Longitudinal Effects of Childhood Trauma
Longitudinal Effects of Childhood Trauma
Longitudinal Effects of Childhood Trauma
Immaculata University
Immaculata University
2
LONGITUDINAL … TRAUMA
Abstract
This independent study will focus on drawing relevant educational experiences tied to research
connected with the longitudinal effects of childhood trauma to the development of adult
understanding of the connection of past trauma and psychopathology and the implications of
these perceptions on a counselor’s work by looking into relevant research. Discussions will
address how better understanding of the development of implementing this research into
counselor education and clinical practice can inform a counselor’s work. A multitude of
scholarly journals and the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders Fifth Edition
2013; Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, 2015; Cohen, Scheid, and Gerson, 2014;
Corso, Edwards, Fang, and Mercy, 2008; Felitti, 2009; Gilbert, Breiding, Merrick, Thompson,
Ford, Dhingra, and Parks, 2015; Kruijshaar, Hoeymans, Spijker, Stouthard, and Essink-Bot,
2005; Merrick, Fortson, and Mercy, 2015; National Institute on Drug Abuse, 2008; Shonkoff,
Boyce, and McEwen, 2009; Venigalla, Mekala, Hassan M, et al., 2017). The goal was to
discover how childhood trauma contributes to the later development of psychopathology and
pathophysiology. The clinically relevant knowledge I gained has allowed me to create a literature
review that could later represent a future thesis or future research endeavors. That being said, it is
important that I highlight the major research limitations encountered. No official funding was
trauma can influence the later development of a mental-health disorder or can contribute to the
later onset of a physical illness that is associated with a plethora of physiological effects and
complications.
3
LONGITUDINAL … TRAUMA
Key Words
Biomarker - An attribute that is objectively measured and evaluated as an indicator of normal
biologic processes, pathologic processes, or biological responses to a therapeutic intervention.
Clinician – Represents either a scientist conducting research or describes the role of a health-
care worker that directly helps with the process of curing patients that suffer from either a
medically-related condition or a mental-health related issue. Examples: Physician, nurse,
therapist, dentist, social worker.
Epidemiological – The study of the distribution (frequency, pattern) and determinants (causes,
risk factors) of health-related states and events (not just diseases) in specified populations
(neighborhood, school, city, state, country, global). The method used to find the causes of health
outcomes and diseases in populations.
Epigenetics - the study of heritable changes in gene expression (active versus inactive genes)
that do not involve changes to the underlying DNA sequence - a change in phenotype without a
change in genotype - which in turn affects how cells read the genes.
FMRI – Measures blood flow through the brain, telling doctors more about the activities of
neurons and show which brain regions are most active.
Neurobiology - a branch of the life sciences that deals with the anatomy, physiology, and
pathology of the nervous system
4
LONGITUDINAL … TRAUMA
Pathology - Describes conditions typically observed during a disease state. Describes the
abnormal or undesired condition. The study of the structural and functional changes produced
by them
Pathophysiology - The study of the disordered physiological processes that cause, result from,
or are otherwise associated with a disease or injury. This seeks to explain the functional changes
that are occurring within an individual due to a disease or pathologic state.
Psychopathology - The scientific study of mental disorders, including efforts to understand their
genetic, biological, psychological, and social causes; develop classification schemes which can
improve treatment planning and treatment outcomes; understand the course of psychiatric
illnesses across all stages of development; more fully understand the manifestations of mental
disorders; and investigate potentially effective treatments
Reliability - The extent to which the results can be reproduced when the research is repeated
under the same conditions. It is assessed by checking the consistency of results across time,
across different observers, and across parts of the test itself. A reliable measurement is not
always valid: the results might be reproducible, but they’re not necessarily correct.
Trauma – Occurs when a person experiences either an actual or threatened death, endures a
serious injury, or is a victim of sexual violence. (American Psychiatric Association, 2013)
Validity - The extent to which the results really measure what they are supposed to measure. It is
assessed by checking how well the results correspond to established theories and other measures
of the same concept. A valid measurement is generally reliable: if a test produces accurate
results, they should be reproducible.
