Behavior of RC Members Subjected To Shear With Background To Provisions of The New Edition of Ecp 203 by Ahmed Abd Elmoniem Saleh Bayome
Behavior of RC Members Subjected To Shear With Background To Provisions of The New Edition of Ecp 203 by Ahmed Abd Elmoniem Saleh Bayome
Behavior of RC Members Subjected To Shear With Background To Provisions of The New Edition of Ecp 203 by Ahmed Abd Elmoniem Saleh Bayome
By
By
………………………………. ……………………………….
By
Ahmad Abd Elmoniem Saleh Bayome
Approved by the
Examining Committee
____________________________
Prof. Dr. Mashhour Ghoniem, Thesis Main Advisor
____________________________
Prof. Dr. Osman Ramadan, Advisor
____________________________
Prof. Dr. Mohamed Talaat Mostafa, Internal Examiner
____________________________
Prof. Dr. Ahmed Mousa, External Examiner
(Helwan University)
Title of Thesis:
BEHAVIOR OF RC MEMBERS SUBJECTED TO SHEAR WITH BACKGROUND
TO PROVISIONS OF THE NEW EDITION OF ECP 203
Key Words:
Shear strength; Concrete contribution; Design for shear; Shear walls; Dynamic loads
Summary:
The objectives of this thesis are to present the background and evaluate the
modifications to the shear design procedure that have been implemented in the new
ECP 203 code for members subjected to static and dynamic loads (cyclic). These
modifications would overcome realized difficulties with using current ECP 203 design
code. The procedure and implied basis for the new ECP 203 shear design approach are
examined and their accurses are assessed using the results of numerous experimental
database. The study discusses the shear behavior of reinforced concrete shear walls and
moment resisting frames under cyclic loads with particular interest in the behavior of
plastic hinge region. An important modification of the new ECP 203 is its utilization of
the concrete contribution to shear strength inside plastic hinge region, where sufficient
compressive stresses exist. The new ECP 203 shear design provisions included: (1) The
shear strength provided by uncracked concrete is modified to (0.16 fcu / c ); (2) After
Cracking, concrete shear strength is reduced to 75% of its uncracked value (0.12 fcu / c
); (3) The concrete contribution to shear strength is modified to be (0.16 fcu / c ) in the
critical region of shear walls and moment resisting frames when the axial compression
force is greater than or equal to (0.1 Ag. fcu). The knowledge gained in this study
explains the merits of these modifications for the new ECP 203 code.
Acknowledgments
Thanks to merciful lord for all the countless gifts you have offered me, and strength to
complete this work.
I would like to express my deepest thanks to Prof. Mashhour Ghoniem, for suggesting
the topic of this thesis, and his kind supervision. It is a great honour to work under his
supervision.
Also, I would like to express my thanks to my examiners Prof. Ahmed Mousa and Prof.
Talaat Mostafa, for their help and kind advice.
I would like to express my extreme sincere gratitude to my fiancée Dr. Amina Hassan, for
her encouragement and support.
I am grateful to my family specially my father, for their support, love, and wishes that
gave me the courage to achieve my goals.
I
Table of Contents
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS.….………………………………………………….………....... I
TABLE OF CONTENTS……………………………………………………………......... II
LIST OF TABLES…….…………………………………………………….…..………. V
LIST OF FIGURES…...………………..……………………………………………….. VI
NOMENCLATURE………………………………………………………….……….... VIII
ABSTRACT……………………………………………………………….……………. X
II
CHAPTER 3: DESIGN FOR SHEAR ACCORDING TO DIFFERENT CODES …….….………21
3.1. GENERAL ...................................................................................................... 21
3.2. CRITICAL SECTION ....................................................................................... 21
3.3. AMERICAN CODE (ACI 318-2011) ............................................................... 22
3.4. CANADIAN STANDARD (CSA A23.3-2004) .................................................. 24
3.5. NEW ZEALAND STANDARD (NZS3101-2006) .............................................. 26
3.6. EGYPTIAN CODE (ECP 203-2007) ................................................................ 28
3.7. INDIAN STANDARD (IS456-2000) ................................................................. 30
3.8. BRITISH STANDARD (BS 8110-1997) ........................................................... 33
3.9. EUROCODE (EN1992- 2004)......................................................................... 35
3.10. COMPARISON BETWEEN DESIGN CODES' REQUIREMENTS .............................. 37
3.10.1. COMPARISON BETWEEN DIFFERENT DESIGN APPROACHES ....................... 37
3.10.2. EFFECT OF AXIAL FORCE IN DIFFERENT DESIGN CODES .............................. 39
III
CHAPTER 6 : EVALUATION OF SHEAR STRENGTH PREDICTION BY VARIOUS CODES OF
PRACTICE …………….……………………………………………….………..…...… 87
IV
List of Tables
V
List of Figures
VI
Figure 5.6: Effect of shear span-to-depth ratio on shear strength for test data [4], and for
the current and new ECP 203 codes ............................................................................. 78
Figure 5.7: Effect of shear span-to-depth ratio on shear strength for test data [15], and
for the current and new ECP 203 codes ........................................................................ 79
Figure 5.8: Effect of transverse reinforcement on shear capacity for test data [22], and
for the current and new ECP 203 codes ........................................................................ 80
