Mystical Writings - Hildegard of Bingen
Mystical Writings - Hildegard of Bingen
Mystical Writings - Hildegard of Bingen
Mystical Writings
0dttul. �
Fiona Bowie and Oliver Davies
Robert Carver
A Crossroad Book
0 Euchari,
Valde beatus fuisti
cum Verbum Dei te in igne columba imbuit,
ubi tu quasi aurora illuminatus es,
et sic fundamentum ecclesie
edificasti.
0 Eucharius!
You were blessed
When the Word of God seized you
In the dove's fire,
When, brilliant as the dawn,
You estab,ished your church.
HILDEGARD OF BINGEN
A Moment of Vision
Preface Xlll
Abbreviations XVI
Fiona Bowie
Oliver Davies
Bethesda, March 1990
Schonau
•
0 25 miles
I '•
0
Spanheime
• •
Disibodenberg Sermersheim
_.//
Hildegard's world
Abbreviations
Introduction
A Time of Turmoil
Hildegard was born into a world in which everyone knew their
place. There were those who ruled and fought, the kings,
dukes, barons and their knights; those who prayed, the clergy,
monks and nuns, and the mass of ordinary people who
worked. Above all was God who had ordained this three-fold
structure of society, and who had an interest in its mainten
ance. It would be another hundred years before the great
movements for evangelical poverty swept across Western
Europe and turned young noblemen into beggars. The Rule of
St Benedict allowed for greater social equality, and the Cister
cians, in a renewal of the primitive Benedictine Rule, engaged
in manual labour, but on the whole religious communities
mirrored wider social conventions. Hildegard and Jutta would
have had a personal servant in their cell on the Disibodenberg,
and in their Rupertsberg convent the aristocratic and high
born nuns were kept socially distinct from the low-born
women who would have done much of the manual work in the
community.
However stable the social hierarchy may have seemed, the
political world was more uncertain. Although the danger of
outside attack which had threatened the German Lands for
centuries, with the Vikings to the north, the Saracens to the
south and the Magyars to the east, had waned by the eleventh
century, interna1 ly the country was torn by strife. Since
the time of the great ninth-century emperor, Charlemagne,
Germany had been ruled by semi-independent dukes, mar
graves and counts, often at war with one another and with the
king. The Church was closely tied into the feudal system, its
prelates receiving land and titles from secular rulers to whom
they owed allegiance. Bishops were soldiers as well as clerics
and both bishops and popes had their own armies which they
A Time of Turmoil I 3
would use to defend their titles and property, sometimes
taking part in the fighting themselves.
During the eleventh century conflicting notions of religious
and secular power began to develop. The monastic reform
movement which had started at the Benedictine abbey of
Cluny in Burgundy, and which led to the foundation of
Disibodenberg in around 1105, had a profound affect on the
Church as a whole. By the time Hildegard was born, in 1098,
the papacy was no longer at the mercy of rival Roman patrician
families, but it was locked in conflict with the German kings
and emperors over their respective powers. A system had
developed whereby the pope would anoint the German kings
as Holy Roman Emperors, and the kings had a hand in the
election of certain bishops anrl of the pope. To the reformers
this dependence on secular power was unacceptable and both
kings and popes fought for the right to invest bishops.
One of the best known of the eleventh-century reformist
popes was Gregory VII, known as Hildebrand (1073-85).
Before his election, Hildebrand had probably spent some time
as a monk, possibly in a Cluniac monastery, as well as pur
suing a distinguished career as a Vatican official. He sought to
increase the mystique of personal sanctity surrounding the
person of the pope as successor of Peter and as Christ' s
representative on earth. He claimed that all Christians were
subject to the pope, including emperors, and that supreme
judicial as well as spiritual power rightly belonged to the pope.
As had his predecessors, Gregory VII attempted to stamp out
clerical marriage and simony (the purchase of ecclesiastical
office) and, more divisively, he tried to abolish royal control of
bishops. This led him into direct conflict with the German
king, Henry IV (1056-1 106) . Bishops were forced to choose
between their feudal ioyalties to the king and their spiritual
loyalties to the pope, and in a series of shifting alliances
various dukes and bishops attempted to play both parties off
against one another to their own advantage. In 1076 Henry
deposed Gregory, and Gregory responded by excommunicat
ing Henry. As a political expedient Henry did penance to the
pope the following year and the excommunication was lifted,
but renewed in 1080 when Henry elected Archbishop Wibert
4 I Hildegard of Bi11gc11
(Guibert) of Ravenna as antipope at an imperial council in
Brixen. In 1084 Henry marched on Rome with his army in
order to install Wibert as Pope Clement III, and to be crowned
emperor by him. Pope Gregory VII took refuge in the St
Antonio fortress before fleeing to Salerno where he later died.
What became known as the 'investiture controversy' rum
bled on for many years under successive popes and German
kings. A temporary peace was achieved between Henry V and
Pope Callistus II at the Concordat of Worms in 1122. A formula
was agreed whereby the emperor renounced the right to invest
bishops with ring and crozier, the symbols of their spiritual
authority, and to allow for their free canonical election and
consecration. The emperor retained the right to be present at
the election of bishops and abbots in Germany, a gesture
towards their feudal allegiance to the crown. The uncompro
mising stance adopted by the only English pope, Hadrian IV
(1154-9), angered the German emperor Frederick I, known as
'Barbarossa' ('red beard') by the Italians, and led to a further
twenty years of strife and the election of a further three
antipopes. Popes were by no means secure in their position.
Innocent II (1130-42), who was elected on the same day as his
rival, the antipope Anacletus II, spent most of his pontificate in
France. Even the most saintly of the twelfth-century popes, the
Cistercian monk Eugenius III (1 145-53), who approved Hilde
gard's Scivias at the Synod of Trier, could not find a home in
Rome, which was in the hands of the antipapal Roman com
mune. During her lifetime Hildegard saw some dozen popes
and ten anti popes elected to the See of Peter. It was the age of
the Crusades, with their idealism and barbarity, and it was a
century marked by constant squabbles between local rulers
and the German crown, between the crown and the papacy
.
and between European royal families.
Hildegard's own sympathies would have been with the
reformers in the Church, allied as they were to the monastic
revival which gave life to her own community at Disi
bodenberg, and supported so strongly by her admired con_
temporary, Bernard of Clairvaux (1090-1 153). Her interests
were, however, by no means identical to that of the papacy
and of the Church politicians. In a letter to the Archbishop of
A Time of Turmoil I 5
Canterbury in 1102, Pope Paschal II expressed his disapproval
of lay elections of bishops in the strongest possible terms:
6 I Hildegard of Bingen
enclosed nun, but she was by no means cut off from this
turbulent world. Monasteries were part of the network of
feudal ties and obligations. They were endowed by wealthy
families who gave them land and goods in return for their
prayers and spiritual works. Abbots and abbesses of large
houses were powerful figures in their own right, commanding
large incomes from their various estates and becoming major
employers of labour. They were also respected figures, on an
equal footing with their lay brothers and sisters who had
remained 'in the world' . The heads of religious houses were
not so unworldly themselves. Bernard of Clairvaux travelled
widely and acted as advisor to several popes, while Hildegard
left her convent to teach and preach throughout the
Rhineland.
It is into this divided but vibrant world that Hildegard was
born, and in which she lived out her mission. It was an age of
expansion, geographically, with the Crusades pushing south
and east; demographically, with the development of agricul
ture, towns and guilds; architecturally, with the foundation of
numerous monasteries, great cathedral churches, castles and
civic buildings; and of the mind, with the growth of univer
sities, particularly the ancient medical school at Salerno, the
law faculty in Bologna and the theological centre in Paris. From
the lowliest to the most exalted in the land, Hildegard was in
touch with the people who shaped her century and, like all
great women and men, she both reflected and transcended her
age.
A Time of Turmoil I 7
Hildegard's Life and Works
HILDEGARD'S LIFE
8 I Hildegard of Bi11ge11
rooms. The formal religious service which marked their en
closure echoed the rites of burial. The women were to be
hidden from the world, for the good of their souls and for the
greater glory of God. Their cell was adjacent to the abbey
church of Disibodenberg, the site of an earlier Celtic monastery
which was refounded by Archbishop Ruthard of Mainz in
around 1 105 in the wake of the Cluniac Benedictine reforms.
The first abbot was formally installed in 1 108, two years after
3
Hildegard' s arrival on the site. It is no wonder that Hilde
gard' s later visions are so full of images of buildings and
craftsmen, and that the construction of the Kingdom of heaven
was seen as analogous to a human building project. The
Disibodenberg monastery and its women's cloister were in a
state of continual development throughout her forty-four
years there.
Hildegard' s early education would have been based on the
liturgical requirements of a Benedictine abbey. She would
have learnt to pray the Psalter in Latin and have heard,
and later taken part in, the cycle of prayer and chanting
which comprises the monastic life. Handcrafts were also
recommended to keep the recluse from idleness, but more
academic studies seem to have had no place in the anchorage.
Hildegard later described Jutta as an unlearned woman, per
haps comparing her to the monks, who had greater access to
books and to formal education.
As other young women came to join Jutta and Hildegard, so
their accommodation expanded, and their life gradually
changed from that of anchoresses to members of a Benedictine
convent. When Hildegard was fifteen she took the habit of a
Benedictine nun, and when Jutta died in 1136, Hildegard was
elected as leader or magistra of the community. They remained
dependent upon the monks for the services of a priest and in
all financial and administrative matters. This restriction Hilde
gard came increasingly to resent, and as her reputation and
confidence increased, she sought to remedy the situation.
An important figure in Hildegard' s life was the provost of
the convent, Volmar, who could not have been much older
than Hildegard herself. Charged with special responsibility for
the nuns' spiritual welfare, Volmar became one of Hildegard' s
10 I Hildegard of Bingen
right when she la� s stress not on what Hildegard knew, but
how she knew it. As her reputation grew, Hildegard' s con
fidence increased and she found that her mental capacities too
were illuminated by a divine light. The lessons she had
absorbed over the years took on a new and original meaning
and Hildegard' s creativity blossomed. Ironically, the lack of
formal instruction she had received may have shielded Hilde
gard from the more misogynistic elements of contemporary
literature. Heloise, a contemporary of Hildegard who entered
monastic life as an adult after a brilliant academic career under
the tutelage of her teacher and lover Peter Abelard, was far
more keenly aware than Hildegard of women' s supposed
inferiority. 6
It was not, however, without trepidation that Hildegard
embarked on her public ministry. The support and affirmation
of men whom she respected, and who held authority in the
Church, was vital to her. In 1 146 she wrote to Bernard of
Clairvaux, a leading monastic figure in the Cistercian (Benedic
tine) reform movement, asking for confirmation of her vo
cation. Bernard replied favourably, assuring Hildegard that
her visions were genuine. The support of so great a figure
would have helped to create a favourable atmosphere for the
reception of Hildegard' s work at the Trier synod of 1 147-8,
presided over by the Cistercian pope, Eugenius III. News of
this remarkable visionary had reached Eugenius both from
Bernard and from Heinrich, Archbishop of Mainz, and he sent
a delegation to the Disibodenberg in order to visit Hildegard
and to obtain a copy of her writings. Eugenius was favourably
impressed and authorized Hildegard 'in the name of Christ
and St Peter to publish all that she had learned from the Holy
Spirit' .
The monks on the Disibodenberg were, no doubt, proud of
their protegee. The enhanced reputation of the monastery, the
visitors, the prospect of endowments, new vocations to the
women' s cloister, and the dowries the women brought with
them, were all to be welcomed. Now a respected figure in her
own right, the cramped quarters and lack of independence
granted her cloister led Hildegard to take a difficult but decis
ive step. In a vision, which followed a period of illness,
12 I Hildegard of Bingen
Rupcrtsberg i11 1625
14 I Hildegard of Bingen
death, was never formally completed due to administrative
difficulties. But in 1324 Pope John XXII gave permission for
her 'solemn and public cult', and Hildegard's status today is
that of a canonical saint. Her feast is celebrated in the German
calendar on the anniversary of her death.
HILDEGARD'S WORKS
Scivias, which means literally 'Know the Ways', is the first and
the longest of Hildegard's visionary works (1141-51). It is
divided into three sections or books, consisting of six, seven
and thirteen visions respectively. Hildegard first records each
vision in detail and then gives its theological explanation,
which is presented by a 'voice from heaven'.
