14 Chapter-6 Design Aspects
14 Chapter-6 Design Aspects
14 Chapter-6 Design Aspects
Design Aspects
6.1 General
291
m and corresponding gross storage capacity 206.03 MCM. The
length of concrete face rock fill portion of the dam is 663.32 m and
the length of concrete non-overflow section and spill way is 145.00
m. The dam axis is located at Latitude 20°22'25" N and Longitude
73°25'51" E.
292
viii) A 1170.00 m long composite embankment (concrete face rock fill)
cum concrete dam across river Khapri (a tributary of Ambica river)
near village Dabdar with FRL 169.00 m and corresponding gross
storage capacity 222.38 MCM. The length of concrete face rock fill
portion of the dam is 1035.00 m and the length of concrete non
overflow section and spill way is 135.00 m. The dam axis is located at
Latitude 20°48'58" N and Longitude 73°32'05" E.
ix) A power house of 3.2 MW installed capacity at the toe of Dabdar dam
with 2 units each of 1.60 MW.
xiii) A tunnel of about 12.70 km long with 3.00 m diameter (D shape) and
bed slope of 1:875 connecting Jheri reservoir with Paikhed reservoir.
xvi) A 369.043 km long link canal off-taking from Paikhed barrage at FSL
142.800 m.
xvii) A 100 m long tunnel No.1 at RD 14.650 to 14.750 km; A 350 m long
tunnel No.2 at RD 24.000 to 24.350 km; A 200 m long tunnel No.3 at
293
RD 32.350 to 32.550 km; A 50 m long tunnel No.4 at RD 37.750 to
37.800 km; and A 450 m long tunnel No.5 at RD 51.500 to 51.950
km;
xviii) A 2.859 km feeder Pipe line connecting main canal with Chasmandva
barrage.
xix) A 14.342 km feeder Pipe line inters connecting Chikkar and Dabdar
reservoirs.
xx) A 12.258 km feeder Pipe line connecting main canal with Dabdar
dam.
xxi) A 7.616 km feeder Pipe line connecting main canal with Kelwan dam.
294
age. The flows comprise vesicular and amygdaloidal basalts with vesicles
filled by zeolite, calcite and green-earth. (Geological mapping in parts of
Nasik district, Maharashtra; Unpublished Progress Report GSI F.S. 1974-75,
Iyyer,R.K.). In general the basalts are without olivine, consisting of basic
glass. Where coarsely crystalline they show appreciable quantity of olivine.
Porphyry are formed by Phenocrysts of feldspar (Manual of Geology of
India and Burma, Vol. III, Pacoe, E.H. 1973). The flows commonly contain
ash beds. These ash beds resemble the flows in their macroscopic
appearance. Another feature of the Traps is the alteration of its basal portion
into green earth. Frequently it is found not only in between the flows but
also in vesicles. Another common occurring rock type is the red-bole,
characterized by its conspicuous colour. The red-bole is clay formed by
decomposition of the crust of lower flow, something a kin to present day
laterisation of the traps. The area has been subjected to faulting and
shearing. Several instances of block faulting with small throws are common.
These are related to the Sone-Narmada-Rift system and the Sabarmati –
west coast faulting.
295
geological interpretation has been done for all the seven dam sites, the rest
of the work including field checks of the photo-interpretation has been done
for only 5 dam sites, viz. Jheri, Chasmandva, Chikkar, Dabdar and Kelwan.
The work carried out at each of the 5 dam sites at Feasibility Report stage of
the Link Project is given in Table- 6.1 below.
Table – 6.1
Details of Geological Investigations at Various Dam
S. Work done Jheri Chasma Chikkar Dabdar KelwanTotal
ndva
No.
2 Geophysical
Traverses (in
line kms/ shots/
soundings taken)
a) Seismic:
4 16 8 8 8 44
22 62 46 44 12 186
22 51 42 28 36 179
3 Eng. Geology
b) Bore Hole 4 - 1 4 - 9
logging (nos and
296
S. Work done Jheri Chasma Chikkar Dabdar KelwanTotal
ndva
No.
c) Trial pit - 11 8 7 10 36
logging (nos and
aggregate depth 12.90 11.47 20.8 12.53 57.70
in ‘m’)
6.1.1.2 Seismicity
297
Table – 6.2
Seismic Coefficients Adopted for Dams
Dam Height of Dam Natural Period Horizontal Vertical Seismic
(m) (s) Seismic Coefficient (αv), g
Coefficient
(αh), g
Embankment
299
plane or other geological features encountered in the foundation shall be
suitably treated in consultation with the Geologist.
Curtain Grouting under spillway at u/s may be carried out as per IS 6066
in consultation with the Geologist. The spacing, depth and inclination of
grout holes may be modified depending upon the State of foundation rock
after excavation and based on the results of grout acceptance tests done in
consultation with the Geologist.
6.1.1 Alternative Studies Carried Out for Selection of Site and Type
Of Structure
301
mostly as contour canals. The main link canal has to cross the ridges
between various basins and sub-basins wherein deep cuts are involved and
also to cross many rivers and streams requiring construction of cross
drainage works. Five tunnels of varying length have been proposed to avoid
circuitous route, CD works and deep cutting.
Table – 6.3
PMF and 50 /100 Year Return Period Diversion Floods
S.No. Dam PMF Diversion Flood (cumec)
302
have been carried out by Hydrological Studies Organisation, CWC, New
Delhi. The details of sedimentation studies are furnished in Appendix - 5.2
of Volume – IV: Appendices – Hydrology and Water assessment.
Table – 6.6
Salient Features of Dam Spillways
Sl.No Details Jheri Paikhed Chasmandva Chikkar Dabdar Kelwan
PMF(in
1
Cumecs) 6539 5307 2578 5649 6683 7979
Top Of Dam
2
(in m) 253 255 222 217 177 174
3 MWL (in m) 247 249 215 212 170 166
4 FRL (in m) 246 248 214 210 169 164
Crest Level(in
5
m) 234 236 202 198 157 152
6 MDDL ( in m) 220 225 190 180 140 140
Silt Elevation
7
(in m) 234 236 202 198 157 130
Foundation
8
Level (in m) 215 210 184 170 132 123
Height of
9 Spillway
(in m) 38 45 35 47 45 51
15
10 Size of Gate(W 15 mx12 15 mx12 12 mx12 m 15 mx12 m mx12 15m
X H) m m m x12 m
11 No. Of Bays 5 4 3 4 5 5
Pier Thickness
12 4 4 4 4 4 4
( in m)
13 U/S Slope 0.1:1 0.1:1 0.1:1 0.1:1 0.1:1 0.1:1
304
Sl.No Details Jheri Paikhed Chasmandva Chikkar Dabdar Kelwan
14 D/S Slope 0.9:1 0.8:1 0.9:1 0.9:1 0.9:1 0.9:1
Horz. Seismic
15 0.09 0.09 0.09 0.09 0.09 0.09
Co-efficient
Vertical
16 Seismic 0.06 0.06 0.06 0.06 0.06 0.06
Co-efficient
Type of EDA Ski Ski Ski Jump Ski Jump Ski Ski
17 Jump Jump Bucket Bucket Jump Jump
Bucket Bucket Bucket Bucket
Radius of
18 Bucket (in 30 30 30 30 30 20
m)
Invert level of
19 176 160 178 155 114 115
Bucket(in m)
20 TWL (in m) 178 185 190 164 123 127
Lip Level ( in
21 180 165 182 170 125 130
m)
Lip Angle
22 30 35 35 30 30 30
(in Degrees)
Ample Free Board above the FRL has been kept for dams to mitigate
against the effects of a major earthquake and wind conditions. For
computations of free board, in respect of all six dams envisaged in Par-
Tapi-Narmada Link Project, guidelines given in IS 10635:1993 have been
followed. Due to non-availability of realistic wind velocity, based on
information contained in IS 875 (Part 3), the Basic wind speed at the all the
dam sites has been taken as 44m/sec (at land surface) while computing the
Freeboard in respect of all six dams. Apart from the freeboard, a tentative
settlement allowance of 1% of the height of the dam above the approximate
deepest acceptable foundation level (based upon the data given in GSI’s
reports) of the dam has also been taken into account while fixing the top
levels (the levels, arrived so have been rounded off to the nearest whole
numeric value to achieve the top level of a particular dam) of all the dams of
the Link project. Features of the CFRDs may require revision based upon
realistic site conditions and related data at the construction stage of the
project.
305
The FRL and MWL are at EL 246.00m and EL 247.00m respectively.
Top level of Jheri dam has been fixed at EL 253.00 m and top of parapet
wall has been fixed at EL 254.20 m.
The wind velocity at the dam sites, the Free Board computed at FRL
and MWL conditions and top of dam levels fixed for Jheri, Paikhed,
306
Chasmandva, Chikkar, Dabdar and Kelwan dams are summarized in the
Table – 6.7:
Table – 6.7
Wind Velocity, Free Board at FRL and MWL and Top of Dam Levels
Paikhed barrage has been designed for 1:100 design flood i.e. 2223
cumecs and free board has been checked for discharge corresponding to 1 in
500 years (3606 cumecs). Due to proximity of dam on upstream, free board
has been checked for PMF (5307 cumecs) as well. The top of pier and
abutments were kept at 152.00 m.
307
No formal diversion arrangement has been provided. The diversion
arrangement during project construction will be evolved depending upon the
requirement. As sufficient width is available, the flow only needs to be
channelized through formed channels which can be decided at construction
stage.
i) Specific Gravity
ii) Water Absorption (%)
iii) Soundness Loss (%) 5 cycles in Na2SO4 Solution
iv) Aggregate Impact Value (%)
v) Aggregate Abrasion Loss (%)
vi) Aggregate Crushing Value (%)
vii) Alkali Aggregate Reactivity Tests
viii) Petrographic Analysis
308
1970. The two nos. river boulder samples bearing Lab. designated No. CA-
14 and CA-18 are suitable only for non-wearing surfaces.
Twelve fine aggregate samples, six of natural sand and six crushed
stone sand prepared from the crushing of rock samples, designated lab. no.
FA-11 to FA-22 were subjected to the following physical and chemical tests
as per IS: 2386-1963 to assess their suitability for use as fine aggregate in
concrete:
i) Fineness Modulus
ii) Specific Gravity
iii) Silt and Clay Content
iv) Organic Impurities
v) Soundness Loss (%) 5 cycles in Na2SO4 Solution
vi) Alkali Aggregate Reactivity Tests
vii) Petrographic Analysis
The results of physical and chemical tests conducted in CSMRS
laboratory, New Delhi on natural sand samples and crushed sand samples
and the report on detailed Petrographic examination of the samples
conducted by GSI, Faridabad are furnished in Appendix-4.9 of Volume-III:
Survey and Investigations.
Based on physical tests report it is found that the natural sand sample
bearing Lab. designated No. FA- 11, 13,15,17,19 and 21, the fineness
modulus is in the range of 3.11 to 4.19 which shows that sand is coarser in
nature and three samples FA-15, 17and 21 also do not conform to any
grading zones I to IV of BIS: 383-1970. However, natural sand which is
coarser in nature may be used in construction works after blending with fine
sand to make the FM 2.5 to 3.0. The crushed sand Lab. designated no. FA-
12, 14,16,18,20 and 22, the fineness modulus varying between 2.73 to 3.77
and conform to the grading zone –I and II as per IS: 383--1970. However,
crushed sand having FM 3.77 which is coarse may also be used in
construction works after more crushing the sand to make FM between 2.5 to
3.0 so that it conforms the grading zone II/III of IS: 383-1970 and the dust
finer than 150 micron should not be more than 15%.
309
6.1.8 Details of Model Studies for Important Structures
No model studies are carried out at this stage. However, the same
may be taken up at pre-construction stage of the project for ensuring
satisfactory hydraulic performance of these structures.
6.2 Dam
6.2.1 Concrete Face Rock Fill Dam – Design Criteria and
Stability Analysis
6.2.1.1 General Layout
310
side and 0.65:1 towards dam side. On the downstream side the thickness of
wall is 15 m with slope of 1.5:1 and 0.25:1 towards dam side. The spillway
blocks have a length of 44 m and the length of NOF blocks is 34 m.
