Final Report
Final Report
Final Report
Submitted by Dillon Kelly, Lilian Martin, William Millgate, Jeovanni Reyna, Colton Silimon
COMM 1010
January 4, 2021
Clean Energy in the Socotra Archipelago 2
Table of Contents
Executive Summary 3
Project Description 4
Methods 5
Conclusion 18
Work Cited 19
Appendices 20
Clean Energy in the Socotra Archipelago 3
Executive Summary
We as the Foo Fighters are fighting to conserve the health of the biodiversity in Socotra,
The process for accomplishing our purpose, which is to conserve the health of
biodiversity, is to research the characteristics of the island and find a solution to help prevent the
The purpose of our criteria was to make sure we achieve a cost-benefit analysis. We
needed to create criteria that would be practical (i.e. cost, government help, etc.) and see the
overall effectiveness of the solutions (i.e. does wildlife benefit, does it have other effects, etc.).
Then we brainstormed solutions independently and presented our solutions to each other. We
scored the solutions based on our criteria, giving the highest marks for solutions that met the
criteria.
We came up with the solution to implement a tidal power plant. Point Absorber Buoys
implemented on the North coast of Socotra with an onshore facility to process the generated
power to usable electricity. We have found that currently fuel-wood is the biggest form of energy
used on the islands. So, we designed our plan to help contribute more clean energy. Our solution
has no carbon dioxide emissions, which is helping to prevent further warming and desertification
on the island. Doing this will also help prevent excessive deforestation from other forms of
energy generators in Yemen. We would start by contacting non profit organizations like Saudi
Development and Reconstruction Program for Yemen as well as the Ministry of Planning,
Project Description
For this project, our team needed to use the skills we learned throughout the semester to
effectively communicate, with the goal of finding a realistic solution to a problem faced by the
Archipelago of Yemen. We assigned team roles and held meetings to go over information. We
then needed to work together through multiple virtual meetings to compile our information in our
final report and create a presentation. While researching the Archipelago of Yemen, we found
that the main island, Socotra, was facing many threats to its biodiversity. From habitat loss and
deforestation to droughts and climate change, the endemic species,which the islands inhabitants
We set out to find a cost effective solution that could significantly address the problem
without much upkeep. It’s important that we find a solution to the problem because if not, the
already struggling people of Socotra won’t have many of the resources that they rely on. Not
only will the loss of biodiversity affect the island's inhabitants, but its implications will also
negatively affect the economy of Yemen and the natural processes that connect with other parts
of the Earth. Our solution that we chose would be to implement tidal energy on the island's coast
through point absorber buoys, which would cause a domino effect on the island. First, it would
provide clean energy and help reduce the use of fossil fuels. This would help many of the issues
faced on the island, but most importantly it would reduce the amount of deforestation. The
reduction in deforestation would then continue to slow a multitude of other problems. So with
only one system, our solution would help diminish countless problems that threaten the island's
biodiversity.
Clean Energy in the Socotra Archipelago 5
Methods
To find the best solution to our problem, we used the Reflective Thinking Process. The
reason behind using this process was to make sure our team fully analyzed and reflected upon the
problem and to stop our problem before it becomes a thing, thus altering any further damage to
the island and its inhabitants. To clarify this process, we will describe each step our group took
in accomplishing our purpose. We will also provide a brief description of our end-product.
I. Part I: Problem
What is the best way we can help protect the biodiversity of Socotra, Archipelago?
A. Characteristics
biodiversity, particularly its endemic species of birds and trees. The island
is home to 825 plant species, 37% of which aren’t found anywhere else in
Cultural Organization. One of the most famous being the islands Dragon
Blood Tree, which got its name after its extremely valuable red sap.
2. What makes this island so special is its unique wildlife and that is why
buoy we would be able to give clean tidal energy to the people of socotra
and not only boost their way of life by giving them an energy source like
they’ve never had, but also protecting the wildlife on the island and
B. Stakeholders
for one city on the island and they are a third world country. Socotra as a
society for the most part, is lacking modern day technologies and bringing
tidal energy will help boost their economy, society and bring them out of
being a third world country, possibly, opening new doorways to buy and
trade goods to and from other countries. Bringing clean renewable energy
to Socotra will do way more than just provide them with energy. Giving
the country an ongoing supply of energy is important , but just think of all
the amazing things they can do once they get that energy and put it to
good use.
C. History
1. Socotra has no written history and what we know about the island has
been gathered from references. The islands are first known to be colonized
Clean Energy in the Socotra Archipelago 7
by the Greeks in about 330 BCE. Socotra has since been known for its
forces landed on the island in 1507 to liberate the island of Arab Islamic
rule but left four years later. In 1876, England would become the
notions made about the landscape and the unique environment and
biodiversity.
