Minutes of 185TH Seiaa Meeting

185 th Meeting of SEIAA
SEIAA Meeting number: 185 Meeting Date January 10, 2020

Subject: Environment Clearance for Proposed Amendment & Expansion in Environmental Clearance for Residential
project “Raheja Residency”.
Is a Violation Case: No
1.Name of Project “Raheja Residency”

2.Type of institution Private
3.Name of Project Proponent FERANI HOTELS PVT. LTD.
4.Name of Consultant Mahabal Enviro Engineers Pvt. Ltd. Dr. D. A. Patil;
5.Type of project Residential Project
6.New project/expansion in existing
project/modernization/diversification Amendment & Expansion
9
in existing project
7.If expansion/diversification,
92
whether environmental clearance
Earlier EC received vide letter No. SEIAA-EC-0000000315 dated 17.05.2018
has been obtained for existing
project
02
8.Location of the project C.T.S. No. 827A/1A & 827A/2, Malad (East), Mumbai, Maharashtra
9.Taluka Borivali
0
10.Village Malad
00
Correspondence Name: Ferani Hotels Pvt. Ltd.
Room Number: 623
Floor: Second Floor
00
Building Name: Construction House - B
Road/Street Name: Linking Road
S-
Locality: Opposite Khar Telephone Exchange, Khar

City: Mumbai - 400052
TE
11.Whether in Corporation /
Municipal Corporation of Greater Mumbai (MCGM)
Municipal / other area
IOD/CC obtained
U
IOD/IOA/Concession/Plan Approval Number: CHE/7128/BP(WS)/AP - (Wing A, B ,C) ;

CHE/7131/BP(WS)/AP - (Wing D & E); CHE/7127/BP(WS)/AP - (Wing F, G, H);
IN
12.IOD/IOA/Concession/Plan
CHE/7126/BP(WS)/AP - (Wing I, J, K, L) ; CHE/7129/BP(WS)/AP - (Wing M, N) ;
Approval Number
CHE/7125/BP(WS)/AP (Wing P, Q, R, S, T) ; CHE/583/BPWS/AP/MISC/OTHER/1/NEW - (For Club
House) ; CHE/1046/BP(WS)/LOP - Layout
M
Approved Built-up Area: 51205.51

13.Note on the initiated work (If
A-
Bldg A,B,C,D,E are existing building and Bldg F,G,H are nearing completion
applicable)
14.LOI / NOC / IOD from MHADA/
NA
IA
Other approvals (If applicable)

15.Total Plot Area (sq. m.) 57252.10
16.Deductions 1517.30
SE
17.Net Plot area 55734.80

FSI area (sq. m.): 1,68,100.00
18 (a).Proposed Built-up Area (FSI &
Non FSI area (sq. m.): 1,85,555.00
Non-FSI)
Total BUA area (sq. m.): 353655
Approved FSI area (sq. m.): 51205.51
18 (b).Approved Built up area as per
Approved Non FSI area (sq. m.): 127163.95
DCR
Date of Approval: 19-03-2016
19.Total ground coverage (m2) 29851
20.Ground-coverage Percentage (%)
(Note: Percentage of plot not open 52.13%
to sky)
21.Estimated cost of the project 9457200000
SEIAA Meeting No: 185 Meeting Date: January

