International Journal of Pharmaceutics
International Journal of Pharmaceutics
International Journal of Pharmaceutics
a r t i c l e i n f o a b s t r a c t
Article history: The most appropriate method to preserve Bufferin 81-mg tablets dispensed for unit-dose packaging in
Received 24 March 2010 the hospital pharmacy was examined. The surface color change of the tablets was investigated over time
Received in revised form 29 May 2010 by spectrophotometry, and the decomposition rate of aspirin was measured by high-performance liquid
Accepted 18 June 2010
chromatography (HPLC). To overcome these, it was found that we can effectively prevent color changes
Available online 25 June 2010
and preserve the quality by maintaining the humidity as 55% or less, storage with drying agent in a plastic
or aluminum pack. It was revealed that the color changes became greater and the decomposition rate
Keywords:
became higher as time passed. Color changes markedly affect the patients’ compliance, and are found
Aspirin tablet
Color change
to be a very important factor. It was considered that the clarity of the correlation between the color
Decomposition rate change and decomposition rate may contribute to a decrease in the number of tablets discarded before
Discard the expiration date.
Storage method © 2010 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
0378-5173/$ – see front matter © 2010 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
doi:10.1016/j.ijpharm.2010.06.031
106 N. Yamazaki et al. / International Journal of Pharmaceutics 396 (2010) 105–110
Fig. 1. Experiment [I]: the aspirin decomposition rate in tablets with each package form stored in a thermohygrostat (temperature: 27 ◦ C, humidity: 65%): at the start of
measurement, the decomposition rate was 1.3%.
Fig. 2. Experiment [II]: the aspirin decomposition rate in tablets with each package form stored in a thermohygrostat (temperature: 27 ◦ C, humidity: 55%): at the start of
measurement, the decomposition rate was 1.3%.
3.2.2. Experiment [II] established by the National Bureau of Standards (NBS unit), and
As it is described that the rate of aspirin decomposition on pul- decomposition rate is shown in Fig. 3. The color difference and
verization decreases at a humidity of 56% or less, in the IF of Bufferin decomposition rate serially increased. According to the NBS cri-
81-mg tablets, this experiment was conducted, while maintaining teria, the color of tablets was evaluated as “noticeably different”
the thermohygrostat temperature and humidity at 27 ◦ C and 55%, after 2 weeks and “appreciable different” after 4, 8, and 12 weeks.
respectively. For storage, 4 package forms ((B), (D), (E), and (G)) The decomposition rate reached 3% more than 2 weeks after the
were employed. The serial changes in the decomposition rate for start of the experiment; the tablets did not meet the standards.
each package form in comparison with that for the (B) package
form obtained at a temperature and humidity of 27 ◦ C and 65%,
4. Discussion
respectively, in Experiment I are shown in Fig. 2.
Concerning the (B) package form, the results were compared
In clinical practice, Bayaspirin® 100-mg (Bayer Schering Pharma
between 2 different humidity conditions: 65 and 55%. At a humidity
Co., Ltd. 2008), which exhibit the same effects as Bufferin 81-
of 65%, the decomposition rate was 3.8% 4 weeks after unit-dose
mg tablets, are commercially available. These are enteric-coated
packaging, as described above. However, it was 2.4% at a humidity
tablets, and non-sealed tablets are also commercially available
of 55%. Concerning the (D) package form, the decomposition rate
as a preparation that can be utilized for unit-dose packaging.
after 8 weeks was 4.7% at a humidity of 65%, whereas it was 3% at
When packaging tablets by unit-dose, the stability may be main-
a humidity of 55%. Concerning the (E) and (G) package forms, the
tained by selecting coated tablets, because their hygroscopic
decomposition rates after 12 weeks were approximately 3% or less.
property is lower. However, actually, Bufferin 81-mg tablets, which
These results confirmed that the aspirin decomposition rate at a
show a marked hygroscopic property, are separately packaged by
humidity of 55% was lower than at a humidity of 65% regardless of
unit-dose in some hospitals, as indicated by the results of this
the presence or absence of pulverization.
