DL Adaptive Closed Loop MIMO
DL Adaptive Closed Loop MIMO
DL Adaptive Closed Loop MIMO
Introduction
1 Motivation and Feature Overview 7 Dimensioning Aspects
Dimensioning Impacts and Examples
Deployment Aspects
6 Activation, Configuration Examples, Fault Mgmt, Trial Area
Introduction
1 Motivation and Feature Overview 7 Dimensioning Aspects
Dimensioning Impacts and Examples
Deployment Aspects
6 Activation, Configuration Examples, Fault Mgmt, Trial Area
DL
• LTE568 DL Adaptive Closed Loop MIMO (4x2) is the DL transmission
scheme using 4 TX antennas and 2 RX antennas in the DL direction
A A A A
n n n n
t t t t
LTE 568
DL adaptive Closed
• It uses 3GPP Transmission Mode 4 (TM4) with switching between Loop MIMO (4x2) LTE 703
single and dual codeword for PDSCH. DL control channels are DL adaptive Closed
Loop MIMO (2x2)
transmitted using 4-way Transmit Diversity (TM2)
• LTE568 DL Adaptive Closed Loop MIMO (4x2) DOES NOT introduce Average DL
four spatial multiplexing layers. The achievable peak throughput is TP increase
not doubled with this feature (when compared to 2x2) DL coverage
increase
• Although LTE568 DL Adaptive Closed Loop MIMO (4x2) will increase the
average cell throughput, peak throughput will be slightly (1..8%) lower
than LTE703 DL Adaptive Closed Loop MIMO (2x2) due to additional
system overhead
Increased
Improved average DL TP DL Cell Range
Cell uses 4 DL
TX antennas.
For internal use
8 5/15/2020 © Nokia Solutions and Networks 2013
LTE568 – DL Adaptive Closed Loop MIMO (4x2) Main Menu
Introduction
1 Motivation and Feature Overview 7 Dimensioning Aspects
Dimensioning Impacts and Examples
Deployment Aspects
6 Activation, Configuration Examples, Fault Mgmt, Trial Area
• Dependency table:
FD-LTE RL release eNB NetAct
Transmission over
Release/version FSMr3 N/A N/A 3GPP Rel. 8 4TX antennas in DL,
36.211
Introduction to
Physical Channel Processing
• Before bits in DL go on air, they are processed in a way specified in 3GPP TS 36.211
• Processing takes place in baseband
• Besides obvious tasks, like fitting stream of bits into the physical resource grids, scheme allows to host various transmission modes
(MIMO among others)
36.211 36.211 36.211 36.211 36.211
6.3.1 6.3.2 6.3.3 6.3.4 6.3.5
codewords layers antenna ports
Scramble the
codeword with
scrambling Modulate block of Distribute symbols Distribute symbols from
scrambled bits using between layers. Map symbols to the
sequence layers between virtual appropriate resource
QPSK, 16QAM or Up to 8 layers are antenna ports.
64QAM modulation supported by 3GPP. elements in the
This is key block for resource grid
multiple antenna DL
transmission schemes
(MIMO, TX diversity).
For internal use
12 5/15/2020 © Nokia Solutions and Networks 2013
Technical Details Main Menu
Physical Channel Processing – Glossary: Codeword
• Append a 24 bit checksum (CRC) to the transport block. This CRC is What about 8x8 MIMO? Why only 2 codewords?
used to determine whether the transmission was successful or not, and See next slide!
triggers Hybrid ARQ to send an ACK or NACK
• Segment the transport block into code blocks. A code block must be
between 40 and 6144 bits long. If the transport block is too small, it is
padded up to 40 bits; if the TB is too big, it is divided into smaller pieces,
each of which gets an additional 24 bit CRC *DCI – Downlink Control Information
• Process each code block with a 1/3 turbo coder
• Reassemble the resulting code blocks into a single codeword
• A layer is a stream of symbols carrying unique information 3GPP standard allows up to 8 layers
• Mapping codewords to layers is specified in 3GPP TS 36.211 6.3.3 For 4x2 MIMO, 1 or 2 spatial multiplexing layers are used
Layer 0
(same as for 2x2 MIMO)
For 2x Transmit Diversity, 2 layers are used
Codeword 0 Layer 1
Example For 4x Transmit Diversity, 4 layers are used
Layer 2 mapping
Codeword 1
Layer 3 For more information about layer mapping, see the book:
• Number of layers determines, how many unique symbols will go on air
at the same time
- So the system is not limited to 2 symbols transmitted at once!
LTE for 4G Mobile Broadband: Air Interface
• Q: Why doesn’t standard allow for more codewords and skip the layer Technologies and Performance
by Farooq Khan,
mapping step? Layer mapping just complicates things!
Cambridge University Press 2009
• A: ACK/NACK, CQI report, is associated with codeword, and consumes the
precious resources. A scheme combining 2 codewords and multiple layers has
been chosen after evaluation of receiver complexity and signaling overhead.
