WWROF WEBNAIR RX Antennas For A Small Lot
WWROF WEBNAIR RX Antennas For A Small Lot
WWROF WEBNAIR RX Antennas For A Small Lot
Receiving Antennas
for a Small Lot
Sponsors
Jose Carlos N4IS
3/4/2016 World Wide Radio Operators Foundation, Inc. Copyright © Reserved N4IS JC DASILVA 1
High performance receiving antennas for small lots
Basic concepts and practical aspects
• Directivity & gain
• Signal to noise ratio
• RDF antenna comparison for 1.8 MHz
• What a receiver antenna can do for you
Dual loaded loop receiving antenna (resources back up slides) • NX4D Doug Waller QTH 1/5 acre city lot subdivision
• Historic evolution • 309 countries heard on 160m
• Beverage EWE FLAG DHDL QDFA • 298 worked 2003 to 2016 40 zones since 2011
• Rotatable Rx antennas HWF VWF • Average of 2 new countries every! Month!
• Constructions details • Average of 24 new countries every! Year!
• 13 years in a row! >> http://nx4d10.wix.com/waller-flag
World Wide Radio Operators Foundation, Inc.
3/4/2016 2
Copyright © Reserved N4IS JC DASILVA
RX antennas directivity & gain
Noise
• The gain is the difference between an amplifier input and output intensity.
• Adding a 18 db. gain amplifier, the signal and the noise will increase 18db
and the signal noise still will be the same.
-38 dBm
28 db. SN
-20 dBm
28 db. SN
30 db. SN
40 db. SN
When the signal is above noise there is little difference on the audio. The
receiver AGC will make the strong signal just more comfortable to copy but it
should not be used for evaluation of the receiver antenna.
QRN
QRN
QRN
DX signal
QRM QRM
World Wide Radio Operators Foundation, Inc.
3/4/2016 7
Copyright © Reserved N4IS JC DASILVA
Understanding directive antenna gain
QRN
QRN
QRN
Sinal de DX
QRM QRM
World Wide Radio Operators Foundation, Inc.
3/4/2016 8
Copyright © Reserved N4IS JC DASILVA
RDF calculation using EZNEC
• Directivity gain is the difference between Total Average gain and maximum antenna gain.
• W8JI Receive Directivity Factor > http://www.w8ji.com/receiving.htm
• “Edward C. Jordan Keith G . Balmain “(Electromagnetic Waves and Radiating Systems) 11.11 pg. 374 Antenna Gain . 1950
• On EZNEC it is easy to calculate RDF using 3D plot configuration
6 dB
Magnetic Loop
*Inverted V for 160m at 120 Ft high 7 dB EWE K9AY FLAG
400 Ft BOG Vertical Flag
Dipole 160m at 3 m high 8 dB
Single Horizontal Flag
Dipole 160m at 20 m high
AS-SAL 9 dB Beverage 500 Ft
180 Dipole; Inverted “V” BOG’s
DHDL
10 dB
Beverage and HWF HI-Z 4 sq 200Ft
40
25 Waller Flag 11 dB Waller Flag
http://www.k7tjr.com/rx1comparison.htm
10 dB
4 Square Vertical Array
11 dB
WF
2 elements Yagi 12 dB HWF
Cubic quad 2 elements
3 elements Yagi 13 dB 3 x WF
4 x WF or EWE
5 elements Yagi 14 dB 4 x DHDL
DX2
3 dB DX 1
1. Vertical RDF 5 dB > FLAG RDF 7 dB ( 2 ) = 3 to 4 dB improvement on ( 1.5to 2 dB SNR for 1 dB RDF )
2. DX 1 only copy on the FLAG antenna HUGE DIFFERENCE
3. DX 2 much improved copy on the FLAG
World Wide Radio Operators Foundation, Inc.
3/4/2016 12
Copyright © Reserved N4IS JC DASILVA
SECOND STEP >> DHDL SAL or single Horizontal Flag 8.5 to 10 dB RDF
DX 1 DX2
8 dB
Flag noise level
DHDL noise level
8 dB
Flag noise level
DX3 DHDL noise level
THIRD STEP >> RX 4 square Waller Flag 1000Ft beverage 11.5 dB RDF
DX 4 WF noise level
1. Vertical RDF 5 dB > WF 11.5 dB ( 6 ) = 9 to 12 dB improvement
2. DX 3 very comfortable copy on the WF
3. DX 4 below noise level on the FLAG and the DHDL
4. WF copy DX4 UNBELIEVABLE !!!!
World Wide Radio Operators Foundation, Inc.
