Bioresource Technology 273 (2019) 25–33

Contents lists available at ScienceDirect

Bioresource Technology
journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/biortech

Positive impact of biochar amendment on thermal balance during swine T

manure composting at relatively low ambient temperature
⁎
Hongtao Liua, , Lixia Wangb, Mei Leia
a
Institute of Geographic Sciences and Natural Resources Research, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing 100101, China
b
Northeast Institute of Geography and Agroecology, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Changchun 130102, China

G R A P H I C A L A B S T R A C T

A R T I C LE I N FO A B S T R A C T

Keywords: In this study, the effects of biochar amendment on swine manure composting performance at temperatures in the
Biochar −5 °C–15 °C range was investigated. Monitoring result showed biochar addition significantly prolonged ther-
Composting mophilic stage duration to meet harmless standards of livestock manure compost at 5 °C, assisting a seemingly
Thermal balance difficult composting to succeed. Additionally, from viewpoint of thermal balance, biochar increased organic
Organic waste
matter degradation derived heat from 50.4% to 86.5% and water vaporization heat from 29.6% to 73.5% while
decreasing heat exchange by two-fold. Overall, the results presented herein indicated that biochar has potential
to play a positive role in amelioration of animal manure composting at relatively low ambient temperature and
provide insight into how biochar influences heat generation and flow during composting.

1. Introduction bioavailability and amount of heavy metals taken up by plants were

decreased in response to amendment of biochar (Karer et al., 2018; Zhu
Biochar is a solid product formed by the pyrolysis of biomass or et al., 2015; Uchimiya et al., 2011). Taken together, these findings in-
organic waste, such as wheat straw, rice husks, tree branches, bamboo dicate that biochar exhibits has great potential for use as a soil ameli-
rods, or sludge and food waste, and has attracted widespread interest orant and mitigate potential environmental risk.
and concern in the last decade because of its environmental and agro- Biochar also plays a satisfactory role in organic waste treatment,
nomical benefits (Agegnehu et al., 2017). For instance, amendment of especially in aerobic composting (Sanchez-Monedero et al., 2018;
biochar can improve water holding capacity of soil (Ennis et al., 2012; Zhang et al., 2014; Liu et al., 2014; Sun et al., 2016). For example, the
Glab et al., 2018), while soil nutrients can also be elevated (Wang et al., ratio of carbon/nitrogen (C/N), which influences microbial growth and
2014a,b; Manolikaki and Diamadopoulos, 2017; Godlewska et al., enables the composting process to proceed, was directly increased by
2017). Additionally, total emissions of greenhouse gas (carbon dioxide, the addition of biochar to the pile (Jindo et al., 2012; Jain et al., 2018).
methane, and nitrous oxide) were reduced after application of biochar Moreover, the cation exchange capacity (CEC), which provides in-
to soil (Wang et al., 2013; Hagemann et al., 2018), and the formation regarding nutrient retention of the final compost, was also

⁎
Corresponding author.
E-mail address: [email protected] (H. Liu).

https://doi.org/10.1016/j.biortech.2018.10.033
Received 28 August 2018; Received in revised form 12 October 2018; Accepted 13 October 2018
Available online 18 October 2018
0960-8524/ © 2018 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
H. Liu et al. Bioresource Technology 273 (2019) 25–33

