Stress Analysis On Piping Systems
Stress Analysis On Piping Systems
Stress Analysis On Piping Systems
SHORE PLATFORMS
A PROJECT REPORT
Submitted by
JAYAPRIYADHARSHINI.T.S
(311116114048)
1
BONAFIDE CERTIFICATE
Certified that this project report “STRESS ANALYSIS ON PIPING SYS-
TEMS IN OFFSHORE PLATFORMS” is the bonafide work of “JAYA-
PRIYADHARSHINI.T.S (311116114048)”, who carried out the project work
under my supervision.
SIGNATURE SIGNATURE
Mr. VENKATESH RAJAGOPALAN Mrs.SHREELATHA KRISHNAN
HEAD OF THE DEPARTMENT TECHNOLOGIST – PIPING,
PIPING, L & T HYDROCARBON
MUMBAI
2
CERTIFICATE OF EVALUATION
3
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
4
ABSTRACT
Process Pipe Line Systems Designs are governed by International Codes and
Standards to transport the fluid, steam, or air in Industries and in many plants.
The piping system involves the components like pipes, flanges, gaskets, elbows,
different fittings, valves and other specialities. The design code ASME 31.3
This paper explains the stresses, elemental forces, displacements, restraints and
also stress intensification factor referring to this code and ensuring that they are
kept in allowable limits as per the standards at different load conditions such a
5
TABLE OF CONTENTS
1.INTRODUCTION 8
1.1.PIPING 8
1.2. TYPES OF PIPING 8
1.3. SIZE, LENGTH, MATERIAL SPECIFICATIONS 9
1.4. TYPES OF JOINTS 9
1.5. TYPES OF ELBOWS 9
1.6. VALVES 10
1.7. FLANGES 11
1.8. TYPES OF LOADS 12
1.9. FACTORS INFLUENCING STRESSES 13
1.10. TERMS OF SUPPORT 13
1.11. MATERIALS, CODES, STANDARDS 14
1.12. CODES 15
1.13. ASME B31.3 15
2.PROJECT PLANNING 16
3.PROCEDURE 17
4.DESIGN 18
5.STRESS ANALYSIS REPORT 19
5.1. INPUT PIPE DATA 20
5.2. STRESS SUMMARY REPORT 30
5.3. DISPLACEMENT REPORT 31
5.4. RESTRAINT SUMMARY 34
6. THEORETICAL CALCULATION 37
7.CONCLUSION 42
6
OBJECTIVE
The main objective of pipe stress analysis is to ensure safety against failure of
the Piping System by verifying the structural integrity against the loading condi-
tions, both external and internal, expected to occur during the life time of the
system in the plant. This is to be undertaken with the most economic considera-
tions. To ensure that the stresses in the piping components in the system are
7
1 .INTRODUCTION
Pipe Design mainly depends upon stress analysis .Process piping is typi-
cally checked by pipe stress engineers to verify that the routing , nozzle loads,
hangers, supports are properly places and selected such that allowable pipe
stress is not exceeded under different loads such as sustained loads, operating
loads and expansion loads, etc., as stipulated by ASME 31.3. It is necessary to
evaluate the mechanical behaviour of the piping under regular loads (internal
pressure and thermal stresses) as well under occasional and intermittent loading
cases such as earthquake, high wind, special vibration. This evaluation is usual-
ly performed with the assistance of a specialised finite element pipe stress anal-
ysis computer program CAESAR –II Software.
1.1 PIPING
Marine Piping
Transportation piping
Civil piping
Plumbing
8
1.3 SIZE, LENGTH, MATERIAL SPECIFICATIONS:
The size, length, material specifications have been established by the three
sources:
1.6 VALVES:
Valves are the device used for controlling the passage of fluid or air
through a pipe or duct etc., especially an automatic device allowing movement
in one direction only.
9
VALVE SYMBOLS
10
USES:
1.7 FLANGES:
A flange is a method of connecting pipes, valves, pumps, and other
equipment to form a piping system. Flanges are usually welded or
screwed.
Socket welding flanges may be used for all pressure ratings upto
1 1\2 NB size except on lines subjected to severe cyclic conditions.
Screwed flanges shall be used for galvanised steel/cast iron piping.
Flat face flanges are used to mate to with cast iron valves and
equipment.