Book One begins with the theme of wisdom, which is
human knowledge and inquiry illumined by faith, humility
and revelation, and it progresses to the theme of humanity in
the bondage of original sin. Then Hildegard turns to the
creation, at the heart of which there stands an unredeemed
humanity, to the old Covenant which anticipates the coming
of Christ and to the angelic order with its promise of fulfilment
to come.
Book Two presents the theme of the Saviour, the Church -
its hierarchy and sacraments, particularly baptism, confir
mation and the Eucharist - and the theme of continuing
temptation and evil.
Book Three explores the work of the Holy Spirit in building
up the Kingdom of God through the virtues, and the last
visions of this book are concerned with the Day of Judgement
and the New Earth. The final vision of all, the 'Play of Virtues'
(Ordo virtutum), is dominated by the theme of victory and
praise, and its blend of action and personification justify its
description as the first morality play. Hildegard herself later
developed the Ordo as an independent piece and set it to
music.
The Book of Divine Works (De operatione Dei) is the third and final
of Hildegard's visionary works (1163-73/4) . This, too, is div
ided into three parts and, again like Scivias, it seeks to address
·:he Christian mystery in its full cosmological depth . The work
:onsists of ten visions of varying lengths, divided into three
books which are themselves of different lengths. The first
book, which consists of the first four visions, deals with God's
creation of the world from love and with the special place of
humanity within it. The second book, or fifth vision, develops
the idea of humanity as the moral centre of the world, faced
with ultimate divine judgement, while the third book, which
consists of the last five visions, is concerned with salvation
history, with the incarnation and the end of time. The central
part of the work is Hildegard' s long meditation on the opening
of St John's Gospel, which forms a considerable section of the
fourth vision.
·
16 I Hildegard of Bingen
the constitution of the human body, its illnesses and their
remedies. Both these books originally constituted a single
work with the title The Subtleties of the Diverse Nature of Created
Things (Liber subtilitatwn diversarum naturarum creaturarwn).
Hildegard was also the author of seventy-seven songs for
which she herself composed the music. The language of these
songs is particularly beautiful, and their accompaniment is
strikingly original. The themes which they address range from
the three Persons of the Trinity, to Mary, the angels, patriarchs
and prophets, the apostles and martyrs, as well as individual
saints . And some are songs written on the occasion of the
dedication of a church. Hildegard's corpus of songs is known
as the Symphonia, and it is believed that they were in greater
part complete by the year 1 158.
During her life time, Hildegard also wrote a good many
letters, of which some three hundred survive . These give
us valuable insight into her private thoughts and personal
struggles, as well as her public mission to advise and, when
necessary, to correct. Hildegard corresponded with a great
variety of people, including four popes (Eugenius III,
Anastasius IV, Hadrian IV, Alexander III), numerous local
rulers (including the King of England, Henry II) and even the
emperor (Barbarossa, or Frederick I, whom she actually met),
numerous archbishops and bishops, abbots and abbesses,
leading spiritual figures (Bernard of Clairvaux, Elisabeth of
Schonau), many priests and lay people .
Hildegard's other works, which generally date from a later
period, include a selection of readings from the Gospels, with
an allegorical commentary (the Expositio11es eva11gelion1111), com
mentaries on the Rule of St Benedict (Expla11atio Regulae S.
Benedicti) and on 'the Athanasian Creed (Explanatio Symboli S.
Atlzanasii), and two biographies: the Life of Sf Disibod (Vita Sa11cti
Disibodi) and the Life of Sf Rupert (Vita Sancfi Ruperti) . There is
also the Solutions to Thirty-Eight Questions (Solutio11es trigi11ta
ocfo quaestionum), in which Hildegard attempted to solve
theological problems put to her by the monks of Villers and
Guibert of Gembloux, and there are two short pieces entitled
the Unknown La11guage (Li11gua ig11ofa) and the U11k11mun Writing
Hildegard's Life and Works I 17
(Litterae ignotae). The former is a glossary of some nine
hundred words which Hildegard herself created and which
are arranged in thematic groups.
1 8 I Hildegard of Bingen
The Living Light
The role of visions in the experience of medieval women is
analysed by Elizabeth Petroff in her perceptive introduction to
her book Medieval Women's Visionary Literature:
20 I Hildegard of Bingen
connected, and from an inherent weakness Hildegard learned
to draw her strength .
Unlike the visions of her younger contemporary and friend,
Elizabeth of Sch6nau, or those of other twelfth and thirteenth
century women mystics such as Marie of Oignies, Mechthild of
Magdeburg or Hadewijch of Brabant, Hildegard' s message
was prophetic and didactic. 11 She has little in common with the
intensely devotional, erotic and ecstatic mysticism of the be
guine writers mentioned above, and her theology is theo
centric or sapiential, rather than christocentric. It is the cosmic
dimension, the struggle between good and evil, an absorption
with the great work of redemption and the role of human
beings in that work, which preoccupy Hildegard . She does not
present herself as a role model or lay down a path of mystical
union for others to follow. Hildegard is, rather, a mouthpiece,
a 'small tru mpet', a 'feather on the breath of God' , whose task
it is to teach and correct her fellow men and women and to
glorify the Creator.
Hildegard claimed direct divine intervention as the source of
all her visionary works, her music and many of her letters and
pronouncements. One is, however, left with the impression
that Hildegard could overstate her case, and that some of her
contemporaries regarded her statements with a degree of
scepticis m. The claim that 'the divine light has spoken' and the
invocation of terrible curses for those who ignored it, might on
occasions have resembled the rantings of an old woman who
had been thwarted, rather than a mouthpiece of God . An
example of Hildegard's style can be seen in her Vita, in a
passage describing her efforts to obtain independence for her
convent from the monks at Disibodenberg. What Hildegard
describes as a 'petition' was, as Peter Dronke so rightly points
out, more of a 'furmination' .
And in accordance with what I perceived in my true vision, I said to
the Father Abbot: 'The serene light says: You shall be father to our
provost, and father of the salvation of the souls of the daughters of
my mystic garden. But their alms do not belong to you or to your
brother s -your cloister should be a refuge for these women. If you
are determined to go on with your proposals, raging against us,
you will be like the Amalekites, and like Antiochus, of whom it was
22 I Hildegard of Bingen
Hildegard's Theology
24 I Hildegard of Bingen
� �mcm( ltbm
�n � rm-pne 3�
ktuun£.
:du1£ tfU mgM �� Of'U( I�
atuid" confununanC ad hntm
Jn dubu! auum �f�!1 tt\Cl
mm �U}''t , �tuuai P.Cml
l � "f CUnomc abbanC ut
bean ry�n e obt pctmfKtC:
� r krthdk
!If ,: ,tptnd.t ltbi'l $ ; \ ''Lt�·
L l ; 1 S l 1 v "' t N l ::;;:. · .
I I
,\ }'I t h" ttt\ 1,'l lt::i p1 11 ,· p .tKIL....;
•
_
�ic . tbWbtt mittart'
a.
.4 cWmuu,.
l � fpll fwu:.
:am( ,l dO uttumfa.umat 5ni
:.t � cuiodwm<
pmcm � �i ii,ro'fuut'
� b�
t1 dt' Gd.ml tt .
THE CREATION
The creation, for Hildegard, begins in the love of God, as this
passage from the Book of Divine Works shows:
The leaping fountain is clearly the purity of the living God. His
radiance is reflected in it, and in that splendour, God embraces in
his great love all things whose reflection appeared in the leaping
fountain before he ordered them to come forth in their own shape.
And in me, Love, all things are reflected and my splendour reveals
the design of things, j ust as the reflection indicates their form. In
Humility, who is my helper, creation has come forth at God's
command; and in that same Humility, God has inclined himself
towards me, to lift up again in that blessedness the withered leaves
that have fallen and through whom he can do all that he will. For he
fashioned, them out of the earth; and from the earth he freed them
after the fall. (DW 8, 2)
In this passage it is striking that this same love of God, which
contains all things in itself, contains humanity too, together
with our fall into sin and our redemption from sin through the
incarnation of his Son. Right from the very beginning there
fore, Hildegard's creation is one which not only contains a
foreknowledge of the great drama of the fall and our redemp
tion, but finds in this its own essential meaning. And it is also
significant that the 'voice' in this passage is that of the love of
God, which is personified as a young woman . As Barbara
Newman has shown, the 'eternal feminine, in her several
guises, links God's coming into the world with the world's
own coming to be' . 19 Hildegard' s vision of the creation is
profoundly christocentric therefore (with Christ at its centre)
in that it is so deeply anthropocentric (with humanity at its
centre) . This is confirmed by another important passage in
which the Love of God again speaks, which is the source of all
26 I Hildegard of Bingen
life, and which tells us how it has 'kindled every living spark'
and how it is aflame 'above the beauty of the fields', gleaming
'in the waters' and burning 'in the sun, the moon and the
stars' . Yet again Hildegard quickly asserts the primacy of the
human: 'For it was always the case throughout eternity that
God wanted to create his work - man. And when he had
finished this work, he gave all creatures to him so that with
them he might work, just as God himself had made his work,
which is man' (DW 1 , 2). Likewise, in her vision of the great
'cosmic wheel' which supports all creation, Hildegard tells us
that it is humanity which is at its centre: 'Humanity stands in
the midst of the structure of the world. For it is more important
than all other creatures which remain dependent on that
world. Although small in stature, humanity is powerful in the
power of its soul' (DW 2, 15). And, in another passage,
Hildegard makes it clear that the fall of Adam and Eve has
repercussions for the whole of the creation, for 'in their misfor
tune and their exile every creature in the world is shrouded in
cloud, as when a ray from the sun shines through dense cloud'
(DW 5, 15) .
For Hildegard, the creation itself takes place through the
Word of God . Here, of course, she is following the teaching at
the beginning of the Gospel of St John ('through whom all
things were made': John 1 . 3). Also, in a sense, created things
remain within the Word. 20 Thus we read:
The Word sounded and brought all creatures into being. In this
way the Word and God are one. As the Word sounded, he called to
himself all of creation which had been predestined and established
in eternity. His resonance awakened everything to life, just as God
had indicated within humanity. God secretly speaks the Word
within his heart ebefore God emits the Word. This is the Word
which still remains within God, even though it is sent forth. Thus
whatever is uttered by the Word remains in the Word. Now when
the Word of God sounded, this Word appeared in every creature,
and this sound was life in every creature. (DW 4, 105)
HUMANITY
The core of Hildegard' s understanding of the role of men and
women within the creation can be found in a remark she makes
in her Life: 'Humanity too is God's creation. But humanity
alone is called to co-operate with God in the creation' ( Vita II,
35) . 22 That special role which we have within the created order
and which emerges so clearly from Hildegard's discussions of
the nature of the creation, is that we alone possess the power to
fashion according to our own will those things and creatures
which have been created by God. After all, we alone of all
creatures possess reason, the light of discrimination (cf. SC III
2, 9), and so we can choose either to co-operate with the
goodness of God, or to defy him and to oppose his order. This
is Hildegard's central perception concerning humankind, and
it is the one which gives such a keen edge to the didactic
character of her work.
28 I Hildegard of Bingen
Even a cursory view of her writings will persuade us how
intensely interested Hildegard is in the human phenomenon.
She writes at length of each part of the human body and never
tires of trying to explain its workings, according to her own
understanding of the structure of the world of which we are a
part. And indeed, she conceives of humanity very much as a
microcosm of the world's macrocosm; for 'God fashioned the
human form according to the constitution of the firmament
and of all the other creatures, as the founder has a certain form
according to which he makes his vessels' (OW 4, 97) . Human
beings are the 'complete creation of God' (plenum opus Oei) and
we contain both the things of the earth and those of heaven:
'Thus humankind is earthly according to its humble station in
the flesh and heavenly because of the heights of heaven which
it possesses in its soul' (OW 4, 99) . And Hildegard compares
the soul directly with the moisture which gives life to the earth:
'The soul is the green life-force of the flesh . For, indeed, the
body grows and progresses on account of the soul, just as the
earth becomes fruitful through moisture . And the soul is also
the moisture of the body because the soul moistens it so that it
does not dry out, just as rain flows down into the earth' (OW 4,
21 ) . In another example, she compares the proportions of the
human head (the seat of the soul) with the harmony of the
created world: 'The sphere of the human head indicates
the roundness of the firmament, and the right and balanced
measurements of our head reflect the right and balanced
measurement of the firmament' (OW 4, 16). And in a further
passage, Hildegard argues that we are ourselves constituted
by the very same elements which make up the external
world:
As has already b�en shown a number o f times, just as the four
elements hold the world together, they also form the structure for
the human body. Their distribution and function in the whole
human being are such that they constantly sustain the person, just
as they are spread throughout all the rest of the world and have
their effects. Fire, air, water and earth are in humankind, and
humans consist of them. From fire they have the warmth of their
bodies, from air they have their breath, from water they have their
blood and from earth their bodies. (CC 49, 29)
Hildegard' s Theology I 29
Indeed, in a sense human beings can be said even to contain the
world; for 'God imprinted every creature in humankind itself
according to its measure' (DW 1, 2).