increased in response to biochar (Prost et al., 2013; Zhang and Sun, Table 1
2014). Aggregate characteristics and physical structure of amended soil Main characteristics of composting mixture and materials.
have also been shown to be improved by biochar (Amoakwah et al., Material Water Volatile bulk density Pile Pile
2017; Sun and Lu, 2014), and it was found to decrease the incidence of content(%, solid (%, (g·cm−3) weight height
plant diseases caused by soil borne pathogens (Bonanomi et al., 2015). wet) dry) (kg) (m)
As expected, biochar inhibited odor generation and release to the air
Swine manure 78.7 ± 0.8 64.7 ± 0.6 0.99 ± 0.03 – –
(Agyarko-Mintah et al., 2017a; Otterpohl, 2012). Furthermore, biochar Rice husk 14.2 ± 1.4 95.2 ± 1.2 0.11 ± 0.04 – –
played a role in suppressive to losses of nitrogen in the form of am- Biochar 3.52 ± 0.1 96.4 ± 0.8 0.15 ± 0.03 – –
monia and carbon in the form of carbon dioxide (Agyarko-Mintah et al., Composted 45.2 ± 1.3 55.1 ± 1.4 0.39 ± 0.06 – –
2017b; Wang et al., 2017a, 2018). It should be mentioned that biochar swine
manure
has all the ingredients to be a suitable additive and bulk agent for
Initial 64.2 ± 0.6 72.2 ± 0.5 0.66 ± 0.07 1090 1.65
composting to render organic waste harmless and stable. com-
Composting is usually conducted in semi-open or outdoor areas posting
because of the odorous gases generated and emitted during the process. mixture
However, in subtropical, temperate and sub-frigid zones, composting is
significantly constrained by outside temperature, particularly during
winter. Indeed, if the outside temperature is below zero or even rela- treatment base located in Xing-shou village, Chang-ping district,
tively cold (e.g., 0 °C–10 °C), the composting process is usually in- Beijing. The mixed composting pile was loaded into a semi-open com-
hibited, delayed or fails. Therefore, environmental temperature is a posting tank that is mainly made of temperature and humidity meter,
critical factor that determines whether composting is successfully pressure meter, thermal flow-meter, ventilator, thermal flux measuring
completed. Moreover, sufficiently high pile temperature is required for board, data logger, cylindrical hydrophobic plastic bucket, online water
organic wastes stabilization and harmlessness. For instance, the USEPA vapor detector, composting material, and temperature probe, using a
(United States Environmental Protection Agency) sets the standard for belt-driven machine, after which it was subjected to aerobic composting
class A compost based on a temperature of 55 °C for 3 days, while class for 21 days, during which time it received intermittent aeration. The
B is formed after a temperature of 40 °C lasts for 5 days (United States period of composting was divided into two stages, an initial 1–2 days,
Environmental Protection Agency, 1994). However, the Chinese stan- during which time the aeration procedure was set to a repetitive cycle
dard for livestock manure harmlessness specifies that the pile tem- of 5 min on and 30 min off. The second stage was from day 3 to 21,
perature must be 50 °C for 10 days or 55 °C for 5 days (National Health when the detailed aeration procedure was set to a cycle of 10 min on
Commission of the People’s Republic of China, Standardization and 30 min off. The pile was aerated intermittently from under the pile
Administration of the People’ Republic of China, 2012). Despite dif- using a ventilator. The pile top area and initial height were 0.98 m2 and
ferences in pile temperature standards between countries, heat accu- 1.65 m, respectively, and the ventilation frequency was
mulation is an essential factor for the composting process (Ghaly et al., 1.95 L min kg−1·VS (Volatile Solid).
2006). This is because the accumulated heat plays a fundamental and When outside average temperatures reached −5 °C, 0 °C, 5 °C, 10 °C,
decisive role in eradication of pathogenic bacteria, water evaporation and 15 °C respectively, the composting experiment were conducted to
and removal, and organic matter degradation to develop humus-like evaluate the effects of different ambient temperature on composting
substances. performance with or without added biochar. The −5 °C and 0 °C ex-
To date, few studies have investigated the impact of biochar periments were conducted in winter of 2016, while the 5 °C, 10 °C and
amendment on organic waste composting completion at relatively low 15 °C experiments were conducted in spring of 2017.
ambient temperatures, such as occur during winter in China. Therefore,
this study was conducted to clarify the relationship between biochar 2.3. Measurement of main composting parameters
amendments and the composting process from the viewpoint of thermal
balance. It is a newly-made hole on the wall to perceive the juncture of Three thermal flux measuring boards, which is mainly made of
biochar ameliorating composting quality in relatively low temperature electro-thermal reactor, infilling, heat flux, negative and positive poles,
above zero. cold and hot areas, were inserted into the compost pile along the ver-
tical direction to constantly monitor the heat exchange between com-
2. Methods and materials posting materials. Moreover, three temperature probes (Pt100) were
inserted into the pile to monitor the temperature change in real time. To
2.1. Experimental materials measure the heat contained in ventilated air flow before entering the
pile, a temperature and humidity meter, thermal flow-meter (Vivo
The composting mixture consisted of swine manure, composted Crop., Madison, WI, USA) and pressure meter were installed in the
swine manure, rice husk and biochar. Swine manure and rice husk were connection between the pile and the ventilator.
collected from a local hog farm and local resident’s home, respectively, To quantify the heat brought by vaporized water during com-
in Chang-ping district, Beijing, China. The biochar was bamboo-derived posting, the weight of vaporized water and its temperature were mea-
and produced by high temperature pyrolysis under anaerobic condi- sured using an online water vapor detector constructed of an ultrasonic
tions at 400 °C–1000 °C. The particle diameter of the biochar ranged anemometer (Gill Instruments Crop., Lymington, UK), temperature and
from 3 to 5 cm. The basic properties of the initial mixture and final humidity probe (Rotronic Crop., Bassersdorf, Swizerland), and a data
composted product are shown in Table 1. The compost materials were logger. To avoid heat exchange between the experimental region and
mixed at a final ratio of C/N (25:1). Biochar was then added to the outside environment, the cylindrical hydrophobic plastic bucket with
composting mixture to give a final amount of 10% (w:w) based on the open both ends and bottom area of 1 m2, height of 1.5 m was fixed.
optimal levels reported in studies from 2008 to 2018. The main char- To assess the organic matter degradation derived heat, samples
acteristics of the composted materials and compost mixture are shown were collected from the upper, middle and lower layers of the compost
in Table 1. pile in the test area using a self-made sampler, then mixed evenly to
develop a final sample. Next, an oxygen bomb calorimeter (IKA Corp.,
2.2. Composting device and environmental temperature design Staufen, Germany) was used to measure heat derived from organic
matter degradation after being dried to constant weight at 105 °C.
The composting experiment was performed in an organic waste Sampling was conducted every 24 h and analysis was repeated three

26
H. Liu et al. Bioresource Technology 273 (2019) 25–33

times. water vapor (kg); Cdryair is the dry air specific heat, which was
To assess the compost maturity, when composting was completed, 1.004 kJ kg−1 °C−1 (Haug, 1993); Cvapor is the water vapor specific
50 g of compost were sampled and soaked in 250 mL deionized water, heat, which was 1.841 kJ kg−1 °C−1 (Haug, 1993); T is the temperature
shaken for 4 h at room temperature, and then filtered through quanti- of composting material (°C); and Taeration is the temperature of venti-
tative filter paper. Next, 5 mL of filtrate was spread on culture dishes lation (°C).
covered with filter paper, after which 50 ryegrass seeds were sown on Therefore, the value of E (Eevapor) can be calculated as follows:
the dishes and incubated in the dark at 30 °C and 35–60% relative
humidity for germination. The germination index (GI, [germination Eevapor (Mevapor − Mareation vapor ) × Levapor (4)
percentage × seed shoot length/germination percentage of con-
trol × seed shoot length of control]×100%) was determined to in- where Mevapor is the amount of water evaporation (kg) and Levapor is the
dicate the maturity of compost. coefficient of water evaporation, which can be quantified by equation
(5):
2.4. Logical relation elaboration on thermal balance and quantification of
L evapor = 2501 − 2.65 × T (5)
its constituent branches
where T is the composting temperature.
In this composting mixture, the heat input consists of storage heat in
The value of F (i.e., heat radiation; Eradiation) was quantified as
the initial composting material (A), organic matter degradation derived
follows:
heat (B), and ventilation sensible heat (C) generated from air flow
streaming into the pile. The heat import consists of storage heat in the Eradiation = σ·A·(T 4 − Tt )·Fa·F (6)
final compost (D), water vaporization heat (E), heat radiation (F), heat
exchange (G), and ventilation sensible heat (H) generated from air flow where the value of σ is given as 5.67 × 10−11 kJ s−1·m−2·k−4; A is the
absorption. Therefore, the thermal balance equation is given as: experimental area (m−2); T is the composting temperature (°C); Tt is the
A + B + C = D + E + F + G + H based on the heat generation and surface temperature of the composting material (°C); Fa is 0.5 and Fe is
transmission. 0.85.
Thereinto, the determination of B has been described in the third In this experiment, a heat flux sensor, which depends on the electro-
paragraph of Section 2.3 according to previous report (Zhao et al., thermal reactor to measure the temperature gradient, was employed to
2010). A and D consisted of two portions, heat contained in water and monitor the heat exchange between composting materials. The electro-
heat contained in solid substances (organic matter and ash content). thermal reactor is made of two different metals. When the electro-
The total storage heat in the initial composting material or in the final thermal reactor receives heat energy, thermoelectric potential will be
compost (Ematrix) was quantified as follows: generated between the nodes of the two different metal materials,
Ematrix = Mwater ·Cwater ·T + Msolid·Csolid·T (1) which will be output in the form of voltage. The output voltage, which
is proportional to the heat flux, was automatically recorded by the data
where Mwater is the water content in material (kg); Msolid is solid sub- acquisition system. Therefore, G (i.e. heat conduction; Econduction mea-
stance content in material (kg); Cwater is the moisture specific heat,
sure) can be calculated as follows:
which was 4.184 kJ kg−1 °C−1 in this study (Zhao et al., 2010); Csolid is
the solid material specific heat, which was 1.046 kJ kg−1 °C−1 in this 3600 × V × S × t
Econduction measure =
study (De Guardia et al., 2012). K (7)
Based on the equation describing organic matter degradation in the
composting process, a certain amount of gas (carbon dioxide and am- where V is the output voltage value (mV); K is the sensitivity correction
monia) is generated while oxygen is exhausted. When calculating gas coefficient, which was set to 13.31 in this study; t is the composting
mass change, 1 kg of organic matter degradation will result in 0.28 kg of period (h) and S is the heat conduction area (m2). Finally, S = L × H,
emitted gas. Considering that the generated gas mass only accounts for where L is girth of the pile bottom (m) and H is the pile height (m).
0.4% (w/w) of the ventilated dry air, it can be assumed that there is no
loss of dry air mass when the ventilated airflow passes through the
composting pile. Therefore, the value of C or H can be calculated ac- 2.5. Statistics analysis
cording to the temperature difference of ventilated airflow between
that entering and leaving the pile as follows: All figures were developed using OriginPro 9.0. One-way ANOVA
was performed to identify differences among treatment effects, and
ΔEaeration = (Maeration dryair Cdryair + Maeration vapor C vapor ) × (T - Taeration)
multiple comparisons were analyzed according to the least significant
(2) difference method using SPSS v. 13.0. Mean values followed by dif-
where Δaeration is incremental ventilation sensible heat (kJ) and Maeration ferent lowercase and capital letters horizontally were significantly dif-
dryair is the mass of ventilated dry air (kg), which can be calculated as
ferent at p < 0.05 in figures and those followed by different lowercase
follows: letters vertically were significantly different at p < 0.05 in Table 2.
Values are the average of three replicates and bars represent the stan-
Pdryair ·Vaeration·Mdryair
Maeration dryair = R·T
dard deviation.
Pdryair = Paeration − Pvapor
Pvapor = RHaeration·Pvs
Table 2
Pvs = 10 ⎡
⎣ ( −2239
Tt + 273 ) + 8.896⎤⎦ × 1333.3 (3)
Maturity of final compost without and with additions of biochar at 5 °C ambient
temperature.
where Pdryair is dry air partial pressure (pa); Pvs is saturated water vapor Treatment Germination index Ratio of humic acid/fulvic acid
pressure (pa); Paeration is ventilation pipe pressure (pa); Pvapor is water (%) (HA/FA)
vapor partial pressure (pa); Vaeration is ventilation volume (m3); Mdryair
Without biochar 62.2 ± 3.5b 1.02 ± 0.09b
is the molar mass of air, which was set to 29 g mol−1; R is the ideal gas
addition
constant, which was set to 8.31 J mol−1·k−1; RHaeration is the ventila- With biochar addition 84.7 ± 4.8 a 1.46 ± 0.21 a
tion flow relative humidity (%); Maeration vapor is the mass of ventilated

27
H. Liu et al. Bioresource Technology 273 (2019) 25–33

3. Results and discussion As shown in Fig. 1(A), in the control treatment (without addition of
biochar to composting mixture), there were 5 days (from day 4–8) on
3.1. Amendment with biochar prolonged composting thermophilic stage which the temperature exceeded 55 °C when the ambient temperature
duration and improved sanitation at relatively low ambient temperature was 10 °C and 7 days (from day 4–10) on which the temperature was
(5 °C) above 55 °C when the ambient temperature was 15 °C, indicating that
these two treatments met the livestock manure harmlessness and sa-
As well known, beside anaerobic digestion, aerobic composting is an nitation standards of Class A of the United States and China. However,
effective approach to recycling and vaporization of animal manure to when the ambient temperatures were −5 °C, 0 °C and 5 °C these stan-
beneficial substances for soil (Otterpohl, 2012). The composting pro- dards were not met. Indeed, at −5 °C and 0 °C, the highest pile tem-
cess is usually characterized by a dynamic change in pile temperature, peratures were only 0.8 °C and 11.2 °C, respectively, during the com-
and the duration of the thermophilic stage should meet the require- posting process. The temperature reached 38.4 °C at an ambient
ments of regulatory officials for harmlessness and sanitation standards. temperature of 5 °C; however, which was not considered successful. As
Previous studies in this field have focused on the relationship between shown in Fig. 1(B), the change in pile temperature at ambient tem-
microbial activity, organic matter degradation and crucial parameters peratures of 5 °C differed between the control treatment and the
such as oxygen conditions, carbon dioxide concentration and nitrogen treatment containing added biochar. Specifically, there were 5 days
transformation, which are primarily associated with the biochemical (from day 4 to 8) when the temperature reached 56.4 °C when biochar
nature of composting (Lv et al., 2013; Komilis and Ham, 2006; was added, but this did not occur in the control. At other ambient
Wilshusen et al., 2004). However, little attention has been paid to temperatures, the pile temperature did not differ significantly between
thermal balance in composting, as it has instead been viewed as an the biochar treated and control piles.
absolute physical process. Nevertheless, it is known that thermal bal- The results of the present study showed that blending of biochar
ance is associated with successful composting, although it is not clear if into the composting mixture prolonged the duration for which the
biochar is an acceptable and beneficial amendment material (Xiao compost temperature was above 55 °C at relatively low ambient tem-
et al., 2017) that can have positive effect on thermal balance, even at perature. This finding seems to be in accordance with those of Jain et al.
low ambient temperature. (2018), who found that biochar addition resulted in advanced

Fig. 1. Change in pile temperature during composting period without (A) and with (B) addition of biochar (rate of 10%, w:w) to composting mixture at different
ambient temperatures.

28
H. Liu et al. Bioresource Technology 273 (2019) 25–33

Fig. 2. The proportion of heat input during the composting process without (A) and with (B) addition of biochar (rate of 10%, w:w) at different ambient temperatures
(−5°C, 0 °C, 5 °C, 10 °C, 15 °C).

thermophilic temperatures of 59 °C when compared with compost that of a composting mixture; thus, influencing some micro-unit or in-
did not contain biochar. Similarly, Czekala et al. (2016) reported that tracellular polymer (Agyarko-Mintah et al., 2017b). This might provide
addition of biochar at 10% accelerated emergence of the highest daily a hint that is beneficial to better understand about incremental organic
composting temperatures and led to the maximum observed tempera- matter degradation derived heat. Biochar is characterized by a large
tures. Moreover, Liu et al. (2014) indicated that biochar addition re- specific surface area, porosity, and a large amount of functional groups
sulted in a shorter time to enter the thermophilic phase, a higher (Godlewska et al., 2017; Sanchez-Monedero et al., 2018). Furthermore,
temperature (56 °C) and a longer duration of the thermophilic phase. Wiedner et al. (2015) used energy-dispersive X-ray spectroscopy to
These reports confirmed that biochar plays a role in increasing pile demonstrate that biochar surface oxidation can be accelerated through
temperature and lengthening thermophilic duration. In the present composting treatment. Taken together, these findings indicate that
study, biochar was also found to have a positive effect on thermophilic biochar provides increased porosity, surface area and functional groups,
duration in compost at low ambient temperature relative to compost which may be involved in oxidation to organic matter and improved
that did not contain added biochar. dissolution of intracellular substances. This improvement in dissolution,
to some extent, has contributed to increased heat generation from or-
3.2. Introduction of biochar reapportioned heat input during composting at ganic matter degradation. However, blending of biochar into com-
relatively low ambient temperature (5 °C) posting systems also promoted microbial activity, which was re-
sponsible for decomposition of organic matter (Pei et al., 2017; Xiao
Although biochar influenced pile temperature elevation and accu- et al., 2017). The addition of biochar also improved the oxygen supply,
mulation, pile temperature is still consequential reflection of the making it more effective to improve aerobic microbial activity (He
thermal balance between heat input and output during composting. et al., 2017). The addition of biochar also optimized the composting
Therefore, the pattern of heat input was also investigated based on real environment to facilitate microbial growth (Liu et al., 2017; Sanchez-
and simulated data. As shown in Fig. 2(A), the distribution of heat input Garcia et al., 2015). Enhancement of the microbial level in response to
indicated that the ratio of organic matter degradation derived heat addition of biochar subsequently increased the generation of organic
among total input-heat gradually increased significantly as ambient matter degradation derived heat.
temperature increased from −5 °C to 15 °C in the treatment without
added biochar. However, the introduction of biochar changed the 3.3. Introduction of biochar reshaped proportions of heat output during the
proportion of input-heat, mainly at ambient temperatures of 5 °C. composting process at relatively low ambient temperature (5 °C)
Specifically, as shown in Fig. 2(B), biochar amendment induced an
increase of 50.4% to 86.5% of organic matter degradation derived heat The effects of biochar on the proportion of heat output during
when compared with treatment without biochar addition. Additionally, composting were also analyzed. As shown in Fig. 4(A), the water va-
the proportion of storage heat in the initial composting material ob- porization heat increased from 29.6% to 73.5%, while that of ventila-
viously decreased from 28.6% to 7.8%, while that of ventilation sen- tion sensible heat and storage heat in the final compost decreased
sible heat dropped from 21% to 5.7%. However, there were no differ- gradually in the control treatment. Similar to the heat input pattern,
ences in the distribution pattern of heat input between piles with and biochar also significantly affected the distribution of heat output, par-
without biochar amendment at −5 °C, 0 °C, 10 °C, and 15 °C. ticularly at ambient temperatures of 5 °C. As shown in Fig. 4(B),
Among these three indicators, the temporal change in organic treatment with biochar triggered a proportional increase of 14.8%
matter degradation derived heat and degradable organic matter at 5 °C (from 58.4% to 73.2%) in water vaporization heat in comparison to the
was emphatically followed. As shown in Fig. 3, the organic matter control treatment. A magnifier was employed to the detailed temporal
degradation derived heat during composting with added biochar was change of this process with biochar addition in comparison to treatment
highest on day 4 (Fig. 3(A)), when the degradable organic matter without biochar, a remarkable increase in water vaporization heat was
content also showed a sharp decrease (Fig. 3(B)) compared with the found on day 3, with maximum amounts being observed on day 4 and 5
treatment without added biochar. (Fig. 5). In addition, significant differences between the biochar
Present results indicated that addition of biochar to composting amended and control treatments existed at almost all time points ex-
systems accelerated organic matter degradation and increased organic amined. Slight reductions in ventilation sensible heat and storage heat
matter degradation derived heat, which accounted for total heat input. in the final compost of the treatment that received biochar were also
Recent reports showed that biochar has intrinsic and nascent structural found relative to the control (Fig. 4). Additionally, a two-fold decrease
and sorption properties that may alter physical and chemical properties in heat exchange from 13.2% to 6% was observed, implying that

29
H. Liu et al. Bioresource Technology 273 (2019) 25–33

Fig. 3. Change in organic matter degradation derived heat (A) and degradable organic matter content (B) during composting process without and with addition of
biochar (rate of 10%, w:w) at 5 °C ambient temperature.

biochar addition drastically decreased conductive heat between com- biochar during the composting process.
post material and ambient air; therefore, temporal changes in heat Water vaporization heat is proportional to water removal from the
exchange were monitored. As shown in Fig. 6, the heat exchange of the composting pile to air. The effectiveness of this process is usually clo-
treatment with added biochar was lower than that without added sely associated with inside structure and porosity of composting

Fig. 4. Proportion of heat output during the composting process without (A) and with (B) addition of biochar (rate of 10%, w:w) at different ambient temperatures
(−5°C, 0 °C, 5 °C, 10 °C, 15 °C).

30
H. Liu et al. Bioresource Technology 273 (2019) 25–33

Fig. 5. Change in water vaporization heat during composting process without and with addition of biochar (rate of 10%, w:w) at 5 °C ambient temperature.