The layout plans of the dams and appurtenant structures are shown in
Drawing Nos.PTNL-5900-P-1036, 3041, 1022, 3001, 1029, 3021, 1043 and
3061(Plates –6.2, 6.8, 6.26, 6.32, 6.50, 6.56, 6.72 and 6.78) of Volume –
311
VIII (A) and Drawing Nos.PTNL-5900-P-1050, 3081, 1057, 3101(Plates –
6.96, 6.102, 6.120 and 6.126) of Volume – VIII (B).
312
As per the ICOLD Bulletin No. 141 on “Concrete Face Rockfill
Dams-Concepts for Design and Construction” the attractive features of
CFRD in respect of design, construction and schedule are as under:
313
As per ICOLD Bulletin No. 141, the maximum heights under
construction or planned exceed 200m. CFRD’s have performed well during
large earthquakes. In spite of poorly compacted rockfill in the older CFRD,
remarkably little damage has occurred. The concrete face will be supported
by processed crushed rock, high strength and high modulus materials.
Because the water barrier is located at the upstream face of the dam, the
embankment materials will not be saturated and, therefore, no deformations
will take place during or subsequent to an earthquake as a result of increased
pore water pressure within the CFRD. Rockfill zoning in a CFRD is also
such that permeability increases progressively from upstream to
downstream.
The slopes of the upstream face as well as downstream face of all the
six CFRDs envisaged in Par-Tapi-Narmada Link Project, have been kept as
1.5H:1V which are quite safe from stability point of view. On the
downstream side of the dam 4 meter wide berms have been proposed to
facilitate the construction and maintenance. Therefore, the average
downstream slope gets further flatter. The upstream or downstream slopes of
the CFRDs may require revision based upon realistic foundation features.
314
The CFRD dam section consists of the following components:
Zone 1A: The zone serves as a source of material that, if required, can
migrate through cracks in the face slab. This zone is placed to a higher
elevation on very high dams so that it can act as a joint or crack healer over
the perimeter joint and the lower part of the face slab. Fine-grained cohesion
less silt and fine sand with isolated gravel and cobble sized rock particles up
to 150 mm. The zone is maintained cohesion less so that brittle cracking
does not occur. The zone is placed in 200 to 300 mm layers and lightly
compacted.
Zone 1B: This zone provides support for zone 1A and in some cases also
resists uplift of the face slab prior to reservoir filling. Random mix of silts,
clays, sands, gravels, and cobbles to provide protection to Zone 1A. This
zone shall be placed in 400 mm layers and compacted.
315
Zone 2A:Sand and gravel filter are located within two to three meters of the
perimetric joint to limit leakage in the event of water stop failure and to self
heal with under water placement of silt or silty fine sand. In the event of
disruption of the water- stops at the perimeter joint, the filter zone 2A will
prevent the movement of silt size particles through the zone and, thus,
serves as secondary defense against leakage. This zone consists of material
equal or nearly equal in quality to concrete aggregate. The material is
manufactured and processed to specific gradation limits. Zone 2A shall be
placed in 200 mm layers, well-compacted with vibratory compactors, and
protected from damage and erosion during construction. The zone 2A filter
material, placed immediately adjacent to the perimeter joint, needs to be
well compacted to strict specifications to minimize settlement.
Zone 2B: Zone 2B provides support to the face slab and consists of sand
and gravel-sized particles, placed in 300 mm horizontal layers and normally
compacted with 4 passes of a 10-ton smooth-drum vibratory roller. The
horizontal width of the zone varies from 2 to 4 m depending on the height of
the dam. This zone consists of material equal or nearly equal in quality to
concrete aggregate. The material is a crushed product and manufactured to
specific gradation limits. The aim of the ICOLD Bulletin 70 specification is
to limit maximum size, to provide a grading which will not segregate during
placement, and to include sufficient fines to give an acceptable low
permeability. A target permeability of 1 X 10-4 cm/sec is recommended. This
gradation exhibits low permeability and some cohesion.
Zone 3A: Zone 3A is to provide compatibility and limit void size adjacent
to Zone 2B.This zone is a transition between Zone 2B and rockfill Zone 3B
and consists of rockfill with maximum size of 300 mm or less placed in 300
mm layers and normally compacted with at least 6 passes of a 10-ton or
heavier smooth-drum vibratory roller. The horizontal width of the zone
varies from 2 to 4 m depending on the height of the dam. For all CFRDs in
P-T-N Project, horizontal width of this zone has been proposed as 4 m.
Zone 3B: This zone resists the water loading and limits face deflection.
This zone commonly consists of rockfill with maximum size of 800 mm
placed in 800 mm layers and normally compacted with 6 passes of a 10-ton
smooth-drum vibratory roller. Water (10%-25% of rock volume) is added
316
during fill placement. Increasing compaction coverage, using thinner layers,
and application of water are means of achieving satisfactory density when
using weak rock. Thinner layers are often used for sand and gravel fills.
The details of the different zones and their gradation are given in
CWC Drawings No. PTNL-5900-P-1037, 1023, 1030 and 1044 (Plates–6.3,
6.27, 6.51 and 6.73) of Volume – VIII (A) and PTNL-5900-P-1051 and
1058 (Plates-6.97 and 6.121) of Volume – VIII (B).
317
6.2.1.5 Dam Slope Stability
6.2.1.6 Plinth
The plinth or toe slab connects the foundation with the face slab. The
dimensions of the plinth have been selected based on precedent and
generally vary with reservoir head and with foundation conditions. The
width of the plinth has been proposed to be changed in several steps and is
not tapered, mainly for construction convenience. For moderately to slightly
weathered rock, the width of plinth has been increased, such that a
maximum hydraulic gradient of 10 is achieved. The minimum width has
been usually set at 3 m. The minimum design thickness T of the plinth is
usually on the order of 0.3 to 0.4 m with thickness varying with reservoir
head, H.
Table- 6.8
Head of Water Vis-à-vis Length of Plinth
318
Type of Rock Length of Plinth
Non-Erodible H/18
Slightly Erodible H/12
Erodible H/6
The primary water barrier of the CFRD consists of concrete face slabs
poured on underlying support zones of the rockfill body of the dam. The
face slab is fully supported by the underlying rockfill, and is mostly in
compression under reservoir loadings, except towards the dam abutments
where tensile strains develop. Because of this, the design of face slabs in
recent years has concentrated more on water tightness and durability than on
design of slabs, and increasing attention has been paid to identification and
control of crack development in face slabs. Deformation of the face slab will
conform to the deformation of the underlying rockfill body of the dam. This
fact highlights the importance of proper selection, placement and
compaction of the rockfill materials supporting the face slabs to limit
excessive deformations and cracking in the face slabs. Face slab generally
moves towards the centre of the dam and away from the dam abutments,
highlighting the fact that most parts of the slabs are generally in
compression except at the abutments. Successful performance of the CFRD
face slabs, in terms of providing a reasonably waterproof barrier to the
reservoir, is highly dependent on factors other than the design of the face
slab itself. In this respect, the determination of face slab dimensions, and
reinforcing is based on previous experience rather than rigorous analysis.
319
0.0035H (where H= head of water above the concerned elevation of Face
slab). The thickness of Face slab at the top level of the dam, is fixed as
300mm. The thickness of face slab will vary linearly at various elevations,
as per simple expression given above, and will be maximum at the bottom
(i.e. at the junction with plinth).
Panel width for face slab typically ranges from 12 to 18m, with panel
width of 15m being common. Factors affecting the width of face slab panels
are mainly related to the width of the slip forms and capabilities of concrete
placing equipment. Narrower panel widths are use where vertical joints are
desired due to changes in plinth geometry, rock topography, or adjacent to
the dam abutments, where larger panel movements may occur. Panel widths
greater than about 18m are uncommon. Wider panel widths can increase the
occurrence of shrinkage cracks. In case of all the CFRDs in Par-Tapi-
Narmada Link Project, the width of the concrete panels has been kept as
15.0 metres.
6.2.1.7.3 Joints
320
6.2.1.7.3 (a) Perimetric Joint and Water Stops
The perimetric joint connects the concrete face slab and the plinth of
the CFRD to complete the upstream water barrier of the dam. Due to its
location and movement that occur at this joint, the perimetric joint is has
been given special consideration. The main function of the perimetric joint
is to maintain a watertight seal against full reservoir load while allowing for
anticipated movements between the plinth and face slabs. The face slab can
move relative to the plinth in three different directions: normal to the
perimetric joint (opening), normal to the face slab (settlement), and parallel
to the perimetric joint (shear). Movement in any of these directions
separates the face slab from the plinth. All longitudinal and transverse joints
in the plinth, the perimetric joint between face slab and plinth and joint
between plinth and cut off wall were provided with the following provisions
to prevent potential leakage:
The face slab rests on the rockfill body of the dam, and will move and
deform as the rockfill it rests on settles beneath it. Leakage is a key
parameter that relates to the overall performance of the CFRD. Large
leakage rates are an indication that damage has occurred to the perimetric
joint and/ or face slab has cracked to some extent. Seepage through the
foundation may also be a contributing factor to large leakage rates. The
fundamental design concept of the CFRD is that the several embankment
zones of the dam including the face support material, filters, transitions,
under-drainage and the body of the dam must remain stable even if
extremely large leakage rates were to occur. It is well known the rockfill is
able to accept and pass large flows. So even if large leakage rates occur, it
may not be an indication that the safety of the dam is jeopardized but it
suggests that remedial treatment to prevent the leakage is required.
321
The details of perimetric joint provided are shown in Drawing Nos.
PTNL-5900-P-1039, 1025, 1032 and 1046 (Plates –6.5, 6.29, 6.53, and
6.75) in Volume –VIII (A) and Drawing Nos. PTNL-5900-P-1053 and 1060
(Plates –6.99 and 6.123) in Volume –VIII (B).
322
Horizontal construction joints are used when only a portion of a face
slab panel cannot be poured, either by design or due to an unscheduled
interruption. Reasons for horizontal construction joints include staged
construction of the rockfill dam body, use of starter slabs, interruptions in
slab construction due to weather or equipment malfunction, long panel
lengths on high CFRDs. Horizontal construction joints typically do not
incorporate any water-stops, and reinforcement is continuous through the
joints. It is important to thoroughly clean and repair any honeycombing or
other damage to the joint before construction of the panel is continued.
For the plinth, face slab and parapet wall of the all the six CFRDs in
Par-Tapi-Narmada Link project, M25 grade of concrete conforming to IS
456: 2000 has been proposed. The Grade of concrete for interface wall has
been proposed as M15 conforming to IS 456: 2000. However, M-20 Grade
concrete has been proposed for 1m thick concrete over face of interface wall
which will be in contact with water.
323
6.2.1.7.5 Reinforcement
Reinforcement of 0.35% (both ways) for face slab has been proposed
for all the six dams. Concrete cover is typically set at a minimum of 150
mm.
Unlike earth core rockfill dams, concrete face rockfill dams have
traditionally been provided with a concrete parapet wall at the upstream
edge of the crest. The parapet wall in CFRD also participates in the
functioning of the Dam and may be kept a part of free board requirement of
the dam. The height of parapet wall has been kept as 1.20m above the top of
dam, in case of all the six dams under the link project.
The main purpose of the parapet wall is to reduce the total volume of
rockfill. Commonly a single parapet wall is constructed. The face slab
construction requires the use of winches at the crest to support the slip-
forming and other equipment necessary for efficient construction.
Additionally, access is required for personnel, for movement of equipment,
and for delivery of concrete, steel and other material. To accommodate these
activities, sufficient working space is required for an efficient concreting
operation. Thus, use of a parapet wall provides a sufficiently wide working
surface at the elevation of the base of the parapet wall for face slab
construction. In addition, the parapet wall serves as a wave splash barrier
also.
The joint between the parapet wall and the face slab must provide an
adequate barrier against leakage from the reservoir water. Commonly, the
base of the parapet wall is located somewhat above the normal maximum
operating reservoir level (ie. FRL) so that the joint is not normally
submerged. During flood, the wall contains the reservoir surcharge. The
elevation of the top of the wall has been selected such that overtopping does
not occur during the probable maximum flood. In case of all the CFRDs
324
envisaged in the link project, the base of parapet wall has been kept above
Maximum Water level (MWL).
At the junction between the all the CFRDs and the spillways in the P-
T-N project, interface wall has been proposed to prevent seepage. The
N.O.F. block adjacent to the CFRD has been utilized as Interface wall. On
both, upstream and downstream sides, the slope of the interface wall has
been kept same as that of CFRD i.e. 1.5H : 1V. On the downstream side the
thickness of wall is 15m for all the dams except Jheri CFRD where this
thickness has been kept as 10.0m. On the upstream side, the thickness of
interface wall, in all the six dams, has been kept as 3.0m. The slope of 3.0m
thick upstream side interface wall shall be 0.65:1 towards the dam side.