Elsewhere Hildegard not only sees a parallel between the
'humours of the body' and the winds which sweep the earth's
surface, but she even suggests that the latter act directly upon
the former: 'Then I noticed how the humours in the human
organism are distributed and altered by various qualities of the
wind and air, as soon as such qualities come into conflict with
one another, because the humours themselves take on such
qualities' (DW 3, 1 ) .
For Hildegard, humanity, despite its special place i n cre
ation, is not distinct from the rest of creation. We are composed
of the same elements, and our nature is constructed along the
same principles, as the world in which we live. And, although
the creatures have been made in order to serve our needs (DW
2, 2), we too are answerable to them:
God has directed for humanity's benefit all of creation, which God
has formed both on the heights and in the dep ths. If we abuse our
position and commit evil deeds, God's judgement will permit other
creatures to punish us. And just as creatures have to serve our
bodily needs, it is also unders tood that they are intended for the
welfare of our souls. (DW 3, 2)
Elsewhere she tells us how the elements will 'hold their right
course' if our deeds are just, but will inflict suffering upon us if
we 'perform evil deeds' (DW 4, 104). Hildegard's view · of
humanity then is one which sugges ts that we express our true
nature when we are in harmony with creation, and she sug
gests that being sinful means that we are not in harmony with
the world around us (SC III 5, 1 7) .
A s befits a world-scheme i n which humankind has such a
central place, Hildegard has a very 'high' view of human
nature in that she believes that redeemed humanity is to take
the place of the fallen angels before the throne of God (DW 1 ,
10). This positive view of humanity is balanced however by a
keen sense of our sinfulness and our need for redemption
through the saving action of Christ, to which theme the whole
of the second part of Scivias is devoted. But what is character-
30 I Hildegard of Bingen
istic above all of Hildegard' s understanding of humanity is her
belief that we and the creation are intrinsically good. The
measure of our sinfulness is the measure of the distortion of
that essential goodness within us. And we are good, according
to Hildegard, because life itself is divinely given and is good.
There is nothing of an unwholesome depreciation of ourselves
or creation here, although Hildegard remains fully and realisti
cally aware of our many failings which constantly serve to
distort that image of goodness within us.
HILDEGARD'S IMAGERY
The whole of Hildegard's work is inspired by the spirit of
balance and moderation. 23 Within the cosmic order of things,
humankind (we who contain within ourselves the elements
both of heaven and earth) represent a central mediating point
located between the divine and the earthly. We are called
ourselves to live in harmony 'with the elements'; to maintain a
proper balance in all things so that the humours and the
system of dryness and moisture within the body will be kept in
ordered harmony. And the chief way in which this concern
with order and harmony is expressed is by Hildegard's under
standing of health. It is this motif which runs throughout the
whole of her work, both when she is talking of the essential
truths of the Christian revelation and of our moral life, as well
as when she reflects on our physical state in her medical
works. And the central, unifying image which she uses here in
order to connect the different levels of her reflection is that of
'greenness' (Latin: viriditas).
At one level, the origin of this image must lie in the subtle,
ever-changing anp deeply affecting green of the hills that
surround the Disibodenberg and Rupertsberg areas of the
German Rhineland, where Hildegard lived and worked. And,
in the first instance, greenness is the living life of the fruitful
earth (e.g . 'The rivers give rise to smaller streams that sustain
the earth by their greening power' (DW 4, 59)). The burgeoning
life of the earth is founded upon moisture (rainfall) and upon
the dynamic life-force which is ultimately the living energy of
God and which, for Hildegard, generally takes the form of
Hildegard's Theology I 31
reproductive power. Although it sometimes has this sense
in us too, the 'greenness' of humanity lies principally in
our rational soul, which 'is the green life-force of the flesh'
(OW 4, 21).
But Hildegard uses this image of the 'green' life-force of the
world in order also to represe nt the spiritual life of grace and
virtue, and Peter Dronke is quite right when he says that
Hildegard's greenness 'is the earthly expression of the celestial
sunlight; greenness is the condition in which earthly beings
experience a fulfilment which is both physical and divine;
greenness is the blithe overcoming of the dualism between
earthly and heavenly' . 24 Viriditns in the natural order is linked
with the moisture which is essential to life, and so, in the
spiritual realm, moisture (rainfall, dewfall) is specifically
linked with the Holy Spirit, the giver of Life: 'Through the
Word, the sweet moisture of holiness fell from God and in the
Holy Spirit' (SC II 1, 8) . In another passage, the Holy Spirit
itself is 'green': 'She [blessedness] is also surrounded with
many gifts which are green with the greenness of the Holy
Spirit' (SC III 6, 33), for it is the Holy Spirit 'which poured out
this green freshness of life into the hearts of men and women
so that they might bear good fruit' (OW 10, 2) . Here Hildegard
is adapting the green fruitfulness of the earth in order to
express the virtues and good deeds of spiritual souls who are
'fecund' (OW 1, 16) :
If meanwhile, we give up the green vitality of these virtues and
surrender to the drou ght of o u r indolence, so that we do not have
the sap of life a nd the greeni n g power of good d eeds, then the
power of our very soul will begin to fade and d ry up . . . But if
we follow the right road, all our actions will give rise to good fruit.
(OW 2, 18)
32 I Hildegard of Bi11ge11
officiates at the Eucharist (SC II 6, 1 1); from 'tears and si ghs the
greening life-force of repentance arises' (DW 4, 32); in number
nineteen of her Songs, the Virgin Mary is the 'greenest branch'
and, in the Book of Divine Works, Jesus himself is 'the green
wood because he caused all the greening power of the virtues'
(OW 1 0, 19) .
Behind Hildegard's image of 'greenness' (and indeed the
rest of her colour imagery) is the central concept of light. 25
After all, the source of her visions is precisely the 'living light'
together with the 'reflection of the living light', 26 and her
writings abound in imagery which conveys this sense of
radiance . Above all, the universe itself becomes a mirror which
captures and throws back the divine light in a symphony of
brilliance and grandeur. At the top of the hierarchy of creation
are the angels, which are like 'the brilliance of many reflections
in a mirror' (DW 1, 6) . Men and women possess the power of
reason, which is the noblest element in the soul and which
Hildegard describes in terms of light so that 'we are flooded
with light itself in the same way as the light of day illumines the
world' (OW 4, 105) . Similarly, Hildegard speaks of the 'daz
zlingly fair wings of reason' on which we can 'soar upward in
true faith and hope to God' (OW 7, 5). And finally, in one of
Hildegard's most powerful images of all, the whole of creation
is radiant with the divine light: 'all living creatures are, so to
speak, sparks from the radiation of God's brilliance, and these
sparks emerge from God like the rays of the sun' (DW 4, 1 1) .
Hildcgard's Theology I 33
Hildegard the Won1an
What kind of person was this extraordinary, enigmatic woman
who made such an impact on her own times, only to disappear
from view for nearly eight hundred years before being 'redis
covered' in our own century? By the end of her life Hildegard's
fame had spread half way across Europe . People of all ranks
visited her convent on the Rupertsberg to seek her advice in
both spiritual and practical matters . Her fame as a counsellor
equalled her reputation for healing and exorcism and her
prophetic gifts led to comparisons with the Old Testament
figures of Miriam, Deborah and Judith, whom she was said to
excel. Hildegard inspired admiration and devotion from many
of those around her, but like all powerful and forceful person
alities, she also had her share of detractors.
Although Hildegard's writings sometimes appear contradic
tory and unsystematic, an examination of her works does give
us some clues as to the kind of person we are dealing with . The
picture of a highly intelligent, sensitive, forceful, artistic and
well-integrated woman emerges. Hildegard is no pious inno
cent, despite her oblation (her dedication to monastic life as a
child) and her relatively restricted experience of the world
from within a Benedictine cloister. She can write with a de
tached enthusiasm about matters such as the pleasures of
sexual intercourse, while at the same time developing a rich
theology of the celibate life, which was celebrated with great
splendour in her convent on the Rupertsberg. If Hildegard was
your friend, she would stand by you, although never being
afraid to correct where she thought necessary, but she was not
a woman one would want as an enemy. Scathing and relent
less in her criticism of those she thought were despoiling the
Church of God , and determined in getting her own way,
Hildegard was undoubtedly a force to be reckoned with. While
34 I Hildegard of Bingen
we may not agree with all that Hildegard says and does -
indeed much of her thinking and her behaviour bears a medi
eval stamp which can seem alien to our own concerns - one
cannot help but respect her. There is a zest for life, a respect for
individuals and for the created world, an irrepressible energy,
an imaginative power and a yearning for the good and the
beautiful which attract and fascinate those who come into
contact with this remarkable woman. As a leading twentieth
century poet Stephan George, himself a native of Bingen, put
it, 'Here is someone with whom one could have talked!'
HILDEGARD'S PERSONALITY
One way of learning more about Hildegard' s personality is by
examining some of her relationships as revealed in her letters.
One of the most important people in Hildegard' s life was
undoubtedly Richardis of Stade, the nun who had been her
confidante during their years at Disibodenberg. From the
correspondence concerning Richardis's removal to a convent
in the north of Germany, and her subsequent tragic death, we
obtain a picture of an intimate, but perhaps overly dependent
relationship, which Hildegard was loath to relinquish . From
letters to Hazzecha of Krauftal, the abbess of a community in
the diocese of Strasburg, we learn something of Hildegard's
wisdom, compassion and common sense. Her key word in
giving pastoral advice is 'discretion', and she displays a keen
and sympathetic understanding of human frailty. A third
significant relationship, of a different tenor altogether, was
with the German emperor, Frederick Barbarossa, one of the
most powerful men of his age. Thanks perhaps to her own
noble background and to the aristocratic circles in which she
moved, Hildegard felt herself competent to approach this
maverick international statesman. They met personally on a t
least one occasion, and conducted a correspondence over
many years .
36 I Hildegard of Bingen
Richardis's brother, Hartwig, entreating him to persuade
Richardis to return to Rupertsberg.
Hildegard's efforts were almost repaid, but Richardis died
before she could make the journey . In the letter bearing the sad
news, Hartwig assured Hildegard that Richardis had longed to
return, and took the blame for her removal upon himself. In
her answer Hildegard is able to express the love she felt for
Richardis, and to forgive all those she had thought were
scheming against her, but at the same time justifies her own
position:
Full divine love was in my soul towards her, for in the mightiest
vision the living light tau ght me to love her. Listen: God kept her so
jealously that worldly delight could not embrace her: she fought
against it, even though she rose like a flower in the beauty and
glory and symphony of this world . . .
So my soul has great confidence in her, though the world loved
her beautiful looks and her prudence, while she lived in the body.
But God loved her more. Thus God did not wish to give her to a
rival lover, that is, to the world . . . So I also expel from my heart
that pain you caused me re garding this my daughter. 27
38 I Hildegard of Bingen
a minority of cardinals nominated an alternative candidate,
Victor IV . Alexander III laid down a challenge to Frederick by
claiming that the German crown was a 'benefice' bestowed by
the pope. The theological argument for this was that the pope,
as representative of Christ, was sovereign over all earthly
rulers. Frederick, not surprisingly, supported the antipope,
and was excommunicated by Alexander.
Hildegard sought a charter of protection from Frederick,
which confirmed the Rupertsberg convent's possessions and
rights as set out in the 1 158 documents. Presumably the
abbey's independence was still threatened by some of Hilde
gard' s opponents. In a second letter, dated 18 April 1163,
Hildegard thanks the Emperor for this charter but, addressing
Frederick as 'Servant of God', reminds him that his worldly
powers should serve a higher purpose than his own ambition.