For internal use
14 5/15/2020 © Nokia Solutions and Networks 2013
Technical Details Main Menu
Layer Mapping in 3GPP
x (1) (i ) d (1) (i )
x (0) (i ) d (0) (3i ) Layer Mapping for Transmit Diversity
3 1 x (1) (i ) d (0) (3i 1)
layer
M symb M symb
( 0)
3 (layers will not be spatially multiplexed )
x ( 2) (i ) d (0) (3i 2)
x ( 0 ) (i ) d ( 0 ) (i )
symb M symb M symb 2
layer ( 0) (1)
Number of3 Number of 2 (i ) d (1) ( 2i )
x (1Codeword-to-layer
) M
mapping
layers codewords
Codeword 0 Layer 0
x ( 2) (i ) i d(10) ,(12,..., 1) symb 1
layer
i M
( 0)
2 4 if M ( 0)
symb mod 40
4 1 x (1) (i ) d (0) (2i 1) Layer 1
4 x ( 22) (i ) d (0) (4i 2) ( 0)
If M symb mod 4M
layer
0
symb
two M ( 0)
null
symb 2
symbols M (1)
symbbe2
shall
x ( 2) (i ) d (1) ( 2i )
x (3) (i ) d (0) (4i 3)(3)
d (1) ( 2i to1) d ( M symb 1)
( 0) ( 0)
x (i ) appended Layer 2
x ( 0)
(i ) d ( 0)
(2i )
Layer 3
For internal use x (1) (i ) d (0) (2i 1)
x ( 2) (i ) d (1) (3i)
layer
M symb ( 0)
M symb 2 (1)
M symb 3
15 5/15/20205 2 © Nokia Solutions and Networks 2013
x (3) (i ) d (1) (3i 1)
x ( 4) (i ) d (1) (3i 2)
Technical Details Main Menu
Physical Channel Processing – Glossary: Virtual Antenna Port
• For each LTE operating mode in the downlink direction for which an Same Reference
Signal from all
independent channel is assumed, a separate logical antenna port is antennas. UE “sees” Beamforming
defined. 4 TX antennas as 1. vector
• In order to determine the characteristic channel for an antenna port, Separate Reference
a UE must carry out a separate channel estimation for each Signal from each
antenna. UE “sees”
antenna port. Separate reference signals are sent from each 4 TX antennas
antenna port.
Beamforming (LTE493) uses antenna port 5:
• In 3GPP standard, each port number has particular purpose.
Introduction to
MIMO
• Challenge: how to improve spectral efficiency Spatial diversity example: i.i.d. Rayleigh fading.
(B/s/Hz)?
Uncoded BEP
-1
• Higher-order constellations suffer more from receiver 10 ~15dB
impairments and have higher computational complexity
requirements. 4096-QAM may be complicated to
implement in practice
nTx=1, 64QAM
nTx=4, 64QAM
nTx=4, 4096QAM
• Solution: spatial multiplexing (MIMO) nTx=2, 4096QAM
nTx=1, 4096QAM
nTx=2, 64QAM
10 15 20 25 30
Avg tx power / noise power dB
Source:
For internal use Feature Deep Dive, LTE70: adaptive open-loop MIMO for two antennas
18 5/15/2020 © Nokia Solutions and Networks 2013
Technical Details Main Menu
Channel Coefficients
1.5
1
Symbol received
Constellation shifts in by RX antenna 1
Q phase and amplitude
0.5
according to the
complex channel
0
coefficients Symbol received
by RX antenna 2
I -0.5
Transmitted symbols
Received symbols -1
-1.5
In case of 4x2 MIMO there are 4 TX antennas at the eNB, but still only 2 RX
antennas in the UE.
xx1 h13 y1
2 TX
…unless the x’s are made dependant of each other, for example: antenna
port 1
h14 x1
x1 x2 ; x3 x4 MIMO
Then we have only 2 unknowns, MIMO equation becomes possible to solve. h21
receiver x3
xx33 TX
That essentially is what the precoder does - combining symbols antenna
port 3
from layers: h22
y2
h23 RX2
…to xx34 TX
Layers Precoder antenna antenna h24
port 4
ports
I I
h22 x2
1 1
W ; x2 jx1
Received
In this example, let’s change the precoding weights: W
•
symbol
• x2 is now rotated 90 degrees to x1
1 j
• Symbols experience channel coefficients same as on previous example as they
propagate, but now something is received at the UE antennae. Q Q
x1
h12 x2 h11 x1
• Signal to Noise Ratio (SNR) can be improved by selection of proper precoder setting.
This is called Precoding Gain. Precoding gain depends on the chosen precoding I I
weights.
• The receiver needs to know the precoding weights that were used by the eNB, x1 1
y1
otherwise it cannot understand what eNB meant by transmitting its symbols – even if it
TX
antenna
port 0 RX1
1
can receive them with higher SNR. x1
-1 MIMO
receiver x2
-1
codewords layers antenna ports x2 TX
antenna
RX2
port 1
y2
Modulation Resource element OFDM signal
Scrambling mapper
mapper generation
Layer
Q Q
Precoding
mapper
h22 x2 h21 x1
Modulation Resource element OFDM signal
Scrambling mapper
mapper generation
I I
x2
• In previous example SNR increase caused by the precoding gain was shown
• This principle also applies double codeword transmission
• Additionally, by proper selection of the precoding weights system is able to balance the SNR of two streams in order to achieve optimal performance
layers
• Optimal precoding setting is construed from channel coefficients alone eNB
• But in turn the eNB needs to know the channel coefficients. How to get this knowledge?
- In TDD, eNB can benefit from channel reciprocity (UL and DL channel coefficients are the same),
but needs update with the UE transmission (SRS is used) code precoder
- In FDD it can only rely on UE feedback book
• On the other hand UE already has full knowledge of the DL channel, so it can calculate the optimal
precoding as well, and request it to the eNB. This requires less signalling overhead. RF
• So the possible codebook settings need to be known to both sides (UE and eNB). These settings are
referred to as codebook.
eNB to UE:
“Here is your
• Once UE selects the optimal precoding, it reports it to the eNB by indicating its PMI (Precoding Matrix data, and I used
UE to eNB:
Index) which its position in the codebook. It can be reported periodically (enabled by default), or “I want this PMI” this PMI”
aperiodically (configurable).