11
WELDING SYMBOLS
All the American code for pressure piping classify the loads mainly into three
types:
12
1.9 FACTORS INFLUENCING STRESSES:
Wind Load
Seismic Load
Relief Valve forces
Fluid Hammer
Settlement
Equipment Vibration
Weights of attachments
13
PIPE SUPPORT SYMBOLS
14
1.12 CODES:
15
2. PROJECT PLANNING
GANTT CHART:
DATE DEC DEC DEC DEC DEC DEC JAN JAN JAN
ACTIVITY 10 12 17 20 26 30 1 6 8
S ORGANIZATION 2
OF WORK
T BASIC OF PIPING 5
COMPONENTS
U BASICS OF PIPING 3 2
DRAWING
D DESIGN OF PIPING 5 5
SYSTEMS ,CODES
Y AND STANDARDS
CEASAR –II 4 1
ANALYSING THE PRO- 2
JECT GIVEN
MODELLING 5
STRESS ANALYSIS 1
REPORT 2
16
3. PROCEDURE
STEP 1: Identify the possible loads that occur in the piping systems dur-
ing the life of the plant. ( Self weight, wind, seismic etc.,)
STEP 3: Get the cumulative effect of the possible loads in the system.
STEP 4: As per the allowable load at the connections find the stress and
STEP 5: As per the allowable limits, find the deformation (using Caesar)
STEP 6: After the system is designed, ensure that the stresses are within
17
4. DESIGN:
18
5. STRESS ANALYSIS
REPORT
19
5.1. INPUT PIPE DATA:
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
---
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
---
From 10 To 40 DZ= -149.225 mm.
PIPE
Dia= 168.275 mm. Wall= 18.263 mm. Cor= 6.0000 mm. Mill%(+)=12.50
Mill%(-)=12.50
GENERAL
T1= 104 C T2= 60 C P1= 141.0000 Kg./sq.cm. PHyd= 211.5000
Kg./sq.cm.
Mat= (106)A106 Grade B E= 2,068,248 Kg /sq.cm. EH1= 2,018,098 Kg
/sq.cm.
EH2= 2,045,938 Kg /sq.cm. EH3= 2,068,248 Kg /sq.cm.
EH4= 2,068,248 Kg /sq.cm. EH5= 2,068,248 Kg /sq.cm.
EH6= 2,068,248 Kg /sq.cm. EH7= 2,068,248 Kg /sq.cm.
EH8= 2,068,248 Kg /sq.cm. EH9= 2,068,248 Kg /sq.cm. v = .292
Pipe Den=7833.4399414 kg/cu.m. Fluid Den= 79.1299973 kg/cu.m.
Insul Thk= 25.000 mm. Insul Den= 136.1579285 kg/cu.m.
RIGID Weight= 493.73 N.
UNIFORM LOAD
Vector1 in G-s X1 Dir = .12 g's Y1 Dir = .00 g's Z1 Dir = .00 g's
Vector2 in G-s X2 Dir = .00 g's Y2 Dir = .06 g's Z2 Dir = .00 g's
Vector3 in G-s X3 Dir = .00 g's Y3 Dir = .00 g's Z3 Dir = .12 g's
WIND
Wind Shape= .500
ALLOWABLE STRESSES
B31.3 (2016) Cycle Max Switch = --- Sc= 1,406 Kg /sq.cm.
Sh1= 1,406 Kg /sq.cm. Sh2= 1,406 Kg /sq.cm. Sh3= 1,406 Kg /sq.cm.
Sh4= 1,406 Kg /sq.cm. Sh5= 1,406 Kg /sq.cm. Sh6= 1,406 Kg /sq.cm.
Sh7= 1,406 Kg /sq.cm. Sh8= 1,406 Kg /sq.cm. Sh9= 1,406 Kg /sq.cm.
Sy= 2,461 Kg /sq.cm.
FLANGES
Location= From Method= NC-3658.3 Class/Grade= ASME-2009-900-1.1
G/C= 393.700 mm. Bolt Area= 11,490.098 mm. SYC= 2,529 Kg /sq.cm.
SY1= 2,308 Kg /sq.cm. SY2= 2,406 Kg /sq.cm. SY3= 2,529 Kg /sq.cm.