The slope of 15.0m thick interface wall on the downstream side shall be
0.25:1 towards the dam side.
325
As per ICOLD Bulletin 141, the filter-drain system provides an all-
important second line of defense. If the water stops at the perimeter joint are
disrupted such that reservoir leakage through the joint occurs, the 2A filter
must retain silt and fine sand particles. High head loss will occur through
the clogged filter interface and/or through the silts and sands trapped within
the joint upstream of the filter. In addition, the filter must be considerably
more permeable than the clogged interface or the material trapped in the
joint.
D15 = particle size in filter (protecting, or coarser material) for which 15%
by weight of particles are smaller; and
d85 = particle size in base (protected, or finer material) for which 85% by
weight of particles are smaller.
Table – 6.9
Zone wise Gradation in CFRDs and Compaction Parameters
326
Zone
Description Source Gradation Compaction Parameters
No. of passes
Dmax <5mm <0.1 Roller Wt
Density (t/m3)
(mm) (%) mm (t)
(%)
1A Silty fine -- -- -- 20 -- -- By
sand Construction
equipment
1B Random fill -- -- -- 40 4 -- 10
2A Processed 40 35-60 5-10 20 -- -- By Manual
fine filter Processed vibrator
2B Processed from 100 35-45 4-7 30 4 2.20 10
filter Quarry to
2.30
3A Transition 300 20-30 <5 30 6 -- 10
(Processed
Rockfill)
3B Major Rock 800 4 -15 <5 80 6 2.20 10
fill (Main Excavated to
fill) from 2.40
3C Rock fill or Quarry 1000 < 20 <5 100 6 2.20 10
Gravel to
2.30
3D Oversize >100 -- -- -- -- --
Boulder 0
Table– 6.10
Salient Features of various CFRDs
Name of FRL MWL Dam Maximum Length of Top Slopes of u/s
Dam Top Height of Dam Width and d/s Face
Level Dam above (Excluding of of Dam
River Bed N.O.F. and Dam
O.F.
Length)
Jheri EL EL EL 75.88m 663m 10.0m U/S: 1.5H : 1V
246.00 247.50 253.00
D/S: 1.5H : 1V
Paikhed EL248. EL EL 94.4m 1310m 10.0m U/S: 1.5H : 1V
00 249.00 255.00 D/S: 1.5H : 1V
Chasman EL EL EL 53.70 2703m 10.0m U/S: 1.5H : 1V
dva 214.00 215.18 222.00
327
D/S: 1.5H : 1V
The Jheri dam has been proposed across Par River as composite
embankment (CFRD) cum concrete dam. The total length of Jheri dam is
808.32 m of which 145 m is concrete dam and remaining 663.32 m is
CFRD. The Jheri concrete dam is 38 m high and the length of non over
flow portion is 54 m and over flow portion is 91 m. The over flow portion
consists of 5 bays of 15 m length and 4 piers of 4 m width, to pass a peak
flood of 6539 cumecs (PMF). Layout Plan, Spillway Plan and Spillway
elevation of Jheri concrete dam are at Drawing Nos. PTNL-5900-P-3041,
PTNL-5900-P-3043 and 3044 (Plate –6.8, 6.19and 6.20) in Volume –
VIII(A).
The Paikhed dam has been proposed across Nar River as composite
embankment (CFRD) cum concrete dam. The total length of Paikhed dam is
1431.85 m of which 121 m is concrete dam and remaining 1310.85 m is
CFRD. The Paikhed concrete dam is 45 m high and length of non over flow
portion is 49 m and over flow portion is 72 m. The over flow portion
consists of 4 bays of 15 m length and 3 piers of 4 m width, to pass a peak
flood of 5307cumecs (PMF). Layout Plan, Spillway Plan and Spillway
elevation of Paikhed concrete dam are at Drawing Nos. PTNL-5900-P-3001,
3003 and 3005 (Plate –6.32, 6.42and 6.43) in Volume – VIII (A).
328
of non over flow portion is 34 m and over flow portion is 44 m. The over
flow portion consists of 3bays of 12 m length and 2 piers of 4 m width, to
pass a peak flood of 2578cumecs (PMF). Layout Plan, Spillway Plan and
Spillway elevation of Chasmandva concrete dam are at Drawing Nos.
PTNL-5900-P-3021, 3024 and 3023 (Plate –6.56, 6.65and 6.66) in Volume
– VIII (A).
The Dabdar dam has been proposed across Khapri River as composite
embankment (CFRD) cum concrete dam. The total length of Dabdar dam is
1170 m of which 135 m is concrete dam and remaining 1035 m is CFRD.
The Dabdar concrete dam is 45 m high and length of non over flow portion
is 44 m and over flow portion is 91 m. The over flow portion consists of 5
bays of 15 m length and 4 piers of 4 m width, to pass a peak flood of
6683cumecs (PMF). Layout Plan, Spillway Plan and Spillway elevation of
Dabdar concrete dam are at Drawing Nos. PTNL-5900-P-3081, 3084 and
3083 (Plate –6.102, 6.113and 6.114) in Volume – VIII (B).
The Kelwan dam has been proposed across Purna River as composite
embankment (CFRD) cum concrete dam. The total length of Kelwan dam is
1330 m of which 189 m is concrete dam and remaining 1141 m is CFRD.
The Kelwan concrete dam is 51 m high and length of non over flow portion
is 98 m and over flow portion is 91 m. The over flow portion consists of 5
bays of 15 m length and 4 piers of 4 m width, to pass a peak flood of 7979
cumecs (PMF). Layout Plan, Spillway Plan and Spillway elevation of
Kelwan concrete dam are at Drawing Nos. PTNL-5900-P-3101, 3104 and
3103 (Plate –6.126, 6.137 and 6.138) in Volume – VIII (B).
329
6.2.2.2 Free Board
6.2.2.3 Zoning
Table – 6.11
Classification of Concrete in Non Over Flow Section
S.No Location Classification Max. size Compressive
. of Concrete of Strength of
Aggregate 150 mm
(mm) Cubes in
N/mm2 (28
days)
1 Concrete in Non overflow C1 150 15.00
section (Except 1500 mm
exterior thickness on u/s
face)
2 Concrete in foundation for C2 40 12.50
filling up crevices etc.
3 Concrete in U/S face C3 75 16.50
330
(1500 mm thick).
4 Fillets concrete. C4 40 25.00
5 Concrete in parapet C5 20 20.00
6 Concrete around C6 40 20.00
foundation gallery, sump
well, pump chamber,
stair / lift well and other
openings.
Table – 6.12
Classification of Concrete in Over Flow Section
S. Location Classification Max. size Compressi
No. of Concrete of ve Strength
Aggregate of 150 mm
(mm) Cubes in
N/mm2
(28 days)
1 (i) Concrete in spillway C1 75 15.00
section (except 1500 mm
exterior thickness on U/S
face and D/S glacis).
(ii) Left and right training
wall gravity section (except
1000 mm thickness on
water side).
2 Concrete in foundation for C2 40 20.00
filling up crevices etc.
3 (i) Concrete in exterior 1500 C3 75 20.00
mm thickness on U/S face
of spillway
(ii) Concrete in exterior
1000 mm thickness of the
training wall (gravity
section) on water side
4 Fillets concrete. C4 40 25.00
5 (i) Concrete in spillway C5 20 20.00
bridge, deck slab, beams
and parapet etc.
331
(ii) Concrete around
foundation gallery, sump
well, pump chamber, stair
case/lift well and other
openings.
6. (i) Concrete in spillway C6 75 20.00
crest, pier, glacis, training
wall (RCC section) and
anchorage length of pier.
(ii) Concrete in stilling
basin, apron (Excluding top
1000 mm).
7 Concrete in exterior 1000 C7 75 25.00
mm thickness of stilling
basin and apron.
8 Concrete in stilling basin C8 20 30.00
chute block, basin block and
end sill.
The zoning of material for NOF and OF sections of Jheri dam are
shown in Drawing Nos. PTNL-5900-P-3051, 3054 and 3048 (Plate –6.11,
6.12, 6.16) in Volume – VIII (A). The zoning of material for NOF and OF
sections of Paikhed dam are shown in Drawing Nos. PTNL-5900-P-3010,
3013 and 3008 (Plate –6.36, 6.35 and 6.39) in Volume – VIII (A). The
zoning of material for NOF and OF sections of Chasmandva dam are shown
in Drawing Nos. PTNL-5900-P-3031 and 3028 (Plate –6.59 and 6.62) in
Volume – VIII (A). The zoning of material for NOF and OF sections of
Chikkar dam are shown in Drawing Nos. PTNL-5900-P-3071, 3074 and
3068 (Plate –6.82, 6.81 and 6.86) in Volume – VIII (A). The zoning of
material for NOF and OF sections of Dabdar dam are shown in Drawing
Nos. PTNL-5900-P-3091, 3094 and 3088 (Plate –6.106, 6.105and 6.110) in
Volume – VIII (B). The zoning of material for NOF and OF sections of
Kelwan dam are shown in Drawing Nos. PTNL-5900-P-3111, 3114 and
3108 (Plate –6.129, 6.130 and 6.134) in Volume – VIII (B).
332
The design has been carried out to fulfil the following requirements of
stability.
Further, all the forces considered in the analysis have been taken as
per IS 6512-1984. The unit weight of concrete has been taken as 2.4 T/cum
and water as 1.0 T/cum. The project area falls under zone –III of the seismic
zone of India. The foundation has been assumed to be granite and mass
concrete (for dams).
6.2.2.4.2 Stability Analysis of Non-Overflow Section
Jheri Dam:
The Non-overflow section has been designed with the following data:
333
The stability analysis for Non-Overflow section has been carried out
at the deepest foundation level i.e. at 210.00m, and the results are furnished
in Table - 6.13:
Table – 6.13
Results of Stability Analysis for Non-Overflow Section
Sr. Load Vertical Stress (in t/m2) Factor of Permissible
No. Combination Safety Tensile
Against Stress (in
2
Sliding t/m )
Upstream Downstream
1 A 99.38 7.12 -- ---
2 B 55.34 28.01 2.80 No Tension
3 C 50.16 30.43 2.60 0.01 fc (20)
4 D 113.95 -2.30 18.20
5 E 37.49 41.93 2.90 0.02 fc (40)
6 F 35.54 29.30 5.90 0.02 fc (40)
7 G 22.59 40.77 4.70 0.04 fc (80)
Paikhed Dam:
The non-overflow section has been designed with the following data:
334
k) Angle of internal friction =55 degrees
The stability analysis for Non-Overflow section has been carried out
at the deepest foundation level i.e. at 175.00m, and the results are furnished
in Table – 6.14:
Table – 6.14
Results of Stability Analysis for Non-Overflow Section
Sr. Load Vertical Stress Factor of Permissible
No. Combination (in t/m2) Safety Tensile Stress
against (in t/m2)
Sliding
Upstream Downstream
1 A 169.24 17.74 -- ---
2 B 41.63 87.06 5.1 No Tension
3 C 38.12 87.41 5.2 0.01 fc (20)
4 D 192.96 1.76 51.0
5 E 7.78 114.64 5.7 0.02 fc (40)
6 F 18.55 86.00 12.9 0.02 fc (40)
7 G -13.47 113.11 9.9 0.04 fc (80)
Chasmandva Dam:
The non-overflow section has been designed with the following data:
335
j) Cohesion =509.858 T/sq.m
k) Angle of internal friction =55 degrees
The stability analysis for Non-Overflow section has been carried out
at the deepest foundation level i.e. at 184.00 m, and the results are furnished
in Table – 6.15:
Table – 6.15
Results of Stability Analysis for Non-Overflow Section
Sr. Load Vertical Stress Factor Permissible
No. Combination (in t/m2) of Tensile
Safety Stress
Against (in t/m2)
Sliding
Upstream Downstream
Chikkar Dam:
336
The non-overflow section has been designed with the following data:
The stability analysis for Non-Overflow section has been carried out
at the deepest foundation level i.e. at 170.00 m, and the results are furnished
in Table – 6.16:
Table – 6.16
Results of Stability Analysis for Non-Overflow Section
Sr. Load Vertical Stress Factor Permissible
2
No. Combination (in t/m ) of Tensile
Safety Stress
Against (in t/m2)
Sliding
Upstream Downstream
Dabdar Dam:
337
right NOF block has been kept at EL.132.0 m and El.145.0 m. With its top
level at EL. 177 m, the maximum height of the NOF section is 45 m.
