Schott - Sex in Games
Schott - Sex in Games
Schott - Sex in Games
ABSTRACT
No sooner is a visual medium invented than it becomes used for pornographic representation - games are no
exception. This paper chronicles depictions of sexual intercourse within game content and the presence of
pornographic imagery that utilizes the game aesthetic whilst attempting to examine some of the motivation
behind its creation and use. Unlike historical accounts of the stimulating effects of art, such as men’s arousal
at the realism of Sansorino’s nude Venus, or Pliny’s account of a man’s infatuation with the sculpture of
Aphrodite of Caridos, sex in games exists within a cyber-culture that offers access to a broad range of erotic,
graphic and specialized pornographic materials. The authenticity of digitally mediated experiences – desire-
driven assemblages of the social and technological – is given consideration in terms of whether the
perceptual nature of sexuality is undergoing a transformation, allowing for wider patterns of variation in
erotic sub-cultures. This paper recognizes how these sub-cultures remain focused upon, and constructed
around phallocentric fantasies and desires, but begins to reflect on how the substance of the body and the
sexual object is continuing to shift and diversify.
Keywords
Sex, Pornography, Visual Culture, Celebrity, Arousal, Effects Debate
Opportunities for engaging with pornographically-tinged material within game spaces have developed so
radically that it is now possible to experience interactive photo-realistic 3D bodies performing explicit
sexual acts. The seemingly unstoppable flood of pornographic materials into cultural interstices has led to
the mediated presence, articulation and consumption of sexual content via game technologies, possibly
sparking a new cultural expression of sexual desire and expanding ever-chaotic global electronic cultures.
The articulation of sexual content within digital spaces add to the already ‘seriously fractured’ (Seidman,
1992, p.211) grasp of the moral boundaries of legitimate sexual expression. Indeed, Heim (1993) has argued
that the allure of technology is itself erotic. He states that, “our affair with information machines announces
a symbiotic relationship and ultimately a mental marriage to technology” (p. 61). The utilization of game
aesthetics and its interactive characteristics in the widening of pornographic territories now pose further
questions relating to its affects upon the constitution of desire. In the context of this paper, a hyper-real
authenticity propelled by ‘technological advancements’ evokes the “literal-minded behaviorism of the public
discourse around sexualized images” (Gaines, 2004, p.31), that the aim is to physically move and
manipulate bodies as a result of their engagement. Here we encounter a very different ‘effects’ debate to the
one that game studies has become accustomed.
Although, the main focus of interest in this paper is the discussion of the representation of the body
and simulated sexual acts within games or virtual spaces, it is probably necessary to acknowledge that there
have always existed a trend for games that have been labeled ‘adult’ or erotic’ that have served mainly as a
conduit for pornographic material. Of the many ‘adult’ games designed for the Commodore 64, they include
Cover Girl Strip Poker (Emotional Pictures), Curse of Ra (Trans X), Harry der Fensterputzer (Brilliant
Software), Erotica (Cybertech) and Girltris (Reliance). These games use play as a screen, often for
removing or revealing pornographic imagery extracted from the sex industry itself (see Fig. 2.1). In these
examples we find the pornographic artifact lodged in the mesh of play discourses, often self-canceling as
pornographic in its re-assemblage as part of game territory and removal from the contextuality of
2
pornography. Conduits for pornographic content continue to exist today, as exemplified by the
development of the online environment of Red Light World (Nightcandy) where the aim is to offer an
experience similar to Amsterdam’s infamous Red Light District, where visitors can access XXX Movie
Theatres, Strip Clubs, Viagra outlets and other Adult themed stores. Most of these in-game representations
inevitably lead the visitor to third part conventional pornography sites.
It does change people's personality. You can tell by the way they use their walk. When I met
Tony, he was the swaggering image of John Travolta, dressed in mocha brown pants with
front stitching and a comb wedged in his back pocket. I was blinded by the light of gold
medallions nestled under his nest of chest hair while his polyester shirt collar threatened to
take flight at any moment. But after the convention, Tony became Anthony, the boy-next-
door in his baseball cap and sweatshirt. His cockiness had rubbed off and was replaced by a
sensitive-man meekness (http://desires.com/1.4/Style/Docs/leisure.html).