SY4= 2,529 Kg /sq.cm. SY5= 2,529 Kg /sq.cm. SY6= 2,529 Kg /sq.cm.
SY7= 2,529 Kg /sq.cm. SY8= 2,529 Kg /sq.cm. SY9= 2,529 Kg /sq.cm.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
---
From 40 To 80 DZ= -820.000 mm.
BEND at "TO" end
Radius= 228.600 mm. (LONG) Bend Angle= 90.000 Angle/Node @1= 45.00
79
Angle/Node @2= .00 78
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
---
From 80 To 120 DX= -779.000 mm.
RESTRAINTS
Node 120 +Y Mu = .30
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
---
From 120 To 160 DX= -250.000 mm.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
---
20
From 160 To 200 DX= -148.000 mm.
RIGID Weight= 609.30 N.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
---
From 200 To 220 DX= -609.600 mm.
RIGID Weight= 2,602.08 N.
FLANGES
Location= Both Method= NC-3658.3
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
---
From 220 To 240 DX= -148.000 mm.
RIGID Weight= 609.30 N.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
---
From 240 To 280 DX= -300.000 mm.
SIF's & TEE's
Node 280 Weldolet
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
---
From 280 To 320 DX= -429.000 mm.
BEND at "TO" end
Radius= 228.600 mm. (LONG) Bend Angle= 90.000 Angle/Node @1= 45.00
319
Angle/Node @2= .00 318
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
---
From 320 To 360 DY= -1,653.000 mm.
BEND at "TO" end
Radius= 228.600 mm. (LONG) Bend Angle= 90.000 Angle/Node @1= 45.00
359
Angle/Node @2= .00 358
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
---
From 360 To 400 DZ= -708.000 mm.
RESTRAINTS
Node 400 +Y Mu = .30
Node 400 Guide
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
---
From 400 To 440 DZ= -2,656.000 mm.
BEND at "TO" end
Radius= 228.600 mm. (LONG) Bend Angle= 90.000 Angle/Node @1= 45.00
439
Angle/Node @2= .00 438
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
---
From 440 To 480 DY= -3,838.000 mm.
RESTRAINTS
Node 480 Guide
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
---
From 480 To 520 DY= -6,691.000 mm.
BEND at "TO" end
Radius= 228.600 mm. (LONG) Bend Angle= 90.000 Angle/Node @1= 45.00
519
Angle/Node @2= .00 518
21
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
---
From 520 To 560 DX= 529.000 mm.
RESTRAINTS
Node 560 +Y Mu = .30
Node 560 Guide
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
---
From 560 To 600 DX= 6,367.000 mm.
RESTRAINTS
Node 600 Y Mu = .30
Node 600 Guide
Node 600 LIM
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
---
From 600 To 640 DX= 529.000 mm.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
---
From 10 To 800 DZ= 148.000 mm.
RIGID Weight= 609.30 N.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
---
From 800 TP-2103 To 1 DZ= 100.000 mm.
RESTRAINTS
Node 1 ANC
EQUIPMENT LIMITS
Nozzle Node = 1 Limiting Loads: A=pipe; B=ref; C=AxB; FA= 8,829.00
N.
FB= 8,829.00 N. FC= 8,829.00 N. MA= 3,973.00 N.m. MB= 3,973.00
N.m.
MC= 3,973.00 N.m. Equipment Major Direction Vector= .0000 1.0000
.0000
Interact. Mtd= Absolute
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
---
From 280 To 1000 DY= 139.000 mm.
PIPE
Dia= 60.325 mm. Wall= 11.074 mm.
Insul Thk= 25.000 mm.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
---
From 1000 To 1040 DY= 76.000 mm.
BEND at "TO" end
Radius= 76.200 mm. (LONG) Bend Angle= 90.000 Angle/Node @1= 45.00
1039
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
---
From 1040 To 1080 DZ= -812.000 mm.
SINGLE FLANGED BEND at "TO" end
Radius= 76.200 mm. (LONG) Bend Angle= 90.000 Angle/Node @1= 45.00
1079
Angle/Node @2= .00 1078
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
---
From 1080 To 1120 DX= 76.000 mm.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
---
22
From 1120 To 1160 DX= 110.000 mm.
RIGID Weight= 170.20 N.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
---
From 1160 To 1200 DX= 371.000 mm.