The Non-overflow section has been designed with the following data:
The stability analysis for Non-Overflow section has been carried out
at the deepest foundation level i.e. at El. 132.00 m, and the results are
furnished in Table – 6.17.
Table -6.17
Results of Stability Analysis for Non-Overflow Section
Sr. Load Vertical Stress Factor of Permissible
2
No. Combination (in t/m ) Safety Tensile Stress
Against (in t/m2)
Sliding
Upstream Downstream
1 A 71.72 3.22 -- ---
2 B 45.41 14.56 4.70 No Tension
3 C 40.71 13.32 4.60 0.01 fc (20)
4 D 82.42 -3.58 22.40
5 E 33.03 24.15 4.6 0.02 fc (40)
6 F 35.71 11.81 11.50 0.02 fc (40)
7 G 26.69 22.24 8.0 0.04 fc (80)
Kelwan Dam:
338
of the left and right NOF block has been kept as 7.0 m. The
foundation level for the left and right NOF block has been kept at
EL.123.0m. With its top level at EL 174 m, the maximum height of
the NOF section is 51 m.
The non-overflow section has been designed with the following data:
Table – 6.18
Results Stability Analysis for Non-Overflow Section
Sr. Load Vertical Stress Factor of Permissible
2
No. Combination (in t/m ) Safety Tensile
Against Stress
Sliding (in t/m2)
Upstream Downstream
1 A 108.72 7.39 -- ---
2 B 60.16 27.83 2.70 No Tension
3 C 51.93 29.56 2.70 0.01 fc (20)
4 D 123.80 -2.25 18.40
5 E 41.64 42.30 2.80 0.02 fc (40)
6 F 39.35 28.68 6.10 0.02 fc (40)
7 G 26.80 41.26 4.60 0.04 fc (80)
339
From above it is seen that:
I. The stresses developed at the base of the non-over flow section are within
the permissible limits specified in IS code 6512 – 1984
III.The factor of safety against sliding for the conditions of reservoirs empty
and full (FRL and MWL) and various load combinations as per IS code
6512- 1984 are found to be greater than 1.00 as recommended in IS
code.
Spillway Profile:
340
The ogee profile consists of two quadrants, the upstream quadrant and
the downstream quadrant. Once the design head Hd of the spillway is fixed,
the crest geometry may easily be evaluated. The recommended shape is
based on detailed observations of the lower nappe profile of fully ventilated
thin-plate weir. Such a profile would generally result in atmospheric
pressure along the entire spillway surface at design head H d. For head lower
than Hd the pressure would be higher than atmospheric and for higher heads,
sub-atmospheric pressure would result.
Table – 6.19
Upstream Profile Co-ordinates
Jheri dam Paikhed dam
341
Dabdar dam Kelwan dam
X 21.85 K 2 H d0.85Y2
342
Chasmandva dam Chikkar dam
343
The stability analysis for Overflow section has been carried out at the
deepest foundation level at which sound rock is available, for load
combinations as Stated under:
i) A (construction condition),
ii) B (Normal Operating Condition),
iii) C (Flood Discharge Condition),
iv) D (Combination A with earthquake),
v) E (Combination B with earthquake but no ice).
vi) F (Combination C but with extreme uplift drains inoperative) and
vii) G (combination E but with extreme uplift drains inoperative).
Uplift pressure are assumed to act over the entire base width and vary
from maximum at heel on upstream side to one third of its value at the
drainage gallery and to zero at toe on downstream side where no tail water
is assumed.
Jheri Dam
Following data have been used for stability analysis of overflow section:
344
9. Foundation level = El.215.0 m
Table – 6.21
Results of Stability Analysis of Spillway
Sr. No. Load Upstream Downstream Factor of Permissible
Combination Stress Stress Safety in Tensile Stress
(T/sq.m) (T/sq.m) Sliding (T/sq.m)
1 A 84.074 6.715 -- ----
2 B 12.805 54.745 1.900 No Tension
3 C 13.478 47.640 1.974 0.01 fc (20)
4 D 99.237 -5.739 25.439
5 E -10.219 75.059 2.142 0.02 fc (40)
6 F 0.090 46.207 4.674 0.02 fc (40)
7 G -24.122 73.572 3.559 0.04 fc (80)
Paikhed Dam
345
Following data have been used for stability analysis of overflow section:
Chasmandva Dam
The overflow blocks of spillway consist of 3 spillway bays of 12 m
width and 2 piers of 4.0 m thickness. Thus the total length of the spillway
comes to 44 m. A spillway bridge with a roadway width of 10.0 m has been
provided. The spillway has its crest at EL.202.00m and comprises of
standard ogee profile with upstream slope of 0.1H:1V and downstream
slope of 0.9H:1V. It has 3 Nos. of 12 m x12 m radial gates. The foundation
level has been kept at EL.184.00m. With crest level at EL.202.00 m, the
maximum height of the overflow section is 18 m.
346
Following data have been used for stability analysis of overflow section:
Table – 6.23
Results of Stability Analysis of Spillway
Chikkar Dam
Following data have been used for stability analysis of overflow section:
Table – 6.24
Results of Stability Analysis of Spillway
Sr. Load Upstream Downstream Factor of Permissible
No. Combination Stress Stress Safety in Tensile Stress
(T/sq.m) (T/sq.m) Sliding (T/Sq.m)
1 A 86.462 12.590 -- ----
2 B 20.255 60.791 1.845 No Tension
3 C 17.398 57.065 1.793 0.01 fc (20)
4 D 96.526 69.194 33.935
5 E 9.754 80.490 2.346 0.02 fc (40)
6 F 2.276 53.909 4.091 0.02 fc (40)
7 G -5.572 65.996 3.789 0.04 fc (80)
Dabdar Dam
348
slope of 0.9H:1V. It has 5 Nos. of 12 m x12 m radial gates. The foundation
level has been kept at EL.132.00 m. With crest level at EL.157.00 m, the
maximum height of the overflow section is 25 m.
Following data have been used for stability analysis of overflow section:
1. Radial gate trunnion elevation level = El. 161.00 m
2. Bridge weight = 10 t/m run (Aprox.)
3. Bridge width = 7.0 m
4. Width of block =19 m
5. Elevation of T.P. = El. 148.310 m
6. Bridge road level =El. 177.0 m
7. Cm = 0.730
8. Spillway crest =El. 157.00 m
9. Foundation level = El.132.0 m
Table – 6.25
Results of Stability Analysis of Spillway
Kelwan Dam
349
standard ogee profile with upstream slope of 0.1H:1V and downstream
slope of 0.8H:1V. It has 5 Nos. of 15 m x12 m radial gates. The foundation
level has been kept at EL.123.00 m. With crest level at EL.152.00 m, the
maximum height of the overflow section is 29 m.
Following data have been used for stability analysis of overflow section:
Table – 6.26
Results of Stability Analysis of Spillway
350
3. 80t/sq.m for load condition as enumerated under G
The stresses obtained are within permissible limit and the factor of
safety against sliding under all condition of loading is much more than 1.0
(the minimum of the specified requirement under different combination of
loading as per IS.6512). Hence, the stability is in order.
351
Chute profile is tentative and subject to confirmation of satisfactory
performance through physical model studies.
The dissipation of the kinetic energy after flow through chute channel
is necessary for bringing the flow into downstream river to pre-dam
condition. The factors that govern the type of energy dissipater to be used
are:
a) Hydraulic considerations
b) Topography
c) Geology
d) Type of dam
e) Economic considerations etc.
In all the 6 dams, Ski jump type Energy dissipation has been proposed
due to:
The details of the principal features in the design of Ski jump energy
dissipation for all the 6 dams are given in Table – 6.27 below:
Table – 6.27
Principal Features in the Design of Ski Jump Energy Dissipation
353
designed to close under its own weight for all operating conditions. The
overall design of Radial Gates shall confirm to IS: 4623-2000. The general
installation of Spillway Radial Gate is at Drawing No. PTNL-5900-JHD-
1501 (Plate No.6.23) in Volume –VIII (A).
One set of sliding type stop logs has been envisaged to cater for
maintenance requirement of 5 nos. of dam spillway radial gates. The stop
log set for opening size of 15.0 m wide x 12.60 m high shall be fabricated in
six units with height of each unit 2100 mm i.e., one non- interchangeable
bottom unit and five nos. interchangeable units. The stop logs shall have
downstream skin plate and downstream sealing, fitted with sliding pads and
adequate structural members. The element is also fitted with side guide
rollers for guiding the elements under operation. The stop logs shall be
designed for head corresponding to FRL of 246.0 m (sill 233.78 m). The
stop log units shall be operated under balanced head condition by means of
a gantry crane of adequate capacity with the help of a lifting beam, except
the top unit, which shall be raised under unbalanced head condition. Four
elements are proposed to be stored in the storage bay and remaining two
elements shall be stored in right/left NOF section of dam when not in use.
The general installation of Spillway Stop log Gate is at Drawing No. PTNL-
5900-JHD-1502 (Plate No.6.24 in Volume –VIII (A)).
354
iv) Instruments and Remote Control
The main items of control and equipment of Jheri Dam Project shall
comprise the following:
B. Paikhed Dam:
i) Spillway Radial Gates and Hoists
355
Spillway crest radial gates (4 nos.) of opening size 15.0 m wide x
12.0 m high shall be provided to control the discharge through the gated
portion of the spillway. Each gate shall be operated by means of hydraulic
hoist of 200 t (2 x 100 t) capacity (tentative). The sill of the gate is located
at EL 235.65 m. The radial gate shall be designed for a head corresponding
to FRL i.e. EL 248.00 m. The gates shall be operated under water head
between elevations EL 249.00 m to EL 235.60 m. The water load on the
gate is transferred from gate through radial arms to trunnion brackets and
finally to concrete piers through anchorage or to the trunnion girder and
finally to the pier through un bonded conventional anchorages. The anchors
shall be designed to cater for loads imposed due to gate being at any
position for different water heads. The gate shall be designed to close under
its own weight for all operating conditions. The overall design of Radial
Gates shall confirm to IS: 4623-2000.The overall design of Radial Gates
shall confirm to IS: 4623-2000. The general installation of Spillway Radial
Gate is at Drawing No. PTNL-5900-PKD-1501 (Plate No.6.47) in Volume –
VIII (A).
One set of sliding type stop logs has been envisaged to cater for
maintenance requirement of 4 nos. of dam spillway radial gates. The stop
logs set for opening size of 15 m wide x 12 m high shall be fabricated in six
units with height of each unit 2100 mm i.e., one non- interchangeable
bottom unit and five nos. interchangeable units. The stop logs shall have
downstream skin plate and downstream sealing, fitted with sliding pads and
adequate structural members. The element is also fitted with side guide
rollers for guiding the elements under operation. The stop logs shall be
designed for head corresponding to FRL of EL 248.00 m (sill EL 235.84 m).
The stop log units shall be operated under balanced head condition by
means of a gantry crane of 40 t capacity (tentative) with the help of an
automatic engaging and disengaging lifting beam, except the top unit, which
shall be raised under unbalanced head condition. The elements are proposed
to be stored in the storage bay located on the right/left NOF section of dam
356
when not in use. The general installation of Spillway Stop log Gate is at
Drawing No. PTNL-5900-PKD-1502 (Plate No.6.48) in Volume –VIII (A).
357
the dam site. The diesel generating set shall be located in the dam to
provide back-up supply to gate operating equipment and to the
computerized control system in case of power failure.
C. Chasmandva Dam:
i) Spillway Radial Gates and Hoists
Spillway crest radial gates (three nos.) of opening size 12.0 m wide x
12.0 m high shall be provided to control the discharge through the gated
portion of the spillway. Each gate shall be operated by means of twin
hydraulic hoist of 180t (2x90t) capacity (tentative) mounted on pier at EL
216.30 m. The sill of the gate is located at EL 201.65 m. The radial gate
shall be designed for a head corresponding to FRL i.e. EL 214.00 m. The
gates shall be operated under water head between elevations EL 215.00 m to
EL 201.65 m. The water load on the gate is transferred from gate through
radial arms to trunnion brackets and finally to concrete piers through
anchorage or to the trunnion girder and finally to the pier through unbonded
conventional anchorages. The anchors shall be designed to cater for loads
imposed due to gate being at any position for different water heads. The gate
shall be designed to close under its own weight for all operating conditions.
