Overview of Wireless Charging Technologies For Electric Vehicles
Overview of Wireless Charging Technologies For Electric Vehicles
Overview of Wireless Charging Technologies For Electric Vehicles
net/publication/279529918
CITATIONS READS
41 7,382
4 authors, including:
Liu Chunhua
City University of Hong Kong
248 PUBLICATIONS 5,683 CITATIONS
SEE PROFILE
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
All content following this page was uploaded by Liu Chunhua on 24 October 2015.
Abstract
This paper gives an overview of current wireless charging technologies on electric vehicles (EVs) charging. In
general, the near-field technologies are preferred over far-field ones. Inductive power transfer and strongly cou-
pled magnetic resonance technologies are chosen for detailed review. Furthermore, special issues related to EV
applications are also discussed, namely efficient power supply, misalignment tolerance, multiple pick-up control,
simultaneous power and data transmission and shielding methods.
1679
C. Qiu et al.: Overview of Wireless Charging Technologies for Electric Vehicles
1680
Journal of Asian Electric Vehicles, Volume 12, Number 1, June 2014
ω02M2
RL, max power = R2 + (5)
R1
2
ω02M2R2
RL, max efficiency = R2 + (6)
R1
In equations (3) and (4), the transferred power and Fig. 4 Schematic of strongly coupled magnetic reso-
efficiency are functions of load and mutual induct- nance system
ances. For EV application, the load is defined by the
battery’s depth-of-discharge and the charging speed, resonators. With the same coupling coefficient, more
and the mutual inductance is directly related to the energy could be transferred to the load [Cannon et al.,
relative position between on-board pickup coil and 2009]. Additionally, the lumped resonant capacitors
fixed transmitting coil. The first problem is both the are replaced by coil parasitic capacitance (C2 and C3)
load and mutual inductance are ever changing because which results an even higher Q-factor. The system
EVs cannot be always perfectly parked or they are operating frequency is normally fixed and equal to the
moving during power transfer. Another problem is that self-resonant frequency of the coil. This frequency is
for a certain conditions, the load power and efficiency defined by geometric layout of the coils and can be up
cannot achieve maximum point at the same time, as to several megahertz.
shown by equations (5) and (6). Therefore, the chal- For practical EV applications, lumped compensation
lenge for IPT wireless charging is the implementation capacitors are still preferred in order to simplify the
of suitable control strategies, such as load matching coil construction and lower the operating frequency to
and variable frequency control to regulate the load kilohertz range.
power while maintaining high transmission efficiency.
2.3 Current wireless EV charging projects
2.2 Strongly coupled magnetic resonance Integrating wireless charging technologies with EV
The strongly coupled magnetic resonance technolo- applications are being demonstrated in both industrial
gies are characterized by special multiple coils and and academic fields. Major achievements have been
loops combination arrangement, as shown in Figure 4. made in the last two decades, and are summarized in
By using two loops and two coils, the internal resist- Table 1. The University of Auckland made an early
ance of voltage source RS and the load resistance RL exploration on high power IPT charging. Although
are excluded from the RLC resonators, which results the air gap was limited to several centimeters the
a much higher Q-factor than conventional two coils power transfer reached tens of kilowatts [Covic and
Institute / corporation Year of Installation Vehicle Type Power Air Gap Efficiency
1997 5 Golf buses 20 kW 50 mm 90-91 %
The University of Auckland 2002-2003 8-23 mini buses 60 kW 30 mm –
2010 Private vehicles 3 kW 180 mm 85 %
92 %
2010 – 4.2 kW 254 mm
(coil-to-coil)
Oak Ridge National Labo- 93 %
2012 – 7.7 kW 200 mm
ratory (ORNL) (coil-to-coil)
91 %
2012 GEM EV 2 kW 75 mm
(coil-to-coil)
Golf Bus 3 kW 10 mm 80 %
Korea Advanced Institute 2009 Bus 6 kW 170 mm 72 %
of Science and Technology SUV 17 kW 170 mm 71 %
(KAIST) 2010 Tram 62 kW 130 mm 74 %
2012 Bus 100 kW 200 mm 75 %
MIT WiTricity 2010 Private vehicles 3.3 kW 180 mm 90 %
1681
C. Qiu et al.: Overview of Wireless Charging Technologies for Electric Vehicles
Boys, 2010]. Their recent research has been aiming half-bridge or full-bridge topologies, the VA rating of
at extending vertical distance and adapting horizontal power switches can be lower than Class E amplifier.
offsets, such as the single-sided flux magnetic cou- However, the efficiency of the Class D amplifier is
pler (DD-DDQ) system [Budhia et al., 2013]. ORNL related to the reflected loaded Q. So there may be a
focused on the high efficiency lumped coil design notable drop when the transmission distance increases
and successfully implemented it into a 72 V lead- [Garnica et al., 2013].