Shri. Anil Diggikar (Member 10, 2020 ( SEIAA-STATEMENT-0000001881 ) Page 1 of Shri. Johny Joseph
Secretary SEIAA) SEIAA-MINUTES-0000002929 13 (Chairman SEIAA)
22.Number of buildings & its configuration
Serial
Building Name & number Number of floors Height of the building (Mtrs)
number
1 Existing Bldg - -
2 Wing A St + 10 36.15
3 Wing B & C St + 7 26.15
4 Wing D & E St + 20 66.35
5 Wing F, G & H B + St + 20 68.80
6 Proposed Bldg - -
7 Wing I, J, K & L B + P + Up St + 35 119.15
8 Wing M & N 2B + St + 33 112.00
9
9 Wing P & T 2B + L St + St + 20 69.85
92
10 Wing Q, R & S 2B + L St + St + 31 107.05
11 Club House B+G+1 8.00
02
23.Number of
Flats: 2134 Nos.
tenants and shops
24.Number of
0
expected residents / 10,670 Nos.
00
users
25.Tenant density
385 Tenement/Hector
per hectare
00
26.Height of the
building(s)
S-
27.Right of way
(Width of the road
The project site is accessible by 36.6 m wide Reservoir Road off General Arun Kumar Vaidya
from the nearest fire
TE
Marg from West side and 18.30 m wide road from North and East side
station to the
proposed building(s)
U
28.Turning radius
for easy access of
IN
fire tender
movement from all 9m
around the building
M
excluding the width

for the plantation
A-
29.Existing
Building A,B,C,D,E are existing
structure (s) if any
IA
30.Details of the
demolition with
-
disposal (If
SE
applicable)
31.Production Details
Serial
Product Existing (MT/M) Proposed (MT/M) Total (MT/M)
Number
1 - - - -
32.Total Water Requirement

Source of water MCGM
Fresh water (CMD): 960
Recycled water -
480
Flushing (CMD):
Recycled water -
81
Gardening (CMD):
Swimming pool
12
make up (Cum):
Dry season: Total Water
Requirement (CMD) 1452
:
Fire fighting -
Underground water AS PER NBC
tank(CMD):
9
Fire fighting -
92
Overhead water AS PER NBC
tank(CMD):
Excess treated water 770
02
Source of water MCGM
Fresh water (CMD): 814
0
Recycled water -
00
480
Flushing (CMD):
Recycled water -
0
00
Gardening (CMD):
Swimming pool
12
make up (Cum):
S-
Wet season: Total Water

Requirement (CMD) 1452
TE
:
Fire fighting -
Underground water AS PER NBC
U
tank(CMD):
IN
Fire fighting -
Overhead water AS PER NBC
tank(CMD):
M
Excess treated water 851

A-
Details of Swimming
Yes swimming pool is provided
pool (If any)
IA
SE

33.Details of Total water consumed
Particula
Consumption (CMD) Loss (CMD) Effluent (CMD)
rs
Water
Require Existing Proposed Total Existing Proposed Total Existing Proposed Total
ment
Domestic - - - - - - - - -
Level of the Ground

3-4m
water table:
Size and no of RWH
tank(s) and 18 RWH Tanks with total 450 KL capacity
Quantity:
9
Location of the RWH
Below Basement
tank(s):
92
34.Rain Water Quantity of recharge
-
Harvesting pits:
02
(RWH) Size of recharge pits
-
:
0
Budgetary allocation
104 Lakh
(Capital cost) :
00
5.2 Lakh/yr
(O & M cost) :
00
Details of UGT tanks
Under Ground Tanks are provided
if any :
S-
Natural water
Towards South Side
TE
drainage pattern:
35.Storm water
Quantity of storm
drainage water:
6,368.58 m3/hr
U
Size of SWD: 600 mm, 800 mm, 750 mm, 1000 mm wide channel
IN
Sewage generation
1344
M
in KLD:
STP technology: MBBR
A-
Capacity of STP
3 STP of total 1500 KLD capacity
(CMD):
36.Sewage and
IA
Location & area of

Waste water the STP:
Location: Below Basement; Area provided: 1357 m2
SE
300 Lakh
(Capital cost):
60 Lakh/yr
(O & M cost):

