Flow Under Gravity
Flow Under Gravity
Flow Under Gravity
Introduction When looking at energy options available to use when designing a livestock watering
system, if gravity energy is available at the site it is usually the first to be considered
because it is ‘free’ energy to:
• move water in a pipeline (refer to Factsheet #590.305-5 in this Handbook series)
• provide pressure to a trough
• frost-protect a trough (refer to Factsheet #590.304-6 in this Handbook series)
While water will ‘flow-down-hill’, gravity pipelines have some specific requirements
for trouble-free operation.
How Much Water The energy due to gravity at a site is equal to the elevation difference between points,
such as between the water supply and the trough site. This elevation difference is
Will Flow?
termed head with units of feet (for water, more accurately, as feet of head of water).
In the case of water, this energy is equal to:
• 1 foot of elevation drop = 0.433 psi of pressure head
• or, for every 2.31 feet of elevation drop = 1 psi of pressure head
Pipe size and flow rate must be ‘matched’ to this energy using the following steps:
• the elevation drop or elevation head is measured
• a flow rate is chosen (refer to Factsheet #590.304-1 in this Handbook series)
• the ‘end-of-pipe’ pressure is chosen (refer also to Factsheet #590-304-1)
• then a pipe size can be chosen (refer to Factsheet #590.304-2, page 6, “Example
– Gravity System” in this Handbook series, for a “simple” system example)
- different pipe sizes and pipe materials will have different flows for a given
elevation drop (i.e., they have different friction losses)
(‘friction losses’ are only ‘lost’ to the water system as energy is converted into heat)
The “how-much-will-flow” question is answered using pipe friction loss tables for the
pipe material type and size chosen. All the energy in the elevation head will be used:
• some to provide the ‘end-of-pipe’ pressure requirement
• the rest will be used up as friction to provide a given flow through the pipe
Hydraulic Theory Unfortunately, gravity water flow in pipes must be designed to the terrain of a site, so
the above is a simplification. If the terrain is a consistent or near consistent grade,
one pipe size could be chosen to use the available energy evenly over the full pipe
length (as in the above noted Example). But sites often have terrains of varying
grades requiring a closer look at pipe sizing requirements, which could include two
Page 1 of 12
(or more) pipe sizes. At this point some knowledge of hydraulic theory is needed.
The following is a brief and simplified overview of hydraulic theory useful in
understanding gravity water flow in pipes. See the reference material for more detail.
Continuity of Flow Principle. This states that for constant water flow in a pipe,
flow in one part of a pipe is equal to flow at any other part of the pipe, as shown by:
As flow is velocity multiplied by pipe area, changing the pipe cross sectional area (a
larger or smaller pipe) will cause a change in velocity. This becomes useful when
selecting a pipe size or in negative pressure conditions, page 5.
Water in Motion. When water is flowing in the pipe friction loss occurs that
reduces the pressure energy at all points along the pipe. With a constant flow a
system is said to be in dynamic equilibrium and pressures are termed dynamic heads.
Hydraulic Grade Line. To fully illustrate the conditions along a pipe, static and
dynamic equilibrium conditions can be plotted on a drawing of the profile of the
system. When the points of static or dynamic equilibrium are connected they form a
line that is termed the hydraulic grade line (HGL). This line represents the energy
level at each point along the pipe (refer to Figure 1, below). As different flows have
different energy levels, they also have different HGL’s.
Page 2 of 12
The HGL for static equilibrium is a horizontal line at the level of the water source, as
in static conditions the pipe has an energy level equal to its elevation below this
water source elevation (no friction loss is occurring).
The HGL for dynamic equilibrium is a line sloped downwards from the water inlet to
either the pressure at the trough float valve or to zero if the outlet flow is to
atmosphere. This line always slopes downward, indicating a ‘loss’ of energy as water
flows downhill and energy is lost due to friction.