Only when he seeks God's Kingdom will Frederick, like King
David in the Bible, be delivered from the hands of his enemies.
On a more personal note, Hildegard undertakes to pray for the
son and heir for which Frederick and his second wife, Beatrice,
so long. Her prayers were answered for in July 1164 they had a
boy, Frederick, followed in November 1 165 by a second son,
Henry.
The third of Hildegard' s letters to Barbarossa is short and
curt. In 1 164 Victor IV died and Frederick elected a second
antipope, Paschalis III. Hildegard accused Frederick of behav
ing childishly, like one who is insane, and warned him that the
grace of God in his life was in danger of being extinguished.
The fourth and final letter is even more terse, a series of biblical
quotations warning of divine retribution for the wicked, sent
after the election of a third antipope, Callistus III, in 1 1 68.
From this corre�pondence, spanning two decades, we can
glimpse something of Hildegard' s sense of responsibility in
her role as a prophet, exhorting, cajoling and, when necessary,
condemning. It was not Frederick's expansionist ambitions so
much as his opposition to the papacy which angered Hilde
gard, but she was tenacious in her determination to get the
emperor to amend his ways. Her influence may not have been
as great as she could have wished, but Hildegard continued to
regard the affairs of state as part of her legitimate concerns.
As for tiaras: I saw that all the ranks of the Church have bright
emblems in accord with the heavenly brightness, yet virginity has
no bright emblem - nothing but a black veil and an ima ge of the
cross. So I saw tha t this would be the emblem of virginity: tha t a
virgin's head would be covered with a white veil, beca use of the
radiant-white robe that human beings had in paradise, and lost.
On her head would be a circlet with three colours conjoined into
one - an image of the Trinity - and four roundels attached: the one
on the forehead showing the lamb of God, that on the right a
cherub, tha t on the left an angel, and on the back a hum a n being
all these inclining towards the Trinity. This emblem, granted to me,
will proclaim blessings to God, because he had clothed the first
man in radiant bri ghtness.10
40 I Hildegard of Bingen
should celebrate the Kingdom of heaven in all its beauty and
extravagance .
The costumes devised by Hildegard for her nuns are clearly
inspired by her visions . In her Book of Life's Merits (6.43 and 44),
Hildegard sees the blessed virgins in paradise 'clothed in
gowns of purest gold and decked with precious jewels' , and
'on their heads they wore golden crowns studded with gems
and interwoven with roses and lilies' . Only those privileged to
wear the crowns could hear the wonderful and harmonious
music of heaven and take pleasure in it.
Rumours of unusual practices on the Rupertsberg had also
reached Tengswindis (Tengswich), the leader of a foundation
of canonesses at St Marien near Andernach. In a polite but
guardedly critical letter Tengswindis asked Hildegard about
the costumes worn by her nuns, and sought clarification
concerning her community's practice of admitting only
women of noble birth. This was perhaps a somewhat disingen
uous question as the canoness orders were normally open only
to aristocratic women. The Benedictine houses, on the other
hand, were divided as to whether their members should be
recruited from all classes, as the Rule of St Benedict rec
ommended, or restricted to noble men and women only. The
Rupertsberg, it would appear, followed the latter line,
although the earliest monastery book of remembrance records
the presence of 'nuns', who were nobly born, of 'sisters', who
were presumably from more humble backgrounds, and of 'lay
women', all of whom would have formed part of the
community . 32 Hildegard, however, defends a degree of ex
clusivity, claiming authority for her words from 'the living
fountain' . Her thinking follows the social mores of her day,
rather than the more revolutionary gospel (or Benedictine)
notions of equality . What farmer, she asks, would put oxen,
asses, sheep and goats in a single field? They would all scatter,
and so would different classes of human beings. They would
tear one another apart in hate, those of higher rank setting
themselves above the lower, and those of lower rank seeking
to rise above the higher. For Hildegard, human hierarchies are
ordained by God, people are ranked like the angels; equally
loved, bu t not to be confused.
Hildegard tlze Wonza11 I 41
In practical terms Hildegard may have had a point. No doubt
it was easier to rule over a community in which each knew
their place, and in which the noble women in her charge had
no excuse to lord it over others. It is only in the last few decades
that many of the present religious orders have done away with
the divisions between choir and lay brothers or sisters, or have
admitted African, Asian or South American religious on an
equal footing. Hildegard may nofhave been right in Christian
terms, but she was not the first or the last person to confuse the
divine order with human social constructs.
The importance of music in the Rupertsberg convent is also
well attested. Hildegard had begun composing her own litur
gical songs and music, based on monastic plainsong, during
her years on the Disibodenberg, and under the inspiration of
her visions she continued with this work at Ru perts berg. Some
of Hildegard's music has recently been recorded and per
formed, and, as with so much of her work, appears startlingly
modern and original. For Hildegard, music was more than a
way of praising God, it was a way of sharing in the life of
heaven itself. Through music, human beings are reminded of
the harmonies of the heavenly spheres, indeed, the soul itself
is symphonic.
When, in the last years of her life, Hildegard's community
was placed under an interdict by the prelates of Mainz for
allowing the burial in consecrated ground of a man who had
been excommunicated, the greatest hardship they endured
was the absence of music. Hildegard never tired in her efforts
to have the interdict lifted and it is in her letters to these priests
that we learn of the central �lace music played in the life of
the Rupertsberg community. 3 In obeying the Mainz prelates,
Hildegard felt that she was disobeying God, and she struggled
to reconcile her duty to her inner voice and to the Church.
When, after her death, a commission was set up to seek
witnesses for Hildegard' s canonization, three of her sisters
swore that they had seen Hildegard illuminated by the Holy
Spirit as she walked through the cloisters chanting one of her
favourite compositions. 34 It was above all through music that
the unity of the human and divine could be realized and the
Rupertsberg convent appears to have been a place where the
42 I Hildegard of Bingen
harmonies of heaven were celebrated on earth in all their
fullness.
Hildegard held extremely exalted views of the monastic
vocation, placing monks and nuns above priests and bishops,
who were in turn ranked higher than ordinary lay people.
While it was possible to aspire to a higher order, to descend
from a higher to a lower state was not to be countenanced
(SC II 5, 35). The monastic vocation should not, according to
Hildegard, be adopted hastily or for impure motives, as once
an individual had made their vows there was no turning back.
Hildegard even suggested that those wishing to leave the
monastic life should be confined and kept on bread and water.
She therefore warns against sending children to a monastery
against their will and condemns the use of religious life as an
escape from poverty, bodily weakness or personal troubles.
The atmosphere in the Rupertsberg convent can only be
surmised . From her extensive writings on human physiology,
on medicine, psychology, and what we would today term
psychotherapy, it is clear that not only the spiritual aspect of
the nuns' lives received attention. What does seem clear is that
life on the Rupertsberg had an intensely mystical flavour. This
can be glimpsed not only from their clothes and music, but also
from a puzzle that has intrigued students of Hildegard for
many years . Among Hildegard's works is an 'unknown lan
guage' (Lingua ignota) with its own 'unknown alphabet'. It
survives in a glossary of some nine hundred words which refer
to items of everyday use, such as the clothes worn by the nuns
and the herbs in the garden, as well as to all manner of natural
and heavenly beings. A few words of her secret language find
their way into some of Hildegard's songs, particularly the
antiphon 'O orzchis Ecclesia' .
This language was evidently important to Hildegard and,
like her music and the designs for the nuns' liturgical habits,
was an attempt to imitate what she saw and heard in her
visions. Hildegard wrote to Pope Anastasius IV in 1 153/4 that
she had been inspired by God to 'form unknown letters, and
utter an unknown language, and to resound with melody in
many tones' . Her Vita also records that she 'composed chant
of surpassingly sweet melody with amazing harmony, and
Hildegard the Woman I 43
invented letters never seen before, with a language hi therto
unheard' . 35 The purpose of the language and its twenty-three
letter alphabet is not entirely clear. It has been dismissed as a
mental exercise, and hailed as an early insight into the genetic
code! Barbara Newman is probably on the right track, how
ever, when she links it to Hildegard's music and to the mystical
life of the community. 36 We should not be surprised that an
imagination as creative and an intelligence as keen as
Hildegard's delighted in such invention, a delight shared,
incidentally, by her compatriot and admirer, Stephan George,
some eight hundred years later.
AN EFFEMINATE AGE
Reading Hildegard we sense that we are in the presence of a
woman who was at peace with herself and who had made
sense of her place in the great scheme of creation. Hildegard
sought constantly to integrate all aspects of life . The super
natural realm, the natural world around her, human beings
with their corporeal existence; all were intimately related and
subject to the same laws. There is no aspect of life which did
not interest Hildegard and which did not come under the
scrutiny of her inner light . There are however contradictions
within Hildegard's writings and she adopts a somewhat dif
ferent style when speaking as a theologian and when speaking
as a medical practitioner or natural scientist. It is not surpris
ing, given the scope of her works and the attitudes of the time,
that she did not always achieve the synthesis which she had
intended.
Hildegard held certain traditional views of gender relations.
Women were seen as frailer than men, more diffuse in their
energies, more passive and (unusually for the period) were
thought to be weaker in their sexual appetites . Both male and
female visionary writers of the twelfth century referred to
themselves as 'weak women', a term which had become a
topos of humility, but which, when directed at women by
others, was used to disparage their works and to u ndermine
their authority . Her behaviour, however, departed from con
ventional female stereotypes and Hildegard succeeded in
44 I Hildegard of Bingen
turning prevailing categories on their head. She referred to
hers as an 'effemina te age' . Because men had become 'woman
ish' , God would make women virile . Traditional sex roles were
reversed; female authority was presented as a restitution of the
natural order, not as a threat or challenge to it. In a letter to a
negligent bishop Hildegard described a vision of Pure Knowl
edge as a female figure dressed in a bishop's pallium . This
female role model might well have been intended as a rep
resentation of Hildegard herself in her role as prophet. 37 In her
visions Hildegard saw the Church, the Synagogue and the
virtues as female figures, but certainly not as weak ones. Her
'living light' was none other than Wisdom, the female aspect of
the Godhead .
It is as though conventional sexual stereotypes never tell
the whole story, and Hildegard is continually modifying and
subverting them . She has strong intuitions about the inter
dependence and complementarity of all aspects of the world,
including men and women. In an exegesis of the scriptural
passage on the capable woman (Proverbs 31 . 10-1 1), Hildegard
describes strength and weakness as common to both men and
women . Woman's strength is seen as more supple and flexible
than man's (LM 28, 36) . In another passage (OW 5, 43) Hilde
gard explains how a man has greater strength and a woman
softer energy . The incarnation itself is seen as a coming
together of the strength of God and the frailty of humanity:
'And the divinity is strong while the flesh of the Son of God is
frail, that flesh by which the world is restored to its original life'
(LM 4, 36) . 38
Hildegard's belief in the complementarity of the sexes also
emerges in her interpretation of the passage from 1 Cor. 11 . 9,
'For the man was not created for the woman but the woman for
the man', which Hildegard modifies according to her own
philosophy:
46 I Hildegard of Bingen
position of the Cathars, who saw all bodily functions as
inimical to the spiritual life, Hildegard nevertheless regards
sexuality as a result of humanity's fallen state.
It is quite clear from Hildegard's descriptions of paradise
that human sexuality as we know it had no place. The love of
Adam and Eve for one another before the fall is contrasted with
the lust of man in his fallen state:
When man transgressed God's command, he was changed both in
body and min d . For the purity of his blood was turned into another
mode, so that, instead of purity, he now ejects the spume of semen.
If man had remained in paradise, he would have stayed in an
immutable and perfect state. But all these things, after his trans
gression, were turned into another and bitter mode. For man's
blood, burning in the ardour and heat of lust, ejects a spume from
itself that we call semen, as a pot placed on the fire brings up foam
from the water beca use of the flame's heat.
