This rubric evaluates college essays on four criteria: structure, grammar/mechanics, language, and content/information. For each criterion, the rubric describes the characteristics of essays that exceed expectations, meet expectations, need improvement, or are inadequate. Essays are given a total score between 1 and 4 points, with lower scores indicating better performance. The rubric provides a framework to assess essays in a standardized way and provide feedback to students.
This rubric evaluates college essays on four criteria: structure, grammar/mechanics, language, and content/information. For each criterion, the rubric describes the characteristics of essays that exceed expectations, meet expectations, need improvement, or are inadequate. Essays are given a total score between 1 and 4 points, with lower scores indicating better performance. The rubric provides a framework to assess essays in a standardized way and provide feedback to students.
This rubric evaluates college essays on four criteria: structure, grammar/mechanics, language, and content/information. For each criterion, the rubric describes the characteristics of essays that exceed expectations, meet expectations, need improvement, or are inadequate. Essays are given a total score between 1 and 4 points, with lower scores indicating better performance. The rubric provides a framework to assess essays in a standardized way and provide feedback to students.
This rubric evaluates college essays on four criteria: structure, grammar/mechanics, language, and content/information. For each criterion, the rubric describes the characteristics of essays that exceed expectations, meet expectations, need improvement, or are inadequate. Essays are given a total score between 1 and 4 points, with lower scores indicating better performance. The rubric provides a framework to assess essays in a standardized way and provide feedback to students.
Download as DOCX, PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
Download as docx, pdf, or txt
You are on page 1of 2
Evaluating a College Essay Rubric
EXCEED MEETS EXPECTATION NEEDS INADEQUATE
EXPECTATION IMPROVEMENT CRITERIA/SCALE SCORE 1 2 3 4 Structure Paper is Paper has a There is some There is no • Organization logically clear level of apparent • Flow of thought organized organizational organization organization to • Transitions Easily followed structure with though the paper. • Format Effective, some digressions, Difficult to smooth, and digressions, ambiguities, follow logical ambiguities or irrelevances No or poor transitions irrelevances are too many transitions Professional Easily followed Difficult to No format format Basic follow transitions Ineffective Structured transitions format Rambling format Grammar/mechanic Manipulates Uses complex Uses Uses simple s complex sentences compound sentences • sentence structure sentences for Few sentences • punctuation/ effect/impact punctuation or Too many mechanics No punctuation mechanical punctuation or mechanical errors and/or errors mechanical errors Language Vocabulary is Vocabulary is Vocabulary is Vocabulary is • Vocabulary; use of sophisticated varied, used properly unsophisticate vocabulary and correct as specific and though d, not used • Tone are sentences appropriate sentences properly in which vary in Frequently may be very simple structure and uses subject simple sentences. length specific Infrequently Uses subject Uses and vocabulary uses subject specific manipulate correctly specific vocabulary subject specific Writer’s tone vocabulary too sparingly vocabulary for emerges and correctly effect is generally Writer’s tone Writer’s tone is appropriate to exhibits some clear, audience level of consistent and audience appropriate for sensitivity intended audience Content/information Central idea is Central idea The central Central idea Clarity of purpose well developed and clarity of idea is and clarity of Critical and original and clarity purpose are expressed purpose are thought purpose is generally through it absent or Use of examples exhibited evident may be vague incompletely throughout the throughout or too broad; and paper the essay Some sense maintained Abundance of Evidence of of purpose is Little or no evidence of critical careful maintained evidence of critical, careful thought and throughout critical, thought and analysis the essay careful analysis and/or and/or insight Some thought or insight There are evidence of analysis Evidence and good, relevant critical, and/or insight examples are supporting careful There are too vivid and examples and thought few, no specific,while evidence analysis examples and focus remains and/or insight evidence of tight There are they are some mostly examples of irrelevant evidence, though general TOTAL: POINT SYSTEM: