Accounting For Derivatives and Hedging Activities: Answers To Questions
Accounting For Derivatives and Hedging Activities: Answers To Questions
Accounting For Derivatives and Hedging Activities: Answers To Questions
Answers to Questions
1 In order for the hedge items to qualify for hedge accounting, management must demonstrate that the
derivative is considered highly effective in mitigating the identified risks. This can be done by using two
different approaches:
a. Critical term analysis. Analyzing using critical terms, such as the nature of the underlying
variable, the notional amount of the derivative and the hedged item, the delivery date
derivative and settlement date of the hedged item. If the derivative and the hedged items
are identical, the derivative is considered highly effective.
b. Statistical analysis. If the critical term analysis does not match, then a correlation or
regression analysis can be used to show the relationship between the derivative and hedged
item. If they are statistically significant then the derivative is considered highly effective.
2 Under the fair value hedge accounting, the gains and losses are immediately recognized in earnings while
under the cash flow hedge accounting, the gains and losses are to be deferred until the forecasted
transactions affected income.
3 Foreign currency commitment is a contract or agreement denominated in foreign currency that will result
in a foreign currency transaction at a later date. For example, a US firm contract to buy assets at future
date from a Singaporean firm that is using Singaporean dollars. The situation is special because the
underlying transaction being hedged is not recorded as assets or liabilities.
4 Under a firm purchase or sales commitment, if the hedge is considered to be effective, then it would
qualify as a fair value hedge. The item being hedged (regardless of whether it is an asset or liability
position) and the offsetting derivative are both marked to fair value at the financial statement date. If
the hedge relationship is not considered to be effective, then the derivative is marked to market at the
balance sheet date, regardless of when the gain or loss on the item that is being hedged is recognized.
No offsetting changes in the fair value of the item being hedged are recorded until they are realized.
5 A company that has an existing loan that involves a variable or floating interest rate enters into a pay-
fixed, receive variable swap. The company is swapping its variable interest rate payments for fixed ones.
These contracts are typically settled net. For example, if the fixed rate agreed upon is 10% for the term
of the swap agreement and in one year the variable rate is 9%, then the company with the variable rate
loan must pay the difference in rates multiplied by the notional amount of the loan to the other party. If
the variable rate is 12%, then the company will receive the difference in rates multiplied by the notional
amount of the loan. Regardless of the movement in interest rates over the term of the swap, the company
will pay the fixed rate, net. This type of swap is aimed at reducing the variability in cash flows related to
the debt; therefore it is designated as a cash flow hedge.
6 A receive fixed, pay variable swap is entered into if a company has an existing loan that involves a fixed
interest rate and desires to swap those fixed payments for variable payments. For example, a company
has a loan with an 8% fixed rate and enters into a swap arrangement so that it will pay LIBOR + 1%. If
the variable rate for a year is 9%, then the company will pay 1% multiplied by the notional amount as
well as the 8% for the loan. Thus, the company has paid 9%, the floating rate.
If the variable rate is 6% (5% LIBOR + 1%), then the company will pay 8% on the loan, but will receive
2% related to the swap. Thus, the company will pay 6%, the floating rate.
This type of swap is aimed at reducing the variability in the fair value of the underlying loan therefore it
is designated as a fair value hedge.
7 Fair value hedge accounting is used when the company is attempting to reduce the price risk of an
existing asset/liability or firm purchase/sale commitment. Cash flow hedge accounting is appropriate
when the company is attempting to reduce the variability in cash flows thus it is appropriate when
hedging anticipated purchases and sales.
Under certain circumstances, hedges of existing foreign currency denominated receivables and payables
are accounted for as cash flow hedges instead of fair value hedges. See question 8’s solution for these
cases.
8 Cash flow hedge accounting can be used when hedging recognized foreign-currency denominated assets
and liabilities if the variability of cash flows is completely eliminated by the hedge. This criterion is
generally met if all of the critical terms of the hedged item and the hedge match such as the settlement
date, currency type and currency amounts. If these don’t match, then it must be accounted for as a fair
value hedge.
