Advantages and Disadvantages: Structure
Advantages and Disadvantages: Structure
Advantages and Disadvantages: Structure
Structure
7.1 E- Procurement
In a fully web-enabled e-procurement system, each step in the procurement process occurs
electronically. From creating and submitting POs to receiving and paying for goods—all transactional
data is automatically routed through workflow processors, reducing the time and cost of procurement
activities, and boosting operational efficiency of the e-enabled organization.
E-procurement is done with a software application that includes features for supplier management and
complex auctions. The new generation of E-Procurement is now on-demand or a software-as-a-service.
The e-procurement value chain consists of Indent Management, e- tendering, e-Auctioning, Vendor
Management, Catalogue Management, and Contract Management. Indent Management is the
workflow involved in the preparation of tenders. This part of the value chain is optional, with
individual procuring departments defining their indenting process. In works procurement,
administrative approval and technical sanction are obtained in electronic format. In goods
procurement, indent generation activity is done online. The end result of the stage is taken as inputs for
issuing the NIT.
Advantages include getting the right product, from the right supplier to the right buyer, at the right
time, for the right price and the right quantity. In reality e-procurement has the advantage of taking
supply chain management to the next level, providing real time information to the vendor as to the
status of a customer’s needs. For example, a vendor may have an agreement with a customer to
automatically ship materials when the customer’s stock level reaches a low point, thus bypassing the
need for the customer to ask for it. A major disadvantage to this type of agreement could be that the
vendor has the power to take advantage of the customer by knowing more information about the
customer than they would have if the customer was in a normal supply chain management structure.
Unlike enterprise resource planning (ERP) systems that enable businesses to automate their internal
processes, e-procurement enables widely dispersed buyers and suppliers to come together, interact, and
execute purchase transactions directly over the Internet.
⃰How E-Procurement
works
:
In spite of many variations, the most common e-procurement model involves an intermediary service
provider or a host who links buyers and sellers in an interconnected supply chain using a web based e-
procurement application. The host manages transactions, facilitates communication, aggregates and
maintains catalog content, and provides the general infrastructure for the virtual marketplace.
Through this network, buyers may compare products from multiple suppliers in a single electronic
catalog or check on an item’s price and availability in real time before electronically creating a PO.
Once a PO is approved, also electronically, it’s sent to the supplier via the host’s Web portal
This same Web portal enables suppliers to automatically return real time PO status. After an order
ships, buyers can process tracking and receiving functions right from their workstations. Creating an
invoice and authorizing payment is handled electronically through the same portal as well !
Beyond merely automating shipping and receiving tasks, however, e-procurement offers far more
process improvements and innovative options for streamlining business operations and maximizing
strategic initiatives-procurement enables access to global . suppliers, real time communication between
buyers and suppliers, electronic payment of invoices, and assignment of logistics freight rating and
routing.
E-procurement has also spawned creative new business models such as auctions for suppliers to sell
excess inventory, reverse auctions where suppliers bid to fulfill a buyer’s order, and trade exchanges
where buyers and sellers simultaneously bid for each other’s business
0
7.2 COMPONENTS OF AN E-PROCUREMENT SYSTEM
Though still in its nascent stage, e-procurement has been able to develop its own body of language and
as such regardless of its model, each has similar components that must be properly considered and
managed to ensure a successful system. These components include Catalog content, Processes, User
maintenance, Establishing buyer/seller relationships, Billing management, Price establishment, Data
transmission, and System maintenance.
Catalogue content
At the heart of every e-procurement process lies an electronic catalog. Similar to a traditional mail-
order catalog, electronic catalogs contain detailed information on products or services available for
sale. Suppliers customize the content to address the specific needs of targeted buyers. This content is
manipulated and imported into a database that the e-procurement application integrates into web pages
The management of catalog data can be handled using import and aggregation tools or by outsourcing
the task to companies specializing in content management. Content providers generally offer the
following services:
There are three types of catalogues that address various buyer needs :
• Product catalogs: Contain data on tangible items such as office products, medical supplies, rolls of
steel, etc.
• Service catalogs: Offer professional service “intangibles” such as office maintenance services,
temporary personnel services, etc.
• Commodity-specific catalogs: Offer specific product families or groups such as chemicals, paper,
or other raw materials
Note that an effective e-procurement platform must support both the buyer’s and the supplier’s
business processes. It should also offer functionality that can easily be customized and configured to
meet specific e-procurement requirements. In general, a successful e-procurement solution will be
founded on an open, component-based model that offers easy configurability and scalability.
Closely related to the two preceding process management components, user maintenance includes
defining the individuals authorized to use the e-procurement system, how these users will be enrolled,
and how to provide them access to the trading community. This component serves as the foundation
for managing the complex buyer-supplier relationships that will occur within the marketplace.