Figure 5.9: Effect of transverse reinforcement on shear capacity for test data [22], and
for the current and new ECP 203 codes ........................................................................ 81
Figure 5.10: Structural wall cross section fig. ex. 6.7.2 ............................................... 83
Figure 5.11:Effect of concrete compressive strength on shear strength provided by shear
reinforcement ................................................................................................................ 83
Figure 5.12: Effect of cross section area of concrete on shear strength provided by shear
reinforcement ............................................................................................................... 84
Figure 5.13: Effect of axial compression force on shear strength provided by shear
reinforcement ................................................................................................................ 85
Figure 6.1: Effect of concrete compressive strength on shear capacity for test data [14]
and various codes .......................................................................................................... 89
Figure 6.2: Effect of concrete compressive strength on shear capacity for test data [21]
and various codes .......................................................................................................... 90
Figure 6.3: Effect of concrete compressive strength on shear capacity for test data [21]
and various codes .......................................................................................................... 91
Figure 6.4: Effect of concrete compressive strength on shear capacity for test data [21]
and various codes .......................................................................................................... 92
Figure 6.5: Effect of concrete compressive strength on shear capacity for test data [22]
and various codes .......................................................................................................... 93
Figure 6.6: Effect of longitudinal steel on shear strength for test data [14] and various
codes ............................................................................................................................. 95
Figure 6.7: Effect of shear span-to-depth ratio on shear strength for test data [4] and
various codes ................................................................................................................. 97
Figure 6.8: Effect of shear span-to-depth ratio on shear strength for test data [15] and
various codes ................................................................................................................. 98
Figure 6.9: Effect of transverse reinforcement on shear capacity for test data [22] and
various codes ............................................................................................................... 100
Figure 6.10: Effect of transverse reinforcement on shear capacity for test data [22] and
various codes ............................................................................................................... 101
Figure 6.11: Effect of shear reinforcement on shear capacity according to ECP 203-07
code ............................................................................................................................ 103
Figure 6.12: Effect of axial force on shear strength ................................................... 104
Figure 6.13: Codes estimate for RC members without shear reinforcement .............. 108
Figure 6.14: Structural wall cross section fig. ex. 6.7.2.............................................. 111
Figure 6.15: Effect of concrete compressive strength on shear strength provided by shear
reinforcement .............................................................................................................. 113
Figure 6.16: Effect of cross section area of concrete on shear strength provided by shear
reinforcement .............................................................................................................. 114
Figure 6.17: Effect of axial compression force on shear strength provided by shear
reinforcement ............................................................................................................. 115
VII
Nomenclature
VIII
Qn nominal shear force, N;
Qs shear contribution due to web reinforcement (stirrups), N;
Qr shear contribution due to Residual tensile stresses, N;
Nu axial tension force applying on the member, N;
IX
Abstract
The goal of this thesis is to evaluate the modifications of the shear design approach
that will be implemented in the new ECP 203 code. These modifications are made to
modify the shear design provisions in the current ECP 203 code for members subjected to
static and cyclic loads.
First, the factors that have influence on the mechanism of shear transfer and the
ultimate shear strength are explored. Then, different shear design approaches of reinforced
concrete members subject to shear are reviewed. Finally, the new ECP 203 shear design
approach is evaluated using shear strength prediction of various codes of practice and
numerous experimental results.
The study discusses the shear behavior of reinforced concrete shear walls and moment
resisting frames under cyclic loads with particular interest in the behavior of plastic hinge
region. An important modification of the new ECP 203 is its utilization of the concrete
contribution to shear strength inside plastic hinge region, when sufficient compressive
stresses exist.