37.Solid waste Management
Waste generation in Waste generation: Construction debris : 10,269 m3; Excavation quantity : 1,47,520 m3
the Pre Construction Disposal of the
and Construction construction waste The construction debris will be utilized at site for Road Paving
phase: debris:
Dry waste: 2134 kg/d
Wet waste: 3201 kg/d
Hazardous waste: -
Waste generation
in the operation Biomedical waste (If
-
applicable):
Phase:
STP Sludge (Dry
13 KLD
sludge):
9
Others if any: -
92
Dry waste: Dry garbage will be disposed off to authorized recyclers
Wet garbage will be composted using Mechanical Composting unit and
Wet waste:
will be used as organic manure for landscaping.
02
Hazardous waste: -
Mode of Disposal
of waste: Biomedical waste (If
0
-
applicable):
00
STP Sludge (Dry
Sludge use as manure for gardening
sludge):
Others if any: -
00
Location(s): Ground Floor
Area for the storage
S-
Area
of waste & other 250 m2
requirement: material:
TE
Area for machinery: 50 m2

Budgetary allocation Capital cost: 140 Lakh
U
(Capital cost and

O&M cost): O & M cost: 56 Lakh
IN
38.Effluent Charecterestics
Serial Inlet Effluent Outlet Effluent Effluent discharge
M
Parameters Unit
Number Charecterestics Charecterestics standards (MPCB)
1 - - - - -
A-
Amount of effluent generation

-
(CMD):
IA
Capacity of the ETP: -

Amount of treated effluent
SE
-
recycled :
Amount of water send to the CETP: -
Membership of CETP (if require): -
Note on ETP technology to be used -
Disposal of the ETP sludge -

39.Hazardous Waste Details
Serial
Description Cat UOM Existing Proposed Total Method of Disposal
Number
1 - - - - - - -
40.Stacks emission Details

Height
Internal
Serial Fuel Used with from Temp. of Exhaust
Section & units Stack No. diameter
Number Quantity ground Gases
(m)
level (m)
1 - - - - - -
41.Details of Fuel to be used

Serial
Type of Fuel Existing Proposed Total
9
Number
92
1 - - - -
42.Source of Fuel -
02
43.Mode of Transportation of fuel to site -
0
RG Required: 13,933.70 m2 RG Provided: 16,118.95 m2, RG on ground:
Total RG area :
8,361.15 m2 , RG on podium: 7,757.80 m2
00
No of trees to be cut
-
:
00
Number of trees to
44.Green Belt Existing trees on site: 223 Nos.; New Trees to be planted: 683 Nos.
be planted :
Development
S-
List of proposed
As mentioned below
native trees :
TE
Timeline for
completion of Trees will be planted after completeion of construction work
plantation :
U
45.Number and list of trees species to be planted in the ground

IN
Serial Characteristics & ecological

Name of the plant Common Name Quantity
Number importance
ALSTONIA Shady large evergreen tree, white
M
1 SAPTAPARAN 66
SCHOLARIS fragrant flowers
A-
Medium sized evergreen tree,

2 PLUMERIA ALBA CHAPHA 346
fragrant yellow flowers.
Roystonea regia is a large palm,
IA
3 ROYSTONEA REGIA ROYAL PALM 5

solitary, erect, grayish white,
Shady tree, small white fragrant
SE
4 MIMUSOPS ELENGI BAKUL 17

flowers
The younger stems are smooth,
5 TECOMA STANS TECOMA 2 hairless (glabrous) and greenish in
Colour..
ANTHOCEPHALUS Shady, large tree, ball shaped
6 KADAMB 38
CADAMBA flowers.
Single-stemmed, tropical palm
with broad, glossy green, feather-
7 ARECA CATECHU BETEL NUT 64 shaped leaves that protrude from a
green crown shaft and has a
narrow, upright habit.

State flower tree of Maharashtra,
LAGERSTOREMIA
8 TAMHAN 68 Medium sized tree, beautiful
FLOSREGINEAE
purple flowers
The tiny, yellowish or greenish
9 COCUS NUCIFERA COCONUT TREE 29 flowers are in inflorescences that
emerge from the leaf axils.
10 MILICIA EXCELSA KHAYA 10 Medium sized deciduous tree
AZADIRACHTA Semi-evergreen tree with
11 NEEM 38
INDICA medicinal value.
46.Total quantity of plants on ground
47.Number and list of shrubs and bushes species to be planted in the podium RG:
Serial
Name C/C Distance Area m2
Number
9
1 - - -
92
0 02
00
00
S-
TE
U
IN
M
A-
IA
SE

48.Energy
Source of power
Adani Electricity
supply :
During Construction
Phase: (Demand 500 kVA
Load)
DG set as Power
back-up during 500 kVA
construction phase
During Operation
phase (Connected 23.4 MW
load):
Power
During Operation
requirement: phase (Demand 12.8 MW
9
load):
92
Transformer: -
DG set as Power
02
back-up during 1062.5 kVA (62.5 kVA x 17)
operation phase:
Fuel used: Diesel
0
Details of high
00
tension line passing
NA
through the plot if
any:
00
49.Energy saving by non-conventional method:
• Energy efficient lighting using LED
S-
• Use of high energy efficient pumps for fire fighting, UG tanks and STP
• Solar Street lights are proposed for common areas such as open spaces, pathways, RG etc.
TE
• Solar hot water will be provided
50.Detail calculations & % of saving:

U
Serial
Energy Conservation Measures Saving %
Number
IN
1 Total energy Saving >20%
51.Details of pollution control Systems

M
Source Existing pollution control system Proposed to be installed

A-
- - -
Budgetary allocation Capital cost: 130 Lakh
IA
(Capital cost and

O&M cost): O & M cost: 6.5 Lakh/yr
SE
52.Environmental Management plan Budgetary Allocation

a) Construction phase (with Break-up):
Serial
Attributes Parameter Total Cost per annum (Rs. In Lacs)
Number
Water spray for dust
1 - 5
suppression
Site sanitation and
2 potable water supply - 10
to labour

As per the CPCB
guidelines through
MoEF Approved
Environmental laboratories – Ambient
3 4
Monitoring Air-RSPM, PM2.5,
SO2, NOx, CO), Noise:
Leq day time and
Night Time
Health check up and
4 - 5
first aid
(Helmets, Safety
Safety personal Shoes, Safety Belt,
5 12
protective equipment Googles, Hand Gloves
etc.)
(Sign Boards, Persons
6 Traffic Management at entry exit and 4
9
Parking area)
92
7 Safety Nets - 25
Storm water SWD along plot
8 4
02
Management boundary
Tyre cleaning and
9 - 4
Vehicle maintenance
0
Safety Training to
00
10 Workers, Safety - 8
Officer
00
11 Disinfection - 3
S-
TE
U
IN
M
A-
IA
SE

b) Operation Phase (with Break-up):
Serial Capital cost Rs. In Operational and Maintenance
Component Description
Number Lacs cost (Rs. in Lacs/yr)
1 STP (Tertiary) Continuous O & M 300 60
2 Solar System Weekly 130 6.5
3 Rain Water Harvesting During Rainy season 104 5.2
Solid waste
4 Continuous O & M 140 56
composting
5 Landscape Daily 146 15
As per the CPCB
Environmental guidelines through
6 - 4
Monitoring MoEF Approved
laboratory
9
52. Storage of chemicals (inflamable/explosive/hazardous/toxic
92
substances)
02
Maximum
Quantity
of
Storage Consumption
Storage Source of Means of
0
Description Status Location Capacity / Month in
at any Supply transportation
in MT MT
00
point of
time in
MT
00
- - - - - - - -
53. Any Other Information

S-
No Information Available
54. Traffic Management

TE
Nos. of the junction

to the main road &
U
-
design of
confluence:
IN
Number and area of

2 Basements with total area of 68,479.27 m2 area
basement:
M
Number and area of

1 Podium with 40,411.46 m2 area
podia:
A-
Total Parking area: 1,29,163.00 m2

Area per car: -
IA
Area per car: -

Number of 2-
SE
Wheelers as
Parking details: approved by -
competent
authority:
Number of 4-
Wheelers as
approved by 2623 Nos.
competent
authority:
Public Transport: -
Width of all Internal
6m - 9m driveways
roads (m):