Fig. 6. Change in heat exchange during composting process without and with addition of biochar (rate of 10%, w:w) at 5 °C ambient temperature.

materials. Previous reports showed that amendment of biochar effec- balance may have a critical influence on success or failure of com-
tively improved porosity and optimized pile structure (Liu et al., 2017; posting. In this study, heat exchange decreased in response to biochar
Sanchez-Garcia et al., 2015; Zhang et al., 2014). Such improvements addition, indicating that heat conduction retention by biochar addition
were undoubtedly beneficial to vertical water streaming in the form of played a decisive role in lower ambient temperature composting.
vapor. Increased water vapor generation and flow will certainly cause
more heat to flow out of the composting pile. Indeed, current results 3.4. Addition of biochar improved final compost quality at 5 °C ambient
showed that biochar addition to the composting mixture increased temperature
water vaporization heat, which was the largest source of heat loss
during composting. Meanwhile, its proportion to total heat output led After composting was completed, the maturity indicators of the final
by biochar addition was closer to those in ambient condition of 10 and compost, including germination index and ratio of humic acid/fulvic
15 °C, compared with treatment without biochar addition. Wang et al. acid (HA/FA), were analyzed. As shown in Table 2, the germination
(2016) concluded that water evaporation heat was the second greatest index exhibited by biochar added-compost was to 84.7%, which was
source of heat loss from a composting system using a model of thermal approximately 36% greater than that of control treatment without
balance. Interestingly, heat exchange triggered by biochar addition biochar addition and met generally admitted as mature value of 80%.
decreased by approximately 50% when compared with that without Similar to the germination index, the value of HA/FA calculated from
biochar addition. These findings indicate that heat loss via conduction biochar added-compost was also 43% higher than that of the control
from composting mixture to ambient air was mitigated. Simulation of treatment. These findings indicate that biochar amendment changed
the thermal balance of the composting process suggested that conduc- the heat balance, while improving the maturity of the final compost.
tion was the main source of heat loss components (Wang et al., 2014a). Subsequent results indicated incremental compost maturity in-
Based on synchronous increases in organic matter degradation derived cluding germination index and ratio of HA/FA were responsible to
heat and water vaporization heat, some specific elements in the thermal biochar amendment into composting mixture in low ambient