The key difference between this situation and the more general cash flow hedge case is that an existing
asset or liability is being accounted for here. Under the more general case, the recognition of gains and
losses is deferred because an anticipated transaction is being hedged. The foreign currency asset or
liability is marked to fair value at year-end and the resulting gain or loss account is recognized, however,
the gain or loss is offset by reclassifying an equal amount from other comprehensive income. Thus, the
asset and liability are marked to fair value, but no gain or loss related to that adjustment is included in
current period income.
The premium or discount related to the hedge contract is amortized to income over the length of the
contract using the effective interest method. For example, if a 100,000 euro foreign currency receivable
due in 60 days is recorded at the spot rate of $1.20/euro or $120,000 and at the same date, a forward
contract is entered into to deliver 100,000 euros in 60 days at a forward rate of $1.18, the company knows
that it will lose $2,000. This $2,000 must be amortized to income over the 60 day period.
9 International Accounting Standards No. 32 and 39 prescribe the accounting for derivatives. Their
requirements are similar to SFAS No. 133 and 138 in terms of determining when hedge accounting can
be used. The requirements for determining hedge effectiveness are very similar. Both fair value and
cash flow hedge definitions and general requirements are similar. However, under IAS 39, firm sale or
purchase commitments can be accounted for as either fair value or cash flow hedges which differs from
the FASB requirement that they must be accounted for as fair value hedges.
10 A forward contract of an anticipated foreign currency transaction is accounted for as a cash flow hedge.
The contract is marked to fair value at each financial date and the corresponding gain or loss is included
in other comprehensive income. Any premium or discount must be amortized to income over the
contract term using an effective interest rate method. The gain (loss) credit (debit) is offset by a debit
(credit) from other comprehensive income.
When the anticipated transaction occurs and the forward contract is settled, the resulting other
comprehensive income balance is amortized to income in the same period as the underlying transaction is
recognized in income.
Solution E13-1
1 a. December 1, 2011
No entry is necessary
2.
Cash (+A) 600,000
Sales (+R,+SE) 600,000
Solution E13-3
Cash 600,000
Sales 600,000
To record cash sales.
Sales 100,000
Firm Sales Commitment (-A) 100,000
To record termination of firm sales commitment.
Solution E13-4
October 1, 2011
1 Forward contract(+A) 49,012
Gain on forward contract 49,012
(100,000 x ($2.00 - $1.50))/(1.005)4
To record the change in fair value of the
forward contract attributable to the discounted
change in the forward price
Preliminary calculations
Value at spot rate $ 64,000
Hedge contract $ 62,500
Discount $ 1,500
2 Discount Balance
-0.79% $ 64,000
30-Nov $ (504) $ 63,496
30-Dec $ (500) $ 62,996
30-Jan $ (496) $ 62,500
Total discount
amortization $(1,500)
Solution E13-6
September 1, 2014
Accounts receivable (fc) (+A) 15,400
Sales (+R, +SE) 15,400
To record sales to Dimple AG; (€20,000 $0.77 spot rate)
October 1, 2014
Cash (fc) (+A) 15,800
Exchange gain (+Ga, +SE) 400
Accounts receivable (fc) (-A) 15,400
To record collection of receivable from Dimple AG. Cash: €20,000 $0.79.
Exchange gain: [€20,000 ($0.79 - $0.77)]
2
Spot rate - January 30, 2015 $ 0.0120
90-day forward rate - November
1, 2014 $ 0.0095
Difference $ 0.0025
$
Merchandise price 2,000,000
Contract loss in January 30,
2015 $ 5,000
SOLUTIONS TO PROBLEMS
Solution P13-1
Preliminary computations
Present value of
loss $ (9,901) a
Inventory
(+A) $ 195,000
Account payable (fc)(+L) $ 195,000
Using the implicit rate of return formula, we calculate the amortization rate
at -1.30%
Discount amortization:
1-Nov $ 195,000
30-Nov $ (2,535) b
$ 192,465
31-Dec $ (2,502) b
$ 189,963
30-Jan $ (2,470) $ 187,500
Exchange loss
(+Lo, -SE) $ 5,037 b
Accounts payable
(fc)(-L) $ 190,000
Exchange loss(+Lo,-
SE) $ 15,000
Forward contract (-
L) $ 17,500
Cash (-A) $ 17,500
To record the payment of the forward contract
Solution P13-2
October 1, 2014
Accounts receivable (fc) (+A) 24,000,000
Sales (+R, +SE) 24,000,000
To record sales to Jang Ltd. (₩25,000,000,000 $0.00096 spot rate).