The game predates the highly popular US television comedy show That 70’s Show (Carsey-Werner
Productions) that also functions to ridicule the now out-dated attitudes of that period and shares humor with
contemporary comedy films such as American Pie, Road Trip and Scary Movie.
The game-play in Leisure Suit Larry revolves around one evening in the life of protagonist Larry
Laffer. During this one evening he goes out on the town looking to coax/charm ladies into love (or sex) with
just his self-perceived good looks, breath freshener and $94 in his pocket. In the original version (prior to its
256 color and ‘point & click’ interface remake), game-play primarily consisted of using the arrow keys to
navigate Larry and a text parser to interact with the environment. Larry encounters four female characters
(see Figure 2.1) throughout the course of the game. The first, a ‘hooker’ in the upstairs bedroom above
Lefty's bar to which he loses his virginity (and life if the player does not seek out a convenience store and
condoms). Second is an ‘attractive blonde’ named Fawn encountered in a disco. In the casino, he encounters
Faith, a security guard, but Larry's ultimate goal remains Eve in the penthouse of the casino hotel. Puzzles
are mostly of the ‘obtain items’ variety, with each female character requiring something particular to satisfy
her before she satisfies the character. The sex itself is shown in real time masked by a black box with the
words CENSORED that comically, in the Benny Hill sense of the word, rises up and down with the motion
of the characters.
Sexual encounters in the 2004 version of the game have been supplemented by the ‘comical’ use of a
sperm icon that requires navigation and the avoidance of gas clouds that cause Larry to slip up when
‘chatting up’ females. Instead, the aim is to hit green icons that guarantee Larry will feed the best lines. A
heart icon is also used within the game interface to signify the current attraction level of the female currently
being engaged. Each of the conversations occurs in real-time with over 90,000 words of dialogue to offer the
game player variety. The latest version of the game also includes naked 3D modeled sex objects that retain a
cartoon-like quality and a game environment peppered with innuendo, for example, bull statues with
exaggerated male genitalia (following in the tradition of Capcom’s 1984 game Knights of the Round which
featured Tigers with highly exaggerated genitalia).
A second early example of a game that attempted to incorporate and depict sexual acts into its
4
narrative in a bid to include adult themes was Golgo 13: Top Secret Episode (1988, Vic Tokai) based on
Takao Saito's 1960’s comic of a Bond-esque hitman (e.g. Olgo 13: Muyonosuke or Samurai Bounty Hunter,
Ninja Comics). In this side-scrolling game that used a third-person view in cut-scenes we get “the first ever
(implied) sex scene on a Nintendo” (mobygames.com). In line with the tradition of British Intelligence spy
James Bond, Golgo 13 encounters intelligent and skillful female operatives who supply him with vital
information for his progress and development but also predictably and inevitably supply themselves. The
game also employs Bond’s approach to mixing sex with humor. Bond films typically operate on cloaked
sexual euphemism and innuendo (e.g. the double entendres of Pussy Galore, Plenty O'Toole, and Xenia
Onatopp). Take this typical Bond exchange from the film Goldeneye (1995) for example:
During the course of the game Golgo 13 has sex with numerous partners. The first example of this is when
Golgo 13 runs into Cherry Grace from the Fixer Group who assists him. On parting company a mere
seconds later Cherry says: ‘When you've finished work, stop by the hotel.’ Later on, a mystery man advises
Golgo 13 that Cherry is waiting in room 702, reinforcing the first directive. After an equally short
conversation with Cherry in the hotel room we gaze voyeuristically at the couple as they are silhouetted in a
hotel room window engaging in an embrace (see Fig. 2.2). The comedic twist that alludes to the
confirmation of sex comes from the restored energy levels of the character the next morning. The follow up,
The Mafat Conspiracy (1990) possessed more by the way of foreplay dialogue and gave its silhouetted
figures a more distinct body outline that conveyed nakedness (much in the same way as the title credits in
Bond films).