31
H. Liu et al. Bioresource Technology 273 (2019) 25–33

temperature. These findings coincided with recent conclusions obtained matter composition following aerobic composting of manure. Sci. Total Environ. 613,
by, Awasthi et al. (2018), Dias et al. (2010), Jindo et al (2016), Wang 20–29.
Haug, R.T., 1993. The Practical Handbook of Compost Engineering. Lewis Publishers,
et al. (2014b, 2017b). However, the results of the present study in- Boca Raton.
dicated that biochar can play a role in promoting humification at low He, X.Q., Chen, L.J., Han, L.J., Liu, N., Cui, R.X., Yin, H.J., Huang, G.Q., 2017. Evaluation
ambient temperature as well as at normal room temperature. However, of biochar powder on oxygen supply efficiency and global warming potential during
mainstream large-scale aerobic composting. Bioresour. Technol. 245, 309–317.
more important, this acceleration on maturity is just auxiliary to make a Jain, M.S., Jambhulkar, R., Kalamdhad, A.S., 2018. Biochar amendment for batch com-
description on final thermal balance resulting from biochar amendment posting of nitrogen rich organic waste: effect on degradation kinetics, composting
to swine manure followed by organic matter humification and mature physics and nutritional properties. Bioresour. Technol. 253, 204–213.
Jindo, K., Sanchez-Monedero, M.A., Hernandez, T., Garcia, C., Furukawa, T., Matsumoto,
compost production. K., Sonoki, T., Bastida, F., 2012. Biochar influences the microbial community struc-
ture during manure composting with agricultural wastes. Sci. Total Environ. 416,
4. Conclusion 476–481.
Jindo, K., Sonoki, T., Matsumoto, K., Canellas, L., Roig, A., Sanchez-Monedero, M.A.,
2016. Influence of biochar addition on the humic substances of composting manures.
Amendment of biochar to swine manure composting mixture sig- Waste Manage. (Oxford) 49, 545–552.
nificantly prolonged the duration for which the temperature was above Karer, J., Zehetner, F., Dunst, G., Fessl, J., Wagner, M., Puschenreiter, M., Stapkevica, M.,
55 °C at low ambient temperature compared with treatment without Friesl-Hanl, W., Soja, G., 2018. Immobilisation of metals in a contaminated soil with
biochar-compost mixtures and inorganic additives: 2-year greenhouse and field ex-
biochar amendment. Additionally, thermal balance analysis indicated periments. Environ. Sci. Pollut. Res. 25, 2506–2516.
that biochar addition remarkably increased organic matter degradation Komilis, D.P., Ham, R.K., 2006. Carbon dioxide and ammonia emissions during com-
derived heat that is a main component of heat input, and water va- posting of mixed paper, yard waste and food waste. Waste Manage. (Oxford) 26,
62–70.
porization heat, which is an important constitute of heat output. Liu, W., Wang, S.T., Zhang, J., Xu, T., 2014. Biochar influences the microbial community
However, heat exchange, another constitute of heat output, was found structure during tomato stalk composting with chicken manure. Bioresour. Technol.
to undergo a two-fold reduction. These results imply that biochar has 154, 148–154.
Liu, N., Zhou, J.L., Han, L.J., Ma, S.S., Sun, X.X., Huang, G.Q., 2017. Role and multi-scale
potential to play positive role in amelioration of aerobic composting at characterization of bamboo biochar during poultry manure aerobic composting.
low ambient temperature. Bioresour. Technol. 241, 190–199.
Lv, D.A., Wang, L.X., Yan, B.X., Deng, Z.Q., Zhang, Y.B., 2013. Changes in phosphorus
fractions and nitrogen forms during composting of pig manure with rice straw. J.
Acknowledgements Integr. Agric. 12, 1855–1864.
Manolikaki, I., Diamadopoulos, E., 2017. Ryegrass yield and nutrient status after biochar
This study was financially supported by the National Key Research application in two Mediterranean soils. Arch. Agron. Soil Sci. 63, 1093–1107.
National Health Commission of the People’s Republic of China, Standardization
& Development Program of China (2018YFD0500205;
Administration of the People’ Republic of China. 2012. Hygienic requirement for
2016YFD0501401), Chu Ko-chen Outstanding Young Scholars Program harmless disposal of night soil (GB-7859-2012). Beijing.
of the Institute of Geographic Sciences and Natural Resources Research, Otterpohl, R., 2012. Boosting compost with biochar and bacteria. Nature 486, 187–188.
Chinese Academy of Sciences (2017RC102) and the Instrument Pei, J.M., Zhuang, S., Cui, J., Li, J.Q., Li, B., Wu, J.H., Fang, C.M., 2017. Biochar de-
creased the temperature sensitivity of soil carbon decomposition in a paddy field.
Developing Project of the Chinese Academy of Sciences (YZ201605). Agric. Ecosyst. Environ. 249, 156–164.
Prost, K., Borchard, N., Siemens, J., Kautz, T., Sequaris, J.M., Moller, A., Amelung, W.,
References 2013. Biochar affected by composting with farmyard manure. J. Environ. Qual. 42,
164–172.
Sanchez-Garcia, M., Alburquerque, J.A., Sanchez-Monedero, M.A., Roig, A., Cayuela,
Agegnehu, G., Srivastava, A.K., Bird, M.I., 2017. The role of biochar and biochar-compost M.L., 2015. Biochar accelerates organic matter degradation and enhances N miner-
in improving soil quality and crop performance: a review. Appl. Soil Ecol. 119, alisation during composting of poultry manure without a relevant impact on gas
156–170. emissions. Bioresour. Technol. 192, 272–279.
Agyarko-Mintah, E., Cowie, A., Van Zwieten, L., Singh, B.P., Smillie, R., Harden, S., Sanchez-Monedero, M.A., Cayuela, M.L., Roig, A., Jindo, K., Mondini, C., Bolan, N., 2018.
Fornasier, F., 2017a. Biochar lowers ammonia emission and improves nitrogen re- Role of biochar as an additive in organic waste composting. Bioresour. Technol. 247,
tention in poultry litter composting. Waste Manage. (Oxford) 61, 129–137. 1155–1164.
Agyarko-Mintah, E., Cowie, A., Singh, B.P., Joseph, S., Van Zwieten, L., Cowie, A., Sun, D.Q., Lan, Y., Xu, E.G., Meng, J., Chen, W.F., 2016. Biochar as a novel niche for
Harden, S., Smillie, R., 2017b. Biochar increases nitrogen retention and lowers culturing microbial communities in composting. Waste Manage. (Oxford) 54,
greenhouse gas emissions when added to composting poultry litter. Waste Manage. 93–100.
(Oxford) 61, 138–149. Sun, F.F., Lu, S.G., 2014. Biochars improve aggregate stability, water retention, and pore-
Amoakwah, E., Frimpong, K.A., Arthur, E., 2017. Corn cob biochar improves aggregate space properties of clayey soil. J. Plant Nutr. Soil Sci. 177, 26–33.
characteristics of a tropical sandy loam. Soil Sci. Soc. Am. J. 81, 1054–1063. Uchimiya, M., Chang, S., Klasson, K.T., 2011. Screening biochars for heavy metal re-
Awasthi, M.K., Awasthi, S.K., Wang, Q., Wang, Z., Lahori, A.H., Ren, X.N., Chen, H.Y., tention in soil: role of oxygen functional groups. J. Hazard. Mater. 190, 432–441.
Wang, M.J., Zhao, J.C., Zhang, Z.Q., 2018. Influence of biochar on volatile fatty acids United States Environmental Protection Agency. 1994. Composting: yard trimmings, and
accumulation and microbial community succession during biosolids composting. municipal solid waste. Lancaster.
Bioresour. Technol. 251, 158–164. Wang, Q., Awasthi, M.K., Ren, X.N., Zhao, J.C., Li, R.H., Wang, Z., Chen, H.Y., Wang,
Bonanomi, G., Ippolito, F., Scala, F., 2015. A “black” future for plant pathology? Biochar M.J., Zhang, Z.Q., 2017b. Comparison of biochar, zeolite and their mixture amend-
as a new soil amendment for controlling plant diseases. J. Plant Pathol. 97, 223–234. ment for aiding organic matter transformation and nitrogen conservation during pig
Czekala, W., Malinska, K., Caceres, R., Janczak, D., Dach, J., Lewicki, A., 2016. Co- manure composting. Bioresour. Technol. 245, 300–308.
composting of poultry manure mixtures amended with biochar-the effect of biochar Wang, Q., Awasthi, M.K., Ren, X.N., Zhao, J.C., Li, R.H., Wang, Z., Wang, M.J., Chen,
on temperature and C-CO2 emission. Bioresour. Technol. 200, 921–927. H.Y., Zhang, Z.Q., 2018. Combining biochar, zeolite and wood vinegar for com-
De Guardia, A., Petiot, C., Benoist, J., Druilhe, C., 2012. Characterization and modelling posting of pig manure: the effect on greenhouse gas emission and nitrogen con-
of the heat transfers in a pilot-scale reactor during composting under forced aeration. servation. Waste Manage. (Oxford) 74, 221–230.
Waste Manage. (Oxford) 32, 134–140. Wang, Y.J., Huang, G.Q., Zhang, A.Q., Han, L.J., Ge, J.Y., 2014a. Estimating thermal
Dias, B.O., Silva, C.A., Higashikawa, F.S., Roig, A., Sanchez-Monedero, M.A., 2010. Use of balance during composting of swine manure and wheat straw: a simulation method.
biochar as bulking agent for the composting of poultry manure: effect on organic Int. J. Heat Mass Transfer 75 (362–367), 2014.
matter degradation and humification. Bioresour. Technol. 101, 1239–1246. Wang, C., Lu, H.H., Dong, D., Deng, H., Strong, P.J., Wang, H.L., Wu, W.X., 2013. Insight
Ennis, C.J., Evans, A.G., Islam, M., Ralebitso-Senior, T.K., Senior, E., 2012. Biochar: into the effects of biochar on manure composting: evidence supporting the re-
carbon sequestration, land remediation, and impacts on soil microbiology. Crit. Rev. lationship between N2O emission and denitrifying community. Environ. Sci. Technol.
Environ. Sci. Technol. 42, 2311–2364. 47, 7341–7349.
Ghaly, A., Alkoaik, F., Snow, A., 2006. Thermal balance of invessel composting of tomato Wang, Y.J., Pang, L., Liu, X.Y., Wang, Y.S., Zhou, K.X., Luo, F., 2016. Using thermal
plant residues. Can. Biosyst. Eng. 48, 6. balance model to determine optimal reactor volume and insulation material needed
Glab, T., Zabinski, A., Sadowska, U., Gondek, K., Kopec, M., Mierzwa-Hersztek, M., Tabor, in a laboratory-scale composting reactor. Bioresour. Technol. 206, 164–172.
S., 2018. Effects of co-composted maize, sewage sludge, and biochar mixtures on Wang, C., Tu, Q.P., Dong, D., Strong, P.J., Wang, H.L., Sun, B., Wu, W.X., 2014b.
hydrological and physical qualities of sandy soil. Geoderma 315, 27–35. Spectroscopic evidence for biochar amendment promoting humic acid synthesis and
Godlewska, P., Schmidt, H.P., Ok, Y.S., Oleszczuk, P., 2017. Biochar for composting intensifying humification during composting. J. Hazard. Mater. 280, 409–416.
improvement and contaminants reduction. A review. Bioresour. Technol. 246, Wang, X.Q., Zhao, Y., Wang, H., Zhao, X.Y., Cui, H.Y., Wei, Z.M., 2017a. Reducing ni-
193–202. trogen loss and phytotoxicity during beer vinasse composting with biochar addition.
Hagemann, N., Subdiaga, E., Orsetti, S., de la Rosa, J.M., Knicker, H., Schmidt, H.P., Waste Manage. (Oxford) 61, 150–156.
Kappler, A., Behrens, S., 2018. Effect of biochar amendment on compost organic Wiedner, K., Fischer, D., Walther, S., Criscuoli, I., Favilli, F., Nelle, O., Glaser, B., 2015.