• eNB will notify the UE with the PMI that is uses with the DL transmission in the Downlink Control
Information (DCI).
RF
code Channel
book estimation
Note: This description applies only to the closed loop MIMO transmission modes!
Open Loop MIMO periodically changes its precoding setting and requires no PMI feedback
UE
For internal use
26 5/15/2020 © Nokia Solutions and Networks 2013
Technical Details Main Menu
3GPP codebook for spatial multiplexing
4 TX antennas
• Both UE and eNB must know the codebooks used. (LTE568).
• Codebooks are standardized by 3GPP in 36.211 3.6.4 Only 1 and 2
- Codebook for 8 CSI reference signals are given in 36.213 7.2.4 layers are used
• Codebooks are designed to minimize signaling overhead and to simplify
UE processing. Codebook un Number of layers
• Codebook size depends on the number of used antennas. index 1 2 3 4
0 u 0 1 1 1 1T W0{1} W0{14} 2 W0{124} 3 W0{1234} 2
1 u1 1 j 1 j T W1{1} W1{12} 2 W1{123} 3 W1{1234} 2
2 u 2 1 1 1 1T W2{1} W2{12} 2 W2{123} 3 W2{3214} 2
3 u3 1 j 1 j T W3{1} W3{12} 2 W3{123} 3 W3{3214} 2
2 TX antennas Wn I 2u n u nH u nH u n 4
u4 1 (1 j ) 2 j (1 j ) 2
T
W4{1} W4{14} 2 W4{124} 3 W4{1234} 2
1
T
5 u5 (1 j ) 2 j (1 j ) 2 W5{1} W5{14} 2 W5{124} 3 W5{1234} 2
(LTE703)
1
T
6 u6 (1 j ) 2 j (1 j ) 2 W6{1} W6{13} 2 W6{134} 3 W6{1324} 2
1
T
Codebook Number of layers 7 u7 (1 j ) 2 j (1 j ) 2 W7{1} W7{13} 2 W7{134} 3 W7{1324} 2
index 1 2 W3{12} 2 8 u8 1 1 1 1T W8{1} W8{12} 2 W8{124} 3 W8{1234} 2
1 1 1 1 0
0 Select columns 1 and 2 9 u9 1 j 1 j T W9{1} W9{14} 2 W9{134} 3 W9{1234} 2
2 1 2 0 1
1 1 1 1 1 10 u10 1 1 1 1T W10{1} W10{13} 2 W10{123} 3 W10{1324} 2
1
2 1 2 1 1 11 u11 1 j 1 j T W11{1} W11{13} 2 W11{134} 3 W11{1324} 2
0.3536 0.3536i -0.3536 -0.3536i
1 1 1 1 1
-0.3536i 0.3536 -0.3536i 0.3536 12 u12 1 1 1 1T W12{1} W12{12} 2 W12{123} 3 W12{1234} 2
2
2 j 2 j j
-0.3536 0.3536i 0.3536 -0.3536i 13 u13 1 1 1 1T W13{1} W13{13} 2 W13{123} 3 W13{1324} 2
1 1
3 - 0.3536i 0.3536 0.3536i 0.3536 14 u14 1 1 1 1T W14{1} W14{13} 2 W14{123} 3 W14{3214} 2
2 j
15 u15 1 1 1 1T W15{1} W15{12} 2 W15{123} 3 W15{1234} 2
• The MMO equation set will have a solution if the equations are linearly independent. layers
• If this condition is not met, system is not able to support multiple streams
eNB
• Ability to support parallel streams is channel rank.
• Same as precoding scheme, rank can be calculated from channel coefficients alone.
• Rank is calculated by UE and reported to the eNB. This report is rank indication (RI) code precoder
• With 2x2 or 4x2 MIMO rank can either be 1 or 2 book
RF
• When UE reports PMI, it is always associated with the reported rank. So if eNB decides
code Rank and
to override rank suggested by the UE, it will not have valid PMI for this rank Channel
book PMI
- This happens with “Dynamic Adaptive MIMO Switching”. In this case, eNB estimation
calculation
cyclically switches available PMIs
U P L I N K C O N T R O L I N F O R M A T I O N
4 Part of UCI
I want this rank…”
MIMO
5 control
codebook
Channel Rank and
estimation 2 precoding 3
6 calculation
RF
layers
1
RF
precoder 7
PDSCH
receiver
9 layers
Part of DCI
eNB “Here is your data, and I used 8 UE
this number of layers…”
• eNB notifies the UE about the used PMI in the Downlink Control Information (DCI) on PDCCH
• There are DCI formats defined for each Transmission Mode in 3GPP 36.212, 5.3.3.1
• TM4 uses DCI format 2
Field Bits
TM Scheme DCI format
Resource allocation type 0/type 1 flag 1
TM1 Single-antenna port (p = 0) 1, 1A Resource block assignment Type 0
TM2 Transmit diversity 1, 1A N RB
DL
/ P
32 3 layers: TPMI=15
- Additionally, in LTE568 DCI format 1 is used for Transmit
33 2 layers: TPMI=15 33 3 layers: Precoding
Diversity to schedule UEs that do not support 4x2 MIMO according to the latest
PMI report on PUSCH
(Class 1 devices) using the precoder(s)
indicated by the reported
PMI(s)
34 2 layers: Precoding 34 4 layers: TPMI=0
according to the latest
PMI report on PUSCH
using the precoder(s)
indicated by the reported
System configures the number of layers and PMIs for which UE has to report to the PMI(s)
35 – 63 reserved 35 4 layers: TPMI=1
eNB. This is done with codebookSubsetRestriction bitmap during RRC signaling (IE
AntennaInfo, 3GPP 36.331, 6.3.2) 49 4 layers: TPMI=15
50 4 layers: Precoding
according to the latest
For internal use PMI report on PUSCH
using the precoder(s)
32 5/15/2020 © Nokia Solutions and Networks 2013 indicated by the reported
PMI(s)
51 – 63 Reserved
Technical Details Main Menu
Relation of Transmission Modes in 3GPP to NSN product
TM8 Dual stream beamforming Single Stream Single stream TM7, TM2 (TM3*)
Beamforming beamforming
TM9, TM10, … Dual Stream Dual stream TM8, TM2 (TM3*)
… Beamforming beamforming
For internal use
33 5/15/2020 © Nokia Solutions and Networks 2013
Technical Details Main Menu
Alamouti scheme for Transmit Diversity
• Transmit Diversity uses two transmit antennas over two symbol periods to transmit two independent data symbols
• A stream of symbols is transmitted over two antennas. Each symbol is transmitted with efficiently designed redundancy
• This is Orthogonal Space-Frequency Block Code (OSFBC)
• Applicable to control/broadcast channels (PDCCH, PBCH, PHICH, PCFICH), the synchronization signals (PSS, SSS), and
(sometimes) PDSCH
• Not applicable to Reference Symbols s1 Reference Symbol
of Antenna Port 0 Q
s 2*
s* s
s1
s2*
I
Antenna Port 0
…s2, s1 Alamouti s*
encoder Reference Symbol
of Antenna Port 1
s2 Complex
s *
1
conjugate of
symbol s
Antenna Port 1
s2
• For 4 TX antennas transmit diversity scheme is a combination of OSFBC and FSTD (Frequency Shift Transmit Diversity).