5
LONGITUDINAL … TRAUMA
Longitudinal Effects of Childhood Trauma
Introduction
The National Institutes of Health (NIH) believes trauma affects more than two thirds of
American children; and estimate that one third experience multiple, often chronic, traumas such
as child maltreatment (child sexual, physical, or emotional abuse; child neglect; or domestic
violence). Yet widespread efforts to identify and effectively treat the potentially serious and
long-term negative impacts of these experiences lag far behind. Research connecting the
longitudinal effects of childhood trauma to the later development of adult pathology expands
mental-health practitioners with at best, broad clinical interpretations. This poses the question of
how exactly negative health outcomes are linked to childhood adversities. A more complete
between childhood adversities and disease burden. Therefore, in order to develop an integrative
understanding of the relationship between trauma and the later onset of pathology, clinicians can
obtain scholarly journals published by different professional organizations and around the globe.
Once a relationship can be established, outlining how the research can implicate and inform a
Trauma
manifests when a person experiences either an actual or threatened death, endures a serious
injury, or is a victim of sexual violence in at least one of the following four ways: (a) directly
6
LONGITUDINAL … TRAUMA
encounters a threatening event; (b) physically witnesses an intrusive event occurring to others;
(c) learns that a close family member or friend experienced a troublesome event; or (d)
highlight that an actual or threatened death must occur in a violent or accidental manner; and
excludes any exposure through social media, television, movies or pictures, unless it is work-
related.
In 1990, Dr. Felitti presented his landmark ACE study showing research that links events
of childhood adversity and health outcomes. This would be the first study of its kind to introduce
the longitudinal effects of childhood trauma. The ACE study strongly established a dose-
response relationship, which is an important step towards demonstrating causality. Through his
research efforts, Dr. Felitti (2009) found that a person with a higher ACE score would become
more likely to later develop a cluster of diseases. Clinicians would become inspired to study just
how trauma over activates the body’s stress response; and many curious how it leads to a
Dr. Alan Guttmacher, head of the National Institute of Child Health and Human
Development, notions when adverse childhood experiences occur, the body has a series of stress
responses. Areas of the brain, such as the amygdala, prefrontal cortex, hypothalamic-pituitary-
adrenal (HPA) axis, sympatho-adrenomedullary (SAM) axis, noradrenergic nucleus in the locus
coeruleus, and hippocampus all rapidly react to the potentially threatening stimuli. Research
7
LONGITUDINAL … TRAUMA
indicates that when a child is overly exposed to a stressor, it can reduce the size of their
hippocampus by up to 4x its healthy developed state. MRI studies have indicated that when
children are chronically traumatized, their risk for dramatically enlarging their amygdalae
skyrockets. Research has shown that trauma can trigger chronic inflammation throughout the
body, alter how hormones functions for decades, and can alter how DNA is replicated and how
our body reads it. Other research using other brain-imaging tests have shown how trauma stunts
a child’s skeletal maturity. This indicates that when a child experiences trauma at a young age,
the child may continue to age in years but will show the muscular age and growth consistent of
their age when the trauma occurred. Overall, the consequences of toxic stress are neurologic,
hormonal, immunologic, compromise the health of telomeres, effect epigenetic markets and
transgenerational genetics.
Corso et al. (2008) includes research suggesting that childhood adversities have an
independent effect on disease burden, apart from their effect on mental and general medical
disorders. These findings are in line with other research showing that childhood adversities are
associated with health outcomes in adulthood. Our study adds to this by showing that childhood
adversities have a strong impact on disease burden, through increasing the risk of mental and
general medical disorders, but also by an effect which is independent from these disorders.
Venigalla H, Mekala HM, Hassan M, et al. (2017) strongly assert that adverse trauma
negatively impacts a child’s short-and-long term mental well-being, biological systems, and its
studies, and meta-analyses to support why adverse childhood events increase a child’s risk of
8
LONGITUDINAL … TRAUMA
later developing a psychopathological disorder(s); such as various mood disorder(s), anxiety
disorder(s), alcohol problems, eating disorder(s), and psychotic symptoms. Their own research
has revealed childhood adversity being significantly associated with children becoming more
susceptible to later experiencing suicidal ideations and suicide attempts. Furthermore, their
research findings indicate that childhood trauma can increase a child’s risk for later developing
concurrent mental disorder(s), and include the risk of having severe interpersonal difficulties,
Gilbert et al. (2015) illustrate a small sample size of research believes adverse childhood
events may be associated with increasing ones risk of later developing a pathophysiological
disease, ischemic heart disease, liver disease, reproductive health problems, migraines, peptic
ulcers, arthritis, coronary heart disease, and diabetes. In addition, there is a growing body of
research that believes early childhood trauma cause damage to the nervous, endocrine,
circulatory, musculoskeletal, reproductive, respiratory, and immune systems. That being said,
despite research findings, clinicians do not have enough evidence to support all the correlations.