Friction. When water is flowing in the pipe energy is lost by the friction of water
against the pipe and fittings, and as it enters and exits the pipe, including such
obstacles as air trapped in the pipe (see Air Locks, page 6) and is determined by:
• the pipe wall roughness
• the velocity of the water (the flow rate through a given pipe diameter)
• minor (usually) things like fittings, water temperature, suspended particles, etc
For a given pipe size, the greater the flow - the greater the velocity - the greater the
energy loss by friction. Friction losses are not linear - doubling the flow may increase
the friction loss by up to four times. This energy loss cannot be recovered. As energy
in a gravity system is fixed by the elevation difference present, lost energy due to
friction is usually an important design factor. Pipe size is selected to ‘match’ pipe
friction loss to the available head to achieve the desired water flow rate.
Natural Flow When gravity-pressured water is flowing in a pipe that discharges to the atmosphere
(say freely into the top of a trough) the maximum flow is occurring. This means the
elevation head is all being converted to friction loss. This flow rate can be
determined by using the friction loss table (Table 2, Factsheet #590.304-2):
• the elevation head (ft) is measured and converted to psi (ft divided by 2.31 = psi)
• the pipe length (ft) is measured
• the available energy for friction loss is calculated
- elevation head divided by pipe length, expressed as psi per 100 ft (psi/100 ft)
• this value is located on the friction loss table under the column for the pipe type
and size and the flow rate for those conditions is read
Note that systems that use a float valve will require some pressure head at the trough
that will reduce the energy available for friction thereby reducing the flow below that
of the natural rate. Refer to Example 2, next page, and to Factsheet #590.304-2, page
6, “Example – Gravity System” in this Handbook series, for examples.
Page 3 of 12
Combination When a single pipe size does not give the desired friction loss, two pipes will be
needed. The following Combination Pipe Size Equation, derived from the Continuity
Pipes of Flow Principle, is much quicker than the ‘trial and error’ method of calculation
where various pipe lengths are tried. It is used to calculate pipe lengths for a desired
flow rate, when the total head and the total pipe length are known and two pipe sizes
have been selected:
Smaller (1 inch) Pipe Length = (100 x 40 ft) - (1.66 x 1200 ft) = 432 ft of 1 inch pipe
(6.31) - (1.66)
Larger (1¼ inch) Pipe Length = 1200 ft - 432 ft = 768 ft of 1¼ inch pipe
• solution: use a combination of 768 ft of 1¼ inch pipe (loss of 12.8 ft: 0.72 x 7.68 x 2.31) and 432 ft of
1 inch pipe (loss of 27.2 ft: 2.73 x 4.32 x 2.31) flowing at 10 USgpm, which will use 40 ft of friction
head leaving 35 ft (15 psi) for trough pressure
• note: these two pipe sizes could be in any order (i.e., the larger pipe at either the top or bottom section)
but it is normal to use the larger pipe in the top section starting at the intake
• note: the above Example is appropriate for sites with no severe grade changes – see Negative Pressure,
next page, for a pipe selection example on a site that has a severe grade change
Page 4 of 12
Negative Pressure Negative pressure (less than atmospheric) may not always be considered in the
design of a pipe system. Negative pressure is usually due to a site terrain limitation
and it can be identified by the use of a site drawing showing the HGL. It will be
evident by comparing the energy available over various pipe sections (various falls
per pipe length) and calculating their individual flows.
The HGL should always be above the pipeline (i.e., there should always be a positive
pressure in the pipe). Should the HGL be below the pipe it indicates a negative
pressure is present in the pipe. This means flow is being siphoned through this pipe
section (i.e., the continuity of flow, page 2, tells us that there can’t be different flow
rates in the same sized pipe). This is usually undesirable as it indicates the flow rate
is being restricted, as well as air can be drawn into the pipe through fittings, etc.