3. In the past, Socotra has received significant support from the Saudi
Program for Yemen (SDRPY). The SDRPY has helped with the funding
positive outcomes for agriculture and livability on Socotra. They have also
across the island. Another sector that the SDRPY has helped in is the
2020).
Clean Energy in the Socotra Archipelago 8
D. Policies
biggest regulations that we would need to follow are with respect to the
ongoing war between Yemen and the United Arab Emirates (UAE).
Currently the UAE has control of the seaports, airport, and sea amid
both the UAE and Yemen due to their shared ownership over the island as
to make sure that we dont break any treaties or laws they might have.
2. We would also need to consider the ethical problems that could arise due
to building our buoy system in the ocean. Not only would we need to be
biologist to ensure that we don’t build in an area that could possibly harm
the marine life. Although there is no current policy regarding marine life
off the coast of Socotra, it would be an ethical problem that we would like
to keep in mind.
E. Resources
1. In order to carry out the project, our team first needed to identify what
our calculations, we’ve found that we could raise 100-200 million dollars.
have much money to spare, there are many organizations our team would
protection programs that are already in place. Programs such as the United
energy for over 25,000 people. Also, the Saudi Development and
a lot of power projects for Yemen. Recently, they donated 500 million
source of funding for us to reach out to. If we are low on funding, there are
media campaign. Our campaign would consist of different posts and ads
we could work with. Not only have they implemented multiple power
buoy systems around the world, but working with this company would
ensure that our team wouldn’t need to spend the time and money to travel
to socotra.
4. The time we have to get this project done is also a very important resource
the project. So working with the connections through the United Nations
integral asset for the project. It would allow us to hand most of the
● Limiting tourism
V. Part V: Organize
A. We narrowed down this option from the others due to its efficiency and cost. Our
other options were good but unlike building a power buoy they would end up
either taking a lot of the precious land away since their needs to be a set building
for these ideas like a nuclear power plant or a not for profit organization. A
nuclear power plant requires a square mile or 640 acres for a building while
power buoys only require a small building with monitors and some databases, but
this building isn’t going to take 640 acres, it will take up no more than half the
size of the school. The other options were windmill power which requires 1.5
acres to make 2 megawatts an hour but typically there isn’t only 1 windmill in a
field there is typically 15-30 windmills so, in the end, this would end up taking up
many acres of land which will totally end up ruining our whole purpose of this
task which was to help the biodiversity of Socotra and developing buildings will
end up harming them in the short and long term even with the clean energy.
B. The chart we used for these criteria in finding which solution we choose was
based on many things like could the government help out, will it protect wildlife,
will it protect wildlife, will it be cost-effective, will it be too expensive, and does
it apply to more than just our specific problem. We chose these criteria to make
sure that the solution would end up not screwing up one or the other we didn't
want to choose one thing over the other like banning tourism would protect the
biodiversity, it would be cost-effective but then it would totally hurt the people of
Clean Energy in the Socotra Archipelago 12
Socotra due to a lot of their economy is based off tourism and cutting that would
drastically hurt them. So we chose things that balance each other out and the pros
C. The solution we chose was to build and maintain a power buoy to help prevent the
overuse of fossil fuels that could drastically hurt the environment, biodiversity,
the people, and the atmosphere some of which help lead to global warming which
is also a problem in Socotra. Our solution that got second was building a
activities that end up affecting the biodiversity of the island like the US has in the
national parks. They would do that as well as they would also be gathering funds
to help prevent illegal trading and smuggling of animals and plants on the island.