5
CREATING A DEMAND
Players tired with lifestyle reality games denying full voyeuristic access to the pet sims that they had
constructed and spent hours nurturing, famously responded by customizing The Sims (Electronic Arts)
through the construction of the nude patch. In addition to early depictions of adult themes in games, the
participatory cultures of gaming have pushed the demand for adult-oriented content thus extending its
representational and experiential boundaries. By infiltrating gaming culture, the patch has contributed to the
formation of new configurations of game characters, game spaces and game play (Schleiner, 1998).
Accommodating every body shape and skin color, the nude patch battled the pixilated censorship of R-rated
areas of the body. In doing so, these acts have also created cyber-celebrities of those who make patches for
others to use, both free of charge or for a small fee (e.g. JD’s SIMulated). Nude patching extends across
gaming genres, including games such as Neverwinter Nights (BioWare Corp.) and Morrowind (Bethesda
Softworks LLC). In doing so, it prompts transformations amongst a range of game protagonist and
supporting characters, such as the brief appearance of females who signify the start of the race in driving
game F1 2002 (EA Sports) or topless prostitutes in Grand Theft Auto 3 (Rockstar Games). Recognizing the
popularity of the phenomena, the means for disrobing game characters have occasionally been endorsed or
supported by the industry itself. Ritual Entertainment, developers of the game Sin, hid a skin
(models/pl_elexis/folder-x) for the character Elexis in its own software. Likewise in a response to censoring
its own game content to guarantee shelf presence in US supermarket WalMart, Planet Moon made
modification simple for players of the game through the deletion of a file (arpfix.gzp) to create topless Sea
Reapers in its game Giants: Citizen Kabuto.
Glamour Grammar
A key point of interest in the nude patching phenomena is the virtual representation of celebrities, both real
and virtual. Firstly, pornography and games collide, as porn star and Unreal Tournament (Epic Games) fan
Asia Carrera reportedly created topless skins of herself for the game. Likewise, the character Julie from
Heavy Metal (Ritual Entertainment) who has also received the nude patch treatment is a character based on
6
the physique of Penthouse Pet of the Year Julie Strain (and wife of Heavy Metal creator Kevin Eastman).
A form of commercial extension of these acts can now be found in the game Playboy: The Mansion
(Cyberlore Studios), an adult-oriented management simulation that offers a blend of tycoon and social
SIMulation gameplay. As Hugh Hefner, the player is required to throw parties, live the free-minded playboy
lifestyle whilst constructing the content of Playboy publications (including both images and articles). The
game contains celebrity representations that include Carmen Electra, Tom Arnold and more than 100 real
Playmates. However, in a similar vein to Leisure Suite Larry, the digitized Hugh Hefner is a younger version
of the magazine mogul who strolls around in his red smoking jacket with half-naked women (large-breasted
automatons with skin colors and hair styles) latched to his arms.
The nude game patch has been used more sensationally to expose celebrities that have not previously
consented to appear nude. For example, the nude patch for the Britney Spears’ game Dance Beat (Metro
Graphics) is described by NudeSkins.com as “jail-bait Britney finally bares her chest like you knew (and
hoped) she always wanted to.” The same phenomena can be found aimed at the virtual stardom of Lara
Croft who was transformed into Nude Raider by patchers. The desire to depict a virtual character naked is in
part a consequence and reflection of the way in which such game characters grow in popularity to achieve a
life beyond the game text. Take, for example, the inclusion of a ‘brief’ topless shot of Siberia (Microids)
character Kate Walker within one of its cut-scenes (see Fig 3.1). Regardless of whether this scene adds
authenticity and realism to the narrative of the game, the game players who took the trouble of capturing and
posting these images online, expressed that they had glimpsed beyond her game-determined costume to
witness the real Karen Walker. Response to this insertion into the game thus appears comparable to the dual
interpretation of a nude ‘in character’ appearance of a desirable actress,
7
The nude exposure of celebrities is a familiar feature of online pornography. Nude scenes from films,
tabloid exposé of celebrities on vacation and other voyeuristic materials find themselves archived online
within countless nude celebrity websites. Where images have yet to be uncovered, celebrities have long
suffered from having their image enclosed within doctored photos. It was a ‘faker’, the purveyor of pixel-
based Photoshop remixing that was responsible for sublimely genuine and widely distributed images of
Ashley Judd mid-stride at an awards ceremony minus her underwear. A sub-culture of online fakers
gathered momentum with the creation of binaries.pictures.nude.celebrities.fake newsgroup in the mid 1990’s
and now face online resistance from such groups as CyberTrackers (formed by the mother of film actress
Alyssa Milano). Unlike the newspaper industry which is prohibited from distorting reality in order to convey
a false or damaging impression, rights and ownership laws have permitted such practices to become
commonplace within the magazine industry. Indeed, UK men’s magazine GQ famously admitted to having
‘digitally altered’ its cover-star Kate Winslet in order to make her slimmer. Particular attention was drawn to
this case as Winslet discussed her comfort with possessing a ‘fuller figure’ within the accompanying
interview. From the styled, manicured and flatteringly lit to the ubiquitous use of digitally manipulation and
composites in magazine images, photos of celebrities consistently erode the line between reality and artifice.