Venigalla H, Mekala HM, Hassan M, et al. (2017) assert that different methodologies can
be used in order to explain and further support the relationship between childhood trauma and
being able to predict a person’s health status throughout adulthood. For example, there are
several studies that adequately portray how the onset of chronic stress, addiction, or depression at
a young age can severely effect a person’s quality of life later on in adulthood. A second way to
9
LONGITUDINAL … TRAUMA
explain the relationship can be performed by using statistical methods to predict a person’s
mortality rate. For instance, the proportional mortality method is a simple way of portraying the
burden of a specific disease within a population. Clinicians are also able to calculate how time a
person loses in terms of their quality of life, because of year(s) lived with a certain disease. For
example, Kruijshaar, Hoeymans, Spijker, Stouthard, & Essink-Bot (2005) estimated that of each
year lived with a major depressive disorder, 46% of the quality of life in this year is missed
because of the depressive disorder. Despite their being different equations to predict a person’s
mortality rate, the calculations have a low validity rate due to the limited research on the overall
impact of childhood adversities on disease burden on a population level. Without this data,
clinicians are unable to accurately calculate a patient’s mortality rate, which explains why its
The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (2015) point out that a child’s risk of
family, and environmental factors, all of which interact to increase or decrease risk over time and
within specific contexts. Obvious risk factors include a child’s age and if they have any special
needs may increase their vulnerability (e.g., developmental and intellectual disabilities, mental
health issues, and chronic physical illnesses). Additional risk factors include the age of the
parent(s) or caregiver(s), the number of children in the household, if there is any parental history
of abuse, neglect, substance abuse, or mental-health issues, if there is any history of intimate
partner or community violence, and concentrated neighborhood disadvantage (e.g., high poverty
and residential instability, high unemployment rates). Although risk factors provide information
10
LONGITUDINAL … TRAUMA
about who is most at risk for being a victim or a perpetrator of child abuse and neglect, they are
not direct causes and cannot predict who will be a victim or a perpetrator. Fortson and Mercy
have argued that no single factor tells the entire story about how and why adverse childhood
experiences occurs, nor outline the exact risk and protective factors.
Epidemiology
Merrick, Fortson, & Mercy (2015) concluded that a child’s risk of being exposed to a
trauma-related event varies across several epidemiological factors, such as a person’s race,
ethnicity, and family income. The research indicates that younger children are most likely to
experience a fatal-related traumatic event while teens are most likely to experience a non-fatal
traumatic incident. According to data from child protective services, African American children
experience abuse and neglect at rates that are nearly double those for white children. Children
living in families with a low socioeconomic status (SES) have rates of child abuse and neglect
that are five times higher than those of children living in families with a higher SES. These
differences are generally attributed to various community and societal factors, including poverty
as well as differences in reporting and investigation. Irrespective of data source, definitions, and
measures, the true magnitude of child abuse and neglect is likely underestimated. As a result,
these numbers should be considered to be on the lower end of the spectrum. Although risk
factors continue to provide practitioners and public officials with information correlating who is
most at risk for being a victim of child abuse and neglect, they are not direct causes. Therefore,
clinicians are unable to precisely predict who will become a victim. This is can best be explained
Venigalla H, Mekala HM, Hassan M, et al. (2017) define a biomarker as an attribute that
group of genes, proteins, or other biomolecules… and can be used to confirm the presence of a
specific disease” (472). Psychiatrists aim to use biomarker testing to measure a patient’s
biological response before and after any pharmacological interventions are made. In addition,
psychiatrist would utilize biomarker testing during a patient’s follow-up appointment in order to
assess the overarching pathological process. This kind of strategic approach and systematic
process would produce objective data for psychiatrist to use to enhance their ability to make an
accurate diagnosis, form a reliable prognosis, and improve the patient’s outcomes.
Venigalla H, Mekala HM, Hassan M, et al. (2017) state that despite the past two decades
of research centered around biomarkers, clinicians have not been able to identify the etiology of
most psychiatric disorders. That being said, the current research literature introduces a set of
anatomical and physiological biomarkers that clinicians believe to correlate with the onset of
certain psychopathology. For example, Young et al. (2016) theorizes the biomarker “C-reactive
protein, Interleukin-6, Tumor necrosis factor- α” influences the onset of clinical depression
(474).
