3 Socio Economic Challenges of Persons
3 Socio Economic Challenges of Persons
3 Socio Economic Challenges of Persons
SocioEconomicChallengesofPersonswithDisabilitiesACaseStudyofEthiopia
© 2019. Muleta Hussein Sedeto & Mohd Jameel Dar. This is a research/review paper, distributed under the terms of the Creative
Commons Attribution-Noncommercial 3.0 Unported License http://creative commons.org/licenses/by-nc/3.0/), permitting all non-
commercial use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.
Socio-Economic Challenges of Persons with
Disabilities: A Case Study of Ethiopia
Muleta Hussein Sedeto α & Mohd Jameel Dar σ
Abstract- The paper precisely and briefly explains the socio- percent of PWDs in Ethiopia live in poverty, which is one
economic challenges of persons with disabilities with focus on of the manifestations of unemployment. Malnutrition
Ethiopia. The findings of the paper also indicates that, across accounts for 20 percent of the disabilities in the country
the countries persons with disabilities have poorer health
(Yohannes, 2012: 101-102). In contrary to this, as cited
accesses, lower education achievements, less social and
in Yetneberish (2013:5), the estimate of 17.6% of
economic participation and less rate of income than Persons
without Ddisabilities. This is partly because people with Ethiopians is living with a disability, contained in the
2019
disabilities experience barriers in accessing services that many World Report on Disability. Studies showed that this
of us have long taken for granted, including health, education, variation was occurred due to the measurements taken
Year
employment, transport and information as well as to classify and categorize peoples with disability and
rehabilitation. These difficulties are exacerbated with high level without disabled or due to the information gap during
of disability disadvantaged individuals. Based on the findings 9
data collection. According to Ethiopian National
of this study, major socio-economic remedy directions are Disability Action Network (ENDAN, 2010:32) such
A
ccording to world report on Disability, more than (2015:179), there is a strong connection between
one billion people or 15% of the world’s disability and poverty due to many systemic factors that
population live with some form of disability, of promote a vicious circle. This may entail that the
whom, nearly 200 million experience considerable mutually reinforcing nature of special needs and low
difficulties in functioning. In the years ahead, disability socioeconomic status. This may suggest that people
will be an even greater concern because its prevalence with disabilities are significantly more likely to become
is on the rise. This is due to ageing populations and the impoverished; and people who are impoverished are
higher risk of disability in older people as well as the significantly more likely to become disabled.
global increase in chronic health conditions such as
diabetes, cardiovascular disease, cancer and mental
II. Personal Challenges
health disorders(World Bank and World Health Majority of Persons with disabilities are
Organization (WHO), 2011: xi and United Nations’ vulnerable of demographic challenges. Demographic
Education, Social and Cultural Organization (UNICEF, challenges here are taken as personal challenges.
2013: 10). These may include age, sex, marital status, types of
Based on the analysis of the United Nations, it impairment, level of impairment, education, copping
is estimated that about eight million people in Ethiopia style, social background, occupation, etc.
live with disabilities. That is about 10 percent of the total
number of the Ethiopian population. An estimated 95 a) Age
Aging has an indisputable factor among PwDs.
Many scholars share similar idea that children and old
Author σ: M.A, Lecture, Department of Governance and Management, age are more vulnerable group of PwDs. Higher
School of Governance and Leadership, Oromia State University,
disability rates among older people reflect an
Ethiopia. e-mail: [email protected]
Author α: Ph.D Political Science, Assistant Professor, Department of accumulation of health risks across a lifespan of
Civics and Ethical Studies. College of Social Science and Humanities, disease, injury, and chronic illness where as children
Debre Markos University, Ethiopia. e-mail: [email protected] under age 5 in developing countries are exposed to
© 20 19 Global Journals
Socio-Economic Challenges of Persons with Disabilities: A Case Study of Ethiopia
multiple risks, including poverty, malnutrition, poor marginalization of women with disabilities (Eleni, 2016:
health, and un stimulating home environments, which 18). Disability related challenges on women are not just
can impair cognitive, motor, and social-emotional two fold to that of men, but are of multiple folds.
development (WB and WHO, 2011:36).Another study
c) Types of impairment
shows that nearly a third of PwDs are over 50 years old
Often, “types of disability” are defined using
in Ethiopia implying causal relationship between old age
only one aspect of disability, such as impairments –
and disability (Yetneberish, 2013: 9). That is, the older
sensory, physical, mental, and intellectual – and at other
the person gets, more vulnerable she/he becomes to
times they conflate health conditions with disability.
disability.