Commenting on these visual untruths, model Cindy Crawford is oft quoted as stating that: “I wish I looked
like Cindy Crawford”.
A cult of perfection clearly pervades our culture. In her film Killing Us Softly: Advertising’s images of
women Jean Kilbourne (1979) argues the ideal woman has no scars or blemishes, or even pores.
Alternatively the rationale for the construction of virtual model Webbie Tookay, who appeared in mobile
communication advertising, is that she will never grow old, fat, develop a drug habit or drinking problem. In
the Hollywood film S1m0ne, film director Viktor (played by Al Pacino) proclaims: ‘Our ability to
manufacture fraud now exceeds our ability to detect it’, referring to his digital actress. In this film, the
narrative touches on the issue of replacing flesh and blood with CGI models or ‘synthespians’ as happened
in Final Fantasy: The Spirits Within that ran the tagline ‘unleash a new reality.’ The examples cited here
point to how the digital is becoming appealing to both producers and audiences. Indeed, in 2004 a Miss
Digital World competition attracted 3600 entries, the winner Katty-to (a digital representation of the
entrant’s wife) received 17,000 online votes. These practices are reminiscent of the ‘techno-orientalism’
(Erceg, 2004) of Oshii’s Ghost in the Shell and the construction of the female cyborg body.
Theorists have considered that it is the disembodying experience of electronic spectatorship that is
signaling a ‘crisis of the flesh’ (Sobchack, 2000). Yet, given the preoccupation with the digital image, are
8
we so surprised by players’ desire to see digital naked versions of digital game characters like Lara Croft?
Baudrillard (1988) has argued that: “America is neither dream or reality. It is hyperreality” (p. 253) and “the
only physical beauty is created by plastic surgery” (p. 257). Even prior to Angelia Jolie taking on the film
role of Lara Croft, the character has always possessed a dual existence as both virtual (Tomb Raider) and
real (Natalie Cook, Rhona Mitra). Yet, it is the polygon pin-up version of Lara that has prevailed to make
the front cover of Playboy Magazine, it was also the virtual version of Lara that was voted the female that
British males would most like to go on a date with. Indeed, pornographic models have donned the Lara
outfit (only to lose it again quickly) in order to appeal to this desire. Lara Croft fantasies are regularly played
out online, for example, in an animated feature on www.interactivexxxgames.com that sees Lara engaged in
explicit sex scenes during one of her adventures. What makes these examples more fascinating is that they
are situated in a culture of ‘pornotopia’ (Williams, 1989) characterized by “sheer ifinitude and availability”
(Gaines, 2004, p.36) that include ‘webcam babes’, ‘pee fanatics’, ‘horny teens’ and ‘fattties’ to quote some
of the enticements contained in e-mail spam received since researching this topic.