Establish user profiles, access rules, catalog filters, and workflow Allow for unique pricing and
contractual relationships between a buyer and supplier The following steps are vital to successful user
management:
Creating the buyer organization: Identifying and defining the individual buyers, how they will form
buying groups, and how they will access the e-procurement process Creating the supplier organization:
Identifying sellers, maintaining company profiles, and creating shipping options and other high-level
parameters for supplier activities E-procurement organization: Aggregating the entire marketplace,
including buyer and supplier, to include such things as hours of operation, billing rates, etc.
Additionally, user maintenance requires establishing authorization levels and associated procedures to
precisely govern buyer and supplier capabilities. Three authorization levels that must be addressed are:
Access to the electronic catalog: Defines who may access catalogs and how to do so Creating and
editing requisitions: Defines who can create requisitions, who can edit requisitions, and who can edit
accounting codes
Managing orders: Defines who has access to POs and who has authorization to override shipping or
billing information
This component has two phases: managing supplier relationships and managing pricing. Buyers and
sellers may be linked based on their previous buying relationship or based on the buyer’s unique needs.
Buyers may make purchases based on negotiated contracts or choose the specific commodities they
need from customized catalogs. Price lists too may be customized for a buyer or buying group. For
example, prices may be established by adding filters that dynamically calculate a price as a markup or
discount of the list price. Or groups of buyers may be categorized into classes with filters applied for
each group.
Billing Management
E-procurement revenues are generally based on transaction fees. A billing management system will
calculate usage charges and generate and distribute statements or invoices to buyer-seller members of
the e-procurement network. Suppliers may also use the billing system to calculate ordering charges or
to distribute operating costs for specific orders. These functions must directly interface with back
office invoicing systems to automatically generate bills.
Price Establishment
Effective pricing enables buyers to negotiate the best possible deals and sellers to liquidate excess
inventory. Two major pricing options are used: Dynamic Pricing and Fixed Pricing.
Dynamic pricing: Allows buyers and sellers in an Internet market to trade goods and services at prices
determined by market forces instead of by a predetermined price list or catalog. An example of
dynamic pricing includes business services such as auctions, reverse auctions, and exchanges Fixed
pricing: Based on a predetermined price list or catalog prices negotiated between a buyer and seller
7.5 DATA TRANSMISSION
Transmitting data over the Internet involves two facets: messaging agents and security. Data and
messaging tools enable the Internet-based exchange of transactional data between different buyers and
suppliers in the e-procurement marketplace. To do this, transactions are sent via the Internet as
“messages” and then integrated into a supplier’s or buyer’s back-office system, enabling financial
postings that coincide with the receipt, payment, and invoicing processes. Data messaging tools are
also used to cancel transactions and log failures when messages can’t be delivered within a predefined
time period or following a specified number of attempts. The most important aspect of the messaging
tool is that it enables real-time communication between buyers and sellers.
System Management
Once an e-procurement system is up and running, it’s important to monitor traffic and system
securityon a day-to-day basis. Inadequately designed transaction engines can result in poor
marketplace performance, lack of scalability, breakdowns in security, and, ultimately, frustrated users.
3. Create and approve requisition: A paper requisition with correct item numbers and prices needs to
be created and approved, a process that often takes up to 3 days or more.
4. Generate and approve P.O. : Once the requisition is approved, the purchasing department splits the
requisition into several purchase orders because the material requested must be supplied by multiple
vendors.
5. Send P.O. to vendor: Purchase orders are eventually mailed or faxed to the vendors.
6. Vendor confirmation: The vendors confirm receipt of the purchase orders and promise delivery
within three business days.
Typically, the promised delivery date ranges from 5-7 business days from the time the requisition is
initially filled out. In the interim, our enterprising sales representative, knowing the delays and
accompanying frustrations of the company’s purchasing process, has decided to buy the items at a
local office supply superstore. This way, the representative acquires the necessary equipment without
delay and with a lot less effort. Unfortunately, the company’s cost for paying retail price is much
higher than necessary.
The benefits of e-procurement over manual purchasing are many and multifaceted. For example:
Streamlined processes reduce transaction time: Buyers can search electronic catalogs containing goods
and services from multiple suppliers and compare products and prices on-line. Real time
communication allows buyers to check current prices and quantities. Suppliers can provide instant PO
status
The benefits of e-procurement over manual purchasing are many and multifaceted. For example:
Streamlined processes reduce transaction time: Buyers can search electronic catalogs containing goods
and services from multiple suppliers and compare products and prices on-line. Real time
communication allows buyers to check current prices and quantities. Suppliers can provide instant PO
status
The benefits of e-procurement over manual purchasing are many and multifaceted. For example:
Streamlined processes reduce transaction time: Buyers can search electronic catalogs containing goods
and services from multiple suppliers and compare products and prices on-line. Real time
communication allows buyers to check current prices and quantities. Suppliers can provide instant PO
status
The benefits of e-procurement over manual purchasing are many and multifaceted. For example:
Streamlined processes reduce transaction time: Buyers can search electronic catalogs containing goods
and services from multiple suppliers and compare products and prices on-line. Real time
communication allows buyers to check current prices and quantities. Suppliers can provide instant PO
status.