Shri. Anil Diggikar (Member 10, 2020 ( SEIAA-STATEMENT-0000001881 ) Page 10 Shri. Johny Joseph
Secretary SEIAA) SEIAA-MINUTES-0000002929 of 13 (Chairman SEIAA)
CRZ/ RRZ clearance
NA
obtain, if any:
Distance from
Protected Areas /
Permission is received from SGNP Eco Sensitive Zone Monitoring
Critically Polluted
Committee vide letter No. DESK/1/20/LND/ESZ/3928 OF 2018-19 DT.
areas / Eco-sensitive
01.11.2018
areas/ inter-State
boundaries
Category as per
schedule of EIA 8(b)
Notification sheet
Bombay High Court. Suit No. 1628 of 2008. The only orders relevant to
the proposed are the order dated 19.07.2012 disposing of Appeal Nos.
Court cases pending
817 of 2010 and 806 of 2010 in the said Suit; there is no restriction on
if any
the development which is being carried on / is to be carried on by the
9
Applicant on the said land.
Other Relevant
92
-
Informations
Have you previously
02
submitted
No
Application online
on MOEF Website
0
Date of online
-
00
submission
Brief information of the project by SEAC

00
S-
TE
U
IN
M
A-
IA
SE

Representative of PP Mr D.D Bhagwat was present during the meeting along with environmental
consultant M/s. Mahabal Enviro Engineers Pvt. Ltd.
PP informed that, the project under consideration is residential project. PP further stated that, the
total plot area of the project is 57252.10 Sq.mt. having total construction area 353655 Sq.mt. (FSI -
1,68,100.00 Sq.mt. + NON FSI- 1,85,555.00 Sq.mt.) and the building configuration is as follow-
Building Name & number Number of floors Height

(Mtrs)
Existing Bldg -- --
9
Wing A St + 10 36.15
92
02
Wing B & C St + 7 26.15
0
Wing D & E St + 20 66.35
00
Wing F, G & H B + St + 20 68.80
00
Proposed Bldg -- --
S-
Wing I, J, K & L B + P + Up St + 35 119.15

TE
Wing M & N 2B + St + 33 112.00

U
IN
Wing P & T 2B + L St + St + 20 69.85

M
Wing Q, R & S 2B + L St + St + 31 107.05

A-
Club House B+G+1 8.00

IA
SE
It is noted that, Project has received Environmental clearance vide letter dated 17.05.2018. It is noted
that the project earlier considered in 100th Meeting held on 20-05-2019 & ToR accorded for the
same. Accordingly, PP submitted the compliance & EIA which was taken on record.
The project proposal was discussed on the basis of presentation made and documents submitted by
the proponent. All issues related to environment, including air, water, land, soil, ecology and
biodiversity and social aspects were discussed. Committee noted that the project is under 8a (B2)
category of EIA Notification, 2006. Consolidated statements, synopsis of compliances, form 1, 1A,
presentation & plans submitted are taken on the record.
DECISION OF SEAC

After detailed deliberations, Committee decided to recommend the proposal for
Environmental Clearance to SEIAA, subject to compliance of above points.
Specific Conditions by SEAC:
1) PP to ensure that CER plan gets approved from Municipal Commissioner/District Collector.
2) PP Shall comply with Standard EC conditions mentioned in the Office Memorandum issued by MoEF& CC vide
F.No.22-34/2018-IA.III dt.04.01.2019.
3) SEIAA decided to grant EC for – FSI: 168100.00 m2, Non-FSI: 185555.00 m2 and Total BUA: 353655.00 m2 ( Plan
Approval no-CHE/1046/BP (WS)/LOP, Date-15.10.2019)
SEIAA DECISION
Proposal was recommended in 123rd meeting of SEAC-2 for total plot area of the project is
57252.10 Sq.mt. having total construction area 353655 Sq.mt. (FSI -1,68,100.00 Sq.mt. + NON
9
FSI- 1,85,555.00 Sq.mt.)
92
SEIAA decided to grant EC for – FSI: 168100.00 m2, Non-FSI: 185555.00 m2 and Total BUA:
02
353655.00 m2 ( Plan Approval no-CHE/1046/BP (WS)/LOP, Date-15.10.2019)
0
SEIAA decided to grant EC subject to following conditions-
1.PP
00
to ensure that CER plan gets approved from Municipal Commissioner/District Collector.
00
2.PP Shall comply with Standard EC conditions mentioned in the Office Memorandum issued by
S-
MoEF& CC vide F.No.22-34/2018-IA.III dt.04.01.2019.