Venigalla H, Mekala HM, Hassan M, et al. (2017) indicated that despite any correlations,
biomarker testing is not openly available for clinicians to use throughout the diagnostic and
intervention process for psychiatric disorders due to its heterogeneous expression. As a result,
until research can precisely pinpoint the root cause that explains why a particular psychiatric
disorder develops, any clinical application of biomarkers to treat mental-health related disorders
12
LONGITUDINAL … TRAUMA
will remain in its early stages. To see more examples, refer to “Table-1: Various Studies
Proposing Different Biomarkers for Different Psychiatric Diagnoses” on page 16-17 and “Table-
2: Various Studies Proposing Genetic and Preteomic Biomarkers for Different Psychiatric
Shonkoff, Boyce, and McEwen (2009) exemplify how the medical community has seen
massive technological advances that have allowed clinicians to observe and study the brain like
never before. Recent developments in neuroimaging have just began to unravel the existing
development of various psychiatric disorders. Such newfound research could guide psychiatrist
to establish a reliable set of clinically applicable biomarkers. Until that happens though,
clinicians are not able to rely on biomarker testing to predict the longitudinal effects of childhood
trauma, nor are they able to better understand how a person’s biological and pathological
Treatment
According to Cohen, Scheid, and Gerson (2014) research study, there are no evidence-
based psychopharmacologic treatments available because clinical trials have generally failed to
demonstrate its effectiveness in any medication for improving pediatric PTSD (p. 11). Since not
can help calm the body’s stress response. When balancing dysregulation pathways by
incorporating exercise, maintaining a balanced diet, developing healthy sleep habits, and
improving upon interpersonal relationships are all ways to negate the longitudinal effects of
adverse childhood trauma. For adults who have not overcome their early-childhood trauma, they
can attend therapy/counseling to help improve their quality of life. In order for treatment to be
successful, a person must work through intense emotional, mental, and psychological tasks
throughout the course of therapy. People may join social support groups, local club, or turn to
graduate curriculums and was to adopt a greater emphasis that acknowledges the longitudinal
effects of childhood trauma, then the traditional biopsychosocial approach that counselors are
trained to practice, would then drastically shift to a clinical approach that largely embodies one
similar to the medical-model. This would significantly effect a counselor’s role and scope of
practice within the entire health-care system. For instance, it would foster more leadership-type
roles in clinical settings for counselors to earn within the mental-health profession and allow
counselors to command greater respect from the general public. Moreover, it may help
destigmatize the public’s misconception that attending counseling is scary or that it is ineffective.
help guild their clinical practices and could significantly enhance treatment outcomes. Generally,
14
LONGITUDINAL … TRAUMA
when more efficient and effective interventions are implemented in clinical settings, it will drive
down the overall cost for treatment and save people tax dollars. For example, the National
Institute on Drug Abuse (2008) reported that the average cost for 1 year of methadone
costs approximately $24,000 per person. As one can see, when someone is incarcerated, the costs
becomes 5x more than the more efficient, effective treatment route. This historical example
adequately depicts how new and improved treatment options could systematically open up doors
that allow people to have better access to mental-health services in underserved, rural, poor
communities.
longitudinal effects of childhood trauma, it would unify the counseling community by shortening
the amount of theoretical orientations that they practice. This is important because other health-
care professions argue that the counseling community cannot agree to use just one theory in
clinical practice. Although most counselors use cognitive-behavioral therapy (CBT) techniques
and strategies, they do so at the expense that insurance companies will generally deny covering
treatments that primarily incorporate other theoretical models. This ideological split within the
counseling community largely explains why clients may have struggled in the past with finding
the right counselor for them or have trouble obtaining mental-health services. Unifying the
If counselors were to adopt a greater emphasis that acknowledges the longitudinal effects
of childhood trauma, it could shorten the amount of times and extend the length of time that
people would attend counseling. That being said, the opposite could occur where it may increase
15
LONGITUDINAL … TRAUMA
the amount of times and extend the length of time that people would attend counseling. While
Research Methods
of resources. The interlibrary loan system at Immaculata University played a pivotal role for this
study. The platform offered global access to scholarly journals and doctoral dissertations that I
otherwise would not have access to as a general visitor of the University. My supervisor, Dr.