(refer to Air Locks, page 7)
This situation often occurs where the pipe leaving the water source is on a flat grade
until it goes down a hill, where the grade is steep. A constant pipe size would have a
low natural flow to the hill but then a larger natural flow down the hill, siphoning
water through the flat grade to maintain that larger flow in the steep grade.
For existing systems with this problem, a second parallel pipe can be installed to
increase the flow rate to ‘match’ the rate in the steep section. For instance, two, 1
inch PE pipes each flowing 5 USgpm (10 USgpm total) have the same friction loss
(each at 0.76 psi/100ft) as one, 1¼ inch pipe flowing at 10 USgpm (0.72 psi/100ft).
Page 5 of 12
Example 3 – Negative Pressure Conditions
Using the same conditions as Example 1, (75 feet elevation head, using 1200 feet of 1 inch polyethylene pipe
free flowing into a trough), but with uneven grade: 10 ft fall in the first 500 ft then 65 ft fall in the last 700
ft, as shown in Figure 2. What pipe size(s) are needed to prevent a negative pressure in the pipe?
• information given: 75 ft elevation head: divided by 2.31 = 32.5 psi; and the pipe length is 1200 ft
• average available friction loss (as Example 1) is 32.5 psi / (1200 ft / 100) = 2.71 psi/100 ft
• natural flow for each section (if separate): the 1 inch pipe is on two very different grades:
- 10 ft fall / 2.31 / (500 ft / 100) = 0.89 psi/100 ft = about 5.5 USgpm natural flow
- 65 ft fall / 2.31 / (700 ft / 100) = 4.02 psi/100 ft = about 12 USgpm natural flow
• Continuity of Flow Principle requires the same flow rate in all sections of a pipe of the same size
• to correct this, different pipe sizes must be selected (larger for top section or smaller for bottom)
depending on the flow rate to the trough (the Combination Pipe Size Equation doesn’t account for grade)
• choose a flow rate: as only 0.89 psi/100ft is available in the top (flatter) section, use this available
friction loss to find the flow rate of pipes larger then the current 1 inch (use the Table below)
- a 1¼ PE pipe has a 0.86 psi/100ft friction loss at 11 USgpm = 9.9 ft loss in 500 ft (10 ft available)
- the 1 PE pipe has a 3.27 psi/100ft friction loss at 11 USgpm = 52.9 ft loss in 700 ft (65 ft available)
- total friction loss at 11 USgpm = (9.9 + 52.9) = 62.8 ft, leaving 12.2 ft head (5 psi) at the trough
- a close ‘match’ is 11 USgpm with 500 ft of 1¼ inch PE followed by 700 ft of 1 inch PE
• combinations shown in the Table below: other combinations of pipe sizes will give other flow rates
• for instance, 16 USgpm with 500ft of 1½ inch pipe followed by 700 ft of 1¼ inch pipe
- this combination will have 16 psi left at the trough (free flowing would siphon to over 24 USgpm)
• or, 30 USgpm with 500ft of 2 inch pipe followed by 700 ft of 1½ inch pipe
- this combination will have 10 psi left at the trough (free flowing would siphon to over 35 USgpm)
Pipe Flow & Friction Loss from Table 2, Factsheet #590-304-2, for Example 3
Site Conditions Polyethylene (PE) Pipe Size (inch)
Pipe Length Fall Available Energy 1 1¼ 1½ 2
ft ft psi/100ft flow loss flow loss flow loss flow loss
500 10 0.89 5 0.76 11 0.86 16 0.81 30 0.77
Air Locks – Gravity-pressured flow is prone to partial or total blockage by trapped air pockets.
The Problem These can be erratic; several hours or days of system use before blockage occurs.