3/4/2016 17
Copyright © Reserved N4IS JC DASILVA
EVEN
-3dB
+3dB
-1dB
0dB 0dB
-1dB -1dB
MAN MADE
NOISE
REJECTION
3/4/2016
World Wide Radio Operators Foundation, Inc.
Copyright © Reserved N4IS JC DASILVA
19
BUT !!! WHAT ABOUT MY LOCAL CITY NOISE!
FORTH STEP >> Polarization filter HWF 11.5 to 12 dB RDF
TX ant noise
- 30 db
Flag noise level
Boom 40 Ft (12m)
Elements 26 Ft (8m)
World Wide Radio Operators Foundation, Inc.
3/4/2016 22
Copyright © Reserved N4IS JC DASILVA
N4IS Horizontal Waller Flag HWF
2006 VWF
2009 HWF
30 ATNO
Average per
year on 160m
Boom 40 Ft (12m)
Elements 26 Ft (8m)
World Wide Radio Operators Foundation, Inc.
3/4/2016 23
Copyright © Reserved N4IS JC DASILVA
HWF, Horizontal Waller Flag Polarplot 40m
480 FT 4 2 1
-25
55H
Gb
TDEG
Fig.1– K. Siwiak, KE4PT, “Is There an Optimum Height for an HF Antenna?”Jun 2011, QST, pp 33– 35.
Fig.2– K. Siwiak, “Ionospherica – The Last Bounce”, QRP Quarterly, Fall 2013, pp 32-33.
World Wide Radio Operators Foundation, Inc.
3/4/2016 28
Copyright © Reserved N4IS JC DASILVA
Man-Made Noise in a 500Hz Bandwidth
Man-Made noise
160 80
vertical polarized
40 20
ground wave
S9
S0 160 m 47 dBm 42 30
80 m 35 dBm 30 22
40 m 20 dBm 15 10
s9 1.25 miles
( -73 dBm )
Noise during the day with no QRN
- 90 dBm ( 500Hz)
N4IS
1.8 MHz
Sky wave propagation noise
• Minimum noise during a quiet winter morning can be as low as1.3dB
• System Noise Figure of 1.3 dB degrades the signal to noise ratio by 3 dB
• The insertion loss of all passive devices adds directly to Noise Figure
• N4IS RX system has 1,4 dB NF >>
• IC7800 20 dB NF
• N4IS .5 dB preamplifier (40 dB gain)
• Input Filter .2 dB
WF system operates near the
receiver noise floor
2 000 K ~ = 9 dB
LOCAL NOISE
60 Ft
Detune TX antennas, nearby structures, elevated radials and low dipoles, that degrade radiation pattern.
World Wide Radio Operators Foundation, Inc.
3/4/2016 34
Copyright © Reserved N4IS JC DASILVA
INTERACTION BETWEEN ELEMENTS
120FT = 40 m
re-radiation
Z in
Changing the impedance Zin or Zout Easy way to kill all your RX antennas is;
does not detune the feedline cable Low dipole and ¼ wave elevated radials
World Wide Radio Operators Foundation, Inc.
3/4/2016 36
Copyright © Reserved N4IS JC DASILVA
DEGRADED RADIATION PATTERN
RX SIGNAL
0 dB
FROM WF -10 dB
-20 dB
TX ANTENNA
SIGNAL
COMMON
MODE NOISE
PREAMPLIFIER IS PART OF THE RADIO - NOT THE ANTENNA
World Wide Radio Operators Foundation, Inc.
3/4/2016 37
Copyright © Reserved N4IS JC DASILVA
NX4D >> When the WF is beaming 90° or less toward the tower, I get 1.5 to 2.0 S-units of noise reduction.
Removing the center coax cable conductor from the tower helps some, but neutralizing the tower is a big noise
reduction.
PY2XB >> Antenna Detuning - Relay Boxes: In order to not jeopardize the RX Flag antenna's pattern, it is
necessary to avoid interaction with nearby antennas or structures. The relays are operated in such way that, on
receiving, the 80m folded dipole and the 160m sloper are not "seen" by the RX Flag antenna.
• https://www.flickr.com/photos/133647736@N07/sets/72157653478604348/
PY2XB NX4D
ELECTRICAL
FIELD
MAGNECTIC
GROUND
5%
100 %
50 %
World Wide Radio Operators Foundation, Inc.