The overall design of Radial Gates shall confirm to IS: 4623-2000. The
general installation of Spillway Radial Gate is at Drawing No. PTNL-5900-
CHVD-1501 (Plate No.6.69) in Volume –VIII (A).
358
ii) Stop logs for Radial Gates
One set of sliding type stop logs has been envisaged to cater for
maintenance requirement of 3 nos. of dam spillway radial gates. The
stop log set for opening size of 12 m wide x 12.30 m high shall be
fabricated in six units with height of each unit 2050 mm i.e., one non-
interchangeable bottom unit and five nos. interchangeable units. The stop
logs shall have downstream skin plate and downstream sealing, fitted
with sliding pads and adequate structural members. The element is also
fitted with side guide rollers for guiding the elements under operation.
The stop logs shall be designed for head corresponding to FRL of EL
214.00 m (sill EL 201.86 m). The stop log units shall be operated under
balanced head condition by means of a gantry crane of 35t capacity
(tentative) with the help of a lifting beam, except the top unit, which shall
be raised under unbalanced head condition. The elements are proposed to
be stored in the storage bay located on the left/right bank of NOF section
when not in use. The general installation of Spillway Stop log Gate is at
Drawing No. PTNL-5900-CHVD-1502 (Plate No.6.70 in Volume –VIII
(A)).
359
c) Water level indication and monitoring along with necessary alarms
provided.
d) Monitoring and indication of discharge measurements for discharge
through all gates and hoist.
D. Chikkar Dam:
i) Spillway Radial Gates and Hoists
360
FRL i.e. EL 210.00 m. The gates shall be operated under water head
between elevations EL 212.00 m (MWL) to EL 197.80 m. The water load on
the gate is transferred from gate through radial arms to trunnion brackets
and finally to concrete piers through anchorage or to the trunnion girder and
finally to the pier through unbonded conventional anchorages. The anchors
shall be designed to cater for loads imposed due to gate being at any
position for different water heads. The gate has been designed to close under
its own weight for all operating conditions. The overall design of Radial
Gates shall confirm to IS: 4623-2000.The general installation of Spillway
Radial Gate is at Drawing No. PTNL-5900-CKD-1501 (Plate No.6.93) in
Volume –VIII (A).
One set of sliding type stop logs has been envisaged to cater for
maintenance requirement of 4 nos. of dam spillway radial gates. The stop
log set for opening size of 15.0 m wide x 12.90 m high shall be fabricated in
six units with height of each unit 2150 mm i.e., one non- interchangeable
bottom unit and five nos. interchangeable units. The stop logs shall have
downstream skin plate and downstream sealing, fitted with sliding pads and
adequate structural members. The element is also fitted with side guide
rollers for guiding the elements under operation. The stop logs shall be
designed for head corresponding to FRL of EL 210.0 m (sill EL 197.30).
The stoplog units shall be operated under balanced head condition by means
of a gantry crane of adequate capacity with the help of a lifting beam, except
the top unit, which shall be raised under unbalanced head condition. Four
elements are proposed to be stored in the storage bay and remaining two
elements shall be stored in right/left NOF section of dam when not in use.
The general installation of Spillway Stop log Gate is at Drawing No. PTNL-
5900-CKD-1502 (Plate No.6.94) in Volume –VIII (A).
The salient features of Spillway Stop log Gate are furnished at Annexure-
6.11 in Annexure Volume-II.
361
iii) Gantry Crane for Spillway Stop logs
The main items of control and equipment of Chikkar Dam Project shall
comprise the following:
362
Tentative estimate of weights in respect of complete hydro-
mechanical equipment as envisaged is worked out and presented Annexure
-6.12 in Annexure Volume-II. The weight estimates are based on standard
empirical formulae and also the hydro-mechanical works actually executed
by various State Government / agencies.
E. Dabdar dam:
i Spillway Radial Gates and Hoists
One set of sliding type stop logs has been envisaged to cater for
maintenance requirement of 4 nos. of dam spillway radial gates. The stop
log set for opening size of 15.0 m wide x 12.60 m high shall be fabricated in
six units with height of each unit 2100 mm i.e., one non- interchangeable
bottom unit and five nos. interchangeable units. The stop logs shall have
downstream skin plate and downstream sealing, fitted with sliding pads and
363
adequate structural members. The element is also fitted with side guide
rollers for guiding the elements under operation. The stop logs shall be
designed for head corresponding to FRL of EL 169.0 m (sill EL 156.73 m).
The stop log units shall be operated under balanced head condition by
means of a gantry crane of adequate capacity with the help of a lifting beam,
except the top unit, which shall be raised under unbalanced head condition.
Four elements are proposed to be stored in the storage bay and remaining
two elements shall be stored in right/left NOF section of dam when not in
use. The general installation of Spillway Stop log Gate is at Drawing No.
PTNL-5900-DBD-1502 (Plate No.6.118) in Volume –VIII (B).
The main items of control and equipment of Dabdar Dam Project shall
comprise the following:
364
One uninterruptible power supply (UPS) of suitable capacity to provide
back up (minimum 1 hour) to the system in case of failure of main power
supply to equipment shall also be provided.
F. Kelwan dam:
i) Spillway Radial Gates and Hoists
365
Gates shall confirm to IS: 4623-2000. The general installation of Spillway
Radial Gate is at Drawing No. PTNL-5900-KLD-1501 (Plate No.6.141 in
Volume –VIII (B)).
One set of sliding type stop logs has been envisaged to cater for
maintenance requirement of 5 nos. of dam spillway radial gates. The stop
log set for opening size of 15.0 m wide x 12.60 m high shall be fabricated in
six units with height of each unit 2100 mm i.e., one non- interchangeable
bottom unit and five nos. interchangeable units. The stop logs shall have
downstream skin plate and downstream sealing, fitted with sliding pads and
adequate structural members. The element is also fitted with side guide
rollers for guiding the elements under operation. The stop logs shall be
designed for head corresponding to FRL of EL 164.0 m (sill EL 151.82 m).
The stop log units shall be operated under balanced head condition by
means of a gantry crane of adequate capacity with the help of a lifting beam,
except the top unit, which shall be raised under unbalanced head condition.
Four elements are proposed to be stored in the storage bay and remaining
two elements shall be stored in right/left NOF section of dam when not in
use. The general installation of Spillway Stop log Gate is at Drawing No.
PTNL-5900-KLD-1502 (Plate No.6.142 in Volume –VIII (B)).
366
iv) Instruments and Remote Control
i. To provide drainage way for water seeping through the u/s face of
the dam and from the foundation,
ii. To provide space for drilling holes and grouting the foundation in
order to provide a grout curtain,
iii. To provide access to the interior of the dam for observing its
behaviour after completion, and
iv. To provide access to chambers like Hoist chamber, Pump
chamber, Sump well, Instrument niches etc.
The water stop shall be installed as per IS 12200.No block out shall
be left around water stop. The water stop shall be raised along with lifts of
concrete for the dam IS 15058 should be referred for specifications of PVC
water stops. Water stop details of Overflow and Non-overflow sections of
the six dams are shown in Drawing Nos. PTNL-5900-P-3047, 3050, 3053,
3007, 3012, 3027, 3032, 3067, 3070 and 3073 (Plates – 6.17, 6.13, 6.14,
6.40, 6.37, 6.63, 6.60, 6.87, 6.84and 6.83) in Volume –VIII (A) and Drawing
Nos. PTNL-5900-P-3087, 3090, 3093, 3107, 3110 and 3113 (Plates – 6.111,
6.108, 6.107, 6.135, 6.131and 6.132) in Volume –VIII (B),
368
200 mm dia. formed concrete drain (vertical) @ 3m c/c has been
provided in all 6 dams as per IS 10135-1985. Elevation of the joints of the
pipe joining the gallery with trap drain shall be suitably located in order to
have proper drainage.
For design of barrages complete set of data could not be collected due
to public hindrance at the project site, therefore suitable assumptions were
made while designing the barrages. No geological investigation / soil
investigation were carried out. Therefore it was assumed that competent
foundation strata of sufficient bearing capacity, is available at reasonable
depth to provide gravity type of barrage floor with independent pier
foundation.
Suitable head regulators for the control of flow in the canals are also
proposed on both the barrages. The details of head regulator and flared out
wall details of Paikhed and Chasmandva head regulator are at Drawing No.
PTNL-5900-P-2505 and 2510 (Plate No.6.232 and 6.241) in Volume –VIII
(B).
369
Barrage location has been finalized on the basis of FSL of canal off
taking from Barrage, topography etc. Paikhed and Chasmandva barrages
are located on the D/S of Paikhed Dam and Chasmandva Dam respectively.
The river reach is straight at these locations and the banks are well defined.
The area on either flank of barrage (bank side) shall be developed to suitable
elevation so that water is safely contained in the barrage pondage. General
layout plans and detailed layout plans of Paikhed and Chasmandva barrages
are at Drawing No. PTNL-5900-P-2501, 2502, 2506 and 2507 (Plate
No.6.228, 6.229, 6.237 and 6.238) in Volume –VIII (B).
Paikhed barrage has been designed for 1:100 design flood i.e. 2223
cumecs and free board has been checked for discharge corresponding to 1 in
500 years (3606 cumecs). Due to proximity of dam on upstream, free board
has been checked for PMF (5307 cumecs) as well. The top of pier and
abutments were kept at 152.00 m.
B) Chasmandva Barrage
370
excavation, provision shall be made for keeping the work area dry by well
point system of pumping.
Silt factor is required to access the depth of scour. In the present case
as barrage is founded on RBM, till specific values are obtained silt factor
value has been taken as 1.
Pond levels were fixed based on the FSL of off taking canals. Pond
levels adopted in case of Paikhed and Chasmandva Barrages are 143.50 m
and 131.00 m respectively.
371
6.3.8 Energy Dissipation Arrangement
To dissipate the energy of water coming out from the barrage spillway
so that it may not cause excessive scour immediately downstream of
barrage, a stilling basin type arrangement has been proposed. Dimensions
(i.e. depth and length) of stilling basin are best determined on the basis of
model studies. However as per relevant provisions of IS 6966, calculations
are made to determine the cistern level and length of stilling basin such that
the hydraulic jump formed under various possible flow conditions, is
contained within the stilling basin.
Seven (7) nos. of spillway radial gate of size 15.0 m wide x 7.0 m
high shall be provided to control the discharge through gated portion of
barrage. The sill of the gate is located at EL 136.0 m. The radial gates are
designed for the head of 14 m corresponding to Upper Pond Level of
EL 150.0 m. The gates can be operated under water head between sill levels
of EL 136 m to Upper pond level of EL 150.0 m.
The water load on the gate is transferred from gate leaf structure
through radial arms to trunnion bracket and finally to concrete piers through
anchorage arrangement. The anchorage will be designed to cater to the loads
imposed due to gate being at any position at different water heads.
372
Each gate will be operated by means of 160 t capacity (2 x 80 t)
(tentative) twin hydraulic hoists mounted on cardanic supports. The general
installation of Barrage Spillway Radial Gate is at Drawing No. PTNL-5900-
PKB-1501 (Plate No.6.233) in Volume –VIII (B).
Fixed wheel vertical lift gate (Eight nos.) for opening size 12.0m
wide x 8.0m high shall be provided to control the discharge through gated
portion of barrage. Each gate shall be operated under unbalanced head
condition by means of electrically operated rope drum hoist of 60t capacity
(Tentative), mounted on Hoist Bridge, supported on trestles fixed on top of
pier EL133.0m.
The sill of the gate is located at EI 123.0 m. The gates are designed
for the head corresponding to Pond Level of EL 131.0 m and checked for
affluxed HFL of 131.456m. The gates can be operated under water head
between EI 131.456 m to EI 123.0 m. Gates shall be stored/ maintained
above top of pier EL 133.0m.The general installation of Barrage Spillway
Radial Gate is at Drawing No. PTNL-5900-CHB-1501 (Plate No.6.242) in
Volume –VIII (B).
373
level of EL 150.0 m (sill EL 136.0 m). Each stop log units is provided with
d/s skin plate and d/s sealing arrangement with music note type Teflon
cladded side seal and wedge type rubber seal at the bottom shall be
provided.
The salient features of Paikhed barrage Spillway Stop log Gate are
furnished at Annexure – 6.21 in Annexure Volume-II.
374
a gantry crane of 25t capacity (Tentative) traveling on barrage spillway
bridge on top of piers EL 133.0 m, with the help of one set of lifting beam
of adequate capacity with automatic engaging/disengaging device. The stop
log units shall be stored in the stop log grooves when not in use. The general
installation of Chasmandva Barrage Spillway Stop log Gate is at Drawing
No. PTNL-5900-CHB-1502 (Plate No.6.243) in Volume –VIII (B).
375
The remote control system which is microprocessor controlled based
shall consist of one operator station located at top of Paikhed and
Chasmandva Barrages and shall be supplemented by an indication status
stations at powerhouse control room.
376
hydro-mechanical works actually executed by various State Government /
agencies.
Table – 6.28
Salient Features of Barrages
Sr. Description Paikhed Barrage Chasmandva
No. Barrage
1 Design Flood 2223 cumecs 1571 cumecs
Discharge
2 Total Length 68.320 m 63.350 m
3 Total Waterway 138.500 m 122.000 m
4 Top level of 152.000 m 133.000 m
pier/abut.
5 Crest Level 136.000 m 123.000 m
377
6 Cistern Level 131.500 m 118.500 m
7 Pond Level 143.500 m/ 150.00 m 131.000 m
8 HFL (1 in 100) 140.529 m 127.446 m
9 HFL (1 in 500) 141.936 m 128.240 m
10 Width of Pier 4.500 m 3.000 m
11 Clear Width of 15.000 m 12.000 m
each span
One set of wheel type stop logs of size 3.0 m x 10.05 m (over all
height) for spillway (consisting of 3 units of 3.35 m high each) is proposed.
Each unit shall be 3.0 m x 3.35 m. The units of stop logs shall be
interchangeable with the openings of barrage spillway. These units shall be
designed for maximum water head corresponding to Upper Pond level of EL
150.0 m (sill EL 140.0 m). Each stop log units is provided with u/s skin
plate and u/s sealing arrangement with music note type Teflon cladded side
seal and wedge type rubber seal at the bottom. Balanced head shall be
created by crack opening of top unit.
The stop logs units shall be lowered and lifted under balanced head
conditions and shall be operated by means of a monorail crane of 12t
capacity (tentative), with automatic engaging/disengaging device. The stop
logs units shall be stored at top of pier at EL 152.0m through suitable
378
latches. The general installation of Stop logs for Head Regulator Service
Gate is at Drawing No. PTNL-5900-PKB-1504 (Plate No.6.236) in Volume
–VIII (B).
Head regulators with 3 bays, 3.0 m wide each are proposed. Identical
vertical lift type fixed wheel service gate in each bay for opening size of
3.0m wide x 1.0m high, are proposed to control the discharge in canals. Sill
level is 130.0 m. The gate shall be designed for water head corresponding
Pond level EL 131.0m. These gates will be operated by means of rope drum
hoist of 5t capacity (Tentative) mounted on steel bridge supported on trestles
above top of pier. These gates will be closed when water rises above pond
level of 131.0m.The general installation of Head Regulator Service Gate is
at Drawing No. PTNL-5900-CHB-1503 (Plate No.6.244) in Volume –VIII
(B).
379
The Jheri and Paikhed reservoirs are proposed to be linked by 12.70
km long concrete lined tunnel of 3.0m diameter (D- shaped) and water
carrying capacity of 11.60 cumecs.
The alignment of the link tunnel and one construction adit has been
finalized by CWC on the basis of contour maps and data supplied by
NWDA. The general Layout plans of the tunnel, Alternative and Final are
at Drawing Nos. PTNL-5900-DPR-1001 and 1002 (Plate Nos. 6.143 and
144) of Volume – VIII (B).
The layout and hydraulic design of the link tunnel has been carried
out for conveying 11.60 cumecs of water from Jheri to Paikhed reservoir.
The size and the slope of the link tunnel have been worked out for supplying
the design discharge under all possible combinations of water levels at the
linked reservoirs under pressure flow conditions. The value of Manning’s
coefficient adopted for design varies from 0.012 to 0.016 for the concrete
lined tunnel.
a. The minor losses occurring in the link tunnel e.g. entrance losses,
trash rack loss, transition loss, exit loss; bend losses, gate groove
losses, etc. are of negligible amount in comparison to the friction
losses occurring in the link tunnels and therefore not taken into
consideration.
b. The flow through the tunnel is under pressure and driven by the head
difference between the upper and lower reservoirs linked through
tunnel
c. The gates installed at the intake and outfall of link tunnels are meant
for regulating the discharge as well as for maintenance purpose.
The sizes of the link tunnels have been worked out in two steps:
380
STEP- I Different range of tunnel diameter are tried under maximum and
minimum driving head between the linked reservoirs by adopting
maximum and minimum value of Manning’s coefficient with
envisaged value of diversion discharge. This gives a range of
tunnel sizes capable of carrying the design discharge which is
found by equating the major friction losses occurring in the
system with the driving head under all possible heads. Different
shapes of the tunnel were also considered.
STEP- II The tunnel diameter is then fixed on the basis of values obtained
from STEP- I. The adequacy of tunnel for its discharge capacity
is checked under all prevailing head conditions by adopting
maximum and minimum value of manning’s coefficient under all
driving heads. The major friction losses are equated with the
driving head to know the discharging capacity of tunnel under all
possible variation of head.
The layout of the intake structure has been planned based on the
geological and topographical data received from NWDA and the alignment
of Jheri to Paikhed Link Tunnel. The intake structure is designed, so as to
produce an adequate acceleration of water from reservoir into the link
tunnel. This is achieved by means of smooth entrance at the intake having
elliptical bell mouth shape and also by placing intake below the minimum
reservoir level for ensuring optimum submergence to avoid formation of
vortices. Metallic trash racks are provided in front of intake structure to
prevent entry of floating debris into the system. The water flows at a small
velocity through trash rack provided in the front of intake structure. The
center to center spacing between the trash bars is provided as 100mm.
381
Submergence of the intake centre line, below the minimum reservoir
level (MDDL) has been checked as per the provisions of IS-9761: 1995. The
hydraulic design of the intake, its dimensioning and sizing has also been
carried out as per the provisions of IS-9761:1995.
Adit
Q value Classification
100-40 Very Good
40-10 Good
10-4 Fair
4-1 Poor
1-0.1 Very Poor
383
The rock support system may need appropriate modifications
depending upon the actual rock mass encountered. Also, the design of rock
support system is not meant for shear zones, weak zones, cavities and very
low cover zones at junctions with adits /vertical shafts, etc. of the tunnel
and the design in these zones require special consideration. Further, the
design of the tunnel is valid for full face excavation of tunneling with
conventional drill and blast method (DBM). The typical excavation and
rock support system is shown in Drawing No. PTNL-5900-DPR-1006
(Plate Nos. 6.148) of Volume – VIII (B).
For discharge of water at the end of the tunnel from Jheri to Paikhed
Reservoir, an out fall structure has been provided keeping in view the
topography and geology at the outfall location of Paikhed Reservoir. A
control gate shaft upstream of the outfall structure has been provided with
provisions of Service and Emergency gates.
384
6.4.6 Hydro-Mechanical Equipment for Jheri-Paikhed Tunnel
Fixed wheel type gate (one no) for opening size of 3.0 m wide x 3.0
m high shall be provided at Jheri reservoir Intake. The sill of the gate is
located at EL 199.50 m. The gate is to be designed for a head corresponding
to FRL 246.0 m and operated under unbalanced head condition. The gate
shall have downstream skin plate and downstream sealing. The gate shall be
operated by means of double acting hydraulic hoist of 50 t capacity
(Tentative). Power pack of hydraulic hoist shall be located at the top of pier
at EL 248.0 m. Maintenance chamber shall be provided at EL 207.00 m. The
salient features of the Service Gate are at Annexure – 6.29 in Annexure
Volume-II.
385
The salient features of the Emergency Gate are at Annexure – 6.30 in
Annexure Volume-II.
Fixed wheel type gate (one no) for opening size of 3.0 m wide x 3.0
m high shall be provided at Paikhed reservoir outfall. The sill of the gate is
located at EL 185.0 m. The gate is to be designed for a head corresponding
to FRL 248.0 m and operated under unbalanced head condition. The gate
shall have downstream skin plate and downstream sealing. The gate shall be
operated by means of double acting hydraulic hoist of 70 t capacity
(Tentative). Power pack of hydraulic hoist shall be located at the top of pier
at EL 250.0 m. Maintenance chamber shall be provided at EL 194.0m.The
salient features of the Service Gate are at Annexure – 6.31 in Annexure
Volume-II.
386
Paikhed Link Tunnel and shall be supplemented by an indication status
stations at powerhouse control room.
387
Detailed estimate of weights in respect of complete hydro-
mechanical equipment as envisaged is worked out and is at Annexure – 6.33
in Annexure Volume-II. The tentative weight estimates are based on
standard empirical formulae and also the hydro-mechanical works actually
executed by various State government / agencies.
6.5 Canals
In planing and design of Canal systems of Par-Tapi-Narmada link project
both Open canal and Underground pipe line systems are studied to minimise
the Land requirement for canal construction. It was opined that replacing the
Main canal by the pipe line system is not viable, techno-economically, due
to the topographical constraints. Hence, it is decided to replace the four
Feeder canals that were planned in the DPR of PTN link project by
Pipelines.
i) Feeder Pipe lines: There are three main feeder Pipe line emanating from
Chasmandva Barrage, Tail Race Channels of Dabdar Dam power House
and Kelwan Dam Power House feeding main canal in Par to Tapi reach.
The lengths of these feeder Pipe line are 2.859 km, 12.258 km, and 7.62
km respectively.
388
ii) One interlinking feeder Pipe line connecting Chikkar Dam and Dabdar
Dam reservoirs to transfer 6.46 Cumecs of discharge from Chikkar Dam
to Dabdar Dam. This feeder Pipe line is of 14.342 km length.
6.5.3 Tunnels:
To avoid lengthy traverse of canal and heavy cutting, Five D- shaped, lined
tunnels are proposed in the Par-Tapi reach of the reach of Par–Tapi –
Narmada link canal. The details of these tunnels are as follows;
389
command area of State Government proposed projects, enroute command
on left side of link canal by gravity and right side of link canal by lift, the
capacity of the canal becomes 63.69 cumecs at the tail before falling in
Ukai, after traversing a length of 177.736 km in first reach, i.e Par-Tapi-
Reach.
The alignment of the proposed Par –Tapi link canal and feeders Pipe
line, finalized on the basis of field surveys have been marked on toposheets.
Canal was aligned as contour canal. The canal off take with FSL of 142.800
m from Head Regulator at Paikhed Barrage. Thereafter the Chasmandva
feeder Pipe line which off takes from Chasmandva barrage at FSL of
130.600 m joins the main canal at RD 62.072 km at FSL of 129.244 m.
Similarly, the Dabdar feeder Pipe line which off takes from the main
dam at FSL 136.960 m joins the main canal at RD 108.25 km at FSL of
119.217 m and Kelwan feeder Pipe line, also off taking from main dam at
FSL 135.46 m joins the main canal at RD 129.600 km at FSL of 114.418 m.
In view of the fact that the FRL of the terminal reservoir at Ukai is
RL 105.150 m and that the length of the Par-Tapi canal is about 177.736 km,
the off take level at Paikhed Barrage has been kept at RL142.800 m thereby
giving working head of 38.35 m . The bed gradient of the Main canal from
Par to Tapi is different from reach to reach and it varies from 1 in 7,500 to 1
in 8500.
390
The main canal has to cross the ridges between various basins and
sub-basins where in deep cuts are involved and also to cross many rivers
and streams requiring construction of cross drainage works. Five tunnels of
have been proposed to avoid circuitous route and deep cutting.
For feeders Pipe lines the off take levels are considered keeping in
view the corresponding FSL of main canal where the feeder pipe line joins
the link. Economy in case of feeder pipe lines from Dam/ Barrage of
Chikkar and Chasmandva diversion points and MDDL at off take diversion
point for feeder pipe lines from Kelwan and Dabdar has been kept in view.