INTERSECTIONS
In this context, pornography like games requires a breach of ‘real world’ ‘fantasy world’ separation, in
which dissolution occurs between spectator and ‘scene’. Described as a ‘body genre’ (Williams, 1989),
pornography is perceived academically as not just being consumed (as an audience or witness) but also
‘used’ (in masturbatory acts). Furthermore, pornography remains devoted to fantasy despite divulging the
harshest realities. Laura Kipnis (1996) argues that, “its fantasies traverse a range of motifs beyond the
strictly sexual” (p. viii). Situated within the mechanization of pleasure, we find a widespread set of practices
attached to virtual sex such as; phone sex, ‘netsex’ and futuristic ‘teledildonics’ that enable ‘erotic’
interaction between individuals whose bodies may never touch. In this age of progressive denaturalization,
Lacan’s notion of desire arising from, and perpetuated by a ‘lack’ is exemplified by aspects of ‘netsex’ that
is based upon the absence of the body and requires individual construction of pleasure through alternative
forms of exchange. Returning to internet pornography and gaming, in both situations, the user has been
described as simultaneously looking and touching. As Gaines (2004) argues:
We seem to produce the real-time screen image with our fingertips. And it is this
simultaneous looking that touches and touching that looks that suggests the paradigm that I
think has so much to offer as it takes us beyond the limits of voyerism and towards a theory
of perception in the electronic age (p. 39)
Such screen-based mediation offers both voyeuristic distance and deceptive proximity, bringing about a
balanced illusion of connection and the reality of disconnection. Brisbane based new media artist Thea
Baumann has picked up this parallel, having developed a strap-on joystick, The Strap-On Love Pack that
extends the joystick rhetoric (e.g. Thrustmaster Joysticks and the acts of banking and shooting) to its logical
extension. Her creation Polymer Slut Lab, uses a strap-on dildo as a joystick in a audio remixing game
which involves the construction of lyrics from differently themed ‘porn spam’ (e.g. Viagra). Likewise, the
intersections of appendages between these two industries was also evident in a post on the Game Girl
Advance website that discussed alternative uses for the Trace Vibrator that shipped with the game Rez
(developer):
We sat side by side on our makeshift couch, I with the trance vibrator and Justin with the
controller. As the levels got more advanced, so did the vibrations … revving up to an intense
pulsing throbbing … (Jane, posted 26/10/2002)
Comments to the post extended this perspective by offering further examples of the use of game rumble
packs and advantages of different game software: “as the gunner in Warthog, you have unlimited ammo and
you can just park yourself somewhere and rat-tat-tat to your heart’s content,” or “If you want hard vibration
on your controller you should try Rallisport Challenge and Crash Bandicoot on Xbox.” In a playful take on
the idea of ‘playing with oneself’ and a future that contains wireless vibrating controllers on wearable
technology, Hot Topic sold a Controller Hot Pant (see Figure 4.1). In contrast to the above discussions of
machine-based representation of the body, these uses of game hardware, like the electromechanical vibrator,
9
focus around directly producing what Williams (1989) calls the ‘thing’ (p. 72) or involuntary convulsions.
10
what we want to offer to our audience is an experience that is indistinguishable from their
favorite porn movie. The only difference is they will have the ability to interact with the
actors in a way that will affect the attitude and actions that are played out in the scene. Once
the player finds something that he/she likes, that moment could be slowed or frozen in time,
rotated and zoomed into so that they could see everything they were interested in without the
limitations of a real camera.
In positioning themselves as an alternative to pornography such sites draw heavily on the conventions of
both soft and hardcore pornography. The inclusion of a ‘monthly 3D babe’ on Somavision gives users a
mock photo shoot that chronicles the featured model disrobing, consistent with the generic qualities of
softcore photographic pornography. Watt’s comments casually equates his company’s 3D creations with
pornographic models, the photo-realistic qualities of the object are underplayed and taken for granted.
Instead, the point of departure is the degree of control and input.
Alternative approaches to adult encounters do exist and include games like the online anime RPG
Playskins that places greater focus on flirtation in order to obtain cybersex. Melinda Kaufman, a designer on
the game, states that the “goal is to flirt”. In trying to seduce other players, part of the representational
motivation during the character design phase of the game includes which ‘moves’ to give the avatar (e.g.