Martinson, played a significant role during the semester long independent study. Throughout our
navigate the direction of my research efforts. In addition, he would answer questions with rich
insight, would recommend scholarly article that was published in different professional journals,
and provided a list of 104 different scholarly publications that may enhance my research
findings. Lastly, he would offer guidance in order to help me navigate and facilitate the overall
Limitations
a number of limitations that are worth mentioning. Although I was given 15-weeks to complete
my study, there are time-related factors that affect the quality-and-amount of content gathered.
Had I been provided additional time or a support staff to help me gather research, it is plausible
that the quality of content would improve. A second limitation occurred when I was asked to pay
free resources, then I can argue that the overall quality of content I could collect would become
limited. A third limitation relates to all of my held or hidden biases’. This complex phenomenon
effected what direction I took throughout the research process. This could lead readers to
question the reliability of my research findings due to events like information bias or research
bias.
Conclusion
There is a large body of research literature that connects the longitudinal effects of
Clinicians have identified that an association exists between the two, but the amount of
participants included in these studies is too small to prove that their findings yield a direct cause-
and-effect. Although certain anatomical and physiological biomarkers are directly linked with
the onset of certain psychopathology, there is not enough evidence to support anything more than
a correlation exists.
researchers hope to one day unveil the true relationship between psychological trauma and
continuously develops, neuroscientists would like to use optogenetics on human brains because it
would allow them to map the brain’s neural circuitry, ultimately revealing secrets about how the
brain processes information and drives human behavior. This breakthrough could allow
clinicians to improve treatment outcomes and enhance a patient’s access to effective, affordable
17
LONGITUDINAL … TRAUMA
care. These improvements may uncover the “how” and “why” trauma causes longitudinal
damage.
all are effected by ACEs in similar ways. Although a child can experience many adverse events
or be exposed to severely traumatic incidents, they can forgo to live a happy, healthy life as long
as a positive, nurturing support system is in place. The long-term impacts of childhood adversity
are not all related to suffering. Adversity can foster perseverance, deepen empathy, strengthen
Table 1: Various Studies Proposing Different Biomarkers for Different Psychiatric Diagnoses
19
LONGITUDINAL … TRAUMA
20
LONGITUDINAL … TRAUMA
Table 1: Various Studies Proposing Different Biomarkers for Different Psychiatric Diagnoses
21
LONGITUDINAL … TRAUMA
Table 2: Various Studies Proposing Genetic and Preteomic Biomarkers for Different Psychiatric
Diagnoses
22
LONGITUDINAL … TRAUMA
Works Cited
American Psychiatric Association. (2013). Diagnostic and statistical manual of mental disorders
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. (2015). Child maltreatment: Risk and protective
factors. National Center for Injury Prevention and Control, Division of Violence
http://www.cdc.gov/violenceprevention/childmaltreatment/riskprotective factors.html.
Cohen, J.A., Scheid, J., Gerson, R. (2014). Transforming Trajectories for Traumatized Children.
Journal of the American Academy of Child & Adolescent Psychiatry, 53(1), 9-13.
Corso, P.S., Edwards, V.J., Fang, X., Mercy, J.A. (2008). Health-Related Quality of Life Among
Felitti V. (2009). Adverse childhood experiences and adult health. Academic Pediatrics, 9, 131-
132.
Gilbert, L. K., Breiding, M. J., Merrick, M. T., Thompson, W. W., Ford, D. C., Dhingra, S. S., &
Parks, S. E. (2015). Childhood adversity and adult chronic disease. An update from ten
states and the District of Columbia. American Journal of Preventive Medicine, 48(3),
Kruijshaar, M.E., Hoeymans, N., Spijker, J., Stouthard, M.E., Essink-Bot, M.L. (2005), Has the
burden of depression been overestimated? Bull World Health Organ, 83(6), 443-448.
doi:/S0042-96862005000600012
Merrick, M. T., Fortson, B. L., & Mercy, J. A. (2015). The epidemiology of child maltreatment.
23
LONGITUDINAL … TRAUMA
In P. D. Donnelly & C. L. Ward (Eds.), Oxford textbooks in public health – Violence: A
National Institute on Drug Abuse (2008). National Institute of Health. Retrieved from:
https://www.drugabuse.gov/publications/principles-drug-addiction-treatment-research-
based-guide-third-edition/frequently-asked-questions/drug-addiction-treatment-worth-its-
cost
Shonkoff, J.P., Boyce, W.T., McEwen, B.S. (2009). Neuroscience, Molecular Biology, and the
Disorders - Are we aware, Do we use in our clinical practice? Mental Health in Family