2 One would expect that this is a highly effective hedge if the notional
amount, $400,000 and the length of the term of the swap agreement agree.
3 a. The LIBOR rate at 12/31/11 is 5%, thus 2012’s interest rate on the
variable loan will be 5% + 2% = 7%. The swap fixed rate is 8%. Cam
will pay .01 percent more than the variable rate. The fair value of the
swap is the present value of the estimated future net payments.
b.
December 31, 2011
Other Comprehensive Income (-OCI,-SE) 13,547
Interest Rate Swap (+L) 13,547
To record the fair value of interest rate swap, cash flow hedge at
12/31/11.
4.
December 31, 2012
Interest Expense (+E,-SE) 28,000
Cash (-A) 28,000
To record payment to Ven Bank of the interest expense for the year
under the variable rate loan. The rate set on the loan at 1/1/12
was 7%.
The new variable rate for 2013 which is set at 12/31/12 is 5.5% +
2%. As a result, the estimated amount that Cam would pay is
reduced from 1% to .5%.
The unadjusted Interest Rate Swap liability is $13,547 credit, but the
adjusted is $5,201 credit. The Interest Rate Swap Liability must be
reduced by $8,346.
1. This is a fair value hedge because the fixed rate loan’s fair value
fluctuates over time as market interest rates change. By entering into
this swap agreement that fluctuation is eliminated. So while the
interest rate fluctuates, the loan’s fair value remains constant,
reflecting the fixed rate in the swap.
3. a.
Date of payment Estimated payment Factor Present Value
based on 12/31/11
LIBOR rate
12/31/12 .01 x $400,000 1/(1.09) $ 3,670
12/31/13 .01 x $400,000 1/(1.09)2 3,367
12/31/14 .01 x $400,000 1/(1.09)3 3,089
12/31/15 .01 x $400,000 1/(1.09)4 2,834
Total $12,960
Notice that the carrying value of the loan is now $387,040 ($400,000 -
$12,960). This agrees with the present value of the loan at the market
rate of 9%.
Proof: $400,000/(1.09)4 = $283,370 <= the present value of the maturity
value. The present value of the interest payments is $32,000 x
PVIFA(i=9,n=4)= $103,670.
The total market value of the loan is $283,370 + $103,670 = $387,040.
4.
Date of payment Estimated payment Factor Present Value
based on 12/31/12
LIBOR rate
12/31/13 .005 x $400,000 1/(1.085) $1,843
12/31/14 .005 x $400,000 1/(1.085)2 1,699
12/31/15 .005 x $400,000 1/(1.085)3 1,566
Total $ 5,108
1 Entries on April 1
Accounts receivable (pesos) (+A) 33,060
Sales (+R,+SE) 33,060
To record sales on account denominated in pesos: 200,000 pesos /
6.0496 LCUs
Contract Receivable 33,228
Contract Payable 33,228
To record forward contract.
2 Entries on May 31
Cash (pesos) (+A) 33,378
Accounts receivable (pesos) (-A) 33,060
Exchange gain (+G,+SE) 318
To record collection of receivable in LCUs: 200,000 LCUs /
5.992 LCUs
Cash 33,228
Contract receivable 33,228
To record receipt of cash from exchange
broker.
Inventory 32,800
Cash (euros) (+A) 32,800
To record purchase and payment in euros at $.6560 spot rate.
December 2, 2011
No entry
March 1, 2012
Cash (fc) (+A) 855,000
Sales (+R,+SE) 855,000
To record delivery of equipment to Ram and collection of 500,000
pounds at the $1.71 spot rate.
Discount amortization:
The spot rate at the date the forward contract was entered into $1.70 x
500,000 = $850,000. $1.68 x 500,000 = $840,000. The discount of $10,000
must be amortized over the contract period. The effective interest rate
equates these two amounts using a 3 month time period, that rate is .
3937%.