Module: Positive and Negative Effects of Religion Date Submitted: - Rating: - Objectives
Module: Positive and Negative Effects of Religion Date Submitted: - Rating: - Objectives
Module: Positive and Negative Effects of Religion Date Submitted: - Rating: - Objectives
1
Motivational Activity
2 pts each!
CONCEPT MAP
RELIGIONS
NEGATIVE
EFFECTS
POSITIVE
EFFECTS
Promotes Social
Harmony Affirms Social Hierarchy
2
Dating back to the emergence of ancient societies, religion has already played an important role in the lives of our
ancestors. In Mesopotamia, for example, the Sumerians organized their settlement into temple communities,
wherein the temple was found at the center of their communities and the veneration of their gods and goddesses
govern their daily lives. They believed that the lands which they tilled were owned by the deities that is why they
offered part of their harvest to their priest, who was also their leader and who was seen as people’s intermediary to
higher beings. In the absence of an organized religion, their concept of morality was based on the belief that right
actions earn the approval of the gods and goddesses and wrong actions may cause punishment. Hence, the
importance of ritual practices to appease the supernatural beings whom they considered as having control over their
lives.
3
Religion Provides Moral Values
Perhaps one of the most significant functions of religion is that it encourages moral values. It provides a systematic
model of the universe, which in effect determines organized human behavior. By providing moral values, one is
ableto distinguish right from wrong, good from evil. It also provides a system of reward and punishment that
administers and standardizes people’s behavior in society. Some people believe that it is sometimes more effective
than the laws implemented by the state, since most people give more importance to the reward and punishment in
the afterlife.
In ancient societies, notions of right and wrong were not yet as clear-cut as the morality imposed by organized
religions. People then acted according to what they thought would please or displease the gods and goddesses.
During those times, rituals were very important because it is through these that they invoke the pleasure or wrath of
the deities. For example, before planting, farmers would perform a kind of ritual, led by their spiritual leaders, to ask
for blessings from the deities so that their harvest would be bountiful. When calamity destroyed their crops, they
would interpret it as a sign that they must have done something which displeased the deities, and would again
perform a ritual to appease them. When they had a productive harvest, they would again perform a ritual to extend
their gratitude to the deities whom they believed to be responsible for their good fortune.
4
Religion Gives People a Sense of Belonging
Just as family, ethnicity, or nationality give people a sense of belonging, so does religion. For some, religion
provides people with personal identity as part of a group with similar worldviews, beliefs, values, practices,
andlifestyles. It provides communities with prospects to recognize and offer vital action and service to provide the
needs of the larger community. Belonging to a particular religion—whose members share the same beliefs, practice
the same rituals, and worship the same god—gives individuals a sense of being in the right place with the right
people. It also provides them with a sense of security because other people who belong to the same religious group
will tend to support and help each other in times of crisis. A religious group or community can provide counsel, help
the sick and underprivileged, and give other services on a more personal level than the government. Members of a
religious community can have the assurance that they can rely on other people’s help in times of need. They can
also expect to have other people rejoice with them in times of success. Religion can provide a sense of personal
identity and belonging.
A good example of religion giving people a sense of belonging is the Sikh principle of Seva, also known as Sewa,
from the word Karsevawhich means “selfless service.” Sikhs are expected to perform work or service without
expecting anything in return. They are encouraged by their Guru (Guru GranthSaib) to perform selfless service with
the belief that by so doing, they are not only promoting good community relations but also paving the way for the
moral uplifting of a person, thus strengthening his or her sense of belonging to the community. They are taught to
reach out to serve and uplift all of humanity to show their devotion to their god.
TRIVIA
Sewaor selfless sacrifice is an aspect of Sikhism that gives people a sense of belonging, one of the positive effects of religion. An example of sewawould be the
feeding program being undertaken by the Sikh people.
5
Religion As An Economic Tool for Exploiting the Masses
According to the German philosopher Karl Marx, “religion is the opium of the masses.” This is in relation to his
critical approach to religion in which he proposed that the bourgeoisie keeps the proletariat in control through
religion. According to Marx, it maintains social inequality by propagating a worldview that justifies oppression. He
believed that religion can be effectively used by the ruling class to maintain a social order that is more favorable to
them. Whether one is Christian, Jewish, or Muslim, religious teachings justifying one’s acceptance of oppression as
a normal part of life on earth and as a means to get an everlasting reward in the afterlife can be seen as a bourgeois
tactic to maintain the status quo where they reap more resources and power in society. Thus, in Marx’s conflict
theory, the abolition of religion is also needed to liberate the masses from their oppressive state.
6
Nicolas Copernicus, a Renaissance mathematician and astronomer, proved that the sun is the center of
the solar system, disproving the Ptolemaic theory advanced by the Catholic church, which claimed that the
earth is the center of the solar system.
The Inquisition
Inquisition refers to the Roman Catholic Church groups charged with subduing heresy from around 1184, which
includes the Episcopal Inquisition (1184-1230s) and the Papal Inquisition (1230s). The Inquisition was a response to
large popular movements in Europe considered heretical or profane to Christianity, particularly Catharism (a
Christian dualist movement which espousedthe idea of two gods, one being good and the other evil) and
Waldensians (a Protestant Christian movement which advocated that apostolic poverty is the way to perfection) in
southern France and southern Italy.