Greater access to suppliers: Using virtual e-procurement portals, buyers have access to suppliers
around the globe, which translates into a wider selection of goods and services
Global operability: E-procurement applications can support multiple languages and currencies, as well
as international financing, taxation, and shipping regulations
Ease of configurability and scalability: Web-based procurement applications can be configured to meet
the unique needs of buyers and sellers and be scaled to grow as the organizations grow.
Building of trading communities: E-procurement allows the development of both horizontal and
vertical trading communities offering consolidated buying power for the purchaser and increased range
for new supply chains.
Lower costs: Cost efficiency results from a variety of factors including reduced time between order
creation and order fulfillment, greater selection of goods and services from which to choose, formation
of trading communities to consolidate buying power, the opportunity to purchase surplus products and
services below market prices, and more !
Increased productivity: Automated procurement processes can yield significant time savings at all
levels across an enterprise, increasing opportunities for employees to focus on more strategically
important tasks and functions.
Spot discounts: Because of the dynamic nature of on-line pricing, vendors can offer limited-time spot
discounts on excess inventory. Even a one-percent reduction in purchasing expenses can yield
significant savings for large organizations.
By far, the greatest e-procurement savings result from the combination of less time required for the
total purchasing cycle and the subsequent reduced transaction costs. Together, these decreased
transactional factors translate into significant cost savings.
The table below shows the approximate time it takes to complete each step in a single corporate
purchasing cycle, comparing manual or electronic data interchange (EDI) purchases to e-procurement.
This Table demonstrates nearly fivefold reduction in time and nearly 80% reduction in cost directly
attributable to e-procurement.
E-procurement Offers Tremendous Opportunity to Save Both Now project your own potential e-
procurement benefit by multiplying the Per Purchase Savings rate by the number of purchase orders
your own organization processes in a single year. Depending on the size of your enterprise, e-
procurement savings could amount to millions of dollars annually. For suppliers, e-procurement stands
to yield significant reductions in inventory holding times and safety stock levels, and an overall
reduction in the purchasing cycle—the time it takes from ordering an item to receiving it.
While e-procurement offers many quantifiable benefits, it still poses many issues that must be carefully
considered before implementing a specific solution. Effectively addressing these issues will help
ensure both a rapid and a complete implementation—one that will help your organization realize all
the benefits of e-procurement, including a lower initial system investment and an increased return on
your investment.
Consider these questions before you choose an e-procurement solution or provider, and consider how
your answers will help you minimize the risks and maximize the rewards of your new system:
Do you already have an e-commerce strategy? How will e-procurement integrate into that strategy? If
you don’t have an e-commerce strategy in place, how can you build one that will support e-
procurement as well as all future e-commerce activities?
How will your current supplier relationships need to change to maximize the e-procurement solution?
What strategies must be developed to build and maintain those relationships?
Is your business model aligned with your system model? Where are the gaps and how can they be
closed?
How can I create a scalable infrastructure that will support future growth?
Factors driving this growth include the number of buyers and suppliers participating, increased
accessibility to authorized users throughout an organization, improvements in Internet e-commerce
software, and organizational growth.
This translates into increased transaction volume that can easily overwhelm the capacity of an e-
procurement system. Will your current infrastructure support e-procurement?
Is your hardware configuration scalable to support additional servers, processors, and an increase in
transactional volume? Note that e-procurement software must be object-based to support the addition
of custom or third party applications, as well as easy integration with your current back office systems,
as the needs of your marketplace change.
With the recent proliferation of proven, commercial e-procurement applications, there’s no need to
build your own. However, consider the following factors when choosing your own solution:
Does the application take advantage of your organization’s current Internet environment?
Does the e-procurement application provide ease of configurability and scalability? How secure is
the data going across the Internet?
How easily will the e-procurement solution integrate with your existing back-office ERP or legacy
systems?
What support is provided to bring suppliers on board, as per the requirement of the situation ?
Does system administration lend itself to adding and changing routine system information on users,
bill-to and ship-to addresses, cost centers and organizational attributes, suppliers and related
information?
Does it support extended business services such as auctions, reverse auctions, and exchanges?
Does it support value-added services such as bill payment, logistics, and taxation? Will the vendor
provide regular updates and software support?