People with chronic health conditions, communication
b) Sex difficulties, and other impairments may not be included
Studies confirm that although men and women in these estimates, despite encountering difficulties in
with disabilities are subject to discrimination, women everyday life (WB and WHO, 2011: 22). The more the
with disability are at the further disadvantage because of types of impairment on a person the more complex the
the combined discrimination based on gender and condition becomes.
2019
disability. Children with disabilities are less likely to country. Over 70% of respondents reported that all of
attend school and have lower rates of staying and being the following were barriers: inaccessible school
promoted in schools (UNICEF, 2013: 10). Less than 2 buildings; schools being located too far away from
Percent of disabled children in school age have access where disabled children live; a lack of appropriate
to education that has special need facility in Ethiopia facilities at school; a lack of teacher training in inclusive
(Yetnebersh, 2013: 12). education methodologies; a lack of appropriate
Many disabled children and young people teaching and learning materials; a lack of extra support
around the world are denied sustained access to basic in the classroom for children with disabilities; social
education. Some of these disabled children never enter stigma and negative parental attitudes to disability;
school, others start but make poor progress eventually poverty (Croft, 2010: 11).
dropping out, and it appears that a relatively small Physical access to school buildings is an
proportion are educated in a parallel system of special essential prerequisite for educating children with
schools, running alongside mainstream schools disabilities. Those with physical disabilities are likely to
(Croft,2010: 1). face difficulties in travelling to school if, for example, the
The Ministry of Education has asserted that roads and bridges are unsuitable for wheelchair use and
2019
Ethiopia can not attain MDG ignoring the marginalized the distances are too great. Even if it is possible to reach
Year
and those with learning difficulties andimpairments the school, there may be problems of stairs, narrow
Franck, 2015:4.As many school-aged children are kept doorways, inappropriate seating, or inaccessible toilet
in the confines of their homes rather than brought to facilities. The attitudes of teachers, school 11
schools (MoE and UNESCO, 2012), working with administrators, other children, and even family members
(WB&WHO, 2011: 8).The social and economic experiences (Berhanu, 2015: 176). Berhanu agrees with
advantages of being employed are well recorded – such Leslie and associates that the practice of social
as security, self-determination, financial resources and a exclusion affects individuals in preventing from
sense of purpose. Yet women with disabilities encounter participating fully in the economic, social, and political
innumerable barriers to obtaining paid employment. sphere (Other studies indicating that due to their
These barriers include discriminatory attitudes, increased vulnerability in the social environment, women
accessibility, lack of support, poor education and with mental, psychological or learning disabilities are
training and inaccessible transport (Eleni, 2016: 21). more prone to becoming the victims of domestic
And an estimated 95 percent of PwsDs in violence, sexual abuse and mistreatment, because they
Ethiopia live in poverty which is one of the do not have the practical means to live independently
manifestations of unemployment. Malnutrition accounts and experience their sexuality (cited in Berhanu,
for 20 percent of the disabilities in the country 2015:177).
(Yohannes, 2012: 102).
b) Attitudinal challenge
In terms of economic inclusion of the disabled
This is one of the formidable barriers PwDs
people, these persons have limited access to the formal
2019
Eleni, 2016: 12). As a matter of fact employment has to features to enable access exist (WB and WHO,
do directly with education. We will benefit from the 2011: 190).
disabled, only as much as invested on them. For Ways forward in information and
instance, if they are not treated specially at schools, we communication technology include raising awareness,
cannot exploit their potential at work. adopting legislation and regulations, developing
standards, and offering training. Services such as
III. Social Challenges
telephone relay, captioned broadcasting, sign language
a) Disability related stigma interpreting and accessible formats for information
Societal beliefs about people with disabilities facilitates participation by people with disabilities.
have a strong impact on inclusion. Disability in Ethiopia Improved information and communication technology
is often perceived as connected with a person’s accessibility can be achieved by bringing together
immorality or curse. Disabled children and parents of market regulation and antidiscrimination approaches,
disabled children are often stigmatized (Franck, along with relevant perspectives on consumer protection
2015: 6). and public procurement. Countries with strong
Social exclusion means lack of belongingness, legislation and follow up mechanisms tend to achieve
acceptance and recognition. People who are socially higher levels of information and communication
excluded are more vulnerable to economic and social technology access, but regulation needs to keep pace
problems, and hence they tend to have difficult life with technological innovation (WB and WHO, 2011: 15).