Page 6 of 12
• dissolved air coming out of solution due to temperature increase (e.g., black PE
pipe laid on the ground) or to pressure decrease (see negative pressures, above)
• entry into the pipe at a stock trough that is installed as a flow-through trough
- these troughs are often used as a "pressure break" in a gravity feed system but
can be points of air entry into the line exiting the trough (as at the main inlet)
How Air Locks Form. Air locks can form either during static conditions (no
water flow) or dynamic conditions (water flow). Air that enters the pipeline when
water is flowing must be carried downstream to an outlet to ensure continued water
flow. If the system is static, the air must be able to rise and exit at the water inlet
point (which, except for siphons, is the highest point in a gravity feed system). If the
air becomes trapped in any high point along the pipe an air lock forms.
Total Air Locks. A total air lock can form in a pipe which will completely block
the flow of water. Figure 3, below, illustrates a simple, single undulation pipe
example where a gravity pipe supplies a float-controlled trough.
When the trough float valve is closed, any air in the pipe that can’t escape up and out
the water supply pipe end can accumulate in the pipe undulation. In this static
condition, the pressures at A and B are the same and equal to the height of water HW.
In the dynamic condition, the trough float valve is opened, and the trapped air bubble
will move down the pipe. Because air has negligible weight compared with water, the
pressures at A1 and B1 are the same and are equal to the height of water H. Therefore
A1 will support the height of water H behind it and B1 will support the same height of
water H in front of it. If the outlet is higher than H no water will flow.
Solutions, on the next pages, include having a flow rate sufficient to move the air
with the water, or using an air release valve at the high point C to automatically let
out air before it accumulates to form an air lock (see air release valve picture page 9).
Page 7 of 12
Multiple Air Locks. In cases where the pipe is laid across many undulations, there
is the possibility of an air lock developing at each undulation. The maximum outlet
height that water will flow to if each section were to air lock is (Figure 3, previous
page):
HT = Hs – (H1 + H2 + etc)
Partial Air Locks. If the trough height, HT, in Figure 3 was lower than the height
H a total air lock would not form but there could be a restriction to the flow. Air can
remain in the downward portion of the pipe reducing the area available for water
flow as shown in Figure 4, below. In this case, the gravity feed system will have
some flow, but less than expected, due to this air bubble forming a partial air lock.
Air Locks – The solutions to air lock problems vary depending on the complexity of the system
layout, access to the pipe after installation, use in freezing conditions (deeply buried
The Solutions
pipes are more awkward to install and maintain air release valves), etc.
One solution is to analyze the pipe system and modify the design:
• a pipe system can be analyzed in detail and the pipe size increased in the critical
areas at rise points – this involves calculation of the air compression in the pipe
and the resultant head available on the lower side of the air lock
• or, the above can be simplified with the assumption that all the lower side is air
filled, add up these air column heights, and subtract from the total head (refer to
Multiple Air Locks, above) to determine the maximum delivery height to a trough
assuming these worst air lock conditions will occur
A second, and simpler solution (where the terrain allows) is to follow basic
installation practices given in Preventing Air Locks, next page.
Page 8 of 12
Preventing Air Locks #1 - Pipe Systems That May Or May Not Air Lock.
The following illustrates the type of pipe systems to be aware of regarding air locks:
Page 9 of 12
Example 4 – Air Lock
_________________________________________________________________________________________
Using the same conditions as Example 1, (75 feet elevation head), but using 1,200 feet of 1¼ inch polyethylene
pipe free flowing into a trough, but the pipeline route has a rise over a hill (50 ft elevation) and then up a
second slope to the trough that must be at 30 ft elevation (refer to Figure 5, below). The required flow rate is
