Case Discussion Questions
Case Discussion Questions
Case Discussion Questions
1. Assess the attractiveness of the Indian sugar industry using Porter’s five forces
model. Discuss the impact of the following factors on its attractiveness:
a) Relative bargaining power differences between farmers and sugar producers;
b) Government regulations; and
c) Global sugar producers.
2. What are the critical success factors of Indian sugar industry?
3. Discuss whether the following possibilities could improve the attractiveness of Indian
sugar industry:
a) Changes in the industry forces within a foreseeable period of time;
b) Deregulation; and
c) Focus on by-products such as ethanol.
4. Compare the characteristics of Brazilian and Indian sugar industries and discuss
whether there is a possibility of convergence of these two industries in terms of their
structural characteristics.
Wil’s Grill
1. Discuss the resources and capabilities of Wil’s Grill and identify its core
competencies in the street food market segment using VRIN framework.
2. What are the strengths, weaknesses, opportunities and threats for Wil’s Grill? Identify
various strategic options for Wil’s Grill by creating a SWOT matrix.
3. You have identified the resources, capabilities and core competencies of Wil’s Grill
developed in the street food market segment while answering question 1. Now,
discuss the transferability of those resources, capabilities and core competencies to the
catering market segment in terms of the following:
a) Which of those resources, capabilities and core competencies are transferable to
the catering segment?
b) What gaps exist in terms of resources, capabilities and core competencies if Wil’s
Grill enters the catering segment?
c) How will Wil’s Grill acquire and or/develop the missing resources, capabilities
and core competencies if it decides to enter the catering segment?
1
4. Based on the analyses done for the previous questions, advise Wil’s Grill whether it
should expand its operations either by entering the catering market segment or by
doing something else.
Sandlands Vineyards
1. Assess the attractiveness of the premium wine segment (i.e. making premium wines)
using Porter’s five forces framework. Is the level of attractiveness likely to change in
the future?
2. Does Sandlands Vineyards have a sustainable competitive advantage in the premium
wine market? (Note: Use VRIN framework to assess the sustainable competitive
advantage).
3. What should the Passalacquas do: buy the Eastside Meats building and develop it into
a winery; buy another old vineyard; or do something else?
4. Can you write a strategy statement for Sandlands Vineyards?
1. What are the major determinants of profitability in the global FMCG industry? How
have they changed over time?
2. What are the historical sources of distinctive competence that helped P&G build and
maintain a formidable market position? Are these sources of advantage still viable in
the medium-term future? What are the main dimensions of strategic change that you
would recommend P&G to consider?
3. Evaluate the position of Trian (Nelson Peltz) as well as the response of David Taylor
and the management of P&G. How would you vote in the proxy battle? How would
you defend your choice?