to the combining of strategic
13
capabilities and competences, human and financial resources, and contacts and
delivery networks.
The black listing of the country by the FATF could affect the Bank’s correspondent
banking relationships, as the Bank will be under greater scrutiny from the eyes of the
outside world. Any severing of such relationship will curtail the bank’s ability to
The deterioration of the banana industry, one of the country’s major industries, could
The anticipated decline of the local tourism industry as a result of the recent terrorist
There is increased competition from the non-blank financial sector, the credit unions,
the savings & loans bank, the building & loans association and the insurance
companies. These institutions are not regulated by Central bank and hence they are
not restricted in their operations. They have been paying very high rates on deposits
and have also been offering more and more of the services which were traditionally
The Eastern Caribbean Securities Exchange (ECSE), which was recently opened by
the ECCB across the eight member territories of the ECCB currency union, will
present other investment opportunities to customers and could reduce our deposits, as
3.3 Strengths
Our leading position in the industry, with respect to our market shares of assets, loans
We are the only local commercial bank with a Board of Directors, a Board that can
attract good business to the Bank as it consists of successful & respected business
people with a good mix of expertise in key industries and with strong social links in
Most of the staff are young and have the requisite capabilities, and are re-trainable for
newer systems and technology. This will therefore make the selection and training of
All the members of the staff are local, and very well known and have good contact
with all sectors of the community. They will therefore be in a good position to attract
The network of branches and other outlets affords customers service from any point
within the state as the computer mainframe is accessible from all branches.
The Bank is leading the local competition in information technology, and its core
banking system has the capacity for further advancements. Customers may prefer to
open accounts at Tat Bank Ltd because statements and account information are
produced faster that our competitors who on several occasions have to wait on their
The monopoly some branches have by being the only bank in the particular area and
the only collector of bills for various utility companies is advantageous in increasing
customer base.
It may be an advantage for Tat Bank Ltd to have the largest customer bade as
3.4 Weaknesses
The lack of exposure for our staff as a result of our poor customer mix makes it
difficult for our staff to be as experienced and equipped as most of our competitors to
Our international competitors, the other four commercial banks, are better prepared to
stay afloat in the face of strong competition with research departments and qualified
staff to keep their institutions in line with legal, technological, operational and other
changes.
The Bank is totally reliant on its correspondent banking relationships to conduct its
foreign exchange business and may find it impossible to survive against its
Although Tat Bank Ltd has the largest customer base, it has over the years had little
Develop a new chequing account called a “Golden Years” account that will attract a
higher rate of interest than the regular savings account and will allow the customer the
Target wealthy Nationals over 50 years of age returning home or resident locally,
Measuring from a scale of 1 to 6, where 6 is the best point, Tat Bank Ltd is currently
perceived to hold the second position of 4 for service offering and also the second
position at 4 for service quality (see Figure I). The Bank’s aim is to also move to the top
position for service offering and service quality through its innovative product
Figure I Figure II
1 1
Promote ATMs and telephone banking services that will provide greater convenience.
Offer innovative wealth-management products that will attract the target group.
5.1 Product
18
The bank will offer a “Golden Years” deposit account that will target wealthy nationals
over 50 years of age, returning home or resident locally, including doctors, lawyers,
managers, entrepreneurs and retired persons. The account will allow for the writing of
cheques while at the same time will attract interest at a rate higher than that paid to
regular savings. It will also allow the customer to access other banking services at
5.2 Price
Interest rate will be 1% above the rate paid to regular accounts in the market.
5.3 Place
Special counter will be made available to golden years customers for them to do their
Provide the service through our network of branches throughout the country.
perform account inquiry and pay their utility bills without visiting the bank.
managers, etc.
5.4 Promotion
19
5.5 Personnel
Recruit a sales team from members of the staff who possess the required skills for the
task.
Provide the members of the team with a formal written program of the project.
Provide each member of the team with a job description setting out clearly the job
Provide the team with the necessary tools and resources, for instance, cell phones.
Provide the team with incentives, such as travelling allowances and rewards for sales
volumes.
Develop a performance appraisal system that will allow for feedback throughout the
Once approval has been obtained, we will move swiftly to implement the plan. We will
also put controls in place to monitor and measure the results of the project to ensure the
6.1 Implementation
Table 1
Implementation Schedule
21
6.2 Control
Table 2 presents a work program to assist Management in keeping the Bank on the course
to success.
Table 2
Control Chart
7. Financial Forecast
The attached projected financial statements (Appendix E and Appendix F) have been
prepared to show the effects of the results of the plan. Prior to this plan, the Bank’s
Management had prepared financial projections for the years June 30, 2001 through June
30, 2005 based on the Bank’s five-year strategic plan. Management’s statements have
been used as the base from which I commenced to incorporate the effects of the plan.
8. Conclusion
We have considered the situation faced by Tat Bank Ltd and the objectives we would like
to achieve. We have also taken a critical look at both our external and internal
environments, and through a “SWOT” analysis have identified our strengths, weaknesses,
opportunities and threats. The way forward has been determined by identifying our
marketing strategies, and by tabling the implementation and control mechanisms aimed at
Appendix A
EC $(000)
BARCLAYS CIBC SCOTIA CBC SBL SBL %
ASSETS
Cash resources 30,072 40,098 29,277 57,232 67,362 30%
Securities 4,400 27,747 500 89,903 33,792 22%
Loans 87,801 89,782 111,974 103,067 243,436 38%
Customers' liability under acceptances 3,339 1,619 2,209 31%
Fixed Assets 7,905 4,395 1,387 4,810 20,488 53%
Other Assets 3,308 795 1,140 2,367 1,273 14%
136,825 162,817 144,278 258,998 368,560 34%
KEY RATIOS
Liquid assets 21.98% 24.63% 20.29% 22.10% 18.28%
Loans to deposits 70.25% 60.47% 80.67% 56.34% 75.87%
24
Appendix B
KEY RATIOS
Net interest margin 5.00% 3.84% 5.13% 3.06% 3.91%
Return on assets 1.09% 0.38% 1.41% 0.51% 0.65%
Return on equity 8.52%
25
Appendix C
KEY RATIOS
Net interest margin 3.83% 3.91% 3.27% 3.45% 2.78%
Return on assets 0.56% 0.65% 0.96% 0.54% 0.34%
Return on equity 7.56% 8.52% 14.27% 9.61% 6.58%
26
Appendix D
ASSETS
Cash resources 49,631 67,362 113,413 64,562 78,257
Securities 36,792 33,792 26,868 22,532 19,507
Loans 276,389 243,436 223,767 205,316 191,957
Customers' liability under acceptances 7,610 2,209
Fixed Assets 20,202 20,488 20,810 15,068 15,549
Other Assets 4,449 1,273 9,080 5,613 7,307
395,073 368,560 393,938 313,091 312,577
KEY RATIOS
Liquid assets 12.56% 18.28% 28.79% 20.62% 25.04%
Loans to deposits 81.45% 75.87% 63.44% 72.16% 67.54%
27
Appendix E
ASSETS
Cash resources 49,631 61,043 71,140 82,538
Securities 36,792 40,092 42,092 43,092
Loans 276,389 296,432 328,475 372,523
Customers' liability under acceptances 7,610
Fixed Assets 20,202 21,113 20,794 19,840
Other Assets 4,449 5,635 5,731 5,857
395,073 424,315 468,232 523,850
KEY RATIOS
Liquid assets 12.56% 14.39% 15.19% 15.76%
Loans to deposits 81.45% 80.00% 80.49% 80.74%
28
Appendix F
KEY RATIOS
Net interest margin 3.83% 3.68% 3.66% 3.62%
Return on assets 0.56% 0.62% 0.75% 0.95%
Return on equity 7.56% 7.84% 9.75% 13.00%
29
Appendix G
30