acid battery powered EV [Miller, 2012]. KAIST has
made great achievement on dynamic wireless charg- 4. MISALLIGNMENT TOLERANCE
ing in the last few years, which is called on-line elec- 4.1 Optimal ferrite core structure design
tric vehicles (OLEV) [Jung et al., 2013]. The OLEV For on-road wireless charged EVs, the track-shaped
project was launched in 2009. In the same year, three primary coil structure is usually adopted. This created
generations of prototypes were reported with power constrains on lateral movement of the EV. The basic
ranges from 3 to 17 kW [Lee et al., 2010]. The first concept in optimal ferrite core design is straightfor-
demonstration, a 2.2 km tram loop, was installed in ward: to maximize the effective magnetic flux through
2010. This 62 kW wireless powered tram equipped pickup coil and minimize the leakage flux. A pair of
with a battery module of 40 % smaller than normal common E-shape ferrite cores are shown in Figure
battery-powered trams. In 2012, an OLEV bus system 6. For the air gap shown, increasing the pole width is
was demonstrated which was capable to transfer 100 an effective way to decrease the air reluctances, and
kW (5 sets of 20 kW pick-up coils) through a 20cm therefore increase useful effective flux. On the con-
air gap with average efficiency of 75 %. [Jim et al., trary, increasing distance between poles will relief the
2013]. KAIST is ready to apply its OLEV technology magnetic field distortion when misalignment occurs,
on a high-speed high-power railway (over 300 km/h, giving a better tolerance of lateral offset. But it will
180 kW) at the end of 2013 [Ahn et al., 2013]. MIT also increasing leakage flux within poles [Shin et al.,
(WiTricity) employed the strongly coupled magnetic 2014]. Therefore, optimal consideration should be
resonance technology and implemented a commercially taken when choosing the pole width.
available 3.3 kW charging kit for market EV models.
1682
Journal of Asian Electric Vehicles, Volume 12, Number 1, June 2014
structure, enabling capture of magnetic flux from both The key concept of decoupling control is to short-
horizontal and vertical directions. circuit the light loaded pick-ups. This is equivalent to
removing unwanted pick-ups from primary transmitter
4.3 Range adaption control of strongly coupled mag- and adding a small amount of reactive power in the
netic resonance primary supply. For a parallel compensated topology,
For the strongly coupled magnetic resonance, the a boost converter is added before the load, and simi-
transmission efficiency drops quickly when distance larly, a buck converter is added for the series compen-
or orientation between coupled resonators deviates sated topology, as shown in Figure 7 [Keeling et al.,
from its normal position. For wireless EVs charging, 2010].
the relative position between resonators could hardly However, this method assumes that all pick-ups are
be stable. So, adaptive control is essential [Sample et operating at the tuned frequency and the mutual in-
al., 2011]. ductance between every primary and secondary coil
The highest possible efficiency is occurred when keeps constant. This might be a reasonable assumption
source/load impedance matches with coil impedances. for monorail system. But for other configuration (e.g.
The impedance adjusting can be realized by real-time lumped pad system), more effective method should be
tuning the operating frequency, or by keeping a fixed explored since mutual inductance changes with pad
operating frequency but using impedance match- positions.
ing networks between coils and source, and between
coils and load. Either frequency tuning or impedance 6. CONCURRENT DATA TRANSMISSION
matching is effective in the over-coupled regime. Oth- Normally, when primary side control is adopted, the
erwise, the mutual inductance is too weak to support information of secondary side conditions should be
high efficient transmission [Sample et al., 2013]. sent back to the primary side, using wireless commu-
nication. However this will increase the overall sys-
5. MULTIPLE PICK-UP CONTROL tem cost. Recent studies reveals that concurrent data
For on-road wireless EV charging, there is a situation transmission with power will offer better solutions.
when more than one vehicle connects onto the same Figure 8 shows the basic principle of capacitive ampli-
power transmitter. Each secondary coil has magnetic tude modulation. The modulation capacitors Cm1 and
coupling with the primary coil but demands for in-
dependent power control. The system will become
unstable when too many light loaded secondary pick-
ups are connected. Therefore, decoupling control is
proposed to solve this problem and meanwhile offers
a possible way to regulate secondary power [Covic
and Boys, 2013].