43
48 I Hildegard of Bingen
1 167, during a period of sickness, Hildegard was told that a
young noblewoman from the lower Rhine was being tor
mented by a demon . According to Hildegard, demons could
not enter or possess people but they could envelop and obsess
them. The demon troubling Sigewize had declared that only
Hildegard (referred to irreverently as 'Scrumpilgardis' or
'Wrinklegard') could help. Because of her infirmity Hildegard
did not want to treat Sigewize in person, but she wrote a
therapeutic drama for her which was to be performed with
great ceremony and seriousness (reminiscent of a shamanic
journey in which the sick person takes part with their imagin
ation) . A temporary improvement followed its performance,
but in the end Hildegard acceded to Sigewize's pleadings to be
treated in person and took her into the Rupertsberg convent.
Hildegard and the nuns were terrified at the prospect and
endured with difficulty the young woman's wild and frighten
ing behaviour. Their method of treatment was communal
prayer and ascetic practices. In this secure and supportive
environment the demon was allowed full expression and
gradually Sigewize's mental instability subsided and her
health returned. Hildegard claimed no miraculous powers,
but displayed sound psychotherapeutic judgement, com
passion and common sense, a combination which achieved the
desired result.
50 I Hildegard of Bingen
Hildegard Today
Notes
52 I Hildegard of Bingen
1 1 . The visionary experiences of these women are described in the
introduction to Beguine Spirituality, ed. Bowie (1989).
12. Dronke (1984), p. 153-4.
13. Newman (1985), p. 171.
14. ibid .
15. This is well expressed in the prologue to the Book of Divine Works,
where the 'voice from heaven' says: 'Commit to writing for the
benefit of humankind and in enduring form what you see with
your inner eyes and perceive with the inner ears of your soul so
that, through these things, people may come to know their
Crea tor and not recoil from worshipping him with the reverence
due to him. '
1 6 . Hildegard's work is not easily summarized, but one o f the best
attempts to do so is that by Heinrich Schipperges in Fiihrkotter
(1987) .
17. It is interesting that Hildegard seems to be giving pride of place
among the virtues here to poverty of spirit. In this she would
seem to anticipate later developments in the Rhineland (Meister
Eckhart and Johannes Tauler) in which this is emphatically the
case.
18. It is this orientation also which distinguishes Hildegard from
some of the later women visionary mystics. Unlike her great
compatriots, Mechthild of Magdeburg and Gertrude the Great for
instance, Hildegard is concerned primarily to instruct her audi
ence in the mysteries of the Christian revelation, and not to
express in a poetic voice the deepest stirrings of her spirit. It is this
fact which led some to speak of Hildegard as a 'prophetess' in her
own lifetime and to compare her with Deborah (e.g. Vita, II,
Prologue and ch. 6) . Cf. Margot Schmidt's excellent article on this
theme, 'Hildegard von Bingen als Lehrerin des Glaubens', in
Fiihrkotter (1972), pp. 95-157.
19. Newman (1987), p. 64.
20. This is, of course, the doctrine of exemplarism, which is given an
important impetus in the Middle Ages by Augustine.
21 . Hildegard has fnuch in common, therefore, with a later 'vitalism'.
There are key differences, however, in that for Hildegard, the life
of nature, while truly existing in itself, is transparent to i ts source,
which is the divine life. Hildegard also has a strong sense of the
order of things and of the necessarily harmonious proportions and
relations of all that exists. In Nietzsche's terms, the Dionysian is
well balanced by the Apollonian, therefore.
22. Unde et homo opus Dei cum omni creatura est. Sed et homo operarius
divinitatis esse dicitur (PL 197, 1 16C) .
Notes I 53
23. It is worth recalling that a primary source for Hildegard's inspi
ration must have been the Benedictine Rule, by which she lived,
and which is justly famed for its wise sense of moderation and the
avoidance of extremes.
24. 'Tradition and Innovation in Medieval Western Colour-Imagery'
in Dronke (1 984), p. 84 (first published in Eranos Jahrbuch XLI
(1 972), pp . 51-106). See also 'Die Bedeutung der Farben im Werk
Hildegards von Bingen' by Christel Maier in Fruhmittelalterliche
Studien, 6 (1972), especially pp. 280ff. and 285, in which Maier
establishes the relation in Hildegard's work between the colours
and the virtues.
25. It is important to see Hildegard within the tradition of those major
theologians, such as Pseudo-Denys and Scotus Eriugena, who
make extensive use of light imagery. Joseph Koch has wri tten an
interesting article on this theme, 'Uber die Lichtsymbolik im
Bereich der Philosophie', in Kleine Schriften, I, Rome (1973), pp.
27-67 (first published in Studium Generale 13 (1960), pp. 653-70) .
26. I am translating umbra here as 'reflection' rather than 'shadow',
which appears to make more sense in the context of Hildegard's
water imagery. Umbra is a word which suggests 'reflection', the
communication of a quality from one subject to another, but also
suggests 'shadow' or 'shade', which may signify the darkness
which is absence of light, or indeed, the darkness which is excess
of light. In Hildegard the secondary word obumbratio is also vitally
important, and it has the added association of being the Vulgate
translation for the 'overshadowing' of Mary by the Holy Spirit
(Luke 1 .35). There is an interesting article on the word umbra by
Peter Dronke in his The Medieval Poet and his World (Rome 1984),
'Theologia veluti quaedam poetria: Quelques observations sur la
fonction des images poetiques chez Jean Scot' (pp . 39-53; first
published in Jean Scot Erigene et l'histoire de la pl1ilosopl1ie, ed.
R. Roques, Colloques Intemationaux du CRNS No. 561 , Paris
(1977), pp . 243-52) . Image and reflection, and the theme of the
mirror, is the subject of Margot Schmidt's penetrating article in
Filhrkotter (1972) . Reflected radiance, as the communication of
faith, grace, love and glory, is shown to be central to Hildegard's
work.
27. Dronke (1984), p. 159.
28. See Bynum (1984), pp. 64-5.
29. For the texts of Hildegard's letters see PL 197; Dronke (1 984),
pp. 186-7 and Fi.ihrkotter (1965), pp. 207ff.
30. Dronke (1984), p. 169.
31 . Allchin (1 989), p. 134. Hildegard's descriptions of the garments
54 I Hildegard of Bingen
worn by the blessed in heaven, and emulated by her own nuns,
are strongly reminiscent of the prophet Ezekiel's account of
Jerusalem, decked as God's bride (16, 8-14).
32. Fiihrkotter (1965), p . 204. For the details of the correspondence
between Hildegard and Tengswindis and for some discussion
on it see Fiihrkotter (1965), pp. 204-5, and Dronke (1984), pp. 165
-71 .
33. Hildegard' s correspondence with the Mainz prelates i s discussed
in Fiihrkotter (1965), pp. 235-46, and Dronke (1984), pp. 196-9.
34. Newman (1988), p. 277.
35. Newman (1988), p . 316. See also Fiihrkotter (1965), pp . 8-41, PL
197: 1 52d; Vita, PL 197: lOlb.
36. Newman (1988), p . 18.
37. Newman (1985), p. 174.
38. Cited in Zurn Brunn and Epiney-Burgard (1989), p . 14.
39. Cited in Bynum (1984), pp. 93-4.
40. Cited in Flanagan (1989), p. 69.
41. Allchin (1989), p. 137.
42. Cited in Dronke (1984), p. 175.
43. Cited in Dronke (1984), pp. 176-7.
44. An account of this exorcism is to be found in Dronke (1984),
pp. 163-5.
Notes I 55
A Short Chronology of
Hildegard's Life
56 I Hildegard of Bingen
1 151-58 Composition of the Natural History and of Causes and
Cures.
1 151 Finishes Scivias. Richardis accepts election as
abbess of a convent at Bassum, near Bremen,
against Hildegard' s wishes.
1 152 Frederick I (Barbarossa) is elected King. Hildegard
writes him a letter in tribute.
Richardis dies .
After
1 154 Hildegard meets Frederick I at Ingelheim .
1 1 55 Hildegard persuades the monks of Disibodenberg
to relinquish the lands given as part of the nuns'
dowry.
1 1 58-61 Hildegard falls ill . She undertakes her first
preaching tour, which takes her along the River
Main as far as Bamberg.
1 1 58-63 Composition of the Book of Life's Merits.
1 1 59 Beginning of the eighteen-year long schism be
tween the papacy and Frederick I. First antipope is
Victor IV .
1 160 Hildegard' s second preaching tour. She preaches
publicly in Trier, and then proceeds by way of Metz
and Krauftal to Hordt.
1 161-63 Hildegard' s third preaching tour, following the
Rhine northwards to Cologne, and then on to
Werden.
1 1 63 She begins to write the Book of Divine Works. She
writes again to Frederick I, and appears to adopt a
neutral position in the schism.
1 164 Second antipope, Paschal III. Hildegard writes for a
third tnne to Frederick, this time adopting a critical
tone .
Around
1 1 65 Hildegard founds the community at Eibingen,
overlooking Rudesheim, on the east bank on the
Rhine, which she visits twice a week. She writes
to Henry II of England and to his wife, Queen
Eleanor.
A Short Chronology of Hildegard's Life I 57
1 1 67-70 Hildegard fall� ill again .
1 1 68 Third antipope, Callistus lll . Hildegard writes to
Frederick I, warning him of divine judgement.
1169 Hildegard heals the possessed woman, Sigewize,
and receives her into her community at Ruperts
berg.
1 1 70 Composition of the Life of St Disibod at request of
Abbot Helenger of Disibodenberg.
1 1 70(71) Hildegard's fourth preaching tour, which takes her
south to Zwiefalten .
1 1 73 Volmar, her secretary, dies.
1 1 73/74 She completes the Book of Divine Works. A conflict
arises regarding the appointment of Volmar's
successor.
1 1 74(75) The monk Gottfried arrives from Disibodenberg.
He begins to write the Life of Hildegard and com
pletes Book One.
1 1 75 Guibert of Gembloux begins a correspondence with
Hildegard. She sends him her Book of Life's Merits
and her Songs.
1 1 76 Gottfried dies.
1 1 77 Guibert of Gembloux becomes Hildegard' s sec
retary.
1 1 78 Interdict imposed on Rupertsberg by diocese of
Mainz.
1 1 79 Interdict lifted by Archbishop Christian of Mainz.
Hildegard dies on 17 September.
1 180-90 Theodoric of Echternach completes Books Two and
Three of the Life of Hildegard.
58 I Hildegard of Bingen
PART 2
Selections
TRANSLATOR'S NOTE
60 I Hildegard of Bingen
recen t years and terms like 'humankind' and 'humanity' have become
curren t in its s tead.
Previous . translators of Hildegard (Ronald Miller in the Letters,
Robert Cunnin gham in the Book of Divine Works and Bruce Hozes ki in
Scivias) have been rigorous, to the poin t of travesty, in their use of
inclusive language, removing personal pronouns for God, translating
homo as 'we' when the voice of the Living Light is speaking, and even,
1
in Hozes ki's case, rendering 'Son of God' as 'Word of God' . Neither
Hildegard nor feminism seems to be well served by such mendacities .
Hildegard pays lip service to the prevailing medieval order, de
preciating her role as a 'poor lit tle figure of a woman' even as she
berates wayward kings and corrupt popes. Paradoxically, in order to
see, in relief, the true originality of H ildegard's vision of the feminine
in God, we need to preserve her differentiation of gender, resis ting
the temptation to rewrite a twelfth-cen tury mystic as a twentieth
century feminist . Newman retains 'the singular collective man for a
very frequent medieval usage in which homo simultaneously
designates the human race and the unique individual Adam, in
whom the whole race is seminally presen t. '2 I have followed
Newman's example .
The choice of Latin texts has been necessarily eclectic. Until the
es tablishment of critical editions of all Hildegard's works, any transla
tion mus t be considered an in terim measure. For the Letters and the
Book of Divine Works, we are still largely reliant on J . P . Migne's edition
of H ildegard (PL, 197, 1855), although Pitra supplies the text for my
translation of the letter of Henry II of England and both Pitra and
Dronke provide separate texts for the letter to Guibert of Gembloux.
3
Heinrich Schipperges' Welt u nd Mensch: Das Buch 'De operatione Dei', is
based on the unpublished Ghent manuscript and I have been able to
supplemen t Migne's text from the lis t of variants appended to the
German translation. 4 For the Scivias, we are fortunate in having the
critical edition by Adelgundis Fiihrkotter and Angela Carlevaris
published in Corpus Christianorum: Co11 tinuatio Mediaeualis, Vols. 43
and 43A (Turnhout: Brepols, 1978) .