RIGID Weight= 950.00 N.
FLANGES
Location= Both Method= NC-3658.3 Class/Grade= ASME-2009-900-1.1
G/C= 165.100 mm. Bolt Area= 3,102.000 mm.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
---
From 1200 To 1240 DX= 110.000 mm.
RIGID Weight= 170.20 N.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
---
From 1240 To 1260 DX= 235.000 mm.
RESTRAINTS
Node 1260 +Y Mu = .30
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
---
From 1260 To 1280 DX= 235.000 mm.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
---
From 1280 To 1320 DX= 110.000 mm.
RIGID Weight= 170.20 N.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
---
From 1320 To 1360 DX= 371.000 mm.
RIGID Weight= 950.00 N.
FLANGES
Location= Both Method= NC-3658.3
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
---
From 1360 To 1400 DX= 110.000 mm.
RIGID Weight= 170.20 N.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
---
From 1400 To 1440 DX= 250.000 mm.
RESTRAINTS
Node 1440 Y Mu = .30
Node 1440 Guide
Node 1440 LIM
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
---
From 1440 To 1480 DX= 211.000 mm.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
---
From 1480 To 1520 DX= 110.000 mm.
RIGID Weight= 170.20 N.
CAESAR II 2018 Ver.10.00.00.7700, (Build 170726) DEC 26,2019 13:32: 4
NODENAMES
800 1 From= TP-2103 To=
CAESAR II 2018 Ver.10.00.00.7700, (Build 170726) DEC 26,2019 13:32: 4
23
MATERIAL Changes:
10 40 Mat= (106)A106 Grade B
E= 2,068,248 Kg /sq.cm. v = .292
Density= 7,833.4399 kg/cu.m.
CAESAR II 2018 Ver.10.00.00.7700, (Build 170726) DEC 26,2019 13:32: 4
JOBNAME: \\LTV-PC-1160\SHARE FOLDER\CAESAR II FILE\NWISR-SYS-12-OPE_REV-C1
BEND ELEMENTS
40 80 Radius= 228.600 mm. (LONG)
Bend Angle= 90.000 Angle/Node @1=
45.00 79
Angle/Node @2= .00 78
280 320 Radius= 228.600 mm. (LONG)
Bend Angle= 90.000 Angle/Node @1=
45.00
319 Angle/Node @2= .00 318
320 360 Radius= 228.600 mm. (LONG)
Bend Angle= 90.000 Angle/Node @1=
45.00
359 Angle/Node @2= .00 358
400 440 Radius= 228.600 mm. (LONG)
Bend Angle= 90.000 Angle/Node @1=
45.00
439 Angle/Node @2= .00 438
480 520 Radius= 228.600 mm. (LONG)
Bend Angle= 90.000 Angle/Node @1=
45.00
519 Angle/Node @2= .00 518
1000 1040 Radius= 76.200 mm. (LONG)
Bend Angle= 90.000 Angle/Node @1=
45.00
1039
1040 1080 Radius= 76.200 mm. (LONG)
Bend Angle= 90.000 Angle/Node @1=
45.00
1079 Angle/Node @2= .00 1078
CAESAR II 2018 Ver.10.00.00.7700, (Build 170726) DEC 26,2019 13:32: 4
24
RIGIDS
10 40 RIGID Weight= 493.73 N.
160 200 RIGID Weight= 609.30 N.
200 220 RIGID Weight= 2,602.08 N.
220 240 RIGID Weight= 609.30 N.
10 800 RIGID Weight= 609.30 N.
1120 1160 RIGID Weight= 170.20 N.
1160 1200 RIGID Weight= 950.00 N.
1200 1240 RIGID Weight= 170.20 N.
1280 1320 RIGID Weight= 170.20 N.
1320 1360 RIGID Weight= 950.00 N.
1360 1400 RIGID Weight= 170.20 N.
1480 1520 RIGID Weight= 170.20 N.
CAESAR II 2018 Ver.10.00.00.7700, (Build 170726) DEC 26,2019 13:32: 4
RESTRAINTS Len MU
GAP YIELD Dir
NODE TYPE CNODE STIF1 STIF2 FORCE Vectors
-------+-------+------+----------+----------+----------+------------------
---
120 +Y .30 .000 1.000
.000
400 +Y .30 .000 1.000
.000
400 Guide .000 .000
.000
480 Guide .000 .000
.000
560 +Y .30 .000 1.000
.000
560 Guide .000 .000
.000
600 Y .30 .000 1.000
.000
600 Guide .000 .000
.000
600 LIM .000 .000
.000
1 ANC .000 .000
.000
1260 +Y .30 .000 1.000
.000
1440 Y .30 .000 1.000
.000
1440 Guide .000 .000
.000
1440 LIM .000 .000
.000
25
CAESAR II 2018 Ver.10.00.00.7700, (Build 170726) DEC 26,2019 13:32: 4
FLANGES
10 40 Location= From Method= NC-3658.3
Class/Grade= ASME-2009-900-1.1
G/C= 393.700 mm. Bolt Area=
11,490.098 mm.
SYC= 2,529 Kg /sq.cm.
SY1= 2,308 Kg /sq.cm.
SY2= 2,406 Kg /sq.cm.
SY3= 2,529 Kg /sq.cm.
SY4= 2,529 Kg /sq.cm.
SY5= 2,529 Kg /sq.cm.
SY6= 2,529 Kg /sq.cm.
SY7= 2,529 Kg /sq.cm.
SY8= 2,529 Kg /sq.cm.
SY9= 2,529 Kg /sq.cm.
200 220 Location= Both Method= NC-3658.3
1160 1200 Location= Both Method= NC-3658.3
Class/Grade= ASME-2009-900-1.1
G/C= 165.100 mm. Bolt Area= 3,102.000
mm.
1320 1360 Location= Both Method= NC-3658.3
CAESAR II 2018 Ver.10.00.00.7700, (Build 170726) DEC 26,2019 13:32: 4
EQUIPMENT LIMITS
800 TP-2103 1 Nozzle Node = 1
26
WIND/WAVE
10 40 WIND Wind Shape= .500
CAESAR II 2018 Ver.10.00.00.7700, (Build 170726) DEC 26,2019 13:32: 4
27
DEFAULT ROT RESTRAINT STIFF= 0.112980E+12 N.m./deg
IGNORE SPRING HANGER STIFFNESS = NO
MISSING MASS ZPA = EXTRACTED
MIN WALL MILL TOLERANCE = 12.5000
WRC-107 VERSION = MAR 79 1B1/2B1
WRC-107 INTERPOLATION = LAST VALUE
DEFAULT AMBIENT TEMPERATURE= 28.0037 C
BOURDON PRESSURE= NONE
COEFFICIENT OF FRICTION (MU) = 0.000000
INCLUDE SPRG STIF IN HGR OPE = NO
INCLUDE INSULATION IN HYDROTEST = NO
REDUCED INTERSECTION = B31.1(POST1980)
USE WRC329 NO
NO REDUCED SIF FOR RFT AND WLT NO
B31.1 REDUCED Z FIX = YES
CLASS 1 BRANCH FLEX NO
ALL STRESS CASES CORRODED = NO
ADD TORSION IN SL STRESS = DEFAULT
ADD F/A IN STRESS = DEFAULT
OCCASIONAL LOAD FACTOR = 1.33000
DEFAULT CODE = B31.3
B31.3 SUS CASE SIF FACTOR = 0.000000
ALLOW USERS BEND SIF = NO
USE SCHNEIDER NO
YIELD CRITERION STRESS = MAX 3D SHEAR
USE PD/4T NO
BASE HOOP STRESS ON ? = ID
EN13480 USE IN OUTPLANE SIFS= NO
LIBERAL EXPANSION ALLOWABLE= NO
B31.3 SEC 319.2.3C SAXIAL= Default
B31.3 WELDING/CONTOUR TEE ISB16.9 FALSE
PRESSURE VARIATION IN EXP CASE= DEFAULT
IMPLEMENT B313 APP-P NO
IMPLEMENT B313 CODE CASE 178 YES
IGNORE B31.1/B31.3 Wc FACTOR= YES
USE FRP SIF = YES
USE FRP FLEX = YES
BS 7159 Pressure Stiffening= Design Strain
FRP Property Data File= CAESAR.FRP
FRP Emod (axial) = 224982. Kg /sq.cm.