(a)
(a)
(b) (b)
Fig. 7 Decoupling regulator. (a) parallel compensated Fig. 8 Capacitive amplitude modulation. (a) schemat-
secondary, (b) series compensated secondary ics, (b) amplitude modulation
1683
C. Qiu et al.: Overview of Wireless Charging Technologies for Electric Vehicles
Cm2 are periodically added to the load, changing the Hong Kong Special Administrative Region, China.
network impedance characteristics. This change will
result in the change of primary voltage. The change References
of primary voltage is then demodulated and converted Ahn, S., N. P. Suh, and D. H. Cho, Charging up the
to corresponding data. The format of the data package road, IEEE Spectrum, Vol. 50, No. 4, 48-54, 2013.
can be found in wireless power transfer standard Qi Budhia, M., J. T. Boys, G. A. Covic, and C. Huang,
[Johns, 2011]. Development of a single-sided flux magnetic cou-
pler for electric vehicle IPT charging systems,
7. EMI SHIELDING AND SAFETY ISSUES IEEE Transactions on Industrial Electronics, Vol.
The alternating current through the coupled coils 60, No. 1, 318-328, 2013.
generate unwanted electromagnetic fields. As the un- Cannon, B. L., J. F. Hoburg, D. D. Stancil, and S. C.
wanted EMI brings up safety issues, the International Goldstein, Magnetic resonant coupling as a poten-
Commission on Non-Ionizing Radiation Protection tial means for wireless power transfer to multiple
(ICNIRP) suggests that the acceptable human expo- small receivers, IEEE Transactions on Power Elec-
sure to electromagnetic field should be less than 6.25 tronics, Vol. 24, No. 7, 2009.
µT at frequency 0.8-150 kHz [ICNIRP, 1998]. Covic, G. A., and J. T. Boys, Inductive power transfer
Coreless hollow winding coils have better misalign- (IPT) powering our future, Power Electron. Re-
ment tolerant performance but with severe EMI into search Group, Univ. Auckland, New Zealand, Tech.
the space [Qiu et al., 2014]. By using ferrite material Rep., 2010. [Online]. Available: http://ceme.ece.
as flux guide, the unwanted leakage flux is contained, illinois.eduiseminars/CEME910Covic.pdf.
resulting less EMI. Using metallic plate as shielding Covic, G. A., and J. T. Boys, Inductive power trans-
between human and coils is a common method to con- fer, Proceeding of the IEEE, Vol. 101, 1276-1289,
trol the EMI level inside an EV. It is worth noting that 2013.
directly placing metal object near coils will decrease Garnica, J., R. A. Chinga, and J. Lin, Wireless power
the self and mutual inductances, thus hinder the power transmission from far field to near field, Proceeding
transfer [Geselowitz et al., 1992]. When ferrite materi- of the IEEE, Vol. 101, 1321-1331, 2013.
als are placed between the coil and metallic shielding, Geselowitz, D. B., Q. Hoang, and R. P. Gaumond, The
this effect can be minimized. effect of metal on a transcutaneous energy trans-
Using reactive conducting coils to create reverse mission system, IEEE Transactions on Biomedical
EMI is proved to be anther effective counter-measure Engineering, Vol. 39, No. 9, 928-934, 1992.
[Kim et al., 2013]. In a 5 x 20 kW wireless charging ICNIRP Guidelines, Guidelines for limiting exposure
prototype, ten parallel compensated reactive coils are to time-varying electric, magnetic, and electromag-
placed alongside with the receiving coils. Each reso- netic fields (up to 300GHz), Health Physics, Vol.
nating coil is parallel compensated with controlled 74, No. 4, 494-522, 1998.
capacitor array. The EMI levels measured at strategic Jaffe, P., and J. McSpadden, Energy conversion and
points are feed to the controller. By choosing a suit- transmission modules for space solar power, Pro-
able resonating capacitance, the EMI can be mini- ceeding of the IEEE, Vol. 101, 1424-1437, 2013.
mized. Johns, B., An introduction to the Wireless Power
Consortium standard and TI’s compliant solutions,
CONCLUSION Analog Application Journal, 10-12, 2011.
In this paper, various WPT technologies are intro- Karalis, A., J. D. Joannopoulos, and M. Soljacic, Ef-
duced and compared in the perspective of EV wireless ficient wireless non-radiative mid-range energy
charging applications. The principles of inductive transfer, Annals of Physics, Vol. 323, No. 1, 34-48,
power transfer and strongly coupled magnetic reso- 2008.
nance are discussed, focusing on maximum power Keeling, N. A., G. A. Covic, and J. T. Boys, A unity
transfer and maximum efficiency. A summary has power factor IPT pick-up for high power applica-
been made on current wireless EV charging achieve- tions, IEEE Transactions on Industrial Electronics,
ments. Other core issues in EV wireless charging are Vol. 57, No. 2, 744-751, 2010.
specially chosen and discussed. Latest solutions for Kim, J., J. Kim, S. Kong, H. Kim, I. S. Suh, N. P. Suh,
every issue is being discussed. D. H. Cho, J. Kim, and S. Ahn, Coil design and
shielding methods for a magnetic resonant wireless
Acknowledgements power transfer system, Proceeding of the IEEE,
This work was supported by a grant (Project No. Vol. 101, 1332-1342, 2013.
201109176034) from HKU Small Project Funding, Kissin, M. L. G., C. Y. Huang, G. A. Covic, and J. T.
1684
Journal of Asian Electric Vehicles, Volume 12, Number 1, June 2014
Boys, Detection of the tuned point of a fixed-fre- electric vehicles, IEEE Transactions on Industrial
quency LCL resonant power supply, IEEE Transac- Electronics, Vol. 61, No. 3, 1179-1192, 2014.
tions on Power Electronics, Vol. 24, No. 4, 2009. Shinohara, N., Beam control technologies with a high-
Ko, Y. D., and Y. J. Jang, The optimal system design efficiency phased array for microwave power trans-
of the online electric vehicle utilizing wireless mission in Japan, Proceeding of the IEEE, Vol. 101,
power transmission technology, IEEE Transactions 1448-1463, 2013.
on Intelligent Transportation Systems, Vol. 14, No. Suzuki, S., M. Ishihara, and Y. Kobayashi, The im-
3, 1255-1265, 2013. provement of the noninvasive power-supply system
Kurs, A., A. Karalis, R. Moffatt, J. D. Joannopoulos, using magnetic coupling for medical implants,
P. Fisher, and M. Soljacic, Wireless power transfer IEEE Transactions on Magnetics, Vol. 47, No. 10,
via strongly coupled magnetic resonances, Science, 2811-2814, 2011.
Vol. 317, No. 5834, 83-86, 2007. Theodoridis, M. P., Effective capacitive power trans-
Lee, S., J. Huh, C. Park, N. S. Choi, G. H. Cho, and fer, IEEE Transactions on Power Electronics, Vol.
C. T. Rim, On-line electric vehicle using inductive 27, No. 12, 4906-4913, 2012.
power transfer system, in IEEE Energy Conver- Wang, C. S., O. H. Stielau, and G. A. Covic, Design
sion Congress and Exposition ECCE, Atlanta, GA, considerations for a contactless electric vehicle bat-
2010, 1598-1601. tery charger, IEEE Transactions on Industrial Elec-
Liu, C., Fundamental study on capacitively coupled tronics, Vol. 52, No. 5, 1308-1314, 2005.
contactless power transfer technology, Ph.D. dis- Wang, C. S., G. A. Covic, and O. S. Stielau, Investi-
sertation, Department of Electrical and Computer gating an LCL load resonant inverter for inductive
Engineering, The University of Auckland, 2011. power transfer applications, IEEE Transactions on
Liu, C., K. T. Chau, C. Qiu, and F. Lin, Investigation Power Electronics, Vol. 19, No. 4, 2004.
of energy harvesting for magnetic sensor arrays on Zhang, Z., K. T. Chau, C. Liu, C. Qiu, and F. Lin, An
Mars by wireless power transmission, Journal of efficient wireless power transfer system with secu-
Applied Physics, Vol. 115, 17E702: 1-3, 2014. rity considerations for electric vehicle applications,
Liu, C., K. T. Chau, D. Wu, and S. Gao, Opportunities Journal of Applied Physics, Vol. 115, 17A328: 1-3,
and challenges of vehicle-to-home, vehicle-to-ve- 2014.
hicle and vehicle-to-grid technologies, Proceeding
of the IEEE, Invited Paper, Vol. 101, No. 11, 2409- (Received May 24, 2014; accepted June 4, 2014)
2427, 2013.
Miller, J. M., Wireless plug-in electric vehicle (PEV)
charging, Oak Ridge National Laboratory, Techni-
cal Report, 2012. [Online]. Available: http://www1.
eere.energy.gov/vehiclesandfuels/pdfs/merit_
review_2012/veh_sys_sim/vss061_miller_2012_
o.pdf.
Qiu, C., K. T. Chau, C. Liu, W. Li, and F. Lin, Quan-
titative comparison of dynamic flux distribution
of magnetic couplers for roadway electric vehicle
wireless charging system, Journal of Applied Phys-
ics, Vol. 115, 17A334, 2014.
Sample, A. P., B. H. Waters, S. T. Wisdom, and J. R.
Smith, Enabling seamless wireless power delivery
in dynamic environments, Proceeding of the IEEE,
Vol. 101, 1343-1358, 2013.
Sample, A. P., D. A. Meyer, and J. R. Smith, Analy-
sis, experimental results, and range adaptation of
magnetically coupled resonators for wireless power
transfer, IEEE Transactions on Industrial Electron-
ics, Vol. 58, No. 2, 544-554, 2011.
Shin, J., S. Shin, Y. Kim, S. Ahn, S. Lee, G. Jung, S.
Joen, and D. Cho, Design and implementation of
shaped magnetic-resonance-based wireless power
transfer system for roadway-powered moving
1685