I have, in all cas�, translated directly from the Latin, s ubsequen tly
revising my version in response to divergent readings noted by Oliver
Davies in the German text.
Robert Carver
Worcester College, Oxford
Translator's Note I 61
1 . Cunningham and Miller's translations appear in Hildegard of Bingen's Book of
Divine Works, ed . Matthew Fox (Santa Fe: Bear & Company, 1987). Bruce
Hozeski, tr. , Scivias by Hildegard of Bingen (Santa Fe: Bear & Company,
1986).
2. Barbara Newman, Sister of Wisdom: St Hildegard's Theology of the Feminine
(Aldershot: Scalar Press, 1987), p. xix.
3. J. B. Pitra, ed., Analecta Sacra Spicilegio Solesmensi Tom. VIII (Paris: Jouby &
Roger, 1 882), pp. 556 and 33lff. Peter Dronke, Women Writers of the Middle
Ages (Cambridge: CUP, 1984), pp. 250ff. I have collated the two editions of
the Guibert letter and moved rather freely between them.
4 . Salzburg: Otto Muller Verlag (1965).
EDITORS' NOTE
The Extracts from the Life of Saint Hildegard by Godfrey and Theodoric,
the passages from Causes and Cures and the following letters:
Richardis von Stade, Abbess Hazzecha of Krauftal, Letter to an
Abbot, Abbot Ludwig of St Eucharius, and the Mainz Prelates, are
translated by Peter Dronke and are reprinted from Women Writers of
the Middle Ages, Cambridge University Press, 1984. We would like to
thank Professor Dronke and Cambridge University Press for their
kind permission to reprint these extracts. The references following
the passages from Hildegard's Life refer to the Berlin Manuscript,
Staatsbibl. Lat. Qu . 674, fols. lra-24vb (see Dronke (1984), pp.
240-1) .
The selections from The Book of Life's Merits were translated by Mark
Atherton and Oliver Davies, using Pitra but also with reference to
Schipperges' modern German translation. The Songs were translated
by Oliver Davies from Barbara Newman's critical edition of the
Symphonia (1988). The references are to Newman's edition. The
remaining passages (Scivias, The Book of Divine Works and the rest of
the Letters) were translated by Robert Carver (SC 1 14, 16 and DW 4, 78
have been slightly adapted by the editors). We are most grateful to all
the translators for their efforts to render Hildegard's powerful but
erratic Latin into modern English .
FB and OD
62 I Hildegard of Bingen
EXTRACTS FROM THE LIFE OF
SAINT HILDEGARD
by Godfrey and Theodoric
64 I Hildegard of Bingen
an audience in Mainz Cathedral, everyone said they stemmed
from God, and from that gift of prophecy which the prophets
of old had proclaimed . Then my writings were brought to Pope
Eugene, when he was in Trier. With joy he had them read out
in the presence of many people, and read them for himself,
and, with great trust in God's grace, sending me his blessing
with a letter, he bade me commit whatever I saw or heard in
my vision to writing, more comprehensively than hitherto.'
B 6vb-7va
Dronke 145-6
B 8va-9vb
Dronke 150-1
SC Introduction
68 I Hildegard of Bingen
..
SC In troduction
70 I Hildegard of Bingen
The Spirit of God
gives life to the soul and
to the body
You see, as it were, a woman, who has in her womb the complete figure
ofa human being. This means that after the woman has received
human seed a child is formed, perfect in all its parts, in the
hidden chamber of her belly. And behold, through the secret
plan of the supreme Creator, the same figure displays animated
motion. For when, in accordance with the secret and hidden
order and will of God, at an appropriate time rightly deter
mined by divine providence, the child in its mother's womb
has received the spirit, it shows by the movement of its body
that it is alive. In the same way, the earth reveals itself and
brings forth its crop of flowers when the dew has fallen upon
it, just as the fiery sphere (having none of the features of the human
body) takes possession of that same figure's heart. For the soul,
blazing in the fire of profound knowledge, discerns various
things in the orbit of its understanding. And, not having the
form of human parts (since it is itself neither corporeal nor
fallen like the human body), it greatly strengthens our heart
because, being the foundation of the body, it rules the whole,
just as the firmament of heaven contains the things below and
protects the things above . The soul also affects the brain
because, in its powers, it understands the things not only of
earth but of heaven, when it knows God wisely. And it pours
itself through all pf our parts, since it has bestowed on the
whole body the vigour of the marrow and of the veins and of all
the limbs, just as the tree gives sap and greenness from the root
to all its branches .
As it emerges from its mother, this same figure of a human being
(which has been given life in this way) also changes colour, according
to the motions which the sphere itself makes within it. For after we
have received the life-giving spirit in our mother's womb, once
Scivias I 71
The Spirit of God gives life to the soul and to the body
we have been born in this way and begun to express ourselves
in action, our own worth is apparent in terms of the works
which the soul performs with the body. For we clothe
ourselves with brightness from good things and with darkness
from bad.
SC I 4, 16
SC I 4, 26
The Trinity
Just as the flame contains three essences in the one fire, so too,
there is one God in three persons. How is this so? The flame
consists of shining.brightness, purple vigour and fiery glow. It
has shining brightness so that it may give light; purple vigour
so that it may flourish; and a fiery glow so that it may burn.
In the shin ing brightness, observe the Father who, in his
fatherly devotion, reveals his brightness to the faithful. In the
purple vigour contained within it (whereby this same flame
manifests its power), understand the Son who, from the
Virgin, assumed a body in which Godhead demonstrated its
Scivias I 73
The true unity of the Trinity
miracles. And in the fiery glow, perceive the Holy Spirit which
pours glowingly into the minds of believers .
But where there is neither shining brightness, nor purple
vigour, nor fiery glow, there no flame is seen. So too, where
neither the Father nor the Son nor the Holy Spirit is honoured,
there God is not worthily revered.
And so, just as these three essences are discerned in the one
fla me, so too, three Persons are to be understood in the unity
of Godhead.
SC II 2, 6
On baptism
He who has believed and been baptized will be saved; but he who has
not believed will be damned. What does this mean? That man who
has seen through his understanding (which is the inner eye)
what is hidden to external sight, and does not waver in this -
he most certainly believes. This is faith. For what we perceive
externally, we also know externally; and what we see internal
ly, we also contemplate internally. So it is that when our
understanding, looking ardently through the mirror of life,
perceives the incomprehensible Godhead which the outer eye
is unable to see, then the desires of the flesh are laid low and
crushed to the ground.
Therefore, the spirit of that man sighs towards the true
height. It feels the regeneration which was brought by the Son
of Man. The Son of Man was conceived of the Holy Spirit. His
Mother did not receive him in lust from the flesh of a sweating
male, but from the secret part of the Father of all things.
Coming in sweetness, he shows in the water the most pure
and living mirror, so that through it man lives in regeneration .
For just as man is born from flesh, created by the divine
power in the form of Adam, so the Holy Spirit restores the life
of the soul through the pouring over of water. The water
Scivias I 75
receives into itself the spirit of man as it rouses it to life, just as
his spirit was revived previously in the wave of blood, when it
was· revealed in a vessel of flesh. For just as the form of man is
fashioned through love, so that it is called 'man', so too, the
spirit of man is given life in the water before the eyes of God, so
that God acknowledges him in the inheritance of life .
So it is that he who accepts the fountain of deliverance with
the covenant of Justice finds life in salvation because he
faithfully believes . But he who does not wish to believe is
dead, since he does not have the breath of the Holy Spirit on
which to fly to the heights of heaven. Feeling his way with
blind eyes, he trembles in the clouded understanding of the
flesh, without being alive. For he lacks the life-enabling disci
pline which God has breathed into mankind to counteract the
mounting will of the flesh.
SC I I 3, 30
SC II 5, 46
On the Eucharist
'
'Eat, my friends, drink and get drunk, my dearest ones. What does
this mean? Eat in faith, you who have come to my friendship
through holy baptism . For the pouring out of my Son's blood
has wiped from you Adam's fall . Think upon the true remedy
in the body of my Only-Begotten, so that the crimes you
frequently repeat when you commit injustice in your works
may be wiped mercifully from you . Drink in hope from this
Scivias I 77
vine which has led you from eternal punishment. Take up the
cup of salvation, so that you may believe firmly and
courageously in that grace by which you have been redeemed.
For you too will be drenched in that blood which was poured
out for you. Become drunk with love, you who are most
beloved of me. Be overflowing in the rivulets of the Scriptures,
so that you tear yourselves away with the highest zeal from the
·
desires of the flesh . Then I may kindle in you the dazzling
virtues that are so lovely to me, as I hand over to you the body
and blood of my Only-Begotten, just as he himself gave the
same sacrament to his disciples, as is written in the Gospel . '
S C II 6, 21
S C II 6, 28
S C I I 6 , 92
•
S C III 5, 6
Chastity
The seventh figure represents Chastity. For once people have
placed their hope fully in God, the work grows to perfection
within them, so that they begin in chastity to restrain them
selves from fleshly desires. Chastity, in the flower of the flesh,
feels abstinence most keenly, just as a young maiden feels the
glow of desire, yet does not attempt to look back at a man .
In this way, Chastity casts aside all that is unclean, panting
with glorious desires towards her delightful lover. He is the
sweetest and loveliest essence of all good things amongst the
delights of all the powers which stem from constancy; and he
can be perceived by his lovers only with the inner beauty of the
soul.
For this reason, Chastity is clothed in a tunic, purer, more
full of light than crystal. It shines with a brilliance like the ·
glittering of water drenched with sun. For she is dazzling in
her single purpose, and utterly clean of any of the dust of
concupiscence's burning lust. She is wonderfully strength
ened through the Holy Spirit and has been clothed in the robe
of innocence. Her robe shines in the dazzling whiteness of the
fountain of living water which is the brilliant sun of eternal
brightness.
80 I Hildegard of Bingen
Above her head, turned towards her face, stands a dove, its
wings stretched as though for flight. This signifies that, from
the outset, Chastity was cherished by the expanse and shading
of the wings - that is, by the protection of the Holy Spirit -
which enabled her to fly through the twists and turns of the
devil's snares. She sees her way by means of the fiery love of
holy inspiration, guiding herself towards the place where she
reveals the countenance of her sweetness.
SC III 8, 24
Divine Wisdom
You see a figure of great beauty standing on the top of this fl.oor. This
means that this virtue was in the Father on high 'before all
creation', arranging in his judgement all the materials of cre
ation established in heaven and on earth. She herself, it is
clear, shines in him as a great adornment, being the broadest
step amongst the steps of the other virtues in him. She is joined
to him in a dance, in the sweetest embrace of blazing love.
Wisdom looks towards the people on the earth. For she always
rules and defends with her protection those who try to follow
her, loving them greatly because they are steadfast in her. For
that same figure signifies the Wisdom of God: since, through
her, all things were created and are ruled by God. Her head
shines like lightn ing: with such brightness that you cannot have your
fill of gazing upon it. For the Godhead is both terrible and
enticing to all creption, seeing and contemplating all things,
just as the human eye discerns what is placed before it. Yet no
mortal can ultimately comprehend the Godhead, in all the
profundity of its mystery.
Wisdom arranges her hands reverently upon her breast. This
signifies the power of Wisdom which she wisely restrains, so
that she directs every work of hers in such a way that no one
can resist her, either in prudence or power.
Scivias I 81
Her feet on the same floor, are hidden from your sight. For her
way, concealed in the heart of the Father, lies open to no
mortal. Her secrets are naked and manifest to God alone . She
has on her head a ring in the form of a crown, shining with great
brilliance. This signifies that the majesty of God, being without
beginning or end, shines with an incomparable glory, God
head radiating with such splendour that mortal minds are
overwhelmed. As for her being clothed in a tunic the colour of
gold; this signifies that the work of Wisdom is frequently
considered as though it were the purest gold. For this reason,
she is adorned with a belt that descends from her breast right down to
her feet, decorated with most precious jewels and glittering in a
brilliant play of green and white and red and sky-blue. For, from
the beginning of the world, when Wisdom first displayed her
work openly, she already extended as far as the end of the
world, like a single path, adorned with holy and just com
mands, that is to say, with the first planting of the green seed
of the patriarchs and of the prophets who, in wretched lam
entation for their suffering, entreated with such great desire
for the Son of God to be made flesh. Then she was graced with
the dazzling virginity of the Virgin Mary; next, with the solid
and ruddy faith of the martyrs; and finally with the brilliant
and light-filled love of contemplation, by which God and
neighbour ought to be loved through the heat of the Holy
Spirit.