The time we live in is known as the era of friends and used to go out with them to do some
information. As access to everything is beginning to activities and sports. But after the injury, it was difficult for
depend on the freshest of information, the disabled with me to go out with them, because the environment is not
no access at all would automatically be put out of the adapted for wheelchair users, either the streets,
daily game of life. transportation, shops, restaurants, or other facilities.” Fadi
(WB&WHO, 2011: 168). I think the situation gets worse
d) Family Related challenges
when the disability is not at birth when a person who
People with physical disabilities are less able
used to perform all kinds of activities suddenly ceases
than others to grow their own food or contribute to
to do most of it, she/he feels like double disability with
subsistence living for the family. They can be seen as a
inaccessible environment.
burden to the rest of the family, the local community, the
social services of the country, and the budget of the f) Health services related Challenges
ministry of health (CBM,2007: 4). Health service is one of the crucial challenges
Family members in Ethiopia sometimes are that PwDs faces in their life. When a person gets sick,
embarrassed to have PwDs in their home and tend to undoubtedly the disability challenge becomes double.
2019
hide them and keep them behind closed doors to This is due to, in some cases inability to care himself
prevent the PwDs from interacting with the immediate without others help, distance of medical institutions, lack
Year
neighborhood and the community at large (Yohannes, of finance to cover medical charge, lack of means of
2012:104). This belief of the family and close relatives is transportation, negative attitude of physicians,
in fact the worst of all can aggravate all the other 13
unwillingness of others to give priority, stages of
challenges. building, long steps and procedures of services
© 20 19 Global Journals
Socio-Economic Challenges of Persons with Disabilities: A Case Study of Ethiopia
acquire a disability within their lifetime (cited in Berhanu, and equal access to facilities and opportunities as
2015: 180). others (Choike, 2009: 7). According to Yetnebersh
Health is also affected by environmental factors, (2013: 7), poverty is the main socio-economic
such as safe water and sanitation, nutrition, poverty, characteristics of PwDs and their families in Ethiopia.The
working conditions, climate, or access to health care. As majority of studies find that persons with disability in
the World Health Organization (WHO) Commission on developing countries have lower employment rates and
Social Determinants of Health has argued, inequality is a lower educational attainment than persons without
major cause of poor health, and hence of disability(WB& disability (WB and WHO, 2011: 39). The connection
WHO, 2011:4). I do not think that any revision of the between poverty and disability is widely acknowledged,
policy can improve the situation unless the attitudes of with disability being both a cause and a result of poverty
family members and health officers changed. There will (Franck, 2013:4).
be no hope left after a disabled person gets sick and Persons with disabilities experience worse
does not have access for medication. educational and labour market outcomes and are more
g) Transportation likely to be poor than persons without disabilities. A
2019
Means of transportation has plies irrefutable role study of 15 developing countries, using World Health
in accelerating social and economic situations of PwDs. Survey data, found that households with disabilities
Year
On other hand its high cost that not much with covering experienced higher poverty as measured by nonhealth
capacity of PwDs, unavailability, poor infrastructure and per capita consumption expenditures in only 5 of the
14 the risks of accidents are unquestionable challenges countries (WB and WHO, 2011:40).
disabled people faces. Debashis (2013: 120) share similar idea with
Global Journal of Human Social Science ( C ) Volume XIX Issue I Version I
According to road traffic safety regulation of ILO/ 2002/ in terms of disability and microfinance that
Addis Ababa city government, Regulation No /2009: disabled people can’t get the same amount of loan as
Dec 3, 2009, the Addis Ababa city Government someone is getting as able. Persons with disability have
proclaimed to minimize loss of life, accident triggered always given less priority and they were not the main
disability and loss of property in the city and its vicinities target group in terms of inclusion of socio economic
(Baseline survey, 2010: 26).But road traffic associated integration. Never the less, all persons with disabilities
accidents which in turn causes disability are still are not in the poorest of the poor group and they have a
aggravated. good capacity to do job properly in the job market.
The same survey shows that many children When there is a level playing field to perform in the job
drop out from school due to lack of transport cost. The market, disabled people did well for their self-
same study gave reasons for the high dropout of employment.
students with disabilities, the changing physical or In 2006, the World Bank estimated the global
mental development of the child that comes with varying GDP loss due to disability to be between $1.71 trillion to
needs, financial constraints to cover transport cost to $2.23 trillion annually between 12% and 20% of the
and from the school and absence of an individual to populations of developing countries were thought to be
escort the child to school are some of the reasons for non-productive due to disability (Robert,
the frequent dropout rate (Baseline Study, 2010: 43). 2004:32).Poverty is the main characteristic of persons
The majority of disabled participants in a United with disabilities and their families in Ethiopia The
-
States study said that transportation problems were a economic loss to Ethiopia as a result of excluding
major barrier to accessing health care. A study in the disabled people from the labour market estimated at
Republic of Korea suggested that transportation barriers USD 667 million per annum or five percent of the
were a likely factor in keeping people with severe country’s GDP (Yetneberish, 2013: 7&15 ).