questionnaire survey. This may be because prescribing physicians
are accustomed to Bufferin 81-mg tablets, with a 40-year history
3.2.3. Color changes from 1963, and because even elderly persons with reduced vision
The changes in the appearance/color of unit-dose-packaged can distinguish light orange tablets. However, based on the results
Bufferin 81-mg tablets at the start of the experiment and after a spe- of this questionnaire survey, there are limitations: Bufferin 81-
cific period (2, 4, 8, and 12 weeks) of storage in a thermohygrostat mg tablets are dispensed for unit-dose packaging, although it is
(temperature: 27 ◦ C, humidity: 65%) are shown in Photo 2. described that this product should be handed to patients with its
The color of tablets immediately after being taken out of the aluminum-sheet package remaining intact, in the package inserts
aluminum sheet (at the start of the experiment) was light orange. of this agent; and color changes related to unit-dose packaging
The white color of the dialuminate-containing layer was slightly require discarding before administration in some cases. To over-
more marked. At this point, the decomposition rate was 1.3%. After come these limitations, an optimal storage method at the mean
2 weeks, the circumference became slightly dark orange, show- temperature/humidity in hospital pharmacies should be reviewed,
ing a change in the appearance. However, the decomposition rate and patients should be instructed on storage at home so that the
was 2.8%. After 4 weeks, the sides and circumference became dark conditions may be maintained.
orange, and the decomposition rate was 3.8%; the tablets did not In this study, the rate of aspirin decomposition for each
meet the standards. After 8 weeks, a portion of the center became packaging form was measured under Experiment I (mean tempera-
dark orange in addition to the sides and circumference, with a ture/humidity in hospital pharmacies: 27 ◦ C and 65%, respectively)
decomposition rate of 5.5%. In addition, after 12 weeks, dark orange and Experiment II (27 ◦ C and 55%, respectively, in accordance with
spots extending at the center were observed, and the corner was a humidity of 56% or less at which the rate of aspirin decompo-
affected in some tablets. The decomposition rate was 7.1%. sition decreases) conditions. The results of Experiment II showed
The relationship among the color difference (E*ab) mea- that the aspirin decomposition rate in Bufferin 81-mg tablets was
sured using a spectrophotometer, criteria for color differences inhibited when the humidity on storage was established as 55%
N. Yamazaki et al. / International Journal of Pharmaceutics 396 (2010) 105–110 109
Fig. 3. The relationship among the color difference (E*ab) measured using a spectrophotometer, criteria for color differences established by the National Bureau of Standards
(NBS unit), and aspirin decomposition rate.
or less. Briefly, aspirin decomposition depends on humidity; an therefore, it should be positively introduced, although it is expen-
environmental humidity maintained at 55% or less during the stor- sive.
age period may be useful for inhibiting decomposition. Based on Concerning color changes, this experiment confirmed that both
these results, it is important to maintain the humidity in hospital the color difference (E*ab) on the tablet surface and aspirin
pharmacies at 55% or less. However, the mean hospital pharmacy decomposition rate serially increased. A spectrophotometer may
temperature and humidity in June were reported to be 27 ◦ C and not be installed in clinical practice; color differences may be visually
65% (Japanese Society of Hospital Pharmacists, 2005), respectively, assessed.
by the Japanese Society of Hospital Pharmacists. During specific Based on the results of this questionnaire survey, 41.7% of the
hours or in some areas, the mean humidity was 70% or more. pharmacists reported that tablets with “slight changes ” in color
Considering this, an optimal storage method under the Experi- were discarded (Photograph 1). The slight changes were evalu-
ment I conditions was reviewed. After Bufferin 81-mg tablets were ated as color differences ranging from 0.5 to 1.5 according to the
taken out of the aluminum sheet, the rate of aspirin decompo- NBS criteria. As shown in Fig. 3, the aspirin decomposition rate
sition rapidly increased, as shown in Fig. 1. In addition, there was 2% or less, meeting the standards. With this color, the phar-
were no marked differences in the decomposition rate among sev- macists discarded tablets, possibly because they considered that
eral storage methods: unit-dose-packaged tablets, those stored in even slight color changes showed an elevated aspirin decomposi-
a plastic pack, and those stored in a can. Briefly, the 0.04-mm tion rate beyond the standards, or because they paid attention to
thick plastic pack employed in this study did not exhibit any anti- the tablet’s color at the time of drug delivery to patients to prevent
hygroscopic effects even when sealed with a zipper, and the aspirin the reduction of compliance related to post-delivery color changes,
decomposition rate was similar to that in unit-dose-packaged or considering the humidity level on storage at home.
