Evaluating A College Essay Rubric For Exam

Download as docx, pdf, or txt
Download as docx, pdf, or txt
You are on page 1of 2

Evaluating a College Essay Rubric

EXCEED MEETS EXPECTATION NEEDS INADEQUATE


EXPECTATION IMPROVEMENT
CRITERIA/SCALE SCORE
1 2 3 4
Structure  Paper is  Paper has a  There is some  There is no
• Organization logically clear level of apparent
• Flow of thought organized organizational organization organization to
• Transitions  Easily followed structure with though the paper.
• Format  Effective, some digressions,  Difficult to
smooth, and digressions, ambiguities, follow
logical ambiguities or irrelevances  No or poor
transitions irrelevances are too many transitions
 Professional  Easily followed  Difficult to  No format
format  Basic follow
transitions  Ineffective
 Structured transitions
format  Rambling
format
Grammar/mechanic  Manipulates  Uses complex  Uses  Uses simple
s complex sentences compound sentences
• sentence structure sentences for  Few sentences
• punctuation/ effect/impact punctuation or  Too many
mechanics  No punctuation mechanical punctuation
or mechanical errors and/or
errors mechanical
errors
Language  Vocabulary is  Vocabulary is  Vocabulary is  Vocabulary is
• Vocabulary; use of sophisticated varied, used properly unsophisticate
vocabulary and correct as specific and though d, not used
• Tone are sentences appropriate sentences properly in
which vary in  Frequently may be very simple
structure and uses subject simple sentences.
length specific  Infrequently  Uses subject
 Uses and vocabulary uses subject specific
manipulate correctly specific vocabulary
subject specific  Writer’s tone vocabulary too sparingly
vocabulary for emerges and correctly
effect is generally  Writer’s tone
 Writer’s tone is appropriate to exhibits some
clear, audience level of
consistent and audience
appropriate for sensitivity
intended
audience
Content/information  Central idea is  Central idea  The central  Central idea
 Clarity of purpose well developed and clarity of idea is and clarity of
 Critical and original and clarity purpose are expressed purpose are
thought purpose is generally through it absent or
 Use of examples exhibited evident may be vague incompletely
throughout the throughout or too broad; and
paper the essay Some sense maintained
 Abundance of  Evidence of of purpose is  Little or no
evidence of critical careful maintained evidence of
critical, careful thought and throughout critical,
thought and analysis the essay careful
analysis and/or and/or insight  Some thought or
insight  There are evidence of analysis
 Evidence and good, relevant critical, and/or insight
examples are supporting careful  There are too
vivid and examples and thought few, no
specific,while evidence analysis examples and
focus remains and/or insight evidence of
tight  There are they are
some mostly
examples of irrelevant
evidence,
though
general
TOTAL:
POINT SYSTEM:

1.0 – 1.5 EXCELLENT

1.5 – 2.0 VERY GOOD

2.0 – 2.5 GOOD

2.5 – 3.0 FAIR (3.0 is Passing)

3.1 – BELOW - FAILED

You might also like