- FSTD is applied to preserve orthogonality between symbols
• Transmit diversity schemes are standardized in 3GPP TS 36.211
s1
2x2 4x2
s2*
To balance for channel estimation 0
accuracy 0
• {s1, s2} are transmitted by antenna ports 0 and 2 Antenna Port 0
• {s3, s4} are transmitted by antenna ports 1 and 3
0
0 RS overhead increase
s3
from 9.5% to 14.3%
s4*
Antenna Port 1
• In most
0
cases, EPA,
dual3km/h,
X-polarized antenna
2100MHz, High will be used for 4TX
corr., real CE
10
deployment High correlation: High correlation:
RS1, RS3
RS2 RS0, RS3
RS2
• Co-polarized elements will me more correlated with each other than
cross-polarized
-1 elements
10
BLER
•
-10 -5 0 5
This can be achieved by proper
10 15 20 25
SNR [dB] cabling to the antenna inputs.
FRIG 2.3
Sector1 Sector1
4
x 10 LCR1: Tx4 & Rx4 LCR1: Tx2 & Rx2
4
4x2 TxDiv indirect cabling /\ \/ Sector1 Sector1
4x2 TxDiv direct cabling /\ /\ LCR1: Tx3 & Rx3 LCR1: Tx1 & Rx1
Throughput [Kbits/s]
2
When feeding the Alamouti- 0 s2 0 s1
paired symbols to the x-pol 0 s1* 0 s2*
1 antenna elements some s4 s3
additional gain can be 0 0
extracted s3* 0 s4* 0
0 Antenna Port 3 Antenna Port 2 Antenna Port 1 Antenna Port 0
-10 -5 0 5 10 15 20 25
SNR [dB]
For internal use
36 5/15/2020 © Nokia Solutions and Networks 2013
Technical Details Main Menu
Link Level Performance of Transmit Diversity
0
EPA5, medium correlation 0
EPA5, medium correlation
10 10
• Roughly the same LL performance of Transmit Diversity 2TX, MCS10
4TX MCS10
in 2 or 4 TX case for all channel models
-1
•
10
General trend: 4TX performs slightly better for low order
MCSs (diversity increase)
BLER
BLER
• For high order MCSs 4TX performs worse due to increased
-1 -2
Code Rate caused by larger Cell Reference Signal overhead. 10 10 2TX, MCS0
2TX MCS10
2TX MCS27
4TX, MCS0
• For a given MCS 4TX performs better than 2TX in high SNR -3
4TX MCS10
4TX MCS27
10
and worse in low SNR region. This is caused by worse -3 -2 -1 0 1 2 3 4 -20 -15 -10 -5 0 5 10 15 20 25
normalized noise normalized noise
channel estimation for the extra 2 TX antennas
ETU70, low correlation 0
EPA5, high correlation
0 10
10
-1
-1 10
10
BLER
BLER
Source: 4GMAX simulations -2
2TX, MCS0
-2
10 2TX, MCS0
10
Duplex: FDD 2TX MCS10 2TX MCS10
BW: 10MHz 2TX MCS27 2TX MCS27
4TX, MCS0 4TX, MCS0
allocation size: 6 PRB 4TX MCS10
4TX MCS10
# of PDCCH symbols: 3 4TX MCS27 -3
4TX MCS27
-3 10
10 -20 -15 -10 -5 0 5 10 15 20 25
-20 -15 -10 -5 0 5 10 15 20 25
For internal use normalized noise normalized noise
37 5/15/2020 © Nokia Solutions and Networks 2013
Technical Details Main Menu
PDCCH performance
Req. SINR for Agg., 3 PDCCH symbols, 20MHz BW, UMaNLoS3 channel model
10
2TX 3Sym AGG1
4TX 3Sym AGG1
• PDCCH is transmitted using Transmit Diversity 8 2TX 3Sym AGG2
4TX 3Sym AGG2
2TX 3Sym AGG4
• In case of 4 TX antenna ports the PDCCH transport 6 4TX 3Sym AGG4
2TX 3Sym AGG8
capacity is reduced due to the fact that additional DL 4TX 3Sym AGG8
reference signals needs to be transmitted 4
Req. SINR
• PDCCH with 4 TX antenna ports requires higher (up 2
-2
-4
-8
30 35 40 45 50 55 60 65 70
DCI Payload size
• Higher gain of single codeword 4x2 MIMO over 4x2 TxDiv than 2x2MIMO over 2x2 TxDiv
• Best performing PMI selected for comparison
• Not all PMIs were available, simulations ongoing
~1dB gain
BLER
BLER
-1 -1
10 10
>5dB gain
rrmMimoRi
• Dynamic Adaptive MIMO Switching is legacy MIMO Mode Control in LTE568
• It re-uses the algorithms and parameters developed for LTE703
• System will use single codeword at the cell edge OR in high correlation,
mimoClRiThU
two codewords when in middle to good conditions
Dual Codeword
1. Wideband CQI reported by UE is compensated with OLLA delta (corresponds to BLER):
1 CW: newCqi = CQI + rrmDeltaCqi; 2CWs: newCqi = (CQI1+CQI2)/2 + rrmDeltaCqi
Single/Dual Codeword
2. If RI=2 newCQI is additionally normalized towards single codeword (for RI=2 reported CQI
mimoClRiThD
is lower)
newCqi = newCqi + mimoClCqiComp
Single Codeword
3. CQI (processed) and RI (raw) reports are fed into the averaging filter:
rrmMimoCqi = (1-mimoClCqiAvg)*rrmMimoCqi + mimoClCqiAvg*newCqi