uncovered tablets. However, as shown in Fig. 1, the decomposition A review of the relationship between color changes and the
rate was markedly inhibited when a drying agent was placed in the decomposition rate obtained in this experiment may contribute
plastic pack. When employing an aluminum pack, it was further to a decrease in the number of tablets discarded before the
inhibited. The introduction of these storage methods in each hos- expiration date (Fig. 3). Briefly, when color differences are trace
pital/drugstore may make it possible to maintain the stability of or slight, the decomposition rate may be 3% or less, meeting
this preparation over a longer period even if Bufferin 81-mg tablets the standards. When they are appreciable, it may exceed 3%.
are taken out of their sealed packaging. However, when administering aspirin for the secondary pre-
In this experiment, silica gel and raw lime were used as vention of myocardial infarction, the dose ranges from 50 to
drying agents. The volume of these drying agents required to 162 mg (Japanese Circulation Society, 2006); its anti-platelet
maintain their effects for 12 weeks was calculated using a for- actions may not be markedly reduced even if the decomposi-
mula (JIS Z0301) regarding anti-hygroscopic packaging methods. tion rate exceeds 3%. However, to prevent Bufferin 81-mg tablets’
Products immediately after arrival from the manufacturers were deviation from the standards and maintain patient compliance,
employed. However, in clinical practice, storage conditions may tablets should be dispensed for unit-dose packaging immedi-
vary: an insufficient volume of drying agents, and the use of dry- ately before administration. When preparing preliminary unit-dose
ing agents absorbing moisture to some degree. In such cases, packages for specific reasons, storage methods are important.
the rate of aspirin decomposition may be higher than in this Quality control with the above storage methods at an optimal
experiment. Silica gel must be dried using a microwave oven, humidity and guidance regarding appropriate storage at home
and used at a sufficient volume. Furthermore, an aluminum pack after drug delivery may prevent color changes, maintaining com-
inhibits the decomposition rate in the absence of drying agents; pliance.
110 N. Yamazaki et al. / International Journal of Pharmaceutics 396 (2010) 105–110
These results may provide information useful for health care Japanese Circulation Society, 2006. Guidelines for Secondary Prevention of Myocar-
professionals and patients, improving future medicinal manage- dial Infarction, pp. 12–16 http://www.netjcs.or.jp/.
Japanese Society of Hospital Pharmacists, 2005. Stability Date in Uncovered Tablets
ment. and Capsules. Iyaku (Medicine and Drug) Joumal Co., Ltd, ISBN 475322130X.
Lion Co., Ltd., 2003. Interview Form “Bufferin® 81-mg Tablets”.
Appendix A. Supplementary data Mann, C.C., Plummer, M.L., 1994. The Aspirin Wars: Money, Medicine, and 100 Years
of Rampant Competition. Diamond. Co, ISBN 4478860092.
Owaki, N., Mase, S., Shibata, Y., Ushida, M., Masuda, S., Shibata, Y., Kammati, A.,
Supplementary data associated with this article can be found, in Ogawa, K., Kumagai, M., Yokota, M., Hayakawa, T., 2004. A multi-center study
the online version, at doi:10.1016/j.ijpharm.2010.06.031. on convenience of removing tablets and capsules from heat-sealed packages.
Jpn. J. Pharm. Health Care Sci. 30, 312–320.
Yamazaki, A., Osawa, K., Kuramoto, H., Honda, K., Tajima, M., Yokoyama, H., Yoshi-
References nari, J., Hiranuka, I., Baba, T., Nonaka, A., Ishibashi, Y., Hino, F., Yamazaki, N.,
Shimokawa, K., Ishii, F., 2008. Activity report about the North Tama North-
Bayer Schering Pharma. Co., Ltd., 2008. Ethical Drug Package Insert Medical-Area Medical/Pharmaceutical Study Meeting. In: The128th Annual
“Bayaspirin® 100mg”. Meeting of the Pharmaceutical Society of Japan, vol. 2, p. 218.
Hirasawa, M., 2001. Super Drug Aspirin: A Way to the Super Drug. Heibonsha Limited
Publishers, ISBN 458285107.