This was good since it was able to help the government which is fairly weak and
their rules and regulations are basically suggestions since the government isn’t the
most stable. The biggest issue with this plan is that we would need volunteers,
really hard to get for a nonprofit organization as seen in many that are more
recognized like American Red Cross, Yemen Aid, Yemen Relief and
Reconstruction. If we made another one for Socotra, in the end, it will end up
either taking funds from these other nonprofit organizations or our nonprofit
would end up not making enough funds to maintain itself. Another option was to
limit tourism and on our criteria chart, it scored the lowest due to fact that it
would not be cost-effective and not benefit the people due to the fact that even
though tourism isn’t the biggest in Socotra, this tourism helps bring in money to
Clean Energy in the Socotra Archipelago 13
the country of Socotra that the island can't survive without. Even though limiting
tourism would greatly benefit the wildlife, as well as this would help solve more
than one problem, the con is the island relying heavily on that income greatly
D. Every plan isn’t perfect and our plant is great, but it has some negatives to it, but
they can be fixed. Our biggest consequence is that where we place this power
buoy could hurt the environment or this shipping route which can be solved by
placing the power buoys on the north side of the island due to it having little coral
reefs and being close to the main city. Another consequence is that these power
buoys could be crashed into by civilian or international ships since Socotra has
many shipping routes around it, the northside having the least amount around it,
but accidents do happen. With this, according to Dr. Mike Mekhiche a leader in
assembly which stands for Pile Driving Analysis this would send signals to ships
alerting them that this Power Buoy is close and to back away. It will alert ships
that are in a radius of 500M which is the designated zone 1000M which is the
warning zone and lastly the 5000M which is the monitoring zone. Another
consequence is that this will pollute the ocean and actually hurt the ocean wildlife.
Although with this, there has never been an accident relating to power buoys as
long as we have great maintenance on them, they should not harm aquatic life.
The last and biggest consequence is with this being in place, there will be no need
for fossil fuels which may seem like a good thing but for people who make money
off fossil fuels this will hurt them and they will try their best to switch back to
Clean Energy in the Socotra Archipelago 14
fossil fuels. The way to fix that would be a ban on fossil fuels and pollution on the
island being backed by the country that owns it, either Yemen or the United Arab
Emirates. So, in conclusion, there are many consequences but with planning and
adjustments to the power buoy, they shouldn’t be problems that should show.
After choosing our solution, we set up a plan for implementing it. We would start
by manufacturing. Each point absorber buoy costs 130 million dollars to produce
which may seem steep at first, but once they are set off into the ocean it will pay
Once the buoys are installed, the tide produces free, reliable, predictable,
renewable, and clean energy that will consistently be made as long as the buoy is
working.
A. Materials
upper clevis assembly, dampers, brake, input rod, screw shaft, ball nut,
carriage, fixed end bearings, another brake located at the bottom of the of
input rod, generator coupling, then at the bottom there is a generator, pca
support, ball screw and guide lubrication system, then linear guides, LDS
(linear displacement sensor), guide rail and pca chassis. This is all the
solenoid valve, reservoir, relief valve, and a pressure sensor that helps the
Clean Energy in the Socotra Archipelago 15
system so it doesn't overload it with too much energy and shut it down.
load controller assembly, main battery, battery charger. The cooling panel
is made of an inlet, back panel, air bleed line connection, outlet 2, the
check valve, coolant back fill hose barb and valve, pump 2,differential
one buoy then the remaining materials necessary is a chain to the ground
B. Location
the south side there are tons of coral reefs. We want to keep the habitat as
close to normal as possible so this is why we're placing them on the north
side of the island. The north side also produced a higher and low tide
which means more energy. There are also a lot more businesses on the
north side which makes it more convenient for us to distribute across the
C. Price
1. We will have Ocean Power Technologies (OTP) build them for us at the
price of 130 million dollars a unit. Each point absorber buoy produces
around 500 kilowatts of power a day. The average person in Nigeria uses
reference to Socotra because of all it’s similarities and both of them being
Clean Energy in the Socotra Archipelago 16
was 137 and you end up getting 8,220,000 kilowatt hours used a year by
the whole population and then we divided that by four because Globally,
average household size ranges from “fewer than three persons per
Composition around the World), once you divide that, you come out with
2,055,000 per household, then you divide that by 500 because each point
absorber buoy makes 500 kilowatts a day. Once you divide that you get a
grand total of 4110 needed, but you need to convert the average kilowatt
hours used a year to divide that by the 500 kilowatt hours that are
produced a day by our buoys and you end up with needing 52 point
absorber buoys to supply the whole population with sufficient and reliable
energy.
decided how much money we are going to spend. Each buoy cost 130
will be buying the buoys from. Once you do the math you get a grand total
the US and that is produced from fossil fuels. At the end of 2019 the U.S.
used a whopping 3.99 trillion kilowatt hours which when you do the math
Clean Energy in the Socotra Archipelago 17
that comes out to 877,800,000,000 dollars that the U.S. paid not just to use
the electricity but to make it and get the materials needed for it to be made.
With our plan that extrudes the need to pay for the gathering and creation
of energy. We pay for the buoy and the waves supply the rest.