She will go on in this way until the end of the world, and her
warning will not cease but will flow out always, as long as the
world endures.
SC III 9, 25
Spiritual music
Just as the power of God, extending everywhere, surrounds
all things without encountering any resistance, so too, the
82 I Hildegard of Bingen
rationality of man has the great ability to sound through living
voices and to rouse listless souls to wakefulness in music.
Even David demonstrates this in the music of his prophecy
and Jeremiah shows it in the sorrowful voice of his lamen
tation. So it is that even you - a poor, weak-natured little woman -
hear, in music, the sound of fiery ardour in the virgin's blush, in the
embracing words of the budding twig; the sound of keenness from the
living lights tlzat shine in the celestial city; the sound of prophecy in
deep sermons; tlze sound of marvellous words from the enlarging of the
apostleship; the sound of blood being poured ou t by those wlzo offer
themselves up in faith; the sound of the priestly mysteries being
observed; and the sound of the virgin 's step on the lzeavenly greenness
of flowering tlzings. For faithful creation echoes back to the
heavenly Creator with its voice of exultation and joy, returning
frequent thanks. But you also hear a sound like the voice of a great
tl1rong, resounding in harmony in the complaints of those recalled to
tlie same steps. For music not only rejoices in the unanimity of
exultation of those who bravely persevere along the path of
righteousness . It also exults in the concord of reviving those
who have fallen away from the path of justice and are lifted up
at last to blessedness. For even the good shepherd joyfully led
back to the flock the sheep that had been lost.
SC III 13, 13
SC III 13, 14
84 I Hildegard of Bingen
THE BOOK OF LIFE'S MERITS
LM 1, 1 6-17
LM 2, 93
86 I Hildegard of Bingen
The vice of forgetting about God
Forgetting about God leads to harmful thoughts and idle
chatter such as: 'How can we know about God if we have never
seen him? And why should we have any regard for him if we
have never set eyes on him?' People who talk like that are no
longer mindful of their Creator, and their minds are smothered
in the darkness of unbelief. For when man fell, darkness fell on
the whole of creation. But God had created human beings to be
full of light so that they could see the radiance of pure ether
and hear the songs of angels. He had clothed them in such
radiance that they shone with the splendour of it. But all this
was lost when man disobeyed God's commandment and so
caused nature to fall with him. Yet the natural elements
retained a glimmering of their former pristine position, which
human sin could not destroy completely . For which reason
people should retain a glimmering of their knowledge of God .
They should allow God to return t o the centre o f their lives,
recognizing that they owe their very existence to no one else
save God alone, who is the Creator of all .
LM 4, 67
88 I Hildegard of Bingen
ranee of life-giving power, just as the summer is filled with the
scent of green plants and flowers.
They followed the way of life of God's incarnate Son and
their hearts soared to great heights. They vowed to God to
preserve their virginity in awe and sacred worship . So now,
rejoicing with them, the Lamb of God lifts up his voice. A
sweet breath of wind, rising from the depths of God, touches
these emblems of their crowned virginity so that they start to
join in the song of the Lamb, a music unknown to those who
do not possess such emblems but who are overjoyed when
they finally hear it. And because they trod the path taken by
God when he became man by ancient design, their shoes
shone with such a light so that it was as if they had been taken
from a spring of living water.
LM 6, 43-6, 48
Hildegard' s commission
For five years I had been troubled by true and wonderful
visions. For a true vision of the unfailing light had shown me
(in my great ignorance) the diversity of various ways of life . In
the sixth year (which marked the beginning of the present
visions), when I was sixty-five years of age, I saw a vision of
such mystery and power that I trembled all over and - because
of the frailty of my body - began to sicken. It was only
after seven years that I finally finished writing down this
vision. And so, in the year of our Lord's incarnation, 1 1 63,
when the apostolic throne was still being oppressed by the
Roman Emperor, Frederick, a voice came to me from heaven,
saying:
90 J Hildegard of Bingen
And so I, a poor and feeble little figure of a woman, set my
hands to the task of writing - though I was worn down by so
many illnesses, and trembling. All this was witnessed by that
man [Volmar] whom (as I explained in my earlier visions) I had
sought and found in secret, as well as by that girl [Richardis]
whom I mentioned in the same context.
While I was doing this, I looked up at the true and living light
to see what I ought to write. For everything which I had
written since the beginning of my visions (or which I came to
understand afterwards) I saw with the inner eyes of my spirit
and heard with my inner ears, in heavenly mysteries, fully
awake in body and mind - and not in dreams, nor in ecstasy, as
I explained in my previous visions. Nor (as truth is my
witness) did I produce anything from the faculty of the human
sense, but only set down those things which I perceived in
heavenly mysteries.
And again I heard a voice from heaven instructing me thus;
and it said: 'Write in this way, just as I tell you.'
OW Foreword
92 I Hildegard of Bingen
is called the Holy Spirit; just as God marked it in man in whom
there are body, soul and rationality.
But the fact that I flame above the beauty of the fields
signifies the earth, which is the stuff from which God made
man . And my shining in the waters accords with the soul;
because just as the water pours over the whole earth, so the
soul pervades the whole body. That I glow in the sun and the
moon, signifies rationality; but the stars are the countless
words of rationality . And the fact that by means of the airy
wind I stir everything into quickness with a certain invisible
life which sustains all, signifies this: those things which ad
vance in growth are animated and sustained by the air and
wind and remain quite unchanged in their essence . '
DW l , 2
DW 2, 19
DW 4, 1 1
96 I Hildegard of Bingen
corrupt deeds . And just as the sun declines in the afternoon,
so too, the soul makes accord with the flesh . And as the moon
is rekindled by the sun so that it does not disappear, so the
flesh of man is sustained by the powers of the soul, so that it
does not go to ruin.
DW 4, 24
DW 4, 78
ow 4, 89
98 I Hildegard of Bingen
brightness is unfailing since in it there can be no death. How is
this so? God alone exists through and in himself and did not
receive his being from anyone else . But everything else in
creation takes its beginning from him.
DW 5, 14
DW B, 1
Love speaks
But now the first figure began to speak: 'I am Love - the
radiance of the livip.g God. Wisdom has performed her work
with me, and Humility (who is rooted in the living fountain) is
my helper. To her, Peace clings. And through the brightness
that I am, the living light of the blessed angels blazes. For, just
as a ray flashes from a lamp, so this brightness shines in the
blessed angels - nor could it do otherwise, since a light cannot
help but shine . For I designed man, who was rooted in me like
a reflected image, just as the semblance of each thing is seen in
OW 8, 2
OW 8, 2
DW 8, 2
DW 8, 3
DW B, 4
DW 9, 2
ow 10, 16
OW Epilogue, 38
(De colerica) There are other women who have slender flesh
but big bones, moderately sized veins and dense red blood.
They are pallid in colouring, prudent and benevolent, and
men show them reverence and are afraid of them. They suffer
much loss of blood in menstruation; their womb is well de
veloped and they are fertile . And men like their conduct, yet
flee from them and avoid them to some extent, for they can
interest men but not make men desire them. If they do get
married, they are chaste, they remain loyal wives and live
healthily with their husband; and if they are unmarried, they
tend to be ailing - as much because they do not know to what
man they might pledge their womanly loyalty as because they
lack a husband . . .
(De melancolica) But there are other women who have gaunt
flesh and thick veins and moderately sized bones; their blood
is more lead-coloured than sanguine, and their colouring is as
it were blended with grey and black. They are changeable and
free-roaming in their thoughts, and wearisomely wasted away
in affliction; they also have little power of resistance, so that at
times they are worn out by melancholy. They suffer much loss
of blood in menstruation, and they are sterile, because they
have a weak and fragile womb. So they cannot lodge or retain
or warm a man's seed, and thus they are also healthier,
1 10 I Hildegard of Bingen
stronger and happier without husbands than with them -
especially because, if they lie with their husbands, they will
tend to feel weak afterwards . But men turn away from them
and shun them, because they do not speak to men affectionate
ly, and love them only a Ii ttle . If for some hour they experience
sexual joy, it quickly passes in them. Yet some such women, if
they unite with robust and sanguine husbands, can at times,
when they reach a fair age, such as fifty, bear at least one child
. . . If their menopause comes before the just age, they will
sometimes suffer gout or swellings of the legs, or will incur an
insanity which their melancholy arouses, or else back-ache or a
kidney-ailment . . . If they are not helped in their illness, so
that they are not freed from it either by God's help or by
medicine, they will quickly die.
Hildegard's Songs \ 1 13
Antiphon for the Virgin I
Today, there opens for us
A door once closed,
Which a serpent barred in a woman:
And so there gleams the flower of our Lady,
Brilliant in the dawn.
(11)
Hildegard's Songs I 1 15
Alleluia for the Virgin
Alleluia!
0 branch Mediatrix,
Your sacred womb
Overcame death
And illumined
All creatures
In the fair flower
Born of the sweetest integrity
Of your sealed chastity.
( 18 )
Hildegard's Songs I 1 17
Antiphon for the Holy Spirit I
The Holy Spirit is life that gives life,
Moving all things.
It is the root in every creature
And purifies all things,
Wiping away sins, ·
Anointing wounds.
It is radiant life, worthy of praise,
Awakening and enlivening
All things.
(24)
1 18 I Hildegard of Bingen
Antiphon for divine love
Love
Gives herself to all things,
Most excellent in the depths,
And above the stars
Cherishing all:
For the High King
She has given
The kiss of peace.
(25)
(44)
for analysis.
So tell me please what all of this seems to you to signify - for I
am someone untaught by any schooling in external matters
(though I have been taught within, in my soul), so that I speak,
as though in doubt. But having heard of your wisdom and
your holiness, I know that I will be comforted. For I have not
dared to tell these things to anyone (since I have heard that
there are many schisms in the world) except to a certain monk
whose conduct in the community won my approval. To him I
revealed all my secrets and he did indeed reassure me that
these were great and worthy of reverence . Father, for the love
of God, I want you to comfort me, and I will be certain.
Two years ago, I saw you in this vision as one who looked
into the sun without being frightened - a truly brave man. And
I wept because I blush so deeply and am so timorous.
Noble and most gentle Father, I depend upon your soul.
Make it clear to me, if you will, through this exchange,
whether I should say these things in the open or maintain my
silence . For it costs me great pains to say what I have seen and
heard in this vision . Yet, because I have kept silent, I have been
laid out by this vision all this time on my bed, in great sickness,
unable even to lift myself up. And so I wail before you,. in
sorrow. For I am prone to the motion of the wine-press lever in
my nature - the nature sprung from the root that rose from the
Devil's promptings, which entered into Adam, and made him
an outcast in an alien world. But now, rising up, I run to you . I
tell you: You are not moved by that lever but are always lifting
it up. You are a vanquisher in your soul, raising not just
yourself, but the world as well, towards salvation.
You are also the eagle looking at the sun. I beg you, through
the serenity of the Father and through his wondrous Word,
through the sweet tears of remorse, the Spirit of truthfulness,
the holy sound with which all creation echoes, and that very
128 I Hildegard of Bingen
Word from which the world was born, and through the
loftiness of the Father who, in sweet greening, sent the Word
into the Virgin's womb, from which it sucked flesh, just as
honey is walled around by the comb. And may that very
sound, the power of the Father, fall into your heart, and lift up
your mind so that you are not numbed when you receive my
words, so long as you seek all things from God, or from man,
or from the mystery itself, until you pass through the opening
in your soul, to know all these things in God .
Farewell. Be strong in your soul and firm in God's struggle .
Amen.
But now the living light says to the sons of that throng: You are
the walls of the Temple; for the primitive Church set you in
place. So shun vanity and pride and avoid the whirlwind of
unrest. Look at these things now with living eyes; and hear
these words by listening with your inner ears. I do not see yorn
community being scattered, although it will feel the smart o
many whips. Live therefore and be vigilant in God. For in tht
true vision, I saw some in that congregation who have the rec
glow of the dawn, who glitter like sapphire, who shine like tht
light of the stars . For those who glow red like the dawn, hole
God in fear and willingly observe, on his account, the precept�
of the community Rule; although, due to the flesh, they seem
now and then to stray from the path, like a sacrificial beast
being led to the slaughter .