5 USgpm. Can the trough be set at this elevation with this flow? If not, what are the options?
• calculate the head available should an air lock occur
- head available at the high point = 75 ft - 50 ft = 25 ft above high point to the water source
- should an air lock occur at the high point, there would be only this 25 ft head for water flow to the
trough including friction and lift to the trough
• calculate the friction loss at the required flow rate of 5 USgpm
- friction loss for 1200 ft of 1¼ inch PE flowing 5 USgpm from Table 2, Factsheet #590.304-2 :
1200 ft x 0.20 psi = 2.4 psi, x 2.31 ft/psi = 6 ft loss due to friction
100 ft
• calculate the trough elevation at 5 USgpm flow with 1¼ inch PE pipe
- 25 ft (available head) - 6 ft (friction loss) = 19 ft remaining for maximum trough elevation
• the trough can be located at 19 ft elevation (56 ft below intake) for the system flow rate of 5 USgpm,
but the required trough height is 30 ft, so under air lock conditions water will not reach the trough
• the solutions are:
1- if the water is available, increase the flow rate to the flushing rate - 7.8 USgpm for 1¼ inch pipe
now there is no air lock, so there is 75 ft - 30 ft head = 45 ft head at the trough
at 45 ft head / 2.31 / (1200 ft / 100) = 1.62 psi/100ft = about 15 USgpm flow to the trough
2- if there isn’t sufficient water, install a valve on the outlet to restrict this flow to about 8 USgpm
3- if 8 USgpm is not available, select a 1 inch pipe size
at 45 ft head / 2.31 / (1200 ft / 100) = 1.62 psi/100ft = about 7.5 USgpm flow to the trough
this is greater than the flushing rate of 3.6 USgpm for 1 inch pipe, so an air lock will not occur
if needed, install a valve on the outlet to restrict this flow to the required flow of 5 USgpm
4- or, install an air release valve at the high point to ensure release of any accumulated air and flow the
required 5 USgpm, or one of the above higher flows (on either pipe size)
Page 10 of 12
Breaking Line Pressure & Releasing Air. Where appropriate, a trough can be
used to release air, but the line pressure is reduced to zero, returning to atmospheric
pressure. This is sometimes used in gravity systems with large elevation falls creating
excess line pressure and where air release is required.
Siphons Siphons are a unique gravity flow situation where the pipeline goes over a point that
is higher than the supply water elevation before falling to the delivery elevation. A
siphon uses the differences in elevation and atmospheric pressure to flow water.
If the both ends of the pipe are submerged and air is removed at the high point
(primed), atmospheric pressure on the supply water surface will move water up the
pipe to the high point (if this point is set at an appropriate elevation) and gravity will
move the water from there down to the delivery point.
Alternatively, with a check valve (foot valve) on the intake and a control valve on the
outlet, closing the outlet valve, filling up the siphon pipe with water, then opening the
outlet valve will start the siphon flow.
Preferred Conditions for a Siphon. A siphon will work better under the
following conditions (refer to Figure 7, next page):
• the short leg is as short as possible
• the high point is as low and as close to the inlet water surface as possible
• the high point is less than 15 feet above the HGL (decrease by 3 ft for every 3000
ft elevation above sea level)
• the slope of the long leg is greater than the HGL slope
• the flushing flow rate (Table 1, page 9) is used to avoid air buildup at the high
point
• minimum fall across the siphon is used (refer to Table 2, below)
• an inlet check valve and outlet control valve are used
• an outlet box is used to prevent entry of air into the siphon (water can be piped
from this box to the trough)
Page 11 of 12
Figure 7 Siphon Showing Preferred Conditions
References The following were used for this Factsheet and have further information on gravity
pipe systems:
A Handbook of Gravity-Flow Water Systems
T.D. Jordan Jr.
Intermediate Technology Publications, 1984
-this is a UNICEF publication dealing with water systems for small communities
Water Supply Flow Problems – Airlocks in Pipes, #FPP 798
MAF Information Services
New Zealand
- this Factsheet outlines air lock principles
Water Conveyance with Siphons
Richard Powley
Agriculture and Agri-Food Canada
- a detailed engineering outline of siphons
Liquid Assets – Water Management for Dryland Agriculture
James Bourchier, Editor
Kondinin Group
West Australia
- articles on pipelines, air locks, siphons
Page 12 of 12