FRP Ratio Gmod/Emod (axial) = 0.250000
FRP Ea/Eh*Vh/a = 0.152730
FRP Laminate Type = THREE
FRP Alpha = 21.5983 C
FRP Density = 1660.80 kg/cu.m.
EXCLUDE f2 FROM UKOOA BENDING = NO
CAESAR II 2018 Ver.10.00.00.7700, (Build 170726) DEC 26,2019 13:32: 4
28
Uniform Load Option ........ 1.000
COORDINATE REPORT
/--------------------(mm.)----------------------/
NODE X Y Z
10 14852.000 39366.000 -25320.000
40 14852.000 39366.000 -25469.225
80 14852.000 39366.000 -26289.225
120 14073.000 39366.000 -26289.225
160 13823.000 39366.000 -26289.225
200 13675.000 39366.000 -26289.225
220 13065.400 39366.000 -26289.225
240 12917.400 39366.000 -26289.225
280 12617.400 39366.000 -26289.225
320 12188.400 39366.000 -26289.225
360 12188.400 37713.000 -26289.225
400 12188.400 37713.000 -26997.225
440 12188.400 37713.000 -29653.225
480 12188.400 33875.000 -29653.225
520 12188.400 27184.000 -29653.225
560 12717.400 27184.000 -29653.225
600 19084.400 27184.000 -29653.225
640 19613.400 27184.000 -29653.225
10 14852.000 39366.000 -25320.000
800 14852.000 39366.000 -25172.000
1 14852.000 39366.000 -25072.000
280 12617.400 39366.000 -26289.225
1000 12617.400 39505.000 -26289.225
1040 12617.400 39581.000 -26289.225
1080 12617.400 39581.000 -27101.225
1120 12693.400 39581.000 -27101.225
1160 12803.400 39581.000 -27101.225
1200 13174.400 39581.000 -27101.225
1240 13284.400 39581.000 -27101.225
1260 13519.400 39581.000 -27101.225
1280 13754.400 39581.000 -27101.225
1320 13864.400 39581.000 -27101.225
1360 14235.400 39581.000 -27101.225
1400 14345.400 39581.000 -27101.225
1440 14595.400 39581.000 -27101.225
1480 14806.400 39581.000 -27101.225
1520 14916.400 39581.000 -27101.225
29
5.2. STRESS SUMMARY REPORT
CASE 4 (SUS) W+P1
CASE 5 (EXP) L5=L2-L4
CASE 6 (EXP) L6=L3-L4
CASE 7 (EXP) L7=L2-L3
30
5.3. DISPLACEMENT REPORT: CASE 2: (OPE)W1+P1+T1
31
CASE 2: W+T2+P1
Node DX mm. DY mm. DZ mm. RX deg. RY deg. RZ deg.
1 0.000 -0.000 0.000 0.0000 -0.0000 0.0000
10 0.004 0.002 -0.094 0.0008 -0.0009 0.0003
40 0.006 0.004 -0.151 0.0008 -0.0009 0.0003
78 -0.006 0.039 -0.375 0.0055 0.0061 0.0023
79 -0.059 0.054 -0.422 0.0073 0.0154 0.0028
80 -0.142 0.054 -0.388 0.0083 0.0255 0.0040
120 -0.350 -0.000 -0.085 0.0113 0.0364 0.0084
160 -0.445 -0.043 0.082 0.0126 0.0396 0.0105
200 -0.501 -0.070 0.185 0.0126 0.0396 0.0105
220 -0.732 -0.182 0.606 0.0127 0.0396 0.0105
240 -0.789 -0.209 0.708 0.0127 0.0396 0.0105
280 -0.902 -0.266 0.912 0.0143 0.0377 0.0124
318 -0.978 -0.312 1.042 0.0164 0.0361 0.0151