Clean Energy in the Socotra Archipelago 18
Conclusion
A point absorber buoy is a form of Tidal energy, it is used to help with creating clean,
renewable energy. The way this device is constructed is that it has a piston that moves up and
down that drives a generator. When waves run through the device the generator will continue to
work. This is all inside of a buoy that is anchored to the ground. There is a cable that runs back
to the shore and gives power to the land. This generator will provide energy that will send
electrical power to the buildings inside of Socotra. The company who will fund these buoys will
The reason why having a point absorber buoy is such a good thing is because it will make
these businesses run on electricity instead of old fossil fuels that will help with reducing air
pollution and all of its other waste. This will help with pollution in this city. Since this will help
with air pollution as well, it will make the air cleaner and the animals would be able to live better
lives, all from just these point absorber buoys. The cost to fully install these buoys would be
“approximately $130M,” according to Osti. This buoy that we would use is a PB500 (powerbuoy
500) which provides “500 kilowatts of power,” according to Osti. Once the price of this 130
million dollar project is paid for it will be free energy as the waves of the ocean run through each
of the buoys powering up the entire town helping to keep the air cleaner and animal pollution
minimalized.
Clean Energy in the Socotra Archipelago 19
Work Cited
Dufera, Hizkyas. “PB500, 500 KW Utility-Scale Powerbuoy Project.” PB500, 500 KW Utility-Scale
Powerbuoy Project (Technical Report) | OSTI.GOV, 3 Mar. 2016, www.osti.gov/biblio/1324306.
Electricity Rates. “Electricity Rates by State (Updated December 2020).” Electric Choice,
www.electricchoice.com/electricity-prices-by-state/.
Fenton-Harvey, Jonathan. "The UAE's Grand Plans for Yemen's Socotra Island." Inside Arabia. 01 Dec.
2020. Web.
New World Encyclopedia Contributors. “Socotra”. New World Encyclopedia. 17 Nov 2019. Retrieved
from https://www.newworldencyclopedia.org/p/index.php?title=Socotra&oldid=102740.
The Editors of Encyclopedia Britannica. “Socotra”. Britannica. 24 June 2020. Retrieved from
https://www.britannica.com/place/Socotra.
Turner Shaw, Shaw. “Your Daily Energy Use vs Africa's.” ONE, 9 Jan. 2019, www.one.org/us/blog/your-
daily-energy-use-vs-africas/.
Saba. “Yemen's Socotra.” SabaNet - Yemen News Agency SABA|, 22 Nov. 2020,
www.saba.ye/en/news3117070.htm.
Hanania, Ray. “Saudis Donate $500 Million to Yemen Humanitarian Relief.” The Arab Daily News, 26
Feb. 2019, thearabdailynews.com/2019/02/26/saudis-donate-500-million-to-yemen-humanitarian-
relief/.
Saudi Development and Reconstruction Program for Yemen. "Saudi Projects in Vital Sectors Advance
Socotra Development." United States. 29 Jan. 2020. https://www.prnewswire.com/ae/news-
releases/saudi-projects-in-vital-sectors-advance-socotra-development-300995295.html.
Clean Energy in the Socotra Archipelago 20
Appendices
Team Contract
Task Roles
Leader: Colton
Recorder: Dillon
Editor: William
Opinion Giver: Lily
Administrator: Jeo
Relational Roles
Tension Reliever: Dillon
Listener: Jeo
Harmonizer: Lily
Sensor: Will
Keep it together: Colton
Clean Energy in the Socotra Archipelago 21
Team Norms
Relational Norms
Be nice
Everyone’s entitled to their own opinion
Constructive criticism
Be actively listening
Task Norms
Research
Note taking
Communicating
Come prepared
Fact checking
Problem Defined:
How do we protect the biodiversity in Sacotro
Criteria Chart
Dillon Kelly - Attended all meetings. Came prepared with new information that he was
assigned each time. He included himself in discussions and played his role very well,
giving his insight on which problem and solution we should follow through with. He
helped with everything.
Colton Silimon- Attended all meetings. He was our team leader, and took lead for most
meetings. He provided great insight on everything and really helped with the
organization of our final report and google slides.
Lily Martin- Attended all meetings. She was assigned as the opinion giver and boy did
she do just that. She filled out our final report with so many side notes that truly made
our final report what it is. Her edits brought our final report to a whole new level and was
extremely helpful.
Will Milligate- Attended all meetings he could be at. Did what was asked of him and more.
Was always asking what he could help with and really helped pull our team together. He
was interactive with the group and played a big role in the manufacturing of the power
buoy.
Jeovanni Reyna- Attended all meetings. Did his part in being an administrator. Did
thorough and extensive research making our final report really pop. Helped with
everyone and was constantly asking if his was good enough which I really liked because
it showed he cared and wanted his work to be the best it could be.