The Par-Tapi-Narmada link canal is predominantly contour canal and
traverses a total length of 369.043 km. In the first reach of 177.736 km,
canal off takes from Head regulator of Paikhed Barrage and falls into Ukai
reservoir in second reach of canal of 191.310 km off takes from Ukai
Reservoir and outfalls into Miyagam branch canal of Narmada main canal.
It crosses several streams, minor/major Rivers and several roads and railway
lines. Each reach has different slope and cross section elements. The
alignment has been marked on the strip survey contour sheet for every 3.0
km along with the corresponding longitudinal section. Total 136 No of
sheets for canal alignment have been prepared. Following data has been
provided as Longitudinal Section table with every Drawing:
1 CHAINAGE R.D (metre)
2 NSL
3 Canal Bed Level
4 Bed Slope (nH:1V)
5 Design Discharge (Cumecs)
6 FSL
7 FSD
8 Bed Width
9 Head Loss (CD Structure)
10 Side Slope
11 Free Board
12 Canal Top Level
13 Depth of Cutting
14 Depth of Filling
391
All the 136 sheets containing the L.S. and strip contour maps of Par-
Tapi-Narmada link canal are given as PTNL-5900-P-2515 to 2650 (Plate
Nos. 6.250 to 6.385 in Volume-VIII (C)). The alignment consists of straight
lines and circular curves as per Clause 6.4 of IS 5968: ‘Guidelines for
planning and layout of canal system’. The range of radius are given in a
table below.
Accordingly effort was made to keep all the curves in the Par-Tapi-
Narmada link canals within specified limits of 200 to 300 m. But due to
hilly terrain in initial reaches it was practically not possible to comply with
these limits as such curves of smaller radius, than depicted above, have also
been introduced at such reaches; however canal bed has to be super elevated
on those curves.
392
in canal bed. Typical details of canal lining and drainage arrangement under
the lining are shown in Drawing Nos.PTNL-5900-P-2513 and 2514 (Plate
No.6.248 and 6.249) in Volume-VIII (C).
6.5.1.6 Shape
393
effort was made to make the canal section as hydraulically efficient as
possible. Therefore trapezoidal lined canal with rounded corners was
provided to improve hydraulic radius of section. Longitudinal slopes for
canal were targeted to be around 1 in 8000 however other factors like
topography, available head between various reaches and expected head
losses due to canal and various cross drainage structures along the length of
canal were deciding factors in finalizing the slopes.
394
The full supply depth of main canal is 2.800 m in Par-Tapi reach and
2.65 m to 3.22 m in Tapi – Narmada reach. The free board of 0.75 m and
0.600 m are provided as per IS code 10430-1982. Effort was made to keep
ratio of bed width to depth within 2 to 8.
In Par – Tapi reach the section of canal at head is 8.5 X 2.8 m and at
tail end is 16.5 X 2.80 m, while in Tapi – Narmada reach the section at head
is 8.8 X 3.22 m and at tail end is 5.0 X 2.65 m. Typical sections for canal in
full cutting, partial banking and partial cutting and full banking are given in
the drawing Nos. PTNL-5900-P-2511and 2512 (Plate No.6.246 and 6.247)
in Volume-VIII (C).
395
Where:
V= Mean velocity in meters per second
n = Mannings coefficient of roughness
R = Hydraulic radius in meters ( The cross-sectional area of flow divided by
the wetted perimeter)
S = Hydraulic slope in meters per meter. This is the indication of the loss of
head in system.
Q = Quantity of flow in cubic meters per second
A = Cross-sectional area of flow in square meters
396
1 circular segment height
2 central angle
7 hydraulic radius
397
Hydraulic details of Feeder Pipe line
398
6.5.1.8 Canal Operation
The main Canal and feeder Pipe lines will be in operation throughout
the year with a peak discharge of 63.69 cumec.
399
6.5.2.1.2 Cross Drainage
Aqueducts have been proposed along the link canal at the crossings of
major streams where the bed level of the link canal is above the highest
flood level of the drain. 37 aqueducts and 3 culverts are proposed in Par-
Tapi portion and 36 aqueducts and 13 culverts are proposed in Tapi-
Narmada portion. Actually small drainages were not delineated in the map
available in Par to Tapi Reach as such all the structures are termed as
aqueducts in this reach. Loss of head of 140 mm (52 mm in Tapi to
Narmada reach) is assumed at each aqueduct. Though head loss in aqueduct
mainly depend upon the length and fluming adopted, more the length and
fluming more is the head loss. Therefore in initial three reaches of Par to
Tapi link where the base width of canal are 5.5 m, 8.5 m and 15.0 m
respectively aqueducts is not flumed to preserve valuable head at the cost of
structure , but in the last reach where the canal width is 21.800 m fluming is
resorted to achieve economy in cost of structure.
400
(B) Cross Regulators
401
(F) Canal Syphons
(G) Escapes
(I) Falls
402
canal and main canal as Residual head was available in all the feeder canals
after finalizing the longitudinal slope of these canals.
Five dam toe power houses and one canal power house have been
planned in Par –Tapi- Narmada link project as mentioned below.
403
Say 21 MW
The design of hydel civil components (six power houses) are based on
limited/ preliminary data available in the form of topographical maps,
geological investigation, power potential studies, electro-mechanical drawings
and feasibility reports. Detailed investigations could not be carried out due to
public hindrance at the project sites. Layout of the power houses designs needs
to be confirmed after carrying out detailed investigations and topographical
survey.
A surface Power house of size 45.32m (L) x 16.43m (W) x 93.0m (H) has
been provided to house three numbers of horizontal Frances turbines of
3000KW each. The centre line of the machine has been kept at elevation
EL.164.40m. The structure comprises of RCC columns and beams designed to
carry the loads due to various electro-mechanical equipment.
The location of surface power house has been selected by studying the
limited contour details available as no site visit could be made to ascertain the
suitability of the strata. Hence the Power House location shall be confirmed
after site inspection and in consultation with geologist.
The Power House plan at EL. 167.92 m and Cross Section are shown
in Drawing Nos.PTNL-5900-DPR-2010 and 2011 (Plate Nos. 6.165 and
6.166) in Volume VIII (B).
The main penstock of 2.5m diameter trifurcates thrice near the power
house into three units penstocks of 1.6m diameter each to lead the water to
three generating units house in surface power house. The water from the
draft tube is lead back to river through an open tail race channel. Three draft
tubes with separate gates have been provided
The power potential study has been carried out by THDC India Ltd.
The rated discharge through each unit of the power house is 7.4 cumec. The
design head is 56.53m. The installed capacity proposed for this power house
is 9000 KW comprising of 3units each of 3000 KW with 20% COL. The
turbine is of horizontal Francis turbine.
The main components of the scheme comprise of:
i) Intake Structure
ii) Pressure shaft / Penstock
405
iii) Surface Power House
iv) Tail Race Channel
After the bell mouth intake and gate structure, a transition has been
provided from rectangular [1.8m (w) x 2.5m(l)] to circular (2.5m dia). The
steel penstock of 2.5m dia, starting from the point, has been embedded in
the dam body for about 25 m and beyond this, steel lined pressure shaft of
2.5 m dia has been provided upto the power house. Pressure shaft is
provided with 300 mm thick PCC (M25) grade backfill concrete with steel
liner. The lining has been designed to resist full external and internal water
pressure including water hammer. The pressure tunnel is proposed to be
excavated by conventional drill and blast method (DBM) and the design of
rock support system is carried out using Barton’s Q method.
Q value Classification
100-40 Very Good
40-10 Good
10-4 Fair
4-1 Poor
1-0.1 Very Poor
406
The penstock (2.5m dia) is trifurcated twice near the power house into
three branch penstocks (1.6 m dia) for feeding water to three turbines. The
steel for penstock is IS-2002(grade 3) and the thickness of steel is 16mm for
2.5mdia and 14mm for 1.6m dia. Typical excavation and rock support
details, Typical concrete lining and grouting details, Penstock steel lining
details and Penstock steel lining ferrule details are shown in Drawing Nos.
PTNL-5900-DPR-2006, 2007, 2008 and 2009 (Plate Nos. 6.161, 6.162,
6.163 and 6.164) in Volume VIII (B) respectively.
The water is led back into Nar River through an open tail race
channel provided after the tail race pool (RCC) of 26.0 m wide. The bottom
slope of the tail race pool has been provided with a gradient of 1(V): 4.0(H)
sloping upwards up to its meting point of the tail race pool /river, as the tail
race channel needs to be suitably provided to join the river based on the
actual site conditions.
Fixed wheel type gate (one no) for opening size of 1.8 m wide x 2.5
m high shall be provided at the downstream of the Intake having bell mouth
shape with elliptical profile. The sill of the gate is located at EL 185.0 m.
The gate is to be designed for a head corresponding to FRL 248.0 m and
operated under unbalanced head condition. The gate shall have downstream
skin plate and downstream sealing. The gate shall be operated by means of
double acting hydraulic hoist of 50 t (tentative) capacity. Power pack of
hydraulic hoist shall be located at the top of pier at EL 255.0 m. General
installation of Power Intake service gate is shown in Drawing No.PTNL-
5900-PKPH-1501 (Plate Nos. 6.167 in Volume VIII (B)).
407
For maintenance of power intake service gate, a fixed wheel type
emergency gate of 1.8 m wide x 2.5 m wide is proposed. This gate shall be
operated under balanced head condition created by crack opening. The gate
shall be capable of lowering in flowing water condition in case of any
emergency. The gate shall be operated by means of double acting hydraulic
hoist of adequate capacity.
Slide type gates (three nos.) have been envisaged at the draft tube
structure on the tailrace side. The clear opening is 4.02 m wide x 2.30 m
high. The gates shall be designed for a head corresponding to average tail
water level of 172.0 m and checked for water level corresponding to
maximum flood level 174.0 m (sill EL 159.40 m).
A surface Power house of size 32.70m (L) x 13.90m (W) x 19.6m (H)
has been provided to house two numbers of horizontal Francis turbines of
1000KW each. The centre line of the machine has been kept at elevation
EL.171.02m. The structure comprises of RCC columns and beams designed
to bear the loads coming from various electro-mechanical equipment.
408
The location of Surface Power House has been selected by studying
the limited contour details available as no site visit could be made to
ascertain the suitability of the strata. Hence the Power House location shall
be confirmed after site inspection and in consultation with geologist. The
Power House plan at EL. 175.12 m, Cross Section and Longitudinal Section
are shown in Drawing Nos.PTNL-5900-DPR-3009, 3010 and 3011 (Plate
Nos. 6.177, 6.178 and 6.179) in Volume VIII (B).
A Dam toe Surface Power House is planned on the right bank of Tan
River. The intake structure is provided adjacent to the main spillway also
termed as “Power Block”. The power block monolith accommodates an
intake structure and a steel penstock (main) of 1.8m dia laid within the body
of the spillway. The penstock emanates horizontally from the intake
structure and after two vertical bends it reaches EL.169.93m to meet the
turbine center line of EL.171.02m. The main penstock of 1.8m diameter
bifurcates near the power house into two unit penstocks of 1.2m diameter
each to lead the water to two generating units in surface power house. The
water from the draft tube is lead back to river through an open tail race
channel. Two draft tubes with separate gates have been provided. The
general layout plan of Power House, both alternative and final alignments,
409
layout plan of water conductor system are shown in Drawing Nos. PTNL-
5900-DPR-3001, 3002 and 3003 (Plate Nos. 6.169, 6.170 and 6.171) in
Volume VIII (B).
The power potential study has been carried out by THDC India Ltd.
The rated discharge through each unit of the power house is 3.64 m³ /sec.
The design head is 32.78 m. The installed capacity for this power house is
2000 KW comprising of 2 units each of 1000 KW of horizontal Francis
turbine.
i) Intake Structure
ii) Penstock
iii) Surface Power House
iv) Tail Race Channel
6.6.2.2 Penstock
The steel penstock of 1.8 m dia has been provided in the dam body.
The penstock is bifurcated into two branch penstocks of 1.2m dia for
feeding water to individual turbines. The penstock is designed to withstand
maximum internal pressure including pressure rise due to water hammer.
410
The steel for penstock is IS-2002(grade 3) and the thickness of steel is
12mm. Trash rack details, Penstock steel lining details and Penstock steel
lining ferrule details are shown in Drawing Nos. PTNL-5900-DPR-3006,
3007 and 3008 (Plate Nos. 6.174, 6.175 and 6.176) in Volume VIII (B)
respectively.