TE
Specific Conditions by SEIAA:

U
1) PP to ensure that CER plan gets approved from Municipal Commissioner/District Collector.
2) PP Shall comply with Standard EC conditions mentioned in the Office Memorandum issued by MoEF& CC vide
IN
F.No.22-34/2018-IA.III dt.04.01.2019.
3) SEIAA decided to grant EC for – FSI: 168100.00 m2, Non-FSI: 185555.00 m2 and Total BUA: 353655.00 m2 ( Plan
Approval no-CHE/1046/BP (WS)/LOP, Date-15.10.2019)
M
FINAL RECOMMENDATION
A-
SEIAA have decided to grant the proposal for Prior Environmental Clearance subject to above conditions
IA
SE


Minutes of 185TH Seiaa Meeting

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

Minutes of 185TH Seiaa Meeting

Uploaded by

Document Information

Original Description:

Original Title

Copyright

Available Formats

Share this document

Share or Embed Document

Sharing Options

Did you find this document useful?

Is this content inappropriate?

Copyright:

Available Formats

Minutes of 185TH Seiaa Meeting

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

185 th Meeting of SEIAA

SEIAA Meeting number: 185 Meeting Date January 10, 2020

1.Name of Project “Raheja Residency”

Locality: Opposite Khar Telephone Exchange, Khar

IOD/IOA/Concession/Plan Approval Number: CHE/7128/BP(WS)/AP - (Wing A, B ,C) ;

Approved Built-up Area: 51205.51

Other approvals (If applicable)

17.Net Plot area 55734.80

SEIAA Meeting No: 185 Meeting Date: January

excluding the width

32.Total Water Requirement

SEIAA Meeting No: 185 Meeting Date: January

Wet season: Total Water

Excess treated water 851

SEIAA Meeting No: 185 Meeting Date: January

Level of the Ground

Location & area of

SEIAA Meeting No: 185 Meeting Date: January

Area for machinery: 50 m2

(Capital cost and

Amount of effluent generation

Capacity of the ETP: -

SEIAA Meeting No: 185 Meeting Date: January

40.Stacks emission Details

41.Details of Fuel to be used

45.Number and list of trees species to be planted in the ground

Serial Characteristics & ecological

Medium sized evergreen tree,

3 ROYSTONEA REGIA ROYAL PALM 5

4 MIMUSOPS ELENGI BAKUL 17

SEIAA Meeting No: 185 Meeting Date: January

SEIAA Meeting No: 185 Meeting Date: January

• Solar hot water will be provided

50.Detail calculations & % of saving:

1 Total energy Saving >20%

51.Details of pollution control Systems

Source Existing pollution control system Proposed to be installed

(Capital cost and

52.Environmental Management plan Budgetary Allocation

SEIAA Meeting No: 185 Meeting Date: January

SEIAA Meeting No: 185 Meeting Date: January

53. Any Other Information

54. Traffic Management

Nos. of the junction

Number and area of

Number and area of

Total Parking area: 1,29,163.00 m2

Area per car: -

SEIAA Meeting No: 185 Meeting Date: January

Brief information of the project by SEAC

SEIAA Meeting No: 185 Meeting Date: January

Building Name & number Number of floors Height

Wing I, J, K & L B + P + Up St + 35 119.15

Wing M & N 2B + St + 33 112.00

Wing P & T 2B + L St + St + 20 69.85

Wing Q, R & S 2B + L St + St + 31 107.05

Club House B+G+1 8.00

SEIAA Meeting No: 185 Meeting Date: January