Pony Ride, French Kiss, Lick, Suck, Bite and Penetration). In this game touching is an essential form of
12
communicating with fellow players. In contrast, the utilization of ‘moves’ forms an integral part of Great
Oyaji The Acrobatics of Sex (Studio Kinky). This game features a middle-aged businessman with a comb-
over hairstyle who wears nothing but socks and a barrel over his penis (see Fig. 5.2). Oyaji is presented as
someone with superhuman prowess with regard to business and mating. The game information contain
descriptions of some of his more outlandish ‘moves’ or acrobatic tricks available to Oyaji that include being
able to somersault over the windscreen of a convertible car, landing neatly (with penetration) on the spread-
legged girl on the bonnet. This game moves securely away from the subtlety of the courtship process behind
Playskins into a performance space where ‘feats’ become the goal and energy levels develop into a
preoccupation.
13
CONCLUSION
Beyond discussions of the sexualized representation of female (and male) characters within digital games
(e.g. Garner-Ray, 2004), this paper has primarily functioned to survey the presentation of sex within games.
For most part, examples provided here have found sex have to been addressed in quite a clichéd, facile
fashion, relying upon unadventurous, out-dated attitudes. One of the many areas that this paper has not had
the scope to address is the impact that including, or engaging in sexual encounters will have upon the
pleasures and experiences associated with the act of playing digital games and the narratives themselves. A
further catalyst for investigation from this paper rests with the idea that ‘bodies without flesh’ are achieving
a representational or aesthetic status where they are perceived as capable of evoking bodily intensities. For
many scholars pornographic consumption lies squarely in “arresting the visual, in the enthralled
spectatorship of the eye” (Wicke, 2004, p. 179). By pursuing a purely realist aesthetic, in common with
pornography, will we reach a point where digital bodies will be able to directly hack into the central nervous
system to actualize their virtual affects for pleasure? It is suggested here that the digital may therefore hold
further potential for re-territorialising or re-mapping pornography. To date, social forces have concentrated
upon film, video and photographic incarnations of pornography, largely to the exclusion of its digital
modalities which do not currently appear to exercise as many individuals. Is this the pathway that sex in
games will explore or are there other realms, new intensities that will open with the virtual/real-world
liaison?
REFERENCES
1. Baudrillard, J. America, Verso, London, 1988.
2. Cowie, E. Women and Representation: Cinema and Psychoanalysis, University of Minnesota Press,
Minneapolis, 1997,
3. Gaines. J.M. "Machines That Make the Body Do Things," in P. Church-Gibson (Ed.) More Dirty
Looks, British Film Institute, London, 2004.
4. Garner-Ray, S. Games for Women, Fuse, New Zealand Game Developers Conference, Dunedin,
2004.
5. Erceg, L. Games and Sex, Next Wave: Free-Play Independent Game Developers Conference,
Melbourne, 2004.
6. Kilbourne, J. Killing Us Softly: Advertising’s images of women (1979)
7. Kipnis, L. Bound and Gagged: Pornography and the Power of Fantasy in America. Grove Press, New
York, 1996.
8. Heim, M. The Metaphysics of Virtual Reality, Oxford University Press, New York, 1993.
9. Lawrence D.H. Pornography and so on, Faber & Faber, London, 1936.
10. McNair, B. Mediated Sex: Pornography and postmodern culture, Arnold, New York, 1996.
14
11. Schleiner, A.M. Cracking The Maze: Game Plug-ins and Patches as Hacker Art,
http://www.opensorcery.net/note.html, 1998.
12. Seidman, S. Embattled Eros: Sexual politics and ethics in contemporary America, Routledge, New
York, 1992.
13. Sobchack, V., “The Scene of the Screen: Envisioning Cinematic and Electronic ‘Presence,’” in J.T.
Caldwell (Ed.) Electronic Media and Technoculture, Rutgers University Press, New Brunswick, NJ, 2000.
14. Wicke, J. “Through a Gaze Darkly: Pornography’s Academic Market, ” in P. Church-Gibson (Ed.)
More Dirty Looks, British Film Institute, London, 2004.
15. Williams, L. Hard Core: Power, Pleasure and the ‘Frenzy of the Visible’, University of California
Press, Berkley, 1989.