319 -1.016 -0.389 1.118 0.0192 0.0315 0.0222
320 -0.967 -0.479 1.093 0.0238 0.0273 0.0299
358 -0.192 -0.930 0.348 0.0530 0.0050 0.0396
359 -0.084 -0.918 0.154 0.0675 0.0016 0.0388
360 -0.037 -0.731 0.008 0.0810 -0.0024 0.0379
400 -0.000 -0.000 -0.174 0.0907 -0.0053 0.0337
438 0.279 3.650 -1.093 0.0605 -0.0070 0.0129
439 0.312 3.774 -1.212 0.0432 -0.0065 0.0112
440 0.347 3.756 -1.332 0.0251 -0.0060 0.0087
480 -0.000 2.395 -0.000 -0.0313 -0.0035 -0.0217
518 -2.644 -0.030 0.074 0.0154 0.0010 0.0055
519 -2.592 -0.078 0.028 0.0155 0.0012 0.0118
520 -2.515 -0.062 0.007 0.0156 0.0013 0.0129
560 -2.401 -0.000 0.000 0.0156 0.0012 0.0055
600 0.000 -0.000 -0.000 0.0156 -0.0006 0.0384
640 0.201 0.353 0.005 0.0156 -0.0006 0.0382
800 0.002 0.000 -0.038 0.0008 -0.0009 0.0003
1000 -0.928 -0.213 0.919 -0.0074 0.0134 0.0115
1039 -0.942 -0.199 0.899 -0.0172 0.0033 0.0137
1040 -0.946 -0.211 0.871 -0.0260 -0.0054 0.0170
1078 -0.748 -0.814 0.620 -0.0665 -0.0033 0.0536
1079 -0.740 -0.855 0.598 -0.0670 0.0060 0.0570
1080 -0.723 -0.826 0.579 -0.0671 0.0158 0.0607
1120 -0.723 -0.826 0.579 -0.0671 0.0159 0.0607
1160 -0.681 -0.709 0.549 -0.0671 0.0159 0.0607
1200 -0.540 -0.316 0.445 -0.0671 0.0160 0.0608
1240 -0.498 -0.199 0.414 -0.0671 0.0160 0.0608
1260 -0.409 -0.000 0.338 -0.0671 0.0191 0.0294
1280 -0.319 0.041 0.262 -0.0671 0.0179 -0.0031
1320 -0.278 0.035 0.228 -0.0671 0.0179 -0.0031
1360 -0.137 0.015 0.112 -0.0671 0.0179 -0.0031
1400 -0.095 0.009 0.078 -0.0671 0.0179 -0.0031
1440 -0.000 -0.000 -0.000 -0.0671 0.0177 -0.0037
32
CASE 3: (SUS) W+P1
33
5.4. RESTRAINT SUMMARY
CASE 1 (HYD) WW+HP
CASE 2 (OPE) W+T1+P1
CASE 3 (OPE) W+T2+P1
CASE 4 (SUS) W+P1
M
Load MX MY Z DX DY DZ
Node FX N. FY N. FZ N.
Case N.m. N.m. N. mm. mm. mm.
m.
TYPE=Rigid
1
ANC;
90 -1075 58 172 45 54 0.000 -0.000 0.000
1(HYD)
TYPE=Rigid
120
+Y;
-16 -4626 53 0 0 0 -0.009 -0.000 0.030
1(HYD)
-686 -2373 -191 0 0 0 -0.876 -0.000 -0.244
2(OPE)
-613 -3563 -148 0 0 0 -0.350 -0.000 -0.085
3(OPE)
-15 -4399 50 0 0 0 -0.008 -0.000 0.029
4(SUS)
- - - -
-
MAX -686/L2 191/L 0.876/ 0.000/ 0.244/
4626/L1
2 L2 L1 L2
TYPE=Rigid
400 GUI; Rigid
+Y;
54 -5299 -181 0 0 0 0.000 -0.000 -0.103
1(HYD)
-3651 -807 -242 0 0 0 -0.000 -0.000 -0.495
2(OPE)
-1475 -3169 -304 0 0 0 -0.000 -0.000 -0.174
3(OPE)
43 -4824 -170 0 0 0 0.000 -0.000 -0.097
4(SUS)
- - - - -
MAX -3651/L2
5299/L1 304/L 0.000/ 0.000/ 0.495/
34
M
Load MX MY Z DX DY DZ
Node FX N. FY N. FZ N.
Case N.m. N.m. N. mm. mm. mm.
m.