rrmMimoRi = (1-mimoClRiAvg)*rrmMimoRi + mimoClRiAvg*RI
rrmMimoCqi
4. Additionally, a forgetting factor is applied to the rrmMimoCqi and rrmMimoRi in case no mimoClCqiThD mimoClCqiThU
valid reports arrive when expected. This enables automatic downgrade to single
codeword 1CW: rrmMimoCQI ≤ mimoClCqiThD OR
rrmMimoRi ≤ mimoClRiThD
Dynamic Switching algorithm may cause mismatch between the actual
used number of codewords and reported RI. In such case, system 2CW: rrmMimoCQI ≥ mimoClCqiThU AND
doesn’t have a valid PMI, so it will cyclically switch between the rrmMimoRi ≥ mimoClRiThU
available PMIs
For internal use
40 5/15/2020 © Nokia Solutions and Networks 2013
Technical Details Main Menu
MIMO Mode Control: Fast Switching (1/2)
0
EPA, 3km/h, 2100MHz, High corr., real CE
10
-1
10
BLER
-2
introduced with LTE568, but can be used also with LTE703 since 10
BLER degradation in switching region
RL50/RL35 of Dynamic Adaptive algorithms casued
-3
10 by cyclic PMI switching
• eNB will not override UE requests regarding the used number of
codewords and PMI 10
-4
-10 -5 0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40
SNR [dB]
• This allows to avoid cyclic PMI switching which was used with
“Dynamic Adaptive MIMO Switching” when transmission rank was 4
CL 2x2 MIMO
x 10
overridden by the eNB. 8
[7, 8] CQIcomp=0
• LL simulations show that Fast Adaptive algorithm performs best
Throughput [Kbits/s]
6 [7, 8] CQIcomp=4
[0, 15] CQIcomp=0
[5, 10] CQIcomp=0
4 [10, 11] CQIcomp=4
2
Fast Adaptive switching
performs better than 0
Dynamic Adaptive -10 -5 0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40
SNR [dB]
algorithms
• If no valid PMI report arrives from the UE, eNB will use the latest reported PMI
• … for a while…
• After elapsing a certain time from the latest valid PMI report, eNB will switch the transmission mode to 4-way Transmit Diversity to the user in question.
• Single/dual codeword transmission will resume immediately after valid report is received.
• Again, this allows to avoid cyclic PMI switching. Link level simulations show that cyclic PMI switching performs worse than 4-way Transmit Diversity
• System will ensure that TxDiv fallback time is longer than PMI report periodicity
• Two horizontally separated x-pol columns with 0.5 lambda separation are
recommended for 4x2 MIMO deployment
Picture Source:
MIMO and Smart Antennas for Mobile Broadband Systems
4G Americas, October 2012
Amplitude
Flat Power
Spectral Density
Antenna Port 0
• -2dB interference
power level (cell edge
Throughput (kbits/s)
conditions) 1.5
2x2 4x2
• Using MIMO 2x2 with 2 Tx antennas the Cell Reference Signals occupies
16 RE per PRB
• Using MIMO 4x2 with 4 Tx antennas the Cell Reference Signals occupies
24 RE per PRB
• This increase of overhead leads to a slightly reduced downlink
throughput at good radio conditions PDCCH reserved
symbols
• DL throughput reduction is caused by exceeding maximum allowed code DL Peak Throughput, Lab Measurement
10MHz, FDD, single UE
rate for MCS=28. According to 3GPP 36.213 7.1.7 UE may skip
decoding a transport block in an initial transmission if the effective Symbols 2x2 MIMO 4x2 MIMO Gain [%]
channel code rate is >0.930: reserved Peak Throughput Peak Throughput
for PDCCH [Mbps] [Mbps]
number of DL information bits CRC
Effective channel code rate 3 62.6 61.9 -1.1
number of physical channel bits on PDSCH
2 68.25 62.85 -7.9
• Effective coding rate will also depend on number of OFDM symbols 1 72.75 71.05 -2.3
assigned for PDCCH
Source: SyVe report
https://sharenet-
ims.inside.nokiasiemensnetworks.com/Overview/D503332333
Introduction
1 Motivation and Feature Overview 7 Dimensioning Aspects
Dimensioning Impacts and Examples
Deployment Aspects
6 Activation, Configuration Examples, Fault Mgmt, Trial Area
LTE 72
4-way Rx diversity
Introduction
1 Motivation and Feature Overview 7 Dimensioning Aspects
Dimensioning Impacts and Examples
Deployment Aspects
6 Activation, Configuration Examples, Fault Mgmt, Trial Area
Source:
RL50 CL MIMO 4x2 / 4-RX Demo
https://sharenet-ims.inside.nokiasiemensnetworks.com/Overview/D499741383
Source:
RL50 CL MIMO 4x2 / 4-RX Demo
For internal use
https://sharenet-ims.inside.nokiasiemensnetworks.com/Overview/D499741383
55 5/15/2020 © Nokia Solutions and Networks 2013
Benefits and Gains Main Menu
FiVe Wroclaw test
Source:
•Test setup: FIVE feature test report
•RL35 TDD release https://sharenet-ims.inside.nokiasiemensnetworks.com/Overview/D502519122
•1 eNB for not HO related tests (FSMF + 2xFZNI)
• tests were done on isolated cell without interferences
• eNB SW LNT3.0_1304_080_00
• Bandwidth 20MHz, 3 cells configured
• 10W per carrier in case of 2x2MIMO and 4x2MIMO
•UE – 10xQuanta 1K31, firmware 20130426_1KQCI_4036_M0.10
•Aperiodic reporting type 3-1 (single PMI)
•2x2 MIMO setup still configured to use 4-way Rx Diversity (test is
not influenced by UL coverage change)
•No RS boosting applied
Test route
Mirror cabling used
Site
6000000
4x2MIMO Dynamic Switching 5.95 39.7
5000000
t-put [bps]
2000000
1000000
0
0 5 10 15 20
Time [s]
2x2 OL MIMO
Only normal user traffic was verified. There were no specific test UEs in use. 4x2 CL MIMO 3dB comp.
Wrapped-around scenario
Parameter Value
UE speed (km/h) 3
indoor penetration loss 20 dB MIMO switching threshold, up 13 (15 dB) Dynamic MIMO switch
thresholds optimized for
MIMO switching threshold, down 10.4 (10 dB) TM4 simulation scenario
Product release RL50
MIMO rank threshold, up 1.7
max MCS DL: MCS28
MIMO rank threshold, down 1.3
max # UEs per TTI 10
0.9
0.8
MIMO mode Mean Cell Gain over 2x2 Fast Switch Gain 0.7
Throughput
0.6
probability
2x2, dyn. switch 14.5 Mbps --- ---
0.5
2x2, fast switch 15 Mbps --- 3.4% (vs. 2x2 dynamic 0.4
switching)
0.3
4x2, dyn. switch 16.1 Mbps 11% (vs. 2x2 dynamic ---
switching) 0.2 2x2 dynamic switch
2x2 fast switch
4x2, fast switch 16.7 Mbps 15.2% (vs. 2x2 3.8% (vs. 4x2 dynamic 0.1 4x2 dynamic switch
dynamic switching) switching)
4x2 fast switch
0
0 0.5 1 1.5 2 2.5 3
kbits per second 4
x 10
• 35..40% cell edge per UE throughput (5th percentile) improvement of 4x2 MIMO over 2x2MIMO
• Fast MIMO switching causes negligible loss for UEs at the cell edge
UE Throughput Distribution
0.1
0.09
0.08
MIMO mode Cell Edge UE Gain over 2x2 Fast Switch Gain 0.07
Throughput
0.06
probability
2x2, dyn. switch 337 kbps --- ---
0.05
2x2, fast switch 330 kbps --- -2% (vs. 2x2 dynamic 0.04
switching)
0.03
4x2, dyn. switch 457 kbps 35.6% (vs. 2x2 ---
dynamic switching) 0.02 2x2 dynamic switch
2x2 fast switch
4x2, fast switch 452 kbps 34% (vs. 2x2 dynamic -1.1% (vs. 4x2 dynamic 0.01 4x2 dynamic switch
switching) switching)
4x2 fast switch
0
0 100 200 300 400 500 600 700
Compare with 34%, 1..2% fast switching kbits per second
38% cell edge gain loss also observed
of 4x2 field trials with FiVe trial
For internal use
66 5/15/2020 © Nokia Solutions and Networks 2013
Benefits and Gains Main Menu
MCS improvement
probability
MIMO mode Mean MCS 5th percentile 0.5
MCS 0.4
2x2, dyn. switch 15 6
0.3
2x2, fast switch 15.2 5 0.2
Introduction
1 Motivation and Feature Overview 7 Dimensioning Aspects
Dimensioning Impacts and Examples
Deployment Aspects
6 Activation, Configuration Examples, Fault Mgmt, Trial Area
* - purpose: categories of parameters have been defined to simplify network parameterization. Parameterization effort shall be focused mainly on parameters included
in basic category. Categorization will be reflected in a ‘view’ definition in NetAct CM Editor (planned in RL60) i.e. parameters will be displayed according to the
category: either in the ‘Basic parameters’ view or the ‘Advanced parameters’ view.
• Modified parameter
dlMimoMode Downlink MIMO mode
Object: LNCEL Parameter selects cell specific downlink transmission
Range: SingleTX (0), 2-way TXDiv (10), 4-way mode set. Each physical channel (PBCH, PSS, SSS,
TXDiv (11), Static Open Loop MIMO (2x2) PDSCH, PDCCH, etc.) will be transmitted using a specific
(20), Dynamic Open Loop MIMO (2x2) (30), transmission mode. Transmission mode adaptation for
Closed Loop MIMO (2x2) (40), Closed DSCH is also predefined within the parameter setting.
Loop MIMO (4x2) (41), Single Stream
Beamforming (50), Dual Stream
Beamforming (60) See slide 30 for details
Step: -
Default: 2-way TXDiv (10)
Multiplicity: 1
Unit: enum
Category: BASIC
• New parameter
actFastTmSwitch Activate fast adaptive MIMO switch
Object: LNCEL Enables 'Fast Adaptive MIMO Switching' for Closed Loop
Range: [true, false] MIMO modes based on PMI/RI reports sent by UEs if
actFastMimoSwitch is set to 'TRUE'.
Step: -
'Fast Adaptive MIMO Switching' supports fast rank selection
Default: false and fast codebook based precoding of data transmission
Multiplicity: 1 using closed loop feedback of precoding matrix indicator
Unit: bool (PMI) in combination with rank indicator (RI).
Category: ADVANCED Enables 'Dynamic MIMO Switching' if actFastMimoSwitch is
set to 'FALSE'.
'Dynamic MIMO Switching' supports RI and CQI based rank
selection after filtering of CQI and RI reports sent by the UE.
• Feature LTE568 (Downlink Adaptive Closed Loop MIMO (4x2)) is activated on cell level
• Feature activation requires object locking
• To activate, 4 TX antennas must be configured in LNCEL-resourceList
• LNCEL-dlMimoMode must be set to Closed Loop MIMO (4x2)
• LNCEL-prachHsFlag must be set to false – LTE48 Support of high speed users not supported
• BTSSCL-rfSharingEnabled must be set to false – LTE447 and LTE435 RF sharing features not supported
• LNBTS-actDLCAggr must be set to false – LTE10889 Downlink carrier aggregation not supported
• LNCEL-actRepeaterMode must be set to none – LTE1159 Repeater Interface Unit not supported
• LNCEL-actSuperCell must be set to false – LTE993 or LTE1542 Supercell features must be disabled
• LNBTS-actDualBand must be set to false – LTE179 Dual Band with One System Module must be disabled
Introduction
1 Motivation and Feature Overview 7 Dimensioning Aspects
Dimensioning Impacts and Examples
Deployment Aspects
6 Activation, Configuration Examples, Fault Mgmt, Trial Area
• Future-proof deployment (RFM and antenna can support 4x4 MIMO when supporting UEs
become available)
LCR3: Tx4 & LCR2: Tx4 & LCR1: Tx4 & 1+1+1N(BW 5MHz and 10Mhz) Sector2
Rx4 Rx4 Rx4 BF Ant Ant An Ant
4 3 t2 1
Cal
FRHC
• Parameters to select desired CQI/PMI reporting mode System will select PMI-enabled reporting
• cqiAperMode automatically for CL MIMO modes
• periodicCqiFeedbackType
PMI Feedback Type
Single Multiple
No PMI PMI PMI
Mode 2-
UE Selected 0 Mode 2-2
(subband CQI)
Feedback Type
PUCCH CQI
Wideband Mode 1-0 Mode 1-1
(wideband CQI)
• To configure Cell Reference Symbol Power Boosting, select proper value from
the drop-down list
Introduction
1 Motivation and Feature Overview 7 Dimensioning Aspects
Dimensioning Impacts and Examples
Configuration Management
5 Parameters and Parameterisation scenarios
Deployment Aspects
6 Activation, Configuration Examples, Fault Mgmt, Trial Area
Features
DL Adaptive CL MIMO (2Tx)
DL Adaptive CL MIMO (4Tx)
TRUE
FALSE
FALSE
TRUE
This slide shows workaround how to
DL Power Boosting FALSE FALSE obtain correct results. RAN Dim
Reference Signal Power Boost [dB] 3.00 3.00
4 way Rx Diversity TRUE TRUE update with new 4TX link level data is
Tx antenna power [dBm]
Transmitting End DL
46.02
UL
24.00
DL
43.01
UL
24.00
pending, after implementation this
Total Tx Power Increase [dB]
User EIRP [dBm]
3.01
69.63
-
24.00
6.02
69.63
-
24.00
workaround will no longer be
Receiving end DL UL DL UL required.
Antenna Gain [dBi] 0.00 21.00 0.00 21.00
Noise Figure [dB] 7.00 2.20 7.00 2.20
Body Loss [dB] 0.00 - 0.00 - RAN Dim models Closed Loop Single CW by
Additional Gains [dB] 0.00 0.00 4.00 0.00
shifting the respective TX Diversity link level data
Channel DL UL DL UL by the amount resulting from the Precoding Gain.
Channel Model
Enhanced Pedestrian Enhanced Pedestrian From link level simulations we know that while it’s
A 5 Hz A 5 Hz
Antenna Configuration 2Tx-2Rx 1Tx-4Rx 4Tx-2Rx 1Tx-4Rx
1dB for 2x2 1CW MIMO, it is 5dB for 4x2 MIMO
Tx/Rx Algorithm at eNB CL TxDiv (with PMI) MRC CL TxDiv (with PMI) MRC
Frequency scheduler Channel aware Channel aware Channel aware Channel aware
Precoding Gain [dB] 1.00 - 1.00 -
Required SINR @ BLER10% [reference] [dB] -5.23 -2.68 -3.03 -2.68
Coding Rate Offset [dB] 0.37 0.31 0.39 0.31
Required SINR at Cell Edge [dB] -6.47 -4.37 -4.25 -4.37
…since Precoding Gain field is not editable, enter
Receiver Sensitivity [dBm] -103.86 -116.56 -101.64 -116.56 the difference between 2x2 and 4x2 precoding
Maximum Allowable Path Loss(clutter not considered) [dB] 172 160 174 160 gains: 4dB
DL Reference Signal Received Power [dBm] -133.65 -121.32 -138.44 -124.33
Site count DL UL DL UL
Cell Range [km] 1.38 0.73 1.55 0.73
Cell Area [sqkm] 1.24 0.34 1.57 0.35
Site Area [sqkm] 3.73 1.03 4.71 1.04
Inter Site Distance [km] 2.07 1.09 2.33 1.10 Now there are gains in DL for LTE568. However, Link
Deployment area [sqkm] 50.00 50.00
Budget is UL limited.