32
H. Liu et al. Bioresource Technology 273 (2019) 25–33

Acceleration of biochar surface oxidation during composting? J. Agric. Food Chem. improve the humification and degradation of sewage sludge. Bioresour. Technol. 168,
63, 3830–3837. 252–258.
Wilshusen, J.H., Hettiaratchi, J.P., De Visscher, A., Saint-Fort, R., 2004. Methane oxi- Zhang, L., Sun, X.Y., 2014. Changes in physical, chemical, and microbiological properties
dation and formation of EPS in compost: effect of oxygen concentration. Environ. during the two-stage co-composting of green waste with spent mushroom compost
Pollut. 129, 305–314. and biochar. Bioresour. Technol. 171, 274–284.
Xiao, R., Awasthi, M.K., Li, R.H., Park, J., Pensky, S.M., Wang, Q., Wang, J.J., Zhang, Zhao, L., Gu, W.M., He, P.J., Shao, L.M., 2010. Effect of air-flow rate and turning fre-
Z.Q., 2017. Recent developments in biochar utilization as an additive in organic solid quency on bio-drying of dewatered sludge. Water Res. 44 (20), 6144–6152.
waste composting: a review. Bioresour. Technol. 246, 203–213. Zhu, Q.H., Wu, J., Wang, L.L., Yang, G., Zhang, X.H., 2015. Effect of biochar on heavy
Zhang, J.N., Lu, F., Shao, L.M., He, P.J., 2014. The use of biochar-amended composting to metal speciation of paddy soil. Water Air Soil Pollut. 226, 429.

33