The water is led back into the Tan River through an open tail race
channel (5m wide) excavated along its alignment. The bottom slope of the
tail race pool has been provided with a gradient of 1(V): 4.5(H) sloping
upwards upto its meeting point of tail race channel.
Fixed wheel type gate (one no.) for opening size of 1.42 m wide x 1.8
m high shall be provided at the downstream of the Intake having bell mouth
shape with elliptical profile. The sill of the gate is located at EL 185.50 m.
The gate is to be designed for a head corresponding to FRL 214.0 m and
operated under unbalanced head condition. The gate shall have downstream
skin plate and downstream sealing. The gate shall be operated by means of
double acting hydraulic hoist of 25 t (Tentative) capacity. Power pack of
hydraulic hoist shall be located at the top of pier at EL 222.0 m. General
installation of Power Intake service gate is shown in Drawing No.PTNL-
5900-CHPH-1501 (Plate Nos. 6.180 in Volume VIII (B)).
411
6.6.2.5 Draft Tube Gates
Slide type gates (two nos.) have been envisaged at the draft tube
structure on the tailrace side. The clear opening is 3.40 m wide x 2.34 m
high. The gates shall be designed for a head corresponding to average tail
water level of 173.02 m (sill EL166.51 m) and checked for water level
corresponding to maximum flood level 175.12 m.
The power potential study has been carried out by THDC India Ltd.
The rated discharge through each unit of the power house is 4.97 m³ /sec.
The design head is 27.47m. The installed capacity proposed for this power
house is 1800 KW comprising 2 units 900 KW each. The turbine is
horizontal Francis type.
413
i) Intake Structure
ii) Penstock
iii) Surface Power House
iv) Tail Race Channel
6.6.3.2 Penstock
The steel penstock of 1.8 m dia has been provided in the dam body.
The penstock is bifurcated into two branch penstocks of 1.2m dia for
feeding water to individual turbines. The penstock is designed to withstand
maximum internal pressure including pressure rise due to water hammer.
The steel for penstock is IS-2002(grade 3) and the thickness of steel is
12mm. Penstock steel lining details and Penstock steel lining ferrule details
are shown in Drawing Nos. PTNL-5900-DPR-4006 and 4007 (Plate Nos.
6.187 and6.188) in Volume VIII (B) respectively.
Fixed wheel type gate (one no) for opening size of 1.42 m wide x 1.8
m high shall be provided at the downstream of the Intake having bell mouth
shape with elliptical profile. The sill of the gate is located at EL 174.50 m.
The gate is to be designed for a head corresponding to FRL 210.0 m and
operated under unbalanced head condition. The gate shall have downstream
skin plate and downstream sealing. The gate shall be operated by means of
double acting hydraulic hoist of 30 t (Tentative) capacity. Power pack of
hydraulic hoist shall be located at the top of pier at EL 217.0 m. General
installation of Power Intake service gate is shown in Drawing No.PTNL-
5900-CKPH-1501 (Plate Nos. 6.192) in Volume VIII (B).
Slide type gates (two nos.) have been envisaged at the draft tube
structure on the tailrace side. The clear opening is 3.4 m wide x 2.34 m
high. The gates shall be designed for a head corresponding to average tail
water level of 171.50 m (sill EL 164.28 m).
415
171.80 m. General installation of Draft Tube Gate is shown in Drawing
No.PTNL-5900-CKPH-1502 (Plate Nos. 6.193 in Volume VIII (B)).
416
13 Type of turbine Horizontal Francis
14 Normal tail water level EL.136.96m
15 Minimum tail water level EL.134.00m
i) Intake Structure
ii) Penstock
iii) Surface Power House
iv) Tail Race Channel
417
vortices and the entry of air into the water conductor system. For
minimizing the losses, the profile of the intake roof and sides have been
streamlined and bell mouth entry has been provided. After the gate a
transition from rectangular [(2.0m (w)x2.5m (h)] to circular ( 2.5m dia) has
been provided. The plan and section of Intake and Trash rack details (metal
work) are shown in Drawing Nos. PTNL-5900-DPR-5003 and 5004 (Plate
Nos. 6.196 and 6.197) in Volume VIII (B).
6.6.4.2 Penstock
The steel penstock of 2.5 m dia has been provided in the dam body.
The penstock is bifurcated into two branch penstocks of 1.6m dia for
feeding water to individual turbines. The penstock is designed to withstand
maximum internal pressure including pressure rise due to water hammer.
The steel for penstock is IS-2002(grade 3) and the thickness of steel is
14mm (for 2.5 m dia.) and 12mm (for 1.6 m dia.). Penstock steel lining
details and Penstock steel lining ferrule details are shown in Drawing Nos.
PTNL-5900-DPR-5005 and 5006 (Plate Nos. 6.198 and 6.199) in Volume
VIII (B) respectively.
The water will be lead in to Dabdar Feeder canal to join the Link
Canal through an open tail race channel 5.0m wide excavated along its
alignment. The bottom slope of the tail race pool has been provided with an
approximate gradient of 1(V): 4.0(H) sloping upwards up to its meeting
point with the Feeder.
Fixed wheel type gate (one no.) for opening size of 2.0 m wide x 2.5
m high shall be provided at the downstream of the Intake having bell mouth
shape with elliptical profile. The sill of the gate is located at EL 134.37 m.
The gate is to be designed for a head corresponding to FRL 169.0 m and
operated under unbalanced head condition. The gate shall have downstream
skin plate and downstream sealing. The gate shall be operated by means of
double acting hydraulic hoist of 30t (Tentative) capacity. Power pack of
418
hydraulic hoist shall be located at the top of pier at EL 177.0 m. General
installation of Power Intake service gate is shown in Drawing No.PTNL-
5900-DBPH-1501 (Plate Nos. 6.203) in Volume VIII (B).
Slide type gates (two nos.) have been envisaged at the draft tube
structure on the tailrace side. The clear opening is 5.10 m wide x 2.34 m
high. The gates shall be designed for a head corresponding to average tail
water level of EL 136.96 m (sill EL 132.19 m).
A Dam toe Surface Power House is planned on the left bank of Purna
River downstream of Kelwan Dam. The intake structure is provided
adjacent to the main spillway also termed as “Power Block”. The power
block monolith accommodates an intake structure and a steel penstock
(main) of 2.5 m dia laid within the body of the dam spillway. The penstock
emanates horizontally from the intake structure with centre line elevation of
EL.134.62 m. The centre line of machine is EL. 135.70 m. The main
penstock of 2.5 m diameter bifurcates near the power house into two branch
420
penstocks of 1.6 m diameter each to lead the water to two turbines. The
water from the draft tube is lead back in to Kelwan Feeder Canal through an
open tail race channel (5m wide). Two draft tubes with separate gates have
been provided. The general layout plan of Power House and L-Section of
water conductor system are shown in Drawing Nos. PTNL-5900-DPR-6001
and 6002 (Plate Nos. 6.205 and 6.206) in Volume VIII (B).
The power potential study has been carried out by THDC India Ltd.
The rated discharge through each unit of the power house is 7.72 m³ /sec.
The design head is 22.16 m. The installed capacity for this power house is
2500 KW comprising of 2 units of 1250 KW each. The turbine is horizontal
Francis type.
i) Intake Structure
ii) Penstock
iii) Surface Power House
iv) Tail Race Channel
6.6.5.2 Penstock
The steel penstock of 2.5 m dia has been provided in the dam body.
The penstock is bifurcated into two branch penstocks of 1.6 m dia for
421
feeding water to individual turbines. The penstock is designed to withstand
maximum internal pressure including pressure rise due to water hammer.
The steel for penstock is IS-2002(grade 3) and the thickness of steel is
14mm (for 2.5 m dia.) and 12mm (for 1.6 m dia.). Penstock steel lining
details and Penstock steel lining ferrule details are shown in Drawing Nos.
PTNL-5900-DPR-6005 and 6006 (Plate Nos. 6.209 and 6.210) in Volume
VIII (B) respectively.
After power generation the water is led back into the feeder canal
through an open tail race channel 5.0 m wide excavated along its alignment.
The bottom slope of the tail race pool has been provided with an
approximate gradient of 1(V): 4.0(H) sloping upwards upto its meeting
point of the feeder canal.
Fixed wheel type gate (one no.) for opening size of 1.8 m wide x 2.5
m high shall be provided at the downstream of the Intake having bell mouth
shape with elliptical profile. The sill of the gate is located at EL 133.37 m.
The gate is to be designed for a head corresponding to FRL 164.0 m and
operated under unbalanced head condition. The gate shall have downstream
skin plate and downstream sealing. The gate shall be operated by means of
double acting hydraulic hoist of 25 t (Tentative) capacity. Power pack of
hydraulic hoist shall be located at the top of pier at EL 174.0 m. General
installation of Power Intake service gate is shown in Drawing No.PTNL-
5900-KEPH-1501 (Plate Nos. 6.214) in Volume VIII (B).
422
hoist of adequate capacity. The salient features of Power Intake Emergency
Gate are at Annexure – 6.49 in Annexure Volume-II.
Slide type gates (two nos.) have been envisaged at the draft tube
structure on the tailrace side. The clear opening is 3.40 m wide x 2.34 m
high. The gates shall be designed for a head corresponding to average tail
water level of 135.46 m (sill EL 131.19 m).
The power potential study has been carried out by THDC India Ltd.
The rated discharge through each unit of the power house is 7.55 m³ /sec.
The design head is 15.97 m. The installed capacity for this power house is
2000 KW comprising of 2 units each of 1000 KW of vertical Kaplan turbine
type.
424
Necessary modification in the design and layout of proposed power
house on Kelwan feeder pipe line due to replacement of open feeder canal
by pipe line will be taken care at the construction stage.
6.6.6.2 Penstock
The steel penstock of 2.5 m dia has been provided in the dam body.
The penstock is bifurcated into two branch penstocks of 1.6 m dia for
feeding water to individual turbines. The penstock is designed to withstand
maximum internal pressure including pressure rise due to water hammer.
The steel for penstock is IS-2002 (grade 3) and the thickness of steel is 14
mm (for 2. 5 dia.) and 12 mm (for 1.6 m dia.). Penstock steel lining details
and Penstock steel lining ferrule details are shown in Drawing Nos. PTNL-
5900-DPR-7005 and 7006 (Plate Nos. 6.220 and 6.221) in Volume VIII (B)
respectively.
The water is led back to the feeder Pipe line after an open tail race
pool. The bottom slope of the tail race pool has been provided with an
approximate gradient of 1(V): 4.0(H) sloping upwards upto its meeting
point of the feeder canal.
425
6.6.6.4 Feeder Pipe line Power House Intake Service and Emergency
Gate
Fixed wheel type gate (one no.) for opening size of 2.0 m wide x 2.5
m high shall be provided at the downstream of the Intake having bell mouth
shape with elliptical profile. The sill of the gate is located at EL 127.80 m.
The gate is to be designed for a head corresponding to FSL 133.94 m and
operated under unbalanced head condition. The gate shall have downstream
skin plate and downstream sealing. The gate shall be operated by means of
rope drum hoist of adequate capacity. Provision of removable guide shall be
made in trestles, when not in use. The gate shall be stored at deck level EL
135.00 m supported by dogging beam. General installation of Power Intake
service gate is shown in Drawing No.PTNL-5900-KFCPH-1501 (Plate Nos.
6.225) in Volume VIII (B).
Salient features of Power Intake Service Gate are at Annexure – 6.51
in Annexure Volume-II.
Slide type gates (two nos.) have been envisaged at the draft tube
structure on the tailrace side. The clear opening is 2.652 m wide x 1.50 m
high. The gates shall be designed for a head corresponding to average tail
water level of 117.77 m (sill EL 112.271 m).
426
The gate shall be lifted under balanced head conditions created by
filling valve. The gate shall be operated by means of independent rope
drum hoist of 10t (Tentative) capacity mounted on trestle at deck level of EL
118.78 m. General installation of Draft Tube Gate is shown in Drawing
No.PTNL-5900-KFCPH-1503 (Plate Nos. 6.226) in Volume VIII (B).
Salient features of Feeder Pipe line Draft Tube Gate are at Annexure – 6.53
in Annexure Volume-II.
6.7 Instrumentation
The studies required at DPR stage have been carried out and included
in the report. The other studies which are not covered in the DPR will be
carried out at preconstruction stage.
427