Site Count For internal use 14 49 11 48
86 5/15/2020 © Nokia Solutions and Networks 2013
Dimensioning Aspects Main Menu
LTE568 – DL Adaptive Closed Loop MIMO (4x2)
• Higher spectral efficiency compared to LTE703 DL Adaptive Closed Loop MIMO (2x2) allows for
achieving higher DL throughput. This is reflected in the RAN Dim tool by corresponding spectral
efficiency gains
ISD [m]
2Tx OL MIMO 2Tx CL MIMO 4Tx CL MIMO 8Tx SS-LTBF 8Tx DS-HBF Gain of 4xTX vs.
Gains in the Mode 3 Mode 4 Mode 4 Mode 7 Mode 8
table are given 2xTX MIMO
with respect to
500 20% 30% 56% 34% 64% 20%
1TX
configuration 1732 16% 24% 39% 28% 56% 12%
3000 10% 15% 32% 18% 45% 15%
Spectral efficiency gains used by RAN dim tool are based on simulation Newest version of the
RAN Dim tool can be
results, not measurements. Real spectral efficiency gains may differ.
found here
Introduction
1 Motivation and Feature Overview 7 Dimensioning Aspects
Dimensioning Impacts and Examples
Deployment Aspects
6 Activation, Configuration Examples, Fault Mgmt, Trial Area
• LTE568 DL Adaptive Closed Loop MIMO (4x2) alone does not provide site count reduction since network is limited by UL coverage:
Site count DL UL DL UL
Cell Range [km] 1.38 0.73 1.55 0.73 Example from
Site layout 3 Sectors<=90° 3 Sectors<=90°
Number of Cells per Site 3.00 3.00 3.00 3.00 Dimensioning Aspects
Cell Area [sqkm] 1.24 0.34 1.57 0.35
Site Area [sqkm] 3.73 1.03 4.71 1.04
slide. Gains depend on
Inter Site Distance [km] 2.07 1.09 2.33 1.10 the assumptions
Deployment area [sqkm] 50.00 50.00
Site Count 14 49 11 48
3dB per pipe power reduction made possible by LTE568, but 2x more active pipes still require additional power.
This power demand increase cannot be compensated by the 15% average throughput gain that feature offers.
Introduction
1 Motivation and Feature Overview 7 Dimensioning Aspects
Dimensioning Impacts and Examples
Deployment Aspects
6 Activation, Configuration Examples, Fault Mgmt, Trial Area
Introduction
1 Motivation and Feature Overview 7 Dimensioning Aspects
Dimensioning Impacts and Examples
Deployment Aspects
6 Activation, Configuration Examples, Fault Mgmt, Trial Area
• 3GPP 36.306, 4.1 specifies maximum number of supported layers for spatial multiplexing
• Category 1 UEs can be scheduled with 4-way Transmit Diversity or single layer TM4
Table 4.1-1: Downlink physical layer parameter values set by the field ue-Category
rdTm4TxDivEnable: TRUE – switching to Transmit Diversity in TM4 in case of missing closed loop feedback of CSI reported by the UE
rdTm4TxDivFallbackTime shall have a value greater than the reporting period configured by O&M parameter 'cqiPerNp' for Periodic
Reporting. (Note: Default parameter for cqiPerNp is 20 ms). Thereby fallback to TxDiversity shall not occur in case periodic RI and PMI
reports are received at eNB without errors and containing valid rank and PMI data.
rdMimoCqiAgeingDrx, rdMimoCqiAgeing
When wideband CQI is not received in a reporting instance where a wideband CQI is expected to be received AND rrmMimoCqi >
mimoClCqiThD, the filter rrmMimoCqi is updated using an ageing factor as follows:
IF (drxLongEnable == TRUE),
rrmMimoCqi = max (mimoClCqiThD, rdMimoCqiAgeingDrx ^ rounddown(delta_t/10) * rrmMimoCqi)
ELSE
rrmMimoCqi = max (mimoClCqiThD, rdMimoCqiAgeing ^ rounddown(delta_t/10) * rrmMimoCqi)
rdMimoRiAgeingDrx, rdMimoRiAgeing
When RI is not received in a reporting instance where RI is expected to be received AND rrmMimoRi > mimoClRiThD, the filter rrmMimoRi
is updated using an ageing factor as follows:
IF (drxLongEnable == TRUE),
rrmMimoRi = max (mimoClRiThD, rdMimoRiAgeingDrx ^ rounddown(delta_t/10) * rrmMimoRi)
ELSE
rrmMimoRi = max (mimoClRiThD, rdMimoRiAgeing ^ rounddown(delta_t/10) * rrmMimoRi)
If “Dynamic MIMO Switching” is desired, LNCEL-actFastMimoSwitch must be set to false. Additionally, if “Dynamic MIMO Switching” is
desired, following averaging filter constant parameters must be configured:
(hidden) LNBTS-mimoClCqiAvg
(hidden) LNBTS-mimoClRiAvg