3/4/2016 40
Copyright © Reserved N4IS JC DASILVA
Protecting RX feed lines from common mode noise
http://www.hifidelity.com/w3eee/Noiz%20.html
A Ham's Guide to RFI, Ferrites, Baluns, and Audio Interfacing by Jim Brown K9YC
http://audiosystemsgroup.com/RFI-Ham.pdf
Common-Mode Chokes 1 by Chuck Counselman, W1HIS
http://www.yccc.org/Articles/W1HIS/CommonModeChokesW1HIS2006Apr06.pdf
http://www.bcdxc.org/pl259_crimp_on_connectors.htm
http://www.eham.net/articles/19257
I am using “N” and SMA connectors only One BAD connector increase noise 2-4 S units
1919 March 5, 1919, Roy A. Weagant, Chief Engineer of the Marconi Wireless Telegraph Co. of America, delivered a
paper describing in detail his apparatus for the elimination of the great bug-bear of transoceanic wireless
communication -- static interference. >>
http://infoage.org/html/wa-1919-04-p11.html
1938 Harold Beverage invented wide band receiver antenna, loaded loop. The present invention relates to short
wave antennas and, more particularly, to antennas for receiving horizontally polarized waves over a wide band
of frequencies. An object of the present invention is to enable the reception of horizontally polarized signals
over a wide band of frequencies such-as is at present used in television.
https://docs.google.com/viewer?url=patentimages.storage.googleapis.com/pdfs/US2247743.pdf
1940. Nearly all the newly re-invented compact receive antennas derive from the terminated loop, the earliest
reference was in an appallingly mimeographed prewar training manual of W3EEE Dad‘s
1973 COMMUNICATIONS 74 CONFERENCE BRIGHTON Wednesday, June 5 1974 — Session 5 Equipment Design
Paper 5.3: Loop Antennas for HF Reception Contributed by: B.S.Collins, C & S Antennas Ltd.,
World Wide Radio Operators Foundation, Inc.
3/4/2016 52
Copyright © Reserved N4IS JC DASILVA
1995 JF1DMQ wrote an earlier article about the Flag antenna in November 1995 in a Japanese magazine. His was only 3.3 feet by 16.4
feet long (1 by 5 m).K6SE's 160m optimized versions are 14 by 29 feet (4.3 by 8.8m).
1995 "Is This EWE for You?" (QST February, 1995, p.31) and "More EWES for You",
QST January, 1996, p. 32) both by WA2WVL.
1996 The Pennant was originated by EA3VY and optimized for 160 meters by K6SE, who first wrote about them on the
Top Band Reflector in 1998
1997 The K9AY Terminated Loop—A Compact, Directional Receiving Antenna By Gary Breed, K9AY
2000 QST Magazine, July 2000, page 34 for K6SE's classic article:
"Flags, Pennants, and Other Ground-Independent Low-Band Receiving Antennas" ...
2006 N4IS developed the BIG flag vertical array >> www.n4is.com
2009 Dr Dallas Lankford, wrote the Flag Theory and design the Quad Flag Array >> Dallas Files
The Dallas Files are now found here: http://groups.yahoo.com/group/thedallasfiles2
2009 AA7JV George Wallner developed the DHDL (TX3A) >> http://tx3a.com/docs/TX3A_DOUBLE_HALF_DELTA_LOOP.ZIP
The current which flows in a loop antenna may be represented by a Fourier series of cosine and sine
terms. The zero order term represents a constant current flowing around the hop and gives rise to the
familiar figure-of-eight radiation pattern typical of a small loop.
The odd order (sine) terms represent the currents which flow in the same direction in both sides of the
loop and therefore do not give rise to any output voltage across a balanced terminating impedance. The
azimuth radiation pattern associated with this current mode in a small loop is circular. When the loop is
fed with an unbalanced feed both even and odd modes can exist. The total radiation pattern of the loop
will be the sum of those due to the separate modes. The zero order mode predominates in a simple loop;
in order to obtain a cardioid radiation pattern the amplitude of the zero order mode current must be
reduced relative to the first order mode current, and the relative phase of the currents must be adjusted
so that the cancellation obtained in the rearwards direction is complete. This result can be achieved by
inserting a suitable impedance in series with the loop at a point diametrically opposite the feed point.
The terminated loop exhibits a near cardioid azimuth radiation pattern for vertically polarized incident
energy and an input impedance which may easily be matched to 50 ohms.
3/4/2016
World Wide Radio Operators Foundation, Inc. EWE 55
Copyright © Reserved N4IS JC DASILVA
Dual Half Dual Loop AA7JV
signal Transformer
Resistor
HWF HWF
HWF
HWF
HWF
HWF
HWF
http://nx4d10.wix.com/waller-flag#!page3/cee5
More HWF photos >>>>>>>>
World Wide Radio Operators Foundation, Inc.
3/4/2016 67
Copyright © Reserved N4IS JC DASILVA