But those who shine like the sapphire, love God, and hence
do not commit grave sins, although they do sin; and it is their
custom to chastise themselves readily for their transgressions.
But those who shine like the light of the stars are full of
good-will and consequently do not quarrel with others, but
they hold in check the petulance of childish na tures and
willingly abstain from serious sins, considering them hateful.
And I have seen others enveloped in the blackness of acrid
136 I Hildegard of Bi11gen
smoke, because of their habitually foul behaviour. Some of
the se are acrid because of the peculiar nature of their minds.
For they love riches, and consequently do not love the spiritual
way of life.
Letter to an abbot
Hildegard uses her medical analysis of people's characters to console a
friend, an unknown abbot who is evidently experiencing some diffi
culties with his community.
These words come not from me nor from any other mortal: but
I present them as I received them in a vision from above. 0
servant of God, through the mirror of faith in which you look
in order to know God; 0 son of God, through the fashioning of
man in whom God wrought and expressed his miracles (for
just as a mirror - in which all manner of things are seen - is
placed in its frame, so too, the rational soul is inserted in the
body, as though in a vessel of clay; so that, through it, the body
may be guided in its mode of living and the heavenly soul may
be contemplated through faith), listen to what the unfailing
light says:
Man is both of heaven and of earth - through the good
understanding of his rational soul, he is heavenly; and
through his evil understanding, he is frail and full of shadows;
and the more he identifies himself with good things, the more
completely he loves God. For if he saw his face in the mirror,
befouled and sp1inkled with dust, he would be anxious to
wipe it clean. So that even if he understands that he has sinned
and been entangled in a variety of vanities, let him sigh; since
he knows, in his good understanding, that he has been defiled;
and let him lament with the psalmist, saying, 'O wretched
daughter of Babylon, blessed is the man who will pay you back
the retribution you have bestowed on us; blessed he, who will
seize your children and dash them against the rock' .
Hildegard's Letters I 143
Which is to say: man's desire was confounded through the
serpent's venom. For in itself it is poor and destitute, since in
speculative knowledge it lacks an honourable reputation, for it
does not desire to seek the glory of eternal life, of which it has a
foretaste through its good knowledge. But blessed is he who
will grasp the fact that he lives from God, and whose under
standing shows him that God made him and redeemed him
and who, because of this freedom which God gave him,
obliterates the evil habit of his sins, and hurls against that rock
(which is the chief support of blessedness), all the misery and
poverty he has in heavenly riches. For when man recognizes
the foul rottenness in himself, and cannot restrain himself by
any means from tasting sin, then the pitch-black birds defile
him utterly .
And although man knows that he exists in this way and that
he lives in the infinite life, he is nevertheless unable to prevent
himself from sinning frequently . And so, how full of wonder
and of sorrow is the cry, that God made such vessels of clay, all
starry with his miracles, when the vessels themselves could
not forsake sin, unless through the grace of God it was
forbidden them. Not even Peter was immune; Peter who
fervently vowed that he would never deny the Son of God .
Nor were many other holy men, who fell in their sins, but
afterwards became more useful and more excellent than they
would have been had they not fallen.
0 faithful servant, I, a poor little figure of a woman, tell you
these words again in a true vision. Even if it pleased God to lift
up my body in this vision in the same way as my soul, fear
would still not retreat from my mind and heart, because,
although I have been enclosed since I was a child, I know that I
am human. Many wise men have been so inspired by miracles
that they have revealed a great many mysteries, but because of
vanity they have credited these to themselves and so have
fallen. But those who, in the soaring of their souls, have drunk
their wisdom from God and reckoned themselves as nothing,
these have become the pillars of heaven. Such was the case
144 I Hildegard of Bingen
with Paul who surpassed the other disciples in his preaching
and yet reckoned himself as nothing. John the Evangelist, too,
was full of gentle humility, so that he drank deeply of the
Godhead .
And how could I, a poor little woman, not know what I am?
God works where he wills, for the glory of his name, and not
for that of mortals. Indeed, I have always trembled with fear,
since I am not confident of any ability in myself; but I hold out
my hands to God, so that I might be supported by him, like a
feather which has no weight or strength and which flies on the
wind. And I cannot fully understand what I see while I remain
in the service of the body and the invisible soul, since human
beings are deficient in both these respects.
But ever since I was a child (when I was not yet strengthened
in my bones and nerves and veins) I have always seen this
vision in my soul, right up to the present time, when I am over
seventy, and my soul, just as God willed, climbs in this vision,
through the changes of atmosphere, to the top of the firma
ment and spreads itself out amongst different peoples,
although they are a long way away from me in distant regions
and places. And since I see these things in this way in my soul,
I therefore also see them according to the changing of the
clouds and of other creatures. But I do not hear these things
with my outer ears, nor do I perceive them with the rational
parts of my mind, nor with any combination of my five senses;
but only in my soul, with my outer eyes open, so that I never
suffer in them any unconsciousness induced by ecstasy, but I
see them when I am awake, by day and by night. And I am
constantly constrained by my infirmities, and many times I
have been so enveloped by grave afflictions that they
threatened to set death upon me, but up till now, God has
sustained me.
The light which I see is not confined to one place, but it is far,
far brighter than a cloud which carries the sun; nor can I gauge
its height or length or breadth, and it is known to me by the
name of the 'reflection of the living light'. And just as the sun,
Hildegard's Letters I 145
the moon and the stars appear in the waters, so the Scriptures,
sermons and virtues and certain works that humans have
wrought, shine on me brightly in this light.
Whatever I see or learn in this vision, I hold in my memory
for a long time; so that when I recall what I have seen and
heard, I simultaneously see and hear and understand and, as it
were, learn in this moment, what I understand . But wha t I do
not see, I do not understand, because I am unlearned. And
what I write in the vision, I see and hear; nor do I put down
words other than those I hear in the vision, and I present them
in Latin, unpolished, just as I hear them in the vision. For I am
not taught in this vision to write as the philosophers write; and
the words in this vision are not like those which sound from
the mouth of man, but like a trembling flame, or like a cloud
stirred by the clear air.
I also have no means of knowing the form of this light, in the
same way that I cannot look directly at the ball of the sun. In
the same light I sometimes (b ut infrequently) see another light
which is known to me by the name of the living light - but
when and how I see it, I cannot tell. And while I am looking at
it, all sorrow and all perplexity are drained from me, so that I
seem then to have the character of an innocent girl and not that
of a little old woman.
Yet besides the chronic sickness which I suffer, I find it
wearying sometimes to relate the words and visions which are
shown to me there . But when my soul experiences the sight of
these things, I am transformed into another character, be
cause, as I said, I consign to oblivion all sadness and distress.
And wha t I see and hear in this same vision, my soul drinks as
though from a spring; but the spring remains full and un
depleted . But at no hour is my soul without the light I spoke of,
which is called 'the reflection of the living ligh t'. I see it as
though I were in a shining cloud, looking at a firmament
withou t stars; and in it I see the things of which I often speak
and which I give in answer to those who ask abou t the shining
of the living light.
146 I Hildegard of Bingen
But in these two respects - in my body and my soul I do not-
The sun arises at dawn and, from the place where it is set,
perfuses all the clouds with its brightness by beholding them,
and rules and lights up all creatures by its ardour, running its
course to twilight: in the same way God has made the whole of
creation - which is man - and then has vivified and lit it with
the breath of life .
For as the earliest dawn rises with damp cold and changing
cloud-shapes, so man in his childhood has damp coldness,
since his flesh is still growing and his bones are not yet filled
with marrow, nor is his blood yet sparkling in full redness .
But, as the third hour of the day begins to grow hot in the sun's
course, so he too, chewing different foods, acquires their taste,
and at the same time learns to walk. When childhood is over,
man in youth becomes daring, joyful and serene, making his
own plans for what he would like to begin, so that if, turning to
the right side, he chooses the good in the sun's light, he will
become fruitful in good deeds; but if, pursuing evil, he inclines
Hildegard's Letters I 147
down to the left side, he will grow black and most foul in sin .
But when, accomplishing his course of action, he arrives at the
ninth hour, he will falter and dry up in flesh and marrow, and
in the other forces with which he advanced as he grew. So too
the highest craftsman has drawn up the ages of the world,
ordered in time from dawn to twilight.
But you, father, who are so named after the Father, reflect on
how you began, and how you proceeded in life: for in your
childhood you were foolish, and in youth you were filled with
joyous assurance . Meanwhile you have embarked on an
adventure of the unicorn - unknown to you in your youth -
and this indeed was my writing, which often carries echoes of
the mortal dress of the Son of God, who, loving a maidenly
nature, resting in it like the unicorn in the maiden's lap,
gathered the whole Church to himself with the sweetest sound
of fairest believing.
Remember too, loyal father, what you often used to hear for
a poor little womanly creature soft in form, about that dress of
the Son of God; and, because my helper has been taken away
by the highest Judge, I now am entrusting what I have written
to you, asking imploringly that you preserve it carefully, and
look over it, correcting it lovingly, that your name too may be
written in the book of life, imitating the blessed Gregory in
this, who, despite the burden of his Roman episcopate, never
ceased composing, impelled by the lute-like sound of the
infusion of the Holy Spirit.
Put on celestial armour like a noble knight, washing away
the deeds of foolishness of your youth, and toil strenuously in
the noonday in the angelic robe of your monk's habit, before
the day declines, so that you may be welcomed joyously in the
heavenly tents into the angels' company.
HILDEGARD'S WORKS
Scivias
Migne J . P., ed., Patrologia Latina, vol. 197 (PL) .
Fuhrkotter A . , and Carlevaris, A . , (modern critical edition) Hilde
gardis - Scivias. Corpus Clzristianorum: co11 ti11uatio 111ediae11alis,
Brepols, Turnhout, Belgium, vols. 43 & 43A, 1978.
Bockeler, M . , (German translation), Wisse die Wege - Scivias . St Augus
tinus Verlag, Berlin, 1 928; Otto Muller Verlag, Salzburg, 1 954, repr.
1987. Includes colour plates of the illustrated Rupertsberg manu
script of Scivias.
Hart, C., and Bishop, T., (Engtish translation), Hildegard of Bi11gen:
Scivias. The Classics of Western Spirituality. Paulist Press, New
York, 1 990. Introduction by Barbara Newman, Preface by Caroline
Walker Bynum. Includes black and white illustrations from the
Rupertsberg manuscript.
Hozeski, B. (abridged English translation), Hildegard of Bingen's
'Scivias'. Bear & Company, Santa Fe, 1986.
Uber vitae meritorum ('The Book of Life's Merits')
Pitra, J . P., Analecta sacra, vol . VIII, (Pi).
Schipperges, H . , (German translation), Der Mensch in der Verant
wortung - Uber vitae meritorum . Otto Muller Verlag, Salzburg, 1 972.
Uber divinoru m operum ('The Book of Divine Works'), (PL) .
Schipperges, H . , (German translation), Welt und Mensch - Das Buch:
De operatione Dei. Otto Muller Verlag, Salzburg, 1 965. Includes
colour plates from the illuminated Lucca manuscript of The Bouk of
Divine Works.
Fox, M . , (ed . ), (abridged English translation, including some of
Hildegard's letters and songs), Hildegard of Bingen's Book of Divi11e
Works, Bear & Company, Santa Fe, 1987.
'3ECONDARY WORKS
Allchin, A. M . , 'Julian of Norwich and Hildegard of Bingen', Mount
Carmel, vol . 37, no. 3, Autumn 1989, Oxford, pp. 1 28-43.
Bonn, C . , Der Mensch in der Entscheidu ng: Gedanken zur ganzheitlichen
Schau Hildegards von Bingen . Abtei St Hildegard, Eibingen, 1986.
Briick, Anton, ed . , Hildegard von Bingen, 1 1 79-1 979 . Festscl1rift zum 800
Todestag der Heiligen. Mainz 1979.
Clifford Rose, F . , and Gawel, M . , Migraine: The Facts . Oxford 1981 .
Dronke, P., 'The Composition of Hildegard of Bingen's Symphonia',
Sacris Erudiri 19, 1969-70, pp. 381-93.
Dronke, P . , Poetic Individuality in the Middle Ages . Clarendon Press,
Oxford, 1970.
Select Discography I 1 57