physical and communication impairments from One study attempted to account for the extra
participating in population screenings for chronic cost of disability in poverty estimates in two developing
diseases (WB&WHO, 2011). In our case, the solution is countries: Viet Nam and Bosnia and Herzegovina.
just far from reality as we lack not only the means of Before the adjustments, the overall poverty rate in Viet
transportation but also needs and parameters to service Nam was 13.5% and the poverty rate among
situations. households with disability was 16.4%. The extra cost of
h) Economic Challenges disability was estimated at 9.0% resulting in an increase
The institute for social development study of in the poverty rate among households with disability to
Vietnams shows that the social model also relates to 20.1% and in the overall poverty rate to 15.7%. In Bosnia
economics. It proposes that people can be further and Herzegovina the overall poverty rate was estimated
disabled by a lack of resources in meeting their needs. at 19.5% and among households with disability at
It addresses issues such as the underestimation of the 21.2%. The extra cost of disability was estimated at 14%,
potential of people to contribute fully to society and add resulting in an increase in the poverty rate among
economic value to society if they are given equal rights households with disability to 30.8% and in the overall
poverty rate to 22.4% in Ethiopia.(WB and WHO, Orthopedic and Reconstructive Surgery): Policy
2011: 40). paper; Physical Disability and Rehabilitation
IV. Conclusion Advisory working group.
7. Choike (2009).Institute for Social Development
Despite their disabilities, the person with Studies: Socio-Economic situations of People with
disabilities who can contribute their part in all aspects of disabilities-vietinam.www.choike.org.disability-
countries development, they lacked this opportunity due vietinam.
to both impairment they had and lack of access and 8. Croft, Alison (2010). Including Disabled Children in
availability towards social and economic services, and Learning: Challenges in Developing Countries:
disability stigma and marginalization that aggravated the Create Pathways to Access: Research Monograph
situation to be worsen. Lack of means of rehabilitation No. 36, University of Sussex, Falmer, Brighton BN1
and support to re-establish their social and economic 9RH, United Kingdom.
situation to normal condition is the other gap not yet 9. CRPD (2007).UN Convention on the Rights of
met. Unspecific policy guideline and its poor Persons with Disabilities.
implementation at ground level is still unsolved 10. CSA (2013). Federal Democratic Republic of
2019
challenges of person with disabilities in Ethiopia. In Ethiopia: Central Statistical Agency: Statistical
Year
general, across the countries person with disabilities Abstract 2013.
have poorer health access, lower education 11. Dawson, C. (2007). A practical Guide to Research
achievements, less social and economic participation Methods: third Edition: A user Friendly Manual for 15
and less rates of income than Persons without Mastering Research Projects and Techniques.
Disabilities (PwoDs) especially in rural areas of Ethiopia.
© 20 19 Global Journals
Socio-Economic Challenges of Persons with Disabilities: A Case Study of Ethiopia
20. Huck, (2004).Elementary Parent involvements, 37. Yamane Taro (1967). Statistics, an Introductory
School Culture, and accountability scores. Analysis: 2nd edition; New York: Harper and Row.
21. ILO, (2009): The Economic Consequence of 38. Yeshimebet Alemu (2014). Impacts of rehabilitation
Excluding People with Disabilities from the World of center on the psycho-social conditions of children
Work, Geneva. with physical impairment. Unpublished MA thesis
22. ILO, (2011): Irish aid Partnership Program: moving Addis Ababa University.
towards disability inclusion, International labour 39. Yetneberish Niguse (2013). General overview of
organization Addis Ababa, Ethiopia. Disability in Ethiopia, ECDD.
23. Kalkidan, Shimelis Tiruneh (2015). Social and 40. Yohannes Teressa (2012). Ensuring the right to
Economic Challenges of Service Providers to equal employment opportunities of persons with
Children with Intellectual Disabilities: The Case of disabilities: Critical examination of the Ethiopian legal
Mekane-Eyesus Center for Mentally Challenged framework. Unpublished ,MA thesis Addis Ababa
Children, Addis Ababa University. University.
24. Kassahun,Yibeltal ( 2013). Law and policy situation
of persons with disabilities in Ethiopia: Federation of
2019