3 L2 L1 L2
TYPE=Rigid
480 GUI; Rigid
GUI;
-157 0 16 0 0 0 -0.000 -0.123 0.000
1(HYD)
-
-915 0 0 0 0 -0.000 5.993 -0.000
2(OPE) 4012
-
-458 0 0 0 0 -0.000 2.395 -0.000
3(OPE) 1609
-135 0 16 0 0 0 -0.000 -0.105 0.000
4(SUS)
- - -
MAX -915/L2 4012/ 0.000/ 5.993/ 0.000/
L2 L2 L2 L2
TYPE=Rigid
560 GUI; Rigid
+Y;
1 -12126 2 0 0 0 0.000 -0.000 0.000
1(HYD)
-5030 -16768 475 0 0 0 -5.872 -0.000 0.000
2(OPE)
-3930 -13101 189 0 0 0 -2.401 -0.000 0.000
3(OPE)
1 -10522 2 0 0 0 0.000 -0.000 0.000
4(SUS)
- - -
MAX -5030/L2 16768/L 475/L 5.872/ 0.000/ 0.000/
2 2 L2 L2 L2
TYPE=Rigid
GUI; Rigid
600
LIM; Rigid
Y;
114 -2335 2 0 0 0 0.000 -0.000 0.000
1(HYD)
5847 -1967 -21 0 0 0 0.000 -0.000 -0.000
2(OPE)
4319 -2006 -8 0 0 0 0.000 -0.000 -0.000
3(OPE)
98 -2035 1 0 0 0 0.000 -0.000 0.000
4(SUS)
- -
- -
MAX 5847/L2 0.000/ 0.000/ 0.000/
2335/L1 21/L2
L2 L1 L2
35
TYPE=Ri
1260
gid +Y;
-0 -2109 55 0 0 0 -0.000 -0.000 0.032
1(HYD)
-436 -2026 423 0 0 0 -0.997 -0.000 0.969
2(OPE)
-482 -2086 399 0 0 0 -0.409 -0.000 0.338
3(OPE)
-0 -2111 51 0 0 0 -0.000 -0.000 0.029
4(SUS)
- -
-
MAX -482/L3 423/L 0.997/L 0.000/L 0.969/L
2111/L4
2 2 4 2
TYPE=Ri
gid Y;
1440 Rigid
GUI; Rig-
id LIM;
-87 -557 -5 0 0 0 -0.000 -0.000 -0.000
1(HYD)
-969 -586 88 0 0 0 -0.000 -0.000 0.000
2(OPE)
-121 -567 -10 0 0 0 -0.000 -0.000 -0.000
3(OPE)
-82 -559 -4 0 0 0 -0.000 -0.000 -0.000
4(SUS)
- -
MAX -969/L2 -586/L2 0.000/L 0.000/L 0.000/L
88/L2
2 2 2
36
6. THEORETICAL CALCULATON
DATAS OF PIPE:
D= 168.27mm =16.827cm
d=131.74mm=13.174cm
T=1.826 cm
AREA= 𝜋 𝜋
𝐷2 = (16.827)2
4 4
Stresses are calculated in the nodes located at the ends of each ele-
ment. For the shear stresses, the maximum tension in the outer surface
of the pipe is given by,
𝑀𝑡
𝜏=
2𝑍
𝐼
𝑍=
𝑅
I = 2457.1575 cm4
SECTION MODULUS,
𝐼
Z=
𝑅
2457.1575
Z=
16.827
Z= 292.06 cm3
Mt=13600 kg cm
13600
𝜏=
2 ∗ 292.06
38
Tension stress, (node 90-100)
Mt=-13600 kg cm
−13600
𝜏=
2 ∗ 292.06
The bending stress acting on the two different plane can be combined,
consequently the combined bending stress Sb acting on the longitudi-
nal direction is given by,
𝑆𝑏 = √((IiMi)2+(IoMo)2) /Z
Mi, Mo are the inner and outer plane bending stresses respectively.
Ii, Io are the inner and outer plane stress intensification factor respec-
tively.
39
Bending stress, (node 80-90)
Mi=-34290 kg cm
Mo=6430 kg cm
Ii=Io=1
𝑆𝑏 = √((−34290)2+(6430)2) /292.06
Mi=-41820 kg cm
Mo=16580 kg cm
Ii=Io=1
𝑆𝑏 = √((−41820)2+(16580)2) /292.06
40
The ASME B31.3 code uses the Tresca Criterion to obtain the com-
bined tension effect S, also called expansion stress.
Se=√(Sb2+4𝜏2)
41
7. CONCLUSION
42