The word “inquisition,” has somehow become associated with the word “torture.” This is because after 1252, torture
was used to punish the heretics. On May 15, a papal bull was issued by Pope Innocent IV, the Ad exstirpanda,
which authorized the use of torture by inquisitors. One common form of torture was the strappado, wherein the
hands were bound behind the back with a rope, and the accused was suspended this way, dislocating the joints
painfully in both arms.
7
THE GODHRA TRAIN INCIDENT IN 2002
In February 2002, a train was set on fire in which 59 people, including 25 women and 15 children, were killed. The
fire happened inside the Sabarmati Express train near the Godhra railway station in the Indian state of Gujarat.
Those who died inside the train were mostly Hindu pilgrims and activists returning from the holy city of Ayodhya after
a religious ceremony at the disputed Babri Masjid site. It took six years for the commission appointed to investigate
the said incident to conclude that the fire was committed by a mob of 1000-2000 people. Thirty-one Muslims were
convicted by the court for the incident and conspiracy for the crime.
The Babri Masjid site was a source of the Ayodha dispute, which was centered on access to the site traditionally
regarded by the Hindus as the birthplace of the Hindu deity Rama. Hindus accuse the Muslims of demolishing a
previous Hindu temple on the site to create the Babri mosque, which was destroyed by radical Hindu activists during
a political rally that turned into a riot on December 6, 1992. The Godhra train incident in 2002 was seen as a Muslim
retaliation for the demolition of the Babri mosque in 1992. The discovery in 2003 of Buddhist ruins underlying the
Hindu and Muslim layers at Ayodhya only made matters more complicated.
Although so many atrocities have been committed in the name of religion, we should bear in mind that more often
than not, there are other factors at play. Politics and economics often play a key role in religious conflicts. Sadly,
some political parties take advantage of religious conflicts to pursue their own interests, and that is winning in the
next elections. In India, for example, political parties have been accused of using Hindu-Muslim conflict to advance
their own interests by ruling in favor of those who will give them the highest votes.
8
Summary
• Religion can be described as a double-edged sword: it can have both positive and negative effects on society. It has played a
very important role in the development of societies by integrating and stabilizing them; however, it has also created conflicts.
• Some of its positive effects are: it promotes social solidarity; it is a source of moral values; it nurtures positive goals in life; it
gives people a sense of belonging; and it fosters social change.
• Some of religion’s negative effects include: it affirms social hierarchy; it triggers conflicts and fights; it promotes discrimination;
it impedes scientific success and development; and it hinders the use of reason.
• Some of the world’s atrocities and conflicts were caused by religion such as the self-immolation of a Buddhist monk in
Vietnam; the practice of sati or widow burning in India; the Inquisition of the Catholic Church; and the Godhra train incident in
India.
ASSESSMENT
Identification. Choose from the list below. Write the correct answer on the blank.
a. Babri Masjid f. Indianization
b. Trepanning g. Sati
c. Devaraja h. Strappado
d. Mount Meru i. Babaylan or catalonan
e. Self-immolatio j. Ayodhya
9
REFERENCE
BOOKS
Haviland, William, et al (2005). Anthropology. The Human Challenge. Belmont, California: Wadsworth /Thomson
Learning.
Harris, Sam (2006). The End of Faith: Religion, Terror, and the Future of Reason. Great Britain: Free Press.
Hunt, Elgin & David Colander (2011). Social Science. An Introduction to the Study of Society. 14th edition.
Massachusetts: Allyn & Bacon.
Meister, Chad (2009). Introducing Philosophy of Religion. London & New York: Routledge.
INTERNET
Balgas, Tresa (2014). Muslim-American man wins nearly $1.2 million in job discrimination case.
http://archive.freep.com/article/20140228/NEWS05/302280130/Muslim-discrimination-beard/Retrieved November
20, 2014.
BBC News. India wife dies on husband’s pyre. http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/south_asia/5273336.stm. Retrieved
September 3, 2014.
Boundless. “Religion and Social Control.” Boundless Sociology. Boundless, 27 Jun. 2014.
https://www.boundless.com/sociology/textbooks/boundless-sociology-textbook/religion-14/the-conflict-perspective-
107/religion-and-social-control-596-2095/Retrieved November 20, 2014.
Fagan, Patrick (1996). Why Religion Matters: The Impact of Religious Practice on Social Stability,” Heritage
Foundation Backgrounder No. 1064, www.heritage.org/research/religion/upload/bg_1064.pdf/Retrieved November
20, 2014.
O’Brien, Nancy Frazer. Embryonic stem-cell research immoral, unnecessary, bishops say. Catholic News Service.
http://www.americancatholic.org/news/stemcell/Retrieved November 20, 2014.
Pennachia, Robyn (2013). On the 50th Anniversary of Buddhist Monk Thich Quang Duc’s Self-Immolation.
http://www.deathandtaxesmag.com/200114/on-the-50th-anniversary-of-buddhist-monk-thich-quang-ducs-self-
immolation/. Retrieved September 2, 2014.
Subramanium, KS (2011). Truth Behind the Fire in Sabarmati Express.
http://www.mainstreamweekly.net/article2684.html. Retrieved September 3, 2014.
The Instiitute on Religion in an Age of Science (2003). The Positive Side of Religion.
http://www.iras.org/positivereligion.html. Retrieved on August 31, 2014.
The Unbounded Spirit. The Negative Effects of Religion on Society. http://theunboundedspirit.com/the-negative-
effects-of-religion-on-society/. Retrieved September 1, 2014.
8 Atrocities Committed in the Name of Religion. http://listverse.com/2008/04/02/8-atrocities-committed-in-the-name-
of-religion/Retrieved September 4, 2014
10